This isn't *bad* IMO... And I like older Styx... ('Dennis de Young Styx'?... Nope, that doens't do the trick , not like saying Gabriel Genesis or Blackmore Deep Purple.). This turns Beatles magic into a not so unique _Classic Rock_ song. We've got plenty of those already. (The BIG drums might be the worst offender.)
The thing I don't like about this video is whenever they say something they literally put it in the video, I half expected Dr. Eggman to show up during the chorus!
they didn't steal it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! it's called a cover which means they made another version of the song! its legal and seems fair.I mean if you were a musician and a big beatles fan then im guessing you wouldn't mind to cover a beatles song.
I actually think Styx did an awesome job with this. One of the best covers, if not "THE BEST", I've heard anyone do "I am the Walrus" (except the Beatles of course :D )
Its not the same unless their wearing a warlus costume and a rabbit costume and hippo costume and i don't know what the hell ringo wore I think it was a chicken costume, but they have to that one too.
Considering that Dennis is not even part of the group in the video, it would be hard for him to kill it. If you are referring to the lead singer his name is Lawrence Gowan.
Sin to cover the beatles? WTFare u talking about? they are arguably the most influencial band in history and their music belongs to everyone.>Especially bands that were influenced and actually have made a career in music> like STYX! So your saying that if you could play an instrument you would NOT ever cover a beatles song...yeah right!
Retards like you should not be allowed to post comments unless you have something intelligent to say! Get real there dummy every rock musician on the planet has played or covered a beatles song at some point!
OH, and good job styx on a fine version of walrus!
I agree, The Beatles inspired so much musicians and bands. If it weren't for them I don't think many bands in the 80's and late 70's would have the potential they had if it weren't for The Beatles. And wtf? How is this cover in any relation to heavy metal?
Thanks for being in agreement, I don't understand most of the idiots on youtube, Most don't know shit!. I also agree> what does this have to do with heavy metal???
well i like styx but.. umm.. NO.... The Beatles could never be beaten with that song.. and what the hell is up with the end!? since when did John scream I am the eeeeeeegmaaaaaan!!!!??/
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
i hate when famous ppl cover other famous ppls songs the main thing is its not gonna be better than the original songs.... FUCK U STYX i swear to god no one should ever cover a beatles song and make a music vid the beatles are one of the best bands ever scrath that the best/famous band ever so js shut up styx
its like when someone looks at your drawing and then uses that technique its like a complement they do this because they like the song and are doing it out of respect and the fact that they like the song not cause they think they can make a better version
wait a minute...this is the Styx that did such great songs as Come Sail Away, What Has Come Between Us, and Suite Madame Blue, correct? Wow. Lose Dennis DeYoung, go back on tour, and turn unto a bad cover band. This is heresy.
how is oasis "trying" to be the beatles? just because they have a similar sound doesnt mean they are trying to be someone else... you must not listen to much oasis if you think they are trying to be the beatles
How about " styx has had a successful carreer in the music business for over 30 years and still tours constantly and makes lots of money selling concert tickets and albums'! What do you do?
Look..i play the electic guitar and well i love to play these songs just like Styx here they love to play msic and they are great at it...and they enjoy it.
Ok, ok. For all you haters out there. I myself am not a big STYX fan. However, this was a well executed tribute. For all of you who say, "The video wasn't wasn't 'trippy' enough," school starts soon, go to bed.
I like the caleidoscopic vision... very 60's-70's. And this dosn't sound bad at all...
dramito 2 years ago
HeavyMetalChicks (dot) com
Dating for 70s 80s 90s Rockers
DateWealthyWomen (dot) com
Date Rich Women
dudeman4756 2 years ago
its goo goo g'joob not koo koo kachu
hersheyguy96 2 years ago
I actually think this version sounds better.
videogamer810 2 years ago
Prefiero la version de Jim Carrey :J
ElChicoRntl 2 years ago
personally I don't consider this Styx this just Stynx
zzjoelss 2 years ago
I personally think that Styx should stick to making their own songs lol
themusicguy12 2 years ago
luwl the beginning actually sounds like john lennon
ko0lb0ii 2 years ago 2
At least they didn't rape it by making a metal version of it. Like they did to Eleanor Rigby. D:
HidetoTakari99X 2 years ago 2
i hate how this vido clip is trying to be trippy but the beatles just did it naturally. Beatles 4eva.
bborda4life1 2 years ago
its like the new version of one winged angel it doesnt even compare wont the oringal
metallavery 2 years ago
eh murded the original with a knife
twilightman444 2 years ago
more like a masume lol
charlieismystagename 2 years ago
meh.. doesn't come close to the original.
residentemojacob 2 years ago
wished jimi & his experience would have done a cover of this superb Beatles song ..look what he did with Dylan`s watchtower..nuff said
chromealien 2 years ago
Very good and pertinent comment.
