Added: 5 years ago
From: saturnslament
Views: 64,740
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (265)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I feel so enchant everytime I hera Emilie playing the violin or piano without her bloody crumpets.Maybe because I like her more without her Bloody crumpets...

  • cool :-) :-)

  • Billy Corgan! Fuck Yess :))

  • It's so weird seening Emilie with her hair down and not alot of makeup and glitter. Still lovely, either way!

  • I love the way Billy always looks like somebody just dug him up from the grave.

  • This would be much better as an instrumental.

  • anyone who disses on billy is a fucking idiot. He was just singing a christmas song for his hometown.

  • i bet the undertaker that corgan stole his suit from is pretty pissed!

  • billy corgan fucking sucks!!! -_- i hate what he did to emilie.

  • @wolvez2 Finally someone who feels the way I do about that prick.

  • Comment removed

  • why does it always have to be about whos better then who? why can't people just enjoy music for what it is... music.

  • Man, I hate this fucking Lex Luthor! D:

  • The string emsemble make this piece

  • @xXprettyxkittyXx We don't want to be "underground" (that's cool for Pavement fans) as you're not goth just because your nickname has some "Xx" and listen to a girl with a heavy makeup and a green hair.

  • @saturnslament Yeah. I made this account back when I was 11 and I thought X's were cool.... Plus, I don't know any musicians who have green hair and heavy makeup. Nice try but your argument has just been ruled void.

  • @xXprettyxkittyXx Oh, no "green" hair? What a fail huh? It suppose to be "heavy makeup and a not-natural-hair-color". Now you know someone? Yeah, I know it's hard, cause there's a milian chicks out there like that just to be "different" and excentric...

  • @saturnslament There's no such thing as individuality anymore. Don't you think I know that? Hence my comment about effing Billy Corgan. Every person I've ever met who has like him/Smashing Pumpkins has thought they were the coolest person EVAR. And to be honest, he's overrated. I haven't met on fan of his who thought his music was "deep" and "meaningful" and then tell me about how awesome Avril Lavigne is in all her cool "punkiness". U+You can talk about EA fans. But Billy's are no different.

  • @xXprettyxkittyXx Yeah, cause a creative man who has criated such a body of work, changed the music scenery, the way people listen to music, what was playing on the radio and yet sold millions around the globe is really like Avril Lavigne, and so their fans.

  • The musical arrangement was so beautiful that I think song would have been so much better without the vocals (no offense to Dennis or Billy). Maybe I am a bit biased as I adore Emilie and her violin, but I couldn't give a rat's(plague or otherwise) ass about the drama. I loved the Smashing Pumpkins music and I love Emilie Autumn's music; their personal lives are so not my business.

  • Dennis de Young sounds good, Billy Corgan not at all (sorry people) and Emilie and the other violinists( sorry I don't know your names ladies :O ) should get more attention indeed. Not only Emilie Autumn, but also the other violinists are completely ignored D:

  • @Romanee92 They should have thrown Dennis De Young off stage and let Billy Corgan fill this song with emotion and beauty like he always does. Dennis De Young has a corny and emotionless voice Billy Corgan cfould have did this a hundred-million better than that Dennis De Young guy.

  • they should have turned billy's mic up...Dennis' voice overshadows billy

  • Did she get Christmas confused with Halloween and dress for the latter?

  • @sanjuancb thats the way she always dresses

  • Ummm... Who the hell is Emilie Autumn?

  • @TheSPumpkin100 a singer and a outstanding violinist..she also dated billy corgan and was the violinist for courtney love

  • @chellywuzhere636 Oh, ok, thanks :)

  • @TheSPumpkin100 no problem :)

  • @davidthedfactor and by the way your poetry sucks your not worth a fucking .004th percent of Billy Corgans net worth! hahah thumbs up to that queer!

  • @geoff1424 lol see "i know where you sleep"

  • Comment removed

  • @guyanaboi122 It's a Christmas song not his song :P

  • Comment removed

  • he's one more dead composer.

  • yeah, Emilie saved the spectacle of those two !!!

    she deserves the centre stage!!

  • Damn, Corgan sings so flat. Dennis saved this so bad. And Emilie, too.

