Magnetmotor - VGATE05a

[ImMiketron]

It's my favorite when people don't understand the conservation of energy principle.

[richnavigator]

WOW!!! it goes around and around. Awesome!

[peterhalleffect]

you waisted all those magnets on this! whats wrong with you? I could make a ufo out of all those.

[elradiuzi]

Why would making the leading edge shielded not work... wtf....

[coasterpro]

Very expensive looking piece of kit! What with all those high quality magnets, precision cut metal discs, and specially machined parts. I'm truly impressed by how much money you've spend on a concept that has absolutely no chance of ever working.

[XoFFoX777]

Zero dude ... it doesn't run on it's own ???

[nagaya011]

no spining. wtf?

[Knoughts]

deerrrpppppppppppppppppppppp

[shadowofcloud9]

Super cool story bro, don't tell it again.

[sykoteddy]

you can build it that "advanced" using so many magnets but you can't make it spin around n around? Very Pooor! Why even bother posting the vid?

[Aerensiniac]

I wonder whats up with all the shitty trolls on every of these videos. What has been recorded its not perpetuum mobile so what? Who claimed it was?

Do everyone a favor and take your own small penises back to your respectable parents and rub it in them for not making it larger. Its ridiculous to watch all you wanna be trolls trying to project your own shitty little stories in everything involving PM projects.

[htomerif]

@Aerensiniac That's a good idea, insulting everyone. I guaran god damn tee that the person making this "motor" (notice it didn't just say "project") thought that it would be some kind of over unity device. FYI its only trolling if its wrong. Everyone who makes these things, EVERYONE thinks that magnets are some kinda fuckin magic, and its the responsibility of the rest of the world to point out that they're wrong.

[Aerensiniac]

@htomerif Wouldnt you say that whoever builds and aims for perpetuum mobile is not retarded enough to not see that his creation in fact doesnt run endlessly on its own?

The only thing i see people taking responsibility in is projecting their problems onto others and lash out at them for shortly after. Your justification is wrong at best.

[htomerif]

@Aerensiniac Wouldn't you say that using a quadruple negative in one sentence makes you a bit of a douchebag?

And yeah, our problem is that people are wasting time with things that a bit of simple math should show them are provably impossible. Please read the comments again, moron, and tell us which ones are "lashing out" at this "inventor"

[Aerensiniac]

@htomerif Wouldnt you say that answering an argument with a claim about my personality is just a bad way of self defense and avoiding answer?

Your way of using math is interesting tho. I cant quite remember who ever used math to make up new theories and inventions... probably MAINLY because math assumes our current knowledge of things as a fix base, not the empirical observations they are.

[Aerensiniac]

@htomerif Wouldnt you say that answering an argument with a claim about my personality is just a bad way of self defense and avoiding answer?

I cant quite remember who ever used math as the start to make up new theories and inventions... probably mainly because math assumes our current knowledge of things as a fix base, not the empirical observations they are, but thats just me.

And i completely agree with you. They could waste time like "real men", trolling others over the internet.

[1RAH]

I know how to make this work



[Shazbat5]

Amazing! You can spin a wheel with your finger!

[QCTechnologies]

I like the colour. In Australia we call that dog dick red.

[ableite]

You will be the one pushing my generator?

[ikov]

@ableite HAHAHAHA!!!

[MrJohnDevour]

when will all these people realize you can't harvest any surplus mechanical energy from a permanent magnet. the exact same force that act as your momentum will then counteract the process once the momentum reaches it's climax, in a perfect environment you could harvest exactly the same energy needed to start the device, but in reality you always lose energy in friction.

[AmsterdamnedMovie]

cool finger, but it's wasted on that stupid device... i wonder how much it would cost to hire it for picking my nose or scratching my arse?

[lucacazzulo]

what a looser

[TheSepticrat]

SHIT!

[jonsoroman]

Nos ha jodido el ingeniero. La máquina sólo es capaz de dar una vuelta, porque al finalizar el recorrido, los imanes se repelen y la frenan y para repetir el proceso, debe vencer la repulsión final dándole un empujoncito. Tanto curro para no haberlo previsto antes. INGENIEROOOOOOOOO !!!!

[metamaggot]

try balancing it..or putting the base at an angle so the rotor finishes its loop with gravity

[gollumsalterego]

@metamaggot The same gravity would just counter-act that force...

