@BEYADEHVATAN it's about more than that - it's about the impermanence of our "great civilizations". at the end of the day we're all humans and we must accept the mortality of our society because we are imperfect. this song is not sad - rather, it's an answer to those who are bursting with pride at the greatness of any society in the world. "exiting empires" , as if they're all just taking their turn to exit the freeway. look at how great the scythian empire was and look at them now.
Dude why can I not just find the original version to this song does anybody know what I'm talking about? It is where he is whistling in the intro and stuff, please for the love of god where can I find the original I'm not saying this version of the song is bad but just tell me where the ORIGINAL IS!!!!!!!
I love the Andrew Bird community on YouTube... a lovely escape from people seeking publicity that really gives nothing but a few "thumbs up if.."... Everyone on these videos posts comments that are their feelings, and just to enjoy the great music put here on Earth by this man.
Andrew Bird never seizes to amaze me! Every time I hear his music I feel as if I'm laying in a field with no cares and worries, He is a great emotional performer.
this is weird.. but i think of a huge empty waterpark right in the middle of a clear, aqua, and refulgent ocean on a sunny day when listening to this song
I just love it when at 1:44 the music goes down and at 1:52, a faint rhythm starts at the background (a sort of a metallic sound), right before the whistling starts.. Wow, awesome..!!!
The beauty of our plastic culture clearly destroying itself. It's about humanity's arrogance, beauty, and general simple nature. Despite the fact that we think we're indestructible we're fragile and the victims of our own behavior: We're temporary.
It's a failure on your part to not be able to string together ideas, understand history, or missing the symbology he presents. You're saying he is just picking random words, I would argue that there is surgical accuracy in his precision. What is it that you think is random or doesn't fit in this song? I can help you out, if you need it.
@BirdieButter All im saying Birdie this song sucks..It makes me feel like my appointment with my dentist has prolonged itself way to fucking long... Its dull sweetheart..
It's one of my favorites too. I actually tried to whistle along with him when he performed this song at the Radio City concert in NYC and encouraged the audience members to whistle along during the middle whistle hook.
sadly most people will never be able to understand/ appreciate how amazingly talented this guy is.... what with nickleback being shoved down everyones throats and all
and if you're stupid enough to listen to some generic rock radio station or watch mtv you deserve to have crap like nickelback shoved down you're throat.
Nickelback are a very talented band, just as Andrew Bird is a talented musician, you may not like their style, but trust me, they are no crap at what they do. It's ok not to like it, I don't like Frank Zappa much but he is still an excellent musician.
No. learn to read, I didn't compare Zappa to Nickelback, I was saying that just because someones music isn't to your taste DOESN'T make that person a bad musician. I have listened and enjoyed lots of Zappa, but he often goes too far with his accidentals for my taste.
Yeah this guy rocks, but thats no reason 2 feel such disdain for Nickleback or in "nubbs" case MTV. Is Andrew a more talented musician than Nickleback? Maybe. But that doesn't mean that anything that comes from them or Mtv is automatically rubbish (although, I admit, a crap load of it is). Don't generalise and don't hate, because it will destroy your heart. And if you appriciate this music as much as you do, then urs is a heart worth keepin in good repair :)
There is something about your comment that makes me want to think of it as the best comment I've ever read even though it consists of a variation of the same phrases over and over. You just add something special to it.
I love some of the shit you deuchebags are saying oh my god you sound like fucking retards; Frenchieflowers: " I love his voice...its like lying on the floor and looking up at the sky-" wow get a life you jackass that was the most rediculous shit i've heard in my life.
i think about it more than i should, we will all be archaic/the past some day but we can't grow old/cold. andrew's music is totally relevant to this spirit.. plasticities? :)
They were an empire north of the middle east that existed in various forms (three kingdoms, and domination by other empires at certain points)around the seventh century BC until the first century AD. The song pretty much describes everything about them... lol
They were reknown horsemen. They suffered defeats, in about the fourth and third century BC I think, at the hands of the Macedonians, Thracians, Celts, and Sarmatians, ultimately combining in a collapse of the Second Scythian Kingdom.
It`s a great album. A couple of reviewers had it in their top ten of 2007 and NPR`s listener survey (composed of thousands of people) for best albums of 2007 put `Armchair Apocrypha`at #10. (Radiohead won with `In Rainbows.`)
If you like this, then check out `Armchair` and `Plasticities` from the same album. In my opinion, the album`s pretty solid throughout, remains creative and thought-provoking, with one exception (turns out that that exception was written not by Bird but by his drummer.)
