Did SHINEE plagiarize JUSTIN TIMBERLAKE?

[Tungdor]

if the similarity less than 8 bars, then it can not be called plagiarism

[KrapasoR]

I hear vague similarities, they're still completely different! But, even if they did plagiarize, I think it would've been a bigger deal considering that Justin Timberlake has taught or practiced some choreographies with various entertainment companies in Korea.

[glowingem801]

To much red ink on the like bar =/

[Zyath]

No.

[lauraziza93]

If K-Pop doesn't match teens taste and teens prefer K-Rock, they will erase SNSD from business and they will create K-Rock groups. It's just about business and money, there is nothing about music! And people who say that it's new, ok it is! But we can't call that music because it is not.

[lauraziza93]

Well, we can say that SNSD "The Boys" is similar to "Telephone" by Lady Gaga and Beyonce, we can say that SHINee "SHINee World" is similar to "Sexy Back" by Justin Timberlake but I don't hear anything similar between "Ring Ding Dong" and "Sexy Back" o.O And you should know that K-Pop business is just about copying American because they try to know what teenagers like everytime.

[ourworld9697]

yeah justin timberlake's MV, remind me of trouble maker MV

[IsachanLovesYou]

Tch, I honestly can't hear it. Sorry, But even if a song has the same rhythm as another, doesn't actually mean they copied. I mean, Seriously. It's completely different. But hey, that's my opinion. And a lot of others opinion as well.

Sorry, just doesn't add up.

Love,

An Obsessed SHINee Fan.♥

[MyNinjaIsMissing]

Ok seriously #1 you keep comparing like its the artists fault when in actuality the artists don't have any input into the song usually they are made and sold to record labels. which has resulted in stuff like SNSD's Run Devil Run and Kesha's Run Devil Run and SHINee's Are you ready or not and Sean Kingston's Are you ready or not. Both songs are equally owned by all the groups because their labels bought them. #2 WTF I hear no similarities....

[AzumyCath]

maybe Trouble maker mv but Lucifer???NO no no

[SoftChickenLegs]

That is not how you troll :(

[Gshawol5]

SHINee SHINee SHINee SHINee SHINee SHINee SHINee SHINee SHINee SHINee SHINee SHINee SHINee SHINee SHINee SHINee SHINee SHINee SHINee SHINee SHINee SHINee SHINee SHINee

[Theinnocentdream]

seeing this made me realize something... The TROUBLEMAKER MV IS FUCKING THE SAME AS THE SEXY BACK ONE!

[seiyashiryu1]

this is really stupid about every 3 songs every made have a similar rythem......-.- and snsd's genie sounds like clifornia girls....................so shut the fuck up

[seiyashiryu1]

..............................­......the fuck?! it doesnt even sound the same at all and not a bad job slowing down shinees song to make it match justin;s song but just for the record..........dont mess with shawols

[lauraW995507]

FUCK YOU !!!!!!!!!!

[MiniMeYumi123]

THEY DONT!

[xxSycoKissxx]

MV~Troublemaker??



[SugaranSpiceTV]

I hate when I get Pulled into BS by catchy or Nu Huh Looking titles YOU SUCK!!!

[otakukerlena]

Oh stas medio sordo o q te pasa?? son muy diferentes !! ¬¬

[SupaSwooper]

no similarity at all

[zarii23]

WTF!!!

completely different.....



[blackoutjj]

i think trouble maker plagiarized sexy back mv

[KayKay130x]

shinee is better than him , justin sound like he is dead , shinee sound so clear and nice lol

[ziggero]

TOTALLY DIFFERENT

[coldheart279]

there is nothing the same between the two songs...

[aelitastoms]

Es mucho mejor SHINee!!!!!! *_* no importa como lo mires *_*

[DluvsU2013]

More Like SHINee brought SEXY Back!! hahaha

[jesika535]

the mirror is similar

[lindou33xd]

Makes wanna watch Ring Ding Dong again.

It does sound a tad similar though.

