Added: 4 years ago
From: jeffvw29
Views: 119,800
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (199)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Le vilain EsKaLiDiNg ne me l'a pas encore traitée cette chanson!

  • One of best album covers ever!

  • song about bonnie prince charlie and the jacobite rising against the hanoverian dutch installed legacy "state"

  • Je vais demander EsKaLiDiNg de traiter cette chanson!

  • try listening to this on a boat on lake lockness with some fucking brews !

  • @vindickmonster666 indeed ,but the word ye want is Loch and it means "Lake"

  • @vindickmonster666 loch not lock

  • Comment removed

  • @atomic116090 ha ha... ok... keep up good work

  • A good idea for people posting videos, to disable comments. Some real fuckin morons on here, what.

  • reminds me of good times

  • hell yea scottish rock forever

  • Does anyone know what kind of guitar and/or amp Kurt Robertson plays in the studio? The rhythm guitar sounds on "the lads who fought and won" and "culling the herd" are EXACTLY the types of sounds I am trying desperately to get, but I have only come reasonably close by mere chance a couple times, and it's never quite what I was shooting for. It sorta sounds like a JCM800, but there's still an element (maybe the specific guitar, speakers, cabinet, mic???) that I can't figure out. Anyone know????

  • Scottish punk rock hell yeah!

  • MAD JACK

  • 2 people who didn't like this will never come back again

  • cos i was lazy, drunk and stoned.

  • HAHAHA!!! basslord you made me laff!! god bless yer!

  • @barneymcgee56 why der you talk like that on ye internet!?

  • a beautiful song just destroyed

  • and lyrics oh so beautiful true drunken poets!

  • this shit is the noise that you must come to love if you love drinkin friend!

  • How do we get from a Jacobite song to insulting born again Christians?

  • @verlox Welcome to the internet.

  • Not entirely true locheelad2. Just after the mass emmigration out of Scotland there were enough smart asses left to invent the science based med schools, schools like Johns Hopkins and others of great reknown still use today. Either way, thank you my fellow Scots for all ya'v done for humanity!

  • @hamil223 Your right man, just before the Revolution, the American Colonists somehow talked Dr. Witherspoon and his wife, to take the long voyage and accept the post of Headmaster of Princeton University. He wasn't young then, but made Princeton top notch, he later helped write the American Constitution.

  • Robert Burns although not a Jacobite, still wrote "MY BONNIE MOOR HEN", about Chairlie, the band should try it.

  • How did only 3 million Scots immigrants from 1700-195? make the Modern World? Education! Unlike other countries, the Scots immigrant could read,write, and cipher. How could a farmers son write as Burns did. All the inventions were Scots. Reason, every Scot was educated from the 18th century. Unheard of in Italy, Spain, France, England, etc., only the rich were educated there. The World owes Scotland for civilization, the dark side is it left a brain-drain in parts of Scotland herself.

  • Not only does the world owe Scotland for civilization and kickass music, but also for the DEEP FRIED MARS BARS!

  • Ha-ha richt ye are.

  • Jewish people learn to write and read before they are 13 since many years bC. Just as divulgational information ^^ (In fact education it's one of their first mitsvot or musts).

  • That's true. In the History book I just read it said nobody did as much for America as the Scots, and Scotch-Irish, except the Jews, it did say however that Scots Presbyterians were not held back by religious dogma as the Jews were, this is the 18th-19th Centuties Diasporas he was speaking of.

  • @locheelad2

    absolutly m8. But hey don't forget the Germans too. Germans and Scots built the land we know as America. Germans had many great inventions too...for fucks sake..the printing press! And we all know and love German bier garden girls...and the bier! hahaha

  • @chiprommel Yes the Germans had a tremendous effect on America, they went everywhere, and were respected for hard work, their contributions to American Universities, and how could I forget the Printing Press, or the true blondes.

  • Will ye nae come back again? ^^

  • I love them!!

