Added: 2 years ago
From: G4TV
Views: 172,549
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,262)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • It's a bad game. The worst of the whole serie. You have no gun, and this is a major disappointment. The game had a great potential, with an incredible light/shadow effect due to the amazing flashlight engine, the smart use of the Wiimote speaker as a phone speaker, smart wiimote+nunchuck moves to interact with objects, drop closets, run faster and throw enemies to the sides. The fact that ALL the enemies look like each other is as limited as the lack of weapons.

  • i like silent hill homecoming its still survival horror even u can fight the monsters

  • that guy doesnt know how to pint whit the wii controller ¬¬

  • awesome game, i finished the game on PSP. one thing that bugs me in all the silent hill games is that, the storyline is so good but i never really understood why are there so many freaking monsters!

  • @Polokpva The town is manifesting the inter psyche of the characters through symbolic creatures, locations, puzzles, etc. It's pretty much stated in all SH games.

  • i've got dis game and bloody hell itz addictive!

  • I just hope this genre won't disappear like the point and click games...There is only a very few of this genre available nowadays...Damn those western influence on japanese traditional horror games e.g Resident Evil.

  • Good game, though it feels more like a point and click style of game now, but i still love :)

  • Ive played all silent hill and i have to say this was by far the worst and i cant be the only one who thought homecoming was a good game, especially on pc.

  • Havent played it but everything seems ok except the no weapon concept. What about bosses?

  • Can everybody STOP complaining about the graphics? Pay attention to the story, the graphics aren't even bad! Silent Hill was always known for its story, and this one gives you soooo much sweety goodness in the story.

  • OMG THE WII IS GETTING CRAZY!! i guess SSBB isnt d only rape game for d WII :D!

  • Like the no weapons idea, don't like the ice world feel :( The weird hell dungeon world and the siren was my fav (creepiest) part.

  • Its so graphicalls ugly.. Its a shame. I mean I love the fact that the american Company that worked with Silent Hill 5. It did what the "fans" asked for and gave us the Silent Hill move in game form. However taking the feel from the game with a cliche ice effect, extream glitchy animations, and an amazing 1st game into an action stragidy/run away game, instead of horror/stratigy/puzzels.... its a sad thing. I love change, just not how this looks... like crap. Hopfully it wont be a dissapointment

  • what is happened to nintendo?? i just see a gay games where is horros,super metroid grapgics??

  • oooooo I wanna draw inappropriate pictures on my phone! :O

  • People are so afraid of change. I mean I love the old games, but I don't hate this.

    I'm playing it now (on the PS2 though), and I can say it is creepy, having to run away and not always know where you're going, it makes you panic a bit more.

    I think Homecoming was a downfall in the series, but this lifts it up again. It does feel like Silent Hill.

    But I gotta admit, if they're gonna make a Silent Hill 6 or whatever, I hope they can stick to the old style with new concepts and twists to it.

  • ya i think its good there bringin mature games to wii i had a wii but i wante mor matur game so i got and xbox

  • Hell should be depicted as rust, fire, death, and despair. NOT a frozen wasteland. I WANT MY FIRE AND DEATH!!! AND SHOTGUNS!!! What is the point of monsters if you can' blow their freakin' head off!!

  • @Goldmotherfunker

    The point is so the monsters scare you.

    Thats the point.

  • @Goldmotherfunker So basically, story is stupid to you and should be replaced with mindless violence and gore?

  • @Lyf3isM1s3ry No I like the storyline just fine. I just think that they shattered the balance between gore and story.

  • this silent hill is a piece of shit, why konami made this, whyyyyyyyyyyyyy, konami is dead, like castlevania and resident evil, silent hill now is a piece of shittttttttttttttttttttttttttt­, this game deserve a very goog remake like the original in ps3 with the best console

  • @chikoebay1979

    Leave Castelvania out of it.

  • Виски - White Horse - Мартини - Bianco - Текила - Olmeca Gold - Ром - Captain Morgan Black - Aммарето - Ликер - Водка - Черная смородина,Цитрон - Коньяк - Обычный, Шоколадный, Миндальный

    5 литров - 1500

    Мы не продаем алкоголь лицам недостигшим совершеннолетия.

    Москва 89653410236

  • This game will get a bad score. Bookmark this and call me on it.

  • one of the greatest looking games on Wii

  • wait so you dont have weapons

  • I hate this silent hill only because they made Harry look like a pussy and frozen transitions argh!!!:P

  • Silent hill Shattered memorize had aws0me graphics on PSP and on Wii!

