Added: 3 years ago
From: marygracia
Views: 274,797
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (3,007)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • pareho naman silang magaling eh..no need to compare..bakit kailangan pag pag-awayan kung sino magaling. at isa pa ibat ibang style sila...si charice maganda boses nya at feel na feel..si charice may pinakamagandang low notes sa buong mundo. kaya nyang kumanta ng kanta na puro low notes lang na super super low notes. si regine magaling din its about technical sa pag-awit...maganda ang quality ng boses ni charice...yung boses nya pang international. kaya wag na kayo mag-away be proud of them.

  • Ok. In my opinion Charice's better, because she actually has larger vocal range. She could hit those high notes, and she succeeds hitting pretty low ones. Regine can't go that low. What about voice control... Hm, I don't think Regine has a better one. This aspect is not perfect neither with Regine nor Charice. Following my heart, I can immediately conclude that Charice is better here, but considering all the facts above I can definetely state that they're almost equal.

  • mas mataas ang key ni regine a5 kay charice either f#5 or f5 lng

  • im a reginian but i also like charice infact i am very proud of all her achivements and please dont compare this two amazing talent pag sisimulan lng to ng hindi magandang relasyon sa pagitan ng mga reginian at mga fans ni charice chasters ba yun?correct me if im wrong ha? lets all be proud kasi sila ang patunay na magagaling tyong mga pinoy sa kantahan.

  • I love charice in some aspects but comparing the two, Obviously its REGINE!!!

  • don't fight about it! they're both amazing singers! love it all!

  • those of you are correct regine is one of the best singer that control her voice from low to high.i considered regine velasquez is the best singer in the philippines

  • it's not about hitting high notes lng nmn.. importante din ang voice quality.. voice control.. diff. techniques.. diction.. etc hehe

  • @lebehsej I agree. And Regine is the best in terms of vocal control from low to high register enabling her to produce a consistent and appropriate sound for any genre of songs she chooses to sing. Her technique is also flawless that's why she is still considered as the voice to beat up to now.

  • LOOK AT THE SUSTAIN ! REGINES STILL THE BEST !!

  • REGINE IS STILL THE BEST AND ACTUALLY HAVINT THE HIGHEST KEY OF HIGHER !!! THAT'S THE REALITY !!!

  • Regine is the Best...prang wlang khirap hirap pra kay ate Reg... cmula noon hanggang Ngayon, Regine is the Queen..... The Ultimate Singer and the Asia`s Songbird.

  • MAS MATAAS NGA KEY NI REGINE DITO...

  • i love them both they are extraordinaire....

  • regs. 100000x better

  • they are both good...

  • @GeorgeHB05 hindi po siya flat. for a singer dapat alam mo that she accessed the right notes in this video clip.

  • they're both great

    i love them both

  • all you guys are filipino! why can't you love and support our own race? and let's be proud of them!

  • all you guys are filipino! why can't you love and support our own race? and let's be proud of them!

  • regine sound like a black american on the highnote part! she level up with patti labelle! alright!

  • ang hina nga ng kay charice! everytme na g5 na eh hirap n hirap na xa at wala ng power!

  • @GeorgeHB05 actually tama ang observation niya. in this particular video clip charice higher part sounded weak. hindi na nga halos marinig. regine sustained the note with more power and with vibrato. sana bago ka mamula ng ibang post alam mo rin ang sinasabi mo.

  • @GeorgeHB05 if I may ask what is charice own style? something that separate her from other singers? surely its not the birit, nor the flair, nor the tone. they both made it OUTSIDE philippines. Cha - US based but is YET to achieve a platinum award there. regine - Asia-based with multiplatinum success under her belt.

    Even if the video is of LowQuality you can easily conclude if one is singing powerfully, struggling, mixing or not. And if you are a SINGER as you claimed, you should know that.

  • ang hina nga ng kay charice! 

  • parang black american si regine sa kanto na to.. loved both Charice and Regine...

  • REGINE is the Queen of all divas...

  • Regine's vocal range has by far been superior to other singers for more than twenty years. Very unbelievable.

  • @mgainggitkaycharice okay so you say she has a problem on low register does that mean she can't do it then, but don't get me wrong I love what Charice has accomplished, I love her on little big star, I love her then and now, but let me ask you this why are filipina singers not that appreciated without their ability to belt out songs, if Regine is the answer then prove me wrong.