[lale22fansub]

jajaja che como lo hiciste parece q si se copiaron pero yo se q NO ES IMPOSIBLE

[darkeyesloveshp]

seriously wth, how is this similar? the tune is not even that similar. dotssssssssssss

[lolek2011eu]

it is not plagiarize

[ky00tekika]

All these 'copy' and 'plagiarize' vids are pointless. It's been revealed already that some of Kpop songs are REMAKES of songs from other countries, however it is not plagiarism if the company buys the rights to the song. Plus the original is given credit in the album notes. And you can't criticize KPop artists for doing that because American artists do it too. They borrow and sample from older pop songs.

[marioncullen16]

NOTHING ALIKE

[Junsukiyoo]

I love SHINEE but i also pay my respect on JT. Damn, his groovy music is no joke

[SoNyeo2007ShiDae]

EVEN IF IS TRUE FUK JT

SHINEE IS BEST

[Joleneshineegirl]

Saranghae~ SHINee oppas! ;D

It is obvious that both songs are diff. -_-

[alextphany]

jajaja WTF??? shinee copy??? you are fucking crazy... if you are going to say copy you must mean for the letter , but the letter is very diferent okay?!! and also the sound , i hate when people think that the only pop must be the pop from usa!! RIGHT NOW IS K-POP!! KOREAN POP.. and you know what i mean because you know about korean pop..

[MollyDino101]

Your my dear friend have problems...

[viggolvr]

god that's the dumbest question. THe SHINee Oppas song sounds nothing like that douche....sorry Justin but my loyalty to the oppas is strongerthen my love for your song.

[xhallon24x7]

where the fuck is plagiat? -,-'

[kikorin06]

I love Justin ! SHINEE?? is a K-poop?

[Goldentalkify]

how can Shinee copy Sexy Back?

it looks like Troublemaker to me!

[kpopsushi93]

Naw not even close...

[shugoshugo123]

How does that sound the same?????

[JulieJustin0LeeLogan]

troublemaker vid copy justintimberlake vid

[jjue123]

shit is similar. *gasp* no wonder I love both songs!

[JassiChan13]

It didtn´t even sound the same

Why are you making those stupit videos ???

You only get enemies !!!

[BeautifulRocks]

OH PUH LEASE!!!!!!!!!!!!! they are not even alike!!!!!! what the hell!!!! when I saw the name was that could be plagiarized I was shocked because I love both of them but HELLO! this is fucking ridiculous

[chrishitlicious]

It just have a BIT of similiarities, come on man..

[mapi0516]

not think it is plagiarism, not look anything

[liv38ig]

All you biased Shinee fans.. of course it's not gonna be exactly the same.. but it's definitely inspired by it (put in a good way).. definitely the same concept.. I cant believe some of you say that there are "ABSOLUTELY" no similarities.. you guys dont know shit about music..

[HottvzInsp]

If KPOP copied all the groups and people they are accused off, then all those fans will listen to that music, not KPOP. We listen to KPOP because America POP has gone to SHIT! it was only good in the 90s. Now is weird as FUCK!

[observerinpink]

its whether im having hearing problems or is it you that is having hearing problems? i don't hear or see any similarities.

[2minjongkeyonchik]

OK so a lot of people say Korean pop music is just copying American pop music but Korean pop music is unique and totally different than American pop. Korean pop music does NOT suck or it is NOT copying/ plagiarizing American pop music. compare the two and sure the beats may sound different but only in the sense that the beat has become quite popular all over the world not just Korea. so people who say Koreans are copying um shove it.

[XAlexablexX]

Erm nah.

[gnesisbroken]

shut up all pop songs sound the same.

[PatriciaTuugamusu]

I don't think so!!

[efdizzle09]

man, there is no plagerism here 

[my831grl]

So, I learned, that the reason why these Pop songs sound so much alike is because they just repeat the same 4 chords over and over again. Hope that helped!

[HYQueen104]

wtf, are you really that bored to make this stupid video? Get A Life dude~ -_- you're over- comparing the songs.

