Metallica 2008 Instrumental track, which was not on the CD

[tibic]

It's not Metallica. Not the same sound, dynamics and so on. But it is pretty cool. I like it very much.

[blackbart316]

synthaziser, wtf, cant be metallica

[rowan371]

this is metallica doing a cover, cause i remember before the album came out they played this song on the radio and they said it was metallica but originally writen by some one else

[liveingthoughtsfade]

there guitar solos dont fit metallica. it cant be them

[MeTaLiZoPo]

I do not know guys, we must accept that this is good, but that nurse is not metallica, that (not really metallica) that I am 110% sure

[metaliguy]

it's not metallica definetely even kirk's solo os missing

[KacperBader]

Its not Metallica style.

[sandman141414]

Cool song :), but whats the name of this... help

[KARWAA]

Esta es la "Butelka" (Botella). Banda de Polonia. Título original "Koshmar" Más en priv.

[fizzo71]

hey..wch band is this then..i want more ;)

[dickdickvondick]

look a little with Kashimir of Led Zep

[maxnin]

Its not metallica... drums sound nothing like DM or any other Album for that matter.... and i know Lars wouldnt play like that....

[fizzo71]

if it is Metallica indeed...so be it..wat the hell...its got a smashing riff...

[96Dethmagnetic]

aint Metallica

[THEKFJ]

its obviously not metallica, mainly cuz i can actually hear the bass, but at parts like 2:15, you can tell metallica wouldn't use those keyboards & whatnot. still pretty dark, is this an actual song?

[guitarwizzz]

@THEKFJ  I have to agree you. I have never heard Metallica use key boards but the riff sounds similar to thier stuff.

[CkY3221]

lol only justice doesnt have audible bass

[opensandwich]

sounds like metallica's guitars and style on death magnetic

[11carnes]

well this aint no pink floyed lmaooooooo

its def metallica tho listen to the bass. and the riff is something they would definatly do

[caimanque]

suicide and redemption is better than this

[misiek230688]

sounds great, but its not Metallica

[perverso2006]

no sean todos pendejos, creen saber mucho que importa de kien sea esta puta cancion, esta fregona y eso es todo

[lastrebel415]

PINK FLOYD!!!!!!!!!!

[MRPSYCOTIC]

what is this shit????

[KARWAA]

Such a text could write just a weak follower of James Hetfield. See the videos MRPSYCOTIC! :) This is just shit!

[mauro987]

haha...Los de Metallica no se tomarían el tiempo de componer y grabar un tema al cual no le van a exprimir dinero, mucho menos para dejar que se distribuya gratis. Esos son capaces de vender sus propios desperdicios en el catálogo de su página web oficial junto con franelas de la banda (no incluídas en el precio) si eso estubiese de moda. Por otro lado...hay teclados en ese tema y todo. Sean quienes sean los que lo hicieron, les quedó bien depinga, me gustó(y)

[isaacmetallica]

jajaja, muy cierto lo que dices

[AGPUSMUSA]

Si no les gusta no lo escuhen.

[isaacmetallica]

metallica??? jajaja

si fuera metallica, estaria en algun disco...o estaria de reserva pero en los estudios de metallica, no en youtube

ES OBVIO

[ratbatblue555]

no comprende

[slade535]

sounds great, but its not Metallica...

suena bien, pero no es Metallica...

[zhixmick]

claramentee estos no son metallica ya que nunca han usado teclados y menos para implicarlos en solos como en esta cancion y la bateria de lars siempre la da un toque mas al estilo de la banda-- its clearly that this is not metallica cuz they never used keyboard and less to introduce solos on their songs ande the lars's drumbs always have a unique sound of the band that is not here

[FollowHim4Eternity]

Ya, this definitely isn't Metallica, but this shit still is pretty dank.

[shinoda91]

może ktoś nie z polski pomyśli ze to "Metallica" ale wiadomo że to "Butelka"

[KARWAA]

Ale prowokacja się udała !! .... :)

[CakePicnic]

Doesn't sound like Metallica at all but a great song.

[sawgunner27]

regardless if its metallica or not it sounds awesome as fuck!!!!!!

