the truth is that elliott was....I have a great deal to say on that matter, but, we have to leave and follow. Music is an unbelievable force. Those that tell you opposite are selling you something.
Everybody has bad days. Elliot was no different. Unfortunately, musicians that play music for a living don't get the luxury of not playing even when they are having a bad day/really really high.
To be fair, this was recorded at the really low point of his career, before his death. Anyone who's seen him live will tell you that when he was on, he was on, and when he was off... well, it's still a live show with Elliott Smith. It doesn't get any better than that.
Well we'll just have to ask da myth buster, maybe they'll do it on the next season cause it's getting kinda old lol and I had I friend RIP who hung him self with a belt in the closet and that sounds just as hard to do with no noose
FOR REAL! the intro is really shaky, elliot smith sounds soooooo much better, this sounds like some youtuber in his home studio trying to sound that him. It does get better in the middle though. too bad he can't re-record it, suicide is never the answer.
@athomestudios you don't even know what really happened to him.. it's humanly IMPOSSIBLE to stab yourself in the heart, pull the knife back out and do it again. i doubt he killed himself. but if he did, he'd probably be the only person ever capable of stabbing himself in the heart more than once. if he really did that ..kudos to him i guess for being that extreme, but, it's unlikely. i feel that ppl assumed it was suicide cos of how sensitive he was and how sad he seemed. i believed it too..
@athomestudios unless the question is "What is the proper name for killing yourself?" HAH! But honestly his death was very unfortunate, though some may maintain that it was actually a homicide, doesn't make the end result any better.
Elliot covered this because one of the members of heatmiser played later with quasi, and contributes to built to spill, ie, friend of the band. Personally, i think he does a great job.
I love this. Not only because Elliot Smith and BtS make everything shiney for me...but I love the honest natural strain of his voice here. This makes me happy inside.:D
Good songwriters write to their own strengths, and Elliott has different strengths than Doug M. from BTS. Still, it's a great song, and it's fun to hear E.S. take a shot at it.
Elliott Smith is my favourite artist of all-time, and Built to Spill is my second fave band of all-time. "Car" has always been my favorite song by them.
Why didn't I know about this before?
Turns out all the songs Elliott covered are amazing (Thirteen, Because, These Days, Isn't It a Pity, this etc.)
well what I meant was that the fact that he covered this song is amazing. And yeah, no matter of this performance, he's the best songwriter ever noticed.
Take the snare down! Ffs
HomemadeIndie 3 weeks ago
The speaker was buzzing. i have the full recording of the show. not anyones fault
mustardpanckackes101 1 month ago
this was recorded with that thing kevin had in home alone 2
dirtmerchant1980 3 months ago 2
take that fuckin snare off asshole drummer :D
equallyeasilyfuqyou 3 months ago
I don't think his voice suits the song.
borisovicinovski 5 months ago
nice try, but as much as I'd like to believe it. That's not Elliott Smith.
Wilcofan1121 8 months ago
@Wilcofan1121 April 1st, 2003. Detroit Bar, Costa Mesa, CA.
YukonGoldenBoy 8 months ago
@YukonGoldenBoy sir, you've just made my day.
Wilcofan1121 8 months ago
Elliott Smith & Built to Spill? My head just exploded.
jenniferdurnell 9 months ago 20
i think the drums sounds cool just saying
lyodd989 9 months ago
and will someone teach this drummer how to turn off his snares during the quiet parts, fuck
equallyeasilyfuqyou 9 months ago
wow this exists, awesome
equallyeasilyfuqyou 9 months ago
THIS IS NOT ELLIOTT SMITH. FAKE FAKE FAKE FAKE FAKE
jasonkise 10 months ago
@jasonkise
Yes it is.