  • they are both magaling but if professionalism ang pag kukumpara bagohan palang si charice kaysa kay regine. Regine is one of a kind diva, lahat ng offer sa Hollywood hindi niya tinanggap because of her fam and friend.. Kahit na masasabi na si charice ay sikat na internationally, hindi parin dapat siya i pantay kay regine, magaling sila and I am proud filipino dahil sakanila, so no away2 na bate2 na lang, i am a huge fan of reg and cha.. but we must think deeply, before tayo mag comment.. ok? mua

  • @lenlenpark mas makapal boses ni charice. if u prefer than kind of voice siempre sasabihin mong mas me feeling niya. regine's voice especially live functions like a violin, it is sweeter and fierce at the same time. if u talk of delivery who can beat regine's legato, breathing, vocal technique and dynamics? I dun think you know regine's voice to say na puro high notes lang siya. Its just an impression that some wants to believe just to justify reg's superiority in that department.

  • @lenlenpark dont worry. im a fan of both. juz feel too indebted to regine not to speak on the technical and emotive aspect of her voice. goosebumps be damned but her voice kept me afloat for many years now even if I am also supporting charice.

  • why not supporting regine its a beutiful voice

  • natatawa ako sa mga nagsasabing boses lata si RV. halatang mga walang alam sa sounds. me masabi lang. its quite evident here whos in control and did sustained and accessed each notes with ease while maintaining the same intensity as she ascends higher.

  • @Pabs145 lol! its obvious naman na yung kay cha, numipis ang boses, halos di na marinig. yung kay regine mas solid, mas sustained at namaintain ang intensity ng tone at such range. baka ikaw ang walang tenga. lol

  • @BackOffLoser1 hah? what are you talking about? lol! not all songs starts from lower to higher notes if thats what you mean just as not all songs starts from piano to forte. it all depends on the purpose of the interpreter. a singer may even have more than 2 versions of the song depending on the theme or intended audience. :D

  • ngo-ngo ba c regine di maintindihan ung words nya...c charice clear na clear

  • winner Regine! Why? Beacuse She is one note higher than Charice.Second Regine has G5 sustained! While Charice did not sustained I think F# and that's the most difficult part in a vocalist, in a extreme high notes to sustained.Thirdly, Regine has a vibrato & Charice donot have....OK!

  • regine ..

  • Regine, no one else.

  • in my own opinion the song bird won in this round! she belted more higher! its so amazin. REGINE is still the DIVA!

  • tama ka dyan...

  • mahirap bang tangapin na grabe ung ginawa ni regine d2 lampaso inapakan pa sa ulo c charice d2 walang awa ung gumawa nito halata namn kung anu ung nakakabilib d2 bobo nlang boboto kay charice ulo d2

  • it's hard to listen to regine belting.. hurts the ears....

  • parang nag-off key ata si regine...

  • Comment removed

  • ang panget ng boses ni regine,...ewwwwwwwwwwwwwwww nakakaloka!

  • mas ok yung kay Charice tama bwelo nya. nag start low note then dahan dahan nya itinataas

  • .im sorry but i really found that charice voice irritating and annoying.too overrated.she is such a poser.and that regine girl always seem to shout and scream in all her songs.not a good technique.

  • FALSETTO KAY REGINE! CHEST VOICE KAY CHARICE!

  • @mcronde08 FALSETTO?? R u insane? you dont know what your saying dear. Learn your music first before you comment REGINE is way higher than charice lets all admit it.. but i do love them both

  • @weheary0u sir/mam im a singer, and both me and my mentor know that regine hit the high note in Falsetto. just listen carefully please. and sir/mam. dont say words like insane to other people. respect others please.

  • @mcronde08 really huh?!?!?! so your a singer? where? in a caravan, for burial? falsetto is a vocal register that occupies frequency range just above the modal voice register and overlapping with it by approximately one octave., with its root term FALSE. It is really hard to believe that regine can execute that very high note with falsetto that might ruin her voice box. the reason why shes reaching that high notes because it coming from her powerful chest that made her THE VOICE TO BEAT!! :)

  • @mcronde08 bobo mu namn chest voice un pure pa binge kba????

  • @kidjcris maging edukado naman po tayo. sorry i got it wrong. :( wag naman magsabi ng mga masasamang salita sa kapwa.

  • @kidjcris parang perpekto kang tao para sabihin mong B@*@ ako. Diyos ka ba na perpekto para sabihin ang flaws ng iba. may flaws ka din naman di ba :(. kaya wag naman ganyan :(

  • @kidjcris sabihin mo ng maayos :(

  • __REGiNE

  • nagtaka pa kau bakit sya 25 years na... eto sample na nagpapahaba ng career nya...di naman disadvantage yung tanggihan nya ung int'l career kasi maraming consequences...but her craftmanship will be remained to the memories of those who has fully heard all of her performances

    /watch?v=gyqJ9LrPxj8

  • @naborghsoj08 oh i forgot...maraming nakakagusto kay regine na foreigners pag nirerevive nya mga male songs...usually mga humahanga sa kanya mga may edad na...mas credible nga sila eh...kasi ang new generation iba ang standards at talagang nagdegrade nang husto ang quality ng music sa America at syempre makikigaya ang mga pinoy...colonial mentality at ethnocentrism (sociology)

  • @naborghsoj08 tsaka may dynamics din sya kumanta di lang buga ng buga. may crescendo at decrescendo din sya...soft/piano, firm vibrato , staccato etc.... at napakalamig sa tainga ng soft toned voice nya na wala halos sa ibang singers...major advantage yun sa mga lalaki na gusto feminine voice not a pinoy pretending to sound like a negro ...

