Added: 3 years ago
From: MoonwalkerWorshiper
Views: 64,615
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (161)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • if you want perfect vocal performance listen to the CD. 

  • 4:14 lol

  • This is best of Liam!!!!!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Liam's weakest performance

  • nice tits

    

  • Liam ruined this gig

  • hes on it

  • blur's better

  • @kevlevy Get a grip you fucking prick.......damon fucked off and created a cartoon band...what does that tell you about the man???And then decides to get blur back together because......... hmmm not doing so well......or is it because Gorillaz were SHIT....least these lads stuck it out for a good few years before departing..AND oasis were a far better live band than blur

  • @davyhboro... wow, Gorillaz "not doing so well"... i don't think so. you really don't like Blur/Damon?

  • nar listen to knebworth 96 or maine road there the best versions of this song..

  • Zak is pish

  • :( my cousin has reason, liam`s voice sounds very wasted in comparison with his early years...  anyway, to be in their concerts are amazin :)

  • @peoplehere And what did you expect? Liam sang with wide open throat for nearly 15 years, he was smoking and drinking a lot. I'm glad that he was able to sing this way until 2003. And I'm also glad that he came back in 2008.

  • This is the best SuperSonic i have ever heard!!! fuk yeee

  • Fantastic, bloody fantastic! Forget all the debate about 'who's best' and the E chord was slightly out of tune etc etc.

    These guys rock, the songs are timelesss, the guitars sound great, the volume is high and the crowd are loving it, great sweaty gig. Wished I had been there amongst it!

    Just enjoy the moment, and savour the band. It doesn't get much better than this really.

  • Topless girl at 4:14. :)

  • look at the crowd....all your criticisms don't matter

  • @lasfilmsadooget That is maybe an even better, more simple argument.

  • @MoonwalkerWorshiper if you can overflow the area that pyramid stage is in...if i were anybody in oasis, i'd feel like nothing can phase me

  • amazing

  • it doesnt matter whether a song has an extremely complicated guitar solo or amazing vocal on it, all thats important is that the song has to be good and appeal to audience. and most of oasis songs do just that. having great techniques makes you a great guitarist/vocalist or whatever, but it doesnt make you a great musician.

  • Now he has better voice

  • simples songs can be the best sometimes. just chords and a sweet vocal melody.

  • Liam really struggles here for some reason

  • the only reason why dickheads think oasis are beatle cover band is because oasis don't hide the fact they love beatles, and these idiots dont listen to oasis, they just assume its the same,

    name a few beatle songs that rock as hard as columbia, bring it on down,

    only similarity i see is they all play chords instead of riffs, and they have melodies in their singing,, thats it,

  • Christ, Liam doesn't half sing through his nose.

  • @MrScottBach all of oasis stuff is the same kind of sound they never done anything like what the beatles did were, they experimented which different genres and different cultures were as oasis are a one dimensional

  • @MrScottBach Still at it?

    If you want to call a rock'n'roll band doing what they are suppose to do, to be "one dimensional" then have it, I still consider their music to be much better than the Beatles music and you haven't been able to argue for quality, so tit for tat.

    If somebody starts a rock band and gets the urge to transform it into freaking jazz or reggae that doesn't mean the songs are automatically gonna be genius. That's what people like you somehow just won't understand.

  • @MoonwalkerWorshiper oasis just copy off beatles song and for u to say oasis are better than the beatles you dont have clue about music at all

  • @MrScottBach

    You can't just continue to fill up the comment space with poor arguments that doesn't mean anything like "you're simply wrong, you don't have a clue" trying to be insultive instead of constructive, I'm afraid I'm gonna have to remove a couple of our comments.

    Copy off Beatles songs? Man, where do you people come from? Are you even listening to this music before you put yourself in the position of "knowing better"? This song got 6 chords, not 3, so who's ignorant?

  • @MrScottBach

    oasis have ballad songs like wonderwall, all around the world, dont go away,

    they have huge anthem songs like dont look back in anger, whats the story morning glory, they have rock out songs like fade away, acquensce, cigarettes and alcohol and they also have atmospheric stuff like who gas panic, etc etc,

    they make great pop songs, ie the importance of being idle, thru to making the best rock songs, thats one dimensional????