[paice95]

there is a ride cymbal, the guitars would never sound like this, there is a keyboard and most importantly Lars' cymbals cut more through the guitar sounds. there are tons of things to say that this is not Metallica, altough it sounds pretty awesome.

[83LittleJ]

..sound like Dream Theater but i hope that this is Metallica!

[AGPUSMUSA]

Is iron maiden.

[sandman141414]

no es metallica, pero me ENcanta, I love it

[joshmore]

who cares its wicked

[0redj9]

All these keybord effects don't sound like metallica. James & co never uses that kind of effects. But anyway the song sounds pretty good even if it's OF COURSE NOT Metallica!

[Paxobo]

This aint metallica guys. Everyone flag the vid.

[marciobro]

o metallica é d++++++++ uma banda respeitada  no mundo todo e tem uma legiao de fas espalhado.

[Syvalep]

A legião e evolved, os homes están ficando máis vellos, gustos mudan. Chegaron mesmo envidado esforzos no sentido de meeldida.Ride do Lighting do dereito - no seu tempo.

[pmanderson]

Metallica would never use all those gay keyboard effects. Lars never uses a ride cymbal, his snare sounds different. James' and Kirk's guitars sound much better when it comes to distortion. And finally, the riff itself doesnt sound like something Metallica would do imo.

[MeTaLiCa15951]

you know how i know this not metallica? lars doesnt use a ride cymbal

[VMSphincter]

listen to there earlier albums he does not saying this matellica just saying he does use a ride alot he usually replaces the ride on live versions with his custom china cymbal

[blackwolf222403]

@MeTaLiCa15951 in kill'em all he definitely did

[KARWAA]

Se trata de un equipo polaco llamado "Butelka" (Botella). El nombre de esta canción Koshmar.Link al archivo mp3 de la canción se llama usuario en KARWAA mas informacion. Para encontrar más canciones de la banda Butelka, escriba en la ventana de búsqueda "ButelkaTorun"

[xurxo12]

this song is damn cool, a lil of van halen, a lil of led zep, u guys dont need to say it's a tallica song, just say this is inspired by metallica dudes, but dont lie cuz that makes people being negative about ur song. good job, and hope to listen to some more good shit from ya soon.

[KARWAA]

This is a Polish team called "Butelka" (Bottle). The name of this song Koshmar.Link to mp3 file of this song is called user KARWAA in more info. To find more songs the band Butelka, type in the search window "ButelkaTorun"

[mexicanplayer95]

damn!! that was awesome

[AlfonsoGallegosP]

fools.

[AlfonsoGallegosP]

Tienen que hablar con el señor EDWARD VAN HALEN. para que les explique como tocar esta cansion con una guitarra. es algo similar a algo que el señor EVH tuvo que aprender, que se llama CATEDRAL.

[AlfonsoGallegosP]

From: alfonso gallegos p. usm-usa. mun.

[AlfonsoGallegosP]

This is BLACK METAL.

[D1d0n]

4:00

[AlfonsoGallegosP]

Tiene su chiste la musica trash. se dice lo que sea. y lo que les sirva resiclenlo. y lo que no pues tirenlo a la basura. tambien a lo que no les sirva por un lado. busquenle el otro lado.

[AlfonsoGallegosP]

Ya hay muchas bandas de trash metal. y varias compañias disqueras interesadas. en estas cansiones.

usm-usa.

[AlmightyHet]

not metallica but awesome anyway!

[AlfonsoGallegosP]

Esta cansion . por mucho es la mejor cansion intrumental de trash metal. que e escuchado. onestamente.

(LOS CHAVOS DE METALLICA SON UNOS GENIOS).

[maui930]

al final como se llama la cancion :S

y el grupo

[Satch6strings]

all nighmare long de metallica

[MetallicTheater93]

i got the real Nightmare. It is a mix of S&D and All Nightmare Long's intro piece. Its a instrumental. i got it the way it was suppose to be. I got Luck Runs out for now. ya'll need to wait for Nightmare. this song is badass though. if its eternal decision, then they may be bumped as my third favorite band

[metpablo]

It is a polish band called "Butelka" (Bottle). The name of this track is Koshmar, or something like that.