    But big minus!!! that game is so boooooriiing!!! just no weapons!!! Just you re like an tourist !! Harry mason jumps ! scrolls up to wall!! unreal =(

  • u.u thats not rlly silent hill style i hope it doesnt disappoint me :/

  • Siletn hill has turned into a Hollywood franchise. As long as there's americans making the new games with the same name, you'll never see something similar to the 3 first games

  • @roaldski

    same goes for Resident Evil as well.

    Best true RE game was Code Veronica... RE4 was great and it was RE, but the change in style kind of makes it not survival horror, especially with the chapter breaks and loads of save points.

  • i would probley like this game so mutch better if it had weponds

  • waaaaa genial da miedo pero lo kiero. Ademas hay mucho manejo y ahora escalan muros cosa que antes estaba super limitada. Me gusta!!!!

  • I miss the original :( Team Silent rock!

  • the original is probably so much better..just better graphics in the wii one.

  • This looks so good

  • did anyone see the gltch in 1:43

  • JFDFL I WANT THIS GAMEEEEEEE.

  • i need this game!:P

  • hmm it seems good but a silent hill game with no fighting? just running away... doesn't seem as fun.

  • What, so you LIKED the ammo-conservation horror atmosphere of all the other games? Well each to his own. :/

  • the grapiq of this game are super good in the full game and they = for some game in 360..

  • that might just be the light setting in the game though

  • Silent Hill was always known for story @ Zweg2 , sure the story may be simple if you look at it in a shallowe way, but all the psychological parallels and backround makes it maybe deeper than any other game (for example the "reason" of the Pyramid heads in silent hill 2...they arent just there to kill Henry, there is much more than that behind it ;) )

  • You Mean James.

    PH is a Guide for James, not Henry.

  • @matrixvalnar

    James...nor henry...PH was originally in silent hill 2, origins, and finally in homecoming

  • @MrTheDHill thanks mixed up names, though PH wasnt actually in Origins, it was the Butcher, also in Homecoming PH was the Boogeyman....mere fanservice of the american developers :/ the real PH was only in Silent Hill 2

  • @matrixvalnar Shit, nobody cares what's more behind it.

  • @zikazivac94 just because you don't care, doesn't mean nobody does, i care a lot about it, and there a thousands who see more in games then just reacting to things happening on the screen ;)

  • graphics graphics graphics graphics graphics graphics graphics graphics graphics graphics graphics graphics if you hate wii why are you...........................­.............................

  • Sure, and the PSX games ALL of them really suks cuase of that ...

  • @cobweb1989 oh shut the fuck up. Graphics don't mean shit. Super mario was one of my favourite games and STILL is fun. fuck graphics it's all about gameplay

  • I was referring to games that are on all consoles. And also modern games. old games like super mario relied on good gameplay, graphics isnt even an issue. However modern games, need to have texture and an image that is clear and detailed for it to be good. that is where the wii fails. that is why it is an inferior console.

  • @cobweb1989 Not even, wii is based on shiity graphics but i love the games i dont give a fuck about the graphics one bit

  • @cobweb1989 well if games nowadays need good graphics to be considered "good games," why are the old mario games still fun to play 20 years later?

  • all you guys aren't getting my point. If super mario bros came out today and you had never heared of it, you wouldnt even give it a chance because the grafics aren't good. its a fact of the gaming world nowadays. Games need to be visually stimulating. Im sorry we cant sit around playing on our old gameboys forever!

  • @cobweb1989 yeah people surely wouldnt give a chance to a video game with oldschool graphics.

    thats why capcom (a company with lots of years in the industry) is releasing megaman 10 with the original graphics of the first megaman. Oh boy they're so stupid.

  • @cobweb1989 that also explains how ps2 & wii are selling more than xbox 360 & ps3.

    lmao, sure, graphics are the most important thing in videogames

  • @cobweb1989 erm..... dude? please just shut up

  • Fuck you! 8-bit Facist.

  • So if they had never made super mario bros. until today, would it be your favorite game?of course not. You liked that game because it was new and fresh for that time period. You still like it because it's a timeless game. I think that if the wii could have better graphics, it would shit on every console. But it doesn't

  • Umm.. i still love super mario? Got it for my ipod touch even.

  • I mean there were plenty of moments that literally made me say "OH SHIT!", many more than in SH 1 and 2. Being pursued just feels like a nightmare. It's simply incredible how this game can duplicate, almost flawlessly the feel of a night mare.

  • the only disappointment to me is that its an ice world rather than red fiery one. this game still looks good, but they're really getting farther and farther away from what Silent Hill is about. this doesn't look anywhere near as twisted as previous games...

  • LOL you'll be surprised man.