[mitkof13]

You know, when I first saw RingDingDong I thought of JT xD

But no, I don't think so.

[miki15misha]

jjajaja estas loco!

[SHINeeAlly]

-.-

[MSloretta1966]

no

[thehihi96]

Not plagiarized cuz now a days a lot of composers from all over the world sends in music to kpop singers so~ <3 thnx for that

[NikyMich]

-___________________-'''

[dinabff96]

i think

[DayanaAlienFujoshi]

no es lo mismo son canciones completamente diferentes!!! e.e

@0sziriiszHYUN tienes razon!

[ItsJESS5209]

ridicolous -.- OFC they didnt

[TheMmira0]

mmno, it's like comparing apples and oranges...songs are like that^^

[Sonimee]

omg top comment is right! this is exactly like troublemaker....

Hyunseung's version is better.... (Just kidding....not really but I don't feel like getting bashed)

[praewty100]

I love SHINEE!!!!!!!

[OIcePrincessO]

Are u kidding xD' Hàhàhàhà :P

[kagome1439]

Kpop is way better than our american pop. besides in the music industry everybody rips off everybody that's how it works.

[sakheero]

Me gustan ambos, así que esto es una estúpidez.

[0sziriiszHYUN]

y se supone que en donde le copio... es totalmente distindo no le levantean falsos a shinee

[jesslojel3]

Shinees beat is faster that only THE OBVIOUS difference, theres more.

[kawaibluebow]

yup i think so...but you can't hide the fact that ring ding dong is amazing, j.T is amaizng too SO STOP THIS MADNESSS!

[rhianna59]

The bands do too XD

[rhianna59]

Id this is plagiarizing..... Then all of the modern pop music in america totally rip off eachother.... Oh and the banda

[BDKpop]

I think we have to talk about Trouble Maker and that scenes... is more... Plagiarized¿

[TheMimimanga]

pff , is really two different music

[HeavyMiau]

Was Justin Timberlake's "Sexy Back" plagiarized by SHINee? Answer: NO.

[TammyHeart]

WTF There's Nothing The Same!!!! Not The Beats And Not Anything!! WTH!!!~

[Splash2391]

WHAT THE BUCK!? How the hell are these alike?!

[Lizziline]

Disslike

[coldhustla]

uhhhhhh wtf? what was the same?

[ieatshyuu7888]

da fuuu- soo confused -_____-

[Sunnyyae]

Kids nowadays...

[AdrenalineRevolverx]

I totally just liked this video because there is Justin Timberlake and SHINee in the same place. They have the same beat... cause that's really plagiarizing (!) 

[Emilove99]

@AdrenalineRevolverx no?

[les4rable]

the songs both have a sexy undertone...that's it

[XxpsychokittydxX]

i see the similarities, but i like both versions still, cuz they both have their own twist on a similar beat.

[dNooriani]

the music is different but kinda have same beat and tempo. lyrics are different too, i think. i don't like kpop but comparing JT and SHINee just doesn't make sense. sorry.

[sacp2126]

ya you're crazy it's totally different

[mataemine]

lol dude it's totally different!

[driftgal1029]

This is the creation of someone who has nothing good to do in life. The only thing similar to JT's song is the MV of Trouble Maker, they kinda have the same concept..:)

[tplikesnike53]

lol does anyone see the dislike bar 0__0

[lannykpa]

It look completely diference

[QueenMeBarBie]

Its just the babyy just that but SHINEE FOREVER

[icecreams96]

funny cause in JT's MV.. it looks like Troublemaker...

[Loveless363]

The scenes from Justin Timberlake's video looks like the scenes from Troublemaker (Hyuna and Hyunseung)

[kristen7joanheathers]

@Loveless363 yo pienso lo mismo y se lo digo a otros y me dicen tay loca

[lazybones12]

@Loveless363 that's what I said xD Both are still good :3

[rosa61217]

@Loveless363 haha yeah , it does !