This isn't *bad* IMO... And I like older Styx... ('Dennis de Young Styx'?... Nope, that doens't do the trick , not like saying Gabriel Genesis or Blackmore Deep Purple.). This turns Beatles magic into a not so unique _Classic Rock_ song. We've got plenty of those already. (The BIG drums might be the worst offender.)
marmas58ink 2 years ago
This sounds more like the Oasis version.
Triplesod 2 years ago
The thing I don't like about this video is whenever they say something they literally put it in the video, I half expected Dr. Eggman to show up during the chorus!
puppetmaster983 2 years ago
look the may have stole but at least it is a decent cover of the Beatles and watching feels some what like the original except a bit tripper
quakerquick 2 years ago
pittyfull, those basterds stole the Beatles music
SuperSwaF 2 years ago
they didn't steal it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! it's called a cover which means they made another version of the song! its legal and seems fair.I mean if you were a musician and a big beatles fan then im guessing you wouldn't mind to cover a beatles song.
forthbridg 2 years ago 2
deff not styx's best....kinda killed the original
Memphis5546 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Stole this song from the beatles. Bastards
MyNameSucksL 2 years ago
its called a cover
SnowandGlasgowfilms 2 years ago
EXCELLENT!! LOVE THIS!! ABSOLUTELY AWESOME!!! Rock on fellas!!
seabee23419 2 years ago
no no no! never do this cover agian nobody can ever do a good cover of this song besides bono
collcoll13 2 years ago
how dare they?
philippfuelb 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
these guys can suck my **** they ruined the song
dittymasta 2 years ago
lol this is so trippy, i wish i had some acid
netowner666 2 years ago
Very good cover. I had never heard this cover of the song before now, I like it a lot.
therealdennisv20 2 years ago 4
wooooah best cover iv heard awesome singer
RHCP1233 2 years ago
this song is like the lsd anthem lol
ac711sk8 2 years ago
Dido on Tartersauce101....
Great job! ...on a difficult song to cover with any respectability. Kudos to Styx!
nojsc 2 years ago
good job, thats a hard song to cover...although i wish there was an hq version of this, the sound quality could be alot better.
Tartersauce101 2 years ago 7
add &fmt=18 to the end of the vid. chee hoo.
Opqosite 2 years ago
nice work styx!
popfrend 2 years ago 10
who ever edited the music video was on more drugs than beatles
wkody7 2 years ago 6
Just another part of life, I guess
brotherstan28 2 years ago
Sit you down Styx, rest you.
jlk1046 2 years ago
YUCCHY STYXX COVERING THE BEATLES
(buzzer) WRONG! TRY AGAIN.
STYX ARE NOT GOOD
TheIncredibleDrAss 2 years ago
really? this is the closest to sounding like the beatles, its a great cover
Genoterredi 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
these guys suck
dragonknight123455 2 years ago
1:15 sucks!!!
kielego 2 years ago
BEATLES ARE WAY BETTER
kradsama77 2 years ago
Good Good Good Job! XD
RiRuBassPlayer 2 years ago
Goo Goo Ga Joob!
23hublock1 2 years ago 2
i know, everybody gets it wrong it pisses me off
futurfry 2 years ago
I Am... The 'Egg' Man
houseoforange0 2 years ago
pretty sickkk.. idk what u guys r tlkn bout who r knockn em.. beatles wud b proudd!
mTallen9754 2 years ago 8
Not a bad cover but the original by The Beatles is
better.
Immortal1000 2 years ago 8
rocking out style of my fav song
Sokker001 2 years ago 4
alright i LOVE LOVE LOVE Styx, and the Beatles rock too.
but no offense styx; this isn't your song.
but i do love it ^^ they didn't ruin it or anything. <3
nikkiiLEIGH 2 years ago
yeah
at least they didnt remix it
kradsama77 2 years ago
this is bollocks. i'am thinking of the simpsons now and homers remarks about styx
kilmorebhoy 2 years ago
John Lennon wwould be very disappointed... :-(
salgadodylan 2 years ago
This a very well done cover and video, Way to go styx!
Did you notice Billy bob Thorton as the eggman?
wakaw07 2 years ago 4
it's an ok cover.... not as good as the original tho
DaGGortiz 2 years ago 2
GOOBGOOBJGOOB
RoboticFishINC 2 years ago
not a bad one but he sang badly a tthe begginign and sounded more like an old man.