Elliott gave some awful performances during the worst of his alcoholism/drug addictions. This was probably one of them,
theuntergroundman 10 months ago
Elliott Smith is among the most overrated musicians ever. Wow, vibrato. What a fucking genius.
spacefaget 10 months ago
@spacefaget stop trolling and make some friends.
thatwalrusguy 9 months ago
@thatwalrusguy stop crying and start listening to someone other than elliott smith
spacefaget 9 months ago
@spacefaget haters gonna hate.
thatwalrusguy 9 months ago
@thatwalrusguy aka what someone says when they know a hater has a point.
spacefaget 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@spacefaget what point are you claiming to make again?
thatwalrusguy 9 months ago
shame the drums came in....
pluginwar 1 year ago 4
@pluginwar yeah seriosly he sounds like hes playing on chairs and sheet rock
DruminBobby 10 months ago
FAKER!
syrupoftears 1 year ago
the truth is that elliott was....I have a great deal to say on that matter, but, we have to leave and follow. Music is an unbelievable force. Those that tell you opposite are selling you something.
happyhalberstam 1 year ago
Everybody has bad days. Elliot was no different. Unfortunately, musicians that play music for a living don't get the luxury of not playing even when they are having a bad day/really really high.
athroughme 1 year ago
such a great song.
limbs32 1 year ago
To be fair, this was recorded at the really low point of his career, before his death. Anyone who's seen him live will tell you that when he was on, he was on, and when he was off... well, it's still a live show with Elliott Smith. It doesn't get any better than that.
teddy5549 1 year ago
Great Job Man!
Newfiepunger 1 year ago
you can hear the snare rattlin'
SlapKhan 1 year ago 2
heartbreaking
thelatedavidsmith 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hey my names jessyrowles and i was just seeing if you could click on my name and check out my new video! Thanks for your time
JessyRowles
jessyrowles 1 year ago
Dammit. This is one of my favourite songs and one of my favourite artists COMBINED! AWESOME.
stephgunit 1 year ago 4
everyone covers this song,
I swear to god,
everyone.
IKillLittlegirls 1 year ago
@IKillLittlegirls It's Elliott Smith. He can cover whatever he wants to!
Sephirothx777x 1 year ago 6
Well we'll just have to ask da myth buster, maybe they'll do it on the next season cause it's getting kinda old lol and I had I friend RIP who hung him self with a belt in the closet and that sounds just as hard to do with no noose
athomestudios 2 years ago
i like it...it's raw
kixjoy 2 years ago 3
yeah this is pretty bad, but i do understand that the audio blows
reusablecatmilk 2 years ago
Not the great mans best cover. Hope built to spill fans don't judge him just on this. It would have sounded better live too.
whitestripebuzz 2 years ago 3
theres a difference between a bad recording and not doing it right....getbiggerP and sdrink need a relisten
Schilltron30303 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This sounds like dogshit.
getbiggerpenis 2 years ago
i loved elliot smith and love built to spill but this just plain sucks.
sdrinksw 2 years ago
FOR REAL! the intro is really shaky, elliot smith sounds soooooo much better, this sounds like some youtuber in his home studio trying to sound that him. It does get better in the middle though. too bad he can't re-record it, suicide is never the answer.
athomestudios 2 years ago 5
@athomestudios you don't even know what really happened to him.. it's humanly IMPOSSIBLE to stab yourself in the heart, pull the knife back out and do it again. i doubt he killed himself. but if he did, he'd probably be the only person ever capable of stabbing himself in the heart more than once. if he really did that ..kudos to him i guess for being that extreme, but, it's unlikely. i feel that ppl assumed it was suicide cos of how sensitive he was and how sad he seemed. i believed it too..
karmacomacure 2 years ago 2
@athomestudios The police didn't declare it to be a suicide. The evidence was inconclusive and his girlfriend at the time acted very strange.
akechi77 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@athomestudios fuck you, die soon
azrial4421 1 year ago
@athomestudios damn i did not expect you to throw that suicide reference in there at the end
jaypeddie 8 months ago
@athomestudios caca
AdlejandroP 7 months ago
@athomestudios unless the question is "What is the proper name for killing yourself?" HAH! But honestly his death was very unfortunate, though some may maintain that it was actually a homicide, doesn't make the end result any better.
Mccampbellthomas 6 months ago
@sdrinksw i'd say you plainly suck
karmacomacure 2 years ago
one of the best songs ever, covered by one the greatest.
Perfect.
Feadpool2112 2 years ago 5
i agree!! Great cover!!
angelanduriil 2 years ago
i just came
ImDaFox 2 years ago
Two of my favorite artists...... I'm hypnotized.
stonesmoke21 2 years ago 4
This is so amazing.
