TRYPTOPHAN CAN CAUSE HUGENESS!!..."That's what SHE said"

[barbaric37]

when I watched this video 4 years ago, I had NO idea that the girl was Carlie. The shaytards vlogs didnt exist.

[Bpickle1290]

LOL I love Mommytard's character in these early ShayCarl videos :D she's like... evil.

[tingDoll]

LOL. that was funny :)

[MissNikkiNeko]

The carlie in this video is like the carlie in todays videos. funny and sassy

[aelievense]

0:30 Grandpatard and Cooper in the back!

[MissNikkiNeko]

@aelievense AWWW COOPER! he is so freaking cute

[christopherawesome]

lol malachi

[theabigailjean]

That guy with Carlie is Christian Colonel, he a baseball player. They got a divorce. I think the necklace Carlie is wearing has her wedding ring on it.

[theabigailjean]

That was awesome.

[encoreprincessboo89]

that guy definitely looks like cooper's dad lol theres so much resemblance...

[ClassicRock109]

Is that carlies husband?

[TheSunnyCheese]

@ClassicRock109 Ex husband

[dicksonqabrn]

This is one of my favorites!

[preciousfootprints]

LOL i've never seen this before!

[can56111]

Is that baby malachi???

[x8holly8x]

@can56111 Na the little one is shay's parents dog I think :)

[can56111]

@x8holly8x thanks. I prolly should have figured since malachi shows up in the video as a big dog lol.

[simplyirrst9]

COOPER'S DAD!

[bambihasteeth]

"are the dishes done yet?" hahaha!

[caddog0sugar]

lol Malachi!

[daysdoes]

I can now see where cooper gets the features from, which i couldnt see in carlie :)

[chinwe37]

is that malachi.... oh my gosh

[hattieeatsthings]

Malachiiii!

[SeattleSeahawksGirl]

Aww, it's Cooper's daddy!

[curtlee2002]

Hahahahahahaha, simple but made me laugh so much.

[Joleine28]

Is that Christian Colonel?!

[iStevieRodgers]

@Joleine28 Yess!

[Joleine28]

@iStevieRodgers Is he Cooper's father?!

[iStevieRodgers]

@Joleine28 Yeah they got a divorce dont know why though

[justxboredx3]

wow shays is fat compare to now! good job on losing weight shay!!! 

[GoldenFlither15]

The funny thing is that I'm currently studying the amino acids for an upcoming quiz. And today was tryptophan day. :P

[taylorbethhh111]

HAHAHA Love this video

[CeeKeh]

This is still my favorite video on youtube!  Love it.

[MrsMJLoveAlways]

Awwww Carlie

[puppylovergirl303]

LOVE Carlie's hair in this, but isn't that Grandma and Grandpatard's dog and Grandpatard holding baby-babytard at 0:27-0:30??????????? :D

[mulberrytoast]

I don't even want to get involved in any of this 'Cooper's dad' crap ... you people are obsessed - and incidentally, it'll be because of you lot that Shay eventually stops the vlogs. You're acting like stalkers. I will say though, Carlie looks so pretty in this! Without wishing to sound cruel, the bleached hair, extensions and tons of makeup don't do her justice. She's lovely either way though!

[MrRicksgirl2006]

Carlie looks way hotter with short hair!

[PurpleRobotMonkeys]

WTF why is there a little rat dog in their house? Was that their dog? Did it die?

[pinkfoundations]

awww hahahahha colby

[SenseiDonGraham]

lol this video was bad, we've come along way in quality

[brendanfick]

@SenseiDonGraham this video isn't bad. It's pretty good.

[password9319]

How did he get Malachi to stay calm while he held him up? Shay tried doing it in a recent video and Malachi freaked out...

[EllaKathryn]

i love their dogs! how cute!

[brendanfick]

@EllaKathryn Shay and Katilette only have 1 dog. And that's Malachi. Just to let you know.

[KaiKinapela]

Carlie! I love your hair short!

[pinksweetheart26]

was cooper born at this time?

[1chickie14]

Hey! It's Carlie and Cooper's dad!

[meandmilife]

lmao!!