[theone7789]

cannot spin fast .. its totaly unbalanced lol

[crocherider]

in case he put his finger in his personal lowest hole,each time the other hole he use for speaking will make an usual and perpetual movment :mouth open and say "aouh" or "aaiiii...":perppetual and noising,amazing no ?

[Rezurok]

So it's a magnetic hill, then.

[gaaraman082]

This could be an assist for a spinning part allowing a machine to use less fuel....thats about all.



[TheOneAndOnlyMichel]

For once, just once, let there be a generator that keeps on turning and turning and turning. I'll watch a 10 hour video of that and it would provide me with much epic joyousness.

[gollumsalterego]

@TheOneAndOnlyMichel People have been trying for YEARS

[TrebleTrouble115]

dude, just dont touch the fucking thing and we will be amused! Generator stopping prick ._.

[mrtigretiger]

Ha ha your apparatus need you just as much as you need your apparatus.

If you can't live without the apparatus the apparatus can't live without. Haha

Still I think I know how to make that thing perpetual. Thanx

[mrtigretiger]

It's like a clock that's guarantee to stop work @ 6 o'clock or a 1 hr clock haha

[CognitiveNetwork]

epic fail. you need a mechanical engineering degree dude.

[bnewton81]

if the top were a flywheel would that make a difference? Would that stored kinetic energy be enough to get it past the gate?

[avrrety132]

try a haver fly wheel?? nice work

[starexports99]

Another v-gate that slams the gate in your face after 360degrees

[Assimilate71]

All that effort to make something that doesn't complete a full revolution without adding external force. You could have demonstrated the same thing by just riding your bicycle.

[joshguy43]

what if it was tipped on its side and gravity took place of the finger

[killer2600]

@joshguy43 preliminary thought is it would fail to work

[vinceqwerty100]

@joshguy43 impossible ;)

[fchiaretto]

Fake. unfortunately.

[F15rocker]

Nice workmanship and appropriate soundtrack but the only energy produced was provided by your hand. Never give up on your dreams - those who never dream of achieving never achieve.

[MrABlinkin]

you can break the gate. all you have to do is build the model 12 more times. set each one at a diffirent time. the force of the other 11 will push each other one through the gate and cause it to spin fully!!!! Good Luck

[tulp35000]

He does not stop it, it stops by itself, he only figured out half of the schematics.

[DJACKfive]

and your point is.........?



[Wmaximum]

В чём его практическая польза? о_О

[ytnerb]

shame you could not get it to do a full 360 degrees by it self.

[katsumorymoto]

A better experiment would require a MUCH larger device. The goal would be to keep the device spinning for long enough to acquire enough momentum to overcome the sticky spot. As it stands, the motor is not collecting enough momentum and momentum per revolution is key for attempting this.

The problem with a much larger device is also the fact that skeptics can much more easily claim that you're hiding a battery or wiring in a hidden storage compartment.

All this to make libertarians happy?

[Texmurphy51]

@katsumorymoto You can never get rid of the "sticking spot" Thats where the device requires energy to make the next spin.

If its a matter or momentum then just place a heavy flywheel on this device.

[deanpaarman]

sag doch bitte was das X-teil ist, danke

[spla300]

make another 2 or 3 of these and connect them so that when one slows down the other 2/3 help it, play around with the timing.

Something like an engine with cylinders, the more the better :-)

[Color12Productions]

He's so fucking close it makes me cry. :D

I'll have perpetual motion by June. :D

[danielcarmi305]

Guys, did he EVER claim this was perpetual? NO. He inputs little energy and gets a full rotation, it is highly practical. Ever think how much gas, money, and energy we could save if our engines only need to do 10% of the work rotating the axles, and magnets could do the rest? So why don't you stop saying that he is lying about a claim he never made!

[GoronkovKA]

@danielcarmi305 He spent more energy, that he earned. Please, read about the law of energy conservation.

[danielcarmi305]

@GoronkovKA I know, but this is highly efficient. I know very well the laws of physics. I meant to say that this is highly efficient.

[GoronkovKA]

@danielcarmi305

This system is highly efficient only for 1 cycle. You're talking about a system with high potential energy which is in a some state of unstable equilibrium (futher "state 1") If you add some disturbance then this system will be moved to state of stable equilibrium ("state 2") with low potential. The difference between potentials in states 1 and 2 is the energy, that you can get. But if you want to get it again you have to spend the same energy to move system from state 2 to 1

[Nickodemusodurn]

@danielcarmi305

Believe it or not he is expending more energy than he is getting back. Otherwise after the first crank in theory the machine could power itself (if attatched to a motor of some kind to kick it each time). But sadly no machine will ever generate enough power to run itself.

