Theatraal. Monumentaal. Prachtige 'vage' tekst. Zo breekbaar en dan weer zo bruusk. Prachtige spanning die mede dankzij de violen te snijden is. Al had ik op het einde alleen op de trommel mogen slaan (6.50 min) ... wowwow.
En als ze dan na 8 minuten klaar zijn. Blijf ik samen met het publiek gehypnotiseerd achter en zing nog even door..
Theatraal. Monumentaal. Prachtige 'vage' tekst. Zo breekbaar en dan weer zo bruusk. Prachtige spanning die mede dankzij de violen te snijden is. Al had ik op het einde alleen op de trommel mogen slaan (6.50 min) ... wowwow.
En als ze dan na 8 minuten klaar zijn. Blijf ik samen met het publiek gehypnotiseerd achter en zing nog even door..
i sang this song to myself after i broke up with my gf a few weeks after in my parents car while i rode in the back seat...i felt the pathos. powerful song...an ending regardless the original intention of the song.
This song in this performace is my all time favourite song (its better here than on the record although its still beautiful on the album)i just love playing guitar along to it...simply beautiful the best band in the world.
This is what seperates Arcade Fire from other bands today, at 5.54 it should have been the end to a great performance. Instead they continue to go the extra mile, they never sit on their laurels!
that's is not new other bands used to end the set with noise and crazy things like that, remember nirvana, the who or sonic youth, nonetheless it's such a great live band
quite amazing, favourited it. This is probably my favourite song by this band, and they're probably one of my favourite indie bands as well. Not much into their second effort though.
you can record it if you have an 8th inch stereo cable and you run it from your headphone output into the mic input, but that tends to sound really bad
I can also speak English if you want. I'm quite sure you can't say it for your French knowledge.
So, first, I wanted to speak French, because, perhaps you don't know this fact, but Canadian from Quebec also speak French! Amazing!? Then, if you don't understand me, no problem, I was not talking to you.
Oh right... just becuase you're in America right. Maybe Spanish would better suit you? Pathetic. Have you ever been to Canada? Meet the people there, give it a chance, and maybe for once Americans can be open-minded.
it's like every time Regine sings the song she is re-telling the story, maybe even reliving it in her mind, brings tears to my eyes.
cheapburritos 4 months ago 2
Who are the 8 people who don't like this????? seriously, ye are deaf.....
jonspillane1980 5 months ago
Se pudesse clicar 500 trilhões de vezes em gostei, eu clicava!!!
TheRadioheadiana 6 months ago
Theatraal. Monumentaal. Prachtige 'vage' tekst. Zo breekbaar en dan weer zo bruusk. Prachtige spanning die mede dankzij de violen te snijden is. Al had ik op het einde alleen op de trommel mogen slaan (6.50 min) ... wowwow.
En als ze dan na 8 minuten klaar zijn. Blijf ik samen met het publiek gehypnotiseerd achter en zing nog even door..
RuudvanDoorn 8 months ago
Theatraal. Monumentaal. Prachtige 'vage' tekst. Zo breekbaar en dan weer zo bruusk. Prachtige spanning die mede dankzij de violen te snijden is. Al had ik op het einde alleen op de trommel mogen slaan (6.50 min) ... wowwow.
En als ze dan na 8 minuten klaar zijn. Blijf ik samen met het publiek gehypnotiseerd achter en zing nog even door..
RuudvanDoorn 8 months ago
1 of the best pieces of music ever
aussieman6910 8 months ago
silence.... and then the bass comes in
ilovemyhoens 1 year ago 5
Je reçois toujours affectif quand je vois cette vidéo
I always get emotional when I see this video
Eu sempre me emociono quando vejo esse video
gabrielbenedetti 1 year ago
That's how you fucking finish a show.
unkommon2001 1 year ago 6
Best on Youtube!!!
CinnamonWeaver 2 years ago 4
Chills chills chills.
Bamchs 2 years ago 2
perfect all around...no other voice fits this song
Mcasha89 2 years ago 3
come to mexicooo!! please!!!!
filipomed 2 years ago
@filipomed And they're comming!!
A dream come true :)
climber910 1 year ago
@climber910 OMG.. thats freakin awesome.. chalee pero no podre ir.. nooooo!! :S
filipomed 1 year ago
Amazing. So much emotion!
vexire 2 years ago
Please come to mexico!!!
ascende12345 2 years ago 2
so awesome
L1oydChristmas 2 years ago
And this is exactly what sets them apart from other bands, they are truly spectacular. This is too amazing for words, I'm blown away.