[pkjing]

@Loveless363

AGREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

look at the songs! KPop does a lot of copycats

But still, they perfected some of the pieces!

[MyPsych96]

@Loveless363 I don't wanna fight or anything, but Sexy Back came out in 2006 and Troublemaker only came out one or two years ago.

[NinjaGrell]

the babaaaaaayyy part sounds the same.......yep thats about it

[VietnameseSweets]

When put the two tracks together they sound very different....

[grizzel]

they are putting the songs on their language

not the first time.

[khunshtan]

@grizzel WTF?

[InuLoverch]

NUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUNCA­, nada a ver cara, é bem capaz do Justin ter plagiado os meus lindos.

SHINee ALWAYS <3

[ioioiohjiohoi]

i didn't know that saying the word "baby" was plagiarism ...

[Yadira1ism]

sooo theres no resemblance except they both say babeeeeeeeeeee...with a long eeeehh....then maybe? not

[AsianFan0Toluca]

Justin me cae gordo, ademas el copia a Rain ewe 

[AsianFan0Toluca]

SHInee LOVE !

[xxkpoplovergirlELFxx]

WTF k pop never copy any one i love SHINee

[gavizhita]

waaaa taemiiin♥ sajdlkas i'm only listenin shinee! jajaja i'm babeeee!♥

[NanaKitten95]

SM don't plagiarize, they buy ;)

yeah these are not similar at all btw LOL

[Franslipi]

totally different

[luvlycrazycooki3]

yeah they are completely going at different paces the baby is hardly similar the beat or chord proggression have no similarity

I THINK PPL JUST NEED A PROBLEM TO TALK ABOUT THATS NOT THERE all these plagerism videos are annoying as it is but this, THIS had to be the worst

[imanagedreamworld]

it's only the baby part =))

[ligiaaelenna]

SHINee st mereu originali <3<3<3..ei nu copiaza pe nimeni

[skyrumen818]

It's called directors.

[rayexraye]

is it just me... or did trouble maker have a similar concept to sexy back?

[MaiioLee]

WHAT THE FUCKING FUCKKKKKKKK? JAJAJAJAJAJ IDK YOU BUT I AM SURE THAT BOTH SONGS AREN'T ALIKE.

[AzzWolffy]

Sincer nu vad asemanarea ... SHINee nu a plagiat melodia si nici J.T nu a afacut-o . Sunt doua melodii total diferite.

[TheBlueGummeBear1]

LOL you obviously have no sense of music.

[SakuraKpop]

SHINee =]

[HeenimButterfly]

A quien se ocurrió esto solo se parecen cuando alargan la ultima sílaba y eso q en ese sentido si nos ponemos a ver a muchas canciones q se parecen

[lovecoree34japon]

SHINEE <3 <<3



[xXPurpleLoliTranceXx]

Yeah. He did.

Shinee is better anyways.

[PearlDeAmethyst]

um, in the ninth grade i wrote a song that started with Babayyyy, and i only got itoduced to kpop in the 11 grade and justin in college....did i do something bad XD

[rasberrylover66]

so what lots of people say baby

[abiesme1]

what the fuck.but if not look anything like these two songs

[ZalleKim]

If you wanna see something that REAL plagiarized to one of SHINee's songs type this "Martin - show the world" . THAT IS REALLY SIMILAR!!!!

[shikamarusgenius]

@ZalleKim umm SHINee bought the rights to that song, and they wrote new lyrics to it...same with Juliette and Corbin Bleu's Deal With It...and more actually

[ZalleKim]

@shikamarusgenius SHINee Didn't bouth anything. It is this man: "Thomas Troelsen". He was the writher of "Show the world". He wrote that song for Martin to Danish X-faktor. Then later he wrote the Korean version to SHINee. Thomas have wrote a lot K-pops songs. Nu abo - Fx, Run devil run - SDNS, Mr. Simple - Super Junior and more. ^.^

[shikamarusgenius]

@ZalleKim yea i know but the company SM bought the rights to the song...and besides it's not just him...i meant the other songs SHINee remade...

