Theory is as essential as breathing. Knowledge is power. This is anything but boring. If you don't learn music theory, you will never be a top tier guitarist. Being "self-taught" or relying solely upon your "ear" is nothing to brag about.
The embarrassing and blatant reality is that with THIS much analysis, music gets lost, does it not? Did McCartney ever sweat these details before writing Blackbird, or Yesterday? Yet McCartney is not so "schooled". I came to the edge of all this years ago, stood at the precipice, then just spat over the edge. Texture, mystery and sense of occasion in music belong to everyone, not just eggheads preaching to the choir. 3 minutes and I was done, and uncomfortable. Sorry.
@GuitarGare Haha actually yes, yes he did :) So sorry all the best musicians in history have an understanding of these concepts, whether they speak the language of "theory" or not. In the same way that people can speak but not read and write. Theory is different from reading and writing notation. Boasting about your lack of knowledge is simply a pride of ignorance, and laughable. Granted theory without putting it into practice is about as musical as doing maths on a calculator to most people.
@sacredgeometry I hope that you don't think I was bragging about my lack of knowledge.In my case, modular knowledge, to a degree, was intuitive. In every single case I've ever seen in my life, these ones doing as the man above were suffering paralysis via analysis. They never got out and made a musical mark. -e.g.- Czerny played live once in 77 years? You can talk about flowers all you want but until you get out in the garden, I'm not sure about listening to a thing you say.
@GuitarGare I completely agree in that case, I have a huge amount of disdain for people that concentrate to hard on either area, it completely negates the point of knowing either in my experience.
@GuitarGare I'm assuming you're saying theory means nothing? Hopefully for your sake that's NOT what you mean..Yeah this guy really makes no sense whatsoever and everything he plays is boring and un inspired, but theory is EXTREMELY important
@SkwisgaarScampini Yes theory is important. No question. This is an ongoing discussion. Read some of the other comments. I'm not the only affected by the way this guy portrays his knowledge. Look at a clinic by Phil Koch for example. Lots of knowledge, Night and day presentation. Fun. A required lubricant for learning. If this guy right here was MY teacher, I'd be a garbage man today. (and making better money, lol)
does the melodic minor scale play better if the guitar is wearing its shirt? and mixing the dorian minor and the melodic minor is ok only while wearing the guitar shirt? :)
Hey great lesson. If I have one suggestion it would be to play over chord changes when giving your examples. It will help us with hearing the scales in context. Especially would have helped with the Bb melodic minor over C minor concept.
@Lydianshadow I can understand protecting the guitar when teaching lessons. But in the controlled environment of a TV studio, there's no need for the protection.
Finally someone that knows what they are talking about I know this is irrelevant but I just came up with it what do u think of blending minor pentatonic with harmonic minor I know it's weird because in harmonic u have a major 7 and the pent doesn't have a 2nd or a six what do u think of that
Moral of the story: melodic minor can be played over the minor chord your on, as well as a whole step below to imply the 2nd mode of melodic minor (dorian b2) on your original minor chord. That is crazy. The second one is like a sub of a sub (melodic minor instead of dorian b2) to imply a new sound. Awesome. I never would have thought of that.
@BlikeNave You can also play it a half step up, a whole tone down, or a fifth up over any dominant chord. Or you can play it straight over a dom chord.
God this guy is so good. I can learn so much. Ahhh too much work for me as a guitarist. I've already learned so much, need to practice and use it in these ways now. Bleghhh. Work, but it will be fun. I just want to be there now!
I have actually learned something from this jazz guitar lesson.. I've learned how my music theory knowledge suck donkey balls :) I know a lot of scales but compered to this guy im little mouse... Respect sir.
Trufire's got some great lessons. I wish they would put more on DVD so that I can just buy them. Nevertheless, when you think you are ready, they are just an internet connection away. Good, good stuff.
A fantastic lesson with really captivating sounds - putting the magic back in music. Really makes me want to get this stuff deeply ingrained. Big thanks to John Stowell, a true magician of the fretboard and a master musician.
basically... he explains how to use melodic minor in a regular dorian situation... the only differance in the scale is the mel. minor has a maj7 or #7 rather than the dorian which has a b7. but it works because the sharp 7 serves as a LEADING TONE. rather than a chord tone as the 7 in dorian. BUT, he does not esplain using mel min as a triton substitute, which is what everybosy also uses it for. try substituting the melodic minor scale a 1/2 step above your 5 chord in a ii-V-I. BOOM... Jazz.
