i think josh is great. of course rhcp won't be the same with him,but never mind. john will have a new cd so don't need to worry about that we'll never hear new track from him. i like both oh them. nice guys. :)
yeah, Josh's voice is kinda girly, nice video anyway! i love John! can anybody love John tell me your feeling about Josh? what do you think about new RHCP?
@augostomarina It's hard to stomach change, but parallel with those feelings I think this is an awesome opportunity and I'm really looking forward to their new music. Listening to Josh's pieces from the 90's there are similarities to John's style (before they even worked together) that kind of show he could be a great fit for the band. But he's still got a very personal style. On top of that, I love John's solo work more than anything, and there's a chance for more of that too :)
Replacing John is like replacing a lost family member: it can't be done. John was perfection; nobody can do the beautiful things he does, the way he does. The RHCP will never be the same.
Smile though, this is a new chapter. I have hope, you should too. Why?
1. Nobody can take my memories of JF away. John's music will live on forever.
2. Klinghoffer = best case scenario "replacement-" what a gifted man.
@augostomarina he's irreplaceable, what he did can't be explained with words he helped them reach the great succsess they actually have today. I doubt josh have the same gift as frusciante but i like josh to as an artist and hope he does a great job with RHCP :)
I don't understand why people are complaining so much about Josh Klinghoffers voice.. It's about the music man.. I think it sounds great and Josh has a beautifull voice..
god I'd love to have josh's voice! but I think that it's quite obvious sometimes that it's a guy's voice. girls often vibrate...quite alot. but I'm a girl and I want his voice XD
Well my guess on it would be that it is an A# major 7 as the jazzchord version, and the second chord would probably come by moving the ringfinger, but am not sure.
Ps, you'll need to dampen the g-string with the tip of your littlefinger
are you retarded? it just takes a quick look at the title to figure that out... besides, if you can't tell just by John's voice that it's him then you don't deserve to listen to such great music.
oh, i see that we have yet another ignorant, obnoxious youtube dumbass... if you're going to be sarcastic, it should probably be funny, rather than a waste of time to everyone who views this video. stop making childish remarks because of your obvious lack of attention
yeah sure, I clicked a video saying NOT A COVER, to find it's a cover and say so.
okay sir, from now on my sarcastic remarks will be 'fun', because you say it has to be so. you could use a little fun, don't ya. harvester-of-sorrow. not childish at all.
nothing hugely famous... Mostly he does work with John, and toured with the Chilis... Does bits and pieces other people's records... Wikipedia will probably tell you more! :-)
wikipedia doesn't say much, but I know he did stuff with John waaaay before touring with the Chilis... I guess he just got to know John, what with them both being musicians an' all... I'm sure I remember reading more about the two of them... I let you know if I remember more, lol!
i think josh is great. of course rhcp won't be the same with him,but never mind. john will have a new cd so don't need to worry about that we'll never hear new track from him. i like both oh them. nice guys. :)
totallyellow 4 weeks ago 2
This is amazing music.
23kyleadams 1 month ago
if you like josh's singing, listen to At your enemies which is with John frusciante! Its beautiful. Thumbs up so people know :)
GRRJayyy 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
How the fuck do they do this at 3:45 ?
TheGroumpfy 2 months ago
Comment removed
TheGroumpfy 2 months ago
that is with Klingoffer?
kaharonus 2 months ago in playlist Další videa uživatele zombiefly
it's Jonh Frusciante wiht Josh Klinghoffer (: John is awesome <3
recolacarean 3 months ago
wow awesome!!!!!!!
rodryalmada 3 months ago
Josh and John... they should play guitar AND sing for Red Hot Chili Peppers - BOTH at the same time!! :)
sleepy91 4 months ago 10
simplemente lo amo !!
vanessasabe 5 months ago
wonder who disLiked this! O.o
lizrdfunk 5 months ago 3
@lizrdfunk Dave Navarro ;)
on the 3 different accounts
jokeyjoe13 4 months ago
Man, they both have beautiful voices.
12rhcpfan 6 months ago 6
@12rhcpfan who's the other one?
sexuallobster134679 5 months ago
@sexuallobster134679 If you're talking about the female-ish voice then it is Josh Klinghoffer. :)
12rhcpfan 5 months ago
John Frusciane looks so good with short hair and the glasses at 2:11 ! ;D
annaishere1 6 months ago 4
On which album is this special acoustic version of this song?
