this video is awesome.....best thing i can say about it is listen to the crowd. Yulia said she would not scream again and she doesn;t, but she does sing the song. Watch the keyboardist at the beginning and you can see him hitting the key for her scream line(no keyboards playing)....but she sings the rest, and Lena is as always, a goddess
si alguien quiere el cd de tatu happy smiles yo lo estoy vendiendo en mercadolibre junto con otros 2 articulos de tatu raros de conseguir en mexico, solo denle en el buscador tatu y es el unico disco que de happy smiles que esta en venta eso si no esta autografiado pero si es importacion de rusia
Roman Ratej the best drummer, solo Roman sabe tocar esta canción de tres bateristas que han pasado por ella, claro Roman es el original (sorry steve y jesper)
I'm kinda perplex about Yulia somehow stealing the spotlight when it's Lena the only one who actually sings live. Ok, I know that Yulia had problems so she can't hit high notes anymore and I don't blame that for that, but at the end of the day it's a weird performance, 50% lip synch ...
ellas son lo maximo! pero en el escenario apestan! he vsito tooooooodas sus presentaciones y siempre es lo mismo... el publico se rebienta rockeando y ellas caminando de un lado a otro
Actually, only the high parts, mainly the "Not gonna get us" lines were lip synced by Yulia. She hurt her voice with a vocal cyst from singing so high in the album before and she can't sing high notes anymore. If she does, she'll ruin her throat forever. Permanent damage. So she has no choice but lip sync. And her accent (which is adorable) is prominent when she sings, so it is live.
@marjoleinleeman because Yulia was sick by that time and because they recorded that song when Yulia was younger, which means her voice was higher... :)
Roman Ratej es el único baterista que a tenido t.A.T.u. que sabe tocar Not gonna get us, Steve Wilson es bueno pero en esta canción no lo hace como Roman y Jesper (baterista de Lena) es genial pero le falto mucho al tocar esta canción...
estube investigando y todo me indica que las notas mas altas yulia las gritaba en el estudio las notas largas , es por esos que no las canta en vivo , es ovio que no vaa a gritar en el concierto imaginense el ridiculo , no digo que no tengaa una exelente voz pero en esta cancion es la opinion que yo tengo, no es la primera vez que grita una nota .
well you do know they don't sing any of their English songs right? :P they said it an interview that they have other people sing the English song for them.
que bonito!!! lo digo porque en todos los conciertos que e visto en youtube.. incluso los de rusia no corean las canciones.... ni siquiera cuando ellas apuntan el microfono al publico! en mexico somos a todo dar!!!! VIVA MÉXICO!!!! y que bonitas ellas... se ven felices y asi como sorprendidas de como es la calides de la gente!!!!
@theonlyoneW600 mexico y todos los paises latinoamericanos!!! estos lados son calientes y la verdad es q somos mas animados en vivo!! por eso es q las bandas q hacen tour por latinamerica siempre vuelven.. sres sintamonos orgullosos de ser latiños coño!!!! Yeahh saludos desde venezuela!!
@theonlyoneW600 De que hablas?? en todos los conciertos de Tatu el publico coreaba las canciones a todo pulmon asi como en Mexico creeme el mundo amo y amara por siempre esta banda.
@theonlyoneW600 pero mexico fue la diferencia entre el resto del mundo....claro ejemplo es este. Lastima que las TATu tomaron rumbos distintos si no este seria el grupaso del momento....
i know .lol. thats wat makes her speacial only her can make her voice sound like that thats what ive been telling people about yulia i still think she has a great voice after her surgery thou:)
I got no time to do some research, I just came to watch them sing but i was a bit disappointed in this vid, I hope they can sing this song live without lipsynching so that it would be more natural and a better performance
bubilouextravaganza is right. do your research. it's one of the first things you would read anyways. and as for it being a better performance because it's more natural? tch. you don't know anything. they ONLY sing live now. you can't blame yulia for something she physically CANNOT DO anymore. jesus.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
sometimes you should use your mind, i came to youtube because i wanna watch them perform, not to read about their fcking history of whatever past they have, lypsinching doesnt make a singer natural. Haha, 2 points for me and 0 for you. They sing live now? well that's good, and im not blaming for if she cannot sing her song, im just happy bcoz technology makes people sound really good but all those boosters doesnt really help them when they sing live. Haha, sorry for pwning you
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
you really got no logic, sorry for owning you again but your goin way out of the topic, Im saying that they dont sing good on live. period! Eevrybody knows that, how old are you? 65? Too old yet too stupid, yes Im jsut a 5 year old kid yet I kept on pwning an old old dirty stinky grandpa like you LOL
i love this song so much....and yesterday i found a new band on youtube by accident,GIRL MEET GIRL-YOU BUR MY HEART,i love so much this band,thats my new fav band....
