I thought this was absolutely horrible! And her smug expression, as if she sounds good, rather than like a monster! Do please listen to Anne-Sophie Von Otter's beautiful version, by far the most dramatic and melodic I've heard. But, oh! to hear it sung by a man.........Michael Maniaci, perhaps, or Max Emanuel Cencic, or (now I'm dreaming) Philippe Jaroussky.
@broschette I actually have seen and heard all the other performances you mentioned and still love this one.
Which doesn't really say anything, of course. My taste and preference doesn't trump anyone and I wouldn't dream of denigrating any singer's performances that I dislike in order to try to sell the ones that I do. If only some fans of other singers would stop and think about how much ill will they generate for their idols with this sort of comments, perhaps they'll also learn to refrain.
@broschette I sort of think that is her fioratura technique ie: the sneer... still a beautiful voice, but I don't like the heavy chesty sounds at times
I love what she can do with interpretation, but I'd give my kingdom for an actual "ah" vowel. It's often times like listening to a mezzo/contralto version of Joan Sutherland -- not in any good way either.
I respect Kasarova for her strong personality and her artistry, even if sometimes she exagerates to the point of mannerism, she is certainly one of the most important mezzos of this time, but... the best? by what standards? how is art measurable? maybe she's your favourite, and that's fine, but there are a few other mezzos out there who are definitely at least as good, even if less known... to you.
That'll depend a lot on what you're referring to as her vocal crisis, I'm afraid. I have just listened to an air-check of her concert from last week and she sounds like her usual self. If you're referring to her use of chest notes and register breaks, I guess that isn't going away since it seems she uses those by choice. :o)
yeah, she sounds pretty good here. Lately she has started to sound very rough, particularly around the passagio. Sometimes its phenomenal, sometimes she sounds like a cat in heat channelling a sick baritone. I have tickets to her in Agrippina next year, so am looking forward to that, my first time hearing her live.
Well, that is quite clearly the doing of her over "darkening" of the voice by using basal tongue-root pressure. It was the same thing that killed Callas's voice (callous's voice -- no pun intended). That rough sound near the passaggio is one of the big warning signs of vocal nodules and over-covering and pushing, we both know, are some of the leading causes of such.
I respect Kasarova for her strong personality and her artistry, even if sometimes she exagerates to the point of mannerism, she is certainly one of the most important mezzos of this time, but... the best? by what standards? how is art measurable? maybe she's your favourite, and that's fine, but there are a few other mezzos out there who are definitely at least as good, even if less known... to you.
she's singer that you get SO much more watching sing. Amazing...and a wonder to watch. Kasarova forever~! <3
magicmonkichi 2 months ago
Questa è una vaccata.
jovi1715 1 year ago
@jovi1715 Apt description of your own comment. Really. Bravo.
SDCmorg 1 year ago
I thought this was absolutely horrible! And her smug expression, as if she sounds good, rather than like a monster! Do please listen to Anne-Sophie Von Otter's beautiful version, by far the most dramatic and melodic I've heard. But, oh! to hear it sung by a man.........Michael Maniaci, perhaps, or Max Emanuel Cencic, or (now I'm dreaming) Philippe Jaroussky.
broschette 1 year ago
@broschette I actually have seen and heard all the other performances you mentioned and still love this one.
Which doesn't really say anything, of course. My taste and preference doesn't trump anyone and I wouldn't dream of denigrating any singer's performances that I dislike in order to try to sell the ones that I do. If only some fans of other singers would stop and think about how much ill will they generate for their idols with this sort of comments, perhaps they'll also learn to refrain.
SDCmorg 1 year ago
@broschette "Chère brochette, quelle conne vous faite' "
Les 3 ou 4 octaves de sa voix ne vous disent rien ?
Jamais Berlioz n'a été chanté avec autant de maestria !
Et quelle énergie !
"her smug" Pauv'e connasse ... Elle place sa voix, ce n'est pas une poupée Barbie ! Pauv'e fille, les brochets, au canal et dans la vase, bordel...
"horrible" vous même ! Pauv'e guimauve ! proletcultiste de mes deux ...
The wizard starts at minute 2. It's WONDERFULL ! Thanks Kassarova ! Bravo !
ak0882 1 year ago 3
@broschette I sort of think that is her fioratura technique ie: the sneer... still a beautiful voice, but I don't like the heavy chesty sounds at times
JH
witchyleo34 10 months ago
I love what she can do with interpretation, but I'd give my kingdom for an actual "ah" vowel. It's often times like listening to a mezzo/contralto version of Joan Sutherland -- not in any good way either.
CountertenorJ 1 year ago
I respect Kasarova for her strong personality and her artistry, even if sometimes she exagerates to the point of mannerism, she is certainly one of the most important mezzos of this time, but... the best? by what standards? how is art measurable? maybe she's your favourite, and that's fine, but there are a few other mezzos out there who are definitely at least as good, even if less known... to you.
oberhuber1960 2 years ago
Bon...j'ai encore du boulot!
mathou1988 3 years ago
She sounds gorgeous here, I wonder wether she will manage to survive her actual vocal crisis.
SENAFOREVER 3 years ago
That'll depend a lot on what you're referring to as her vocal crisis, I'm afraid. I have just listened to an air-check of her concert from last week and she sounds like her usual self. If you're referring to her use of chest notes and register breaks, I guess that isn't going away since it seems she uses those by choice. :o)
SDCmorg 3 years ago
yeah, she sounds pretty good here. Lately she has started to sound very rough, particularly around the passagio. Sometimes its phenomenal, sometimes she sounds like a cat in heat channelling a sick baritone. I have tickets to her in Agrippina next year, so am looking forward to that, my first time hearing her live.
altodivo 3 years ago
Well, that is quite clearly the doing of her over "darkening" of the voice by using basal tongue-root pressure. It was the same thing that killed Callas's voice (callous's voice -- no pun intended). That rough sound near the passaggio is one of the big warning signs of vocal nodules and over-covering and pushing, we both know, are some of the leading causes of such.
CountertenorJ 1 year ago
Another piece of wonderful singing from the best Mezzo-soprano today-many thanks for posting..best regards Paul
berlinman46 3 years ago 3
I agreed with you, she is the BEST mezzo
rbmezzo 3 years ago
I respect Kasarova for her strong personality and her artistry, even if sometimes she exagerates to the point of mannerism, she is certainly one of the most important mezzos of this time, but... the best? by what standards? how is art measurable? maybe she's your favourite, and that's fine, but there are a few other mezzos out there who are definitely at least as good, even if less known... to you.
oberhuber1960 2 years ago