    I just see them live it was really great:)

  • totally brilliant

  • Ach, as much as we live aff the dole and fuckin' kill cunts. There's always scottish pride, if scotland's bein ripped the pish oot ae, they've nae seen the country side man. Fuckin' beautiful.

  • willl yeee nae come back again?

  • i think its scotish for will you never come back again

  • Correct Jordan78able, absolutely, I'm sure it was a typo, I make them, but there are 2 t's in Scottish, for the uninitiated out there.

  • nae bad lyk... you got to gi the original song writer their due ana though. lol :P

  • will ye nae come back again not for another round of taki no he wasnt good enough

    BUT FOR SOME MORE DRINKIN AND MCKENZIES!

  • this sums it up. After the defeat of Bonnie Prince Charlie at Culloden and his escape back to France, with the aid of Flora MacDonald, there were still many who hoped that he would return, some day. Here is a song about that sentiment, written by Carolina Oliphant (Lady Nairne) in the first half of the 19th century). There are a number of versions of this song, this is one of them.

  • What means "Will Ye Nae" in the title? :))

  • I think it means: "Will You No Come Back Again"

  • will you not.. we scottish are lazy cunts when it comes tae speakin and writing so will u no means will u not no can be used as not and no like yes and no haha. peace fae scotland bruv :D

  • braw scottish punk sound, proud the Mckenzies sing belting scots tunes

  • if ah say they are good then their good,

  • I'm going to fucking kill you. You have no sense of music at al. The Real McKenzies are the greatest celtic band ever. They're style is impeccable, Pauls voice is beautiful and the musicianship is just phenomenal. Go die.

  • @Rocknrollradio92 stupid kid! you're going to kill someone? You'll get wet panties ;) You should go out and find a brain, so that your head is not only for carrying your hair!

    by the way: the Real McKenzies are great musicians!

  • Yeah I guess I got a little out of hand.

  • Thank you for your opinion, now move along down the line.

  • we should get our ears examined? you should get your brain examined dude... seriousley

  • Holy discussion of global warming Batman, Not what i expected from a Real Mckenzies post... The frist ice age took a long time to start and a long time to end, i believe thats why they call it and "age" rather then a "sudden" freeze. A globe reduction in temparture of one degree is huge. Its kinda like saying that the globe's ran fall has increased by an inch, its doesn't seem like much until you think about it, its alot of water.

  • Man, why do people always say the ice age took so long to begin? An ice age can start in a hundred years or even less. It is a sudden freeze, caused by a sudden change in global temperature. It doesn't end quick, but it begins very, very fast.

  • @ TENLITTLEPIGS

    Look this up moron. Paleoclimatology (also Palaeoclimatology) is the study of climate change taken on the scale of the entire history of Earth. It uses records from ice sheets, tree rings, sediment, and rocks to determine the past state of the climate system on Earth.

  • What the hell happened while I was gone?

  • god bless the irish

  • To everyone who's bloody well posting stupid racial crap, I'm going to quote to you some of the chorus of one of The Real McKenzies other songs. "Bugger off, ya bastards bugger off!"

  • If Al Gore were here he'd post glacial crap.

  • Ha! nice play on words!

  • yup yup, so what if my kids dont see polar bears? i don't care cause i didn't either!

  • That's not all it's about dipshit. Eventually, your kids offsprings, offspring into generations or so, maybe not even that far, won't even be able to survive, due to harsh environmental catastrophe that was caused by stupid fucks like you.

  • i like how you put that cause it sounded like I WAS THE FUCKING CAUSE FOR GLOBAL WARMING which in fact ISN'T OR FAULT, its another global season, take for example the Ice Age, did it get insanely cold because the cavemen made to many fires or maybe because the animals farted too much huh!?

  • The Ice Age happened over many many many many many years. What's happening now, is happening so fast it makes politicians and Eco-friendly motherfuckers heads spin.

