Comparison - Mac Feline Kohl vs. L'oreal Extra-Intense Liquid Pencil Eyeliner

[Iamhappy149]

nice girls and great review..bud I don't understand english very well:-(..so please which pencil is blacker ??...Feline or L'oreal?..thank you and greetings from Czech.

[ginoandmiranda]

@Iamhappy149 The L'Oreal is the one that didn't smudge hardly at all when she ran her fingers down them.

[Iamhappy149]

@ginoandmiranda

aha..ok,ok..thank you

[AngeLEyes8100]

Did you get the black or carbon black? and Do you like this on your waterline? Is it creamy like feline? thanks for the review.

[sarapo96]

you guys are GORGEOUS!(:

[rzp011]

Funny, I got this liner the other day and fell in love with it. It really is sooo BLACK!

[Respectmee95]

iLove that L'oreal Eyeliner SOooooo Much, iWant some More.

[IluBiebs]

@litttledolphin4 you sharpen it the same as you would sharpen any other pencil eyeliner! yes, it's plastic, but i've done it and it works perfectly!

[Sandlizbeth]

yal so funny.. thanks for the review

[Litttledolphin4]

how do you sharpen it? i got it and cant figure it out lol

[pollyyyb123]

i am getting this tomorrow! better be in england!!

[onvassirere]

Don't buy L'Oreal, they test on animals, they would be your own pets

[vina213]

Feline is sooo overrated! lol but if it smudges on your waterline..u can always set it with matte black powder..but if you want something that stays try the rimmel waterproof eyeliner..its AWESOME I wear contacts my eyes are all watery from allergies and that stuff doesnt budge! i highly reccoemmend it for anyone looking for a good blk liner for their waterline :)

[viviencanady]

omg im glad i watched this, im def getting this eyeliner

[hawj89]

you two are hilarious! appreciate the review...of course pricier things are always better...you just proved it...

[cinthiayfelipe]

i purchased it and it smears on me ahh.. that sucks

[PBFproductions521929]

i have the loreal liquid pencil thing in brown i also got it cuz of ginabinawina haha i like it but it doesnt stay on my waterline very long at all....so im kinda dissapointed :( i like it on my upper lash line but not my waterline

[MsBinkies]

oh my god! that's seriously amazing! i'm totally getting it the next time i'm at cvs.

[caitlin777444]

How do you sharpen it?

[BornDance]

Oh my goodness! Your new intro is so cute. I love it. I feel like it is the intro to a cute reality show!! How do you make intros in general? Thank you for this review/comparison. I have been eyeing the feline Kohl for a while, but now I am going to pick up the L'Oreal and save myself some money and smudging :D

[Gleam21]

Are you two sisters or just friends?

[AyatoMoe]

@Gleam21 OF COURSE THEY ARE SISTERS! :D Open your eyes!! looool They maybe are twins or very very close age... OMG they really deeply look like each others but JUST with different hair cut!

[beagle4864]

@Gleam21 Yes they are sisters. Tracy's on the right, she's 28 and Stef is on the left. She's 22 or 23.

[MsBinkies]

@beagle4864 are they really 28 and 22? get OUT! i just started watching them.

[fictionwriter04]

cool video! thanks so much! i don't wear eyeliner but i will definitely tell my friends who do to check out your vodeo before buying MAC :)

[MehganFox]

is there tension between us?

[xmegs11o]

ahhh thank god you did this. i was so sold on getting mac feline until i saw this. love half the price, half the smudge <3

[cheer4life1234567]

i <3 ur intro how did u do that

[eleventhgorgeous]

a friend made it for us ;)

[MoreThanWhatYouSee]

Love your intro...

X

[eleventhgorgeous]

thanks!