  • @MoonwalkerWorshiper oasis are no were close to the beatles and even liam would admit to that and to say that oasis are better the beatles your just wrong. oasis have made millions off simple simple songs which is fair play but to say that they are better than the bealtes your wrong as the beatles revolutionized rock, and went into many genres which in my opinion sign of a great band however all oasis songs sound the same and only have 3 chords in them.

  • @MrScottBach The argument that I was somehow "wrong" is still as unsuccessfull now as it were earlier. There is also a thing called opinion, and each to their own are entitled to their opinion.

    But if you want to get objective you need to explain in what way somebody like Oasis cannot "come close" to the Beatles. They're very close; same country, generally same humour, same clothes, same hairstyles, same class, well alot of people tends to relate to Beatles and Oasis as sibling bands.

  • @MrScottBach

    The comparison I don't buy at all, if you want to come to an Oasis video and claim me or someone else is wrong. To me, much of the Beatles music sound the same, not necessarily because of the musicianship but more due to their limited rescources and orchestral abilities at that time. And talk about simple songs; Beatles rarely made a track longer than 3 minutes, Noel didn't mind to drag it out for 6 minutes back in the heyday and he still does. 3 chords? This song alone got 6.

  • @MrScottBach

    sick of people saying oasis songs are simple,

    IF ITS SO SIMPLE WHY DONT U WRITE THEM AND GET PAID MILLIONS,

    the fact is, simple songs are harder to write,

    u can be a technical guitar player, doing sweeps, appegio's and licks, but how about u try writing live forever,,

    stop saying oasis music is simple, yes its simple to play, but its bloody talent to create oasis songs like noel does.

  • @sunj5976 Well here's a guy I definitely sympathize with and understand, because he talks sense. Thank you sunj.

    The people who spouts off about themselves know something about music and trash others for being ignorant, they are the real ignorant jerks in this case. They magically consider themselves to know more about music BECAUSE they know nothing of Oasis. Isn't that a bit contradictive?

    What I hate about the old beatlemania is that it feeds the arrogant attitude among these pricks.

  • @sunj5976 just listen to what you've just said ''the simple songs are harder to write''

  • @MrScottBach I don't think Oasis songs are that simple, the prerequisites for your argument is bogus in the first place. Rock'n'roll is not suppose to be a complex structure, doesn't mean the songs are easy to create or simplified. In fact, Oasis are one of few bands that actually hit the nail on it. The songs sunj reeled up are definition of the 90's rock and the 90's generation to many. I don't think there's any other band that have achieved as much as Oasis musically.

  • @MoonwalkerWorshiper well if you read what i said early, i said fair play for making simple songs and i never said oasis arent a good band, my point is that there nowhere near the beatles and that alot of oasis song are simple and copied off the beatles

  • @MrScottBach

    I will post a few responses anyway.

    "fair play for making simple songs"

    Oasis songs aren't simple, they have an uncomplicated structure which is still hard to perform and sing accurately. The riffs are strong and difficult to deliver good, and the vocals are often very high or very raw.

    "i never said oasis arent a good band"

    I didn't accuse you of saying that either, I'm simply correcting your false statements.

  • "my point is that there nowhere near the beatles"

    Your point is that you don't know what you're talking about, and you can't back it up either but simply repeating yourself. You need to explain stuff like this. I already explained they very much lived up to the same hype in the 90's as oppose to the 60's, but a comparison isn't really needed since we can all tell Oasis songs are better.

    "copied off the beatles"

    False naturally, and by its own means, unless you can prove it.

  • i dont think his voice is that bad here...his voice is just not as high as it used to be when he was 20 years old.

  • wow the drummer's playing is SOOOO enthusiastic.. and look at liams garment wtf is up with that haha.

  • how can you call noel a prick.. if it werent for him youd be gettin no songs on an oasis tour.. maybe watching the rain in the boardwalk.

