Added: 3 years ago
From: ClassicManiac
Views: 339,927
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (354)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • floyd just cant be touched they where just years ahead of there time thats all..with electronica making its way into the us these days they are becoming even more popular becouse they laid the foundations for whats popular today..the music world would be hard to imagine without floyd these days

  • I dedicate this song to the girl that i like <3

  • @TheFloydGilmour No, I said that people that I knew, in 1980 never heard of pinkfloyd, all but a select few. Now every body I know knows who pink floyd is. I was wrong in my original post to say I was a fan before it was cool. Any time your a pinkfloyd fan is cool. It just seems like they are more popular now than they were then. At least in my neck of the woods.

  • Me hubiera gustado nacer en los años de pink floyd, me encantan pero ahora solo esta una moda patetica donde esta el reggaeton, la cumbia, los wachiturros y eso.

  • please don't confuse me </3 cuz yoU know I LOVE yoU!!

  • i would write a movie just so i could play this song in the credits.

  • truly genius.

  • @SurealBlurr. ...lol...I guess it was always cool to be a pinkfloyd fan. But when I first got into pinkfloyd in 1980, I was the only one from my school that ever heard of them. Of coarse I'm from the south, if that has anything to do with it. Now it seems like everybody likes them. Thats a good thing. I will always be a fan :-). Peace out my freind.

  • I love it! ...I was a fan since before it was cool to be a pinkfloyd fan.

  • @jimijakjones99 since when was it not 'cool' to be a pink floyd fan?

  • @jimijakjones99 Hipster... and are you saying that it was un cool to like floyd before 1980, their peak was 1973 with dark side

  • Nick Mason linked to this on twitter, haha

  • those who dislike have declared themselves tone-deaf.

  • stop talking bout just bieber here ffs!

    let's just listen to that master piece

  • Today problem is not Justin Bieber, but those techno music.

    How could someone call that music?

    Music is not made by some computer program it is made fro your heart and feelings!

    Pink Floyd Forever

  • @Dealer486 dude i think you are kinda wrong... creativity is not narrowed just in one kind of music! electronic music can be very nice and create really strong emotions and specific songs need some serious skills to be made! so yeah the problem is not the kind of music it's the merchandising of music! think about it ;)

  • I wonder what 17 j.bieber fans were doing hearing real music?

  • Comment removed

  • thanks for the upload!

  • woww!!

  • Dislike any Floyd song and you are destined for hell!!!

  • @Z00T3D1 Fanboy detected.

  • Long Live Roger Waters

    

  • @ThePFloyd65

    And David Gilmour, too, of course. And Nick Mason.

  • easiest and best song i know on guitar

  • Classic!!

  • you did good looping this again and again

  • I've fallen in love...with this music piece

  • this song echoes through my heart mind and soul. reminds me that life isn't easy so don't be hard on yourself ..& don't worry just be happy :)

  • A minor will always be my favourite chord after hearing this song.

  • Pink Floyd is one of those bands that I can say I've enjoyed them since my dad showed me them... from the first song I've listened to, they touched my soul..... Music like this should be around today.... <3

  • Touch me deep inside.

  • Comment removed

  • π + 3, 8 -->

  • try to feel every moment of the music.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • he used to play this song to me :) i miss you.

  • 299 , 92

  • the guitar is pretty hard to learn

  • @TheHankypanky32 kind of...if you can play a minor, easy f and c, you can learn it too!

  • The guitarrs in the beginning is awesome.

    I love this song.

    The Dark Side Of The Moon is the best ever

    .

  • @hellnowayman this is The Wall

  • @hellnowayman fail. typical pink floyd poser fan

  • @hellnowayman wat

    This is The Wall

    try harder

  • when i hear this song I fotget for a sceond that the life's shit

  • Great repetitious extraction of this song, I love any and all aspects of Pink Floyd.

  • Pink Floyd <3

  • These songs are just hitting my soul!

  • check out my version, just visit my channel:)

  • Is there anybetter song out there?

  • @crookhunter haha, that made me laugh, nice comment, man :)

  • AWESOME, NOW I DON´T HAVE TO PUT IT IN REPEAT SO MANY TIMES. THIS SHIT REALLY HITS YOU STRONGLY IF YOU ARE FEELING ALONE. IF YOU´RE NOT IN THE MOOD... IT´S STILL AWESOME !

  • amazing ,,,,

  • get back pink floyyyd !! plz sbscribe 2 my chanel and i'll do the same things for you

  • classic

    

  • irgendwie so endgültig...

  • He is simply wrong ... there is someone out there, and all of us know it. It; however, is up to each one to accept and believe reality. Mushrooms, lysergic acid, and all other chemicals, naturally occuring and synthetic, will not hide the simple truth ... please, call upon your Creator for truth ...

  • @timblue238

    By 'creator' you mean what, my dad?

  • so happy some one else has looped it..