[rgolianeh]

In this motor, you are the motor rotor, idiot. You spend all that money, to take my time?

[rgolianeh]

That thing you do with your hand I don't like it.

[BraveWomanCandy]

what if you took multiple devices that start the chain reaction of the next in a circuit?

[yourunclehank1]

OR raise the left side til gravity pulls it across

[yourunclehank1]

need about three more mags on the end

[ericrob2112]

magnetic motors cant not work.

[drijfkip1]

Wow amazing. A Finger Powered Motor!

[canapevache]

@drijfkip1 with 2 thousands people we could make a dragster

[aaronzuky]

dejalo k gire stupid

[GuybrushUlysses]

Sind Sie Neodym magneten !?!?!?!?!?!?!?

[leelawbooboo]

That invention I can understand. Nice!

[arky3000]

if the first (smallest gap) part was in between the end part (widest gap) wouldnt it not stop? and be more efficient? lol

[marlonbtx]

if you r trying to create a motor without using energy ,read about perpetual motion ... thermodynamics

[LiamXaoh]

This is a digital motor.

Middle digit that is.

[brigitelopezruiz]

JEJEJJEJEJEJEJ

[tbcslayer]

bad design it cant go on its own .

[omnikills]

@tbcslayer Ever heard of the fucking second law of thermodynamics!?

[debrainwasher]

@omnikills Ever heard of the SECOND amendment of the FIRST law of thermodynamics? Stupidity can neither be created, nor destroyed but converted - into money.

[davavanstone]

Its funny how every video of yours, you feel the need to stop it with your hand before it finishes a complete rotation? Explain why?

[TankeS]

@davavanstone it stops by itself, its a prototype

[SuperMardiGrasBros]

@davavanstone He doesn't stop it, it stops itself. The machine tries to back up when it returns to the initial position, and he has to push the rotor through the flux increase at the start of each stroke. The motor self-accelerates until it reaches the beginning again, where he has to exert more energy than the motor can produce on its own by pushing it through the full rotation. If he left it alone and didn't push it through, it would never complete a full stroke on its own.

[TheKultus]

@davavanstone he's not stopping it with his hand he is pushing it over the sticky spot, The magnets either side of the gap at the front create equal force of a repelling nature and stop the rotor from completing a full rotation

[xxXpitboyXxx]

@davavanstone he is not stopping it. it is like like a ball rolling down a hill. it will stop then you have to carry it up again. except here there is in the mechanics of a magnet system. it is physically impossible to create energy from nothing. go back to elementary, moron

[davavanstone]

@xxXpitboyXxx "it is physically impossible to create energy from nothing" and you spend time watching supposedly possible perpetual motion machines, why?

[coatduck]

@davavanstone I don't know why he does it, but sometimes, they give me ideas for things that are actualy possible. some of them are pretty cool too, check out the ones by davinci, they are impossible, but still really clever

[xxXpitboyXxx]

@davavanstone because i have nothing better to do on youtube

[GameMaker04]

its not from nothing, its energy from the environment , magnetic force is an environmental force, by your definition there solar cells are impossible because we dont put energy into them but we get energy out. The sun like magnetic force, is an environmental force and you can use that to produce a device that gives you more energy then you put in.. this does not mean its making energy from nothing.

[ferkyou420]

@davavanstone He doesnt

[djtonyxxx5]

@davavanstone becouse the most usefull motor is the one that can only handle a single turn. in fact also ma car do this. and i have to turn the engine on every single cycle... wtf.

[HongKongBoyz100]

@davavanstone simple reason: it doesn't stop if he let's it go, and it would be pretty dangerous sticking an object like a stick in it

[kiomsie613]

eines tages wenn leute wie der george ein besseres morgen geschaffen haben, dann sagen ploetzlich die kritiker von heute: ja ich war auch schon immer an dem thema interessiert, hahaha...

one day when guys like george have created a better tomorrow, all the nay sayers of today will suddenly announce: yea i was always interested in the topic, hahaha...

[Ph1lg00d]

haha doesnt work neither, stop dreaming guy

[MueraTelevisa]

A device like that one would be perfect for a bicycle, I'm sure it would help pedaling up on hills.