  • yes it did but that did not change the fact that it happened, this is not because we are polluting (which i admit we are), it is another global season, the world's temperature as a whole either a) decreases or b) increases and at this moment it is increasing, there are just too many object's in the world to heat up, and actually Phoenix Arizona maybe the hottest place in the U.S. snowed during the winter of 08 if you call that global warming than you're messed the hell up

  • ...It doesn't change the fact that it happened...yes...I suppose. But that's not what we're debating here. I'm saying you can't compare what's happening now to then. 1. because that happened while there were no human. 2. that was a major freezing, not heating. and 3. it happened over a much much much longer period of time. It's damn uncanny what's happening now.

  • well yes it is happening but if you think about it and do some research, i bet you'll find that the highest temps around the world have been gradually increasing, it's not all of a sudden, whether it be from us or global seasons is yet to be found out, and i like how this went from a fuck to a polite debate :)

  • Yeah man, I gotta say I do have some respect for you. I'm all done with debating for now. Hope you're an actually Real McKenzies fan btw.

  • aye mate i am ;)

  • "its another global season, take for example the Ice Age, "

    Your a moron, it took over 3000 years for the global temperture to drop a degree during the start of the last ice age. The temperture had dropped a degree in the past 40 years.

    I bet your one of these born again christian fucktards, who dont believe in science.

  • glad you bring this up, i was waiting for an idiot like you, you said that it took over 3000 years for the global season to drop a degree? well how do you know that in the past 2000 years the global temperature hasn't dropped to a slight degree? i doubt from 1 B.C. to 1899 B.C. people have been recording the temperatures from around to world

  • world temperature, seasonal change , weather, oxygen levels etc. are all recorded in the fossils of plant life and can be accurately determined by geological process.

    I have no doubts that you are a creationist. Creationists simply do not believe in many different sciences and scientific methods.

  • You seriously don't think they were recording temp in 1898?

    The ancient romans had ways of recording temp, which was before 1 B.C.

  • sorry 10littlepigs was me, it turns out someone got into their youtube account on my computer while i was away, and no i don't believe i'm born again and im not a very good chrisitian in fact i don't even go to church i believe there is some sort of higher power and science isn't a belief idiot science is all around us, take a computer for example this is a perfect example of science, how neutrons and electrons pass through cords and such ;) think before ya speak next time bud

  • @kingdomofdalriada I am an actual Geophysicist (not an internet scientist) and thank you for calling someone out on their anti-science rhetoric. That jack ass Ron Christie went on Hardball a few days ago and said "I think scientists still debate climate change". We don't. Pass the word. We all agree it's anthropogenic, like we all agree smoking is bad for you.

  • AHaHaHaHa...

  • Comment removed

  • I'm an internet douchebag.

  • Damn this song is catchy.

  • americans going on about history on a canadian scotish band video lol you people need a life

  • Yes, Winning an online argument is like winning a race inthe special olympics. You won, but your still retarded.

  • How original. I am floored by your comedic pioneering.  Implying that people on the internet are stupid, truly a conquest of modern comedy. Kudos, sir, kudos.

    - Gentle Dementia

  • @basslord7188 heh, or even if you are the last man standing in a fight. Sure you were dumbass to get in the fight...but you still kicked their fucking asses AND the bartender cleared your tab. 8^) winning is all...even if you look like demotivasional poster doing it.

    ;^)

  • Ha ha, i have to remember Rambo: 50% Indian 50% German makes --- 100% American! Thats the cool about Americans, they took just the best of all the others... and as well the "Teutonian Deathwish". At least american Wars exist because there is a German in you, and he wants out... excuse my bad english ;-)

  • Two questions, was this rambo's heritage or stallone's? Also, did you mean indian from the subcontinent or american-native indian

  • Two answers... 1. Rambo of course, i dont like Stallone - he´s a douchbag. 2. The natives :-)

  • that´s the biggest garbage I ever heard mate :D

  • @Ezyjimi your opinion bro

  • @02dartda well finally I don´t know why or in which context I wrote this, I really love the Mckenzies ;)

  • Youtube, the great racial battleground.

