Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (393)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • my first record I ever bought,I was 11

  • I had this album when it came out,where is it now? This in my opinion is Elton's and Bernie's best work ever! Probably second to this album would be Rock of the Westies! Third,Goodbye Yellow Brick Road! Candle In The Wind-Sweet Diana.Rest in Peace my Princess.

  • underated

  • Elton at his very best!

  • Que saudades!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Tempo bom!!!!!!!!

  • Nice :)

    abeldanger(dot)net

  • Slow build and at 2:31 guitar chords hit...Elton John Magic...NICE!!!

  • I always saw this song as the story of Elton and Bernie Taupin. Elton is Captain Fantastic and Bernie is the Brown Dirt Cowboy.

    

  • Great Album!

    I'd wish there were albums like this nowadays, but unfortunately we are now stuck with half-educated morons "singing" about their cars, guns and bitches. Anyway...

    Long live Elton and Bernie!

  • So, So PROUD Of All the People Who Love This Like I Do :) You All Give Me Hope.....

    There Still May Be Enough Of Us To Know What GREATNESS Is....Thank You All :)

    I Was Dancing In My Room in '75 With This One Too...Singing Really Loud...lol....

    Love this Album Cover, Still Have It In the Milk Crate, that Heavy Thing....rotfl....

    ::EJ4Eva::

  • me it take me back I ALSO BOUGHT THIS ALBUM IN 1975 STILL GOT IT STORED IN A GOOD PLACE.

  • "Hand in hand, went music and the rhyme..."

    Thank God it did work out that way. I thank God for people like you and Bernie.

  • @davidhwalton Indeed. If this were the only song they ever wrote it would be incredible enough.

  • Greatest song Elton ever recorded, in my opinion. I never tire of this song or album.

  • Jesus is coming back, but when only he knows....and he will be pissed at alot of people.

  • @myscreechy I talked to him yesterday...He said he was going to visit you first...top of some list...something like that...He and Judas are going to go visit a few folks and straighten them out on some history...or so He said. oh, btw...He also said He never answered to that name in his life...and also,he said he'd appreciate it if you referred to him as 'Yeshua' or Mr. benDavid, or, 'Dude Supreme' ...as he assumes all calls to Jesus are for one of the few million souls that had been Latins ...

  • I was 15 when this album came out...it remains one of my favorites, musically and lyrically both. Classic Elton John and boy, does it make me long for the days when music was this beautifully crafted.

  • this used to be my fave elton album. so many great tunes and song writings tells of experimentation with he and bernie. read between the linesl.

  • @murraymae

    Sorry, I meant the song We All Fall In Love Sometimes.

  • i played this song in houston,tx for years in the 70'z relearnin this ld stuff and make a comeback

  • this was my first 8 track and I was drawn to it because of the song someone saved my life tonight, but quickly realized that the entire production was a masterpiece !

  • Elton John & The Brown Dirt Cowboy - From the Edge of the World to your town! Complements of YouTube!

  • I love this sound. Love the way the mix the acoustic guitar, the mandolin and the electric guitars and I love Elton's voice. I just wish he hadn't felt the need to mess up an otherwise classic by mocking Jesus' return. ". . .And all this talk of Jesus. coming back to see us. mmm, mmmm you couldn't fool us."

    There is something called the "normalcy bias" which says that if something has never happened that it won't EVER happen." I'm afraid Elton fell into that trap concerning Jesus' return.

  • @mreaganismyhero

    Totally agree. that line bothered me when the album first came out.I gave him a pass though, as Bernie mentioned Lord and God so many times in other songs ie Daniel.

  • @mreaganismyhero re. mocking JC's return > the line "... couldn't fool us" > it sounds like he's looking back at his own naive, ego ridden youth. I wouldn't sweat it. Artists, really great ones, know their creative juice is a gift.

  • Wow, really amazing.

  • Goosebumps! This is his greatest album and you never hear any of these songs on the radio. You never see him perform this song in his concerts. And people don't ask for it either. Strange fucking world.

  • lol, brown dirt cowboy....uhmm yeah..he can make it all beautiful

  • i cant believe, but some peoples after listening this divine song, keep calling the justin bieber work "music" .

  • This brings back so many wonderful memories.

  • I'm with everyone on this. Elton John is one of my favorite Artits.......he can sing I shit all day and I'd love it ! lmao. A true Legend

  • I've always LOVED this song. What a masterpiece. Sad you never hear this one on the radio anymore.

