Verdi.La Traviata.Di Provenza il Mar...;No,Non Udrai...

[ferdecla]

En vivo suena mas a tenor Hampson que Villazón, no son buena pareja para esta ópera. Deberían buscarle un barítono mas Pesado a Villazón o un Tenor mas liviano a hampson.

Muuuuy ridículo el cachetazo, solo en los circos un hombre voltea a otro de un cachetazo.

Hubiera sumado que el reggiseur hubiera leido la dama de las camelias...

[beethoven838]

no me gusta el escenario!!!!



[federic017]

In questa occasione il baritono Hampson mi è piaciuto più del solito...saluti

[trendyyy]

both are ridiculous !!!

[elcomportal]

Das ist doch bei den Salzburger Festspielen, oder?

Eine wunderbare Aufnahme! sehr gefühlvoll vorgetragen, gefällt mir seeeeehr gut!

LG

Torsten

[elcomportal]

Das ist doch bei den Salzburger Festspielen, oder?

Eine wunderbare Aufnahme!

LG

Torsten

[yanreurriek]

Hampson is pushing the piece out the whole time...consequently, his pitch wanders, his forte is just yelling, and his vibrato is noticeably wide. Very disappointed. I can't imagine him carrying very well in the house. His voice is very wooden and dry.

[singinginthebay]

@yanreurriek You must know better than all the general managers/conductors who hire him all over the world. Have you seen his schedule lately? When was the last time YOU were on stage (and where)?

[ferdecla]

@yanreurriek totalmente de acuerdo.



[corocancun]

este tenor le falta voz, o sera que mi volumen no sirve.?

[singinginthebay]

@corocancun Ha de ser tu oído al que le falta agudeza

[pippopapa]

One of the worst rendition I have ever herd. Simply two dilettanti

[singinginthebay]

@pippopapa Do you have a recording of your own voice to share?

[coralrabida]

JAJAJAJAJAJAJAJAJAJJAA LA OSTIA QUE LE DA A VILLAZÓN!!!! jajajajajajajajjajajajajaja

[ZeevRoizman]

...and on the top of everything singers are so beautiful . They are so light .. are flying like butterflies in the flowing garden ... Physic beauty weights a lot in opera, especially nowadays because it opens direct channel for beautiful music to materialize and make strong impact on our (viewers) subconscious first of all. Unique solution of the opera. Verdi would be proud of the time's thread in this case.

[ZeevRoizman]

Beautiful singers. Perfect acting. We'll realize what what was perfect here after December 2012. Most people's mind is not flexible enough to mirror simple things multiplied by the time and epoch. People screamed on first "Carmen" (s) (terrible, les idiots, la honte, en dégoûtant ) and then... Bravo.. Bravo. Some comments are simply unpleasant

[Maggielicious21]

@ZeevRoizman you actually believe that crap of december 2012! come on!

[ZeevRoizman]

@Maggielicious21

Of cause, as an every normal person I do NOT believe in that. It's just a metaphor to underline that many people just simply are not able to have their own opinion

(and so on....) It's why I have mentioned that maybe after "that due date" we will ...

[Maggielicious21]

@ZeevRoizman ok i think i get it now, so glad you don't really think so :D

[Jaydoggy531]

I personally find it bad because this is a verismo piece, and a "concept" set doesn't match it at all. It goes completely against the style of the music and era. It shows a lack of research.

[Maggielicious21]

@Jaydoggy531 mmm but verismo is characterized for the realistic treatment to daily CONTEMPORARY  life, this minimalistic concept was very well suited, but that's just my opinion

[Jaydoggy531]

@Maggielicious21

Quite true, but when there are other conceptual ideas here that go beyond verismo and instead interpretive, and that is against what Verdi and Piave wanted. I have no problem with minimalist or newer stagings but there's a problem when direction goes against the very clear intentions of the writers: In this case Verdi and Piave insisted on a realistic setting and had to fight to finally get it.

[MrCafiero]

MICS MICS MICS!  ENHANCEMENT!

[xav71176]

I usually like Hampson but here he sounds almost like a pop singer, not sure why ; they're probably not helped by the ridiculous stage settings...

[trendyyy]

ridiculos !

[chiara54324]

Which girl?

[joanabanyeres]

very bad and grotesque production Too bad ! sorry.