welll she lips sings that part because she cant go that high any more my mothers a singer so high notes u can do in the studio is much different than the ones u do on stage in the studio u can do it over and over again ontill u get it right but when ur out there on stage if u crook on bit that messes everything up and yulia got a throught surgery a couple years bak before they did the album dangerous and moveing so she doesn't have that fine cute chiky movie like she did she still sounds great!
because shes getting older like puberty her voice is gonna change like when yulia speak u can hear that she speak like shes kinda horse but its still cute her voice has change alot but her talent and well hottness havn't change one bit lena voices havn't change much she rocks too tatu is too girl takeing on the world and they rock at it TATU FOR LIFE!!!!!!
omg 5 +´s for such a nooooooooob statement xD you lil footfolks have no idea about music, the secret is EVERYBODY can sing those songs, but it wouldnt that good without the lil man behind his pc
you can hear clearly that she didn't sing the high parts. they are playback. but I think it's ok that they at least sing the normal parts by themself.
you probably don't know the background story to either of them.
the one with black hair (Yulia) who sings the "Not Gonna Get Us!" bits had a vocal cyst and clearly can't go that high anymore, plus she was only about 15-16 when she recorded that song, and her voice is going to sound different. Besides, on the other parts she sounds fine, and the one with red hair (Lena) sounds amazing when she sings as well.
oyer pero si yulia nunca ha cantado las partes agudas su voz la arreglan por el ordenador para el cd musical , nunca la he escuchado cantar en vivo esas partes agudas ,pero me gusta mucho su musica , tatu : the best
se re nota que el "not gonna get us" es gravado y no lo dice ella, si bien CREO que ese tipo de entonaciones le trajo problemas en la voz, no quita el echo que nunca lo pueda cantar y solo aparezca en el disco ya que posee multiples ediciones
Fact is, she has sang like that before, but like the above said, damaging the vocals happens, and that's exactly what happened to these two, but they're still awesome :)
she did actually used to go that high, its becuase of going that high she got a vocal cyst, and now unfourtuanaly she cant hit those notes anymore. =/ but there still amazing! i love t.A.T.u.!!=D
la neta estas chava cantan bien poka madre!!! (aparte de ke estan como kieren) son lo mejor de Rusia... hay ke apoyarlas para ke sigan con su carrera las niñas!!!
Dark2104malo Esta bien disculpame de verdad staba de mal humor cuando lei tu comentario, una sola palabra basta para dañar el dia d una persona asi q si vas a responder a un comenterio lee bien xq me cayo bien mal que me discutieras algo q es obvio que ella hace playback en el coro xq sta operada d las cuerdas vocales yo no dije nada ni malo, ni falzo, ni del otro mundo para q me respondieras d esa manera yo soy fan d tatu y uno d los mejors. chao cuidatex
bueno lo que m paso cuando Vi tu comntario yo habia djado de ver la parte 3 cuando cantaban OBEZYANKA NOL Y POR UN DSCUIDO MIO MeREGRESE ALA SEGUNDA PARTE OSEA ESTA DE NOT GONNA GET US Y COMO NO ME DI CUENTA YO PENSE Q ESTABA LEYENDO LOS COMENTARIOS DE LA 3ra PART COMO YA T MENCIONE ASI Q CUANDO vI TU MENSAJE M SALI D MIS CASILLAS PORQ EN LA 3RA PART JULIA CANTA SUPR RONK Y PZ ESE FUE MI ERROR NO T PREOCUPS LA CULPA LA TNGO YO POR SER TAN DSCUIDADO YO TAMBIEN SOY FAN DE TATU
okokokokok fue mi error lo admito puede que en el coro lo haga ¬¬¡¡¡ y no me digas imbecil, estupido'¡¡¡¡¡¡ ya admiti que fue mi error pero no es necesario lamarme imbecil tarado¡¡¡¡¡
Lena actually has some singing potential..Julia really just doesn't have a voice. =/ Lena tends to run out breath, but with training she can do better.
I respect the girls of t.A.T.u. so much. I must be rather hard for Yulia to be able to face the audience ever since her manager had ruined her voice. It's still rather beautiful, but she'll never be able to sing "Not Gonna Get Us" again without a playback.