    - Gentle Dementia

  • Ya, cant we all just get along and not be douchebags to eachother?

  • apparently not.

  • Why can't we all just continue to be douchebags but have the common understanding that we're just joking?

    This is the internet, after all.

  • The internet has done more to facilitate the total downfall of civilization than anything else in history.

  • Truth.

  • Television

  • Well yeah. Everything in civilization that's bad basically flourishes on the internet.

  • @obglobgablob true that

  • @ewd76 explain?

  • hey all you fuckin mutts, im American German, Irish. i grew up in Southie boston, where if you aint got herritage or history, your just another wondering mutt in the street waitin ta get snatched up and beat. I too play the pipes, and have played in both irish and hardcore bands. how come very time we played at the pubs, mutts like you never thought to challenge me or my pals on this subject?-cause you cunts dont say shit when you come out from mommies house.

  • when is the end? india lived under opressive british rule until 48 south africa until 94 so i think the revoultion was the most neccesary thing us americans ever did

  • I love all this heritage-based bitching.

    Seriously, is there some law that says you can only sing a style of music if your heritage is based in it?

    If that were true no white guy would be able to play rock and roll, because it's based in the blues, which was invented by black slaves.

    Music transcends race and heritage you morons.

  • Amen.

  • actually dumb fucker, blues came from blue grass, bluegrass came from Iirsh music. do your history before you say dumb shit. and by the way, some people take great pride in preserving their herritage, so get fucked you mutt!

  • Calm the fuck down kid. No one said anything about abandoning heritage, my point is that music crosses racial and cultural borders.

    And no, you are still wrong. Blues evolved out of traditional African music and then bluegrass mixed country/folk with blues. Don't make shit up.

    Now go off to bed before your mommy yells at you for being up too late.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • I'm 8 and 3/4 thank you very much.

    Nothing wrong with sticking to your roots at all, but I also don't think that there's anything wrong with sticking to someone elses' roots, if you want. Why not play Irish/Scottish music? It's good stuff! Even if you aren't Irish or Scottish.

  • 100% agree. Blues is much more traditional irish music rather than african wich gave only the rythm.

  • finally, someone with more than 1/2 a brain. cheers pal!

  • you stupid bastard. just because you dont have a percussion section doesnt mean its just noise, besides, irsh, scottish, german...whatever had their own forms of rythym and percussion. every one acts like the African American invented rock and roll and its simply not true. they werent the only ones to influence music, and who cares about the god damn slaves anymore anyways, dont we have a whole knew mess of shit to figure out?

  • @copperkrone Well, Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton are still bitching about slavery. Like either of them have ever been within sniffing distance of slavery.

  • I kinda feel this was my fault, but it's hilarious how upset some people get, I mean, who feels it necessary to look at my profile because god-forbid I'm not actually Irish.

    -Gentle Dementia

  • Why all the fighting?

    Who the feck cares if you're Scottish or no?

    Just enjoy the fecking song for what it is.

  • lol feck u sound liike my lil sister

  • History not your strong point? The pilgrims came to America for free practice of religion. In much the same way the Irish Catholics fight for it against the oppresive Church of England (unless of course you are muslim). As for Canada, it's easy to be the tough guy and take your independance, when you have the big dog (USA) living downstairs. As for those of us with Irish ancestry, our ancestors came here out of neccessity, to avoid starvation. It wasn't for wanting to separate from Ireland.

  • Why all arguments about who is irish and who is scottish? Why is there almost no one that comments about how incredible great this song and this band is?

  • fyi, i know for sure that paulie from the real mckenzies is scottish, i met him in person at a show here in ontario. however, that said, i agree that who the fuck cares where they're from... they are incredible live, great music, and fun guys!