[sandman141414]

se sabe que no es de metallica, pero esta excelente la cancion, ¿de quien es?

[projectseeds]

Listen to like around the last half, You hear a voice start to say something. I can pick out one word "Tambien" and I can only pick out that word because It's the only Spanish word my 1 year teachings can recognize. This is from a Spanish group. If you're Spanish please translate what they say, It's like half way through or something.

Here i'll give the exact time: 4:20

It's not english.

It's not metallica

However it is awesome to listen to. What's the real name?

[Metallicgnacio]

Well... Im from Argentina, and I dont hear any spanish message there dude

[sandman141414]

esa cancion no es de metallica, pero de quien es, parece rammstein, diganme porfa

[ericles1976]

the drums sound like lars's the name of the song,changes all the time,i think it souds just like metallica,i think this song didnt make it to the albumand then just change titles,maybe im wrong,also listen to this song call : inu,trasher,the thorn of ivory (where this songs came from) it is definitely metallica.

[campoobutt]

it is from a band called eternal decision.

[ericles1976]

Guys it is Metallica,but I'm afraid that this song didnt mae it to the album,the question is Why?????? It is a slap in the face if this song didnt make it,cause we all like it more than the ones that did,dont you think????

[isaacmetallica]

no sea tan idiota

esta cancion no es de metallica

[ksanman]

yea this is not metallica cause the song all nightmare long doesnt sound close to this

[isaacmetallica]

de cual grupo es esta cancion???

alguien sabe???

[JohnPierce321]

Fucking EXCELLENT!

[whiplash34]

this is not lars's drums sound. so this is not metallica. but fine

[kirantmo]

realmnt el principio esta basado en matrix escucharlo bien

[assrapevictim]

its like dream theater mixed with tool but definatey not metallica

[micloudon1]

not metallica but good

[godsey265]

hey drongo, METALLICA are gods!! I think its about time that they turned around and went hard out again. Tell you what boy, wait until their new album rocks up on the shelfs next month. It's called "DEATH MAGNETIC". LONG LIVE METALLICA!!

[Gogetahan]

Well So far what I've heard from the albume I'm not impressed.  but thats just me.

[Manichek1906]

this is not metallica for sure... some kind of asshole do a not funny joke's

[KARWAA]

See the profile of the author of this comment.

It is the beet, the red nape and the dog′s dick from under the Cracow′s- village.

His intellectual level is sub-zero, so so that he understand, I had to to drop to him level.

[mycatdoneit]

This was something rejected from tool

[Rjc1986]

Do I hear some TOOL riffs in there?

[177583876]

i have to agree syntheizer metllica would never do... but the song dont sound that bad

[MikeyGee001]

Dear god ... PLEASE PLEASE make this not be the next Metallica album.

YUCK

[glenn1365]

fake

[plconz]

ignorantes todos como dicen esas papurradas de verdad no aprecian el buen vino que trae metallica

[Graciano007]

Bad joke man!!! Don't play with the metallica's army

[KARWAA]

1.2

Oyez crying people !!

I even-Stephen how You listen to Metallica. I listen also to the team "the Butelka"("the Bottle") which plays this composition, and for "the Butelka" "Metallica" is an inspiration.

Any time would you hear this music if it I did not make this provocation??

, and after all many from it priced You this composition very well.

With difficulty one is to pierce the band without the financial subsidiaries and to this from so small country as Poland.

1.2

[KARWAA]

This band does the really good music, give a chance to them, see their profile on myspace,com/butelka (only the comma exchange on points) I EXCUSE ME ,I AM SORRY ALL RESENTFUL

[MetallicA83to91]

it's not metallica ...

but the song is pretty cool :)

[keelone]

Sabemos que estan desesperados por ser lo que eran pero no no no eso no va a poder ser solamente que clif vuelva de los infiernos y los resucite,es mas con esos sintetizadores menos,estan tratando de hacer lo mejor y ojala les valla bien aunque lo dudo.

[Goofyboy2006]

Synthesizer... I really doubt Metallica would go there!

[gencidarksaga]

this is not metallica? yes? or no man?

