Lou Reed & Metallica - Sweet Jane (Live - Madison Square Garden - October 30, 2009)

[dnch]

lars gone totally crazy?

[juanperez43]

this performance is better than the whole lulu album

[justplainjoe]

Is Lou Reed even saying words?

[LeMetalGuy]

I am the table

okay

[aot99901]

There are 186 people that are not true metalheads

[EpiphoneLesPaulBlack]

@aot99901 those people are the real metalfans here....thats crap

[beiuMETALLICA]

Metallica it's worse it Lou Reed

James is the best vocalist what i ever heard.

i Don't think this old man it's good for the METALLICA

[vadesdecero]

da' fuck was that...

[eltonma]

Damn... What's next?? Metallica and Britney Spears ??? Fivesome? Come on....

[illidankratos]

haahhahahahaah metallica is so fucked

[IlluminatedPhantom]

People think this is a Metallica song? LOL. I think its safe to say Metallica fans are the most stupid fans in music, I mean just look at their logic, heavy/hard = good soft = bad. What's more shameful is them continuously insulting a music legend like Lou Reed, someone, the majority of them have just learned of. Them not knowing who lou reed is really says a lot about their music knowledge, making what they say about him void and invalid.

[LordHondros]

@IlluminatedPhantom fuck off. I've been a metallica fan since the age of 4 (parents grew me up with a wide variety of music). Generalizing ALL metallica fans like that is a huge freaking no no. I for one was not a huge fan of Lulu, but gave it credit where it is due.

[DanBlabbers]

I have to put this out here but Sweet Jane is a legendary song. Written 40 years ago, Metallica obviously look up to lou reed for all the contributions he put into Rock and Roll. For all of you who think his voice is too dull and say he can't sing. You should know it was Lou who put sex and drugs into rock and roll. HE made it dark. He's the king of the new york underground. Heroin, cocaine, polymorphic sex. Calling the song Sweet Jane shit shows how much of a musical ignoramus you are.

[staticfreaker]

@DanBlabbers Does that make this performance, and Lulu for that matter, good? Cause it's not. No one should listen to this. It honestly sounds like some old man was offered to sing with a rock band and this was the end result. This performance sucks my ass.

[HeliusRE]

@staticfreaker I couldn't agree more. This is atrocious. Very unfortunate for all artists involved, I feel :P

[MpchermidafilhoA]

I wonder if Metallica see those comments...

[Diaarozza]

Alright, this may be not as good as THE BLACK ALBUM or One or any of these epic hits ever made before but I still like it... It's just has a new style than the other albums and I still believe that the thrash metal first band ever can do better than any other in the whole fuckin world :)

[lilD20205]

@Diaarozza I'm all for being different but this sounds like shit.

[Diaarozza]

@lilD20205 unfortunately it does xD hope that the new album does better anyway

[ORIONSTARSEED]

This is SHIT!

[ORIONSTARSEED]

Megadeth are now way ahead of Metallica ... and thats a FACT!

[xbox360pwnsall]

@ORIONSTARSEED Nope. just this album they put out with Lulu sucked. Metallica is still ahead of Megadeth. The new songs they put out (beyond magnetic) are pretty good.

[ilmaialinofortunato]

FA CAGARE

[AKLPUNDERGROUND]

i love how into it they look

[Arielbg]

Its supposed to be a narrative, I still don't like it, but its supposed to be like that...

[MegadethDM7]

Honestly Fuck metallica...

[SilentJ2602]

if metallica does not pick their shit up with a fucking rocking album i dont know that ill bother with their albums much anymore

[SilentJ2602]

what the fuck was that piece of shit

[hunterspeckamador]

wow bad experiment!!! metallica was great and lou red with the velvet underground make incredible songs...but...please don't fuck your legacy

[ZX2ManDave]

Remember back in the day when Hetfield would come out on stage with FUCK Bon Jovi on his guitar? Now he's dickriding on this old codgers junk? I'd rather listen to Bon Jovi anyday over this nonsense. In fact i will take it one step further, Justin Bieber is heavier and more metal than this shit.

[Pinonso95]

mp3 download? please

[izzyp301]

Not enough table !

[boyomeboyo]

@ericmarshall19

they're not booing. they're "Louing".

[ericmarshall19]

lmao at the boos 0:16

[built2shred2010]

Wouldn't even pay 5 bucks to see them play these songs.guitar solo was so far off weak

[built2shred2010]

Sucks

[PowermetalCoffe]

wtf..........................



[MrLeo2885]

2:37 he wants hetfields dick.