TheFirebirdPhoenix 9 months ago
@TheFirebirdPhoenix There is an all-acoustic version of Shadows Collide with People, just google it. :)
Kimekk 9 months ago
i have a crush on him, or maybe his music
and i'm straight or maybe thats what i think
anyways he is the best
canibaldance 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Happy birthday john!!!
loyet172 11 months ago
Muy bueno
agusquezadaa 11 months ago
yeah, Josh's voice is kinda girly, nice video anyway! i love John! can anybody love John tell me your feeling about Josh? what do you think about new RHCP?
augostomarina 11 months ago
@augostomarina It's hard to stomach change, but parallel with those feelings I think this is an awesome opportunity and I'm really looking forward to their new music. Listening to Josh's pieces from the 90's there are similarities to John's style (before they even worked together) that kind of show he could be a great fit for the band. But he's still got a very personal style. On top of that, I love John's solo work more than anything, and there's a chance for more of that too :)
SovLotus 11 months ago
Replacing John is like replacing a lost family member: it can't be done. John was perfection; nobody can do the beautiful things he does, the way he does. The RHCP will never be the same.
Smile though, this is a new chapter. I have hope, you should too. Why?
1. Nobody can take my memories of JF away. John's music will live on forever.
2. Klinghoffer = best case scenario "replacement-" what a gifted man.
3. Flea, Anthony, Chad. Still here. Be greatful.
Good luck to John in his solo career!!!
NortheasternHuskies 11 months ago 13
@augostomarina he's irreplaceable, what he did can't be explained with words he helped them reach the great succsess they actually have today. I doubt josh have the same gift as frusciante but i like josh to as an artist and hope he does a great job with RHCP :)
(Bad English)
JohnFruscianteYEAH 8 months ago
I can't wait to hear how Klinghoffer sounds with the RHCP guys.
But, secretly, I'm hoping for an Automatic Writing 3.
Carnane 1 year ago
i just love this. im sitting here listening to it crying.
danclockable 1 year ago
I don't understand why people are complaining so much about Josh Klinghoffers voice.. It's about the music man.. I think it sounds great and Josh has a beautifull voice..
Quatano93 1 year ago
This song is too good for words...so just close you mouth, stop typing and listen.
liveecarbme 1 year ago 3
I don't care if this Josh guy is John's twin, he is not and will never be John Frusciante. (tears)
dinster70 1 year ago 2
@dinster70
don't judge until you've heard their new album. I mean, his vocals are pretty good in this song so you never know.
teh1owner 1 year ago
@dinster70 who told you he's trying to be John?
EyeJustSkateboard 1 year ago
john frusciante ftw!! klinghoffer not to be the guiarist of the chili's!!!
tombayley 1 year ago
@tombayley Considering that Josh is basically John MkII, about the only thing that will change will be the timbre of the backing vocals.
Nireves33 1 year ago
It's his mom
Kickdrum16 1 year ago
Comment removed
Kickdrum16 1 year ago
ONE OF THE BEST SONGWRITERS OF OUR TIME.
kkuebler 1 year ago
@kkuebler THE best of ALL time
Andrewthegreathobo 1 year ago
The best part is how their voices play off of each other.
1dotonly 1 year ago
Josh is going to be one of the best musicians in the world
Wolfillete91 1 year ago 3
haha josh Klinghoffer is amazing man
great prodigy for john F=]
arsenicRG120 1 year ago
They are Gods.
fl0914 1 year ago
el mejor.......................john
windsilver1 1 year ago
This could so easily have become a great no woman no cry cover with these chords. However, Frusciante is the man
Downie493 1 year ago
Help my heart is gonna pop!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
gooberwench 1 year ago
@gooberwench
me too! lol
<3
eliexmute 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hey, Cool Video #VIDUPLOADERID#
Don't know this but looks pretty good.
I'm usually online watching movies on infinitefree movies
but I think I'll stay tuned to your uploads
Keep posting and more power to you!
altonswallowta 1 year ago
great song!!
ketchupecoca 1 year ago
best musicians ever !!!! josh n john
000alain0awad000 1 year ago
Also, look up Ataxia..."Communique" and "At Your Enemies" for Josh's vocals.