  • A person where i work killed himself, the last thing he did was posting this song on his blog. Very sad.

  • superb . classicmaniac/Mastersof guitar - in this adaptation , you are holding reigns of real music Power. V Good period .

  • Such a sad song... but the chord progression gives me a sense of hope, and that better days are to come.

  • So...this is just the same song played over more than once. Right? I don't think PF originally recorded it like this.

  • canT stop listening ,

    again and again, more and more and so on..

  • great song to blaze up to and relax after work

  • put on your slippers

  • Ich liebe Pink Floyd Music über alles . Ein Leben ohne diese Music kann ich mir einfach nicht vorstellen .

  • where the fuck is the song son of a bitch

  • @bigjoel254 turn on your speakers son.

  • Very clever.... well done... I converted it to MP3 to use as a filler on a mix disc or something... thanx...

  • Comment removed

  • This is making me feeling relaxed .

    Pink floyd for life !

  • nicely done mate! Beautiful

  • James Bond <3 Pink Floyd are the greatest & although this piece is original it does sound very similar to james bond theme tune, just slowed down

  • do you ever get in those estranged moods where life and everything around you seems so peculiar? i do believe, it is in these moods, where i feel most at home, while i sit here and listen to The Wall, and realize in myself, i've built my own wall, and in perfect isolation, am comfortable behind it.

  • @unknownsilenceband What you just said is so catchy, so cliche, but somewhat so true...+1 from me

  • @unknownsilenceband - achtung ! doing too much of that my friend

  • I shudder every time I hear it!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • RIP Richard and Syd!

  • epic

  • 14 peolple are out threre...

  • @Migashbk god your stupid. just listen to the fucking music

  • @unknownsilenceband

    fucking violent -.-'... chill...

    

  • A very beautiful musical piece.

  • how can somebody get it over his heart and push the not like button, ok, its looped, still a masterpiece! the simplicity and strength is unbelievable!

  • excellent version! it is of music that never you wish that it finishes, congratulations by so good work =)

    excelente version!!! es de la musica que nunca deseas que termine, felicidades por tan buen trabajo =)

  • Great job! i love that track but that long? cant even imagine how awesome.

  • within the middle of where the magnificient happens all the time, it is not true or lets say, a kind of miracle, may be looks like a smile on a baby's face, when the time comes & the buss to the neverland, arrives, may be it just looks like to the face of death. but when the time comes, I am sure, we all feel the same, so, my friends, lets propose a toast, for the whom, lives underground and never withness to the dark side of the sun, is the place, where no love exists at all,
  • @yemreyen well put!

  • Ahhhh....the memories. One of my favorite movies ever.

  • magnificent job!!!!! I always get annoyed when this part of the song ends!!!

  • anyone who couldnt like this has no ear for music,its just classic guitar

  • So I love this looped version and want to know how I can get it transferred onto my iPod or iPhone. Any suggestions?

  • @bathswife.. Youtube MP3 converter my friend, just google it and you'll find one. (:

  • i love this song but it's make me sleepy :D

  • perfect loop =) good job

  • @iball78217 and that reason would be?

    

  • The album had so much crap on it, I think. Yeah, I know, it tied the story together, but I'd much rather they'd just leave that stuff off, so stuff like this, and the longer version of Empty Spaces would fit. :)

  • I LOVE THIS SONG!

  • Geometria. Perfezione. Follia.

  • It always makes me shiver...

  • wgaule: seriously? He was obviously just trying it out, and personally I like it. So go off and troll some bad music, not good music, thanks.

  • You shouldn't mess with this stuff. You're not really extending it because in a long version there would be nuances of difference between the repeated parts. The song is a classic, maybe they should have made it longer but they didn't and you have to respect that!

  • @wgaule Or he can do as he pleases and you can go listen to the original if you want. Problem solved.

  • @IHaveAPodXTLive Yeah, he can do as he pleases, as we all can; but by posting it on youtube he is putting it out there and so I can comment on it as I please etc. etc. And I didn't listen to it, as the very idea of it sucks.

  • There is a reason why it's short.

  • @BugsBunny3D what reason?

  • Thank you !!!

  • muy denso.. acuerdense que ellos son PERFECTOS, por algo lo hicieron tan corto...

  • it's still amazing! i HATE David for not making it longer :/ can you plzz put it up for download?

  • I like the extended version here great job on the loop nicely done.

  • FINALLY SOMEONE DID THISSSS!!!!

    THANK YOUUUUU

  • Magique. <3

    

  • son musicas asi por las que el mundo evoluciono completamente en lo que representa el rock..... pink floyd los reyes del genero....