RosiE5890 2 years ago 6
Régine seems to be very emotional when she sings this song which is amazing by the way
reaper1304 2 years ago 3
That's because the song is about her mother, who died in a car crash. Listen to the lyrics carefully and you'll see the connection.
Tomorourke442 2 years ago 8
Great song. I am sure this is very difficult to sing bt Régine does it well.
bernardzyx 2 years ago 4
Every now and then I am in a melancholic mode and then this is just one of the perfect songs. Mmmmmmmmmmm
RuudvanDoorn 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
Grab this ringtone I did at DownloadEveryTone . Com it was complimentary!
harrelllqkqi 2 years ago
Mizzica
sinalecai 2 years ago
I love how in the audience there is dead silence until the bass comes back in, like they were mesmerized. I was!
ilovemyhoens 2 years ago 6
I love this song!
melissadjahida 2 years ago
This could be a movie song
MonsieurDDD 2 years ago
i picture a movie scene in my head every time i hear this
BassmastaWillHAM 2 years ago
I'm viewer 37000 !!!!!
Great song and incredible band, went to see them live 3 times. Can't wait for the next album.
moiabxl 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
moiabxl 2 years ago
This chick is kool! Love this performance.
jdrcastillo 2 years ago
Best performance ever
MadmanKar 3 years ago 3
Yes, this is one of the better versions, pretty
ilovemyhoens 3 years ago 2
i sang this song to myself after i broke up with my gf a few weeks after in my parents car while i rode in the back seat...i felt the pathos. powerful song...an ending regardless the original intention of the song.
spruecutter 3 years ago
Great performance of a marvellous song in a legendary place of an amazing city -
I hate my hometown
OllyHutton 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
they think that because they do a 9 minute lasting song, it will be regarded as great
Bland
FanDeLionelMessi 3 years ago
orsome song
nedofbronx100 3 years ago
This song in this performace is my all time favourite song (its better here than on the record although its still beautiful on the album)i just love playing guitar along to it...simply beautiful the best band in the world.
MadmanKar 3 years ago 3
awsome!! I hope to see ypu in Istanbul..
kurtmus 3 years ago
A very, very beautiful performance. Long live the arcade fire. Please come to south florida.
asomaholiday 3 years ago
this is beautiful...
ravenbrite 3 years ago
this seriously made my hair stand
beautiful.
Arteist2020 3 years ago
I wish I was there..
Vandoooorrr 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Arcade Fire kind of sounds like a band from the early 80's.
homgprdgn 3 years ago
Increíble, excelente!!!!
Todo el disco FUNERAL es el emjor, el punto más alto de The Arcade Fire
alexmaskm 3 years ago 2
i love regine she is so amazing..the whole band are completely awesome..i didnt liek this song at first but its fucking incredible now
pestilentfrost 3 years ago
this is real music!
sano2000 3 years ago 5
Beautiful.
Poolio27 3 years ago 6
It brought me tears in the eyes, u could see through her eyes. And feel the sadness and Loneliness.
estardeepbrown 3 years ago 2
is that owen pallett on the violin?
dudeitzkendal 3 years ago
yes it is. he played with them pretty regularly for a couple of years I think.
Username880 3 years ago
Bless her heart! I can't think of an Arcade Fire song that doesn't give me goosebumps or make me wanna cry...
Cat -x-
LyricalLoki 3 years ago 16
this song is so beautiful. nothing can compare to the importance of this song.
no bjork here, just regine chassagne, pooring her heart out, singing this amazing ode to her lost mother.
very touching.
raveyraveyman 3 years ago 7
This is what seperates Arcade Fire from other bands today, at 5.54 it should have been the end to a great performance. Instead they continue to go the extra mile, they never sit on their laurels!
jerkop2 3 years ago 6
that's is not new other bands used to end the set with noise and crazy things like that, remember nirvana, the who or sonic youth, nonetheless it's such a great live band
noiseadicted 2 years ago
Wow. I just saw this for the first time & it almost leaves you gaspin for air in the end, doesn't it? How brilliant. Thanks for having this here.
Anarva 3 years ago 3
buf
this song is so amazing
chipinjuliette 3 years ago
i saw them live this past fall and this song brought me to tears... beautiful
megananne137 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
she sounds like bjork too me...
najiel03 4 years ago
Bjork sounds like an un-greased door hinge; Regine is a goddess.