  • @ladybluluv So true. Maybe we should start requesting it

  • Just heard this for the first time on Dave 92.9 Atl. What year was this? Love it!

  • @TheAmelia75 : 1975 was the year Captain Fantastic came out. This album (and the follow up, Rock Of The Westies) both debuted on the Billboard Album Charts at #1. Something unheard of at the time. 1974/1975 belonged to Elton John.

  • Who else thinks Captain Fantastic should join The Justice League??

  • @beatleman98 You people suc, was the most inspiring work he ever did!

  • @beatleman98 I think he should join the ambiguously gay duo =]

  • Geez..I just discovered this song today. This is one of his more abstract ones, for me anyway, and I read the lyrics and cried. They are strange yet make so much sense. Elton John was/is a great writer/performer.

  • Was 14 when this came out. Totally wore it out. Spent many an hr. with my headphones on listening to this album, and learning every word to every song.

  • I remember reading somewhere that the album cover was Bernie's idea.

  • @bettyfelon1 yeah Bernie rocks

  • after hearing every song of elton john i feel happy. his music is the bestttt!!!!!!

  • My favourite Elton John album - the soul of my adolescence!

  • @laurataten XO same here

    

  • Great album, completely forgot about this one. I was 12 when this came out and I played it until I wore out the grooves (remember vinyl?). I might be somewhat of a metal head now, but this still sounds great and I will be getting this cd again.

  • Damn I forgot what a great album this is...I was kinda in a low place much better now TY Elton and Bernie

  • Fantastic!

  • @EltonJohnRocketMan ...and the Brown Dirt Cowboy!

  • Best Elton John song. He's so good with that cowboy idiom.

  • I was at college when this came out...funny...makes me recall walking in the sunshine at grade school...timeless

  • I remember when this album debuted, it was at #1 then and it still... well... fantastic!

  • Elton has earned his title of "Sir" through his fantastic creations of music that the WORLD has been able to relate to...An ICON...Thank You "Sir John".

  • I absolutely love Elton John and while it's hard to pick this has to be my favorite song of all.

  • You won't find this on the greatest hits CDs. Elton fans know where to find the true gems, and this is one of them. From the end of the world to your town.

  • This song is great. I can't believe I've never heard it before today. Some Elton John fan I am.

  • hard album to digest

    ahem

    so we rephrase it as

    Meeeeeeee and my old lady

  • ...worked with the Man on this Tour....Changed everything for me....He's an amazing Showman indeed

  • Elton's best song !

  • All you Elton haters out there...we'll blow your planet up

  • Such a nostalgic song for me. My Dad's funeral's next week and we're playing this for him, was one of his favourite songs. Well, that is, right after we play Summer Holiday by Cliff Richards 'cos he thought that'd be hilarious. RIP Dad, and long live Elton John!

  • Great, great song, almost prog like in its changes of direction and the way it builds to two or three climaxes. The band are absolutely smoking on this too.

  • Wow! Used to shut myself up in my room and jam this album all day:) Great song! Part of the soundtrack of my very young 1970'S.

  • @lah6786 LOL, yeah, me too! Excellent album!

  • Wow The memories...can't believe I still remember all the words to this song....Elton is forever the BEST

  • Very nice.

  • @rainernew yes I love all his songs but this is the best one

  • I love the mandolin in this song

  • pookie if you read this i hate you marryed that blok reggie come 2 me

  • early EJ was the soundtrack of my youth...

  • @geeter68 early EJ... saw him in concert '71... just he, Dee & Nigel... that was Rock & Roll!

  • This is a fantastic song. Overlooked and underrated song from the great Sir Elton John. A magnificent title tune from a magnificent album. Superior quality. Sounds fantastic on a record, still good elsewhere, but really meant to be heard on a turntable. It's much more powerful that way, for any song. This is music.

  • oh ok some random country music, ...ok nice lyrics and vocals...hmmm this is getting good... oh s**t!!!!

  • wow. reminds me of this February. i had to write a five page paper on anyone i wanted. i chose elton john. people made fun of me for choosing someone gay. i didnt care cuz i knew what an extraordinary guy he is. the looks on their faces when i showed them all the albums he has was priceless. they now know what a true musician and good person is. thank you ej for giving us this example.(:

  • This IS music!!

