Girls Aloud - With Every Heartbeat (Radio One's Live Lounge)

[MultiUlme]

This is no cover, it's called plagiarism.

They used Robyns song without asking her of permission.

[coolpunkchick115]

@MultiUlme it's a cover cuz they're doing it for live lounge and on live lounge it's all approved

[maritta2504]

Well, I usually like cover versions (especially the ones from Radio 1 Live Lounge), but this one is crab in my opinion......

[somethingkindaNICOLA]

Tbh, I think this is one of their best vocal performances EVER. Nicola's voice sounds so pure and beautiful. And the rest really do sound in tune and they don't over do it. Seriously, if you only have bad things to say about Girls Aloud's talent they why do you even bother looking at their videos. You saddo's. They all sound amazing. Fair enough they aren't the best singers, but on this song.. they are a hell of alot better than most pop stars these days.

[corrierox06]

Nicola should stop warbling - her voice sounds beautiful when she just sings normally ! She sounds off key at the beginning :/ xx

[beckytweedyx]

nicola & cheryl = amazing.

[clairegrant05]

i think kimberly is the worst singer tbh

[daydreamz06]

what the hell happened there LOL

[Akumajodracula]

off key hell

[Solidus4000]

gutless shite.worst cover ever.the wankers filming themselves playing this on an acoustic guitar are better than this souless pap

[TweanCoyle]

Nadinee sounds AMAZING like alwayss

Cheryll didnt sound as good,

Sarah sounds alrightt,

Kimberleyy, sounds good <3

andd same for nicolaa x

[Jensypensy1972]

awful!!!!! Overdoing a song does NOT make it better...mmmkey?

[liverpoolrule80s]

apart from yhe very first bit it was pretty dam gd actually

[kls0520]

yeah, that harmonizing isn't good . they shouldve left this to robyn ( :

[popcock2007]

I think this is actually quite good considering what it couldve been

[yorkieboy69]

Sorry but this rubbish, nuff said. Actually its bloomin terrible. haha

[nofancypants]

The first girl sounds like a goat.

[BaileyGuinea]

This is awesome I don't know what you guys are talking about. It gets better as it goes along, so those of you who criticise the start, listen to the end. At least they can sing live!

[dawnjones82]

meh :/ this sucks compaired to robyns accoustic version!

[JadeNaitsinger]

The beginning is really bad!!

[bigbumpaa]

Sarah is such a rock chick love her!

[RattG]

the chick at the beginning is flat =/

[bobOVamble]

cheryl is a geordie like me.... shes brill!!!

[patmold]

NO.... your a geordie like HER!

[bobOVamble]

dos it make a difference.... erm nahhhhh

[hanzibanbillabongxox]

By the way if you like cheryls voice in this i found a song shes done called Didn't I its a lot slower and quieter than the girls aloud stuff shes done. Its the B-Side of her new single. :)

[HWLKbaby]

Cheryl iloveyouiloveyou(L) x

[Hannah199429]

i personally really like this, i like the mellow sound, and how nateral it is

[joana362]

they should record this.... xD

[HattyandSophie]

Kimberly is my cousin ans she's gorgeous end of :) x

[patmold]

no.

[zoeluvesyouu]

GOSH! thats an old picture aint it !

[sadams291]

nicola best voice, amazing

cheryl hottest

kimberly best figure but worst voice

sarah soooo annoying, we get it, you live in camden!

nadine second best voice but thinks she can go solo

LOVE THEM SO MUCH :)

[mp4lyf]

cheryl is bessssssttttt

[GeordieA318]

Cherrrrrrylllll (L)

[samevans1]

Shite!

[danimaryx]

well i love this version anyway :D

x

[MegsKOfficial]

The harmonies at the beginning are awful! They don't choose the best songs for their voices do they??

[notetoselfimissyouxx]

its sarah which ruins it

[cokidman90]

girls aloud are pretty vile me thinks. and they're mostly bloody northern. thank god they're 'taking a break'

[ghftydtrsersrfytt786]

They're not mostly Northern, and so what if they were?

[coecrew92]

whats wrong with being northern?

[danielnclsn]

The original is much better

[danielnclsn]

Compared to Robyn this is DISGUSTING they sound like cats.

[Charliefisher1987]

this is song of the day on popjustice today!!!

[edwardgbell]

There's some alright singing in this, in the middle, but surely all the defenders of Girls Aloud can admit that the tuning in the first minute is absolutely hideous. Equally, the detractors should stop generalising how bad they are, a couple of them clearly have alright voices...

