Added: 2 years ago
From: michellebranchtv
Views: 2,008,545
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,580)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • amazing song

  • jep got this song from buffy and charmed :)

  • i love this song and i love buffy!

  • does the fish get fed?

  • damn, nostalgic memories.

  • I feel like the fish is more popular then her. Is it or is it not in almost (if not) EVERY. SINGLE. VIDEO? That is the most photogenic fish I've ever known. xD

  • I worship her even back when those stupid Hannah Montana music conquered the air plays in 2006.

  • I do not like the fact that an invasive species was released if that may have been the case oooh shame on you it's dinner I hopes cool vid none the less freedom is a wonderful sight to share and I do like the sence this video brings to me and others I beleve.

  • yeah lets reach 2 million views

  • Thumbs up if you think this kind of music is a dying breed! I am 25 now. I have grown up to this music. I was 15 when I first heard this song. Michelle Branch was such a sweet singer. I just love this song. I own it on a cassette! :)

  • @dark4krad it is dying for a reason, it lacks substance.

  • Pretty deep song about a fish.

  • This fucking good times ,I miss them so much.

  • the gold fish must be saying to himself, I thought it was goodbye let me go already woman

  • @mr8bally my thoughts exactly xD

  • what happens to the music of nowadays generation? this is the real music

  • @oxydro still aroune just not mainstream now so it doesn't get noticed.

  • Thumbs up if you are still listening to this in 2012.

  • I lovelovelove this song, the perfect song for Willow and Tara:')

  • this reminds me to a laguna beach episode

  • reminds me to a laguna beach episode

  • I love this song...old times

  • goodbye to you ♥

  • She looks weird,not ugly,but weird.

  • i dont care buffy im here because i love michelle's songs .

  • wish this caliber of song writting would re-emerge...

  • Will a new Michelle's CD be product?

  • Like this if you're here simply because you love Michelle Branch and her music...not because of some stupid TV show. :)

  • @TakaraStarChan obviously we like her too...but i loved her even more when i heard this song on buffy cuz i never thought they would use her amazing music in those shows.. and fyi. tose shows were not stupid asshole.

  • @LiiLFREAKx0x

    I'm sorry I offended you so much.

  • Thumbs up if you are here because of Buffy the Vampire Slayer or Charmed.

  • She sounds a bit like Susanna Hoffs here.

  • gay that this isnt available for mobile v.v

  • "Feels like I'm starting all over again..."

    "I want you but I'm not giving in this time.. "

    >>so damn good lyrics!<<

  • i love this song but i don't really understand the video

  • @Matila96397 the story is going backwards

  • @lemonice2700 Yet she has picture of all the places has been ... oooo spooky! :P

  • Comment removed

  • atfer 5 yrs of loving you now im moving on alone. i wanna say goodbye for everything :(

  • "I want you, but I am not giving in this time.." sooo Spuffy angsty :]

  • i miss michelle!

  • omg i think its nemo

  • Klaus? Is that you??

  • Comment removed

  • I understand where everyone got this from Buffy, but does anyone else remember Charmed with Cole's last ep. Both were great eps though.

  • i was so sad when tara and willow broke up

  • Heard this on Charmed and Buffy....now I can't stop listening to it

  • Love how this song paralleled Spike/Buffy affair, Giles leaving, Willow and Tara breaking up, and a foreshadow of Xander and Anya's failed marriage. Thumbs up if you know what I'm talking about.

  • @Ehrenlightswornmonk ..........spoilers lol jk

  • @Ehrenlightswornmonk Nope, but I think you've just ruined Buffy for me. Thank you.

  • @lemonice2700 How so? The show is far done....and most of what I said was in the ep that this song is on.

  • @Ehrenlightswornmonk I haven't seen Buffy, but I was going to start. I didn't get this song from Buffy. I just like Michelle Branch.

  • @lemonice2700 Lol. Well this song is highly associated with BTVS, so of course there's going to be BTVS related comments.

  • I bet that fish died..

  • Why is she releasing a fresh water fish into salt water?

  • @MannerPylonTV Because its a metaphor

  • this remind me when i move to U.S....=(

  • Letting go doesn't mean you're giving up, it's just accepting some things are just not meant to be.

  • @lavender1262 thank you, that really helps :)

  • @lavender1262 But the one thing that you never give up on is hope.

  • its hard to give up on the only think I've ever wanted, but this song is helping me get through the hardest choice I've ever made.

  • Thank you, Tabula Rasa. Thank you, Amber Benson and Alyson Hannigan. Thank you Joss Whedon and thank you Michelle Branch. You give me hope for love.