  • best band in history in my opinion and it should be everyones opinion

  • @AlanJohnC94

    Yeah it should mate, but most people would not dare to challenge the old beatlemania even though it's dead since 40 fucking years

  • @MoonwalkerWorshiper I dont know man, from the musical point of view, The Beatles are way superior to Oasis. Plus most of the recording, composition and performing standards of today were set by them in the 60's with a quarter of the technology we have today.... There are amazing bands, legendary bands... and the best band the world will ever see, and they are The Beatles. P.S. Im an Oasis lover

  • @americanblues05

    Speaking of the old performing standards in that time, I consider musical acts such as Simon & Garfunkel and Little Richard for instance to have way better sound wall than the Beatles ever had, the Beatles musicianship were mediocre at best in my opinion and I can understand they have been a big source of inspiration and been massive in popularity but that doesn't make them best to me personally. Legends, yes. Best ones? No, Oasis are the last legends, and best at that.

  • There's no pace and urgency to the performance - that's the problem. Look back at Glato or Roskilde 1995 there's a great frenetic pace that makes those performances so great.

  • Something's seriously wrong with this performance and it isn't just Liam's voice, everything sounds out of time. The chorus is especially bad listen to 1:37-1:41 man that's not Liam messing up.

  • at least the crowd was on pitch

  • drummin is weakkkkkkk!!!!!!

  • It blows, but it was the first live gig for Zak Starkley

  • What a rubbish performance. Critics all sited this as one of the worst, Liam is fucked, this is what singing incorrectly for years eventually does to your voice.

  • @pooisgood123

    actually, that would be cocaine that did Liam's voice in.

  • I luv Oasis and Liam's voice

    But My dog has a better voice than Liam in this song

  • mindless kids, oasis is noel oasis is liam. wtf? oasis is noel and liam together, The tracks are great, most of them came from noels mind, but I m sure many ppl wouldnt like them, if noel would sing them all...liam had the perfect voice for these songs, and they are great just the way they are from noels mind from liams mouth, cheers

  • for me oasis is NOEL & LIAM

    maybe liam add this stupid kid attitude but i think u know liam add this little something in his voice that thing i dont know how to explain but this thing its important for oasis and noel know that .

    NOEl is have a very very big talent to write song and you know what i think that toasis need these two brother

  • Noel is a hairy arsed prick. who keeps giving us the greatest hit setlist tour after tour. I'm glad he's left, now the new Liam project will have to use their own songs and Noel's greatest hits. I wished to God, in their last tour, we would of heard some songs played live, that weren't played before. But no, Noel is a hairy arsed prick at times. Love you Noel.

  • Don't think they'll play Noel's songs though. But personally I'd like to hear more tunes from Heathen chemistry and Be here now for instance

  • liam sings so shitty...it´s horrible. what the fuck liam. look at them playing live back then when familiar to millions came out. it´s sad.

    best rockn roll band in the world back then....now it´s mando diao.

  • Muse r posh twats is correct:D

    unliike oasis the working class heros:)

    RIP OASIS

  • First, Muse are definitely not twats. Second, no need for RIP; they're continuing, just without Noel.

  • aw 1st muse r posh twats snoby bastards

    and 2nd if you were a REAL OASIS FAN you would know they r not continueing .Liam is makeing a new band along with Gem,Andy and Chris.& Noel is going solo.

    There is some speculation that they will keep oasis name .

  • I agree with your second point. Oasis IS Noel.

    Lastly, if you really think that Muse are twats then you must really enjoy lemonade on top of your lager.

  • lol.i love Muse but they r stuck up snooby twats be honest they wer rich kids .

    and NO NOEL NO OASIS.dont continue on the oasis name without Noel its 100% pointless.he is the back bone of oasis.

    dont you agree??

  • i dont think hes out of tune, infact i love his delivery here, he was on good form that night its weird how oasis never come across well at festivals, i think its cos festival crowds expect their bands to get into the spirit maybe jump in the crowd get down n dirty and oasis never seem to care

  • Awesome...why noel?

  • Comment removed

  • fucking shut up div

  • youtube it pal

  • no one blows oasis out of the park. never has, never will

  • well said

  • Especially not any bands out today who are all about fame and fortune. Oasis is about music. They say like it or don't. We don't care.

  • Muse are fucking posh southern twats

  • Brilliant!

    Thankyou for uploading!

  • You're welcome..!

    :D

  • Thanks buddy. Oasis are certainly legends and in about 10 years we all will see it.

  • Most definitely. I see it already

  • right at about :9,starkey misses the head completely an hits the rim haha

  • what time did you say?