    /watch?v=nobXqUMtyOA

    /watch?v=kPa4QZAji2M

    /watch?v=QgjgbgOfeGk

    /watch?v=ypnXl7VQESM

    /watch?v=21VaqjGW9Fs

    /watch?v=x1ksQbXqxMY

  • PAREHAS CLANG MAGALING.......WAG NG PAGSABONGIN..PAREHAS NMAN NILANG NAPATUNAYAN NA MY NARATING N SILA..... MAYAMAN NA SILANG PAREHAS BY USING THEIR TALENT  ANG MASAMA NGA LANG NAGKAROON N NG "K" ANG IBANG TAO NA MAGSALITA NG MASAMA LABAN SA KANILA........

  • ok lang din yung kay charice... pero mahirap tlga tapatan ang kay regine.. wag mu na kcng gayahin charice si regine .. be original!! next time ahh

  • /watch?v=MilvM3Tkqy8

  • people can be dilussional sometimes just to satisfy their belief! keep believing that regine is better while she rots in philippine soil till she cant sing anymore!

  • @wornoutshoes11 WHOAAA YOU'RE DAMN RIGHT....SHE HAS BEEN HOWLING ANG YELLING FOR 40 YEARS AND SHE GOTTEN NOWHERE....CHECK ALL HER VIDEOS,NOT A SINGLE VIDEO REACHED 1 MILLION VIEWS...THAT'S A SIMPLE INDICATOR SHE IS A NOBODY.

  • Both were great and such a notes they can reach but if i were to choose who's the best between them both, i'll go for Regine Velasquez.. She's obviously sing higher pitches than Charice and no denying about it.. If you said Charice's notes is higher than Regine, then i guess you might be deaf or know nothing about notes.. lol.. anyway, salute to both!! =)

  • Whoever this Regine is she sounds like a banshee LOL.

  • regine!

  • @peoplethinker Plus Regine held the note and sustained, Trully the "Queen"

  • mas mataas ung kay regine...

  • NONSENSE GUMAGAWA NG VIDEO NATO.. NIREREPLAY2x PA. WALANG UTAK ANG GUMAWA. KAHIT ANO SABIHIN AT GAWIN NINYO CLA ANG KUMIKITA AT YUMAYAMAN. KAYONG MGA NANGHUHUSGA EWAN KO N LNG<

  • ang performances ni charice may universal appeal at patok sa mundo..while ang kay regine may specific na target para lang sa mga mahilig sa high notes....pero hindi un sukatan ng pagiigng great artist....dapat yung talent mo ay na appreciate ng buong mundo ...hindi lang pang pilipinas kundi pag mundo talaga....ika nga complete package si charice.....nandyan lahat ng elements para sumabak sa international scene....kay regine may specific target eh..mga baklang reginians na mahilig sa nota....

  • @LetsReview101 Legrande says Regine's technique is magificent, her natural sound angelic, her control extraordinary. McKnight agreed. Bryson Agreed. Cayabyab Agreed. Asia agreed when they gave her two multiplatinum albums.

    Then came Charice. Foster became her producer. They asked Oprah's help. The hype and full support of big names such as Dion, Degeneres, and Oprah were all on her. America listened to her. America has spoken. Her album flopped. Ironic for someone who has universal appeal.

  • regine parin!

  • regine's key is higher...

  • Comment removed

  • Your video is pathetic..

  • makaiba lang ng timbre.. mataas lang pakinggan kay regine kasi matinis yung boses n'ya tapos falsetto pa.. kay charice naman solid boses.. parehong magaling in their own way..

  • mas magaling si charice pero magaling din c reg but i think charice is much better tlga

  • i like regine's voice , but there is something in charice's voice that makes me wanna hear her singing all the time with any songs, it's the sound of charice's voice that i enjoy so much plus her endings of the songs. the way she delivers the songs as well....a lot of singers maybe reaching the high notes but that's not the only thing im enjoying but the sound of the voice plus delivery.