[bam824]

It is quite hard to split what one person sings into 5, or even have them all tune to one note when they usually sing in chords.

[zeear25]

Ginger one iz a good singer shez wasted in the band she needs bigger parts kimberly is soooo shit n she singz wasys more than ginger!!!

[MGirlsAloudFan]

'the ginger one' has a name. and they can all sing, maybe not always but they can most the time and very well

[shariotoflove]

who gives a fuck if we dont use her name...is the Girls Aloud Police gonna get us! oh please....

[ijfarr]

ah heard this on jo whileys show, never heard the robin version before ah heard this, and to be honest ah never liked girls a loud but ah must say they are brilliant singin this song

[linzandmand]

girls aloud are soooo good on this song and when i say girls aloud i mean EVERY member!!!!!!

[atalayu90]

kim sucks ! sarah rocks !

[robbiescousin]

if people dont like things why search them or even bother to listen to them??? maybe they need to get a few more hobbies other than sitting infront of the internet posting crap!? only a suggestion?

[thesnoogs]

I like their cover more than the original. It's a bit more emotional than Robyn's and I definitely appreciate that. But then I'm biased: I've loved Girls Aloud for years and I think practically everything they do is great. Mostly because it is.

[motionintheocean03]

girls aloud are soooooo awful

they are only famous on their looks

talentless!!

[thesnoogs]

That's your opinion but it's a very misinformed one.

[motionintheocean03]

common sense i heard?

[thesnoogs]

Well you've got the "common" part right.

[motionintheocean03]

yada yada yada yada girls aloud suck

[thesnoogs]

See? Common as muck.

[motionintheocean03]

borrrrrrrring

[boyfive5]

i love them, but this is horrible

[w00tsville]

Painful

[pixiemittens]

i actually think this is a really nice cover :)

it's not as good as robyn's, but girls aloud have a different sound and different ranges so it's not gonna sound like the original but i still think it's good

[yaznted]

there was an article in a magazine about girls aloud and how out of tune they are and how their voices are digitally fixed. But the man who does it says he has never had to edit the pitch as much for anyother band as he does for them.

[emmyjo720]

There are clip son you tube of them singing accepella and beautifully, including Cheryl...so I doubt that..they need that much editing and that that with the same pinch of salt as the rumours for years that they will spilt and of jealously towards Cheryl.... GA sing live all the time.... This sing is pitched very high which would be especially tough on Kimberley who has a lower register...

[Sati1979]

It's okay to listen to, but I do agree that this isn't the best cover to listen to. I think it's more to do with the fact that it's a difficult song to sing, rather than the actual performers.

[Stinemari88]

OMG, this sucks sooo much!!!! Listen to Robyn, she's ace!!!!

[SophStaax]

at the start its reall crap, but it gets a bit better further into it (:

[ashod111]

i dont understand why nadine didnt sing more.. shes the only brilliant singer in the group she could have carried the song for the others who are average

[tartansam]

ouch, HOW out of tune and terrible?? :-( painfull.

[edwardgbell]

Ouch.

There is some awful stuff in here....

[nadineandersson]

The girl that sings in the start of the song, succs, she sings so false!!:O:O but the songtext is nice:)

[lauraaakatieee]

i loved it when they did this on TU tour <3

[GirlsAloudmegafan1]

Cheryl really sings from the heart <3

[tjoeptjoep5]

i think it gets better after a minute...

"reflects the current state of music and its listeners in this country"?? DUDE!

[xcxjxwx]

what where they thinkin how crap 1 of the worst live lounge covers

[JadeeeL1993]

they can sing any song ! i lovee them , they are just great , cheryl is the best i love her to bits ,xx

[sjussun]

I think the fact people think this is good, reflects the current state of music and its listeners in this country. They can't be honoured with the titles of singers, or musicians. Successful only due to their media campaigns, backing tracked live shows, good looks, and being manufactured from a tv show.

[011y89]

ouch, this is actually painful to listen to!

[thacrazychick93]

ii love this songgg.. and they do an amazing version! ii heard it a while ago at my boyfriends house but didnt know who was singing it..

♥ Love it :D

[theevereddies]

Jo whiley knows nothing about music, It is embarrasing, radio 1 is a musical corprorate whore!!!

