Y es lo que hay Mrs. Robota. gracias a tus videos comprendio mucho mas de la historia de MT, que me ha deceps+cionado bastante, sin embargo, es la banda de mis sueños. Gracias por este video, que la verdad , por parte de Dieter, comprueba la horrible voz que tenia, en Blue system era un poco menos horrible.
@rytmic83 Ok I won't be unfair with SIB, I will tell you what happened. Actually part of this video was taken first by a moron for discredited and insult to SIB (he said this show that bohlen was real singer and not them LOL), but he didn't realize only was discrediting the same Bohlen showing his real tuneless voice, and this was very funny, many months later i could find the complete video (this one) and upload for show it. So it was for sure a big kick ass to this idiot. You understand now?.
I personally wonder how much the dieter B.mohl l create such great music when you can not and no one could sing, live. It's kind of like Milli Vanilli. Thomas is a good singer.
Hola! Verdaderamente nunca crei que dieter pudo cantar un vivo con su vos,por dios que verguenza.pero algo se debe admitir en todo esto.sin dieter nunca se hubiera formado Modern Talking,eso es mas que claro y seguro.(mas alla de todas las farsas.) y otra cosa que me dejo en duda.los coros de SIB denuncian a dieter de haberlos ocultado.claro claro y yo en el 2 album leo en una parte:Many tanks To our Friends Detlef Wedke,Birger Corleis,Michael Scholtz,voy al caso que Al menos los nombro...
@nosequeponer1994 no puedes justificar con un par de menciones en algun disco, todo un trabajo de muchos años (no solo haciendo coros sino tambien haciendo los arreglos y otras cosas), eso fue realmente nada si tambien tomas en cuenta que recibian solo una propina por cantar en esos discos y aparte que se les prohibia que trabajaran independientemente en producciones propias... eso era algo más que injusto
@MrsRobota Si si ya se,,, Tienes toda la razon no te lo discuto...pero debes admitir que si Dieter no hubiera hablado con Los coros y con thomas no hubiese habido Modern _Talking
Well i guess we can agree to disagree.Bottom line is we all enjoy the music no matter who wrote it or produce it.My only problem with all these artists from the 80s is that even now in the year 2010 they still use playback in concert.I dont know whats wrong with all the fans in Russia.These artists still tour and popular there but all they do in concert is use playback.And they charge people money for this sham??The guy onstage sounds exactly like he did 20 years ago??Are these people deaf?
Martin Gore gave his home worked demos to Alan Wilder and whoever produced next DM album and they made it into what you heard on the album.Did you know that Enjoy The Silence was originally a ballad until Alan Wilder put a club beat on it?But on all DM albums it still said "All words and music by Martin Gore".Same goes for MT and BS.Since Dieter was the originator of the ideas he got all the credit for it.Was it fair???Absolutley not but thats the way the cookie crumbles so to speak.
My comment will be a little lenghty so bare with me please.After watching the video that i was pointed to i came to the conclusion that nowhere in that documentary did anybody say that Dieter did not write his own songs.Yes Dieter did not ARRANGE his own song but he did write and produce them.I also would like to point out that the whole business of making demos and then giving them to other people to produce is very common.Let me give you a perfect example.Depeche Mode.
@NewOrderCure Dieter Bohlen didn't wrote the lyrics of the songs, because he doesn't know english, he had always this problem, then other people was asked to help in this part, about to produce, during the trial with Corleis, also was claimed a copyright, because Bohlen just made some sounds, and then asked to end the song, so it mean he really didn't compose totally these songs. I don't care about any other band, we are talking here about Modern Talking
Bueno, vamos por partes... la primera estrofa de thomas es absolutamente directo hasta llegar a los falsetes donde ya están de fondo los grabados de estudio y esto contínua sin embargo en la segunda estrofa de thomas, donde se nota perfectamente que canta encima de su propia voz grabada (tb de la version de estudio) en fin... es el primer directo que escucho de ellos en los 80 y ni siquiera en condiciones... jejejee Dieter, FATAL! Thomas, estupendo.
se demuestra la verdadera voz de dieter, pero el tipo algo tuvo que ver con la fama del grupo, sigo diciendo que modern talking era la voz de Thomas ,los coros de Sib, todo reunido por el buen ojo y talento de dieter
@jukakoreg75 no realmente, eso es lo que dieter quiere todos crean, pero el trabajo en estudio fue realizado por todo un equipo, hay nombres que ni conocemos que tuvieron más que ver ke Bohlen en ese éxito, al único que conociamos era a Luis Rodriguez, pero por ejem. la idea de los falsetes fue de SIB, las letras compuestas por Geff, y si Bohlen es un excelente marketero y hombre de negocios, pero artista?, lo dudo...