I adore elliott smith, and built to spill is an incredible band.
This is like awesomeland for me ♥
WeAreAllOurOwnDevil 2 years ago
Is this real?
aleemotomato 2 years ago
I need a car you need a guide you need some map
If I don't die or worse I'm gonna need a nap. At best I'll be asleep when you get back...
Fox378 2 years ago
who needs a map
pivottofakie 2 years ago
<3
and fuck youtube
Paramoregirl15 2 years ago 2
Elliot covered this because one of the members of heatmiser played later with quasi, and contributes to built to spill, ie, friend of the band. Personally, i think he does a great job.
coconutbombshell 2 years ago
lovely
tatelabianca 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
butcher
jnt32001 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
top five indie bands
1. elliott smith
2. bright eyes
3. mountain goats
4. fleet foxes
5. kevin m. kirker
but elliott smith will always be #1! we miss you and love you elliott! we'll never forget you! rest in peace
astonishing00 2 years ago 3
I love this. Not only because Elliot Smith and BtS make everything shiney for me...but I love the honest natural strain of his voice here. This makes me happy inside.:D
rainydayzefish 2 years ago
Good songwriters write to their own strengths, and Elliott has different strengths than Doug M. from BTS. Still, it's a great song, and it's fun to hear E.S. take a shot at it.
jontv 2 years ago 18
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i dont think thats elliott smith?
clintgil108 2 years ago
yeah that's totally elliot. you've never heard him live?
ironichaos 2 years ago 4
nope i nvr have
clintgil108 2 years ago
BTS and Elliott Smith are so very dear to me.
Vektruscen 2 years ago 6
wow this is great. elliott plus BTS = epicness
scatmanwfm 3 years ago
this sounds awsome. i love both built to spill and elliott
narutothedobe 3 years ago
This is unbelievable.
Elliott Smith is my favourite artist of all-time, and Built to Spill is my second fave band of all-time. "Car" has always been my favorite song by them.
Why didn't I know about this before?
Turns out all the songs Elliott covered are amazing (Thirteen, Because, These Days, Isn't It a Pity, this etc.)
tutani 3 years ago
He just doesn't sound that good. Elliot always had the sweetest voice, and this one seems strained. I'll take your word for it I guess.
nickbeat1 3 years ago
well what I meant was that the fact that he covered this song is amazing. And yeah, no matter of this performance, he's the best songwriter ever noticed.
tutani 3 years ago
That's because it's a dry mic, his studio cd's are layered, chorus and reverb adds a fullness to his voice.
That's what Elliot would sound like sittin right next to you, give or take some tonal quality.
I should know, I'm stuck in the same boat, damned diaphram ain't worth a lick.
deardichotomy 3 years ago
That doesn't sound like Elliot. Can someone verify that is really him?
nickbeat1 3 years ago
oh yeah, I can even verify from the "thanks" after the song that it's Elliott.
tutani 3 years ago
It isn't Elliot, it's Elliott. ;)
sonicboom 3 years ago 6
lolz
insidefeever 2 years ago
but it's too late
jxwhee 3 years ago
Wow, thanks a lot, I love built to spill, never knew he dug doug martsch.
slctdmbntwrx 3 years ago
dug doug
deekay629 3 years ago 4
someone shut the goddam snare off haha. 2 of my favs; BTS and elliott
MadmanMoon 3 years ago 5
Woah.
I never knew he covered this song!!!
awesome. BTS is one of my fav bands.
Spartacuswolf 3 years ago
i miss you elliott
stiltedattitude 3 years ago
so unexpected, so cool.
NismoBdon 3 years ago
wow.
just beautiful.
you wouldnt know how to get an audio file of this recording would you?
wolfblass88 3 years ago 9
I got this off soulseek.
Dragonaut2112 3 years ago
Use Youtube downloader followed by AoA Audio Extractor, download them free
pandgb 3 years ago
@wolfblass88
there is a thing you can use to rip it off of here.
francmeister420 1 year ago
@wolfblass88
disagree sounds like crap
scurt420 4 months ago
Oh my god, I wish I would have known about this sooner.
Thanks.
sk8tolive123 3 years ago