    :9 is not a time

  • haha my bad at :09

  • best song ever writte

  • yeahyeahyaha2  - saying douche bag obviously shows your a dick and dont have a clue about english music, alex turners a miserable yorkshire monkey and has got nothing on liam gallagher.

  • For some reason i think liam sounds good here.

  • this is the good stuff, tnxs men

  • best band and a fucking amazing video!

    thanks for uploading.

  • You're welcome,

    thank you for appreciating it!

  • I have a very large amount of oasis Bootlegs, and I Still think this is the most chilling and Atmospheric version of this song I've ever heard.

    Huge.

    Thanks

  • 4:14, GET YER TITS OUT LUV :o)

  • ya, nice

  • Comment removed

  • Liams voice sounds f**ked!!! That coat is fucking awesome though!!!

  • THERE SONGS REMIND ME OF MY YOUTH. I still think " Whats the Story, Morning Glory" is one of the best Album's ever made. Magaluf 96. Sat on the balcony, Me and Rachel singin to every word b4 we went out to get morteled!!!

  • Cool but what's "morteled"??

  • Pissed dear.

  • well I will agree but definately maybe is awesome as well

  • brill

  • I think Liam's singing is a little bit off, but not too bad, just a bad day at the office, even one of the best bands ever is entitled to that. Have to say though, i though Zak Starkey was a crap choice for oasis. I'm not saying he isn't talented, but he slow, plodding style just saps the energy out of the song. I thik Wembley 2000 or especially Earls Court are the best versions of this song

  • True....true!

    and that's a good tip, gonna check it out

  • @howieboy62032914 i agree about zak. he obviously got the job as drummer because of his name.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • i think this is one of liams best songs to sing, his voice mught not fit other songs, bit it fits this one perfectly!

  • Hes of 'is tit lol but Oasis is fuckin' amazing

  • Liam's voice here in PEru the last thurdays was really good!! we enjoyed their first concert here!! we were 44 000 people singing. =D

  • Is it up on youtube yet?

  • yes it is!! there are a lot of videos even in HD

  • wow liam looks awesome...

  • i love the guitar tune at the start

  • liams voice wasnt the best in this period, thats fact. he would prob admit that. but too be fair the guy, with noel bending the fills on the whammy it knocked the e chord out slighty, so he does sound a bit out of tune, but the chorus he's off anyway so dont matter. lol. best supersonic was wembley 2000 1st night.

  • totally :)

  • yeah true, but its still ok

  • lol hes probably pretty drunk too.

  • Its crap listening to it on youtube but i bet if we were there would be better

  • Just look at the City of Manchester gig the next year and you'll see they're back on top form however.

  • I think we can just tick this concert off as a really, really bad day at the office that they very quickly got over. Shame they had to perform so badly in front of so many people though...

  • Yeah I'll take some fans were disappointed.

  • bad drums in this one, and its too slow, i like the ones back in 2000 and 1999 when Zak played it fast and really well.

  • This concert was Zak`s first year with the band, Alan White was the previous drummer.

  • This drummer is son of Ringo Star, pay some respect to his daddy

  • the reason this performance isnt the best is because it was their first live show in over a year and they also had a new drummer most some of the material for the first time, listen to later gigs with Zak and u'll see the difference with his drumming

  • sing passion seems over in this live...

  • listen to the live versions of supersonic over 10 years back and hear the difference, the vocals seem to have gone or maybe his just nt interested

  • what's up with liam here? I mean c'mon he's like playing around with the song

  • wtf dis a shite i agree wit all of use dis is fukin shite cant belive ppl didnt kick up afta dat terrible performance and for once liam isnt the main reason for it being shite

  • A bit on the slow side... but still pretty good

  • This sounds bad 'cos Oasis don't want to play on that show, probably cause of Jay-Z singing Wonderwall, I'm not sure if that happened in that show, but I believe that this is the answer of this bad performance

  • this performance is from 2004

  • Oh, sorry... You're right, i didn't pay attention to that detail =P...

  • what the fuk r u on about lol u dont no shit. the talentless fuk jay-z performed fukin in 2008 not 2004 fukin ell lol ! u suld no that cus oasis would always headline glasto ther to good not to!nar it is wank cus they had a argument before the gig and they cba and wanna get off the stage ;)

  • noel loses notes, that's not good

  • right im off to watch the earls court version!!