[juicychick427]

When he said "Just one rule DO NOT FEED HIM..." totally thought he was gonna say "after midnight".

[mindofarock]

He looks like Coopers Dad. I wonder what happened to him? Wiki and rumors say he's a in prison? lol. Mommytard looked so hawt at the end with those highlights in her hair.

[AMBROSITY2]

Whose Pomeranian was that at 1:04...?

[cpellow36]

HAHA I LOVE SHAY!



[swiimgfreek]

Hahahahahahahahahahahaahahahah­ahahahaha that was funny!!!! It's like gremlins.

[luijie911]

another great video shaycarl :) so consistent with the funniness which will never end.

[thebrassmonkey100]

@ImmaFuckingGOD that does make a lot of sense. i think shes like 30 or so, and in her older brothers guest bedroom. And the house before this, plus if you catch her without her makeup on. It kind of looks like some sort of long term speed addicion. thats just IMO.

[C16Hollywood]

Omg! It's Carlie!!! :)

[shaytardsfollower]

thats malichi at the end

[gmamafrat79]

@ImmaFuckingGOD HAHAHAHAHA PRO RIIIGGHHHT!!!!!!!

[stevan5000]

what was on this guy's head when she left carly?!?!?!

[brenduhhize]

aww is that Coby how kute and small

[GeorgXOXO]

So thats christian colonel, Carlie i am sorry for you

[Cookie4cora2lee]

@GeorgXOXO i dont know the story between them but i feel sorry for him he left someone who seems so nice and cool

[GeorgXOXO]

@Cookie4cora2lee Yeah i heard that carlie is like and drinker and a crazy person when i read that i was like omg no she isnt she is amazing i love her. and she doesnt act like that. so yeah hahaha and btw i watch like all the old shaytyards videos and i always she you comment. hahah

[Cookie4cora2lee]

@GeorgXOXO ya im a new subscriber and i wanna watch all his videos from the beginning hehe

[Brenda4Rock]

Wow, that short hair look GREAT on Carly! But hey, that doesn't? She's beautiful and I think she even would be pretty if she where bold.. :p

And please people, stop talking/guessing why Carly and her ex broke up.. That's personal stuff.

I just love this video! :D

[nintendoscarface1982]

Dude ! Noooo. Lmao pup went from small to giant and momytard are the dishes done yet lol

[spunky080802]

@BoomerDisney - they didn't go to the same school either, or even attend college in the same state. Him cheating on her is all hear-say..there is no proof. They're both from the same hometown and so the logical conclusion to draw from their relationship is that they dated for a while, she got pregnant, and it didn't work out. There is no reason to believe that they cheated on her, everyone is freaking out over nothing..

[dbaum23]

From a black lab to a great dane, haha...

[seakid123]

what the hell did i just watch?

[LegitMonster]

AWWWHH LITTLE MALICHI!!

[jamieleesmit2010]

Carlie is pretty in this video indeed.

Now with these comments i've read, that I do agree she deserves to have privacy but since there are personal issues going on, please do her a favor and stop bringing stuff up that is confidential and no one needs to hear about it! Please respect the "Shaytard" family!

[chrissynb]

Hey look, its carlies douche of an ex husband

[SPARTAN3056]

theres an ad for kincect with the shaytards... why cant ALL ads be like this one?!?!?!

[cmoz88]

LOL @ the end

[imseksie]

Cooper's dad looks handsome. That puppy was so cute!

[kennykiller911]

lol at shay carrying malaki.. malaci. malakaie.. the great dane

[mottasim]

@kennykiller911 malachi*

[kennykiller911]

@mottasim ahh.

[hihihibi]

HOW DO YOU KNOW HE CHEATED HOW DOES ANYONE?

thats not like the kids names or whatever it's something that has never been shared accidently in a vlog. People split up for all different reasons and it's none of our business why. Leave it at that.

[usernameamy]

@hihihibi I agree with you. People deserve some privacy.

[adiavoy]

So... what's RELIABLE evidence that Cooper's dad is a cheater, alcoholic, dead-beat, AND a druggie? Honestly, why should you judge a person from comments left on a video? Saying that his dad abandoned him?... seriously, you have to mind your own business.