Why does this guy sing about Ancient Iranic empires hahah
BEYADEHVATAN 2 weeks ago
@BEYADEHVATAN it's about more than that - it's about the impermanence of our "great civilizations". at the end of the day we're all humans and we must accept the mortality of our society because we are imperfect. this song is not sad - rather, it's an answer to those who are bursting with pride at the greatness of any society in the world. "exiting empires" , as if they're all just taking their turn to exit the freeway. look at how great the scythian empire was and look at them now.
aymansays 1 week ago
Lol this song is about how the US lost the Iraq War
Cropduster777 1 month ago
Comment removed
juijitsuiskoo 1 month ago
Dude why can I not just find the original version to this song does anybody know what I'm talking about? It is where he is whistling in the intro and stuff, please for the love of god where can I find the original I'm not saying this version of the song is bad but just tell me where the ORIGINAL IS!!!!!!!
fuentcent 2 months ago
@fuentcent perfected scythian empires is the one i think is the one you are talking about
fromtoronto2guelph 1 month ago
This is seriously my favorite Andrew Bird song. I don't understand why it's not more popular.
04211992April 3 months ago 2
I think I may have just found THE perfect song.
FloatingAnvil 3 months ago 3
That's no moon, it's a space station.
masonmhite 4 months ago 6
@masonmhite Hahahaha YES!
YesWallisisagirlname 4 months ago
@YesWallisisagirlname Wallis isn't a girl name.
masonmhite 4 months ago
that's not an owl...it's a parakeet.
wrighjac 5 months ago
stare at the owl and it starts to look like its moving or 3-D. crazy shi t
iambored1121 5 months ago
PERFECTION.
xuki2090 5 months ago
is andrew bird an owl?
xXChingon2480Xx 6 months ago 4
Listening to Andrew Bird at work, my spirits are lifted. How can you possibly have a bad day when you listen to his music, impossible!
Aggieboy83 7 months ago
This song is the best song ever!!!! When I first listened I was stuck to it!
orrin1136 7 months ago
4 people can't hear
mike759759759 7 months ago 5
This song makes my journey through life just that much better.
onthewaterr 7 months ago 5
Officially my favourite song of all time. Yup, I said it. It means little to most, but I said it. And meant it. Listen.
falang78 8 months ago in playlist Andrew Bird - Armchair Apocrypha 6
I love the Andrew Bird community on YouTube... a lovely escape from people seeking publicity that really gives nothing but a few "thumbs up if.."... Everyone on these videos posts comments that are their feelings, and just to enjoy the great music put here on Earth by this man.
PeteOnRunescape 8 months ago 12
@PeteOnRunescape
Except that you're getting thumbs up by deriding those same people. Love AB, just saying.
genovesachx 1 month ago
Oh,do I love the album cover
Feygeass 8 months ago
Great song!
sneltekenaarHugo 8 months ago
I've been modeling most of my music around the sounds Andrew Bird masterfully created on this album. What he does is amazing.
If any of you have a moment, I'd be nterested to hear what others think of my music. Let me know what you think. I have a video on my channel.
clemdarlingmusic 9 months ago
1:59
dysenterygary69 9 months ago
he sounds exactly like mark kozelek in this....
deshorty504 9 months ago
Comment removed
Viovoks 9 months ago
Comment removed
Viovoks 9 months ago
Comment removed
Viovoks 9 months ago
If I study abroad, I think I'll give an Andrew Bird CD to my host family and say, "THIS is American music!"
lunasspecto 10 months ago 8
i will scotch-guard your macintosh!
shiroshini 10 months ago
en este dia perdi mi amor, el que queria para siempre, esta cancion te la dedico enrique herrera, y espero que seas feliz.....te amo
erikopan 10 months ago
This song I like very much. It's sort of soothing.
arrivederciliebe32 1 year ago
for some reason this stuff reminds me A LOT of penguin cafe orchestra, anyone else??
AviatorAndyK 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Whistle into my ear............................
kaithlyn123 1 year ago
tbh I don't love his voice, no subtlety. Kinda think it damages this heavenly song.
BlckComb 1 year ago
How the fuck are there comments about Nickleback on a Andrew Bird song, good god.
eoipa 1 year ago 48
@eoipa RIGHT?? fucking ridiculous.
LittleBrotherofWar 1 year ago
@eoipa Irony: yours is the only I see.
aqua1993 1 month ago
I think of strolling hills covered in pine, horses galloping, ancient meteor showers when I hear this song.
lowmazda626 1 year ago
i love gay men
samstrobe 1 year ago 2
I love him. I love him. I love him.