  • Comment removed

  • Charice did this note 10x better. No struggles and controlled

  • No comparison. Charice voice is powerfully controlled. Regine sounds like she's struggling and in pain. Chariceis the Clear Champion.

  • @botoiching oi.. hindi.. ah mganda lng ung kay charice kac mababa haha.!

    kay ate.reg mataas na maganda.. no..! ensin.. just hear a lot of what regine did.!

    in the history.!

  • Comment removed

  • pareho lang... charice sinunod lang niya ang original and regine had a diff. way of singing it.. but they both reach the note...

  • simple lang naman yan eh.. ilang taon na ba si regine.. at ilang taon lang ba si charice... atsaka, ang sakit sa tenga ang pagiging matining ni regine.. pwede pambasag salamin...

  • charice is world class while regine is just for phillipines

  • idol ko si regine but overall ts charice.. di lang sa taas at birit nasusukat... there's gotta be emotions too! charice got that part.. regine reyna ng birit, on top of it.. but charice,.. damn she is the next big thing

  • I choose charice, Regine sounded very shrill voice. This is very different with charice

  • anu yon! regine effortless! kaya nga hindi nagustuhan na e adopt ng mga kano kasi kulang sa emotion pag nag perform! kanta lng ng kanta c lola regine wlang emotion! kya pag sya ang kumanta, wla akong maramdaman kahit anong emotional ng kanta! hahaha! charice on top

  • charice is the best sing ever

  • nasa panahon lang po iyan. naranasan na din ni regine yung kasikatan na tinatamo ni charice dati. at ngayon patuloy nya itong napanghahawakan. si charice naman ay maswerte talaga at tunay din nmn na talentado. sana pagtanda ni charice, mapanghawakan niya pa din yung kasikatan niya at talento niya gaya ni regine. saludo ako sa dalawang yan! haha

  • close your eyes, listen to regine. parang hindi boses ng tao. hehehe. parang may isang bagay na ngcreate ng noise pag sa high notes na.

  • great pinoy ....

  • BROWN MONKEY LAOS!~~ PANG LOCAL LANG SYA PARA SA MGA PIPITSUGING SHOW SA PINAS...

  • @kunsensyanlHAISGAY1 SI REGINE LOCAL LANG ATLEAST NAABOT NYA ANG PINAKAMATAAS NA PWEDENG ABUTIN NG ISANG BABAENG SINGER DITO SA BANSA NATIN, NA CONQUER NA NYA ANG LAHAT movie,commercial,araneta concert,teledrama,beauty endorsementy..SARAH IS ON HER WAY,, si charice di nya kaya i conquer ang pilipinas, at kung sasabihin mong sikat si charice sa ibang bansa, SIKAT SA PAGIGING WHITNEY HOUSTON HAHA! mas sikat pa nga sa kanya sina demi lovato,selena gomez,miley cyrus, saka si jojo,, KAWAWA!

  • Regine!

  • ang galing talaga ni charice kaysa

    

  • Sino ang Bumirit? at Sino ang Umirit?

  • kahit ano pang comparison ang gagawin nyo si charice parin ang panalo.dahil siya lang ang naka pasok sa international stardome at naging no# 8 siya sa billboard top 100. she's the best. si regine si sarah hnd kilala ang mga yan hollywood.kaya maawa naman kayo. 'wag nyo nang ipilit. malayo na ang narating ni charice si sarah at regine malapit na maging lola dito parin sa pinas.haaaayyyyy.....stop it...

  • @dandin402 darling . its not the achievement.. hndi aman un ang issue dito eh... 

  • Charice is the best.

  • First of all.. i dont get what the big deal is... the did it both well.. they are both Filipinos.. bakit pinapagbangga nyu ang parehong south poles ng magnet?? kahit anung gawin nyung pag compare... magaling sila pareho... walang laban dito... mga talangka!

  • charice mas magaling. 

  • if your in the japan area dont miss american idol winner fantasia in Tokyo at billboard live jan 20-27

  • charice. . . . higher higher higher (SIGAW)

    regine. . . . . HIGHER HIGHER HIGHER! BELTED! EFFORTLESS. . .

  • sakit sa tenga ng voice ni regine... creating noise. mataas pero hindi pleasant sa ears...

  • charice: higher higher higher higher!!!!!!

    regine: haya haya haya hayaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa!!!!!

  • @liltemper21 haha! funny

  • ehehehe iba talaga c regine..

  • @dunyaOdunya ; at age of 40? sinong singer ang makakabirit ng gaya ni regine? may naiisip kaba? diba wala? natatangi lang si regine, tingnan natin si charice kapag umabot na xa ng 40, kung makakabirit parin xa.

  • mas magaling si regine at mas mahaba yung high notes nya, at mas mataas