461oceanblvd 2 years ago
The past, and the present alternating vocals....very cool.
461oceanblvd 2 years ago
Well we now know Josh can hit Johns' high notes
snlfan1979 2 years ago 5
@snlfan1979
OMG FUCK YEA
thats wat IM SAYING!!!!
eliexmute 1 year ago
beautiful
safari8soldier 2 years ago 2
god I'd love to have josh's voice! but I think that it's quite obvious sometimes that it's a guy's voice. girls often vibrate...quite alot. but I'm a girl and I want his voice XD
rhcpbeMINE 2 years ago 2
it's so freakin' good, i love it
niekker 2 years ago 37
if you truly listen to frusciante then you will know and love klinghoffer.
italllies 2 years ago 7
ha josh's vocals
MrAlfredocolon 2 years ago
insperrrationel
mychemfan250 2 years ago
Josh Klinghoffer sounds sooo..... Girly! But it's so awesome!
Scearus 2 years ago 67
sounds sweeet.... yea i sound kinda girly too wen i sing high, scared ill get bagged out =P
mrpattrike 2 years ago
@Scearus I like his voice
IfearGuitars 9 months ago
@Scearus is it Josh klinghoffer? o.O omg I didn't know, but he is good
djina0605 5 months ago
@Scearus you got to be kidding me, its a woman singing, right? o.O
djina0605 5 months ago 2
centralize the force of rot
hsp882 2 years ago
isn't it john who sings? ;O
Br4iaN96 2 years ago
john and josh klinghoffer (back vocals)
autumnviolin 2 years ago
its josh klinghoffer singin and its not a cover its the real thing
rhcpfrush420 2 years ago 3
Can anyone please tell me the chords he is playing in the bridge - gracias!
fluffycheep 3 years ago
Well my guess on it would be that it is an A# major 7 as the jazzchord version, and the second chord would probably come by moving the ringfinger, but am not sure.
Ps, you'll need to dampen the g-string with the tip of your littlefinger
lars1122334455667788 2 years ago
Nice 3:12 flash ;)
RockAndLoadJM 3 years ago
1.omission
2.carvel
3.the real
redfoxfilms 3 years ago
is this a cover?
ploisteer 3 years ago
are you retarded? it just takes a quick look at the title to figure that out... besides, if you can't tell just by John's voice that it's him then you don't deserve to listen to such great music.
HarvesterofSorrow94 3 years ago 2
haha it seems you're the retarded one
retarded people don't get sarcasm, shithead
ploisteer 3 years ago
oh, i see that we have yet another ignorant, obnoxious youtube dumbass... if you're going to be sarcastic, it should probably be funny, rather than a waste of time to everyone who views this video. stop making childish remarks because of your obvious lack of attention
HarvesterofSorrow94 3 years ago
yeah sure, I clicked a video saying NOT A COVER, to find it's a cover and say so.
okay sir, from now on my sarcastic remarks will be 'fun', because you say it has to be so. you could use a little fun, don't ya. harvester-of-sorrow. not childish at all.
blame my lack of attention for noticing that.
ploisteer 3 years ago
that was hilarious
pause
NOT
anyway, who's the girl doing the other vocals??
markbooher1 3 years ago
oooh you made jokenot? I liiiiikkeeee
and it's not a girl, it's a guy. but I can't recall his name at this moment..
ploisteer 3 years ago
i made a jokenot!
i figured it was josh klinghoffer
but i wasn't sure he could sing that high. sweet thanks.
markbooher1 3 years ago
not a girl, josh klinghoffer
hsp882 2 years ago 4
I don't believe you, he can't have such a girly voice
fleaargento 2 years ago
you leave murderers...amazing song
elisaak 3 years ago
my favorite songs from JF gotta be
look on
fallout
going inside
omission
and alot more
okandah 3 years ago
1. Past Recedes
2. Omission
3. Height Down
robass5 3 years ago
1. omission
2. second walk
3. the slaughter
patriots12 3 years ago
i would say:
1.omission
2.song to sing when iam lonely
3.slaughter
Thewilltodeath576 3 years ago
The stereo mix is off.