Sarah2egn 1 year ago 4
Brilliant lyrics by Andrew Bird
Five day forecasts bring black tar rains and hellfire
While handpicked handler's kid gloves tear at the inseams
Their Halliburton attaché cases are useless
While Scotch-Guard Macintoshes shall be carbonized
Now they're offering views of exiting empires
Such breathtaking views of Scythian empires
lklnd97 1 year ago 8
Andrew Bird never seizes to amaze me! Every time I hear his music I feel as if I'm laying in a field with no cares and worries, He is a great emotional performer.
jetaimevogue 1 year ago 2
One of my brothers favorite bands, I think I'll have to buy the album and play it at his memorial. My brother died last week.
csycica 1 year ago 6
@csycica really? or are you trolling?
jsmyth259 1 year ago
so sorry for you loss :(
bambar02 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
so sorry for you loss :(
bambar02 1 year ago
Love this end of the world.
flannery98 1 year ago
This song is awesome
ANeonTiger 1 year ago
2:00. Reminds me of the Breakfast Club when they're all whistling a tune together:]
peace4allyo 1 year ago 2
I don't smoke weed but when I listen to this I feel high =)
spooninspoon 1 year ago 5
this is weird.. but i think of a huge empty waterpark right in the middle of a clear, aqua, and refulgent ocean on a sunny day when listening to this song
iSodaa 1 year ago 2
I just love it when at 1:44 the music goes down and at 1:52, a faint rhythm starts at the background (a sort of a metallic sound), right before the whistling starts.. Wow, awesome..!!!
redemptionredeemed 1 year ago 6
really love this!
misstickly 1 year ago
love them
Cy86 1 year ago
ive only recently started listening to him. can you believe it took me 17 years?! absolutely brilliant. i will be seeing live soon :D
sawthewaves 1 year ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
one of those songs i wouldnt like anymore if they played it on radio too often
360burner 1 year ago
one of those songs i wouldnt like anymore if they played it on radio too often
360burner 1 year ago
just felt like sharing it. I was sitting down listening to this album.
handicappeddoilookok 1 year ago
Probably one of the most brilliant intro's. ever. But then again, this is a brilliant song.
JitskeNL 1 year ago 6
andrew bird plays the most beautiful music i've ever heard.
mollysthename 1 year ago
i hadn't heard this version before and do have to say Iove both versions equally.
gableto 1 year ago
beautiful song. Makes me yearn for the past so much.
Alleneagle88 1 year ago
What's the song about?
Twycross 1 year ago
The beauty of our plastic culture clearly destroying itself. It's about humanity's arrogance, beauty, and general simple nature. Despite the fact that we think we're indestructible we're fragile and the victims of our own behavior: We're temporary.
jophus82 1 year ago 6
Great song writer, just wish he didn't use the dictionary as a dartboard.
rouleduke86 1 year ago 4
It's a failure on your part to not be able to string together ideas, understand history, or missing the symbology he presents. You're saying he is just picking random words, I would argue that there is surgical accuracy in his precision. What is it that you think is random or doesn't fit in this song? I can help you out, if you need it.
jophus82 1 year ago 2
Just came back from Bird's concert at the Esplanade Singapore!!! SMASHING!!!! This was one of the songs!!!
LadyDancer55 2 years ago
God, this is bugging the hell out of me.
Does anybody know which Australian ad uses the 'whistle' chorus from this song?
awesome87 2 years ago
@awesome87
it's the Seek ad
yaidan 2 years ago
@awesome87
FUCK, i knew i'd heard this somewhere
gloomyoutlook 1 year ago
amazing
ParkerPennsylvania 2 years ago
This music has a little playful soul in it. Hooray for reminding us we are alive instead of hypnotizing us, Andrew Bird!
Mattprole 2 years ago 8
At 1:04 when those higher notes start, my brain starts to get ecstatic. Audiophile orgasms *shiver* until the end, and then I play it all over again.
I'd almost feel dirty if I didn't know any better. ;)
BirdieButter 2 years ago 90
What about the bass at 2:30? That's what gives me the mindgasms
Bubbadude329 2 years ago 4
@Bubbadude329 its all ridiculously awesome! :-)
Volume1216 2 years ago
@BirdieButter same here bro, same here, great music!
Volume1216 2 years ago
@BirdieButter damn, same here :O
Cucu1 1 year ago
@BirdieButter wow your mind is sxy i only smile with this song but i think it´s beautiful
AmApOiA 1 year ago
@BirdieButter huh man relax
speeches 1 year ago
@speeches Do you mean woman, relax? Go relax yourself.
