Rethink Afghanistan War: Jon Rainwater vs. Jeremy Shapiro

[smokethosetaliban]

Military or criminal investigation response? Is that the question? Answer..Military because of the threat created by the nexus between terror orgs. and rogue govts....Again the real threat is the nexus itself, not the parties to it. I'm trying to imagine the call from Interpol to the Taliban on 9/12 saying "we need your help". We have no experience winning wars with PR(hearts and minds), at least when not preceded by a thorough defeat of the fighting enemy as in Germany or Japan--PR comes later

[psbjr]

@smokethosetaliban 2002 called and it wants its idiotic rhetoric back

[smokethosetaliban]

@psbjr typical lib response--no substance...just vitriol and namecalling to disguise the absence of intelligent ideas...

[silverton7777]

Who paying for Afgan China is financing this once this drys up America will fall. The military Defence contractors want war. Haliburton

[911truthandjustice]

Stop policing the world, we cant even afford to take care of our own country.

Vote Ron Paul!

Legalize Freedom.

[13lackLight]

I find myself agreeing with the dude on the right of the screen (Jeremy I think). He seemed to be able to back up what he believed and would talk about facts.

[warhater]

Are we still looking/ 4 Mr. Bin Laden/ The guy the USA trained?/ Won't find him/In those mountains/ So we murder more civilians?/ "Get us the hell out!"/U must all shout/ 2gether U have power/ Killing those like U/Destroys U 2/ When will you sour?/ Genociding innocents/Gives U no moral sense?/ R leader's always lie/& very hard try/ 2 make you hateful, tense/ Vets come home/Feeling alone/ Their care is so bad/ Join us & preserve/Making leaders, us 2serve/ Stop the senseless jihad.

[LatifAhmadi]

If you have from get-go these character wellcome otherwise........... We say it sample and perfect..... get it. In generosity and helping others be like a river... In compassion and grace be like sun.... In concealing others' faults be like night... In anger and fury be like dead... In modesty and humility be like earth... In tolerance be like a sea... Either exist as you are or be as you like. MEVLANA

[gsuitter]

Time to come home.

[Qu33nZyunGvET718]

these guys sound like they shouldnt deserve the position to debate because they dont sound like their being truthful and spreading their propaganda.

[bob733333]

the U.S will prolong and increase the violence and war. it's big business.....

[RespectMyHate]

Im leaving for afghanistan march 20th. I hope I'll be OK.

[will4ward]

Try learning a bit of Farsi (language)and their history and traditions so you don't

come off like an ignorant Yank.

Good luck - man - be safe.

The good thing is , that at least you have an administration that gives a s---t now.

[RespectMyHate]

Thank You

[Lawyerdude]

Blah blah blah. Boring uneducated shithead paid politician/ lobbyists

[074August]

dude, stupid megalomaniac witch, who pretends to be a god & is above everyone, I don't advocate being in Afghanistan, but I do resent witches as you posting your crap propaganda on youtube.

Go away.

[Qbeck01]

There is no valid legal or ethical argument to justify either war. Unless you consider "might makes right" an argument.

[Qbeck01]

The debaters agree with each other...that's not a debate.

Can anyone tell me what the nationality of the 911 hijackers were? hint-not afghan.

If a criminal organization killed thousands of people and runs to another country to escape justice -Union Carbide (i.e. Dow) disaster at Bhopal- it doesn't give the victimized country the right to decimate whichever country the perps happen to have fled to...otherwise India would have attacked the US...and Canada.

[intelegens]

The plan is actually good,but the terrorists have control over governments etc...

[buckfush12]

/watch?v=NuMUSxzej3A

Hey guys just want to help spread this families story.

[WKaliber1]

Second!!