Bloody hell, there's constructive criticism and then there's just being rude, "it's a bastardization" is a bit out of order don't you think? I don't think a metronome is needed, and personally I think it's good, however people are right in saying it needs more emotion, it did seem like you were just playing for the sake of it, and I couldn't fully enjoy the peice, however, having said that, it was rather good. Not so harsh next time eh?
Work on smoothness, and slow down a bit. Listen to the notes more carefully, and FEEEEEEEEEEL!!! the emotions that Chopin put into this nocturne! Keep up the good work, though! ^^
i completely agree. he plays well, but theres no passion and hardly any feeling. btw i totally meant to click on the thumbs up so sorry bout that haha.
k, first of all, find a metronome. and use it, a lot. second, you're banging out notes. try making it softer. honestly, right now, it's a bastardization of how Chopin intended it.
@arsenalfooty4 true. he was the first to break from the status quo and play in a completely free, rubato style. his pieces AREN'T SUPPOSED to be played in perfect tempo like bach or mozart.
I totally agree with you. These are completely displaced comments.... OK this performance is perfectible, but not that bad at all, to start with... tempo's pretty good, to me anyway...
Yeah, play it softer.
mathsprofessional 9 months ago
I hear a lot of emotion in this...
dimakamalov 10 months ago
Comment removed
dimakamalov 10 months ago
Bloody hell, there's constructive criticism and then there's just being rude, "it's a bastardization" is a bit out of order don't you think? I don't think a metronome is needed, and personally I think it's good, however people are right in saying it needs more emotion, it did seem like you were just playing for the sake of it, and I couldn't fully enjoy the peice, however, having said that, it was rather good. Not so harsh next time eh?
HarleyBalmerHowieson 1 year ago 4
dude. this is not the way it is played. play emotionally, softer and smoother.
anshiman 1 year ago
Put some emotion into it. Its too fast as well. Listen to some other versions of it and see if that helps. It always helps me.
MissHappyAllTheTime 1 year ago
too fast, too loud with too narrow a dynamic range. work on feeling the music and the emotions... your dynamic ignorance hurts my ears
namenottaken0 2 years ago
too fast...missing the emotion and feel of the piece too... technically seems good though
namenottaken0 2 years ago
Work on smoothness, and slow down a bit. Listen to the notes more carefully, and FEEEEEEEEEEL!!! the emotions that Chopin put into this nocturne! Keep up the good work, though! ^^
Viyemelle 2 years ago
Comment removed
OriginalBasaliskos 2 years ago
You have the notes down, but you're playing way too fast in my opinion.
sswizard 2 years ago
i completely agree. he plays well, but theres no passion and hardly any feeling. btw i totally meant to click on the thumbs up so sorry bout that haha.
thecelloslave 2 years ago 3
i agree, there are dynamics but not much emotion. he also made a few mistakes in terms of stopping, unless that's supposed to be the emotion O___O.
btw i reversed your thumbs down. you're welcome ^___^
united768 2 years ago
k, first of all, find a metronome. and use it, a lot. second, you're banging out notes. try making it softer. honestly, right now, it's a bastardization of how Chopin intended it.
nikhilshinday 2 years ago 5
@nikhilshinday Did you know that Chopin hated metronomes?
arsenalfooty4 1 year ago 3
@arsenalfooty4 true. he was the first to break from the status quo and play in a completely free, rubato style. his pieces AREN'T SUPPOSED to be played in perfect tempo like bach or mozart.
gwdeckert 1 month ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Frédéric Chopin
@nikhilshinday wow music critics on youtube these days are funny.
they make it sound like they've known him since birth
they make it sound like they can play it perfectly when some of them can't even find a C
And lastly, if you think he played it badly, play it better yourself, jeez~
J3LL13Z 1 year ago 2
@J3LL13Z
I totally agree with you. These are completely displaced comments.... OK this performance is perfectible, but not that bad at all, to start with... tempo's pretty good, to me anyway...
Keep up the good work robyyoutoo!
Cedericoco 7 months ago
@nikhilshinday Maybe so, but watch what you say. It's kind of hurtful to the person
musicislife748 1 month ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Frédéric Chopin
chopin...daje joooooooo!!
rikygirl 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
if any body wants free sheet music for this you can get it at my web site
link is in my channel
thechopperdotter 2 years ago
jajaja esta medio rapidón por ser el andante me da la impresión pero bien
Macross100 3 years ago
sencillamente hermosa....
PsychedelicBat 3 years ago
it needs a lot more emotion in it. The left hand is to heavy. SOFTER!!!SMOOTHER!!!4*
pianoboy321 3 years ago
Way too fast, and emotionless :(
s33b4n4n3 3 years ago 6
too fast
Blekota272 3 years ago 3
yes you're right everyone, i think it's played too harsh, with no emotions..
but it's an awsome play though!
Nadiditta 4 years ago 2
this sounded very harsh for a chopin try and make it more smooth and even.
it is also a very emotional peice u just played notes no emotion!
scratch8d 4 years ago 2
Your left hand is just a bit heavy , but apart from this little thing than was pretty well played:)
compliments. Try to give more of you heart and soul in this nocturne and it will be nice.
frankyoriginal 4 years ago
try to play it more slowely, and att the first rit. slow down a bit more. and much more soft
thisismethenhehe 4 years ago 3
it's played like a piece of brahms:) a bit to heavy, chopin sounds more soft. nevertheless good job.
mephisto66773 4 years ago
très bien joué, mais je trouve que c'est joué un peu trop fort... c'est magnifique quand même !!!
lulupiano 4 years ago
OUI! SI! THANK YOU. :)
Slippie 4 years ago
a bit heavy in the left hand...apart from that pretty good!
avo5536 4 years ago
ein sehr schönes stück.
angeldust189 4 years ago
Emozionante!!amo questo notturno...
Tizy86 4 years ago