    I'm not going to lie, I've played all the silent hill games, but never finished one... They just get too damned repetitive, the story runs flat, and it becomes tedious.

    This is the only silent hill game i've ever bothered to complete because it's so damn compelling.

    And to say it's not as twisted, is a gross understatement. The atmosphere is unbelievable creepy and real... It's hard to describe, but it's just like a nightmare.

  • well i wouldn't know, but from what i've seen it definitely looks creepy, but not so much on the twistedness. i'd have to play it and figure that out.

    i love the concept of only being able to run from the monsters rather than fight them, but it (from what i've seen) seems to be going farther from what it original all meant to be, but i'm glad to be wrong on the twisted quality of the game.

  • The lack of combat makes it all the more scary, knowing your pursued. It's just like running from something in a nightmare.

  • Alone in the Dark seems to be a bit of a knock-off of the other Silent Hill games.

  • I wish I could weigh in on this game, but I pre-ordered it from GameStop and told them to call me when they got it in. Those buck-futters never did and now they have my money and someone else has my copy of the game.

  • this game is total bullshit. if they're going to waste money on this crappy reimagining which screws the story of SH and makes you as helpless as a little girl, why didn't they just remake the first damn game for us who didn't have ps1s and can't find copies of the origional?!!

  • " you have to run, you cant fight with them" that is the originality of the game , scape from the criatures, you are alone with nothing, u have to run for ur life, and there are 5 silent hill before this one, 5 games killing monsters and crazy shits, its time to see only the horror in SM.

  • Of course the graphics are gonna fail if it's for the Wii. But the sound effects and music and story are pretty good to me.

  • I agree! Never been a fan of Silent Hill. TOO scary for me, I love Resident Evil games and Dead Space, but Silent Hill is still too scary for me. I´m looking forward to play this on my PSP.

  • i hate to break this to you but the original japanese developers copied there story and design from an American movie,

  • And made it better. =D

  • SH has never been known for story... You don't know what your talking about. Many review sites applauded the story for being highly emotional and involving.

    As for repetitiveness, let me tell you, that is what turned me off of the other silent hill games. This game gets rid of that, even Gamespot and other sites aknowledged this by saying it removes much of the tedium.

    The interactivity is more creative than I've seen in any other SH game.

  • ok this is like fatal frame now. (with the camera)

  • People are so afraid of change. I mean I love the old games, but I don't hate this.

    I'm playing it now (on the PS2 though), and I can say it is creepy, having to run away and not always know where you're going, it makes you panic a bit more.

    I think Homecoming was a downfall in the series, but this lifts it up again. It does feel like Silent Hill.

    But I gotta admit, if they're gonna make a Silent Hill 6 or whatever, I hope they can stick to the old style with new concepts and twists to it.

  • there might not be infernal world but a frozen world but even so the fact that monsters are not as slow as hell and that it's a whole interactive thing makes up for it :D

  • @MzMorgana How could you play a game without a combat system?

  • @DonnyMarksPa

    It was quite easy, I just picked the controller up and played ;)

  • @MzMorgana Sounds pretty boring. : / This has nothing on the original silent hill games.

  • @DonnyMarksPa

    Yes well, my first comment was while I played the game and hadn't finished it or anything, but having finished it a few times now I notice it's way too short, it's very easy once you've figured a few things out (don't want to spoil) and yeah, it's not very exciting to play over and over again. And you finish it in about 2 hours the 2nd time. I didn't mind not having a combat system, but they didn't do enough to compensate for it imo. Story-wise very good though.

  • @DonnyMarksPa Amnesia.

    Enough said.

  • @MzMorgana Exacly

  • GPS?, ice world? ive loved the silent hill franchise since the beginning and imo its died, SH5 and this dont count in my book

  • Ill get it if it can be first person

  • yo mama OHHHH SNAP !

    lol jk

  • ice world sucks the old rusty one was fucking scary this world is just going to make me feel cold lol

  • Ice world? whyyyy! why can't they keep to the original world, that is more scary and dark!

  • Love it.

  • Hmm will be worth a play through but i feel this will be like Juon abit meaning that you will only play through it once then shelf it

    cant say im impressed by the graphics either knowing the wii as i do it is capable of alot better i just wish they would take the wii more seriously and design some well detailed horror games though remakes like this are the way forward I really want some old games remade with brilliant graphics I'd love to see all the silent hills and resi games redone

  • I liked the red world more than the ice world. That's what the "Otherworld" is really like.

  • To be honest I think it is refreshing there is no gun, but perhaps a knife would have been nice. Though the idea is to panick and use the environment around you to survive.

  • 1:42 LOL nice grafic xD

  • @Cesco36 LOL

  • That's an animation error, not a graphics problem. And they fixed it later.