She did very good. I expected a full play-back. Both she and Lena did very well. :)
They used to be able to when they were teenagers, but their voices work differently now. They can still both sing very high, but Yulia can't really scream high notes anymore because of the cyst she had. But, I don't know, maybe after vocal therapy, she can do it again. We'll have to wait for the 3rd album
I love them in their concerts because they are so nice... they urge the crowd to sing and most singers dont want the crowd singing cuz it drowns out their singing.....
son lo mejor tatu!!!!! no importa en vivo o en play back u rock!!!! ya viene su nuevo disco "waste manegent" en el 2008 creo y su pelicula "finding tatu"!!!!1 ustedes son lo mejor!!
Yulia didnt lip-sync, but for the parts like at the beginning and end like "not gonna get us" in super high pitch, was lip-syncing, and "shining in your fire" was lip-synced too. the notes to reach those are impossible without editing, even she dosent lip-sunc the rest of the time, those parts will be lip-sunc. great performance guys!
oh, that's cool. Still, if the U.K. is free, how can they ban something like that? I don't recall the U.S. doing that to music and last I checked, the U.K. was more free then the U.S.
They try to ban, then the press get a hold of them lol.
I think they get complaints about music video's but don't ban them anymore. Unless they depict a whole lot of violence or sex. Even then just put till after 9pm or something.
this video is awesome.....best thing i can say about it is listen to the crowd. Yulia said she would not scream again and she doesn;t, but she does sing the song. Watch the keyboardist at the beginning and you can see him hitting the key for her scream line(no keyboards playing)....but she sings the rest, and Lena is as always, a goddess
quidda1 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
si alguien quiere el cd de tatu happy smiles yo lo estoy vendiendo en mercadolibre junto con otros 2 articulos de tatu raros de conseguir en mexico, solo denle en el buscador tatu y es el unico disco que de happy smiles que esta en venta eso si no esta autografiado pero si es importacion de rusia
russiantoni 3 months ago
Roman Ratej the best drummer, solo Roman sabe tocar esta canción de tres bateristas que han pasado por ella, claro Roman es el original (sorry steve y jesper)
LenaKatinaTv 4 months ago
I'm kinda perplex about Yulia somehow stealing the spotlight when it's Lena the only one who actually sings live. Ok, I know that Yulia had problems so she can't hit high notes anymore and I don't blame that for that, but at the end of the day it's a weird performance, 50% lip synch ...
ROMANTIKILLER2 4 months ago
Playback 50% ^^
Bartoszizi 5 months ago 2
ellas son lo maximo! pero en el escenario apestan! he vsito tooooooodas sus presentaciones y siempre es lo mismo... el publico se rebienta rockeando y ellas caminando de un lado a otro
addictedtotoxic 5 months ago
Actually, only the high parts, mainly the "Not gonna get us" lines were lip synced by Yulia. She hurt her voice with a vocal cyst from singing so high in the album before and she can't sing high notes anymore. If she does, she'll ruin her throat forever. Permanent damage. So she has no choice but lip sync. And her accent (which is adorable) is prominent when she sings, so it is live.
Itachiboii9898 8 months ago 7
Lenaaa! diabLos es tan seeeeeexxxyyyy :D!!
leenaloveejockeer 10 months ago 2
the "not gonna get us" part is sooo fake :(
marjoleinleeman 10 months ago
@marjoleinleeman because Yulia was sick by that time and because they recorded that song when Yulia was younger, which means her voice was higher... :)
AmyandZacky4ever 9 months ago
@marjoleinleeman
Hmmm.. ok but who cares?
RadhaDaSilva 3 months ago
OH Por Dios siempre envidiare a Mexico y esta sera una razon mas
tatuyugipiulover 1 year ago
Man they're hot. But their voices fucking suck. What happened? Couldn't afford some autotune?
legitimatemind 1 year ago
tatu es Lo maximo qee bueno aun hay PERSOnas qee les guustaa tatu cmo amY=)
Tatumaniaqa 1 year ago 2
En mexico somo bien chingones apoYando, nosotros si CANTAMOS (Y)...
Wuuapolina 1 year ago
I dont' understand one thing: if Yulia can't sing high notes, why doesn't Lena? She can. Well, she sang that song alone anyways...
zapolnenie 1 year ago 2
es super entendible porque esta doblando... maldito ivan le daño las cuerdas vocales :/
claudianthescene 1 year ago
it's understandable why she has to lip synch the high notes
girlplz007 1 year ago
I love them <3
ExcellenceOfInnova 1 year ago
oh, yulia, i know you really have to lip synch, and i am at awe with your effort on singing live on obezyanka nol (see part 3). t.A.T.u. forever.
sugarrruiz 1 year ago
is the best crowd so far.... just bcause they haven't come to CHILE! ask any artist and they will tell you the same.
oktannuza 1 year ago
Roman Ratej es el único baterista que a tenido t.A.T.u. que sabe tocar Not gonna get us, Steve Wilson es bueno pero en esta canción no lo hace como Roman y Jesper (baterista de Lena) es genial pero le falto mucho al tocar esta canción...