[KatonBoy]

@MueraTelevisa

The magnets would make the bike a lot heavier.

[wyrrox]

If I were you, I wouldn't even upload this on youtube.

[fuckystoat]

finger motor...?

[mbudd121]

ever notice how every vgate design you see doesn't work?  Maybe perhaps the scientists are right when then said years ago that this won't work.

[escorpionfox22]

fake booooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­

[craig265]

need three

[redmp68]

How do you say gay in german?

[billrbushatutube]

GOOD WORK IT LOOKS LIKE YOU SPENT SOME MONEY ON MAGNETS SO FAR ,TRY ANDING TEN MORE STACKS ON TO YOUR STARTING POINT,OVER LAPING THE FINISH POINT BY ONE OR TWO AND ADD A FLYWHEEL LIKE BUDDY SAID KEEP GOING YOUR ALL MOST THERE .AND CALL IT COEFFICENT AND YOU GOT IT.GOOD JOB

[Bubblytubebob]

All you need is a flywheel to keep the momentum to get to the start point again

[onthecuttingedge2005]

you'd be better off if you sold the work you did to a novelty store.

[obese1konobe]

Und jetz??

[MuF123]

MOTOR is something that takes energy from steam, or sun, or electricity and converts it to some kind of movement that can run something else.

May I ask what can be run with this? Because when this can be used to run anything, it isn't a motor.

[n1gn0gyo]

what if you added a swinging pivoting arm with a weight at the end that swong forward when it stopped to push it over the point where it stops each time

[svartahridxhgc]

Ok, now do not touch it.

[TheFizzlerr]

@svartahridxhgc yah stop catching it and let it turn.

[jib1000]

@TheFizzlerr Its stopping he isn't catching it.

[ficken360]

ja nu mal klartext.... nichts davon läuft..... und teil X existiert nicht.....

sie haben noch eine stromrechnug.... hätten sie diese nicht würde man ihnen ggf. glauben!

mfg jemand der es besser weiß!

[foxacoustics]

Why is it that everyone shows a single arm/rotating magnet unit not working?

Add 2,3,4 or 5 more arms with more rotating magnets. Only one can be in the sticky spot at a time so it seems like the more arms/magnets you have the more it will overpower the sticky spot.

[Eaglebird]

@foxacoustics This is not free energy. The motor works on the principle that the initial movement (the few degrees you push it to get it started) push it over the 'hill' and it rolls down said 'hill'. When it comes back around, it's coming back up the hill, but due to losses in friction and magnetic flux, it will not have the same energy to make it up the hill. Adding more arms serves no point.

[leigh7801]

@Eaglebird Who said anything about free energy

[Eaglebird]

@leigh7801 This entire page. I'm sorry to learn you can't infer anything.

[theemurf]

It seems to me, if there were 6 nor 7 arms spaced out evenly instead of just 1, then when each arm reaches the catching point, it might be cancelled by the other 5 or 6 arms that would be at the powerful part of the cycle. 1 catching point but 5 or 6 arms busy being propelled. Worth a try.

[UltimateSign]

"Ohne Teil X"

Taugt sonst auch nix...

LOL...

[bluesisk]

Guter Aufbau, auch die Beschleunigung ist gut zu sehen.

Mit 8 Rotormagneten ist die "Abbremsung" (beim Verlassen des V) allerdings auch 8mal zu überwinden. ;)

[ZZ2SVA]

Ja,Dietmar jetzt mit meinen Teil X würde er so beschleunigen das du es nicht mehr anhalten kannst ohne abzubremsen.

[dietmarhohl]

Grüß Dich George! Ja ich weiß. Mit den restlichen Rotorelementen und mit dem Teil-X wird kein Auge trocken bleiben. Huch!

[serverlala]

teil x , tippe mal auf abschirm material

[sirHOAX]

Are you using a CNC Machine to cut those templates? They look precision. Really excellent work.

Checked out your website. Nice that you show a lot of information on what you are building. Thanks for the link.

Appears that if you layered that design it would spin indefinitely. Regards, --S--

[hochplatte]

Herr Hohl,

dieses Modell 100 Fach auf Youtube. Das ist ganz klar eine Sackgasse. Warum dieser Versuch?

[intmusic]

@hochplatte

um die Leute zu verwirren und damit den Nobel Preis alleine nur für den George zu beanspruchen ;)