Es el primer "concierto" de Modern Talking donde veo a Dieter Bohlen cantando los coros de verdad. Normalmente no canta o no se le oye. Aquí sí que se le oye. Digamos que no lo hace muy bien, pero no pienso quejarme, todo lo contrario, adoro a ese tio.
@joancasanovas Por si no entiendes ingles, este video lo subi solo para demostrar que Dieter Bohlen NUNCA cantó en Modern Talkiing. Hubo veces en las que a MT se le obligó presentarse en vivo y es allí donde él tuvo problemas, Bohlen siempre movia solo los labios, además, no escribió siquiera esa canciones, y ya va siendo hora de que el mundo se entere
I know that Mrs Robota is a huge SIB fan and she like to give Dieter any dont credit for creating that famous MT sound and i am cool with that.I also know that Dieter cant play guitar and cant really sing although i do enjoy listening to Blue System.I also know that during his concerts in Russia in the 90s Bohlen would "sing" over his playback voice which was a travesty and i cant believe people paid money to see that.But now i read he didnt write his own songs?Is that true??
I still think that Dieter's voice appears on some MT songs, but only talking or whispering, not singing... Like in "The Angels Sing In NY City" (the "Can you see the Albatross" verse), the whispering part of Jet Airliner and in "Who Will Save The World". Dieter's problem is that he hasn't a powerful voice and it gets easily out-of-tune... :D But anyway I respect his songwriting exquisite talent... :)
@moderntalkingalex yes his voice appear as effect only in short parts of some songs. And btw Dieter didn't know english, he was not the song writter of these songs, but he took the credits or the real composers like Geff Harrison, is time to say the truth!!.
Great video!!! Realy Live!!!
djlatt17 5 months ago
This is priceless, thanks for uploading!
justanotionX 9 months ago
Y es lo que hay Mrs. Robota. gracias a tus videos comprendio mucho mas de la historia de MT, que me ha deceps+cionado bastante, sin embargo, es la banda de mis sueños. Gracias por este video, que la verdad , por parte de Dieter, comprueba la horrible voz que tenia, en Blue system era un poco menos horrible.
hookedonlove1987 11 months ago
Love MT, but the guy in yellow jumpsuit is horrible at singing, and plays the guitar like it dominates the whole song...
rob2049 11 months ago
by the way,thank you very much for this video !!
rytmic83 1 year ago
@rytmic83 Ok I won't be unfair with SIB, I will tell you what happened. Actually part of this video was taken first by a moron for discredited and insult to SIB (he said this show that bohlen was real singer and not them LOL), but he didn't realize only was discrediting the same Bohlen showing his real tuneless voice, and this was very funny, many months later i could find the complete video (this one) and upload for show it. So it was for sure a big kick ass to this idiot. You understand now?.
MrsRobota 1 year ago
I personally wonder how much the dieter B.mohl l create such great music when you can not and no one could sing, live. It's kind of like Milli Vanilli. Thomas is a good singer.
Regina4431 1 year ago
que piolas
154049903 1 year ago
Hola! Verdaderamente nunca crei que dieter pudo cantar un vivo con su vos,por dios que verguenza.pero algo se debe admitir en todo esto.sin dieter nunca se hubiera formado Modern Talking,eso es mas que claro y seguro.(mas alla de todas las farsas.) y otra cosa que me dejo en duda.los coros de SIB denuncian a dieter de haberlos ocultado.claro claro y yo en el 2 album leo en una parte:Many tanks To our Friends Detlef Wedke,Birger Corleis,Michael Scholtz,voy al caso que Al menos los nombro...
nosequeponer1994 1 year ago
@nosequeponer1994 no puedes justificar con un par de menciones en algun disco, todo un trabajo de muchos años (no solo haciendo coros sino tambien haciendo los arreglos y otras cosas), eso fue realmente nada si tambien tomas en cuenta que recibian solo una propina por cantar en esos discos y aparte que se les prohibia que trabajaran independientemente en producciones propias... eso era algo más que injusto
MrsRobota 1 year ago
@MrsRobota Si si ya se,,, Tienes toda la razon no te lo discuto...pero debes admitir que si Dieter no hubiera hablado con Los coros y con thomas no hubiese habido Modern _Talking
nosequeponer1994 1 year ago
@nosequeponer1994 Y viceversa, pero quien se quedo con toda la fama y dinero??? y quienes son los olvidados?? recuerda siempre eso
MrsRobota 1 year ago
Conclusion:handsose face of Thomas and Dieter's cheerful smile saved the song. I couldn't even imagine that Bohlen gotta detonating voice!
Freyalll 1 year ago
Gracias por compartirlo!!
jrcasano 1 year ago
Well i guess we can agree to disagree.Bottom line is we all enjoy the music no matter who wrote it or produce it.My only problem with all these artists from the 80s is that even now in the year 2010 they still use playback in concert.I dont know whats wrong with all the fans in Russia.These artists still tour and popular there but all they do in concert is use playback.And they charge people money for this sham??The guy onstage sounds exactly like he did 20 years ago??Are these people deaf?