  • im irish but i was born in america and have lived here my entire life but im just as irish as any from ireland say what you will but i bleed emerald green

  • This is the first song of their's i've heard...

    absoloutely awsome :)

  • Love the Real McKenzies

    jealous of my dad who's seen them and is friends with them

    but i got their autograph so im ok! :D

  • maybe this quote can help you to understand what i´m talking about.

  • there is nothing wrong with being proud of what other people have done, it is not claiming their achievements for yourself. is it wrong for someone on a football team to be proud of his team's victories? I am glad to be an irishman, I am not saying I am proud of what other people have done. I am saying I am proud to be a part of what other people have done. that, is national pride.

  • Yopu are not an irishman you are amerian, twhere the fuck do you americans get the audacity to call yourself irish/scotsman

    you are an american. deal with it

  • how do you know my nationality?

  • It says american on your profile I am willing to bet you are not irish, you were not born or raised in ireland either you have probably never even set foot in ireland but you are merely a plastic paddy

    am I correct

  • fraid not. America is where I live, not where I'm from.

  • Plastic paddy how i hate that term. We are proud of our Irish heritage and ancestry, seeing that when our ancestors came here they were treated worse than slaves, and lower than dirt. Did we give up and ask for hand outs, nope, we endured, educated ourselves, rose up and took over. So if anything us Americans with Irish ancestry are the true testament to Irish grit. Oh and my feet will be on Irish soil next summer.

  • you are american, if you have the audacity to call yourself irish you area a plastic paddy, that what the irish call you wannabes

  • randy0572 My father is irish born and bred, That does not make me irish by any means.

    I used 2 live in dublin for over 5 years with my irish girlfriend and I know for a fact that the irish do not consider americans like you as fellow irish. Heence the term plastic paddy if you call yourself irish.

    I also do not need 2 bang on about my irish heritage, I just say my dad is irish and I am not. Heritage is a silly word that realy doesnt mean anyting other than yer ancestors were differant cultur

  • You see Scottish here is the problem. I live in a country of hyphens. Every special intrest group and minority are encouraged to fly their flags and claim the greatness of their homeland. All we in America are doing is expressing the pride we have in our ancestors that came to this country, rose up and helped build this great nation. And don't get my wrong I am American first I bleed red, white and blue. But that doesn't mean I can't be proud to fly the green, white and orange.

  • No matter where you ancestors came from you are all the same you are americans and their may be regional differances i.e. new york culture vs texas culture.

    However, you are all the same. Europe is as multicultural and mixed as america yet you will never get someone from a european country that hyphenates themselves.

    you are who you are, not who your ancestors were.

  • Sorry but your ancestors are who you are. Their blood courses through you veins and their DNA make you the person that you see in the mirror. Oh and those who don't learn their past are doomed to repeat it.

  • That DNA comes from your ancestors. whether they are scottish or not is irrelevant.

    You are not scottsh so fuck off. your a wannabe, we scots do not consider you as scottsh END OF STORY.

    your a pain n the arse.

  • what a fuckin wanker. you have nothing intelligent to say so now you resort to childish name calling. must be a liberal. and i never said or claimed any scottish ancestry, try to keep up. i'll use small words and not so many syllables.

  • Get em randy. "They don't consider Americans like you as fellow Irish" might be true, but then again they don't take kindly to anyone at all. Kinda like the old man sitting on the porch all day yelling at anyone and everyone for no reason.

  • piss offf gaelic u sorry twat, im irish and welsh but live in England but the irish side of my family came from france many years ago. Your 'pure blood' scottish heritage is probably descended from an italian along the way so stfu. We all start from somwhere

  • proud, the nation to which he belongs to. Thus he recovers and is now in gratitude ready to defend with hands and feet all errors and follies which are its own.

