Added: 4 years ago
From: umesang
Views: 211,224
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (211)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • 素晴らしい曲に仕上がってますね。重低音が効いていてスケール感­抜群です。ちょっとみなこちゃんが弱いかな~。でも、ガンバッテ­ルって感じ。

    この曲聴いてCDを購入しました。

  • HEy! Try LIBERA's version of Ave Maria

  • Not too shabby, my friend! The Universal reach of Cosmic music such as Caccini.

    This is a good introduction of our species to a first contact with other intelligent being so they know what kind of creative species they're dealing with!

  • very very amazing

    this is the greatest ave maria song i ever heard

  • In 2000 I listened to an Andrea Bocelli album with all versions of the Ave Maria on it, and found this one the best, and still do!

    I find this version a bit too 'light', although she has a lovely and special voice.

    Bocelli's ... watch?v=SqBJFDbE2ZI

  • SUMIがどうとか誰がいいとか、いちいちつまらんコメントがあ­るものですね。いちいち誰のほうがとか言って、自分が好きなほう­が上じゃなきゃ気が済まないんだなぁ。幼稚というのか頑迷という­ものなのか。。。。ちょっと許容できないものもあるとしても、本­田さんのは十分OKと思うけどね。

  • AMAZINGLY AMAZING !!!

  • Minako Honda who has died of leukemia. It is very wonderful to have the skill as a singer very much in Japan.

  • Beautiful!!! Theres so much emotion it almost brings me to tears. Bravo

  • Ethereal, unworldly voice... it makes you wonder if the singer is human or some kind of fairy...

  • Oh my god the composer of this song is just wow ! When I first heard it I was like ewwy but now I'm amazed! Good job !

  • Nice!! Especially the last is good.

  • Nice!! Especially the last is good.

  • i kinda like libera's tom cully version ...sorry im just saying the truth but dont worry you sang very well to just keep it up more...:D

  • I believe that. A lot of work during Soviet Era is miscredited to Western countries...I see that in science too.

  • I am a person born in Fukushima. This is very concerned that nuclear power plants. I do not worry about a second Chernobyl. At that time, Caccini Ave Maria for my heart is healing.

  • Such a beautiful, almost otherworldly voice, so soft yet so powerful, bringing a more modern mainstream slant on such a lovely piece. It is so sad that she is gone, yet another living piece of art lost to the world. May she rest in peace, I will always treasure this recording. Thank you so much for posting it!

  • Piękna kobieta,piękny głos i piękne wykonanie.BRAWO!!!

  • gorgous, r.i.p god bless you Minako

  • Didn't realise she had passed away :(

  • @theovanua yeah from leukemia

  • @AnimeLuver70 that's sad :(

  • Comment removed

  • Anyone know if there is an instrumental of this version :)

  • shit! i wanna cry.... :-(

  • 惜しい方だった。

    ご冥福をお祈りします。

  • Very beautiful

  • What a beautiful voice and music. A lovely rendition.

    I noticed all the haters and ''experts are on here too critising everyone and talking up their favourites, (as if anyone's interested) It must be torture for them, going around listening to the numerous artist they don't like, before passing their supreme judgement lol...Still I suppose it's a way for them to raise their own profile out of insignificance

  • whoa this song got ANIME'd!  I like this version. It reminds me of a dramatic manga like Death Note or The Demon Ororon.

  • r.i.p honda

  • I'm sorry if this sounds harsh, but she is evidently famous and will never read this. She's too breathy, her phrasing is all wrong and she sounds like a baby when she sings. Just not my style at all.

  • @flowersings breathy is prob the producers fault... trying to get some effect going on.

  • I like it's very cute and enchanting actually.

  • こんな凄いボーカリストとは?感動しました何回聴いても色あせな­い本物ですね・・・

    話とびますが この曲聴いた後の 名曲 「あの日のように / 矢沢永吉 」 は

    やっぱり本物・・・最高ですww

  • 本田美奈子.のクラシックナンバーからどれか一つを選べと言われ­たなら、私は躊躇せずにこれを推挽する。日本語詞も無論悪くはな­いのだが、クラシックはやはりスキャット。そして彼女のそれは、­さながらオーパーツにも似た神々しさで、聴き手を揺さぶり、忘我­の境地にさせる。

  • it sounds cute ~ but yet creepy at the same time... 

  • With this voice, she should not sing this song. It's a disgrace.  I just abhor average singer jumping on a popular songs or good music and ruin it.

