Added: 5 years ago
From: marinersfanfromny
Views: 38,665
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (126)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • okay, so, what was in the egg ??

  • Her hair looks like over-cooked pasta.

  • Just as a little note, I'd like to comment on the birds and the fish. I think that the man may represent a bird: he doesn't have limitations, he's seems to be a wanderer of sorts. The girl is a fish: attracted to water, and chained to a specific place, like how a fish must stay in water.

  • I'll admit, I teared up a bit when she screamed.

  • 5:35 is about the part I stopped trying to understand.

  • I'm so confused, I really like this movie but I don't get what it's about. I've heard so many explinations but none of them really make sense.

  • @herana01 Yeah I thought so too, and metaphorically got her pregnant in the process. I think the part where she falls into the cliff/water is her going into labor, since she kisses an adult version of her and becomes it, and then holds her abdomen (her womb), and then drowns in the water (dies while giving birth).

  • @PuraraX I love your take, that was so well put. And I am also a bit antsy on the interpretation of the breaking of the egg as rape since it doesn't really seem that way to me, but it's open interpretation to each person, so whatever pleases them, I guess...

  • @hifef Yeah, he showed too much care of her for it to be rape... But heck, the possibility of a very sex-less procreation motif (à la ghost in the shell) had not occurred to me yet....

  • ありがとう

  • VERY IMPORTANT, I am currently collecting emails and messages to send to Criterion in an effort to get a release of this film. Everyone, please contact me as soon as possible to support this wonderous film. SIncerly, Angel's Egg Coalition.

  • @Fragile0Still Do you have a website?

  • I am so confussed I love this movie I just don't understand it

  • Comment removed

  • Damn symbolism ruined this movie. Why did the writer have to leave everything to our respective and greatly varying points of views? It was so interesting...

  • Could the shadow fish represent the piscean age and the girl and her bottles of water represent the aquarian age?

  • I feel the girl was in fact an angel of the depicted "rebirth" who had lost her/its way, or wished to hide from its fate through the guise of youth, simplicity and purity. The man struck me as a missionary to expose her and set the rebirth into movement once again. Of course, that's just one way of looking at it...

  • She at first protests his 'advances' (following/protecting), much as many shy or closeted girls would if a guy expresses interest so brazenly, yet soon welcomes it despite possible hazards, surrendering to needful whims - tempting fate (perhaps hinted at when she lifted her dress needlessly - sort of tentative female to male teasing).

  • A lonesome individual, innocent in the fact that she knows so little of others and does not understand the callous world that she lives in - the man brings new words and logic and method to her, and she somehow becomes infatuated/ her mental simplicity is challenged. - The man brings new views and ideals, and she is forced to realise that the world goes beyond herself, her egg, her jam and water...

  • I understand how people always fall upon the whole rape bandwagon - it just sounds so hardcore, and physical corruption is so infatuating to us in place of mental. But really, I feel that we only truly "see" the girl for the first time at the very end of the movie/clip. She has always been a grown woman. Only, the viewer sees her as a child for that is how she wishes to see herself.

  • Comment removed

  • I could stare at the artwork of this movie for days on end O-O

  • Holy shit, the whole movie is all quiet and then all of a sudden she screams. Damn. Guess I don't need my shot of coffee today.

  • @fromthesixstory ohh your telling me i saw her face screw up and i knew what was coming and i just thought "oh heck"

  • oh, i get it. so she got 'raped' and was 'impregnated' and therefore produced new eggs to replace the old one? so it's like a life cycle.

  • Not to be a perv or anything (well I AM a girl so I don't think it counts anyways) but did she just grow boobs when she was in the water?

  • would this be considered film noir?

  • I don't understand everything, but in many works of art, birds represent freedom. The man smashing the girl's egg......... He took away her freedom of life

  • I'm a christian and everything, I mean I love talking about God and studying the Bible, and I mean studying for fun. But I think this movie has nothing to do with Christianity...