  • too right!

  • also i think for anyone who has been to see oasis on this tour so far i think chris sharrock could be the best so far. he has more power than whitey and drums quicker than zakk ever did. i loved whitey and his rythms were phenomenal, zakk was good but too slow and he struck me as a bit of a cock who thought he was the bollocks. anyone ever see the gig where noel introduced him as ringo and he got the hump big time!

  • Lol what gig was that?

  • i agree with all the comments here. defo the worst oasis gig on youtube. liam couldn't give a shit and i think that transcended throughout the band. plus the sound levels are fuckin awful (andy's bass sounds bloody terrible at this gig) and yeh zakk is well off the pace. the think with zakk is that theres no doubt he is a good power drummer, but he just does every song far to slow and it ruins songs like this. whitey and now chris are much more with it in that respect. plus liams coat is crap!

  • right, reason this gig was shit is that liam dint sound that good admittedly but fuckin hell zack starkey on the drums on this gig is wank .. dunt get me wrong he gets better in the future by a long way hes an ace drummer but this was his first gig and his timin is fucked up man ..

  • Glasto '04 is definitely the WORST Oasis gig on YouTube.

    Liam = Kermit the Frog (the only thing Liam did right was wear that badass coat!)

    Noel's playing seems a bit lackluster. Something with the guitars and bass just sound like utter shit.

    And the way the songs were played? Wtf! It all sounds sooooo sluggish! Pick up the pace, lads!

  • Heh and I didn't even liked the coat he weared

  • This is by far the worst performance of Supersonic I've ever seen. I can't quite work out what the problem is. Is one of the guitars out of tune? The chorus in particular sounds all over the place.

  • I haven't got a clue actually, the whole concert sounds like that. Supersonic is a bit worse than the other songs because Liam is out of tune, wich is not often..

  • all they guitars are in tune, liams just screwing it up.

  • Its much better if the second ''take u home'' is higher like @ wembley, thats awesome...

    too bad he doesnt do it here

  • yeah, maybe Liam is a bit lazy in his singing sometimes

  • wats so bad abot this concert? i think its good. the best supersonic was the one at wembely. this is pretty good, the drums are a bit week but nothings really bad.

  • Exactly, Whats wrong with this?

  • this was just a horrendous gig.  Zak was great after this. look at rock n roll star at the manchester 05 gig. zak is great. hope the new guy is good enough.

  • For those who bother about Liam's voice, do you guys have any idea how hard it is to sing in outside venues?! He basically has to scream in order for the people in the back to hear it. Zak's drumming is good, he did not ruin those songs like DLBIA or Live Forever. I mean I agree, he did play a bit too weak on Supersonic, but his drumming was spectacular for Oasis and for The Who.

  • I always say, turn the mic up! Would help them alot

  • This is one of the worst versions i've heard. Its sounds if they can't be bothered to play. I know they had a new drummer and that but Starky aint exactly a novice.

  • Whitey aint coming back, they paid him off and before he left they had a massive row

  • bring back Alan White

  • Think you're being unfair, maybe the drumming is somewhat weak but you gotta admit Noels solo in the end is mind blowing.

  • well yeah but a solo dosent compensate for the bands performance through the majority of the song. They sound shit here, and by all means im no expert here put i dont here any base, zak sounds like he's scared to break a nail, and the guitars just seem all over the place. Im so glad Zak has left OASIS because in my personal opinion, he destroyed songs like 'live forever, dont look back in anger rock'n'roll star amoung others. His drumming just makes some of the songs sound hollow.

  • As long as we're talking drums I'm gonna agree full but perhaps it's because of "stage conditions" here that makes it feel poor. I've seen the whole Glasto 04 concert and Liam has been better, no doubt. We all get pissed when something makes Oasis sound bad, so... just wait 'til next tour and hopefully they're gonna shape up. yup A White was definitely more rock than Ringos son

  • wats wrong with andy bell? hes great! much better than guisg

  • how exactly can this be awful dickhead?

    if you are referring to liams voice ... you are 50% correct...

    but this version still kicks ass

  • this version has got the best feel

    long live rock n roll

    long live oasis

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more