Added: 5 years ago
From: ezetty92
Views: 6,646,667
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (5,481)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • 585 people thought that phil collins version, the original, was better than this. They are right.

  • She sings beautifully :) 

  • wonderful thanks =)

  • super intense. sang from her bottom of heart

  • se la come doblada esta atorranta

  • I wish I could just make you turn around,turn around and see me cry there's so much I need to say to you,so many reasons why.....

  • um video q ja foi visto mais de 6 milhoes e seissentas mil vezes diz tudo neh perfeita a a presentaçao da mariah!!!

  • Я бы вдул!!!!!!!!!

  • what's up with the sorry quality of the sound? Her version blows.

  • she's mazing..=)

  • D maiss

  • Excellent cover, no doubt of it, but I still prefer Phill Collins'

  • mariah at her best. love her.

  • Your the BEST MARIAH CAREY! I LOVE YOU!

  • Linda essa música

  • É bonita a filadaputa...

  • OWSOME!!!, this song its beautiful,...im unbreath..YOU'RE THE ONLY ONE WHO REALLY KNEW ME AT ALL

  • i love the end."hmmmmmmmmmmmm"..:D..that melisma gave me goosebumps..

  • Sings from her heart

  • good, but phil > mariah still.

  • nag-iisa walang makakagaya sa kagalingan nya

  • classic. i think mariah is best female singer of all time.

  • whats the name of the note at 2:45 ?

  • @LimeStone001 gamma

  • @LimeStone001 I think its D5

  • MARIAH CAREY is the best singer i ever had b'COz she have a wonderful and celestial voice..^____^

  • goosebumbs... this .. is just like.. the emotion :O HOLY MILEY! It's crazy :)

  • mariah she give this song all the emtion need she did justice mcforever

  • i love her version of this song. i tried to do my own short rendition acapella, please take a look if you get a chance!

  • Comment removed

  • Weird recording. Looks like some noise gate is applied and it keeps bouncing. And glitching.

  • Ok, let's settle this now, they're both good!

    For example, no can argue Bob Dylan's genius, but his singing obviously isn't the best. I think it's the case for Phil Collins, and Mariah Carey the opposite.

  • kaya kaya ni cahrice kantahin ito puro na kasi siya whitney at celine pwede ba next time mariah nman

  • @anthony802511 but , mariah's still best than charice .

  • Comment removed

  • You people are deaf if you think Phil Collins can compare to Mariah Carey. She simply slays any song she sings and any singer she is compared to.

  • She is beautifull, but her singing is so bad, she can sing in man tonality.

  • @Peraazdaha Are you fucking deaf?

  • TheTea4ever, i completely agree

  • She's the best singer ever ,really.And come on people , if you like Phil's version better , then listen to it.You don't have to write negative comments here! This is MARIAH'S VERSION.

  • Love it

  • whats with the negativity?? she didn't fucking ruining anything she's amazing

  • what a great singer she is.

  • wow amazing ... :)

  • I don't care for her rendition. Phil Collins puts his soul into this song, she does not.

  • she seems like is singing gospel... dont get me wrong she has a beautiful voice, but phill's version is THE one.

  • I feel like i just had a religious experience!!

  • so amazing!!

  • No one is better than Phill...

    

  • she sings good , but she got AMAZING BOOBS !~!#

  • Someone needs to upload this in HD

  • this totally destroys phil collin's version

  • @shirusubemonaku in a good way or bad? The ending literally tears space apart.

  • kaya kaya ni charice pempengco kantahin ang kanta na ito.

  • @reformedOrder. Agreed. I like the way u think. I notice things like that about people too.

  • Mariah's look at the end, "her eyes in general" represented in this song she wonderfully sang seemed to take her to a place of a time where she had a situation of what exactly this song was about. She sang it as if whoever "left her" in the past would somehow hear her sincerity in those amazing notes & "come back." I learned a lot about her "spirit" in the Music Box album. That's back when artist still had freedom to do & write what they wanted. She screams for LOVE & ACCEPTANCE in those songs.

  • @ReformedOrder shut up

  • @ivory3908 Look, don't hate. It's Christmas, get OVER it. :-)

  • I think her version is really good, much like Without You she performed it from a female vocalist's perspective and to me it feels like quite a heartfelt tribute, seeing as it ties in to what she was going through in her life around that time + considering Phil Collins has nearly 30 covers to his name, his fans shouldn't be talking about who deserves to cover what.

  • AMAZING!!!!

  • If u all don't like it then why u listening to it I think this song is amazing and she sang it really well and don't forget its the live verstion of the song so stop hateing and get on with it

  • @leedsgirl4ever123 I listened anyway just to see if it was good. Some covers are awesome. Some are sub-par, like this one. I like Mariah, I just don;t think this is all that and I voted it down.