161803 4 years ago 4
You have to be kidding me. Bjork is amazing. Watch her movie "dancer in the dark" then come talk to me
wordismdude 3 years ago 5
good actress; bad movie.
mentalstephanie 3 years ago
A BAD MOVIE?
It's so touching.
Josenovich 3 years ago
Ok, I love Björk, but Regine is AMAZING!!!
birtuzzz 2 years ago 2
What is going on at the end when the lights go off? What's with the parrots in the drums?
saratita93 4 years ago
she does fucking rule!
Josenovich 4 years ago 2
everything about this song is perfect, gives me chills every time i hear it
awyea 4 years ago 21
First time i watch this song live! :D
Arcade Fire rocks!
guilovsh 4 years ago
One of the most beautiful songs I've ever heard.
She fucking rules.
123456vaitomanocu 4 years ago 8
this is my favorite song! arcade fire is so cool...
solventlind 4 years ago
wtf noch 7 tage dann live das nwird so geil ich liebe euch alle!!!
siddle007 4 years ago
yessss lovely song. Thx Arcade, thanks
sebovox21 4 years ago
I love Régine Chassagne; she's perfect.
EgonSchiele2 4 years ago 2
Snirf.....
fuip99 4 years ago
quite amazing, favourited it. This is probably my favourite song by this band, and they're probably one of my favourite indie bands as well. Not much into their second effort though.
cursestar 4 years ago
The best musical video i've ever seen.
gracebundy 4 years ago 3
"alice died / in the night / i've been learning to drive / my whole life."
bitchsbrew 4 years ago 2
This is a great song. There was another version on here where they were performing on PBS and I can't find it anymore. :(
Lemurbutt 4 years ago
jesus fuck. this song is so.. real. amazing stuff
m3nd3s 4 years ago
i truly love this song
bolleholle 4 years ago
greatest youtube video ever.
naseoj 4 years ago
i smell an encore
porkfriedrice77 4 years ago
i'm pretty sure that was the encore.
naseoj 4 years ago
it's impossible not to cry when you know the story behind the song and what it means to her...
BlackIroni 4 years ago 2
who has a MP3 of this?????????????????????
ecstatic1 4 years ago
You can buy on ITMS
(I'm not a staff of Apple)
sarlmblue 4 years ago
No, I meant a mp3 of this performance. I already have the two albums... thanks anyways.
ecstatic1 4 years ago
you can record it if you have an 8th inch stereo cable and you run it from your headphone output into the mic input, but that tends to sound really bad
snookthehippie 4 years ago
this song makes me cry =o( but i love it. its hopeful.
unicoforever 4 years ago
this song is somewhere between bliss,perfection,deep sadness and this unnamed-like the soundtrack of all the human emotions-Life's pretty and though*
****love***music****peace**arcade fire****
nickscreamingsilence 4 years ago
Every time I hear this song I want to cry.
skychotic 4 years ago
every few days i find myself coming back to watch this clip. why is this band/this song so unbelievably amazing?
naseoj 4 years ago
me too!!! amazing
crisp3kr3am 4 years ago
i'm still trying to find out, myself
MUN7001 4 years ago
Win rocks....October 31st Nottingham Arena!...cant wait!...hehe!...see you there!
TFB01 4 years ago
everytime i hear it...i get goosebumps
it's an amazing song...
kreicy 4 years ago
this is probably the most powerful song i've ever heard...i heard this was about her mom
Aurora8669 4 years ago
Yeah, it's about her mother's death.
naseoj 4 years ago
OK 161803,
I can also speak English if you want. I'm quite sure you can't say it for your French knowledge.
So, first, I wanted to speak French, because, perhaps you don't know this fact, but Canadian from Quebec also speak French! Amazing!? Then, if you don't understand me, no problem, I was not talking to you.
ChristoBaldFromParis 4 years ago
At last, for the polical criticsm, unfortunately, look at our last elections... But perhaps, you do not know that French citizens have voting rights.
God bless America, and save the Queen.
ChristoBaldFromParis 4 years ago
Satire.
161803 4 years ago
i burst into tears when this song was performed at berkeley last weekend.
very very powerful.
gomodgo 4 years ago
What an amazing performance and audience!!
gragg 4 years ago
This is absolutely stunning. I hope I don't die before I get to see them perform.
satininacoffin10 4 years ago
awesome bass
obeythemustache 4 years ago
Bon, c'est simple, il y a 2 groupes qui sortent (véritablement du lot) en ce moment :
Jack the Ripper (si vous ne connaissez pas, c'est une erreur) et Arcade Fire.