I LOVE ROMAN RATEJ
LenaKatinaTv 1 year ago
this is the best audience ever.
29candygurl 1 year ago 5
są najlepsze < 3
anka666229 1 year ago
D: is she lipsinking D:::::
PSYCHOSRUS 1 year ago
que contraste de vestuario entre las dos
Britneysimsvideos 1 year ago
Класс ! Урааа !!!
saninnaa 1 year ago
oh..so sad...yulia can't sing this song anymore...can't find any "real live"...
catnip302 1 year ago
PART 2 DONE GOING for 3
JVProductionsvids 1 year ago
estube investigando y todo me indica que las notas mas altas yulia las gritaba en el estudio las notas largas , es por esos que no las canta en vivo , es ovio que no vaa a gritar en el concierto imaginense el ridiculo , no digo que no tengaa una exelente voz pero en esta cancion es la opinion que yo tengo, no es la primera vez que grita una nota .
XXPHOENIX1000 1 year ago
yulia es la que mejor canta y no se porque la ponen en playbak
wiishit 1 year ago
@wiishit Porque perdio mucha voz Lena tambien canta bastante bien sostiene muy bien las notas por eso en el segundo disco se oye mas ;)
LenaKatinaTv 1 year ago
No entiendo porque esta cancion siempre la parte de yulia la colocan en playbak... acaso no puede cantarla en vivo?
ildyavolo 1 year ago
@ildyavolo NO AGUANTA LA NOTA ESTA LASTIMADA SU VOZZ Y YA TIENE RATO DEVERIA CANTARLA AUNQUE FUERA TONOS MAS ABAJO
jose8989ful 1 year ago
@jose8989ful supongo que si puede hacerla mas bajito pues lena tambien la canta y bien suavecito como es caracteristica en su voz (de Lena)...
ildyavolo 1 year ago
la morena nunca cantó...pero igual...sexy
nincas 1 year ago
eres entero pollo
davidneposedy 1 year ago
T.a. t. U=AMEN
alexchris500 1 year ago
julia tuvo problemas de voz, pero canta fenomenal, y le da esa fuerza libertaria a tatu
davidneposedy 1 year ago
Why has such a bad voice and why he sings to playback? answer pls
milanurna 2 years ago
HE????? SCUSE ME
tatuyugipiulover 2 years ago
she :) ....sorry,i am asshole :D
milanurna 2 years ago 4
Yulia Volkova had big problems with her voice, and she can't everytime sings the high notes...
t.A.T.u. rocksssss!
ExcellenceOfInnova 2 years ago 7
well you do know they don't sing any of their English songs right? :P they said it an interview that they have other people sing the English song for them.
katierospe 1 year ago
yes thats right!!!
theonlyoneW600 2 years ago 3
que bonito!!! lo digo porque en todos los conciertos que e visto en youtube.. incluso los de rusia no corean las canciones.... ni siquiera cuando ellas apuntan el microfono al publico! en mexico somos a todo dar!!!! VIVA MÉXICO!!!! y que bonitas ellas... se ven felices y asi como sorprendidas de como es la calides de la gente!!!!
theonlyoneW600 2 years ago 38
@theonlyoneW600 mexico y todos los paises latinoamericanos!!! estos lados son calientes y la verdad es q somos mas animados en vivo!! por eso es q las bandas q hacen tour por latinamerica siempre vuelven.. sres sintamonos orgullosos de ser latiños coño!!!! Yeahh saludos desde venezuela!!
TheYamr 1 year ago 2
@theonlyoneW600 De que hablas?? en todos los conciertos de Tatu el publico coreaba las canciones a todo pulmon asi como en Mexico creeme el mundo amo y amara por siempre esta banda.