ShawnMcCool 3 years ago
Awesome Song! What Does John Say For The Whole Second Verse?
Romans10Verse9 3 years ago
dam, where'd you get this acoustic version of Ommission and Carvel? Straight Nastiness.
ahession 3 years ago
Best Song EVER.
1st Place - Omission
2nd Place - This Cold
3rd Place - Song To Sing When I'm Lonely
:]
FrankZappaRule 3 years ago
my same exact picks!
victurban 3 years ago
Nice ^^
FrankZappaRule 3 years ago
I would've rather chosen
1- Time tonight
2- Omission
3- Song to sing when I'm lonely.
Time Tonight is one of the best songs I've ever heard :P
RedHotsFan 3 years ago 4
I'll look for it.
thanks ^^
FrankZappaRule 3 years ago
i would say:
1. Carvel
2. Omission
3. Second Walk
shadygrl4 3 years ago 2
the backvocal who is it singing
and why are you talking about emily?
foogrrrl 4 years ago
Josh Klinghoffer
KelC210 4 years ago 2
is he in an band?
foogrrrl 4 years ago
nothing hugely famous... Mostly he does work with John, and toured with the Chilis... Does bits and pieces other people's records... Wikipedia will probably tell you more! :-)
KelC210 4 years ago
okaiiii..thanks
do you know why they know him?
foogrrrl 4 years ago
wikipedia doesn't say much, but I know he did stuff with John waaaay before touring with the Chilis... I guess he just got to know John, what with them both being musicians an' all... I'm sure I remember reading more about the two of them... I let you know if I remember more, lol!
KelC210 4 years ago
okay.thanks..that´s really nice
foogrrrl 3 years ago
hes in Ataxia with John
philhenderson 3 years ago
who is emily?
soadfn1 4 years ago
emily kokal is johns old girlfriend
HenryOrange 4 years ago
oh,
does he go out with anyone currently?
soadfn1 4 years ago
i dont know but im glad they broke up coz she was ugly...
HenryOrange 3 years ago
thats the worst reason to break up with a girl.
Looks arent everything you know.
soadfn1 3 years ago
Ok, sorry dude :)
HenryOrange 3 years ago
no its fine...lol
soadfn1 3 years ago
thats the worst reason to break up with a girl.
Looks arent everything you know.
soadfn1 3 years ago
Love this version
gibbers82 4 years ago
The voices are awesome in 2:00.
albaco375 4 years ago 2
where are these acoustic versions from?
aitc37 4 years ago
he has a free download of the acoustic version of this CD on his website. which is where they are from.
Jeremy1281988 4 years ago
And there is a free release with 21 songs by JF, besides 7 Demos for Shadows Collide with People.
albaco375 4 years ago
awesome song
nachoman360 4 years ago 3
that's klinghoffer?! i thought so much of a woman, maybe emily kokal..never heard her voice.
stonedchili 4 years ago
whose emily?
guitichie99 4 years ago
emily kokal - john's now ex-girlfriend.
VeniceQueen91 4 years ago
is he single now then?
guitichie99 4 years ago
i suppose he is :)
VeniceQueen91 4 years ago
thx:)
guitichie99 4 years ago
when did they break up? How do you know?
lizhogg 4 years ago
Who's the other person in this song?
I liked of "duo". It's a woman who's singing with John?
squirrelzpa 4 years ago
its Josh Klinghoffer....its pretty weird coz he sounds so much like a woman but yes....
zombiefly 4 years ago 8
Josh does a tremendous job.
TommyDermot 4 years ago 2
sounds like NO WOMAN, NO CRY - same chords?
TedRyan 4 years ago
LOL no
pjm012345 4 years ago
yah! i think so to..
257melomaniacs 4 years ago 3
This song always makes me feel hopeful
BIGminnes1214 4 years ago
i think "unreal" sums it up. Ive read somewhere on one of these comments for a dif John vid and i totally agree "johns cooler than jesus" lol
MM4Lyfe1122 4 years ago
sory....I do not have a clue what u just said!
zombiefly 4 years ago
literal translation: "great!, the vocals are amazing and josh's completely!
youngbrooklyn11220 4 years ago
Good song. I don't like this as much as the original version.
gbrooks2 4 years ago