[aitseddik]

so not metallica



[THEMASTEROFYOU2000]

wow, if they really wanated to do another garage album I surely could have picked some hotter tunes....lols.poor lou reed.....he still has to look to find A D and G on the guitar.after what 50 years?.lols.oh well....they can do what they like, and if thats what they like well more power to them......people buy what they like,and people dont buy this I imagine.all good..one wonders if metallica knows this songs about a tranny and not heroin tho.hmmmmmmm??

[Waltoooooo]

Man, this is the only time I can say that I wouldn't like to be there.

[conspiracyofravens]

what the hell. this is just not like metallica. what the fuck have they done? i bet cliff burton is watching this, and he is shitting him self.

[milosgelic]

is so guyyy.... thumbs UP if you HATE this shit :S :S: S

[unforgivenromantic]

Ok, you guys. This is only bad cuz you come on expecting heavy ass shit. Granted it ain't NEARLY as good as any of their other CDs, including their shitty ones, but I don't think they were going for that at all. I think they were going for a rock and roll style rather than the thash we've come to expect from them.

[xTroels]

this is really.... bad :S

[ImSiCJim]

Also you take and a bonus cd with the title "Ozzy Osbourne's prophet words"

which it contains the chorus of the crazy train " I'm going off the rails on a crazy train (twice) "

Order it NOW !!!

[ImSiCJim]

Well people !!! If you wanna suicide, order now the new LuLu Metallica's album!

Any illegal copies of this mastershit, will be chased down! ~ by Lars Ulrich pt.4 line 3 ~

[chewbaca1997]

kirk hammet is a faggot. lol

[despain79]

Sounds like shit

[Mferno1]

I am just amazed :o I never thought something that used to sound so good, could become this much SHIT.... Man... Atleast they found a tempo in wich Lars could keep up :PpPpPPPp

[DECIFERTHIS09]

when you try to think of the progression of metallica, you think they would be like a death metal hardcore band like all the others now, but they soften I like the instruments still, but get lu of the stage.

[dougmilne27]

sorry, but this is gay.

[hellodeh07]

Jesus... they need to stop

[danieljh]

This has me all F^^ked up. I was a Lou Reed fan for 2 decades and a Metallica fan since about 8 konths before cliff died. Strange how they are jamming with lou now. I hated the last 3 Metallica Albums..but I really don't know what to think of their collaboration with Lou at this point.

[hellspeaker87]

It appears Metallica just likes to get on stage and make noise now days.

[Rammsteinmetz]

crowd shouting "boooooo", Lou thinks "hey, they are shouting my name"

[ewindsor10]

I am ashamed for alot of things but I am ashamed that I ever was a metallica fan.

[DivinaMorbi]

whaat the fuk! Metallica was this desperate are u shitting me?!?! this guys gonna fucking have a heart attack. worst fucking disapointment since gay rights act.

[Stewpa2000]

Without Lou Reed and the Velvet Underground influencing hundreds of musicians, more than likely, we wouldn't have Metallica. Gotta pay our respects.

[revepenate]

@Stewpa2000 WTF??????

[WMGsuck]

I would have booed too...

[jtelefunken7]

Everyone is having a great time and it's a great tune--lay off with all of the negative comments...

[WMGsuck]

@jtelefunken7

Everyone but us, the fans of Metallica and Metal in general

[XHappyKillerX]

st anger is a masterpiece compared to that

[oretom97]

@XHappyKillerX I can not understand y many people think st anger was that bad, it was just different, this is different as well but the attempt didn't succeed

[MpchermidafilhoA]

@XHappyKillerX I don't think St. Anger is bad...

[timuss]

There not booing there saying LOU LOU!!!

[PopsiclesFreezer]

@timuss now they have reasons to boo them...Man what happened to Metallica...Lulu is the worst album ever...DAMN!!!!

[zetyadrian]

hmm well this vid started as muted I guess I shoulnd'tve change that... : /

[dexterinligne]

metallica is too poor to made this bizarre project. niquels for them, for god's sake!

[dexterinligne]

shit

[bahumutSIN]

wow none of this collaborates at all. I love operatic metal or symphonic metal and none of this sounds good at all. Im hoping its the just because its live

[Mordadigsjalv]

Well, this is pure fucking shit, any porngrind band is better than that

[maysonseyebrow]

Were they Booing or saying Lou?

[RockRollerDJ]

Esto es ridiculo, el mundo se ha vuelto loco. ¿de que coño va esto?

[Colonsigmoide]

0:18 the audience booed him?

[saggiehead]

Why did they boo him? I just think that their music style don't mesh. I love this song, but here it just doesn't work.