  • "well, you've gotta have creepy little kids in it, its a horror game" lol

  • silent hill 2 is still gonna be more brilliant and atmospheric. topping it won't happen. i hope this one doesn't try too hard and sacrifice interesting content in order to try to match sh2. just try and make a fun and creepy game in its own right

  • その嫌悪感は何ですか? 真剣に誰も嫌悪感をl強制的にそれを見ると

  • I wish they would give Harry at least a knife...but being defenseless is scary. I just hope that the defenseless thing just doesn't screw up the your ability to progress in the game, like being rape by a bunch of monsters and not having the ability to get yourself out of it.

    I'm not really a fan of the ice world stuff, I like my silent hill to be rusty and red...but it is new and interesting to at least say. It does remind me of The Thing though, and that game was horrible

  • lol at the wiebe watch.... my hero hahahaha

  • Looks awsome

  • I am in no way saying that the game is going to be bad, but I don't think I'll like it nearly as much as the earlier games. I like running out of bullets and frantically searching for more. I like getting to the bosses and beating the shit out of them. I don't think it's going to be nearly as good. It's like changing the Castlevania games. They're still good, but the fact that you're just in one dungeon the whole time takes away from the games...It's just not nearly as good.

  • Wow Im really surprised by this. When I read the title I was like "Oh great another shitty american silent hill" but Im really impressed. I dont really like the 'ice' world. Silent Hill will always be red to me, but Im really glad this isn't a fan game where you see red pyramid for no reason.

  • Just got a wii for Christmas and this game looks pretty cool... I might wanna buy it

  • Cmon people. lets think outside the box instead of running and gunning. go play call of duty if thats your thing :]

  • >.> oh yea cuz i wanna run around with a flashlight not fighting monsters.....

  • OMG! Don't you even fight theses things? All you have to do is shake them off?

  • I look forward to playing it, I am not very combat oriented like must so i would rather think my way out of things then shoot um up bang bang...

  • this looks terrible. i LIKE being able to defend my self from monsters. ya know, the satisfaction of cutting off the head of a nurse or smashing monsters with the steel pipe. its just another "oh, lets use motion controls :D that makes every game better! if we do that we wont even have to use a weapons system, oh the money we could save!" SH is SUPPOSED to be scary, DARK, and so on. in the words of the angryvideogamenerd "What were they thinking?!?"

  • oh, and ice?! wtf? the rusty, dead, decaying world was the best aspect of the series! rawrrrr, this is pissing me off

    >:( SH homecoming was an IMPROVMENT sure the wimpy people who have issues swinging a pipe (heather, henry, so on...) made the game scary, it was cool, but when you could quickly attack was great :) but now you cant attack at all? wtf?

  • @angelica462 Yes, do you want this series to turn into RE? Too many guns make everything lose it's scare effect

  • not at all. RE was good in the original game, different scare, but now the series is to different. I dont want a bunch of guns :/ i like have a weapon in general (preferably a knife) so if im surrounded by creatures from all directions i cant get out. and whats the threat or scare from a monster that doesnt really hurt you, only tackles you. nurses are scary, any moment they can slice you open but if your fast enough you can get them back or injure them enough to run away and survive.

  • dude, what's scarier? Being able to defend yourself, or being defenseless? They were trying to make this game scarier, by making you defenseless against the monsters.

  • Its just a scary puzzle game

  • Ok when i first heard about this, even though i've only played Silent Hill.4, i thought it looked epic. But i would also live in a town like that just because...

    Anyway, this game might seem horrible just because of Climax but it's soooooo good. Sure the consoles weren't the greatest choices but the endings and twists through the game are HANDS DOWN the best. Epic game...

  • ehhh this game is scary to me...just torchlight

  • just when i thought silent hill was not gonna get worst.... Silent Hill has going downhill since the last couple of games, practically since SH3... it should be back in Japan on Konami's hands, but now that Akira Yamaoka Left Konami, i dont see anything good for Silent Hill

  • The only pros about this is the flashlight control, there's nothing Silent Hill in it...

  • ke rayos!!!! O_o

    cuando me entere me esperaba un juegazasaso, algo asi komo tipo resident 4, pero me topo de frente con un juego fuera de contexto ke pretende innovar con sus gameplay evadiendo por completo el alma del clasico silent hill, si me lo compraria nadamas por nser fan y ver SH1 con mejores graficas pero neta ke me desepciono -_-'

  • man... that shitted silent hill series

  • Hands down one of the best SH. It might not have weapons or any combat system (which SH hill should not be about looking back at SH homecoming...sucked) enviroments and graphics are great for the wii. creatures don't really attack you, they hug you to the ground and then they sort of rub of you...it's kinda creepy. nightmare sequences are hectic and creepy. Great game overall.