  • @torius12 she has the rights to sing what she wants, stop judging on how people sing songs, it's getting stupid, i'm not that good at it but i don't give a crap, it's music just have fun with it.

  • @VanilleFF They just can't help themselves!...still who's interested? not me!

  • People are casting an opinion from a classical point of view. This is not in the classical styles. It's comtemporary and it's very good. This version captures the essence of the song and yet appeals to a new audience. Rewind and listen with "new" ears and spirit. Music is not exclusive.

  • sooo schhhööönnnnn

    *fast am heulen ist*

  • 有難うございました。久し振りに彼女の歌声を聴くことができまし­た。

    がんばりやの美奈子さん。きっと天国でも歌いつづけてるでしょう­ね。 安らかな微笑をイメージできました。

    

  • I really like this.

    she's not as bad as people r saying she is. While it's certainly not the best I've heard I wouldn't go as far as saying it's appalling...

    she actually has a very beautiful voice, but people are so used to the tone of the opera version, so this softer tone is a bit different than usual. Everybody sings differently...and I've heard much worse.

    I give her credit for still sounding beautiful...

    R.I.P.

  • Wooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oow :) gracias merci thanks origato

  • omg... she's really bad

  • Actually, I don't mind the arrangement so much. I actually rather like it. It could be nice with the right voice, but she just doesn't have the chops for this song. This is not to take any shots at her talent. She obviously was very talented and had a great career before succumbing to leukemia several years ago. RIP.

  • Horrible. I agree... No real emotion. The notes may be there, and even correct, but the sense of reverence and absolute adoration is absent for me. Sorry for harsh comments, but, the piece is originally so perfet, why should anyone want to do this to it?

  • interesting ....

  • so beautyful!!!!! I love it...... practicing this song too....

  • This is appauling.

  • @2ndstarr I am APPALLED at your spelling, but I agree completely with your comment on this... this... monstrosity!

  • @nielsjoklein lol

  • OMg, so addocting. It's like my medicine. Please, stop me, now im addicted. (but don't) beautiful intonation.

  • Beautiful voice of our Dearest Minako Honda. R.I.P.

  • Ave Maria miscredited to Caccini

    actually belongs to russian composer

    Vladimir Vavilov (1925-1973)

  • @ffmartin2925539

    Indeed !!!! Everybody name Ave Maria composed by Caccini. It is not.

    Ave Maria is a popular and much recorded aria by Vladimir Vavilov, generally misattributed to Giulio Caccini, and composed around 1970. Vavilov himself published and recorded it on the Melodiya label with the ascription to "Anonymous" in 1972.

    Cor Schorel

    Netherlands

  • @ffmartin2925539 Actually nobody is really sure. They found the identical music in the '30s, so as far as anyone knows, it could belong to me.

  • @ffmartin2925539 I don't think anybody thinks she actually composed it. Ave Maria is internationally known with many covers

  • @ffmartin2925539 Hahaha! That's a good one, RT!

  • i kind of prefer Sumi Jo's voice for this song. I like Libera too. (sorry, i know i'll get thumbs-downed pretty soon, just giving my opinion).

  • @ScientiaVeritasEtLux lol u got thumbed up instead dude ;)

    and i totally agree with you and the other 20 ppl who likes this xD

  • @ScientiaVeritasEtLux this is nice... but i agree Sumi's renditions (at least the 2 i've heard) is more to my taste as well.

  • @ScientiaVeritasEtLux ....i kinda agree with you i like more libera's version its more clearer and younger voice anf high to......

  • her voice is quite annoying at some parts...

  • beautiful thank you

  • it sounds cute ~

  • terrible le rytme et bon ton somme bien on n et envouter c ca supere

  • A beautiful version...

  • Comment removed

  • nice

  • GREAT!! I love it!!!

  • Sorry. Don't like it. Sounds like cheesy anime background music sung by a chipmunk. Theodore, I think.

  • so beau

    tyful!!!

  • Somebody link me the rock version of this song... please... oh and IMTHUO (in my totally hones and unbiased opinion) Carmen Monarcha's version is so much better...

  • Check out Jo Sumi.

    Much better

  • yes sumi jo sounds like some type of beautiful lol . this one sucks

  • 若い頃好きだった思い出があります。

    その後の彼女のご活躍をリアルタイムで感じれば良かったとちょっ­と後悔してしまうくらいに

    素敵な方でしたね。

    あらためてご冥福をお祈り致します。

  • 本当に天国で歌っているみたい。

    どうぞ安らかに。

  • Mesmerizing

  • Maria, please protect my daddy...take care of him...