  • The cheapest form of pride however is national pride. For it betrays in the one thus afflicted the lack of individual qualities of which he could be proud, while he would not otherwise reach for what he shares with so many millions. He who possesses significant personal merits will rather recognise the defects of his own nation, as he has them constantly before his eyes, most clearly. But that poor beggar who has nothing in the world of which he can be proud, latches onto the last means of being

  • welcome to insanity.... ts ts ts...

    First of all i's skapunk fun music but nothing else

    secondly the band is canadian origins... if you just look up in wiki.... they take more or less the mickey out of it..... but anyway everybody wear this shoes if you fit in@greenpunk

    And finally... 4 stars for entertaining music

  • this is to scotish nationalist

  • Bunch of canadians pretending to be scottish.

  • Better then a bunch of Scots who thing they can sing.

  • least they arn;t irish pretending to be scottish ;)

  • aye could be worse could be a fuckin paddy

  • true!

  • I smell a commie. take it somewhere else pinko

  • greenpunk, YES I AM FUCKING PROUD TO BE SCOTTISH. at least I AM FUCKING SCOTTISH. A tleast I am not some foreign root seeking idiot.

    fuck you and yer obscure scottish heritage, You bastards are all wannabes.

  • I don´t wanna be scottish. I don´t wanna be german. I just want to hate every fucking moreon who is so proud for his country! YOUR IQ HAVE TO BE LOVER THAN 2.5 DAMN IDIOT! FUCK YOU!

  • can't even spell moron hahah. silly commie.

  • Loooool, just reading this.

    Y'know what?

    Just go impale yourself with a spoon, we don't need your scum kicking around, claiming it's wrong to be proud of your country.

    Some person you are . . .

    By the way . . . . Moron*

    IQ of what now?

  • Jes i´m claiming it´s wrong to be proud for his country. And now i´m no morone. I got arguments. Everytime you couple of idiots meet another bunch of idiots who´s "SO PROUD" too, there will be a conflict. Fuck you. What am i doing. Claiming things to an idiot that won´t get it anyway. oi!

  • There is nothing wrong with being proud of your country and your heritage.

    I am proud to be Irish and am proud of my countries history and culture.

  • so you´re proud of what somebody else has done??? Come on man, that´s crazy. But respect, you´re the first guy wich is not talking shit like "ühhhhh, you can´t spell moron"

  • Yes, i am proud of what my people have done and the history of my island.

  • Pot calling the kettle black irish boy ;)

  • Proud to be scottish! riht on mustang! your the guy called them tourists plastic scots on antoher video!

    hahaha

    well i agree with you here, fuck this guy greenpunk, being proud of being scottish doesn't mean proud of your government green punk, it means proud of your heritage. My last name is campbell, im proud to be from the highlands, i dont care about the governmetnt of scotland i just love my heritage

  • And Keir, what government?

    We're still England's lil' toy.

    Here's to the people of Scotland.

  • SCOTLAD

  • They are from Canada, actually.

  • Vancouver.

  • Anokpoet is absolutely right, they've got the words to this wrong and, in so doing, have managed to expose their glaring ignorance about the Scottish language. The title of this song is "Will Ye No Come Back Again?", their use of the word nae means that what they are singing doesn't even make sense. It makes my blood boil every time I hear it, because in every other respect, this is an awesome version. It's a shame, but there you go.

  • You should actually be honoured that people are trying to have your nationality. It's amazing how many people would want to be Scottish or even Irish. I haven't met anyone yet that claims to be Flemish while he's not, you know.

  • Biglank, you are talking pish...to us Glaswegians (or west coasters) it is 'Will Ye No', but to those in the East/North East Will Ye Nae come Back Again makes perfect sense...ask any Aberdonian.

    There are a lot of expat Scots and those of Scottish descent in Canada and if they want to celebrate their roots I take my hat off to them. On the other hand Scottish people like you make me cringe.

  • Also I used to listen to McNasty when he was in the peg! I'm also a piper! He was always trying to be on the cutting edge and is leadin the pipes exactly where they should go! Especially after listening to Mark Sauls stuff lol!