[ZalleKim]

@shikamarusgenius Thats right

[shikamarusgenius]

@ZalleKim huh?

[MsHMChai]

more like troublemaker!!!

[Alexandra16185]

Shinee tiene otro estilo mejor que el de los estadounidendes duela a quien le duela Justin Timberlake les queda chico para Shinee y quien dijo que es un plagio Shinee es original y es el mejor

[NSNiss]

u.u cada vez mas mal.. apoyo a shine ademas ay canciones que se asemejan muxo ,.. pero no son plagios o si no todos estarian plagiados

[pinaychocolate0772]

I love both of them!!!(: but I heard to resemblance?? Haha

[xRaineDropsx]

Nope I don't really see a resemblance :)

But I do prefer SHINee's song :)

[SJchayenneSM]

kpop is better bcuz ne yo and pitbull stole songs from bigbang, gaga stole songs from big bang, nathalie makoma stole songs from snsd, kesha stole songs from snsd and to top that off Will.I.Am, black eyed peas's leader is cllabbing with 2NE1 and he also said:'' 2NE1 isnt just going to be big in asia but also in america, brazil etc.etc.'' if u wanna kno the source, serach for this: WILL.I.AM interviews about 2NE1.

[SJchayenneSM]

i dun hear anythin except for that shinee was wayyy better then that white guy who tries to be ne yo and ne yo who tries to be taeyang, even if ne yo existd earlier, kpop and its artists are way better. plz like this if u agree with mee

[GracieDisneyPrincess]

o.O these are totally different...and SHINee is waaaaaaaay better anyway xD JT can go suck a big one

[MegaKoreanlover]

I really hate it when people compare kpop songs to american songs. Even though there is no resemblance at all.

[gavizhita]

JAJAJJAJJAJ for me i want to keep listen shinee .-. is like the sound is so BABEEEEEEE! djasdljsajds

[Jilltheanimelover]

I hear no resemblance.....

Btw I love both Justin Timberlake and SHINee <3

[Danaa1608]

SHINee IS THE BEST BAND EVER!

[blossomcutie1234567]

Hey guys, I'm not Korean. I am American-born Indian who loves MUSIC, like american and korean, and I just have to say: I think Justin Timberlake is extremely popular and talented, but you know what? SO IS SHINEE. I am a HUGEEEEEE SHAWOL and forever will be, and you know what? PEOPLE NEED TO JUST ACCEPT THAT THEY ARE BOTH AMAZING AND TALENTED FROM THE BEGINNING. Everybody and everything is inspired by something, some way or another. Are you gonna go around saying that Las Vegas plagarized Paris??

[lisshappyful]

poor idiots dont be stupids the korean have talent dont are the same trash loosers



[starfOREVERkpop]

I do not see any resemblance!!!! .....

the Koreans if they are talented

[shaketheshikshin]

I am the one who does not see any resemblance?

[Isauriful]

@shaketheshikshin yo tampoco veo el parecido en nada ¬¬

[ClassyJohn]

@shaketheshikshin its ok. just means ur not stupid. ^.^

[kpoplover543]

@shaketheshikshin no your not



[13elieveinELF]

- - WTF do u have no music sense o.o the beat is like totally different

[iLuVkittzykkAG]

i don't care what is true i just love SHINee and they are best! <3 ^^

[nookyoyofck]

if you say SHINEE copy Justin Timberlake you so wrong, because Shinee ring ding dong came out first so you can say that Justin Timberlake plagiarize Shinee ring ding dong, but it not the same. I like Justin timberlake and shinee. So don't make other misunderstand something stupid like that! it's not like me to say something like that but i really can't take it

[iJEEYO]

totally different, sounds like crap when it mixed -_-

[bethery123]

justin timberlakes mv reminded me of hyunseung and hyuna's troublemaker

[Taniagatita1]

@bethery123

True, I just realized, is very similar in the mirror. . . but in the song, nothing to see hahaha

According to me, Trouble maker is better!