[TrashMojo]

only thing i liked about that was kirks tone and solo. other than that i just dont like it. it doent make sense to me like, i dont even have a good comparison or quip for this......meanwhile at mustaines house

[zetetic666]

Cowboy Junkies did the definitive version of this song. Even lou reed admitted that. This is pointless dross by increasingly irrelevant has-beens dining out on a misplaced sense of their own star-quality which itself trades off past glories they have no right to any more. Too many yes men around them, not enough people saying: NO! - this is not different, not interesting, not relevant, not necessary and not good. Poor Rob (remember Suicidal?) Meanwhile at mustaine's house... :D

[eskariot]

omg, what's this shit...

[George32027]

this is so different compared to other metallica's works. it's not bad, just...different

[andreronco]

@George32027 Different as in retarded or handicapped?

[pstamatiou]

great song, great artists and a HORRIBLE DRUMMER that ruins everything!

[dukeraoul100]

i love this song but lou is looking like he doesn´t know where he is waking up :D

[George32027]

@dukeraoul100 i disagree. he's just getting pretty old, hence the strange look

[UglyPratFace7]

I don't think I'll be into LuLu, as much as I adore Metallica. ... I know the album's about a character in a German play from about 100 years ago, so I find it interesting that they've had a go at making a concept album because narrative within music is quit cool ... I just think I wont like the album from what I've heard so far.

[wigus]

Videos showing someones DEATH should be banned from YT!

[BulletForMyTeacher]

What is grandpa doing on the stage with Metallica? ;O

End of the World is coming...

[mrslipknot1930]

Sweet Jane = good!

Lulu = fuck ..

[jacktheripper45ds]

You immature "metalheads" who comment this, you know that without lou reed and the velvet underground, metal wouldn't exist in this kind?

i thought metalheads are tolerant and open for experiments...

[pellyell]

thats not singing!, thats talking!!!

[thethorn42]

Thirteen!

[falcopotter]

why? why? why? Metallica

You sold U.U

[VocalDomain]

@falcopotter Whether you like it or not, I quite don't get how would this be selling? A heavy metal band teaming up with a rock icon is selling? How?

[JoxTraex]

I'm a fan of trying new things but this is just terrible. There is no key synchronization with the voices.. and as such it sounds terrible. Lou reed and Metallica should never happened. I'm a huge fan of Metallica but I will never buy this album.. dare I say if it includes this guy then it must be as bad as st. anger.

[juanmax94]

I DON'T LIKE THIS !

[Yossupdude91]

@juanmax94 none of us do.

[tattooedturners]

rock and roll is supposed to be fun and bring people together... and re: Trujillo....yeah...i'm sure he's real upset.. he could retire tomorrow.

[potitocaquita]

meanwhile in heaven, cliff burton "*palmface*"

[Yossupdude91]

@potitocaquita hell*

[brosestallica]

Don´t know if i must cry or just kill myself

[Stevenakos123]

Fuck! Lou Reed is terrible!! His voice is Terrible!

[FBIfoxmulderrr]

I'm cursing that day when Lou Reed met Metallica...

[Bafometson]

fuck this the music is dead

[dreekii]

this sucks 100%

[dreekii]

lou reed is to old for metallica

[dandinofat]

@dreekii ....And some Metallica's fans seems to be too narrow minded for Lou.

[hahahahihihification]

ya i respect them for going out of their ordinary but metallica and lou reed should never have happened

[Alive4Metal]

when are close minded "metal head" going to stop being hypocrites and realize the Metallica make music to please themselves, not to kiss the mass's ass

[tneal1990]

dog shite

[boondockflip]

this is nothing like Sweet Jane at all

[boondockflip]

ummm what WTF?

[zilvee]

fuck lou reed

[MetalHead2710]

@zilvee Up yours just cause it aint metal, metallica is epic GFY!

[zilvee]

@MetalHead2710 metallica is epic, but this shit is total tragedy

[MetalHead2710]

@zilvee Lol true sorry thought you dissed metallica

[Alhambrattp]

to think Lulu sounds even worse and at some points identical to this garbage......

[navezou94]

Remind me of Whiskey in the Jar (Metallica version)

[FBIfoxmulderrr]

Playing with lou reed ok, but recording a cd with that kind of music is a fucking lie the fans...

[Itsygooo]

Lou Reed è un grande, ma quando si esibisce live sembra un ubriaco al pub!

Lou Reed is great, but when he performs live he sings like a drunk man at the pub!

[edkowitsch96]

epic fail......



[nosnayack]

well i am not immature and my cosmic joke is being saved for song lines.

FOR REAL. I may be immature but I am also a table. A very nice table. A table

to show fine expensive thing on. a precious a artistic table. no crumbs or

yesterdays nrews. The cat is forbidden on this table. Iif u find me t a flea market

it was your lucky day table. table are deep. i stop...to ponder. tables.

[nosnayack]

it is another cosmic joke. the absurdity of the universe serving us our dose.

it's what we are here for, too suffer in disappointment & find an adequate way

to self medicate, pass all drug tests (or not) and .... to die in a state selective reasoning expressing no regrets, and the band played on. the birds still sang. to be human is to reason an drink going insane! i am a bong. a fable. a myth. a table!