  • @cottoncandy113 Read interviews with the director Mamoru Oshii, and you'll find that he wanted to Join the seminary at one point and this film was his expression with a disillusion with his faith.

  • But, what was the "egg" at the beginning with clearly a bird fetus inside.

    And, what and where did that machine come from?

    Much like "Windaria"

  • cont... Our concern is with the girl, however, so she is shown clearly on the ship. Her soul is in ascent. Below we see the soul prison or "purgatory" where Christ continues his quest for other souls (perhaps this last part is a stretch, but clearly he does not leave...). He carries a cross which is a "weapon" of a spiritual type. His hands are covered to hide his wounds and he asks the only pertinent question ultimately reserved for God: the rhetorical "who are you?"

  • @tegulum1

    Awww, just fucking stop it, you fucking fundie.

  • @St1gar Stop what???

  • cont... I think they are represented as statues because that is the symbol of God's workmanship: the symbol is a statue. The egg is the girl's faith and hope. But it's not empty. When it breaks she is released from the soul prison. I assume that she drowned in the flood like everyone else. Those who seek out God will find him. I think that the fishermen are such seekers as well. There is no reason to assume that the fishermen were not among the "saved" on the ship.

  • This seems to be an interpretation of the short account St. Peter gives of Christ's descent into the soul prison. The soul prison (if I remember correctly) holds souls from before the flood. They are given the gospel by Christ and when they hear it they are saved. They then leave with Him. (In the Bible this takes place right after the crucifixion as the earthquake breaks open the graves and the souls venture heavenward).

  • well maybe that girl was crying because her egg is broken and in the end she sacrifice her life to bring the the egg/birds to exist. that could be her hope to bring the egg alive.

  • To me the whole section mean something positive ,rebirth or something like this( compare bird's skeleton with embrion in big egg, girl/woman in angel's choir i.e. Heaven or similary).

    Girl's cry maybe represent suffering when she realize something( maybe maturity, I don't know in that moment).

    But meaning is more philosopical/estachological to me than antropological( like rites of passage and similar stuff).

    Great movie anyway xD

  • My theory is the soldier is the Angel of Death. He is not necessarily( however you spell that) evil, but is looked upon as bad because he ends life, in this case the protector of life ,and a future life giver when she becomes an adult , the little girl. When he breaks the egg, he seems to know that the girl will die soon because he sees her soul off to heaven where she is a angel, the part where she is a statue on the machine rising to the sky.

  • That guy was some kinda douche. Coming out of nowhere just to destroy the girl's hope and then run away again.

  • If you support this movie, vote it up past 8.0 on IMDB. More exposure will hopefully result in an eventual Blu-Ray release.

  • Dramatic crying..

  • ='(

    so sad..poor girl...

    but now I notice...the sky was red the last time the machine rised.. since then, the sky turned black.

  • and she was at the center of that grand ark upon the sky. remnants of war passed by, the man was a soldier of the last futile remaining ppl running about. but their time ran out long ago...

  • its hard to nderstand for me...... what about the feathers at the end...whats this huge mashine and why does he break her egg..... where did this egg come from

  • @oOLeetahOo remember the fossilized angel? it was her egg. the huge machine is the heaven where the girl returns after dying. the feathers are angels' feathers.

  • New Intereoitation now that i see, That large eye looking thing, represents Heaven. The girl, representing Christ. Christ grew up to become a man to save man. This girl had lost what was precious to her and as she died, she gave life (the eggs) and returned to Heaven. If you noticed, the place where she was sitting looked like a throne while the other people were standing.

  • Hm. "A girl must grow up and change to become a woman. She gives her life to her offspring so they may live. So theyw ill continue on."

  • @Selenewerewolf

    loss of innocence -broken shell of egg-nature is forceful with women

    rites of passage from child to adult. same with the world the characters were living it is broken

    where as man must be forceful with nature

    conquer and do his duty to the state or his beliefs

    the world is ripe for rebirth

  • Poor girl, it makes me so sad :'(

  • I have added a Facebook group to discuss this movie.