  • I bought this album in 1975 when i was 10 years old,but philadelphia freedom was the first song that got me hooked to elton,since then i have followed his whole career bought every album all the way up to The Union with leon russell and have been playing piano and writing my own songs since i was 13 years old and i'm now 46 years old and i still think about Elton and Bernie everyday of my life being simply blown away at what they have created together for over 40 years.

  • @mactheartofwarfare I was 11.

  • @mactheartofwarfare Wonderful! Thanks for sharing!

  • This is Elton at his very best vocally, and Bernie at their very best lyrically. If I was stranded on an island and could only listen to one album for the rest of my life, this would be it. A close second would be GYBR, but the autobiographical lyrics of Capt. Fantastic are second to none. My favorite song and my favorite album of all time. Marty Mitchell b. 1963.

  • @monicapop13, I would choose Tumbleweed Connection myself, but this is a good album as well

  • The guy is a heck of a singer for a ....well.

  • Bought this album 2nd day after it was released in the USA. STILL one of my all time favs.

  • What a song!! Elton and Bernie were something else!! Loved this song since.....damn, I'm gettin old LOL!!

  • Elton John is an amazing person

  • This whole albumwas, basically, an autoboigraphy...Someone saved my life tonight was about John Baldry talking to him out of suicide...fantastic album..fantastic musician..

  • Comment removed

  • i came up with a theory that involves the book of genesis (fig leaves) buddha (sitting under the bodhi fig tree) jesus (many sayings about figs) ross horne's book (new health revolution) and science (figs are the most important source of food for fruit eating rainforest animals). i then experimented on the figs by eating mainly dried figs (same brand) for 6 years now and found cycles which i related to the numbers in psgs 11/12 of the book of revelations. this theory has gone around the world.

  • This is my best song by Elton John. But don't get me wrong, all of his songs are great . But the 70s were the greatest.

  • Nice and Easy album in start, about the life from Elton John and Bernie Taupin.

  • GOD DANG...I forgot how WONDERFUL this song was!!!!! Love EJ since I was 15...am 51 now...THANKS FOR ALL THE FANTASTIC MUSIC EJ!!! wish I could meet you and have lunch. It would be the thrill of my life!!

  • Comment removed

  • @chrisseals1 for me too

  • @chrisseals1 Then you remember how significant this album cover was for the intrinsic arts' me too' 51 and growing strong' its was the best of times with the world all there for its conquering'

  • @DrFruedienslip ... Yes, the cover art is awesome. I sure do miss the album covers. I miss going to the music store and looking at the albums. (later ..the CD's and getting a chance to listen to some of them. Buying music has really lost a lot of fun experiences.

  • @chrisseals1 Nowadays its Cd's but vynl was so much more real because the age of electronics has taken something away from us' do you still have a record player' I have one an the quality is so much finer'

  • @chrisseals1 go to bernie taupin.com you might enjoy hear bernie's stories

  • @chrisseals1 - Met him twice when I first came to the States. I was 8 y.o.

  • @chrisseals1 I spent all day on here, wow i am also 51 and that whould be a great day..every song you hear where were you when you first heard it.

  • I have always liked this song as well as the whole album I remember going into my brothers room and playing the album on his good record player.

  • Love the rattle snake percussive .. I always was wondering what that was until I bought one from Guitar Center 20 yrs. ago.

  • remember being disappointed when this album came out....but after a couple of plays, specially this song, it fast became one of my favorites....all his songs give me the chills!!!

  • @olilymom There have been lots of albums ( not just his) that I wasn't so sure of the first time I heard them and then they became my favorites.

  • As an early artist I used to stare into the cover art of this album, and would create dreams.

  • Elton the KING...Truly blessed to have him in my lifetime...

  • Comment removed

  • This is my favorite Elton John song and my favorite Elton John album. Love it.

  • @rainiernew Lest not forget that Bernie Taupin was the song writer' a great duo'

  • @rainiernew this whole album was great i'm 50yrs old and i long for good music like this

  • did fool us

  • I purchased this albulm for myself, I wrapped it, and put it under the Christmas tree when I was 10 years old. I played it hundreds of times. It is so great to hear it again. What memories it brings back. Thank you Elton.

  • i was 8 years old when this album came out. still sounds aewsome,my older brothers christmas present .

  • @piercethevale LOL LMAO !!!

