Of course it is a lot of work and it was nice of you to invest it. I am not criticizing you, but the musicians. The pieces deserve a much more subtle approach and a far better recording, that's all.
@casalQuartett Well, maybe you should record it and show me how to play these pieces. Let me know when you are ready. I will listen (but not compare........)
Grumiaux isn't god himself and therefore not immune to error. He was an excellent player, no doubt, but at Mozart's time vibrato was an ORNAMENT not a condition. This is a fact and can be learned from Leopold Mozart's violin school. Between the war and before Harnoncourt, Gardiner and others Bach and Mozart often sounded tame, boring, slow and sweet as sugar candy. If every note gets an accent and has only vertical phrasing within a fugue there is no transparency and nothing to learn from...
@casalQuartett Why can't you just enjoy the fact that I up-loaded it with score, and spend time and effort on this video and thousands more so people can enjoy splendid music, instead of criticizing it. Thank you!! I up-load out of love for music not for the sake of an argument.
@casalQuartett Ruin it? You are critical of Arthur Grumiaux and his trio? Wow! Music performance is a matter of interpretation and technique. Those are unjudgable when excellence is reached. Just enjoy the merits of this performance and keep learning.
This has been flagged as spam show
I don't like this detached style. More legato and vibrato for this beautiful fugue!
mtv565 1 month ago
Comment removed
mtv565 1 month ago
Of course it is a lot of work and it was nice of you to invest it. I am not criticizing you, but the musicians. The pieces deserve a much more subtle approach and a far better recording, that's all.
casalQuartett 3 months ago
@casalQuartett Well, maybe you should record it and show me how to play these pieces. Let me know when you are ready. I will listen (but not compare........)
bartje11 3 months ago
Grumiaux isn't god himself and therefore not immune to error. He was an excellent player, no doubt, but at Mozart's time vibrato was an ORNAMENT not a condition. This is a fact and can be learned from Leopold Mozart's violin school. Between the war and before Harnoncourt, Gardiner and others Bach and Mozart often sounded tame, boring, slow and sweet as sugar candy. If every note gets an accent and has only vertical phrasing within a fugue there is no transparency and nothing to learn from...
casalQuartett 3 months ago
@casalQuartett Why can't you just enjoy the fact that I up-loaded it with score, and spend time and effort on this video and thousands more so people can enjoy splendid music, instead of criticizing it. Thank you!! I up-load out of love for music not for the sake of an argument.
bartje11 3 months ago
How can they ruin this music by playing sooooo romantic and every note with vibrato??
casalQuartett 3 months ago
@casalQuartett Ruin it? You are critical of Arthur Grumiaux and his trio? Wow! Music performance is a matter of interpretation and technique. Those are unjudgable when excellence is reached. Just enjoy the merits of this performance and keep learning.
bartje11 3 months ago
Error- 404 not found
F1R1NMAHLAZAH 5 months ago
@F1R1NMAHLAZAH I found it. Playing just fine.
bartje11 5 months ago
@bartje11 it works for me too, i was just joking around cause this is KV404
F1R1NMAHLAZAH 5 months ago
Danke, habe Link gesetzt
MrConvivator 7 months ago
Fugue would sound better if played slightly slower and more legato....
mtv565 9 months ago
is it my impression or the fugue is from BWV 853?
karter76 11 months ago
@karter76 I just noticed that too.
SDMSProductions 10 months ago
@karter76 Yes. This is Mozart's transcription of a few Bach fugues. I believe the preludes are original.
ryanlock2u 10 months ago
@karter76 Click on the "show more" tab and you will see all the info.
bartje11 10 months ago
so very beautiful!
thank you!
sentimental gratitude from an Austrian living in Canada ;o)
mmbmbmbmb 1 year ago
wonderful!!
Mozart2you 1 year ago
i've been searching this.. man! awesome.. do you have the quartetts for the bach's transcriptions? thanks
Mozeroscar 1 year ago
@Mozeroscar
tenés las partituras para enviàrmelas por correo?
menusis 1 year ago