Apocaskybanzz 2 years ago
This wasn't that bad. I'm surprised.
elwanning 2 years ago 4
acid trip style
xlpps 2 years ago 3
I actually think Styx did an awesome job with this. One of the best covers, if not "THE BEST", I've heard anyone do "I am the Walrus" (except the Beatles of course :D )
vladimir1944 2 years ago 8
This comment has received too many negative votes show
oasis did it the best! thumbs down if you suck DICK!
sly4308 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ur a fagget
KiroDark69 2 years ago
beatles r wayyyy better
102Help 2 years ago 4
great cover ...
APACHEKID69 2 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
The remake that Styx did destroyed this song. They made it sound horrible
EnjoiSpitfire 2 years ago
I love it when people do covers of the Beatles this was a good one but you get some which are bad but I still love it. =)
Oh except Jonas brothers. X(
phillitupp 2 years ago 5
Its not the same unless their wearing a warlus costume and a rabbit costume and hippo costume and i don't know what the hell ringo wore I think it was a chicken costume, but they have to that one too.
Dickcheney64 2 years ago
another thing it's not goo goo g'choo it's "Goo goo g'joob."
STILL AWESOME COVER.
If you like metal and The Beatles, then listen to this.
SoulcaliburMage 2 years ago
Well, they had a couple lyrics wrong when trying to replicate this song in their own way.
"Get to chant" is "get a tan"
"I am he is you are he is you are me" is really "I am he as you are he as you are me"
Just a couple wrong, but this is a great cover. (Honestly, John was high when he wrote the song, so it sounded like he said the lyrics.)
SoulcaliburMage 2 years ago
As a lover of music, The Beatles, and Styx...this is fucking excellent.
MHB203 2 years ago 7
Seriously. I completely agree; as a Beatles & Styx fan, this is fucking excellent.
sanelately 2 years ago 9
Stupid people! Why do u compares everyone to Beatles? Beatles is the best, but this cover's cool. Just enjoy!
luisbrucewayne 2 years ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
Pretty nice cover!
abramo1111 2 years ago
what the fuck u do not remix a beatles song...... u just simply dont,... i just like fighting chuck norris, u just dont do it!
yourvidisbad101 2 years ago
both pure suicide X_X
remixing is your reputation commiting suicide
and fighting chuck norris...thats jusy you tired of living
runemaniac312 2 years ago 2
...Why the hell would you heavy metal a perfectly fine Beatles song?
00Kirby0 2 years ago
what the hell is this shit.
poupefaction 2 years ago
styx suck
beatles are way better
happewolf 2 years ago
Great cover!
Loved it!
And of course people should cover other peoples songs! Thats one way they can be remembered!!
digoclassicrock 2 years ago 4
Why is everyone ripping on styx???? I think this is a great cover! No where close to the beatles but still good
Rush1013 2 years ago 6
...No. Just no.
MasterKnuckles 2 years ago
wow u guys are fuckin gay
u think no one should cover other ppls music?
a lot of great songs were covers like hey joe by Jimi Hendrix and Hound Dog by Elvis jeez
6slavid 2 years ago 4
Buena versión.
revistaespejonet 2 years ago
0:25 Sgt. Pepper outfit!???? He doesn't deserve it!
Unicaine 2 years ago 3
not bad, but wayy too much guitar the original music sounded hundreds of times better along with the vocals.
dwnrety1 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
only one band should be allowed to cover this song, and that is Oasis, this version is miserable.
MENTH13 2 years ago
Bravo Styx...Bravo!!!
toysalot 2 years ago 5
Dennis killed this song..someone bury him now please...!!
Nakbub 2 years ago
Really? I think they did pretty good!
BuzzsawJFB 2 years ago 5
Considering that Dennis is not even part of the group in the video, it would be hard for him to kill it. If you are referring to the lead singer his name is Lawrence Gowan.
BSUTRPT 2 years ago 3
It's a great version of the song, but the Beatles' version is (waaaaaayyyyyy) better.
JmanMarvelMenace95 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
its should be a sin to cover the beatles. their music is theirs, nobody else's.
Joebell2412 2 years ago
While I do agree the Beatles cannot be improved, I do find it interesting to see how other bands think the song should sound.
Of course, none of the covers are nearly as good as the original.
JKrow48 2 years ago 3
Sin to cover the beatles? WTFare u talking about? they are arguably the most influencial band in history and their music belongs to everyone.>Especially bands that were influenced and actually have made a career in music> like STYX! So your saying that if you could play an instrument you would NOT ever cover a beatles song...yeah right!
popfrend 2 years ago 3
you CAN cover a beatles song
but it's just kinda stupid
because everybody who hears it
who has also heard the beatles
will think it sucks
because the beatles are sooo much better
it sounds like crap
DeniseQuack 2 years ago
Retards like you should not be allowed to post comments unless you have something intelligent to say! Get real there dummy every rock musician on the planet has played or covered a beatles song at some point!
