Added: 8 months ago
From: goldpikpikcarrots
Views: 30,877
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (284)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • You had me at the shoes tapping out the beat <3

  • Whenever I want to listen to the song, I always go on this one over the one that won. :)

  • if you did not watch this movie YOU HAVE NO CHILDHOOD

  • I agree, I feel like this one should've one. But those who are complaining about the winning one being animated shouldn't. Pogo WANTED people to be creative, he didn't mind if people made a video like he would, but he never said they couldn't do anything outside the box.

    In my opinion, all the winning videos are deserving and well done to the people who made them :)

  • You guys do realize Pogo made this account right? Haha he made this and was caught by a fan :D

  • To me, this is will always be the winning video. 

  • This should have won.

    It is incredible, I bet it took forever to make this. :D

  • I love it so much, happy to have voted for it, shame there is no link to it in Pogo's account anymore, took me 10 mins to find it!

  • this amazing love Pogo!

  • This should have won first place; it's beautiful, and seems as if it was done by Pogo ♥

  • you should have won imo

  • My favourite of the Mellow Brick Road videos!

  • YOU ARE AMAZING!

    I am in awe of your talent. This must have taken you forever to find the right pieces to cut together and then to edit it all so beautifully - well done!

    I want more!!!

  • WIN

  • Real Deal !!!

    DONE

  • This turned out really good!

    I like how you took the time to find all those clips from certain scenes of the movie and actually match up close to the audio remix as well. It was really fun to watch this and very enjoyable, too. I'm with chiixichigo, this looks like something Pogo made himself. :)

    Good job!

  • This is my favorite one. I've got nothing against the animated ones, but they don't have that 'Pogo feel'.

  • Comment removed

  • @3:00 "Use it in your bottom"

  • @1:57 I Can SMOKE ?!

  • This diserved to win.

  • 14 people have no taste in music.

  • I wish this won. I don't really like the animated one, it feels rushed. I'm sure it must have taken you a long time to get this together and finding each clip to match the vocals.

  • i think i like the up remix better

  • I outta send Paramount the link to this video; they could use it for a promo

  • @jfritzyb Or they have it taken down for copyright violations.

  • This one should have won, I love it way better than the others.

  • it seems that others have copied this video, claiming it's theirs... a shame really!

  • @Brinah really? where?

  • @goldpikpikcarrots let me retract; I saw a video that's similar but not copied exactly for the same contest!

    /watch?v=xoZ_LUWJ1lA

  • @Brinah That video was released June 15 2011, this one was released June 9, 2011.

    *facepalm*

  • @MrUselessBanana Yeah, so? 

  • OK, I respect the fact that Pogo wanted to releases this song sooner than later by letting the public create a video. However, a stick man?, Tom and Jerry?, and construction paper?

    This is by far MY official "Mellow Brick Road" video. And i strongly believe in the "KISS" method.......Keep It Simple Stupid.

  • Comment removed

  • This should have won.

  • Beautiful!

    :D

  • 3:01-3:17 great Wicked Witch solo

  • WoW- Weeeee, Whew...

  • I think this was the best one made personally

  • Comment removed

  • does anybody else hear "pixie dust" when it's really Dorothy saying "things he does"??

  • so much butthurt in these comments, its delicious.

  • For some reason, the shot of Dorothy tapping her heels together at the beginning, paired with the beatiful music, makes me feel all happy inside.

  • I like this one better... sssshhhh!

  • This has instantly become my all-time favourite you tube video. Absolutely superb. I cannot watch it without a big smile on my face. Very, very well done goldpipikcarrots.

  • I think this should have won. The other entries were good but this was the most pogoish :P

  • This should have won. Seriously. The amount of effort you put into finding the exact split-second moments to match BACK up with the appropriate sounds alone must have been immense. I tried doing the same thing, but gave up. Well done!

  • Oh darn... I was really hopin your video would get 1st... still, this one is still my favorite so I'm happy that at least it got recognized as 3rd. :)

    But other than that, I'm happy with how the contest came out.

    Great job, goldpikpikcarrots! :D

  • I thought the video that won was well done....but this definitely should have been in 1st place....

  • This will always be the Mellow Brick Road video. :)

  • yeh i dont understand how u didnt win, ur videos are just pogolistic! at least the stick didnt win thank god!