[TheSuperWomanX]

i need this !!! thankyou so much X

[allyssac1602]

i bought MAC Powerpoint EYE Pencil & im totally disappointed with this product, by the end of the days is everywhere but my eyes.... same thing with the UD 24/7, it dessapears,,,, if someone can give me a tip or something cuz i gotta be doiin something wrong bcuz everybody raves about that pencil in youtube.......... the 24/7........... MAC i totally gave up!!!!!!!!!!!!

[1971browneyes]

Thanks girls! I bought the Loreal liner last week after watching LovePeaceandLipgloss Gina (she actually found it first and recommended it to Ginabinawina Gina). I had a heck of a time finding it~but I LOVE it!! I was going to checking out the MAC liner, but now I won't bother!! Thanks for saving me $17.50! Just an FYI (unless you know already and if you like cream liner - otherwise nevermind!) the Wet & Wild cream liner is amazing in the waterline and doesn't budge at all! Thanks again! :)

[supagirl01]

LOVE the intro!!!!

[jaypistolx]

WOW love the intro! soo cute!

[glamcandy2]

OMg I'm going to buy yhis thanks ladies ur the best

[Bluefairy0173]

Cool New Intro :D you guys are so cute great video oxox Melinda

[munkyjam91]

aww u gals r so cute!!! i feel the same about feline being too like slippery =-/ thanks for the tips!!!

[ifloatupwards]

New into? I love it because its so cute! BTW Ulta is having a sale online and in stores L'Oreal is on a sale buy two things get one free. Now that I saw this I might go back and get that eyeliner along with some new mascara or something. Awesome video and thanks for showing us the comparison.

[MiniDOLL418]

pretty snazy intro ,but its cute !

[Ohhalyssa1]

I've been wanting to try that eyeliner..

haha so this was really helpful :D

[LilysMusics]

hey guys i want to make another video for you, what's ur favorite songs/song nowadays? xo p.s. i'm about to go try and do the eye look ur wearing right now. it's beautiful. i'm gonna go buy the l'oreal liquid pencil eyeliner!

[TheP0rcelainheart]

i really love how you guys respond to pretty much everyone.. I think its so rude when gurus dont respond to their fans who took time out of their days watching the video and commenting on it... making the gurus who they are today.. I mean I know sometimes its too many comments but still.. I know I would be able to at least write thank u to everyone..

[eleventhgorgeous]

we try :) the whole part of doing youtube is the viewers!! so we try our hardest to answer as many as we can! and we love the feedback so we like to let everyone know that by thanking them. lol ;)

[xoxninaxox20]

you know, i was wondering... what does your username mean?

[christinebenoit9]

i love the loreal eyeliner it dosn't smudge on me much.

[randomlybrooke2932]

the MAC one is darker,

[briellejacobs]

I'm going to buy that right now. I'm closing my laptop and going to Target. Eff it. Thank you!!!!!!! <3

[eleventhgorgeous]

lol :)

[x3chapstick09]

wow..LOVE the intro!! =)

[annabandanaa]

steph has perfect eyebrows.

[Chrazycat]

I's actually less than half price =] :)

[Chrazycat]

WOW! Your new intro is AMAZING!!!

[SAGERELLAwasHERE]

lol its not new, go to their older videos

[DafneCloe]

Love the intro! Very useful review, girls! Thank you!! xoxo

[eleventhgorgeous]

thanks!!!

[oncefoundmakeup]

i had a feeling the l'oreal one was gonna be good as i scanned the makeup aisles at target. i never picked it up because i had feline but for half the price, i'm definitely going to pick it up. thanks girls!!!!

[ilovetoshop1010]

awesome vid, helped me a lot!

[esmiedaddy]

omg i am going out to buy that eyeliner today i fell in love with it ;] great vid girls

[ilpr123]

the intro is so cool!

[shaycandy94]

yay you guys' intro is back!!!

wow i gotta get the l'oreal 1

[eleventhgorgeous]

we <3 it!

[kmaroney35]

Thanks guys! awesome

[MoiraS63]

you guys are great at reviews! Thanks for sharing...now I have to buy yet another eyeliner..just got the Dior one and I luv it, but for everyday use I am going to get the Revlon!!! 5*s!