OH, and good job styx on a fine version of walrus!
wakaw07 2 years ago 4
I agree, The Beatles inspired so much musicians and bands. If it weren't for them I don't think many bands in the 80's and late 70's would have the potential they had if it weren't for The Beatles. And wtf? How is this cover in any relation to heavy metal?
slayer759182 2 years ago 3
Thanks for being in agreement, I don't understand most of the idiots on youtube, Most don't know shit!. I also agree> what does this have to do with heavy metal???
peace!
wakaw07 2 years ago 2
This is exactly how I like my covers..
Til the end that is.
KairuHakubi 2 years ago
Totally agree there
I love how he was actually with george martin too!!!
revmull 2 years ago
juiced!!
MOSKII58 2 years ago
well i like styx but.. umm.. NO.... The Beatles could never be beaten with that song.. and what the hell is up with the end!? since when did John scream I am the eeeeeeegmaaaaaan!!!!??/
spotofblack 2 years ago
embarrassing. tasteless sound production and a really really embarrassing video.
succumber 2 years ago
Comment removed
maddyrudd 2 years ago
Its alright, I guess. I like The beatles' version more but this one is okay.
Matthordika 2 years ago
one more thing where the hell was mark david chapman when this happened fuck he can kill all of em js bring back john... r.i.p john lennon
Dlamb1995 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i hate when famous ppl cover other famous ppls songs the main thing is its not gonna be better than the original songs.... FUCK U STYX i swear to god no one should ever cover a beatles song and make a music vid the beatles are one of the best bands ever scrath that the best/famous band ever so js shut up styx
Dlamb1995 2 years ago
its like when someone looks at your drawing and then uses that technique its like a complement they do this because they like the song and are doing it out of respect and the fact that they like the song not cause they think they can make a better version
CATSwhoCHASEtrees 2 years ago
well chase trees dick so shut up
Dlamb1995 2 years ago
some songs should never be covered. this is one.
papakilatube 2 years ago
its the best cover but the beatles version is better
ProblemswithLJ 2 years ago
Very nice!! But the oasis' version is the better of all!!!
cahfilho 2 years ago
Are you shitting me? The Beatles is the better of all music never mind the best version of there own fucking song.
nasiraliclark 2 years ago 2
better of all covers*
hahaha.. of course the version of the beatles is the best.. Is the version OF THE BEATLES =P..
cahfilho 2 years ago
wait a minute...this is the Styx that did such great songs as Come Sail Away, What Has Come Between Us, and Suite Madame Blue, correct? Wow. Lose Dennis DeYoung, go back on tour, and turn unto a bad cover band. This is heresy.
phacopidrama 2 years ago
Actually, on tour, they were Far better than Reo, and 38. special. And Why the hell can bands never do cover songs?
magicmage316 2 years ago
Comment removed
wakaw07 2 years ago
aaah it's horriblee :(
u2forinterpol 2 years ago
This is good. No where near as good as the beatles version though.
McDynamicEntry 2 years ago
FUCK YOU STYX!!!!!!!!!!!
NYCSubwayFreak 2 years ago
who is the faggot that is singing?
y4m5m5 2 years ago 2
No...
negima1276 2 years ago
what did the bishop wager on his last hand of poker???
i will raise you a nunand 2 alter boys
ANCESTERSMEMORIES 2 years ago
The Styx is a good version,
BUT YOU CAN'T BEAT THE CLASSIC!!!!
IT'S IMPOSSIBLE!!!!!!!!!!!
dduuddeechil 2 years ago 3
the only version that was close to the beatles's version was oasis's...
stiil, the beatles won
SouleatsOnepiece 2 years ago
wow they suck at this song
himewii 2 years ago
That was quite possibly the most trippyiest video ive ever seen
jmanofawesome 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this is better than the beatles i think he has a better voice than john
HTWFCHAMP321 2 years ago
No it isn't Beatles are better than any band that ever was, and John Lennon is a Legend Styx will never be better than Beatles NOT EVER!
Expozane 2 years ago 2
2/10
Orginial is better look on my channel to c it
figgboy345 2 years ago
man.. dont know why.. who ever cover this song, this song still sounds very strong!