  • "Fantastic" song and album. His talent in writing, playing and singing is amazing. Unfortunately, he is in for a surprise on the day Jesus does return.

    " . . . and all this talk of Jesus coming back to see us.  mmmm, hm. You couldn't fool us. . . . "

  • The absolute best Elton John lp!  A true concept album...unbelievable melodies hovering over incredible lyrics. No one makes records like this anymore.

  • This came out when I was about 7 years old, and I remember the album being on display in WH Smiths (in my hometown of Brighton). I remember the cover freaking me out; if you look at it closely, you can see how the artwork would freak out a young kid (it's pretty weird!!!!)

  • Being a guitar player it is really nice to here an EJ song that is constructed around strings rather than keys. His voice is great and this song reminds me of my childhood, my brothers were older and turned me on to him when I was young. I hope he does know that Jesus' return will not fool us. He has gone to prepare a place for those that accept him, and he will return to claim us. Every knee will bow and every tongue confess that he is Lord.

  • @jrlpc You're joking right!?

  • @jrotuno About what?

  • i have this on a 12 inch album didnt know was elton till bout 10 years ago got all his albums

  • Damn, this song makes me happy. My sister sent me this cd the summer I broke my leg and I drove my family nuts playing it on CONSTANT repeat.

    Thanks for posting em, cos my cd player's busted!

  • And all this talk of Jesus coming back to see us....mmmmm couldn't fool us.... LOVE IT!

  • Farmer workers on the back of a truck at 5am.

  • They'll get together...

  • Whats a little dirt cowboy? and wtf is a chocolate biscuit???...No never mind I don't want to know.

  • @ivegotamagicstix The song draws on childhood memories of things like playing cowboy and eating chocolate (cookies), as they say it in England. Sorry, I'm a know-it-all!

  • Elton John was always one of my favorites back in the day. He has great music.

  • what year was this?

  • @okrabay ...............1975

  • timeless music...nothing really more to say, just press PLAY

  • Love it.

  • best album. ever.

  • This was the 4th and best of Eltons run of great albums and it is an absolute masterpiece, including this brilliant opening song. The whole album simply oozes craftmanship and class. What an inspiration.

  • @arfurlife Captain Fantastic was not Elton's 4th album. It was actually Elton's 9th album.

  • @Sbrownlee I know it was nt his 4th album. i meant it was the 4th of his 4 greatest albums which all ran consecutively. Also, I m not belittling his superb earlier works like Tumbleweed and Elton John/ Honky Chat etc. Its just my own opinion that "dont shoot me "to Capt F " was Elton at his very peak. Thanks anyway..would have hated to not know about the former albums. 'Come down in time' is one of my absolute all time faves.

  • This is the very fist album I ever bought when I was 12 years old. Saw this album on the rack at the store.  Fell in love with the cover had to have it............. What a amazing album this was. The best $4.95 I ever spent........I am 45 now and still listen to it. This album was the soundtrack to my life back then.........

  • When this album came out I was 6 years old and living in Brighton, UK; I remember the album being in shop windows, and thinking that the cover was quite creepy and scary ( you have to look at the cover close to see how it might freak out a young kid!). My favourite Elton track, though.....

  • SWEET CHOCLATE BISCUT???

  • Released 3 weeks befor I graduated high school...A good time for me....

  • congrats to elt on the new baby! this is a wonderful song,

  • Anything after Rock of the Westies.....that when Elton went down hill....but anything before that was classic great music...

  • GREAT,GREAT!!!

  • this is a great song, but could someone please explain to me what the fuck the lyrics mean? i know its supposed to be about their careers and there might be some gay overtones, but what i dont get is how sweet chocolate biscuits have anything to do with anything.

  • @pleeppleep Some times art doesn't need any explanation. It just is. BTW I don't know. All I know is the words just fit. Good question though. I wish I did know.

  • @pleeppleep one thing to remember is that, in England, biscuits mean cookies. In that verse he's (Bernie Taupin) talking about sitting in his mom's house, eating cookies and apples, asking her if he has what it takes to be in the music biz. The whole album is written about the time after they got together but before they were successful, back when they were only writing songs for other people to record, Elton John being Captain Fantastic and Taupin being the Brown Dirt Cowboy.

  • @pleeppleep you dont ???

  • @pleeppleep just imagine it as a conversation over tea and cookies (biscuits).