NewOrderCure 1 year ago
Martin Gore gave his home worked demos to Alan Wilder and whoever produced next DM album and they made it into what you heard on the album.Did you know that Enjoy The Silence was originally a ballad until Alan Wilder put a club beat on it?But on all DM albums it still said "All words and music by Martin Gore".Same goes for MT and BS.Since Dieter was the originator of the ideas he got all the credit for it.Was it fair???Absolutley not but thats the way the cookie crumbles so to speak.
NewOrderCure 1 year ago 2
My comment will be a little lenghty so bare with me please.After watching the video that i was pointed to i came to the conclusion that nowhere in that documentary did anybody say that Dieter did not write his own songs.Yes Dieter did not ARRANGE his own song but he did write and produce them.I also would like to point out that the whole business of making demos and then giving them to other people to produce is very common.Let me give you a perfect example.Depeche Mode.
NewOrderCure 1 year ago 6
@NewOrderCure Dieter Bohlen didn't wrote the lyrics of the songs, because he doesn't know english, he had always this problem, then other people was asked to help in this part, about to produce, during the trial with Corleis, also was claimed a copyright, because Bohlen just made some sounds, and then asked to end the song, so it mean he really didn't compose totally these songs. I don't care about any other band, we are talking here about Modern Talking
MrsRobota 1 year ago
Bueno, vamos por partes... la primera estrofa de thomas es absolutamente directo hasta llegar a los falsetes donde ya están de fondo los grabados de estudio y esto contínua sin embargo en la segunda estrofa de thomas, donde se nota perfectamente que canta encima de su propia voz grabada (tb de la version de estudio) en fin... es el primer directo que escucho de ellos en los 80 y ni siquiera en condiciones... jejejee Dieter, FATAL! Thomas, estupendo.
jenriquest 1 year ago
se demuestra la verdadera voz de dieter, pero el tipo algo tuvo que ver con la fama del grupo, sigo diciendo que modern talking era la voz de Thomas ,los coros de Sib, todo reunido por el buen ojo y talento de dieter
jukakoreg75 1 year ago
@jukakoreg75 no realmente, eso es lo que dieter quiere todos crean, pero el trabajo en estudio fue realizado por todo un equipo, hay nombres que ni conocemos que tuvieron más que ver ke Bohlen en ese éxito, al único que conociamos era a Luis Rodriguez, pero por ejem. la idea de los falsetes fue de SIB, las letras compuestas por Geff, y si Bohlen es un excelente marketero y hombre de negocios, pero artista?, lo dudo...
MrsRobota 1 year ago
Es el primer "concierto" de Modern Talking donde veo a Dieter Bohlen cantando los coros de verdad. Normalmente no canta o no se le oye. Aquí sí que se le oye. Digamos que no lo hace muy bien, pero no pienso quejarme, todo lo contrario, adoro a ese tio.
joancasanovas 1 year ago
@joancasanovas Por si no entiendes ingles, este video lo subi solo para demostrar que Dieter Bohlen NUNCA cantó en Modern Talkiing. Hubo veces en las que a MT se le obligó presentarse en vivo y es allí donde él tuvo problemas, Bohlen siempre movia solo los labios, además, no escribió siquiera esa canciones, y ya va siendo hora de que el mundo se entere
MrsRobota 1 year ago
I know that Mrs Robota is a huge SIB fan and she like to give Dieter any dont credit for creating that famous MT sound and i am cool with that.I also know that Dieter cant play guitar and cant really sing although i do enjoy listening to Blue System.I also know that during his concerts in Russia in the 90s Bohlen would "sing" over his playback voice which was a travesty and i cant believe people paid money to see that.But now i read he didnt write his own songs?Is that true??
NewOrderCure 1 year ago 2
@NewOrderCure search my video "La Historia de Dieter Bohlen - Anexo II"
MrsRobota 1 year ago
I think it was last time when they real-lfe xD
MrsRobota great thanks for that video, it's very nice!
orionus 1 year ago
I still think that Dieter's voice appears on some MT songs, but only talking or whispering, not singing... Like in "The Angels Sing In NY City" (the "Can you see the Albatross" verse), the whispering part of Jet Airliner and in "Who Will Save The World". Dieter's problem is that he hasn't a powerful voice and it gets easily out-of-tune... :D But anyway I respect his songwriting exquisite talent... :)
moderntalkingalex 1 year ago 2
@moderntalkingalex yes his voice appear as effect only in short parts of some songs. And btw Dieter didn't know english, he was not the song writter of these songs, but he took the credits or the real composers like Geff Harrison, is time to say the truth!!.
MrsRobota 1 year ago