  • @marinersfanfromny Dude, do a search for EGGS OF A FALLEN ANGEL. I can't put the link here or upload it to youtube due to copyright issues, but it's a gut-wrenching overdub I did and uploaded to my website...which you might also find interesting. ;-)

  • anyone will see a diferent explanation of the movie , it doesnt matter if you dont undernstand the movie

    thaths the poit i

  • The article will clarify the whole film.

  • There's a translation on wikipedia that is the most in-depth and accurate analysis of the film. If you're really interested in the symbolism I suggest reading it. Just wiki "Angel's Egg" and the article will come up

  • to prove my point, you can clearly see that she tried to kill herself by jumping off the cliff as she was devastated that the egg had been broken.. and the minute she touched the water, she transformed into a lady.. and from her comes other eggs which is to remind us that there are lots of little girls like that in this world.. and they need to keep what's pure and precious with them and not to give it away till the time is right..

  • I agree and disagree. At 4:33 she doesn't look like she tried to kill herself. She looks like she was running after the man but just fell into the ravine on accident.

    I did watch this before seeing your post. I agree on the innocence. She clutched her stomach, chest then throat in the water after she became a woman.

    It chilled me. I had to look to see if anyone saw it too.

    So that huge sphere was the gothic city half buried?

  • Woah- I didn't notice that the first time before!O.O her transformation that is, it happened so fast. Good eye!

  • upon analysing the bigger scheme of things, i'm quite sure that the egg represent's a girl's virginity.. and when it has been taken away, she no longer is a child.. she becomes a mature woman, as her innoncence and childlikeness has been robbed from her.. and yes, i think he did rape her in the end..

  • OMG! it seems so obvios now!!!!!!!!!

    THANK YOU!

    n i thought itw as abotu christianity .. no wonder i was confused

  • Ya tht's wat i was thinkin too, but it was so hard to believe tht guy raped her (he looked like a nice guy)

    I guess it makes more sense now...

  • @electropanda

    Yep. It's clear how he sneakingly 'got' the egg when she was asleep and the lights went out. The way she transformed into a 'woman' is also a give-away.

  • C'mon!! only like 0.03% of the people who have commented this understood this movie!!!

    so stop trying to sound smart

  • I'm confused, can some one please explain whats going on?

  • One of the darkest and most twisted animes I've seen in a while.

    Extremely good though.

  • that scream took me off guard. o.O

  • wtf he raped her?!? D:>

    omg poor girl!!! poor, poor girl!!!

    and those cries as she layed on top of the shattered pieces of her egg :'(

    what does her going after the soldier symbolize???

  • @GoC

    Probably wanting to take back what was rightfully hers, or chasing him out of anger, or "why" he did it.

    That soldier is a pedo!

  • lol....omelette for breakfast!!

  • SPOILER being in such a world and losing the thing that she lived for its no surprise she died. l like to believe the egg was common and she was delusional while the angel fossil was merely something else more sinister. the man's story is incomplete.

  • ok now i really dont get it. why did he crack the egg???

  • This movie was really terrific, I wonder if Angel and that man were the last two people there...That would be rather sad...

  • why not? they would reporoduce again like adam and eve and create a new world

  • that would be a bit kinky having to have sex with my sister....

  • It's like that giant ball thing is heaven, and all of those statue's are angels, and all of the statues from that city were people that have to chase the shadows of dreams, that they will never catch. And there was an ark, he did mention Noah, so I guess this movie could be an alternate ending of the fable "Noah's Ark" if they people gave up and never returned to land...or something to that effect XDD.

  • ...why? lol, that was philisophical!

  • o_O? wtf is all i have to say lol

  • For some reason this movie at this part reminds me of something off of Noah's ark. With the rain. And the town that's being destroyed or soon to be....

  • ok so these trees'' with eggs on top are obviously killing the earth right? he said earlier he remember a tree coming out of the horizon and sucking the life from the earth was he referring to the one in the beg.?