  • Aside from loving this album, I can remember spending many hours studying the cover art. Elton has never duplicated the greatness of his '70's albums, but that's OK...this is enough greatness for any artist.

  • Awesome album xx

  • Make your order now # lushfmlk.info #

  • @alcofridy

    tsk tsk.

  • In the day I was as rabid an EJ fan as you would EVER find. If it had his (or Bernie's) name, face, or voice on it, I owned it. Trust me - there was never any mystery "subtext" about this autobio. album. Everyone knew Bernie was the Brown Dirt Cowboy - the quiet country boy always in denim shirts and cowboy boots - and EJ was Captain Fantastic, the glammy, mercurial rock star. BTW, Bernie wrote Tiny Dancer for Maxine, whose photo appears inside of GYBR, and who then became his wife.

  • Comment removed

  • It's amazing how good this album was, and how much pretty much everything later sucked ass. I loved everything Elton did up to and to include this album, and hate almost everything after....

  • I think this song along with Someone Saved My Life and Curtains are some of Eltons greatest songs. At the same time, this is not one of my favorite of his albums. Goodbye Yellow Brick Road is my favorite because from beginning to end it is high quality. Captain Fantastic has some fantastic songs but also some so so songs.

  • I was a junior in high school, bought this album the day it went on sale. Saw him @ Dodger Stadium a little later. What a show!!!!

  • this is the 1st album I ever bought. every song is a classic to me. great memories, great music

  • EltonJohn,fez em1980 o melhor dico de sua carreira .e eu simplismente reverencio este ser humano espetacular

  • I enjoyed this album in the seventies, totally oblivious of the overt, pro homosexual theme. Still love the music...

  • @Nicap2 "overt pro homosexual theme"? where???

  • @pudljumper A brown dirt cowboy was a euphemism for a homosexual. It's still Elton Jonhs best album IMHO.

  • @Jupitersgoose i didn't know that. i always thought 'brown dirt cowboy' refered to bernie taupin (who i believe is str8) and 'captain fantastic' refered to elton

  • @pudljumper  Good point. I'm not sure if the euphemism existed before the album or became a euphemism after the album was released. Anyways, I'm not homophobic and its a bloody good album. There are other references in the album but they are veiled and subjective, eg. I like the warm blue flame, the hazy heat it brings, loosens up the muscles and forces you to sing. Again it's meant to allude to poppers ( a stimulant that relaxes the anal sphincter). It could mean something else.

  • @Jupitersgoose lol. i was thinking exactly that! my GUESS is that because elton came out the year after this album was released, some people (thinking they were funny) started using 'brown dirt cowboy' as a euphemism for homosexual. and i guess it stuck (elton was very popular in the first half of the 70s). anyways, in regards to poppers or any other gay references, my understanding is that the album is the autobiographical story of elton and bernie's CAREER from the point that they met .....

  • @Jupitersgoose ....(cont) up until they released their first album (empty sky). and keep in mind the lyrics were written by bernie, so i'm not sure why he would feel the need to include veiled homosexual references. i guess lyrics r subjective and u can read what u want into it. personally, i don't care either way. like u said, it's an amazing album!

  • @Jupitersgoose

    Bernie Taupin wrote these lyrics. He is straight, and he is the Brown Dirt Cowboy, because he was always the simple country-living guy who eschewed the fame spotlight and loved the romance of the American West (hello, Tumbleweed Connection & Honky Cat). Elton is Captain Fantastic. And there is no "flame" involved ininhaling poppers. It's most likely a reference to smoking something, like hash or opium.

  • @SabbeleuDesigns Poppers can be inhaled directly or they can be used on an aromatherapy oil burner to release slowly into the air over a long period of time. It works well in a confined space such as a bedroom. That would be the warm blue flame reference. Not that it really matters in the end, its a good album.

  • @Jupitersgoose

    It's one of my top favorites. Just a total work of art, from vinyl to cover. It also had an awesome full color lyric book included. Many people don't know that it was the first album ever to enter the charts at Number 1.

    Those interested in learning more aboutamazing  Bernie "The one who writes the words" Taupin should check out his website, or his Americana (cowboy roots) music show on Sirius.

  • @SabbeleuDesigns

    I have the vinyl as well, and I'm 26!

    Found it at a Second-hand place.

  • @Jupitersgoose Sorry for double posting.There are other (possible) references. I always thought it had gay undertones but still lov