[nikandcar]

haha that was a funny video! carlys ex was cute but hes an ass if the cheating rumors are true, he messed up big time!

[xsmellyy]

Cooper's gonna be one handsome boy when he's older xoxo

[Spongebobs4Life]

i feel sorry for malachi.... also i love carlie's hair in this video!

[koivosk]

Didn't Cooper arrive to the ShayTards a bit later than Carlie on christmas? He was probably at his dad's.

[kwelgirl15]

@rachel935higgins he didn't really abandon her. but that guy was horrible! he cheated on her with other woman when he was traveling for his baseball team. It just makes me disgusted >:(

[Thewaterofthepool]

@kwelgirl15 Who would cheat on Carly?!?! seriously he's mental

[usernameamy]

@kwelgirl15 How do you know that? Does Shay or Carlie says that in a video or something?

[cutestuff1046]

@kwelgirl15 How would you even know that? unless ur a creepy stalker its there personal life so just leave them alone and stop making rumors.its none of ur business

[ohemmi]

I started watching ShayTards last year...so I don't know much but is that Coopers dad?

[BoomerDisney]

@ohemmi Yeah, Cooper's parents split up because his dad cheated on Carlie when he was on the road. (He was a college baseball player when carlie was a cheerleader)

[spunky080802]

@BoomerDisney - they weren't even in college at the same time. He is a lot older than Carlie.. They probably just aren't together anymore because of his baseball schedule.

[BoomerDisney]

@spunky080802 sorry, I didn't know they weren't in college at the same time i just assumed it since they both went to the same school. But he definitely cheated on her

[wsiklogfh]

so seriously, why did carly and this jerk broke up?

[livinlovinlifexoxo1]

@wsiklogfh I read she left him cuz he was an Alcoholic and a druggie, but idk, it's their business not ours

[wsiklogfh]

@livinlovinlifexoxo1 a booze-bag AND a junkie, what a loser.

[JD666MCK]

@wsiklogfh Apparently he cheated on her ... He slept with a few of her friends and other women while he was on the road playing baseball. There's a lot of stuff being said about both of them so I'm not sure what to believe. But grandmatard said in an email to me that he is a cruel person. So idk ...

[wsiklogfh]

@JD666MCK he had a gorgeous, wonderful woman like carly, and he cheated on her?, and more than once? DAMN IT! what was this greaseball thinking? it's guys like him that make a bad name for the rest of us.

[SimonStorey87]

wow mommytard look HOOOOOOOOT!

[seanmaln]

WOW!! cool video and Carlie and Mommytard look way different

[cullendroid1]

ohhhh now I get why malachi is so big...lol

[Rach2625]

Omg. Is that Malachi? Little puppy!

[Senneeeuh]

what happened to this guy why did he leave carlie?

[flowingover]

yeah that guy def looks like Cooper. what a loss for him.

[BackToGoAgain]

@flowingover yeah Christian Colonel is coopers dad. 

[ichiilah]

hmm 3 months after cooper was born, carlie a little chubbie but still hot as hell

[ichiilah]

thats christian colonel carlies ex

shay can take him on

[basktballking55]

I added carlie on facebook and she said that she couldn't add me because her ex boyfriend is crazy and he makes fake profiles and tries to add her. she didn;t want to be harassed or stalked anymore

[RockDaRedness]

1:58 :)

[NiMur90]

PS. Carly is frickin hot!

[NiMur90]

haha I lol'd at this. Shay should seriously make more sketches on his own in Idaho for this channel.. I'm not knocking the station, but these are better.

[KevinAZheng]

is that malichi? lol

[NBertuzzi]

that guy looks like a creeper

[twilightlover2412]

Carlie looks gorgeous in this video

[AiNinaMa]

I luv how the majority of the comments here are about Carlie's life rather than the actual video.

The video's so cute and the dog is HUGE! o.o

[xxxjavadasxxx]

CHRISTIAN COLONEL is Carlie's ex ... Yes it's the guy in this video.

[pinkfoundations]

@xxxjavadasxxx The baseball player? Dang. Idiot is missing out on alot.