Rrodriguec 1 year ago
@Rrodriguec yo no digo que la gente no las queria, yo me refiero a que en muchos conciertos, la gente parecia sin emocionos... todos tiesos!
theonlyoneW600 1 year ago
@theonlyoneW600 pero mexico fue la diferencia entre el resto del mundo....claro ejemplo es este. Lastima que las TATu tomaron rumbos distintos si no este seria el grupaso del momento....
soyguapoylindo 6 months ago
@theonlyoneW600 no es por ser xenofobico pero en italia y en otros paises fue lo mismos ..creo que ahi se escuchaba ma spor el tipo de escenario
777SCP 6 months ago
taty *___*
ExcellenceOfInnova 2 years ago 6
Tatoo! Those hena on my arms, not Tatu xD
xxxruzzelxxx 2 years ago
that's a pity....they should invent time machine to make her be able to sing as she could before...
jajohnek 2 years ago 3
i know .lol. thats wat makes her speacial only her can make her voice sound like that thats what ive been telling people about yulia i still think she has a great voice after her surgery thou:)
shanaekt 2 years ago
Well technology really makes one sound so good, i love technology and i love tatoo
xxxruzzelxxx 2 years ago
I got no time to do some research, I just came to watch them sing but i was a bit disappointed in this vid, I hope they can sing this song live without lipsynching so that it would be more natural and a better performance
xxxruzzelxxx 2 years ago
bubilouextravaganza is right. do your research. it's one of the first things you would read anyways. and as for it being a better performance because it's more natural? tch. you don't know anything. they ONLY sing live now. you can't blame yulia for something she physically CANNOT DO anymore. jesus.
scenekidx43 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
sometimes you should use your mind, i came to youtube because i wanna watch them perform, not to read about their fcking history of whatever past they have, lypsinching doesnt make a singer natural. Haha, 2 points for me and 0 for you. They sing live now? well that's good, and im not blaming for if she cannot sing her song, im just happy bcoz technology makes people sound really good but all those boosters doesnt really help them when they sing live. Haha, sorry for pwning you
xxxruzzelxxx 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
um. so thanks for pwning me with a complete lack of ability to spell. how old are you? five? yeah. i thought so.
scenekidx43 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
you really got no logic, sorry for owning you again but your goin way out of the topic, Im saying that they dont sing good on live. period! Eevrybody knows that, how old are you? 65? Too old yet too stupid, yes Im jsut a 5 year old kid yet I kept on pwning an old old dirty stinky grandpa like you LOL
xxxruzzelxxx 2 years ago
Wow... :') Como siempre el pulbico mexicano el mejor, hahaha!!
Daria todo por haber estado ahi!!!!
t.A.T.u!!!
tatumalchik13 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i love this song so much....and yesterday i found a new band on youtube by accident,GIRL MEET GIRL-YOU BUR MY HEART,i love so much this band,thats my new fav band....
porcalhaos 2 years ago
welll she lips sings that part because she cant go that high any more my mothers a singer so high notes u can do in the studio is much different than the ones u do on stage in the studio u can do it over and over again ontill u get it right but when ur out there on stage if u crook on bit that messes everything up and yulia got a throught surgery a couple years bak before they did the album dangerous and moveing so she doesn't have that fine cute chiky movie like she did she still sounds great!
shanaekt 2 years ago 6
because shes getting older like puberty her voice is gonna change like when yulia speak u can hear that she speak like shes kinda horse but its still cute her voice has change alot but her talent and well hottness havn't change one bit lena voices havn't change much she rocks too tatu is too girl takeing on the world and they rock at it TATU FOR LIFE!!!!!!
shanaekt 2 years ago 3
omg 5 +´s for such a nooooooooob statement xD you lil footfolks have no idea about music, the secret is EVERYBODY can sing those songs, but it wouldnt that good without the lil man behind his pc
Gosu85 2 years ago
I love t.A.t.U.
ExcellenceOfInnova 2 years ago 3
you can hear clearly that she didn't sing the high parts. they are playback. but I think it's ok that they at least sing the normal parts by themself.
nodlimax 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Same thing as on the other performances. Certainly a catchy song, but they suck live.
VoxHouseStudio 2 years ago
they don't suck live.
you probably don't know the background story to either of them.
the one with black hair (Yulia) who sings the "Not Gonna Get Us!" bits had a vocal cyst and clearly can't go that high anymore, plus she was only about 15-16 when she recorded that song, and her voice is going to sound different. Besides, on the other parts she sounds fine, and the one with red hair (Lena) sounds amazing when she sings as well.
xXxcrazyxXxmeeganxXx 2 years ago 2
amo a yuliaa lastimaa x los de sus cuerdas vocales
VMCOXE 2 years ago
me siento mal por la garganta
de yulia
bueno no solo por la garganta si no por sus cuerdas vocales
ya lleva muchas operaciones
que bueno que se cuide...
y ya no haga esas notas tan agudas
basteth66 2 years ago
oyer pero si yulia nunca ha cantado las partes agudas su voz la arreglan por el ordenador para el cd musical , nunca la he escuchado cantar en vivo esas partes agudas ,pero me gusta mucho su musica , tatu : the best
javidralban 2 years ago
I love them and this song but they always lipsynch when they sing it live
xxxruzzelxxx 2 years ago
damn i wish i went to this concert, i'm a really big fan of tatu and i feel so sad that they are spitting up... i love them! they changed my life!!
estoyhartodeesto 2 years ago
and the girl with red hair LENA IS HOT TOO!