[sopranino56]

Very Good , Thanks .(Dziekuje)

[nisticom]

In my opinion he's really not suited for this role... or any other role, for that matter... well, perhaps some lieder... he sings with his strange colorless voice and completely ruins this wonderful aria. In the second verse he also seems unnecessarily angry... and when he goes on the piano, he loose what little color he has... I never understood why he became a star!

[seektheforce]

@nisticom what do you mean by color?

[nisticom]

@seektheforce What I mean is the "quality of sound" in his voice. Some people have a darker, richer sound. Others, like Hampson, have a sound deprived of richness that reminds me of a shout (when he's singing forte. When he sings piano, it's almost always in falsetto...) anyway, I find him out of style and overly mannered. By that is my personal taste...

[nisticom]

I totally agree with you. TOTALLY!!

[joanabanyeres]

for what ?

[urs1765]

whao the last piano (fade out) is absolutely genius!!!

[chrizosthemis]

Hampson is one of the nicest voice I've ever heard. He's so good as Geronte as in Das Lied von der Erde.

[pavoman23]

7:40 Hampson keeps his pimp hand strong.

[HMW]

haha, nice.

[oneringwraithof9]

As for thin, what are you talking about?! His high notes have an extremely rich tone. As for bright and open, when did that become a sin?!

[loucatuu]

good! i wanna sing like that

[operaspark]

This is very dissapointing. No smooth melody, strained notes and singing without any sentiment whatsoever! Poor. I'm really not looking forward to his ROH engagement next year unless he has considerably improved!

[richstan4d]

I'm singing this for the Met audtion in 2 weeks. Who does the best Di Provenza on youtube? Anyone have any tips on how to sing this well?

[operaspark]

I hope the audition went well! My personal favourites are Leo Nucci, Ettore Battastini and Dmitri Hvorostovsky. I can't give you any help though as i'm not a singer! It's a beautiful aria.

[Ted10038]

It may be too late, but you should go over the aria with an assistant conductor from the Met. They have their special ways and you should know them.

As far as ideas for singing the aria see Tito Gobbi, Fischer Dieskau, Hvorostovsky and Lawrence Tibett. But remember that it has to be presented in current style.

Also remember that Germont is FRENCH not Italian.

In bocca al lupo!!!

[navarro2968]

robert merril

[jimpharris1]

Check out up and coming baritone Benjamin Harris on youtube.

[FacePaster]

Villazon tries to imitate Domingo a lot.probably this is part of the reason he is having troubles now. Domingo sang gloriously in a way that would have destroyed other throats. Hampson sings extremely well, but I don't think his voice is best suited for Verdi baritone. He sings the top notes open like a tenor would, not turned like a baritone. He probably could've been a good tenor, but perhaps his personality is more suited to baritone rep. Hard to fault him because he has made a sack of money!

[aguacun]

Absolutly agree:

1)Villazon forces his throat trying to sound bigger and darker.

2) Domingo did not destroyed his throath because... luck?. ALmost never had high notes because he wanted to sound bigger. MOre center, less high notes.

3) Hampson is not for a Verdi or any composer Bariton because is a Tenor.

[dfpjrnyi]

You were right until you got to the part about Hampson being a tenor. You've got to be kidding. That's obviously the comfortable tessitura for him, and he sings this quite well, despite all of the Verdi know it all's who think that any baritone who sings Verdi needs to be Leonard Warren or Sherrill Milnes. It might not be as heavy as those two, but it's fantastic in its own right.

[ruffatony]

Unusual to have 2 tenors on stage for this scene. Oh, I'm sorry, did I miss something? How is Mr Hampson able to get engagements in the Verdi repertore? Has he ever sung this repertoire in Italy--presumably not, because they would boo him off the stage.....no richness, no real line, just a shallow, colourless sound. Yuk.

[hillevifan]

because the met seems to only like traditional performances- they frown on productions like this

[Architect115]

Thank God!! I prefer the Met's more traditional Zeffirelli designed sets. I do love this aria though even if I believe that Hampson is not the best suited for it. Verdi always gave his older characters such beautiful arias.

[igipereira]

i dont know why, but i dont like hampson here :(

[guy1938]

les hanteurs sont très solides et excellents et l,orchestre aussi , je mets un 5/5 pour la musique, mais pour le setting ont repasseras.

[Elried]

I cant get enough of hampson in in this aria!

love it. alswasy get goosebumps

[js59695]

i see a lot of emotion. this is a very nice version of traviata