[miguelal12]

this is not metallica but the snare sound like lars use

[Metallithrasher]

Someone should find this fucker and all the other fuckers posting fake metallica and fucking shoot them.....i could rip someone's fucking head off right now

[12ruby8]

yeah same man.

[jb14079]

yeah, they deserve to get shot..hunt this fucker down...seriously...while playing Leper Messiah loud as fuck...

[typedavemorrisingoog]

fuck you

[s268432]

it doesnt sound like metallica.

[gymguy25]

I'm so sick of losers trying to get people to listen to their songs by claiming it's Metallica.

[FitoEmAll]

borra esta wea fea, culiao tonto

[kane555444]

If i dont understand you im gonna give you thums down

[reayne13]

this is not metallica ... -_-

[Jomommax]

yeah really. someone should ask the guy who posted the video where he got it from

[dibbilydooha]

If this band had any talent they wouldn't need to use Metallica's name to get people to pay attention to them.

[heavymetal25]

i think it s dream theater ...

[brennw]

Here are the "Death Magnetic" song titles in the running order . . . yeah, they released the titles That Was Just Your Life The End Of The Line Broken, Beat & Scarred The Day That Never Comes All Nightmare Long Cyanide The Unforgiven III The Judas Kiss Suicide & Redemption My Apocalypse

[Redindodo]

unforgiven lll lol.. kk

Lets see in semptember and untill then, i won't believe anything of this

[Metallirocks]

Go to the metallica website. They have the official track listings up. And yes, there is Unforgiven III, believe it or not!

[WinternightTragedies]

terrific!!! Can´t wait!

[rocafella142]

BET U BELIEVE NOW HUH HAHA

[dragonzith]

all nightmare long? I still think is not metallica but we will see.

[cowboyfromhell02]

As many of you, I don't think it's Metallica. It's Fucking great though!

[brennw]

this isn't metallica

the new metallica song is called all nightmare long, and isn't an instrumental

[dragonzith]

and i doub they are going to use keybords or synths

[sabu43v3r]

ya metallica wouldnt use key bords

[6stringMike]

dont know who is doing this... but it is total crap to try and pawn something else as metallica. theres like a whole album of this imitation band on you tube supposedly metallica

[Diewithlaughter]

The riff was cool... but I'm not realy that excited bout the drums. They need to work on that... ;)

[Hardrocker80]

j'adore =)

[jaysicksix6]

its them.this is an instrumental

[sandman141414]

similar a rammstein la introduccion; esta muy buena: very cool

[Ugluk333]

Yeah this isn't metallica, but FUCKIN' GOOOD:D

[kirkhamster]

check this out if you are a true fan of hetfield:

watch?v=50lVR9I5g5c

[metfan911]

definately not metallica

[jauhisss]

Keyboards eh! That one riff was like Kashmir ripoff. The haunting intro was pretty nice, but Metallica, right.

[MetallicA83to91]

metallica or not metallica songs pretty much kicks ass

[metalistas1993]

Metallica* sorry

[metalistas1993]

This shit is ain't Metallic

[KARWAA]

Może i nie Metallica, ale zajebisty kawałek polskiej kapeli z Torunia...kapela nazywa się Butelka... jako Litwin nie powinieneś mieć miec problemu z odczytaniem tego tekstu...

[metalistas1993]

WTF???????????????

[KARWAA]

Nie udawaj, że nie rozumiesz po polsku!! Przecież Litwa to największa dzielnica Polski!! :) ;)

[clanstead]

I think he might be from a different country

[nuke00]

bullshit again

[sinfonian39]

This sounds like Dream Theater. It sounds like something they would've put on "Train of Thought." I like this for what it is, but it is certainly not Metallica.  How bout at 5:00 where they rip "Kashmir?" If it's not copyrighted, I may take it and elaborate. Even if it is, I may noodle with some of the concepts. Overall, well-done, but it's not Metallica.

[HenrikKalluR]

Die Beste der Welt.... einfach die Beste...