  • ALL guitar parts in Pink Floyd were played by the great David Gilmour. this one included

  • @baladin30 said:"ALL guitar parts in Pink Floyd were played by the great David Gilmour. this one included" What about the gtr parts played by Syd Barrett? Or the many acoustic parts that are played by Waters? As for this song, Gilmour said in interviews that he tried to play it and was not satisfied with the results."I could play it with a leather pick but couldn't play it properly fingerstyle" A studio musician named Ron DiBlasi was brought in for the recording.That's him playing on The Wall

  • @kyropter  - interesting . thx

  • @baladin30 - i agree 100% (without knowing for sure) - its the little accents that make me agree with u m8

  • thumbs up if you think this video's URL ending with 'kud0' is not a coincidence. youtube knows good music.

  • I've always loved this piece, and always thought it was too short. You did a really nice job looping it to extend the length.

    In the course of looking for this on YouTube, I only recently found out it's not David Gilmour playing on the original. Odd that I felt disappointed to learn that.

  • @kyropter well then is it roger? who is it?

  • I'm playing this live with 2 violins in a couple of weeks... such an excellent track... such a wicked album

  • I only wish this played on a longer loop. When I hear this, I want to look out into the expanse of the Old West and just think.

  • I wish it was looped forever in my head.

  • this song creeps me out.

  • 12 ppl are not out there

  • @FredWeasley88 Real original comment using the # of people who disliked the song in your post like everyone else does.. YT has got to start testing idiots like you and the 10 lemmings who agreed with you. YT has been taken over by Justin Bieber and Lady Gagme noobs posting strictly for ratings. Pathetic

  • @crookhunter well if you want to invoke the greater powers of YT against what you perceive as lesser beings, first you need to analyse what makes ur own comment so original and special to avoid failing the YT testing you're calling for. Who is Lady Gagme btw?

  • I love when people 1st discover Pink!

  • bellissimo

    

  • Oh my god....finally, i don't have to count the 7 "Is there anybody out there", just to hear the solo!!!!

  • it's amazing how a simple chord progression can be so beautiful! i'm glad i know how to play this :')

  • @2010NKC Yeah this song is REALLY easy to play but so beautiful :P

  • @PhilGerb93 The most simple music is usualy the best.

  • @PhilGerb93 it depends... if you play it with alternate picking, it's harder. And that's the original.

  • @zoltanszogyenyi Yeah it's harder but still easy.

  • Awesome!

  • this is more refreshing than a pitcher of cold lemonade on a summer day

  • Why wont u accept video responses for this song from genuine Pink Floyd fans,u have no rights to this song and i think its a total disgrace.Give someone a uniform and they think they're Hitler all right.Your a joke.

  • how can someone dislike this music :(

  • @MyMaverick87 it's impossibleeeeeeeeeee

  • Comment removed

  • I wish this song would last forever :)

  • thanks for making this

  • its so wonderfull... made from god :)

  • Man i always said that this song should be way longer!!! that it was just too short for its goodness. It can get a little repetitive after 3 mins tho. But i understand ur need to have this song playing for more time :p

  • Thumbs up if Roger Waters is sitting beneath a lamp post in the middle of no-where in your mind too.

  • listen it when you're hiiiiiiiigh

  • This goes perfectly with a hd minecraft sunset

  • There should be a law allowing the whole entire world to hear this masterpiece. It may even be able to create and establish world wide peace (WWP). Does anybody know where I can find the longer version? ha-ha . . thnx I'm gonna play it again.

    I will ...

  • perfection!

  • Excellent song, but who wrote it? was it Bob Ezrin on the understanding that waters would recieve credit?

  • lol this is the only part of this song that I like! Whenever I listen to it on my ipod, I always skip to this part :]

  • @MortalKombat773 You do realise this is the whole song, just looped a few times right?

  • @coast3dg3 Yes I realized that. I'd think you would realize that since I said I listened to this part on my iPod all the time.

  • @MortalKombat773 I mean to say that you havn't specified 'this part' so I don't know if you mean a small section of the song or the whole song

  • Comment removed

  • @coast3dg3 Did you want me to say I listen to this one minute and twenty three second version that is on my ipod, but I have to skip half of the song to get to it? Is that more acceptable for you?

  • @MortalKombat773 Yes. Yes it would.

  • @coast3dg3 Alright then, whatever you say.

  • i swear i've heard this in a movie before. anyone know what movie might have had this in it? wikipedia only talks about it in tv shows...

  • @eliaspman The Wall was originally a movie before it became an album. Miniscle dialogue and all the songs now in The Wall album, you would have heard it there if you've seen the movie.

  • i picked up guitar lessons yesterday just to play this song. he's like super good lol he can play metallica w/o even thinking! but i doubt i'll ever make this song as beautiful as these guys

  • Hauntingly beautiful~ Pink Floyd is the best band ever. Period.

  • Now that i found this i can finally listen to some quiet music while i work, a amazing solo. Thank you ClassicManiac for this song!

  • type in the word 'repeat' in the url address between 'youtube' and '.com' it works so well with this song. Thumbs this up so everyone can see!

  • @MrHarrybongo I didnt know that.. Thanks alot mate. :) Now I can listen to songs non-stop!