  • Who the hell is Billy Corgan!? Show me Emilie! lol :)

  • Comment removed

  • @xicedlovexoxo Emilie Autumn is a Musician, Poet, Violinist, Pianist, Singer, Writer, Model, Artist. Her Music is defined as a mix of Victorian and Industrial Music. she also plays the Electric Violin and even released an album named Laced/Unlaced, Laced including music with classical violin while Unlaced had song for Electric Violin. she also had a relationship with Billy Corgan, and designed some clothes for him.

    DOES THAT ANSWERS UR FUCKING QUESTION?

  • @Jazy1993 LOL. Epic! *claps*

  • @Jazy1993 epic win on the answering every ones question. i approve :D

  • I find it ironic that everyone is complaining about Emilie supposedly getting the shaft, yet the majority of the people making these comments make these remarks as if the other violinists and the cellist aren't there...

  • @serveandvolley24 that's true, I guess. but I think Emilie did a lot more [or helped] whatever with it all and wasn't exactly credited

  • The only way this sounds HALF good is because Emilie fucking Autumn

  • I love how Emilie stands out (love her outfit, btw). I love how concentrated she looks. She's so into the music. I love her!

    Corgan and DeYoung are awful as a duet, though!

  • oooh he's cute

  • I love how out of place Emilie Looks in the group of violinists :)

  • @MichelleElizabeth92 I know. She even toned her outfit down a bit and she STILL sticks out like a sore thumb.

  • Comment removed

  • @spikedylacid you know this is a traditional song, don't you?

  • i loooove how there are sooooo many shots of emilie there are when the focus is supposed to be on Billy Corgan& Dennis DeYoung

  • @saturnslament have u even heard emilie autumn's music?

  • @Jazy1993 Yes, I have.

  • Eh, gotta pay the bills too Emily? I don't hold it against you. Sounds like she saved their butts too by fixing the song in another video.... over night even.

    I just feel so bad for her. After all the help she was, they didn't promoter her at all... they just pushed her aside. Bastards.

  • Fuck this is so bad. Emilie is a Goddess as always, but, woooow. Those two men suck.

  • I love how everyone is dressed so formal cept for her, Go Emilie!

  • DeYoung is starting to look like Tony Bennett

  • If Billy was singing this on his own, it might have worked. But his voice corresponds terribly with DeYoung's. Emilie looks and sounds lovely. I don't think she's "on the side or anything", she's playing the violin with the rest of the musicians there. But all in all this is very strange for a Christmas performance!

  • Billy Corgan is cracking me up. He looks so awkward!

    And I love you Emilie! Two of my favorite people in the whole world. :)

  • ohh poor emilie..but beautiful as usual!my eyes are catched by her reeeed hair (:

  • Emilie <3

  • This is some serious WTF. The song, the voice, the suit Billy's wearing. I'd think it's a parody on Christmas songs if they weren't so damn serious. Only Emily retains some dignity in this flop.

  • I'm sure it was heard for Emilie to concentrate on the beautiful flow of her music with asshole Billy screeching in the background.

  • What year was this?

  • Being in the background really doesn't suit Emilie.She needs to be centre stage!

  • my thoughts exactly

  • Needs more Emilie *pouts* And she wasn't even mentioned. =C But it was still good.

  • I know that during the interview with DeYoung (after this performance), Billy Corgan at least mentions her as a contributing artist to his new album. And then they mention that she wrote the quartet's string arrangement overnight. She got a great round of applause. :)

  • Yes, heres is one of the futures Blodie Crumpets xD

    Emilie is so Greaaaat!

  • WTF how is billy singing like that

  • My favorite Christmas song. :D

    And I adore Emilie.

    So this has made me a rather happy camper. Lol

  • EA was excellent in this piece, funny how she wasn't even mentioned but she is way more tallented than Billy and Dennis.

  • thats weird!

  • Emilie's cellist there turns out to be Lady Joo Hee.

  • You can barely hear Billy at all :(

  • Billy Corgan should have played a guitar solo xD

  • wow, i didn't know Corgan had a voice that didn't come out of his congested nose.

  • Rofl!

  • this is starange.....

    poor Billy Corgan, he looks so miserable.

  • thanks for sharing, great video.

  • They forgot to mention EA! D=

  • Emilie Autumn *-*

  • Billy looks so uncomfortable

  • lol billy corgan reminds me of what characters looked like in the nightmare before christmas.