  • anyone notice this isn't the same version as the one on the cd?

  • One year ago today, this song got me through a really rough breakup of a 12 month relationship.

    Unfortunately I think my 7 month relationship will be ending soon..and I know this song will get me through it too <3

  • She's coming out with a new album that is pop/rock.

  • it hurts to want everything and nothing at the same time.

    I want what's yours and I want what's mine.

    I want you but I'm not giving in this time.

  • I remember this song by heart.

  • kung fu panda brought me here.

  • thumbs up if you wanna cry when Tara leaves Willow

  • @H2oJames93 better than what happens later on...

  • @livialioness07 uhm wrong this is their break up song.

  • @H2oJames93 How does that make me wrong?

  • @H2oJames93 That and that Giles flies away.

  • @SarahTheBloody yeah that too but it's sadder when Tara leaves D:

  • @H2oJames93 I agree but I loved Giles too. Very much :)

  • Thumbs up if you heard this on Buffy first!

  • Um, that looked like a goldfish... Some goldfish can survive in low salt levels if acclimatized and all but putting a goldfish right into the ocean is a good way to kill it. So I don't suggest getting rid of 'relationship' fish pets that way...

  • Like this if Buffy the vampire slayer brought you here!

  • There is something illogical in this Video

    Video is at the beginning of the ring that was selling its chain and the end still has it

    How??

  • she looks asian with a hint of irish.

  • Comment removed

  • Forgetting brought me here.

  • There was a awesome video with charmed and this song, long time ago when youtube wasn't this big.

    Can anyone help me find it?

    It has some emotional memories.

  • god has been grt to me i just wish i could start going to church

  • goodbye to you fishy.

  • Thumbs up if you listened to this after watching Buffy :)

  • @cazeecaz Tabula Rasa is so bitter sweet

  • @WeAreNoobz It really is such a fantastic episode. And hilarious - Spike: "Randy Giles? Why not just call me 'Horny Giles' or 'Desperate for a shag Giles'" - brilliant.

  • @cazeecaz LOL I am popping in to agree. Another great episode; 'Once More With Feeling'

  • @britbrighton Indeed it is! Joss Whedon is a genius. :)

  • @cazeecaz how did you know?!?!?!!

  • @cazeecaz I knew I'd heard this somewhere...

  • @cazeecaz I'd seen it before, but didn't realize it was on Buffy 5 years before this video was made...wow.

  • I <3 this song!

  • This is my favorite video music ever <3

    

  • Comment removed

  • I wonder how often she comes back and look at all her videos and comments?

    ANyway LOVE all her songs

  • wouldnt releasing a goldfish into salt water kill it?

    

  • I always wanted to do that . jump on a train and just go where ever it goes .

  • I know that shes busy witha family an eveything, but I wish she cme back and mae music like this

  • Don't you wish you could say that to pepes sometimes I do :( but today finally had a good Christmas but that's not my parents fault of the Christmases before.Love you mom and dad :)

  • So, just a couple of ramdom facts

    The Spirit Room her debut album that includes this song was released on August 2001, the song was feature on Buffy episode "Tabula Rasa"on November that same year, and on Charmed 100th episode in June 2003.

    And I love all three things, her music and both shows ^-^

  • The fish grew up to be a doctor.

  • @1playingyou That makes me happy to know that the fish made a life for himself after all he went through.

  • @ORBuddha Maybe that fish prefers freshwater. :-P

  • Am I the only one who is seeing Trojan commercials before her music videos, and the only one finding it EXTREMELY awkward and weird???

  • I have this album and when I was little I would sing along to every song in my room.

  • Goodbye fishie<3

  • She's only 28 let's not write her off just yet.

  • Very underrated but she did get attention, shame shes not big in the charts still. She found the fine line between chart hits and country music.

  • This song always makes me cry :'(

  • luv this song. luv u michelle!!

  • i knew this song.. its.. simply nice n_n and well..

    well..

    time to go X3

    nice song!!

  • Meganheartsmakeup bought me here. She's such a sweetie :)

  • i love you so much 16

  • Michelle Branch brought me here!

  • goodbye to my old personality so i can be with the most important guy of my life.

  • Je super :)))*

  • I love how this song can have so many meanings! Whether Buffy the Vampire Slayer or Charmed or even a high school senior assembly...this was the song they played at my high school when they went through the senior slideshow of pictures...."last 3 years were just all pretend"...song was and is so deep

    Thanks Michelle Branch...thanks =)

  • Love this song, it gets me everytime. I loved it wen she performed it on buffy

  • Comment removed

  • Totally just killed that poor gold fish...