  • Whoever picked that damn animated video as the winner doesn't know anything about pogo and what he would do for the video for this song. He would have used ACTUAL CLIPS FROM THE MOVIE! NOT A CUSTOM ANIMATION. Amazing job goldpikpikcarrots :) You are the winner

  • No matter what, this one will always be the winner, not that animated crap of a video that got picked >< WTFF

  • Why couldn't this one have been the winner!? WTF? :( You guys suck -_-

  • Beautiful and dream-like. It really captures the magic of the movie!!!

  • I hate that this didn't win.

  • wow how did this not win it looks like Pogo did this himself holy crap GREAT JOB

  • Sorry you didn't win... :(

  • great editing!!! love it

  • The spirit of Pogo lives in you!!!

  • this is so brilliant - i seriously hope this wins the competition, it looks like Pogo did it himself, well done!

  • Definitely as Pogo would have done it. I suppose that doesn't necessarily mean that its the best though. Certainly the best to use exclusively clips from Wizard of Oz

  • awesome! favourited!

  • It looks like you did something to the frame rate when you imported the footage. Did you use some kind of motion correction or HD playback tool? There's not as much of a blur track as is in the actual footage.

  • Congratulations on a beautiful pogo-esque video. You matched his style impeccably and the A/V sync is incredible. Finding all of those clips must have been insanely tedious. Great work!

  • Fukken saved!

  • this video may not be "original" but what better material to use than the movie itself? I don't care who wins, whenever I want to see the video for mellow brick road, this is the video I will come to. The others are good and "original" but aren't classic pogo video style and don't capture the movie at all. This video deserves to win.

  • i'm afraid I came to this competition late in the game and so am only now just getting my first glimpse.  And when I saw this contest, my first thought was, "Well, damn. Now I'll never know where the clips are from." As Pogo said, "Couldn't have done it better myself!" High praise for a great video. And the reverse engineering comment is spot on.

  • I wish the 12k views were turned into votes, I want your video to win the most because it remains under the pogo law of how videos follow. The others were nice, don't get me wrong, But when I hear any of pogos songs, I always think about the video that went along with it, with the characters talking or dancing at the time.

  • Wait, so did you go back and find each of the audio clips from the song and match them to their video clips? That's some goddamned reverse engineering right there. Nice work.

  • @GreatColors The freezes were on purpose.

  • @goldpikpikcarrots I can see that now, but the rest of my previous comment still stands. Thanks for making me understand the freezing though.

  • @GreatColors "I Dont Mean To Nit-Pick" But Fuck You(:

  • @DuhSparkleMuncher You're the asshole side of pogo's fan-base, trying to be cute by bashing every semi-negative comment that doesn't agree with your opinion. Stop thinking so high and mighty of yourself. No one asked for your harsh response. Everyone thinks differently. God. It's people like you that make his fans appear elitist simply because they like a "different" underestimated type of music. Kindly get your head out your ass. You aren't funny. =/

  • @GreatColors i hate people who go on youtube to try sound smart and put other people down... keep quiet its a great video

  • @cormacogara I wasn't trying to put the creator down. There were just a few things that I thought didn't work well in the video and felt the need to state my opinion. Overall I liked it and appreciate the hard work put into the entry. Someone steps outside the popular opinion once and you all attack. You people need to stop being so sensitive.

  • Based purely on the fact that this entry took only 4 days to complete, while the other top entries took 12 days to make shows class. This masterpiece was finished well before the others and therefore deserves to win.

  • this was made beautifully but sadly its just not original. this is pogo's natural approach to making vides, and the point of the contest was to make origianl out of the box videos.

    this was amazing and a joy to watch over and over again but you do not hav my vote :/

    on a side not lets give a hand to judy garland for dancing around in high heels, must have been a lot of work on her feet XD

  • You win :)

  • Although this probably took a lot of work, the task of creating a unique video was not accomplished imo. I know this got a nod from Pogo, and probably would be his regular approach, but that's just it. It is a regular approach to what was asked of all competitors. I've seen more originality in the other videos. That is what makes this all fun. Best I could say for this one is that it did Pogo a favor of being done so he didn't have to do it.

  • the scarecrow cracks me up with his forehead wipe

  • you need to win. NEED TO.

  • I want this one to win! I don't know why it's not winning!! =[

  • Love this one! My vote goes to you!