[strawberrykisslover]

Supposedly she deleted her youtube channel because people were posting mean  comments about her and her son. WHICH IS TOTALLY RUDE AND NONE OF THEIR BUSINESS..

<3

[xaprilwindsx]

@strawberrykisslover that is actually the reason, she said so herself. but i do believe this guy is crazy, so i wouldnt be suprised that he was harassing her as well.

[Acoontey]

that is definitely Cooper's dad

[kolahn1]

I liked that alot

[schokaholik]

"oh crap" ^^

[greeneggsandham642]

if carlie and that guy are supposedly married, then why aren't they wearing wedding rings?...

[rebelx2]

haha malachi xD

[sooljaboy]

@XxBlondie4everxX Yeah it is a minor leauge baseball player

[live4love87]

This is the most genius thing I have ever seen lol

[AussieLozi]

@XxBlondie4everxX sure is

[huangerjr]

i think thts not malachi, i think its shays parents dog cuz in his more recent videos, malachi and a smaller black dog with a blue leash would play together while malachi has a red leash

[jmhappy56]

@XxBlondie4everxX yes

[0unconscious0]

LMFAO malachi is the cutest

[JD666MCK]

Go down in the comments to ccolonel14 ... that's Christian's account. A couple of months ago he started posting a bunch of comments on Carlie's channel and harassing her. That's why she deleted it.

[jmhappy56]

@JD666MCK what did he say?

[molly1002]

@JD666MCK What did he say to her? I want to know because he seems like a nice guy o.O

[molly1002]

@JD666MCK I don't think she'd tell me...It'd probably just piss her off or I'd seem nosy...Which I kind am in this case cause i've always wondered who her ex was. I heard that one of them cheated and that's why they broke up! Carly doesn't seem like that kind of person, I can't imagine her doing that! but he also seemed like a nice person so I don't know.

[molly1002]

@JD666MCK Yeah, I heard that he got another girl pregnant or something! That's some freaked up stuff! Some people said Carly cheated and spread lies about him, Theirs so many lies and rumors that you really can't blame anyone! Carly seems like a fun girl to be around and somebody who wouldn't cheat on her husband! Plus most people who cheat don't have any interest in their kids...Carly seems like she loves Cooper.

[MichelleTwinky]

@molly1002 I don't think a nice guy would just leave his own son sure get divorced that doesn't mean cooper is not his son anymore so I do believe he cheated on her, a nice guy wouldn't leave his son.

[molly1002]

@MichelleTwinky Yeah, I agree! If it was Carly that cheated then I imagine he would DEMAND custody (or share) custody of Cooper! but he never sees cooper and doesn't have any interest in him (or it appears that way), so that leads me to think that he was the one that cheated.

[Denmarkpwns]

@molly1002 yeah, that is exactly what i thought.

[moterola26]

the story is the the idaho state journal. A legitimate news source

[moterola26]

STORY about Christian Colonel (Coopers Dad) Picture with cooper in it...

[moterola26]

google" christian colonel A waiting game" and it should be the first link

[GiannaStuffedWithFun]

Holy crap, Carlie looks like Kristen Wiig from SNL! :O

[Jessie12353]

Cooper's dad is a douche.

[prtybrneyez18]

Of course the first dog isn't Malachi! The second one is though

[TheCarriePotter]

carlie's hair is SO pretty short

[BornForWatchingVids]

that guy is an baseball player named christian colonel

[AndreyZidaneTM]

Cooper's dad is a dumbass! Why would you not wanna have such a hot wife and such a beautiful kid?? That's crazy...

[lulipeke7]

I don't like that guy!

aw :3 Carlie is always so pretty!!!!!!!!!

[Annergize]

Cooper's Dad... Carly and Cooper live with Shay and I think Shay buys their food and stuff. Seems like he just ditched them. What an ass.

[Acoontey]

holy crap its cooper's dad O _O

[gianelvr4]

i don't think that's malachi....isn't he like 7 years old? this was made 2 years ago

[ryanli189]

@gianelvr4 i dont think hes malachi either bcuz dont u remember in some other videos like umm the wrestle dog one on the shaytards he squirms around when he gets picked up

[Rawp90Extream]

carly is hot im glad she dumbed that douchebag she can do way better then that guy