TatushkaGirl 2 years ago 4
they can sing so shut t he fuck uo now
TatushkaGirl 2 years ago
se re nota que el "not gonna get us" es gravado y no lo dice ella, si bien CREO que ese tipo de entonaciones le trajo problemas en la voz, no quita el echo que nunca lo pueda cantar y solo aparezca en el disco ya que posee multiples ediciones
Cindor4 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
they cant sing for shit but the black haired is so HOT !!!!! XD
dengladepostman 2 years ago
chido
OSOHACK 2 years ago
Lena es lo máximooooo canto demasiado biennnn , como siempre XD
EvangelineTodd 2 years ago 4
but damn.. the black haired girl is so hhaaawt xD
revan91m 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
damn i would be so embarrest if i stand on stage and scream in a microphone, that isnt acutally on.. lol..
i like the song.. but performing like this is a joke.. i mean.. they got a number one hit and cant sing for shit...
revan91m 2 years ago
awesome!
wwebatista111 2 years ago 2
I love the live-versión although u can hear the playback, their voices are still there, that's great. I love tatu!
oktannuza 3 years ago 4
woow that was the first time ive ever saw tatu no joke it was the first time i ever heard them sing there the best tatu rocks,
julian1dude 3 years ago
Asi o mas playback no entiendo por que lo hcen si ellas cantn muy bien
Milena88101 3 years ago
do you actually realise how hard it would be for someone to sing the parts were yulia is in lip sync.
robertuk2006 3 years ago 2
es lindisima lena *_*
pixuloncoman 3 years ago 14
yulia is sexy
MiguelAngelThielman 3 years ago 39
I have never actually heard Yulia sing the 'Not gonna get us!' part ever. Its always from the cd recording.
YuriLover164 3 years ago 2
thats because the part where she was singing because she can't actually go that high. no one can its just like...not possible :)
xXxcrazyxXxmeeganxXx 3 years ago 3
Actually it is possible. People can go higher.
YuriLover164 3 years ago 13
even if they can, they avoid it or don't do it at all 'cause it's really damaging and pointless in a live performances
it's cool for the studio recordings though
BlumchenLive 3 years ago 9
Fact is, she has sang like that before, but like the above said, damaging the vocals happens, and that's exactly what happened to these two, but they're still awesome :)
NigsnMilk 3 years ago 10
she did actually used to go that high, its becuase of going that high she got a vocal cyst, and now unfourtuanaly she cant hit those notes anymore. =/ but there still amazing! i love t.A.T.u.!!=D
zombiesrock567 2 years ago 3
alot of miming there;)
Ollie9393 3 years ago
la neta estas chava cantan bien poka madre!!! (aparte de ke estan como kieren) son lo mejor de Rusia... hay ke apoyarlas para ke sigan con su carrera las niñas!!!
son la neta!!!
(y estan como kieren)
jajajaja
Arturopollon 3 years ago 3
I wish Yulia would stop wearing those tacky clothes.
NotSo0rdin4ry 3 years ago
Dark2104malo Esta bien disculpame de verdad staba de mal humor cuando lei tu comentario, una sola palabra basta para dañar el dia d una persona asi q si vas a responder a un comenterio lee bien xq me cayo bien mal que me discutieras algo q es obvio que ella hace playback en el coro xq sta operada d las cuerdas vocales yo no dije nada ni malo, ni falzo, ni del otro mundo para q me respondieras d esa manera yo soy fan d tatu y uno d los mejors. chao cuidatex
jesus17valencia 3 years ago
bueno lo que m paso cuando Vi tu comntario yo habia djado de ver la parte 3 cuando cantaban OBEZYANKA NOL Y POR UN DSCUIDO MIO MeREGRESE ALA SEGUNDA PARTE OSEA ESTA DE NOT GONNA GET US Y COMO NO ME DI CUENTA YO PENSE Q ESTABA LEYENDO LOS COMENTARIOS DE LA 3ra PART COMO YA T MENCIONE ASI Q CUANDO vI TU MENSAJE M SALI D MIS CASILLAS PORQ EN LA 3RA PART JULIA CANTA SUPR RONK Y PZ ESE FUE MI ERROR NO T PREOCUPS LA CULPA LA TNGO YO POR SER TAN DSCUIDADO YO TAMBIEN SOY FAN DE TATU
ESPRO Q ESTES BIEN
Dark2104malo 3 years ago
i am so exited just because i saw the video...