[mbeat28]

this is foul. flat as a fart. it just reinforces my opinion that they really cant sing. they just look good. except the ginger one. she still looks like a shoe

[nick232323]

LOL

[hre80]

Amazing how little talent they have - cats can sing better than them.

[mysteriousfantasy24]

LOL!

[thekingofdefford]

It takes a little while to get going but the end is amaaaazing!

[NachosFairy]

*chuckle* But you're joking, right? It should _never_ take until the end of a song to be good. It should be good from the start.

Some of the pitches in this song were terrible, and it lacks the spirit that Robyn had in the original. I say that even as a Girls Aloud fan, and it's unfortunate that they were so awful here.

[xXxChimFanxXx]

they sang it amazingly on there last tour!!

[conorD13]

omg ga are my idols i wud die for them bite me jerk off

[snowflakeleopard]

this is them live....they are awful!

[tubegirl200]

im not 2 sure about this cover it ent all that amazing but yesitsme333 APOLOGIZE IS AMAZING AND 1000000X BETTER THAN THE ORIGINAL it really shows how gd the girls r. nic is the best anyway

[jewishprincess08]

are u deaf hun? apologize is unbelievably flat

[yesitsme333]

this is a great cover,apologize is the worse cover iv ever heard i wish i had never heard it its that bad!

[martinobrien87]

i thought this was really good aswell

[barelyevenyours]

this is good ! don't know why you're all slating it .

[wowsat]

I really liked that! thought they sounded fantastic!

[philsearle123]

Worst cover ever!!!!!Robyn was

better

[laurac12321]

is it me or can they not sing at all???

robyn was 100x better

[axeman1234567]

One of the worst live lounge covers.

[GBRSilverDragon]

The 10minutes of OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO at the start wasnt great. but they are hawt so who cares

[cheekymunkiioxoxox]

i think this is shokin tbh... it dnt suit em.. nt the rite song 2 cuvva in my opinion :)

[sahimc2k]

they sang this on tour last year, sounded so much better than this!!

[hfg4880]

Cheryl Cole sounds awful, Nicole wasn't too bad, but as someone else said she has no control over her vibrato! Kimberly and Nadine were good though.

[xXxChimFanxXx]

its Nicola

[hfg4880]

I apologise, Nicola

[primevalrocx]

i like this cover but the beggining was kinda bad!

love ga waaaay more than robyn

ga 4eva XX

[epsonmicrosoft]

Nicola and Nadine sound great on this.

[ndamex]

Robyn for the win!

[pierre00]

God. There girls are amazing, but DUDE, they are so tacky! They always have lame outfits on.

Look at this picture! God. Ahahahaha. Corny!

[xXxChimFanxXx]

That pictures like 5 years old

[gigglesgem]

That was wen they 1st started out n that  picture was taken 6/7 years ago so obviously their style has changed.

[craignuste]

i think nicola is well fit

[dodgeyjammer]

i like this version but they did a great version in the O2, i watched it yesterday and now i cant find it!!! there's a lot of poor quality ones, but there was ont great one.

[xMarissje]

I can send you a high quality mp3 of the O2 version if you want to

[sj2686]

I love Girls Aloud. But this is a weak cover. Their voices do not blend at all. Nicola can't control her vibrato, Although i love the tone of her voice and she should get more leads along with Kimberley

[Hantuchova777]

Nicola sounds beautiful on this, really.

[barbiechic83]

I like lots of their songs but they can't do it better than Robyn I'm sorry. And I think when you can't do a song better than the orginal you shouldn't do that cover at all. I'm sorry in this case they should have picked another song.

[xCarlyyx]

i dont like the part of this.

[96Hannilein69]

It isn't bad but it isn't good.

Robyn is the best.

[wanstall69]

wtf is with you guys?

GA is awful imo but this song is sung really well!

[sjoobbe]

This was really bad.

It can´t be better that with Kleerup and Robyn!

[aaronbell8]

I hate girls aloud with a passion but this song isn't that bad.

[insanitygonemad]

hmm... it was ok, they aren't the worlds greatest vocalists but they're good as a group. is it just me or does sarah's voice not fit at all with the rest of the band? not saying she's bad, just a bit too rocky for a girl band...

[swbird132]

i actually think this is a really good version of this song! good job girls!

[codesss1991]

Their version of "Apologize" was far better than this.

This is SO BAD.

x

[MrKnoxville351]

Still hotter than the spice porks

[JulianHe]

OMG this IS AWFUL.