[ginabinawina99]

LOL! You guys are hilarious. "half the price for half the smudging" lol!! I haven't been using my feline, either. man was it overrated! Thanks for the shoutout!

[Lunababe1989]

were is a good place to get this? i didnt see it at my local walmart

[AbercrombieGirl2011]

@Lunababe1989 try walgreens, cvs, target

[paula42396]

yes feline is awful! It really does smudge crazy. However, if you don't want to just have it sit in your drawer, it works nicely as a black base under your shadows if you are interested in looks like that. It's also nice if you use it sparringly on the upper lash line and smudge it out for more of a smokey look.

Anywy, nice review, you girls look absolutely GORGEOUS!

xoxo, Paula

[eleventhgorgeous]

thanks!! that's a good idea to use it as a base for shadows! ;)

[xoElissa]

thiss is going to be my new eyeliner. (:

thanks!

[azLizJane]

I have purchased all three colors and love them. LisaLisa1 said the brown pencil is a dupe for MAC stubborn brown.

[eleventhgorgeous]

might have to pick up the brown one! i love the black!

[BarbieBrittany1]

omg i luvvv the new intro!! so cute!

and i love both eyeliners :) they're amazing

[charmini7]

Very helpful!!, I'm running to Walgreens they have 40% off on L'oreal right now :)

[eleventhgorgeous]

yay for sales!

[sarahxmakeup]

yeah, i have a mac liner and it smuges super bad !

[beautyncharm]

thanks for the review.

[luvgandp]

glad i didn't buy feline!!! thx

[eleventhgorgeous]

i wish i had known about the loreal when i got the mac feline ;)

[Policosmetics82]

great vid! :)

[MohicanSwim]

how do u get eye liner not to smuge?

[3890Leah]

loooove the intro

[genny7172]

I loveeee you reviews!!!!!!!!!I was this close to getting the Mac Feline Kohl!!!! Thanks girls!

[eleventhgorgeous]

yay, glad we helped you!!

[LelyCheer]

can you PLEASE give a shoutout to the show "The Beautiful Life" here on youtube. It originally aired on the CW but got canceled, so Ashton Kutcher put it on here to see if it could run successfully. It would really help to put get more viewers so they can make more episodes

[ivanandjeska]

I love it this was a great video

[beachgirl7611]

Thanks for the review! Really good comparison. I'll have to look for it next time I go to Target or ULTA. Oh, and thanks for the info about the BOGO with the Revlon lipsticks - had to go to 2 Targets, but I was able to get Baby Pink and Soft Nude. Thanks again!

[eleventhgorgeous]

yay for deals and bogos!!! so glad you were able to find the deal!! ;)

[laurenavery1]

feline looks darker

[eleventhgorgeous]

that's because our light is shining on the loreal one b/c it almost looks wet which makes it look lighter because of the reflection

[luvglitter012]

Great video!:)

[Kodasaurs08]

Thanks for this video! Im in love with the Technikohl liner in GraphBlack, but i ran out. And I dont feel like going all the way to the mall to get one, soim going to walmart/target/riteaid asap! Btw-- you forgot ginabinawina's link, :D

[genam8]

I love the intro!

I was looking for a good black dark eyeliner and a lot of people recommend the Stila Black one but its like $17. I was not about to spend that much on a little pencil.

Haha I will def be looking for the L'oreal one

[GiselTY]

is it too creamy that you get clumps and stuff?

[eleventhgorgeous]

nope!! it's super easy to apply and it also doesn't lose it's point too quickly.

[eVerythingPinkk]

ooh thanks for this.

[sugarrimmed07]

OMG i love love love the intro

please chck out my channel i am trying to reach 600 before my b-day maybe could you help me if not please subscrbe!

[KaylaMarieeBubblezzz]

great vid

[DanceTrixxx]

fiiirst love u guyts