Tous les 2 comme par hasard réalisent des prestations scéniques extraordinaires, incroyables.
Les uns sont français, les autres sont québecois... Un renouveau du rock? Je l'espère...
Régine tu es une diva.
Bonne continuation à Arcade Fire et à bientôt à Paris.
ChristoBaldFromParis 4 years ago
Ah, French! This is youTube, not vousTube.
161803 4 years ago
Oh right... just becuase you're in America right. Maybe Spanish would better suit you? Pathetic. Have you ever been to Canada? Meet the people there, give it a chance, and maybe for once Americans can be open-minded.
-An American.
Justlikespecialk01 4 years ago
My hobby: making satirical posts on the intertubes; hat tip, xkcd[dot]com.
Though the French are filthy socialists, for the most part.
161803 4 years ago
why don;'t you shut the hell up idiot, and this is from a Canadian english person
MUN7001 4 years ago
that was rude.
greenpolkadotz343 4 years ago
she's not originally from haiti. her parents are from haiti. she was born in canada.
placebo525 4 years ago
I love them, the video is amazing, but it's a lie to say that she's got a beautiful voice!
Come on, I think she has a good voice, but the great parts here are the violins, the bass..
and the chorus part it's so amazing!
giulia86lotr 4 years ago
guess where both on the same page about that
obeythemustache 4 years ago
this womans voice is amazing!
homerhitman 4 years ago
Best song, best band, best performance - probably the best thing I ever seen on Youtube. Absolutely outstanding.
CinnamonWeaver 4 years ago
so good
notcoolmy 4 years ago
me encanta!
pgaviria11 4 years ago
... unbelievable...
just love this song...
troyyorkeson 4 years ago
what a performance. beautiful voice beautiful woman
hassy82 4 years ago
just a wee honey
arcadewin 4 years ago
I am loving this band more and more each day.
rufie710 4 years ago
Superb
telecasterthommy 4 years ago
love the band love the song,
shlammer99 4 years ago
OMG!
161803 4 years ago
Incroyable
bananealareglisse 5 years ago
this is simply excellent. And they are from my hometown. Good luck on the new disc.
broom72 5 years ago
one of the most beautiful songs you'll
hear in the history of pop music. beatles, gershwin, cole porter, the band, joni mitchell, elliott smith, radiohead, arcade fire...
peacemonger1967 5 years ago
good job for a live performance! The song is beautiful and so is the hidden meaning behind the lyrics.
shizadi1989 5 years ago
Oh my gosh. UNBELIEVABLE.
naseoj 5 years ago
just amazing.
full of feelings...
great band, love them.
thehappyjack13 5 years ago
The line "My family tree's losing all its leaves" always brings tears to my eyes. Incredible band. Can't wait to see their return.
musicdweller 5 years ago
Holy crap. I think the singer died.
FunDunn 5 years ago
et en plus elle est française !! ;) She is french !!
breizhthony 5 years ago
canadienne, d'origine haitienne ou y ayant vecu, nan ?
troyyorkeson 4 years ago
Regine (the female singer) is originally from Haiti but they are all Canadian.
naseoj 4 years ago
beautiful song, amazing performance
taramousie 5 years ago
good performance. Definitely they are artist
maquinadehuesos 5 years ago
wow
thetofus 5 years ago
Son increibles!
GianninaMeza 5 years ago
This song is one of the only few that can truelly make me shed tears. o.o Any other song is cheesy lol. Excellent song.
Poolio27 5 years ago
Yeah, Regine really outdid herself with this song.
pytko3 5 years ago
lindo ! adorei !
minha musica preferida deles :D
PoshFishhh 5 years ago
Gosh I love this band!
kilon828 5 years ago
awesome song
jorge1234 5 years ago
Wow .. amazing live!.
leaflock 5 years ago
Just beautiful! So much emotion too. This is definitely Regine at her absolute best!
pytko3 5 years ago
Yes, my favorite! Thanks!
Kapila 5 years ago
Awesome Ending!
pixienymph 5 years ago
It so foreshadows an encore.
AWM05 5 years ago
How could anyone do an encore after that? Anything else would be such a letdown and take away from this.
ecstatic1 4 years ago 7
Two words: "wake up"
petah2001 4 years ago
As much as I love Wake Up, i have to agree with ecstatic1.
This version to close the show is absolutely phenomenal. Plus, over here on the Australian tour, the band have been opening with Wake Up ;)
kximike 4 years ago