  • To yo u daddy..u passed away 16 years ago...i was 11...to young to loose such a great dad like u....i miss u so much...Protect mum, mimi and help me every day..i m crying..i miss you too much..I LOVE U

  • Her voice is just as beautiful as her enchanting appearance.

  • Beautiful voice, beautiful girl. Sorry that she passed away too soon!!!

  • Parece una Virgen ... ¡¡ hermosa !!

  • CON ESA VOZ Y ESA CARA ES UNA AVE

  • how old is she?

  • If she lived, she becomes 42 years old

  • Очень хорошо!!! Благо ДАРЮ!

  • Dude please have the respect to at least be discreet about downloading mp3's. I would advice to buy the album from itunes or some paying site if you like it so much.

  • I can make it an .mp3 for you, if you'd like...

  • 彼女も、この曲を録音してたんですね。

    多少切実感がありますが、よくぞここまで属性を排しました。

    彼女の生き様を照らし合わせると、身につまされる思いです。

  • yup =)

  • Thanks to dominaxel for the kind response. There was more to Minako than she let on or even consciously knew. I was first impressed by the quality of her voice, then by her beauty, then by her ability to combine sensuality and wholesome goodness. Even before she sang opera and long before she became ill I recognized a deep spirituality in the background of her personal warmth and charm. As you say, more and more people are coming to realize the depth behind that charm and talent. Greg G.

  • For Minako this is a song about spirituality. For me, hearing her sing it and viewing images of the beauty she was as I listen, it is a song about the spirituality inherent to femininity. As a Buddhist I see her as the very embodiment of the bodhisattva Kannon. Those who appreciate her were lucky to have her here with us as long as we did. She still calls to us from the Pure and Joyous realm of the Buddha of Endless life. To hear her now is to hear the Buddha as well. Greg G. of Portland

  • Since long time , your coments are a faithful tribute to Minako Honda. Day after

    day, moving coments are increasing numbers from all the world. She becomes a

    symbol of universal brotherhood.Minako Honda , even in her most sad moments,

    is so sincere as person that there is no place for shade. Only bright impress

    remains of her . She is not only an artist, you'r right, she reveals a spiritual

    nature highly universal. Thank you Greg G. of Portland.

  • A different style. But it sound nice too.

  • The image of the woman who had died of sickness seems to have become an angel.

  • we love u Minako , we miss ya Minako.....

  • very enchanting! its beautiful

  • I love this version of ave maria I sing it all the time, no matter where I go

  • her voice is soft. i thought it was a great different interpretation

  • This is the story:

    Ave Maria, Caccini

    This is the dark one:

    written by a none

    just a sort of...

    Vladimir, Vavilov...

    Stars are quivering, Vlad.

    on your sound, there is no wound.

  • How come brilliant genius often pass away early?  It makes me want to know what on earld Gold is thinking about human lifespan.. RIP

  • this kinda reminds me of the anime full moon.... but with a sad ending :( and no romance

  • I'm Japanese. About 20 years ago, she was an idol and often appeared on TV. She was quite popular then. She died of leukaemia in 2005, when she was 38.Toward the end of her life she sang some classical songs. I believe this nideo is one of them. Too young,so sad.

  • Comment removed

  • 15 seconds into the video it says her name :p minako honda

  • Thank you, I'm sorry v.v

  • honda minako

    本田  美奈子

    What a lost :(

    A young talented vocalist. :(

  • zOOm

    :(

    Belíssimo...

  • Me gusto esta musica. Mucho gracias!!!

  • Absolutely beautiful, angelic - I love this rendition of the song.

  • Not the best version, but her looks will take her far.

  • she died of cancer

  • Did not know that, honest.

  • Ignore that cookies idiot. Her voice was passable, her looks were outstanding...being dead doesn't change those facts....

  • I wasn't arguing that, you canuck wimp. I thought she was going to advance in her career until cookiesNrainbows told me that she died of cancer.

  • LOL Being neither a wimp, nor a Canadian the best I can tell you is try again. LOL But that's a lot of moral condemnation for a guy saying she was gonna get ahead with her looks not her voice...which is 100% true...Thanks for the laugh mate....

  • Your account says you're Canadian, and Canada is pretty much the 51st state. I said it wasn't the best version, that doesn't mean it's bad. It's a fact that looks help a lot in the music business, so I thought she'd be resourceful and use that along her other tools to get ahead. Yeah laugh it up, numb nuts.

  • so.. you are laughing at yourself too then?