  • reminds me of Eraserhead!

  • is that big thing at the end supposed to represent Heaven?

  • thats exactly what i was thinkin

  • Mamoru Oshii + Yoshitaka Amano = win

  • HUHHHHHHHHHHHH...........

  • Now, the actual why??? well, sex is never just sex. Here, even though in a cruel way, he liberates her from her obsession.

  • Why did he have to break her egg? Was he really that curious about its content? Was he a bad guy that just wanted to crush her? Was it just because he didn't want anybody else to be happier than he was? I still don't get it. Can someone please tell me?

  • He has a sword (phallic symbol), she has an egg (fertile symbol). He breaking the egg without her permission (rape). ~He took the girl's innocense. T-T

  • ok, now it makes sense, because I wa sjust asking the same questions to myself what Lemonadder was asking..its kinda sad really too..

  • Now that make sense.Thanks

  • Creepy...that does sort of explain why she appeared to age 10 years right before she died. Her innocence was deteriorating, and she'd never be the same again...

  • @herana01 Looks more like a gun to me, what with the barrel and no blade.

  • @herana01

    Interesting concept

  • @herana01 that actually makes sense!!!!!!!!!!!!!! o.o

  • @herana01 that is NOT a sword

  • @jedancovek What is it then? (either way, it still fits phallic symbol qualities).

  • @herana01 I think it's a little more deep/complex than rape, like going more with taking the innocence in some way than a sexual line. Haha, I was like "DAMN, HOW COULD I NOT REALISE?" when I saw how phallic the cross and that line of vehicles were. I'm trying to figure out whether the fact that all these phallic symbols are metallic and machine-like bears importance...

  • @kalacs32 Now that you mention it, it makes me want to re-watch this movie just to look for all that. Somehow your comment reminded me of Asuka's mind rape (from Evangelion).

  • @herana01 ermmm I dun wanna sound like a retard...but what exactly is phallic?

  • @xXPandaTsubasaXx a representation of the male reproductive organ, usually anything that is long and brings power from withing itself. A staff, a sword, a loooong Car, a tall building.. you name it! ( You made me remember when I had this explained for the first time during English class.) My mind of course expanded to identify phallic symbols from then on!

  • @kalacs32 Well, I'm not sure wether I agree with your interpretation but... aren't machines and especially weapons often associated with masculinity?

  • @herana01 Oh man you´re right! That was really like a rapescene poor girl. :(

  • that part with the feathers stirring on the ground just before they flew off... ingenious rite there...

  • i dont think there was anything in that egg its all metaphors. the end ripped my heart out but in many ways im glad her life ended so she no longer had to put up with that lonley world.

  • when she falls in the water, notice how much her face and body have changed, she isn't a child anymore but a woman, and her dying breath gives birth to new life, new eggs. Death and rebirth.

  • She became a woman cause the man breaking her egg represented rape and thus a loss of innocence.

  • poor girl her egg broke

  • So strange and beautiful, yet sad. It bring tears to my eyes. :'/

  • Could anyone please tell me what is happening and going on in this movie because this is such an amazing clip and I have no idea whats going on

  • best i can say is, watch from the beginning and read the wikipedia page on it

  • lo amo contacteme alguien casi nadie conose esta peli y yo la amo lovesmenot23@hotmailcom

  • It's bringing tears to my eyes...

  • So powerful! So beautiful... It makes me want to...hug my computer...

  • i recognized an elemnt of oshii, the part where she touched her reflaction resembels 2 scenes from ghost in the shell (movies 1 and 2{there are 3}), although it was also in masamune's 1'st GITS manga.

  • Though Angel's Egg is much older than GITS Innocence. Angel's egg came out in 1985.

  • oh, yes i know, i just meant how he uses it, i know that this is older (:

  • ^^ i love it

    lo amo

  • *shudder* those cries...

  • *agrees*

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more