  • Wowwowowow

    shes a singer!! i love you mariary

  • CHOOCH IT

  • Moaning your way through a Phil Collins song =/= good. This is butchery. Bad 'suggestion' Youtbue.

  • @TheChopsinator Obviously didn't watch the whole thing. Her version >>>>

  • @lawlinat0r yes, I did. I didn't happen to care for it.

  • Better than the original!

    The greatest!

  • She's amazing.

  • All you delusional freaks (who most likely have numerous accounts and add nasty comments about Mariah) really, sit your ass down. Phil Collins thought Mariah's tribute to his song was phenomenal . You can read online of what he said etc . so pip down geesh. PLUS this is a females point of view (thats why Mariah choose it at that point in time because it went with her life at that time) which was 1999.

  • Mariah doesn´t have even a tenth of Phil Collins´ talent. She´s just a bitch getting money from fools around the world. Mediocre and awful.

  • @Rodrigo79799 You're delusional.

  • Why can't I watch this without crying?

  • @myNSproductions cause you still have a hang up about your ex, like the rest of us.

  • Phil Rocks . Mariah is just mediocre .

  • I love this song and id rather this more than thank god i found you. i dont know why this never reach the number one in the hot 100 :S

  • @TheArca9 cause mariah sucks dick

  • This is shit compared to Phil Collins. Mariah sings it with half the passion as Phil Collins!!

  • Esta cancion es tan hermosa!!!!

  • Great.

  • Great.

  • wow! best voice!

  • @ PandaBear2700

    just as an FYI George Straight has had 57 #1 singles...just figured id throw that out there...

  • @theREALxSpinZx No he has not. I don't even know who that is.

  • Mariah Carrey is a great singer, but I like Phil Collins' version much better.

  • i like the song by her but why do everyone think its her song when it was Phil Collins song . Mariah Carey just did a cover of the song.

  • u know what mariah voice is very emtional she is sing this song her own style i love

  • love 3:00

  • Comment removed

  • FAIL. Only dumb fucks can possibly like this version. But the world is full of dumshits,so, very possible

  • awesome song

  • thumbs up if youll listen to this in 2012

  • @imQreative Id listen to this in 20FOREVER... :)

  • She's so so so beautiful. The most beautiful female singler in the entire world!!!!!!!!!!

  • She is PERFECT.

  • i'd much rather listen to phil collins sing it. she has a nice voice, but phil just seem's to put more of his sould into it

  • My God woman! Always giving me chills.

  • 4 WORD : SHE IS A LEGEND

  • I LOVE THE DRUMS....AND MARIAH VOICE ...

  • Mariah, ima let you finish, but Gavin Degraw does the best cover of this song of all timez

  • wow  amazing

  • OH MY GOSH I FREAKING LOVE THIS SONG AND IT WAS UPLOADED ON MY BIRTHDAY I FEEL SPECIAL ♥ I LOVE MC !!! :D

  • Mariah carey's voice - A m a z i n g :)

  • @BrokenxStrings she suck's! 

  • @naughtyvalues If you seriously believe that then why are you wasting your time looking up one of her videos and going onto it? Pretty sad if you ask me....

  • @BrokenxStrings cause i happen to like some of her music.. just didn't like the cover she did to this song!

  • @naughtyvalues Yo0u could fool me, the way your mouthing off about her, you cant seriously be a fan.

  • @BrokenxStrings I didn't like her cover of aginst all odds, When she did the cover for without you (by nilsson), i thought she did a great job, but i was truly disappointed with this one!

  • nyak..bkit 1st si regine

  • Great!

    1. Regine Velasquez

    2. Celine Dion

    3. Mariah Carey <-------

  • @dddiiiooonnn11 who is regine ??? is she a new singer

  • i cant imagine how she sung wonderfully and blessfully.... she has the power to sing, its such a thrill.i love her songs so much..godbless you always mariah carey..

  • @totskiebau god didn't bless her, the devil did!

  • being brought up on this woman, and being biracial myself... only ever seeing HER and thinking "thats the only person on TV I look like" (Even when everyone ELSE thought she was whittee) .... omg... shes such a part of who i am.. theres not one breakup I havent sat listening to HER (who can write better lyrics with such ease and truth behind them).... uhhh... I feel like I owe her my "sanity" at times. But HEY.. whatareyagonnado..

  • @MemyselfniLK She doesn't write her own lyrics you fucking donut

  • @Banuel oo"BANUEL" first of all you're talking to someone whos currently in artist development with U. MOTOWN so only donut thing about me is the free ones im eating in 4 star hotels in manhattan for free, um so "BANUEL" I just wanna say this and then you u can go suck on 1 or sounds like maybe eat.. hungry?? r u some jealous fat person?hm..FIRST OF ALL to make it fast search Songwritter and Mariah Carey LOL K. we <3 Walter Afanasieff too.yea soo MC=BMI songwriter of the year 2 times. HA!*muah*

  • @Banuel Mariah Carey has written every single song she's ever released, besides the cover versions.