  • this brings me back to my child hood( im 14 so i mean when i was like 5) we had to sing this song at my private school( hated it/ the school)

    but ya emilie is very talented/ they should just stop singing and just let emilie play ;A)

  • Emilie outshines them all !! :)

  • You can't hear Billy sing at all, this sucks

  • You can hear Billy sing too much. That sucks. You can't hear enough of EA!!!

  • omg, i want EA's hair colour :D

  • EA rocks

  • 3:24 billy's best moment EVER

  • Absolute BS!!! EA barely gets credited!!! I like Smashing Pumpkins alright, but EA is like 10 times more amazing and unique!!!

  • Billy Corgan...

    This is just hilarious. I've never seen the poor guy look so akward. He doesn't have his guitar, so you can tell he doesn't really know what to do with his hands...he just kinda rocks back and forth a bit.

    It's adorable.

    Love Billy.

  • Wow, Emilie is great. When she performs, she's all I could look at. She's really beautiful, talented, and special. <3!

  • its sad she didn't get more exposure on this appearance. instead it closed with some crappy book he was promoting. he should have tried harder to promote her instead.

  • this is my favorite christ-mas carol, im disappointed that emilie is not singing, i would have liked to hear her sing this song

  • Emilie looks so pretty in her black dress...she outstands from the other violinist by her dress, violin and the way she plays :)

  • I KNOW!! i thought i was the only one to notice!i mean compare Emilie to the other two violinists!Please do...what do you see?

  • OMG I noticed too!!! xD She's defff more awesomerrr!!!

  • cant believe this guy from styx sang this shit !! he is a legend"""

  • lol, Emilie seems much more into this than the other violinists.

  • To all of you girls claiming Billy Corgan, yes THE Billy Corgan raped this girl, I need some serious back up. I have done research via the internet on this and have found NOTHING but claims on this video. And YES, I have read the lyrics to her stupid song and I do not see any line alluding to rape. Please enlighten me. Direct quotes would be best.

  • Unless youre talking about the one lyrics about the 'bed' where he 'ruined it all'.

    Anyways, interviews plz.

  • her book is coming out soon...she might say something there.  I'm not saying he raped her..and I'm not saying he didn't. I have no idea, so I can't say.

  • I don't actually know, but I'm pretty sure she was not raped by him. She was raped when she was very young. She had a full blown relationship with him.

  • I agree with you.

  • 'i know where you sleep' says it all. who knows what really happened, but i doubt she wrote it for no reason. must have done something.

  • Not too keen on this... Admittedly I only clicked as I saw Emilie's name, but I like some smashing pumpkins and the one song of Zwan I heard. Never knew about the stuff people are mentionning here and if it's true then I am ashamed to like something he's done (though I won't deny I do). However, do you all reeally believe Emilie would want her fans who she clearly has a connection with to get into serious trouble on her behalf, or even that she'd want him to have that happen to him at all?

  • There isn't enough words to descibe how mush I love Emilie. She's still herself even though she'd be getting weird looks from others... :D And she has a very odd coloured violin O_O

  • :s Surely its slanderous to say Billy Corgan would beat and rape EA . she was assaulted at a young age and im sure she would've reported it if he did . Obviously something bad happened between them but i doubt he raped her . Is there any proof of EA claiming this ?

  • ha, that's silly, billy looks like he doesn't want to be there.

    You look around, yeah, just normal people.. sing song yeah. and then, holy crap, red hair, stripy legs, wth? ...oh yeah, it's Emilie! :D

    I wonder what the other violinists thought of her.

    Personally i would prefer it as an instrumental, i cringed every time he sung star. oh, even better, get Emilie to sing instead (:

  • Ohhhhh the other violinists were completely jealous of her!!!!

  • I wonder if they realised how lucky they were to play beside her.

  • I wouldn't even be abel to play correctly standing that close to her!

  • I wouldn't even be able to BREATHE properly standing that close to her!

  • I would drop everything and worship her.

  • I think my brain would stop functioning completely and i'd fall in a heap at her feet... like..yeah.. astounded muffin clear up on aisle three.

  • lol...I might scare her out of the country

  • It's weird seeing Billy without a guitar in his hands lol.

    ..He should have just held one while he sang just to make the image look better.

    haha jk

    -This was a lovely performance.

  • Emilie just stands out from those other violinists! XD

    And everyone else in the room for that matter!