now imagine if i was there! :D
wanna see them :(
so bad :(
tatu rocks(:
0omare 3 years ago
Dark2104malo en el coro hace playback imbesil!!
jesus17valencia 3 years ago
okokokokok fue mi error lo admito puede que en el coro lo haga ¬¬¡¡¡ y no me digas imbecil, estupido'¡¡¡¡¡¡ ya admiti que fue mi error pero no es necesario lamarme imbecil tarado¡¡¡¡¡
Dark2104malo 3 years ago
i love this song, but they arnt singing in this video :S just a little bit..
Jolle1337 3 years ago
Yulia hace playback en el coro xq ella esta operada de las cuerdas vocales y no puede cantar d esa forma en vivo!
jesus17valencia 3 years ago
acaso no oyes lo ronca¡¡¡¡¡¡ q esta¡¡¡¡¡¡ y me dices que esta usando playback porfavor¡¡ ¡¡¡¡
talvez si estaba operada de las cuerdas vocales¡¡¡¡¡
pero se esta sacrificando a que le tiren tomatazos por lo ronca que se oye mis respetos para ella¡¡¡¡¡¡
Dark2104malo 3 years ago
julia sings some parts on playback :)) but shee is stilL good (H)
cgikidrajula 3 years ago
Lena actually has some singing potential..Julia really just doesn't have a voice. =/ Lena tends to run out breath, but with training she can do better.
stefgi32 3 years ago
I agree, she can sings beautifully but does need some coaching.
NotSo0rdin4ry 3 years ago
Nas Ne Dogoniat!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
ppoddge 3 years ago
the one with the short hair has the perfect voice. the oe with the long hair... her voice is kinna borin
madcow2790 3 years ago 2
yulia is singing not gonna get us on playback but they are fabolus
iva2888 3 years ago 2
nonononononono i want listening to a real voice (true live)
Yulialoves 3 years ago
i take that back, they sing in some places :p
majjskolven 4 years ago
hmm they dont sing live. they use playback and mimick themselves =// not the same thing but well who cares
majjskolven 4 years ago
Nas Ne Dogoniat!!!
picvic7 4 years ago 6
t.A.T.u. is most definatly the BEST.
i love how theyre always so hyper
i love all of their songs, even the russian ones, especially the russian ones
taty es lo max del mundo... la cancion all the things she said - ya soshla s uma , me hace recordar bonitos tiempos... :)
xiki619andaluza 4 years ago 7
lol who is yulia tryin to fool?
chanmenh 4 years ago
is palyback only in the julia's parts
but lena sing in life
she sing and julia so
but she have a grave voice
pka2apo 4 years ago 3
I respect the girls of t.A.T.u. so much. I must be rather hard for Yulia to be able to face the audience ever since her manager had ruined her voice. It's still rather beautiful, but she'll never be able to sing "Not Gonna Get Us" again without a playback.
She did very good. I expected a full play-back. Both she and Lena did very well. :)
I applaude you, t.A.T.u.
MagiciansMaiden 4 years ago
That say that the manager yulia? That the fault is his problem of the vocal cords?
xiki619andaluza 4 years ago
Yep. He forced her to sing REALLY high notes. Her voice just couldn't take it after a while, so it got hurt...
It's all his fault.
MagiciansMaiden 4 years ago 3
I hate Ivan and Parviz >:(
xiki619andaluza 4 years ago 6
a mi me tambien
lingpat11 3 years ago
i like how the crowd dancing like Yulia @ da end :]
picvic7 4 years ago 2
Somehow, they ALWAYS go playpack in the choros on this song. Makes me wonder if they are actually able to sing those high notes in real life?
TheGirlInTheBloodyDr 4 years ago
They used to be able to when they were teenagers, but their voices work differently now. They can still both sing very high, but Yulia can't really scream high notes anymore because of the cyst she had. But, I don't know, maybe after vocal therapy, she can do it again. We'll have to wait for the 3rd album
Yablonya28 4 years ago 2
Yes, PLAYBACK!
Flavia36 4 years ago
playback!
jochynichols 4 years ago
shes not a very good lip syncer for the playbacks!!!!
popsikitty101 4 years ago
i think she had surgery not to long ago!!! Her voice sounds so painful! But she still awesome!