  • what do ya mean by "RUB" !?

  • clitoris

  • alright, throughout my experience my monsters had like high heels on and big fish lips. they looked like naked old women with fish heads almost... when i finally would die one would kneel down and put a hand on my back, gently almost. like they were putting me to bed... wierd. To me that kind of morbidness IS sh. Double helix SH homecoming was like watching that god awful film again.if they do more they should take the SH SM and build upon it.Try it. it's different in a good way.

  • "You can scribble, you can draw inappropriate pictures..." hahaha I know what I'm gonna draw... I don't know about you guys but I'm very excited about this game.

  • @BrokenFish i bet u are o.o

  • WHAT!!!! NO GUNS, PIPES, CROWBAR, PLI WOOD, OR EVEN A FUCKING SLINGSHOT TO HIT THE ENEMIES. we need new producer. story writer with great imaginations and most of all new director or bring the OG people because these people have no idea what they are making. My own stories that wrote and draw about my silent hill story will come soon

  • I wonder if Climax will ruin this one too...

  • It's already ruined:

    Harry looks stupid, Dahlia is a stripper, the otherworld is a winter wonderland, there is no combat at all, the monsters attack looks like they're hugging, the graphics are bad, too.

  • no gun T.T

  • drawing on the map would really help

  • thank god for the phone! save anywhere? gps updating whenever you move? interactive map? WE NEEDED THAT A LONG TIME AGO

  • I'm actually looking foreward to this, I hope it's not as glitchy as homecoming was, but having to run from absolutely everything has got to suck something awful.

  • @Crazyflake1

    There is a little of running so you won't get bored of it.

  • good graphics :D

  • this game looks sick

  • wait ps2?

  • wait wheres the epic metal pipe of epicness? no pipe WHAT NUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU~

  • personally i would get bored running away from every god dam monster they could have at lease gave you a stick or a pipe

  • "You can scribble, you can draw innappropriate pictures, you could write useful notes...

  • "The cellphone is like a motion dettector for aliens" Aliens are involved in silent hill?

  • have you ever beaten the original and gotten the alien ending?

  • well yeah i played the homecoming one and had that weird alien ending o-o i dont get why aliens are involve in this realy could you explain?lmfao

  • The alien endings of SH are jokes, just for entertainment is all, not actually meant to be a part of the story. Since I'm commenting lemme just say, wow SH on a Nintendo console, exciting stuff X3

  • @xTailsPrower

    Monsters are there, why you think aliens are joke?

  • If you've ever played any silent hill game and gotten the alien ending, it's clearly a joke. It's always something like "suddenly a ton of aliens come and blow up the town"

  • Why joke? Aliens can be someone's fantasy just like monsters.

  • Because thats just what it is, search for "Silent Hill joke ending" and you'll find them, they're intended to be funny.

  • Search for what? Videos named so because people think it was a joke. But really, why not?

  • werid how its for the wii and ps2 but not xbox. Technically is they made it for ps2 they may not have even optimized it for ps3

  • its nice too see dynamic shadows on thee wii but they have no volume to them, it completely defeats the purpose of dynamic shadows

  • also, doas anyone know what method of dynamic shadows this game uses?

  • what is a dynamic shadow? is that a type of texturing or effect in a game?

  • dynamic shadows is when shadows change direction depending on nearby light sources apposed to shadows that do not change direction.

  • ohhh i see thanx

  • man.. the graphics are bumming me out. the movement speed of the character (turns etc.) aren't realistic at all... textures on the monsters aren't good. (Dead Space Extraction = decent Wii gfx maximization). and the feel of SH, SH2 and SH3 are completely non-existent here.

  • so just run away from a monster that dose not look intimidating. i mean look at them all they do is jump on you and bite that's it.

    overall it looks good.

  • you know it feels good to shoot stuff....nowyour runnin runnin ruinnin....i liked the rust.....anyway whether its goodor not i prolly wont get to play it because it seems way to smart for my little brain. the original scared the begeeges out of me.

  • Girl on swing set is not creepy...Its cheesy...I wish Japanese people would make this game....

  • They would make a girl come out of a well or a TV...

  • Wow The Ring...then Americans copied it to make cheap money since they're not creative. Stop supporting Climax, they fail in every aspect.

  • The Ring, however, was one of the best Americanized Japanese films.

  • For the "best" it still wasn't great.

  • 1:40 I hate how when the monster jumps on his back the monster is through him

  • @dries86 well its still in progress remember that