Q&A with Hassanain Rajabali & Sheikh Jehad Ismail - 7

[nazifdaniel]

did shia coporate with wahabi and english to bring down ottomon chalipate?

[TheSukainaJaffer]

lol. The eye and its electrical energy xD

[afilahk]

Assalamoualakoum.

it is a good video and i have seen other videos of HR, however he made a mistake with the story of the women and the baby. This story did not occur to Ali, but to Prophet Sulayman (AS). just thought i would share.

salaam

[QambarAH]

What precise answers, even then if someone doen't understand, ALLAH help him.

[MAFHHZB]

"TRUTH unmasked: THE ARAB PROPHET AND HIS FAMILY"

The Trilogy is finally here. Know what you didnt know.

Y.tube link: watch?v=1Ge_iMBX-ko&feature=Pl­ayList&p=444D450B7B5DC05E&inde­x=0&playnext=1

[shahkalender]

You idiot

Hz. Abu Bakr and Hz. Umar are father in laws of Hz. Rasulullah SAV and Hz. Uthman is the two times son in law of Hz. Rasulullah SAV. Is this no t the most intimate affiliation?

Is Uthman RA not from ehl-i beyt, are his sons and daughters not the grandsons of Hz. Rasulullah?

Answer the question idiot

all you say is stupidity, first of all there is no ayat about Mehdi and what is this masumiyet, except Hz. Rasulullah SAV nobody is masum but only mahfuz

[humayunka]

u r indeed a total and utter jaahil. the prophet had only one daughter and his grandchildren were only 2, imam hassan and imam hussain. All your imagination cannot change that. show me an established book, sunni or shia, which says otherwise. you are a buffoon and base ur history on crap.

[Aloosh12]

@humayunka what?! brother remove this comment.... shame on you there are many and many hadiths from the imaams stating that the prophet had 4 daughters.

[ReligionofAbraham]

Did you know that Uthman ibn Affan banished the great and beloved Abu Dharr into a deserted land to die?? What do you think of your caliph now?

[imandxb31]

Do you accept the sunni hadith book ????

Do you accept Sahih Muslim, or you think you are better than the sahabah of the prophet????

Now read this:

Sahih Muslim:Book 31(Chapter 4 : THE MERITS OF 'ALI B. ABI TALIB (ALLAH BE PLEASED WITH HIM)), Number 5920, 5921, 5922, 5923

Allahoma Sale Ala Mohammad Wa Ale Mohammad

[Aloosh12]

wow man... sob7an allah

[hinaz]

Yay my favourite two speakers! Mash-Allah!

[shiagirl13]

MAY ALLAH BLEES ALL THOSE WHO TEACH ABOUT ISLAMLIKE THESE TWO Hassanain Rajabali & Sheikh Jehad Ismail

[theiraqi1]

aflaha man sala 3ala muahmmed wa alee mauhmmed!!!!

[14infallible]

Allahoma salli aala Mohammden wa Ali wa Fatima wal-Hassan wal-Hussein, wa Ali ebnal-Hussein, wa Mohammad ebna-Ali, wa Jaafar ebna-Mohammaden, wa Moussa ebna-Jaafar, wa Ali ebna Moussa, wa Mohammad ebna-Ali, wa Ali ebna-Mohammad, wal-Hassan ebna-Ali wal-Khalaf el-Hadi el-Mahdi......

Hojjajo Allah aala ebadihi wa omanaehi fi beladeh, salatan kathiratan daaaaaaaaaaaema!!

[trueislam14]

Nice video!

[Cefaclorskies]

having a similar problem. Whats his email? Searched the net for a long time to no avail.

[ikermalli]

Does anyone know his email? I want to ask him something

[AngelBeauty92]

thank u so much Jazak Allah Khair

this make me feel like im not the only one going through these spiritual difficulties

[lostprophet786]

How do you know it was the Khalifa Umar and Uthman and not any other Umar and Uthman?

Last time I read history quite a few people had those names at the time of the Prophet.

[BiGaLz007]

Man your freaking stupid what about Abu Bakr that Ali(R) named. It was his nickname, know one else had it loll. Keep finding excuses.

[lostprophet786]

"Man your freaking stupid"

Great manners, is that how the Prophet taught you to interact?

"It was his nickname, know one else had it"

answering-ansar. org/answers/names/en/index. php

Read the section on Abu Bakr. There were at least 9 other Abu Bakr's in Arabia according to YOUR sources.

[LightofMuhammad]

Great Video, many good points covered.