@GLeone221 BOOM... the altered scale, which is a mode of the melodic minor. I think the main purpose of this video is to explain his use of the melodic minor scale in itself, not the 6 other modes.
@latino13x3 It has nothing to do with eye sight :P. Notice how well he can get around the fret board while maintaining a straight wrist (which is preferable for any string instrument, as to not hurt yourself in the long run). I don't play with my guitar quite that high, but it is definitely not "to close" <3.
... as far as the guitar, it seems to resemble a more " rockin" frame model within the "soloette" portable / travel guitar line.it also seems to have a fabric covering for the frame to look less weird.
stowell is super badass. i have seen him a few times and attended a clinic and he definitely delivers on a few levels and is extremely approachable and willing to demystify things and has clearly considered what NOT knowing something is like and HOW different people may absorb information.
Theory is as essential as breathing. Knowledge is power. This is anything but boring. If you don't learn music theory, you will never be a top tier guitarist. Being "self-taught" or relying solely upon your "ear" is nothing to brag about.
123jozef 5 days ago
I'm sorry...what?
rabmusic2 6 days ago
Lmao "jazz musicians aren't smart enough to have another scale in 2 directions" yeah right, not smart, that's funny!
pr0llyn0t 1 week ago
funny man. Maybe he is one of "the others" in LOST.
danlovesnan 1 week ago
like the old sack on the guitar; classy
isleoforkney 1 week ago
nice video ... i am gonna see more
samwylde2 2 weeks ago
nice
iibKaradesh 2 weeks ago
Enyone else read the title ans "Modern Jazz Improv - Sharp 4 Melodic Minor Scale"?
ibanezbloke 2 weeks ago 2
It's like Seven of Nine teaching me guitar. I guess Stevie Ray was a flippin' Klingon.
GuitarGare 3 weeks ago
The embarrassing and blatant reality is that with THIS much analysis, music gets lost, does it not? Did McCartney ever sweat these details before writing Blackbird, or Yesterday? Yet McCartney is not so "schooled". I came to the edge of all this years ago, stood at the precipice, then just spat over the edge. Texture, mystery and sense of occasion in music belong to everyone, not just eggheads preaching to the choir. 3 minutes and I was done, and uncomfortable. Sorry.
GuitarGare 3 weeks ago
@GuitarGare Haha actually yes, yes he did :) So sorry all the best musicians in history have an understanding of these concepts, whether they speak the language of "theory" or not. In the same way that people can speak but not read and write. Theory is different from reading and writing notation. Boasting about your lack of knowledge is simply a pride of ignorance, and laughable. Granted theory without putting it into practice is about as musical as doing maths on a calculator to most people.
sacredgeometry 3 weeks ago
@sacredgeometry I hope that you don't think I was bragging about my lack of knowledge.In my case, modular knowledge, to a degree, was intuitive. In every single case I've ever seen in my life, these ones doing as the man above were suffering paralysis via analysis. They never got out and made a musical mark. -e.g.- Czerny played live once in 77 years? You can talk about flowers all you want but until you get out in the garden, I'm not sure about listening to a thing you say.
GuitarGare 3 weeks ago
@GuitarGare I completely agree in that case, I have a huge amount of disdain for people that concentrate to hard on either area, it completely negates the point of knowing either in my experience.
sacredgeometry 3 weeks ago
@GuitarGare I'm assuming you're saying theory means nothing? Hopefully for your sake that's NOT what you mean..Yeah this guy really makes no sense whatsoever and everything he plays is boring and un inspired, but theory is EXTREMELY important
SkwisgaarScampini 6 days ago
@SkwisgaarScampini Yes theory is important. No question. This is an ongoing discussion. Read some of the other comments. I'm not the only affected by the way this guy portrays his knowledge. Look at a clinic by Phil Koch for example. Lots of knowledge, Night and day presentation. Fun. A required lubricant for learning. If this guy right here was MY teacher, I'd be a garbage man today. (and making better money, lol)
GuitarGare 5 days ago
@GuitarGare I get what you're saying sorry for wasting your time I didn't read the previous comments haha..
SkwisgaarScampini 5 days ago
does the melodic minor scale play better if the guitar is wearing its shirt? and mixing the dorian minor and the melodic minor is ok only while wearing the guitar shirt? :)
brtmont 3 weeks ago
Soloette with carbon fiber neck?
kusakenn0335 1 month ago
Tan bueno como fea es la guitarra
erperejildo 1 month ago
huh?
leojames321 1 month ago
so whos gonna break it to him his headstocks gone?
xxxEnterSandmanXxX 1 month ago 11
@xxxEnterSandmanXxX Who's gonna break it to you that it was never there?