  • @BigBlyeEyes1234 No! she has a hand full of songs that she copied! ever heard of without you? she copied it in 1994, thats what she does best!

  • @naughtyvalues Yes, they're cover versions, which I clearly accounted for... 'Mariah Carey has written every single song she's ever released, besides the cover versions'.

  • @naughtyvalues All of Mariah's 18 number 1's were written by her.

  • @BigBlyeEyes1234 . don't care, she killed this song!

  • @naughtyvalues Your opinion. Phil Collins himself said he loves Mariah and her version of the song.

  • @BigBlyeEyes1234 he was just being nice! that's his way, he's kind to everyone!

  • I happen to like her myself! I jerk off to her poster all the time when i was in middle school, 

  • Comment removed

  • @BigBlyeEyes1234 See the thing about that, many times the original artist will normally not like the cover because it's their original song, now if the original artist says that don't like a cover they will come across as arrogant that their version is the only good version. When an artist is asked about such a thing they almost have to say that they love the cover because they don't want to seem like an a-whole.

    I personally didn't hate nor like the cover. It was ok in my opinion.

  • @tfast210 Phil has stated his love of Mariah a few times though. Even when she did that dreadful cover of Bringin' On The Heartache, he defended her against fans that critised it.

  • @BigBlyeEyes1234 That is true but you still really never know. I can't see Phil lying about that and assume he is truthful and sincere about his statements. I am just kind of stating generally that the original artist more times than not feels obligated to make positive feedback about a cover for various reasons that I stated, otherwise they will probably face harsh criticism for making negative statements...

  • WOW WOW WOW Just perfect

  • LOVE THIS PERFORMANCE :)))

  • Wow! Goosebumps....

  • what a beautiful song

  • i wish i cud sing..

  • Damn, she pulled this off note perfect.

  • I Love you From the Bototm of my Heart..CRT forever.. The best singer on the entire Planet.. and #1 singer and hero in my heart, even past the end of time CRT forever

  • she's so fucking beautiful. it's like watching a barbie doll sing, and sing like a motherfucker.

  • perfect perfect perfect

    

  • @AndrewJamesYo it suck's ass. much like her

  • @naughtyvalues no, you

  • @AndrewJamesYo I don't think so!

  • @naughtyvalues i win.. lol

  • @AndrewJamesYo how do you? she still sucks! and your picking a fright with a 14yr old

  • @naughtyvalues im pretty sure ur the one picking the fight. lol.. But Ill bow out.

  • i love her version. i tried to give this song my own spin acapella, please take a look if you get a chance!

  • very good, but Phil do much better!

  • very good, but Phil do much better!

  • AWESOME JOB,AM SURE PHIL WOULD SAY THE SAME

  • MARIAH CAREY!

  • @DanielAvilaAGT SUCKS ASS!

  • All I can do is watch this video and feel like I've lost my greatest love, besides my children. I miss You, Angie...

  • 02:45 omfg ... never got so many chills in one moment

  • Will someone put this female out my misery. I cant bear it when she gets over excited-its so unnecessary.

  • 叫艾Bitch過來這裡看看吧,這才叫唱歌好嗎!妳唱那什麼東西­阿。爛透了!

  • @pili78919 說的太好了!! 完全贊同 真不知台灣評審到底有沒有聽過原版呢!

  • @pili78919

    像MARIAH CAREY一樣就不用參加什麼比賽了!

    偏激個屁!

  • Your the only one who really knew me at all

  • the high note at the end is a backing track... i think that's the only part she lipped, and with a high F/ F#, I don't blame her a bit!

  • @singadude1983 i can hit a high F# lol falsetto cuz i have bawls :P

  • @atreyujuggalo666 rofl... ditto

  • this is such a great performance. and this song itself is timeless. i tried to give it my own spin acapella, please take a look if you get a chance!

  • Just take a look at.... Original Phil Collins version and cry Mariah...

  • i loooveeee!! this song sooo bad ^^

  • she seems so dead...like she just doesn't care. The flourish at the end does not warrent the crowd response.

  • Please MC turn 90s back , we really miss that times

  • LOVE the last humming part. beautifull.

  • RIP JOEY I WILL MISS YOU TILL WE MEET AGAIN ILL NEVER FORGET....

  • Comment removed

  • good song

  • No puede ser que esta mujer cante esta canción, déjensela a Phil Collins, deveria ir a prisión.

  • worst lipping ever. i do love mariah so much but at the end when she's flapping her arms it's cringeworthy!!

  • @HmNoClue this is clearly, clearly not lipped

  • I'll say this - if Phil Collins had never sung "Against All Odds" and Mariah's version were the only version there was, I'd give her performance two thumbs up...but Phil Collins is a tough artist to outperform - he's one of the best singers of all time. So while Mariah does a fine job, I've gotta give "top props" to PC.