  • @KalsDivinity yea, i know!! hahha!!

  • Sad Tabula Rasa is sad.

  • This is like me to my ex i didnt wanna say "goodbye" to him but i had to =/ we had a bad fight and things were said, i mean we're fine now but i still had to say "goodbye" to what we had, he was my first love ill always love him but this song describes us so perfectly...

  • @Laurenrules16 get back with him don't act a fool, you only live once!!!

  • @cirisy28 well i have a new boyfriend now and he has a girlfriend and we didnt work out for a reason, we had a long distance relationship like an hour and a half away from each other, he has no job, so he wouldnt have gas money to come see me and i dont have a license, plus when we dated he cheated on me towards the end of our relationship, we did a friends with benefits thing for about a year and it just made everything difficult, as i said he'll always be my first love but theres a reason

  • @cirisy28 we didnt work out. it's all good though he'll always have a piece of my heart but i have a guy who honestly treats me a lot better who honestly can make me more happy then my first love did.

  • SOY MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA MARICA xD

  • @darkavapunk soy Alycia.

  • <3this is exactly how i feel:(

  • This song is old but I still love it.

  • This song comes up if you search "terrible music." try it for yourself.

    But if you try it, notice the Like-Dislike percentage.

    Youtube thinks its bad, youtube viewers disagree.

  • this song used to make me cry like crazy!!! aah those were the days! lol

  • Im not a lesbian or anything but she has some sexy ass lips lol ;-)

  • @countryfan3000 wow and she's your best friend? Maybe you should have a sit down how many times has she done this to you? Please don't let someone who is apparently your friend do that to you...

  • You were the one thing that I tried to hold onto

  • you hurt me so much we were friends and i wanted to be more but i understood u werent ready we were at a fair with my bff she saw our love was having a moment and stole u i didnt wanna say good bye but u did u left me crying while this song played worst day of my life

  • @countryfan3000 did your bff know how you felt? cause if they did that's really messed up and maybe you should have told them or just wait my boyfriends sister went through what you are now and she is now about to marry the guy. Trust me I bet your story will true into a fairy tale if not with him than with someone better ;) I can promise you that just wait and be patient

  • @kaceywarner ya she knew but i dont think its gonna be happy ever after

    

  • I wanna say goodbye to the one I love....shes already engaged...I want to win her back..but..I know shes already happy with that guy....it hurts..it really hurts...goodbye my love....

  • @fireblaze1182 understand this!

  • @mattf739739 I understand if you have a different understanding on this video......it is just how I interpret it...and I just love this song...and it touches my heart.....peace.....

  • may i know where is that place that shoot for this mv ?? driving with alot tree feel so nice

  • lady gaga killed this genre..

  • that episode in buffy that had this song, I LOVE IT.. i used to sing it all the time when i was little, and i found it by typeing in ALl the lyrics and found it,... btt what happned to her, she should make more songs :DD

  • What happened to her? She was so good. I remember all her songs on the radio <3

  • @rhymeswithblonde she went to country for a few years as part of the wreckers

  • mantap...

    

  • Wow Amo a Michelle Espero y pueda venir a Mexico un dia!

  • new favorite ko ......ang ganda ng song ehh .//

  • LISTENING TO THIS BECAUSE OF BUFFY!

  • huh, this version sounds different than the album version. Still, one of my favorite songs.

  • ahhh.. this song, i miss those days.. :(

  • cause you're everywhe... oops, wrong video

  • this reminds me of a guy that i liked and i never wanted to lose him altho he was a total player and he moved and i sang this song bcuz its how i felt cuz i never got to say goodbye

  • she looks like she came out of free people

  • :>

  • it piss me off if i said, i love m.branch... and they like "whose that.?? your friend in FB.?? someone u met.??"

    WTF which planet u in.??

  • Your awesome :)

  • i love this songggg

  • Ahh memories.

  • @aftershock71 Just tell him. Love will always be a gamble, you either win or lose. Yet, when you win, darling, it is so dayam awesome :) GO FOR IT!

  • @xxmelaniex715 Awww Mel, I know what' you're talking about. I cared about a few people in my life that much. It was so hard to say "goodbye" to those guys; i know exactly what you mean. They were my shooting stars at the time too ;), somebody to dream about. Michelle Branch's music will definitely get you through the rough times. It always seemed to clear my mind and make me happy :)