  • This is my favourite ! :)

  • @sahills Me too!!

  • How the heck could this video not win?!

  • This follows his style perfectly, definitely this one! :)

  • This one just seems more pogo i vote yours :)

  • i like your the best

  • This is the same genuine that's private you're running down too be funny and it's funny? This is the same genuine that's inside out today you're... running...

  • very POGOish!. hope you win

  • This seriously looks like it was done by Pogo himself, absolutely beautiful~

  • Comment removed

  • @chiixichigo Because he did do it himself :D

  • Every vid in the top 5 is indeed great and beautifully produced, but this one has to be my favorite cuz it follows Pogo's trend and line of videos. Good job mate.

  • Wow. I loved every vid in the top 5, they are all awesome, but this is most definitely the best of them. It matches the track perfectly, and makes me want to dance - just like Pogo's own videos. Lovely.

  • @Sparkonetwo Wholeheartedly agree. Nearly half the other entries in the contest tried something like this, and honestly, weren't all that good. It's obviously much more difficult than it seems; I think it takes a certain finesse to create a video like this that flows well. This one definitely has my support.

  • love it hope you win

  • This is the only video that does the track justice. The other video entries might be creative, but they don't capture the whole feel of the song. Anything being used besides the actual film that the track is representing just degrades it. I don't think this video will win and I'm a little disappointed in the fans who are going to allow of the other video entries be the official embarrassment for such a great track.

  • i thnink the other competetors, put their vid on more social platforms, or could spread more in the net, like goldpikpikcarrots.

    i votet for you cause this is the original pogo, like everyone knows.

    couldn't belive the count of the others they are so far ahead; the other competetors must be cheating or something.

  • This is amazing!!! :DD

  • After seeing all the other entries, I must say this deserves to win the most as far as I'm concerned. Yeah the others are cute and all, but this one follows the traditional video style of Pogo, which I think shouldn't change. Nice job!

  • @dariendude17

    exactly, and that stupid fucking one with the SAME shot of the stick figure dancing is winning...

    PEOPLE ARE FUCKING STUPID...and they disappoint me. Can you HONESTLY say going onto his yt site, seeing all these professionaly edited videos, and then seeing THAT peice of shit (even the thumbnail would look offputting) makes you.....nm, I'm just ranting now lol

  • @joemcbobinite Calm down. Bashing other people's opinions like that just make you an elitist in a bad way. The reason people choose the stickfigure video is because it is so lively and does a very good job of the emotions that people go through when listening to pogo videos. maybe it doesn't work for you, and it doesn't touch you. But that doesn't mean it's just bad bad bad. It's just not your taste.

  • @HannekeDebie

    theres just so much more.."love", involved into making this one tho...

  • @joemcbobinite This one might... actually be him signing up for a new account and submitting in his own contest, but people are voting for the stick figure one just because it's a new perspective on these. He did the stick figure so it'd be simple, or he's lazy. Either way, that one got my vote because I like seeing him perform the songs.

    If that one didn't exist, this would be my choice, though.

  • @joemcbobinite @HannekeDebie @NatSams10 Hey, momentai. You're forgetting what the competition is about. Its about creativity and everyone coming together to show what we can all create. Nobody loses, we all win. Shame on you.

  • why is this one not winning!! everyone go to pogo's website and vote for goldpikpikcarrots to win! this is a true winner!!!!

  • @PornStar2823

    people are stupidfucks thats why.

  • @joemcbobinite you have a "smoke session" playlist?

  • @MarsPearls yep.for when im smokin up and wanna hear the wondrful sounds of pogo and many others.lol

  • @joemcbobinite oh, I guess that makes sense, sometimes when I watch Pogo's videos it feels like drugs to me, especially alice.

  • you should have won

    I seriously dont get why he the rest didnt ACTUALLY use movie footage

    WTF T-T

    GREAT JOB!!!!!!!!!

    You should be proud!

  • YAY!

  • Wait, so this is Pogo's work! XDD

  • Got the spirit of pogo :)

  • Can't see why this one wouldn't win.

  • Comment removed

  • Part of me wants this one to win as it sticks with pogo's original format, but activeobjectx's was just too entertaining, had to vote for him x.x

    Good luck regardless

  • Voted.