:D
picvic7 4 years ago 3
well the chorus was allways playback, like allways. But the other parts were live. Oh and "shining above you" was also playback
2620719 4 years ago
I love them in their concerts because they are so nice... they urge the crowd to sing and most singers dont want the crowd singing cuz it drowns out their singing.....
Petray69 4 years ago
Omg I why is yulia singing the parts of Lena :')
Cannotfindaway 4 years ago
She isn't.
FagtasticMalchik 4 years ago
son lo mejor tatu!!!!! no importa en vivo o en play back u rock!!!! ya viene su nuevo disco "waste manegent" en el 2008 creo y su pelicula "finding tatu"!!!!1 ustedes son lo mejor!!
kikokokenvcdvfbf 4 years ago
Playback??
jakithaa 4 years ago
Shining in your fire? What the fuck?
You mean shining above you?
HA.
Stupid.
GREAT VIDEO!
LenaTatuYulya 4 years ago 2
few lines in NGGU lyrics are often mistaken:
'shining above you' is 'shining upon you'
'nothing can stop us' is ''nothing can stop this'
'to everything simple' is 'keep everything simple
just for the record lol :)
dannii02 3 years ago 4
what did lena say 2 yuila at the end??
vennejam 4 years ago 2
Yulia didnt lip-sync, but for the parts like at the beginning and end like "not gonna get us" in super high pitch, was lip-syncing, and "shining in your fire" was lip-synced too. the notes to reach those are impossible without editing, even she dosent lip-sunc the rest of the time, those parts will be lip-sunc. great performance guys!
xxxiluvNickCarterxxx 4 years ago 3
ay man why why the playback...they could have made the audience sing...like always...
darkgoddessaki 4 years ago
yulia's voice being shot to shit was the reason for the playback of her vocal track.
ligerbusa 4 years ago
umm i know that whole cyst thingamajiggy. all i'm saying is make the audience sing along like they usually do.
darkgoddessaki 4 years ago
This was in 2005. Month before they started having the audience sing.
FagtasticMalchik 4 years ago
chingas a tu puta madre
victoririzar 4 years ago
luv this performance!!! luv t.A.T.u.!!!
brendonatkins 4 years ago
OoH I wish that they'd come to the U.S., but if they don't come for their next album, I'm going to go to Mexico to see them >:D
And poor Yulia, her throat! :/
StLibee 4 years ago
mexico no es mierda, ademas tatu fue a brasil y argentina ha hacr conciertos asi que, informate antes de hablar. P.S- no soy mexicano
darkangel1417 4 years ago
tatu
sanjoe1975 4 years ago
i love u julia julia volkova ;)
lovejulia69 4 years ago
jajajaja eso si somos super suertudos jujuju tatu es lo maximo jajajajajajaja
pilili89 4 years ago
Awiiiiiiiiiiii ! <3
kotikatu 4 years ago
i fink on this song is to high 4 yulia so they use playback Lena is lucky not 2 hav 2 sing really high notes !!!
wizzyB 4 years ago
damnn cool i'm jumping right now
OomeBien 4 years ago
julia seems to sing a playback but lena not
EeoutofmymindEe 4 years ago
why are they banned from the U.K?
Connyml1521 5 years ago
they are banned from the uk it really isnt fair :(
rudolf1992 5 years ago
yeah it is not... and i cant believe how it is possible in UK???
(such a country) WHY???
junomathilda 4 years ago
well baisically, it was homophobes saying it wasnt suitable, and then they got banned, so now we cant but any of the CD'S or DVD'S they release :(:(
rudolf1992 4 years ago
What????? t.A.T.u. were banned in the U.K.? No they weren't I haven't anything about that.
brendonatkins 4 years ago
They weren't banned when they first came out BBC tried to ban the video, but my local music store carries all thier cd's and dvd's.
ravenrya 4 years ago
oh, that's cool. Still, if the U.K. is free, how can they ban something like that? I don't recall the U.S. doing that to music and last I checked, the U.K. was more free then the U.S.
brendonatkins 4 years ago
They try to ban, then the press get a hold of them lol.
I think they get complaints about music video's but don't ban them anymore. Unless they depict a whole lot of violence or sex. Even then just put till after 9pm or something.
ravenrya 4 years ago
I see!!! lol
brendonatkins 4 years ago
mexico is a Fucking lucky country you have tatu twice !!! while ther rest of us never or just once
Brockurock 5 years ago
wooooooooooowwwwwwwwww
chucho9 5 years ago