MalinariTheMind 2 weeks ago
This is a tough lesson for sure... I think he might as well have gone over the acsending and descending variations of the melodic scale as well.
moneyhooligan03 1 month ago
Hey great lesson. If I have one suggestion it would be to play over chord changes when giving your examples. It will help us with hearing the scales in context. Especially would have helped with the Bb melodic minor over C minor concept.
iTzNoxy 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
is this mixed scale (the last he mentioned) useful on a F7/9#5b as a passing scale?
awfulguitarplucker 1 month ago
Comment removed
awfulguitarplucker 1 month ago
I like to sing the melodic minor scale when my girlfriend sucks my dick
andrew19vato 1 month ago
@andrew19vato so .....once a year or so?
olafbigandglad 1 month ago
why is his guitar wearing a shirt?
Lydianshadow 1 month ago 30
@Lydianshadow I can understand protecting the guitar when teaching lessons. But in the controlled environment of a TV studio, there's no need for the protection.
guitarslim56 4 weeks ago
BRAIN ANEURYSM!!!!! ARRGGHHHHH!!
MrWhoTookMyName 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hey Folks, This course DOES NOT CONTAIN TAB. That was a misprint by TrueFire which I am sure they will correct when it is brought to their attention.
wvgman 1 month ago
hey John! - nice vid
loopbasedzero 1 month ago
My brain is like scrambled egg after trying to take all that in............
GBPaddling 1 month ago
the most weird technique ever seen haha
Strummingkid 2 months ago
Finally someone that knows what they are talking about I know this is irrelevant but I just came up with it what do u think of blending minor pentatonic with harmonic minor I know it's weird because in harmonic u have a major 7 and the pent doesn't have a 2nd or a six what do u think of that
timsmashuhoe 2 months ago
So basically what hes saying is take a minor arpeggio and get creative with chromatics...targeting the notes within a chord, just listen to Django.
illnastic 2 months ago
DIS GUY MUST BE AN ALIEN OR SUTIN
googoplexable 2 months ago
chatty guy..
Jplent1 2 months ago
Great demonstration.Thank you mr Stockwell.
EVEROSFP1 3 months ago
This gentlemen knows his craft. Period. Thank you for sharing.
giannidinovi 3 months ago
very nice lesson. i like the idea of mixing C mel.minor with C dorian b2. btw, what kind of guitar is that?
lucasmartinez3 3 months ago
Brother of Donald Sutherland
arnosiemons 3 months ago 4
2:21 HIS LOOK IS KILLER HEHEHE
Bflatest 3 months ago 2
i like his spider fingers
1herbiekritzer 3 months ago
Moral of the story: melodic minor can be played over the minor chord your on, as well as a whole step below to imply the 2nd mode of melodic minor (dorian b2) on your original minor chord. That is crazy. The second one is like a sub of a sub (melodic minor instead of dorian b2) to imply a new sound. Awesome. I never would have thought of that.
BlikeNave 4 months ago
@BlikeNave You can also play it a half step up, a whole tone down, or a fifth up over any dominant chord. Or you can play it straight over a dom chord.
FunkeyBiscuits 3 months ago
God this guy is so good. I can learn so much. Ahhh too much work for me as a guitarist. I've already learned so much, need to practice and use it in these ways now. Bleghhh. Work, but it will be fun. I just want to be there now!
BlikeNave 4 months ago
NIce lesson
bskkid4eva 4 months ago
lol, jazz musicians aren't smart enough? :D
bskkid4eva 4 months ago
I have actually learned something from this jazz guitar lesson.. I've learned how my music theory knowledge suck donkey balls :) I know a lot of scales but compered to this guy im little mouse... Respect sir.
mateo2711ify 4 months ago
this guy is good
dpapaioannow 4 months ago
Excelente consepto y buen sonido. Gracias por compartir y difundir el conocimiento.
roberto1950ful 4 months ago
Wonderful lesson, made me want to try playing melodic minor scales
rololoo 4 months ago
Fuck you jazz musicians are smart.
PsiloPsymon420 5 months ago
@PsiloPsymon420 he's a jazz musician. obviously it was a joke.
mrsaganscosmos 5 months ago
@PsiloPsymon420 Wow that went right over your head didn't it? Even though he was kidding, you kinda proved his point by not catching the joke!
MikeToddOnline 4 months ago
what kind guitar is that?
Great stuff
MareGitara 6 months ago
please stop blink
pianozutabo 6 months ago
Excelent Guitarrist !!!!