BirdieButter 1 year ago
@BirdieButter All im saying Birdie this song sucks..It makes me feel like my appointment with my dentist has prolonged itself way to fucking long... Its dull sweetheart..
speeches 1 year ago
@BirdieButter audiophile? youtube? lol.
thisisrlynotmyname 4 months ago 4
After seeing him at the Ryman in Nashville this song has grown on me SO much.
It was in his finale, and it was SO epic. The lower tone(bass) part of the song thrumped through the floors of the Auditorium as the crowd danced :D
ProfessorCrow 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I was there! So good.
michckay 2 years ago
my favorite song from this album. And that's saying something. For some reason, I don't think Nickelback when I listen to Andrew Bird.
bastiat2450 2 years ago 2
This is my favorite song!
His songs are emotional...
99jimmycat 2 years ago 2
i'm gonna marry this guy:)
peace4allyo 2 years ago 4
This song is awesome!!
qdiddylishish 2 years ago 4
Comment removed
superframus 2 years ago
YOU SIR ARE NOT JUST SILENCED BUT DIS AGREED WITH!
To:superframus
manatyson 2 years ago
Comment removed
superframus 2 years ago
Lol it wasn't just my opinion ur comment was blocked... And im not the one that did it... it was the 7 people that disagree with you :p
manatyson 2 years ago
why are people talking about nickleback on a andrew bird song? i really like this singer.
lifesart1 2 years ago 4
CARLOS TE AMO
anegela 2 years ago
i always get chills at 2:33
PACKSrock331 2 years ago 4
@PACKSrock331 omg you're so right
KopfSchm3rz 1 year ago
This was the first Andrew Bird song I ever heard. I think it's still my favorite.
megdondero 2 years ago 7
It's one of my favorites too. I actually tried to whistle along with him when he performed this song at the Radio City concert in NYC and encouraged the audience members to whistle along during the middle whistle hook.
hippityhop05 2 years ago 4
I totally meant to give a thumbs up on this one. EEP!
Anyway, *THUMBS UP* for getting a crowd to whistle :)
radiohigh 2 years ago 7
That's OK. =)
I wonder how many audience members actually whistled along. I didn't pay attention.
hippityhop05 2 years ago
The Khazars were Scythians:
watch?v=2r9A0PGNJ2A
xXxXTigerManXxXx 2 years ago
Tell us more.
angelbe88 2 years ago 2
"their Halliburton attache cases are useless"
sadly most people will never be able to understand/ appreciate how amazingly talented this guy is.... what with nickleback being shoved down everyones throats and all
pinug79 2 years ago 11
most people don't know what a halliburton attache case is
if i hadn't seen the first season of lost, i wouldnt have known what it was either
nubbs 2 years ago 2
and if you're stupid enough to listen to some generic rock radio station or watch mtv you deserve to have crap like nickelback shoved down you're throat.
nubbs 2 years ago 9
... :D
ikbenarne 2 years ago 3
Nickelback are a very talented band, just as Andrew Bird is a talented musician, you may not like their style, but trust me, they are no crap at what they do. It's ok not to like it, I don't like Frank Zappa much but he is still an excellent musician.
bizarrefruit 2 years ago
fair enough. if nickelback does it for you, who am i to judge.
nubbs 2 years ago 3
Nickleback has no talent they keep releasing the same song over and over
yebhx 2 years ago 90
@yebhx
OMG YES!
juliadrum 1 year ago
@yebhx You can literally post this as a comment to any music video and people will vote it to one of the top comments.
enewmister 1 year ago 2
@yebhx actually they changed it up, now they're releasing motley crue songs over and over.
ADarkerBreed 1 year ago 4
@yebhx this is true, but what does it have to do with this song? O.o
Jose5k 1 year ago
@Jose5k they were brought up in the comments a year ago when I watched this the first time
yebhx 1 year ago
@yebhx while you're ridiculing them for their unoriginality, they're laughing all the way to the bank
cheeseUout 10 months ago
@cheeseUout Yup, laughing at their fans.
yebhx 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Nicklebacks is the epitome of Pop Rock trash. They have talent but I have no idea why they don't use it. They are just as bad as the Jonas Brothers.
superfly299 2 years ago 16
you just compared frank zappa to nickleback.
olavtrygve 2 years ago
No. learn to read, I didn't compare Zappa to Nickelback, I was saying that just because someones music isn't to your taste DOESN'T make that person a bad musician. I have listened and enjoyed lots of Zappa, but he often goes too far with his accidentals for my taste.
bizarrefruit 2 years ago 2
@bizarrefruit Yeah, but . . . all of nickelback is an accident . . .
silverlament 2 years ago 4
Comment removed
suiciderobotmonkey 2 years ago
Comment removed
marbacc 2 years ago
Yeah this guy rocks, but thats no reason 2 feel such disdain for Nickleback or in "nubbs" case MTV. Is Andrew a more talented musician than Nickleback? Maybe. But that doesn't mean that anything that comes from them or Mtv is automatically rubbish (although, I admit, a crap load of it is). Don't generalise and don't hate, because it will destroy your heart. And if you appriciate this music as much as you do, then urs is a heart worth keepin in good repair :)
check out "Whitley - Lost In Time"
olleywoodstudios 2 years ago 6
@olleywoodstudios
There is something about your comment that makes me want to think of it as the best comment I've ever read even though it consists of a variation of the same phrases over and over. You just add something special to it.