[sheilaswheelsunite]

Nicola (I think it is) is really off at the beginning, but it improves from there on and actually becomes a really good version. I don't know how one can compare it to the original, as they sing it so differently from Robyn. Both are good. :D

[jonthg23]

is it just me or is that britney spears instead of sarah harding in the picture? like girls aloud but this is so awful compared to the original.

[KirstySpencer1991]

4/5

Didn't like the harmony at the start but amazing. Robyn's voice is annoying.

[dancinbabe91]

woa, it wasn't that bad...I mean it wasnt perfect but people are goin crazy as if its the worst thing ever, its just not their song

[dancinbabe91]

meaning it wasnt the right song for them...obviously its not their song lol

[SuperKryptoS1S8]

Girls aloud should have known better too to sing live cus thy never can unless it's their own songs tht hav been made for them!

[SuperKryptoS1S8]

WOW! They sounded SO BAD at the beginning, the harmonies were awful and thy couldn't sing it, too hard for thm, too big a song and Robyn's too unique 4 any1 to do a better job, only a really good singer could do this justice and thn Girls Aloud sing it- OMG! Could it have been worse?!?!... No. Thy were OK in a few parts on their own after about the first minute an a half but come on!... it was all over the place!!!

[shutterwinkie]

a good cover version :)

[CherylXFan]

Love it its a hard song to sing but they do it great and they did it amazing at the TU tour and robyn has sung this song alot worse and its her song.

[rchallen]

Just discovered this... WOW. This is AWFUL.

In the U.S. we don't have Girls Aloud... but we do have "Danity Kane." They're pretty terrible too.

[fukemduk]

This is an insult to robyns talent

its absolute crapppppp

[tjompus]

damn, how could Robyn/Kleerup allow this. Damn.

[lindsieanne]

you think there shit! .. There the ones up there singing not you!! Are u any better?

[shandee96]

nadiineee (L) sarahh (L) < best singerss in girlss aloudd x

[xsheselectric20x]

could have found a more up to date pic! fuckin hell nicolas shit at singing!

[PyroDaHero]

one of them was off key at the begining

[typhontyrant]

its not that bad.. i actually really like some parts of it

[silverstar27]

Who is that singing at the beginning, it sounds bloody awful, and Nadine's accent is just bizarre.

[moleman0000]

shut the fuck up u little prick this is well gd

[Kuksafari]

This sucks. They completely rip the song apart. And what's with the happy piano? It's a SAD maddafakkin song!

[nicsperrin]

They sound shit compared to robyn

[hawkwind999]

Rachel hylton sang this better

[seberg]

truly awful - flat and not in tune

[xhilaryxduffxfanx]

Oh my goodness, was that beautiful or what?

I can't get over how good Girls Aloud actually are.

What more could you want - five beautiful, friendly, kind and young girls, each with their own unique, amazing voice. And they sound great when they harmonise. I love the 'Ooh' bits at the beginning.

They're a breath of fresh air and have been a PHENOMENAL sucess. I couldn't think of anything negative to say about them.

I love GA <3

[shniggles]

I think girls aloud actually make decent music, but all their stuff on live lounge is absoutley shite. This is too slow and flat. xhilaryxduffxfanx - You are a massive gimp

[xhilaryxduffxfanx]

Um.. thanks, shniggles...

[meathead689]

finally someone who has commented on ere who i agree with! thank you!

[Squirrelunderabus]

Is Nicola out of tune?

[HeroBreakers]

Awful!

[JAAAAAAAAAB]

better voice than whitney? i hope u bein sarcastic mate. i hate whitney but a good voice (before the crack pipe that is)

[moonprincess0060]

nicola

[12052114]

this is really gash!! sounds like 5 rats being sledge-hammered to death.

[dannyboi301187]

this song is fab i love it, shows they can actually sing really well. fab x

[Stinemari88]

They have destroyed my fave song!!! This is shit!!! Robyns version is WAY better!!!!!

[meathead689]

thats because robyn was the original person to sing it no cover is as good as the original

[FeastsandFires]

The first forty seconds had me mesmerized.

[scruicks]

This is absolutely gash

[MiiSSBRiiGHTSiiDE]

nadines voice sends shivers down my spine tbh

shes fuckign amazing

xx

[baskalayt]

these bitches can't do harmonies to save their lives. stop trying.

[PadrethePio]

started off shitty but got a little bit better.

[batteryoperatedpen]

im sorry ...but they were out of tune with the OOOOOOooooOOOOoo bit...

[EmNem08]

i really like it!