  • yes you misunderstand me noirmusic but i forgive you

  • The girl's voice is not meant for this music to breathy and shaky yikes!!!

  • Im very aware and I have listened to singers sing in all those..And all were lovely. But I think that NYCroxmysocks was referring to a higher more soprano voice. And I answered thusly. :)

  • oops i thought this was sumi for a second ^.^;;

  • how did that happen? they sound completely different

  • i saw the picture and thought it was her and read the discription, so i had assumed, sorry

  • sumi is korean, and an amazing singer ^.^

  • I love it! Hm, isn't there a similar version in Delightful Girl, a Korean drama?

  • can you link us to it please? i'm curious to hear. who is the singer?

  • Nevermind. My bad. The version from Delightful Girl sounds almost like this one, but it's not. I still like it though. You can check it out if you'd like to: Delightful Girl Choon-Hyang ep.1 (1/7)

  • she passed away?

  • i dont like it at alll!! it sohould be done in an opera voice (haah if that makes any sense)

  • Perhaps she could not hit extremely high notes. Its not easy to hit really high notes.

  • lol

  • ...wazruszająco cudowne...

  • It is quite sad that this lovely young woman with obvious talent has passed away. May she be at peace. To echo other comments here, the epitome of this piece was reached by Jo Sumi. It is simply the finest rendition of this version there is. I do not particularly favor the orchestration of this version but Miss Honda's voice was certainly angelic. Further, as has been stated, this was written and orchestrated by Vladimir Vavilov, not Caccini as is often claimed.

  • Yes " angelic" would certainly describe her voice. It is unfortunate that I just now found out about her.

  • pięknie :)

  • cudowne:):* kocham to:*

  • wspaniałe...

  • sumi jo has a great voice, but this version is not as heavy and has a more easy, calm tune.

  • May her soul rest in peace, and in the arms of Ave Maria....

  • ご冥福をお祈りします。

  • scary.....

  • AVE MARIA...Hail, Mary. This is, or should be, a prayer, not a "modelling theme." When you separate the music from the purpose, it rings a false note.

    She has a lovely voice, but the execution of this number is ponderous, the arrangement sounds like a dirge, and the entire effort is unimpressive.

    I am sure the artist does better with other material. This just isn't for her.

  • the second part with the.... hitting on a damaged piece of metal took some mark away, otherwise will be as good as somi jo

  • I don't see why there are so many negative comments?

    It's not so bad really, I actually enjoy quite alot. And for you people who say "oh her voice isn't strong enough...blah blah blah.." Go leave negative comments on some Miley Cyrus videos or something. If you don't like it, don't watch it, let alone comment.

  • I love supportive comments too, she has her own style ^^ But sumi jo is queening this song

  • omfg lmao miley cyrus

  • Absolutely beautiful!

  • This is a pop version and sumi's one is more on opera style. This version is more of dreamy type, a lost love perhaps. It works on me though. I like sumi's one too.

  • very anime-like. good point. i agree.

  • nah her voice just aint powerful enough to touch the soul...:(

  • She squeeezed her voice to touch miracle power to kick out her cancer.

  • I think see did a great job. Everyone can't be Sumi Jo.

  • I have heard much much better versions! sorry japan!

  • こんにちは、

    本田美奈子もこの曲歌ってたんですね、ソフトでいいですね~

  • 本田美奈子さん大好きだけど、SUMI JO バージョンのAve Mariaを聞いてしまうとこれはポップスっぽくて、ちょっと.­..という感じです。

  • 天使の歌声・・・

    ファンでした・・・

  • the voice is not really special and also not strong

    I can also sing like this... and I have no talent

  • I smell jealousy... :D

  • not really. I only said what I think about it. and the voice isn't so good (sumi jo version is much better. ..bzw. die beste)

    it's the bitter smell of a critical commentar ;)

  • How critical could I be? Im 13. xD

    Im in love with sumi jo's version btw.

  • Sumi Jo has beautiful voice. Minako HONDA has beautiful feature. Let's look at beautiful side of each person. Your life could be more beautiful, and fun!

  • uuuum Better give appropriate comment. People appreciate you.

  • She went to the heaven.

  • She was a singer in Japan.

  • the best version of this song is by sumi jo and the libera (st. thomas boychoir)...I love the cinematography of this video, the woman is beautiful, but the voice is nothing special...

  • Falsetto sì, troppe aspirate! Esecuzione fredda senza sentimento. Dov'è la voce??? Questa "Ave Maria" dovrebbe far venire i brividi!

  • good!!very good!!!

  • falsettto?