[tagman2]

we deny her words because she turned against prophet mohammeds successor, daughter and grandchildren....they are the real anlul bayt,,,Aisha was not under the sacred cloak whn prophet mohammed PBUH blessed his family.....that is why

[watchnlearn07]

The prophet muhameds successor was Abu Baker which happens to be her father ;) Would you turn against your father??????

[lostprophet786]

"The prophet muhameds successor was Abu Baker"

-How did he become successor?

-Did the Prophet say Abu Bakr will be the successor?

"Would you turn against your father??????"

Mohammad bin Abu Bakr, the son of Abu Bakr fought against Ayesha in the Battle of the Camel, and also planned the murder of Uthman, so history has shown that Abu Bakr's own son went against him.

en.wikipedia. org/wiki/Muhammad_ibn_Abi_Bakr

[watchnlearn07]

OMG Wikipedia are u joking right now? Is this where u get your info? WOW.

[lostprophet786]

Wikipedia is an unreliable source I know, but sometimes it references its statements, so look at the reference section at the bottom. (",)

[watchnlearn07]

The quran is all I need for reference. Ali (ra) being the successor is a BIG part of religion. How come it isn't mentioned in the quran? Or the 12 imams??? Were they under the 'sacred cloak' when the family was blessed.??? Or praying on a piece of clay? Do me a favor and ask yourself one question: What would it be like if Ali was made successor?

[lostprophet786]

I was talking about Historical references and you bring up the Quran?

[watchnlearn07]

The quran should be your number one reference and if any other reference interferes and contadicts the quran you need to drop that reference. So tell me...what would it be like if Ali (ra) became successor.

[lostprophet786]

I dont think you understand. I was talking about the life of the son of Abu Bakr and you put forward the Quran as a reference.

"The quran is all I need for reference"

When you want to study the biography of a person, do you use the Quran as your reference?

"what would it be like if Ali (ra) became successor"

Peace, Love and Justice.

[watchnlearn07]

If Ali created peace love and justice then I guess the Mehdi wouldn't be neccessary right? If something contradicts the quran that means it is false.

[lostprophet786]

"If something contradicts the quran that means it is false"

I dont think you understand what I am saying.

If I was to ask you when World War 2 happened, would you look in the Quran for the answer or a History book?

[watchnlearn07]

Of course I would look in the history book. You are right. But what I mean is that sometimes a piece of history that is told contradicts the quran...like it doesn't flow with the quran. This is when we have to assume that it is false.

[lostprophet786]

Thank you for your words of wisdom.

As for your question of Ali being the successor and the impact this would have had on the Mahdi, this is a very delicate and sensitive area, and I am not a Shia Scholar, I am only a student.

[lostprophet786]

It is a very very good question, which has got me thinking for quite a while (",). After reading the question, the first response which came into my mind was Imam Mahdi would create love, peace and justice all over the world, whereas Ali, would have only been able to do so in the Arabian Peninsula, keeping in mind offensive wars in Islam are forbidden.

[lostprophet786]

Another point is just because Ali would create peace, love and justice within the community, does not mean that their would be no opposition. Abu Jahl opposed Allah's greatest messenger, and I personally could see many opposing Ali also.

The goal of Imam Mahdi is to make Islam a universal religion throughout the WORLD, and to remove injustice.

Think of it like this, the Mahdi will finish what Ali has started. Allah and his messenger know best.

[lostprophet786]

What I have said above is my PERSONAL opinion, not the opinion of the Shia Madhab. I will refer to someone more knowledgeable than I and get back to you with a more convincing answer, inshAllah.

[14infallible]

Good video.

[watchnlearn07]

I quote: "Who better to follow then the people who lived in the house of the prophet muhamed". Aisha was his wife. His spouse. She is part of Ahlul Bayt. Please correct me if I'm lying. Why do the Shia deny her words?

[tagman2]

we deny her words because she turned against prophet mohammeds successor, daughter and grandchildren....they are the real anlul bayt,,,Aisha was not under the sacred cloak whn prophet mohammed PBUH blessed his family.....that is why

[watchnlearn07]

lol. like fairy tales.

[lostprophet786]

Anyone who opposes and goes to war with the Family of the Prophet is not considered reliable. Simple (",)

[watchnlearn07]

As Ali went to war with Aisha you mean?

[lostprophet786]

No, Ayesha went to war with Ali.

[nawidzazy]

my two favorites aswell....such role models.....by allah i love em both specialy sheik jihad's lecture...wat a amazing man by allah!!!

[truthJUSTICEfreedom]

my 2 favourites..!! where and when was this..?

[lostprophet786]

Dearborn, Australia, 2003!