JoluBadBoy 6 months ago
Thank god for youtube that allow such a vast myriad of content. This guy is so relaxed and he has an attitude that is very inspiring.
nattensvaffel 6 months ago 3
Trufire's got some great lessons. I wish they would put more on DVD so that I can just buy them. Nevertheless, when you think you are ready, they are just an internet connection away. Good, good stuff.
JSustain 6 months ago
Unfortunately I'll have to brush up on my music vocab before this lesson can make any sense to me, haha.
ShittakeBukakke 7 months ago
people might find this more interesting: melodic minor myths geoff stockton
roccckkerrr 7 months ago
Oh !!
He looks like the guy from road trip
maxomilian 7 months ago
@maxomilian Kyle ?
PepitoSmooth 5 months ago
Who does he look like :s
maxomilian 7 months ago
I love this video! He's talking my language!
joojoo456 7 months ago
Great lesson! Don't listen to the idiots posting stupid comments; they're probably upset because you're not talking in "tabs".
chazzy968 7 months ago
Somebody cut off your guitars headstock.
sighisoaraa 7 months ago
that's why his guitar has a condom on it
christopher321 8 months ago 2
This guy is ridiculous!
paulb7 8 months ago
A fantastic lesson with really captivating sounds - putting the magic back in music. Really makes me want to get this stuff deeply ingrained. Big thanks to John Stowell, a true magician of the fretboard and a master musician.
twangbarfly 8 months ago
I played One of the his notes and my guitar instantly got pregnant.
SpectersKrade 8 months ago 2
Beautiful tone, excellent lesson
AllBluesCat 8 months ago
John Stowell is a true Master!!
subjulio 8 months ago
This guy's a genius!
EquinoxParadox91 9 months ago 2
basically... he explains how to use melodic minor in a regular dorian situation... the only differance in the scale is the mel. minor has a maj7 or #7 rather than the dorian which has a b7. but it works because the sharp 7 serves as a LEADING TONE. rather than a chord tone as the 7 in dorian. BUT, he does not esplain using mel min as a triton substitute, which is what everybosy also uses it for. try substituting the melodic minor scale a 1/2 step above your 5 chord in a ii-V-I. BOOM... Jazz.
GLeone221 11 months ago
@GLeone221 BOOM... the altered scale, which is a mode of the melodic minor. I think the main purpose of this video is to explain his use of the melodic minor scale in itself, not the 6 other modes.
FenderBender93 6 months ago
He supplied the epiphany damn ! i dont have the ability !
elbowout 11 months ago
He supplied the epiphany damn ! dont have the ability !
elbowout 11 months ago
"0.o" is the face you'll have if you don't know any theory like me!
choganskateboarding 1 year ago
"jazz musicians aren´t smart enough to have another scale in two directions"... now that´s stupid!!
y7u7r7i 1 year ago
man its called glasses....gt sum...ur face to close to guitar...
latino13x3 1 year ago
@latino13x3 It has nothing to do with eye sight :P. Notice how well he can get around the fret board while maintaining a straight wrist (which is preferable for any string instrument, as to not hurt yourself in the long run). I don't play with my guitar quite that high, but it is definitely not "to close" <3.
johnland82 9 months ago
... as far as the guitar, it seems to resemble a more " rockin" frame model within the "soloette" portable / travel guitar line.it also seems to have a fabric covering for the frame to look less weird.
stowell is super badass. i have seen him a few times and attended a clinic and he definitely delivers on a few levels and is extremely approachable and willing to demystify things and has clearly considered what NOT knowing something is like and HOW different people may absorb information.
semiprecioustones 1 year ago
amazing lesson
Liad0205 1 year ago
too technical for me...its really good for those jazz-maniac
jagung5 1 year ago
great lesson man
giladm 1 year ago
Great lesson, thanks!
gandalph915 1 year ago
Great lesson!!!
fly1rack 1 year ago
tnx man
RockYourLeggsOff 1 year ago
boooooooooooooooooorrrrrrrrrrrrrrrriiiiiiiiiiiiiiinnnnnnnnnnnnngggggggggggggg
zesora 1 year ago
@zesora you just don't get it!
rodeojoe55 1 year ago 11
@zesora Then leave, retard.
Fishies125 1 year ago
@zesora You mispelled FUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUNNNNNNNNN :D
johnland82 9 months ago
dont eat the guitar
marino4691 1 year ago 40
@marino4691 HAHAHHAHAHAHHAA.. Its his wife!!
Ronnsonnn 1 month ago
@Ronnsonnn lol
marino4691 1 month ago
what kind of guitar???
DesertedAcorn 1 year ago