  • i love emilie's outfit :)

    she's so beautiful and talented <3

    i love her.

    and this is also one of my favourite christmas songs :D

  • i very much doubt billy would do that, and if he did, i'm sure there would be press coverage on that

  • Yay, Emilie o.o

  • how different voice on this video and the voice tecnique with the SP

  • billy corgan beat and raped a woman?

    umm... good bye billy's career i hope, and name, and face. i hope he's royally disgraced

  • why would billy corgan have to rape anyone? he could have sex with 2 billion fan girls. i havent heard or read anything about this alleged 'beating' and 'raping'. roflz

  • Comment removed

  • Rape is not about sexual attraction. It's about controlling and dominating another person to make yourself feel better. That's what makes it sick.

    and he had a relationship w/ Emily Autumn, who wrote the song "I Know Where You Sleep" about that. You can get a good idea of what their relationship was like from that.

  • does anyone know the story about EA and billy corgan? because ive heard a lot of different stories

  • Give EA credit! D<

    Well, kinda late for that, but still.

  • im sure he was trying but dennis de youngs voice drowns out bills

  • he looks like Jack Skellington here

  • Billy Corgan looks undead.

  • emilie had a relationship with billy in that years.

  • Why didn't Emilie get any credit for this? She was and as always been amazing.

  • STAH OF WANDAH STAH OF LIGHT

    His accent gets in the way so much.

  • It seems billy was not serious in singing the song. I hope he will sing more Christmas Carols with better effort next time, if he's willing to. However, danny de young and emille autumn are both really great!

  • where can i get this song?

  • I reiterate:

    Why do Emilie and her crew not get any credit?!

    Otherwise - grand. =)

  • pure genius.

    I hope as the holidays come nearer, we hear more christmas joy from Billy Corgan.

    A Smashing Pumpkins Christmas? Coming soon?

  • that was relly good i love the violen was played good by the girl in the red hair!1

  • you mean emilie autumn!!! she's so awesome her music is wonderful...

  • she IS emily autumn, she is classicly trained and can play many insterments, she can sing writes her own music, and she will charm you while creeping you out at the same time.

    I hear that she is a manic depressive and was raped as a child. But you know what they say madness masks true artistry.

    She also does crafts, and is very kind, how many musicians would stop the middle of a concert because a fan collapsed and personaly tend to them, Emily did.

  • I LOVE HER i went to see her live and she was so amazing!

  • this is so freaking strange!!! it's like a bad episode of "where are they now?"... jeeze

  • you sir, have the brains and artistic impression abilities of a rat turd.

  • :o What exactly did he do? :S

    i really need filling in here.

    If he did anything to hurt our wonderful emilie i'll help you with all your murderous plans!

  • They dated for a while, and he used to beat and rape her.

    I was horrified when I found out, it was terrible.

  • hell no, that's awful!! how could he?

    how did you find this out!?

  • I found out off another friend.

    Who kows everything there is to know about milie. literally.

    Well, ex, not friend I suppose :/

  • WHAT???

    that bald man?? was that b4 or after this? x

  • i met men like that. i am on your side and emilies.

  • No nice Emilie Autumn!

  • awkward

  • wtf? Em gets no credit?

  • 3:24 - 3:28 Billy Corgan's best 4 seconds ever.

  • Nice.

  • Bizarre! My favorite voice of all time (DeYoung) and my least favorite (Corgan)... but a nice performance. And I hope you all noticed Dennis' hair... the most convincing hairpiece in all of rock n roll! :)~

  • why didn't they show one of emilie's albums at the end? Her pictures are on them... people aren't that stupid that they wouldn't recognize the "girl playing violin" on an album cover. Poo

  • This is just too Werid!

  • Emilie looks beautiful here.

  • xD where are his fans on youtube xD I only read; Emilie's too good for him. "They don't even meantion her name". xD

    Who's the bigger artist then?

  • These guys are bastards they dont even mention Emily's name...thats the only reason im watching this stupid video!

  • In another clip that has been taken off of YouTube, after the performance they showed Billy Corgan mentioning Emilie, saying that she composed all of the string arrangements in one night and that she did an amazing job. It's simply another clip, and this one is just the performance.

  • Billy didnt do such a bad job,

    especially considering that this isnt his usual style.

    And of course, Emilie was magnificent ;]

    xx

  • Emilie Autumn should be singing instead of this

    Billy Corgan character. I don't like him that

    very much, Emilie Autumn is way better. Even

    though they are different genres of music. Aren't they?