  • simply amazing..fantastic

  • great video much pogo like everything is perfect im bout to make my decision between lolits matt and you

  • i am super impressed. i had started making a video out of the movie for the competition as well and could not for the life of me find every speaking part! but u did! awesome.i had to leave the country a day after the contest was announced but i will try and finish when i get back!

  • This is beautiful, teeming with the happy glow-y warmness of nostalgia of watching this as a kid - As Pogo vdeos should be. This is the closest to his style. It's not right to take the imagery away from the music. You certainly got my vote, and would get many more from me if it would let me vote again!

    Good Luck, hope to see more from you. :)

  • Had to vote for this one, i just love this film too much. Nostalgia, much!

  • I love you for this. So much.

  • FANTASTIC!!! 8-D

  • I think this is truest to the style that Pogo has established with his own vids. I think it's very well done!!

  • YO ARE THE TOP 5!!! I HAVE SUPPORTING YOU THE WHOLE WAY!!! YOUR IN FOR THE WIN!!!!!!

  • 1:05 to 1:13 brings a genuine smile to my face. ; u;

  • I like this video because it follows the same idea as Pogos videos... Very well done!

  • Beautiful :')

  • got my vote

  • You know I think that this is the true way to enjoy movies

  • Awesome vid. Loving that you kept it in the style of Pogo's editing

  • @goldpikpikcarrots

    I voted for you! You have to win now! xD

  • Thank you everyone so much for your support! I plan on keeping this video up even if I don't win the competition. And look forward to more fan videos! Thanks again! :D

  • @goldpikpikcarrots Pfft. Like you'll lose!

  • 3:31 

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • voted

  • My only peeve about this one is that some of the scenes were used a bit too much for my taste, but overall I loved it. Although the other entries were well made and fit the music perfectly, this one had the Pogo style which I was looking for.

    You got my vote. ;)

  • Defffffffffinitely got my vote. Although all the others were a stylistically distinct from Pogo's regular videos, this one was the most compelling. It is the only one that really carries the song's energy and truly "works".

  • At first glance, I knew I would love your one. It brought shivers down my legs due to the elegance and continues to carry on with Pogo's imagery for his works. I'm not a huge fan of favourtism and choosing one person to win something, but I do hope you continue with your fan videos so people can have a fresh breath of music to listen to. Good luck to all the entrants.

  • What sends chills up my spine is when Dorothy clicks her heals to the beat

  • dude this is fucking amazing. congratulations whether you win or not. Absolutely wonderful and would love to see more!

    Encore!

  • This one is the most connected to the song!

  • gold, its ApertureDreams. My vote is your video, FOR SURE. Good job, man. :D

  • WOW!!!!! THIS ONE HAS TO WIN!!!!

  • fantastic video :)

    i love this and the stick figure (producing music) videos, but to me, the pogo videos are about seeing the emotion in the characters faces during each part of the song, like with bangarang/expiladicious/skynet symphonic etc. etc.

    You picked out the parts from the film exceptionally, and it has defiantely got that pogo feel to it! :D

  • All I can say is... Excellent!

  • Spectacular work!  Congrats on making the top 5, and best of luck!

  • ohh...back in the 60's when nothin was CGI ....

  • @detestosu >mfw this movie was made in 1939

  • Hoping either you or Ifurget beat out that stick figure animation (Why is it so popular anyway?)

    Regardless, this is the video I'll be opening when I want to hear Mellow Brick Road, official or not.

  • I love every video, but I have to vote for this one. It's just like an official Pogo video!

  • Out of all the vids I've seen for the competition, I hope this one wins. All the other ones were entertaining, but this is the one that keeps both Pogo's style and music alive! Great work and I hope you come out on top!!

  • @PrincessTinkForever yes I agree

  • good editing! 

  • Am I the only one who hears PIXIE DUST?!? <333

  • wowww. great job.

  • You can definitely see the amount of work that went it to this. A well deserved win if it comes to it;)

  • I definately vote for this one to win because the video fits perfect with pogo's song and style, and also because this video is just plain awesome! :D

  • Gah! Now I can't decide :(

  • i hope you win man, you can tell you put hella time into this, good luck!

  • This is the best video by far. Very nicely done! It has my vote.

  • This definitely captures Pogo's style. Whoever did this, wow, you been sittin down and watching pogo video's 8 hours a day minimum to get this down to a science.

  • Comment removed

  • how did you/they know what clips to use.. must have watched this film as many times as I did lol