I feel a big power coming from this song every time I heard it..
bebaslepas 2 years ago
4/5
little more upbeat than the original but i definitely prefer the original. this is okay though.
ordealbyfire 2 years ago
no one is trying to be the beatles they are covering them because they respect the work they did not because they are trying to be the beatles...
linebackerdw 2 years ago 2
Oasis is
aabb3ElOriginal 2 years ago
how is oasis "trying" to be the beatles? just because they have a similar sound doesnt mean they are trying to be someone else... you must not listen to much oasis if you think they are trying to be the beatles
linebackerdw 2 years ago
no, not cuz their sound
they try to "look like the beatles"
aabb3ElOriginal 2 years ago
im actually ok with them sounding like the beatles that's what makes me like their music
but the singer(Liam i think is his name) try a lot to look like john lennon
and well that sucks
cuz "U need to be yourself, u can't be no one else... im feeling supersonic...." haha xD
aabb3ElOriginal 2 years ago
it's good but, i like the most the beatles one!!
l1nk133 2 years ago
stinkbomb band. they sound like fags to me
tracyterry 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this sucks The Beatles Forever nobody can be better than them. I HATE STYX
NYCSubwayFreak 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I hate Styx
Atticus9590 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
nobody cares what you think
markandbrodrick 2 years ago
lol no one can ever top the beatles
BlinkxD27 2 years ago 2
Pretty good. Of course I like the original better.
qpoqiuqytqrewq 2 years ago 2
kinda cheesy, the pictures of everything they sing, haha i hope it was intentional to be that corny. I hope i'm not the only one.
xmonroebotx 2 years ago
Styx has always been somewhat intentionally corny for your viewing and listening pleasure! So good for them!
wakaw07 2 years ago
Great cover with lots of energy!
cricketbat08 2 years ago
kill. nice attempt, but never as good as the beatles
runningfreak244 2 years ago 2
i think the best cover is by the ppl in the movie across the universe. lol
MsHappyCinnamon 2 years ago
How about: 'I Am A Has-Been'
AndyBoy63 2 years ago
How about " styx has had a successful carreer in the music business for over 30 years and still tours constantly and makes lots of money selling concert tickets and albums'! What do you do?
wakaw07 2 years ago 2
this sucks
dragonknight123455 2 years ago
Check out the Frank Zappa version,
that's more like it!
putadepadre 2 years ago
The Beatles were better, but I like this video better.
AutobotChick25 2 years ago 3
i like the beatles song better, but this video is a fuckin trip and awesome
pmsHammerTime 2 years ago
Oh Dear what an abortion, they need a contract put out on them for destroying a classic.
tatkaoz 2 years ago
beatles still better, sorry
bladeisgroovy5 2 years ago 7
I really like Jim Carrey's version :D
Over this one and The Beatles, actually
SteveLikesThings 2 years ago
lol lemon
iaznnnn 2 years ago
ouch!
grr1118 2 years ago
not bad, pretty good cover
atombomber25 2 years ago 3
this sucks... go listen to the beatles version
sparklersandstars 2 years ago 2
well of course the beatle's is better. there is nothing in the world better than them. but this isn't half bad
pmsHammerTime 2 years ago 2
Have you heard John Lemon?
Creepybabies 2 years ago 2
lemon??
gubz1992 2 years ago
Damn right!
John Lemon.
Creepybabies 2 years ago
LOL funny =P
sarahlou77 2 years ago
great songs dont need 2 be remade
wweandhorrorfan247 2 years ago 2
many songs are remade...for fun...for impression...mostly for fun you would know if you knew how to play an intrument well.
BESIDES THEY DID A GREAT JOB
aleiva101 2 years ago
okay all im saying is if the songs great then theres no reason 2 make another 1 and how do u know i dont play an intrument
wweandhorrorfan247 2 years ago
your comment was what gave it away.
Look..i play the electic guitar and well i love to play these songs just like Styx here they love to play msic and they are great at it...and they enjoy it.
aleiva101 2 years ago
i hate covers but this one is not bad at all WAY BETTER than bono hate the guy
soadfl 2 years ago 4
personally i like jim carry's version better lol
coopmister00 2 years ago
yeah, i preffered the original one by the beatles, but this one isn't too bad either.
therandomshowch 2 years ago
not as good as the original, but I have to hand it to them. Not too bad for a more contemporary version.
StrawKatt 2 years ago
Ok, ok. For all you haters out there. I myself am not a big STYX fan. However, this was a well executed tribute. For all of you who say, "The video wasn't wasn't 'trippy' enough," school starts soon, go to bed.
MrCheckraiseAllin 2 years ago 2
Yes and recorded recorded live!
popfrend 2 years ago
how many original styx member left in this line up?
ApostleCreed10 2 years ago