So einfach toll... and fuck to all who have said, that metallica is bullshit.... no comment

[Mulletfish1]

whoever says this isnt metallica can just f@#K right off,dont you see that metallica is a very versatile band,like the difference between 'enter sandman' and 'nothing else matters' is so great,and 'seek and destroy' and 'hero of the day' they arent just one genre,they are all...'mama said' is country'seek and destroy'thrash metal' and 'nothing else matters' is for all!so if you dont like etallica because of this song then you are not a metallica fan(thats right i went day time emmy on your arse)

[blindreaperlp]

I like Load and Reload...they have some really good songs on there. And St. Anger wasnt all that bad either. But this isnt metallica...the sound's pretty similar, but I'm sorry to dissappoint. There are some things in the song that just dont sound Metallica...

Unless Rob Trujillo isnt their new bassist and now plays the synthesizer lol

[Krysztau]

Do you know the polish band from the 80's called "Kombi"? It sounds very similar. If you don't know, find it here in youtube. I recommend song called "Słodkiego miłego życia".

[walhall1471]

if this is metallica i f@kc your sis :-)

[Danatreyu]

f-at-kc?

[prantja]

this aint metallica.....thats full of shit....

banned this video pls...

[karton17]

Is this next joke like SEgun el Ares??

[jessiejames2012]

im gay

[ultrabigpig]

nice!

[diegorockhell]

in the last fifteen years metallica has vanished altogether but one always has a hope of re-creating good music, not for the MTV garbage, long life to good mu

[snuffdipper]

sounds pretty good but the keyboards have to go makes it sound bad other than that i like it sounds better than there last few records

[Pabloslayer2010]

mmm... I'dont think so....

[jakob129]

I hope it's them. sounds kind of better than the last shit.

[diegorockhell]

metallica back to make good music? or already died many years ago ¿?... any doubts, the truth is that their latest discs are a waste

[quezance88]

they're back!...and they did not die, and i cant wait to get the new cd!...there still my all time fave band.

[Mulletfish1]

dude im sticking with you,it seems that no one else likes the new metallica,well,not just the new material,because they've been like this since the 'load' album,and it all started with 'nothing else matters' and it was a great song,metallica lives

[MacMillan555]

Listen to their new shit! It's all Christian Metal! That don't blend! What ever happened to "The God that Failed"???

[josemari1976]

Amazing sound..It,s Metallica!

[VigoGatsu]

Who played those keyboards? hahaha FAKE ¬¬...where is James's voice?

Anyway, good song :P

[cBsSyN]

its a instrumental -_-

[met1bama]

Sounds like Dream Theater,And a little Tool,little bit of Floyd!!

[dennifan99]

its not Metallica!!!!!!!NOT

[consiglieridelmetal]

Metallica is dead!!!

[quezance88]

metallica aint dead!...they're still kickin' it ;)

[Nikiguitarrista]

might be one of the worst intros ever, ugly cheap keyboardsound..

[topher23288]

not metallica but still awesome song

[renanchaosguitar]

This isn't metallica...that's Fake!!!

[carolina666amduscia]

Nice

[projectch3]

the Call of Ktulu meets Kashmir... and the obvious Dream Theater influence doesn't help much either... Hope it goes over well in Japan. No Yen for my 4.58 a gallon gas... PS. this is not Metallica

[5926875]

after listening to some "new" song about 2 months ago from metallica I didn't have much hope for the new album but after this... This kicks ass. I hope this is Metallica's new music and not somebody pulling our chain

[sacred04]

This isnt metallica this vid was added in february metallica just finsihed recording the album in later april early may

[lozanozl]

MetallicA Rules them ALL!

[bobpower]

it annoys me that people use metallica's name to trick people but this was quite good stuff i must say.

[acdcdude1121]

wtf! lars does not have a ride cymbal in his set, he hasnt for atleast 8 years......dumbass

[w4lkm4n]

not just the snare ..ride too ..lars has got zildjian extreme rides ..this is some sabian i think ..very thin ..portnoy is good drummer too

[Jslayes]

Portnoy is the HALL of Famer the best drummer in the world in my opinion

[HuffyGuitarist]

Jslayes, Portnoy will only be the world's best drummer when Neil Peart dies.

[Sim2322]

Neil Peart can't die, he's a cyborg