[andrewantosik]

All of these comments are so immature, im a metal head, but im also open minded and respect musicians for going out of the ordinary, isnt that what make metal popular in the first place? being different.

[MrSmh89]

@andrewantosik I have to agree

[Exalmer]

@andrewantosik OK, dear fellow metalhead... Y do u think me and many other Metallica fans luv Metallica?? Hmmm??? Brutal, Pure Heavy Metal... Load, ReLoad is a fail including this album... Y?? Cus its not the same Metallica we know and luv... Yes metal is popular for being different but come on... THIS does not qualify for Metal... At least make Lou Reed sing using a METALic vocal and maybe I'll buy it... Open minded eh?? K, I'll accept Metallica is not metal anymore...

[mark23q]

meanwhile at mustaines house: HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

[allinrocks]

better than Lulu

[BobWizard]

yeah i was afraid the majority of metallica fans doesn´t get it, but nevermind....anyhow, me never having been a metallica fan at all really like this, thanks lou!

[jorge782210]

great song.



[luigibattista10]

I want to kill myself.

[AmadeusRw]

0:17 this part says it all...

[iamcoak]

WTF... I'm going to wait till metallicagetsthere shit together. Im just disapointed right now. . :'(

[rockeropsycodelic]

hahahahahahahah lou reed is shit,,, and metallica isnt metallica

[MacExperiment]

It is avantgarde and different music tones. Art music mixed with rock. They are brave to play this shit. It is so new and different, I think a new fan group will find this band. Pop and dance people and the old fans will not like this if they dont like softer form of rock.

[Yezu666]

This is terrible... I'm speechless...

[Technicolorpoets]

I don't understand why people say it's shameful of Metallica to team up with Lou Reed. Lou Reed can do so much better than this, he doesn't need a lousy band like Metallica. I mean, he was in the Velvet Underground ffs. The result of this teaming up is terrible.

[Misslotusification]

@Technicolorpoets THANKS FOR REMINDING THAT!

[Misslotusification]

@Technicolorpoets THANKS FOR REMINDING THAT! It doesnt go either ways, its not the right guitar sound for Sweet Jane :-(

[MrJaisonxx]

metallica decayo con este disco D:

[TheLittleVirus]

It sounds better than Lulu though.

[RobinJansenMusic]

Next terrible performance: Metallica feat. Rebbeca Black - Friday

[AnamariaOcampo99]

this fucking sucks, kirk wtf are you headbanging to god dammit?

[pandemoniker]

Biggest load of shit they ever produced

[sinner00000]

damn man, this guy is out of tune so badly :( .. wtf is going on :( ? shit

[dasapa79]

sounds well fucked up at 1:52.

[Mytzita22]

HIS VOICE SUCKS!

i prefer James's voice. 

come on please.

[taj334]

Metallica are free to do what they want. Death Magnetic was a great thing, but i don´t see myself visiting a Metallica concert in the future if they continue doing this stuff. I wonder what the Big Four shows are going to look like.

ANTHRAX

MEGADETH

SLAYER

METALLICA ft. LOU REED

Well... that´s not that good in my opinion.

[LORENZOMETAL89]

the world's richest pub band! thats what metallica are turning into if they stay attached to this diabolically shit l lou reed!!!!!!!!

[colosalblack]

You shit heads show some respect for Lou Reed. I do agree his style might not go so well with Metallica but he is certainly a very talented musician and there's no harm done in experimenting a bit.

[MrVaHiX]

fuck lou

[MrDiegoverdugo]

both of them cant sing shit

[jessekr1989]

I am glad Metallica are more open minded are more willing to give credit where credit is due than you metal snob cunts! Lou Reed!!!!!!!!!!

[hunterhearsthelmsy]

i love it, its bad to see most of metal fans r so narrow minded with music, not everything that make noise is good guys, there r so shitty metal bands today that ppl love coz they make more noise instead of showing passion same with load and reload.

[sniperhswwe]

IM sorry Metallica, im still gonna buy this CD but this is like Aerosmith and a rap group singing a duet! ...oh wait damn, that already happened but it was good. U better pull something out of ur ass Metallica cause i may lose it

[MrMetalfucking]

i love lulu

[glenn94NL]

0:57 Kirk looks at Lou and he thinks: " you motherfucker raped our album"

[Gardoggle]

its a little known fact that Lou Reed and Sigourney Weaver are in fact the same person.

[vssay]

booo

[punkrock360]

Lol, Trujillo is like "I left Suicidal Tendencies for this?"



[Mytzita22]

@punkrock360 HAHAHAHA