That's a compliment, by the way.
LifesOutcastOfDeath 2 years ago 4
thank you! I totally agree
strawberrygirlxD16 2 years ago
love the rhythm and bounce
PoundItGandhi 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I love some of the shit you deuchebags are saying oh my god you sound like fucking retards; Frenchieflowers: " I love his voice...its like lying on the floor and looking up at the sky-" wow get a life you jackass that was the most rediculous shit i've heard in my life.
Whitfoa 3 years ago
looks like somebody love teh cawk
iluvjumblies 3 years ago
my favourite andrew bird song. its so magical!
Sovay83 3 years ago 2
@ cal2jack and cakeisamadeupdrug i think its: "Armchair Apocrypha"
TheManWithaSmile 3 years ago
I love his voice...its like lying on the floor and looking up at the sky..and watching the clouds slowly move by...with a smile on your face
Frenchieflowers 3 years ago 15
Woop Woop too right xD hehe
polo1233 3 years ago
@Frenchieflowers that is EXACTLY spot on!
Sassafrasican 1 year ago
lol like alot of u i was looknig for this cos of the film 4 advert, great song! :P
utnewireSam 3 years ago
anyone know what key this is in?
Soraandkiritogether 3 years ago
D# i think lol
jsmyth259 3 years ago
Makes a lot more sense to think of it as Eflat. The reason: if it's in D# you would have to spell your tonic chord as D# F double # and A #.
cartographersband 2 years ago
Amazing song! so peaceful and relaxing, something i need after a long day at college! :D:D
MCRmYlifeSAVER 3 years ago 3
Finally found this song after hearing it on a Film Four advertisement. What a fantastic song.
Can anyone recommend an album?
cakeisamadeupdrug 3 years ago 2
heh you know ditto on that, good song is good.
cal2jack 3 years ago
the meaning is so good. One day we will be the past. So true. Not something commonly thought about.
catbellzzz 3 years ago
It's not something uncommonly thought about.
Kagomewolf 3 years ago
so its the middle ground then, thought about, but not really heavily though on.
cal2jack 3 years ago
lol :)
cakeisamadeupdrug 3 years ago
i think about it more than i should, we will all be archaic/the past some day but we can't grow old/cold. andrew's music is totally relevant to this spirit.. plasticities? :)
alchemistsgarden 2 years ago
Can anybody give me the defenition
of 'scythian empire'? perhaps i'm
from the Netherlands but i've never
heard about 'scythian'..?
thanks a lot
tomvdveer 3 years ago
They were an empire north of the middle east that existed in various forms (three kingdoms, and domination by other empires at certain points)around the seventh century BC until the first century AD. The song pretty much describes everything about them... lol
They were reknown horsemen. They suffered defeats, in about the fourth and third century BC I think, at the hands of the Macedonians, Thracians, Celts, and Sarmatians, ultimately combining in a collapse of the Second Scythian Kingdom.
ehdagio 3 years ago 5
they also made wicked badass (bronze?) sculptures of animals with parts from other animals which corresponded to wicked badass metaphors.
stabbedintheface 3 years ago
not that that has any relevance to the song, or really to the scythians. but still, they were a wicked badass peoples.
stabbedintheface 3 years ago
lol, right on man.
alchemistsgarden 2 years ago 2
How is the whole album?
RedCurrantRaceme 3 years ago
It`s a great album. A couple of reviewers had it in their top ten of 2007 and NPR`s listener survey (composed of thousands of people) for best albums of 2007 put `Armchair Apocrypha`at #10. (Radiohead won with `In Rainbows.`)
If you like this, then check out `Armchair` and `Plasticities` from the same album. In my opinion, the album`s pretty solid throughout, remains creative and thought-provoking, with one exception (turns out that that exception was written not by Bird but by his drummer.)
kourieneki42 3 years ago 2
Just found the link for the SXSW 2007 performnce on NPR archives...thanks for the review!
RedCurrantRaceme 3 years ago
This is such a great song.
sufjandorado 4 years ago