Listen, it doesn't matter how uncomplicated the song is -- whether it be incredibly complex or 'just a few drumbeats' -- i'ts the feeling and environment it portrays. This song doesn't need any more. These songs are bloody fantastic just how they are..
This song reminds me of those repetetive "sound drug" tracks that are supposed to put you into a state of mind-wandering lucidity. Except this sounds much better and works a lot better.
@SuperiFox No, there's some stupid shit called "I-Dosing". Google it- it's basically for idiots who think that sounds can create the same effects as actual drugs and think it's worth it to pay outrageous amounts of money for a single "dose".
@dotZodiac Yeah it's pretty stupid, I've never paid a penny for the I-Dosing crap but I've listened to some of it before and it's basically just repetitive noise patterns that are supposed to alter your brainwaves or some shit. The Ghosts albums are all the I-Dosing I'll ever need.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I am actually a fan of Trent put he is a annoyingly insecure guy who lets his public persona (what he believes it to be influence his music- rahter than just let loose and do his thing, he will purrposely put out loud noise crap so he can still be considered underground - can't have to many people like my musc bs, then put out this minalmist crap to be "artistic" - he is capable of better, but doesn't do it cause he's a pussy. This is just a drum machine and a few chords- that I can do -DOUCHE
@realguy640 I agree. Your version of "Away in a manger" is so epic that Trent can't help but bow his minimalist pussy ass to your more superior and thought provoking art. No wonder why you are so godly and famous! I have every single last one of your albums. I am slightly obsessed, and it's unhealthy at this point. Will you have gay sex with me?
@egobrain25 wow. to get so personal and catty to a man who is simply giving his op. it's amazing you can write with a cock in your mouth at the same time.
@realguy640 I've had a lot of practice. I took a shot in the mouth and wrote that in two seconds. I can walk and chew bubble gum, too. Thanks for recognizing my talents. - Fan for life.
@realguy640 howbout we see you use your musician skills (if you have any) to make an even better album than this one in less than the 10 weeks that trent made these awesome 36 instrumentals. oh and trent was a drug addict and thats what drugs do to you, you should know only a seriously stoned guy could have the stupid thought to type down what you did. oh and 5yr olds shouldnt be taking drugs
haha this brings back memories of my best friend and I just chilling out and listening to this song while watching milkdrop on winamp. So hypnotizing :)
I know this is going to sound weird...but it reinds me of someone watching porn...like the first couple seconds its him just seeing a couple of pictures and then going back to his buisiness...then as the song continues...he frequents it more often...showing how it consumes your soul if you give in, lol.
@Icerokou Kinda reminds me of a visual I get of either Les Claypool or Meynard Keenan suddenly appearing over my shoulder when I'm looking up porn... It kills the mood pretty quick. It appeared to me in a nightmare once...
@7YearMask There's a simple beauty in all of the songs on ghosts. It's about what sort of mood the song puts you in or the images that it conjures up in your mind. This is an amazing song in disguise.
the begining of this makes me feel like im walking through a completly deserted city just as the sun is going down, where everything slows down and everything in the world just seems to be perfect for a breif second. i love it
@auzzification I get almost that same mental picture, except mine is in an old village in the wild west with tumbleweeds rolling around~~~and at 1:32 I usually see a beautiful woman standing somewhere, and then she disappears and keeps reappearing in other places everytime that guitar melody kicks in.
I've neverbeen high in my life but I imagine it'd be much like listening to this song at 3 in the morning. this is probably my favorite album this month.
I highly doubt that. ;x It's been over a year since I uploaded this and you're the first to mention that. Plus if I labeled them wrong I think ninoffical would have noted me when they made the copyright claims.
anddd Ghost 1 would be Ghost 0? Does not make any sense. >:l
Weird isn't it. A total mystery. It's certainly one of the best tracks on Ghosts in my opinion. I must have listened to it about 30,000 times. Wait a sec...
It's classic case of one's mouth making the REST of you trip upon yourself and rolling down a FLIGHT of concrete stairs: Or simply tasting one's [MY] own shoe soles ('cause I shoved me own foot way up inside my mouth)!
The day after I posted that comment I went to the official NIN site: I turned **BEET RED*** and my mouth went DRY! For all I know I DISSED Trent Reznor himself (u never know -- we all clearly realize how Utterly BRILLIANT he is! :(
you didn't like it before you knew it was his, so you're saying that you like the work that he does merely because it is his work - and not because of its inherent quality.
just sit back a feel the vibes...that all you have to do...every song will trigger different thoughts and moods. Its like experimenting on your own brain.
So many sad people out there, get a grip on it! Who are you to say what's good or not, where are your innovating music and albums!I like my music to be as diverse as the people i have known through my life, different and exciting.
listen to reznor's intro to the ghosts project. It's not supposed to be all about the standard NIN idea. It's not supposed to be about standard musical ideas at all.
Reznor doesn't do music for money if he was, he would be planning a big fucking tour with Manson and charging a lot of money for the tickets 'cause he knows we the fans would pay anything or almost anything for it. I don't know about that family thing but he's few of the artist out there that deserves every penny that he charges in his cd's, dvd's and concerts in general they're amazing just like Tool's!!
Ooh... $535 if she puts on a Sandal Sombrero. But unless you can tempt me further with your ludicrously witty taste in aunt's clothing, that's where I'm staying.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Is this for real? you guys are joking right? a retarded monkey with a sequencer could do this crap. these aren't even songs. I was wondering why I haven't heard anyone talking about a new NIN album, and that is apparently because there is none. this is just a joke on you retards. Trent trying to make some money.
hmm really? trying to make money? thats strange since it was release FREE on all the main torrent sites by Trent himself. Get your facts straight you douche bag.
hmmmm,so how did he make over a million dollars selling a bunch of crap? Its a scam. yeah its free but then he gets all these douche bags to buy a 300 dolar special edition. maybe you should check your facts. thats the genius part, he gave gave it away, but somehow makes millions on garbage. I'm not accusing him of being stupid, but i am accusing you of being retarded.
I agree with you man, if we wanted to buy garbage we would buy Justin Timberlake shit or any American Idol's "music" So to finish my comment Marilyn Manson and NIN work is some of the work that I buy without even listening anything before hand because you know these guys make great music.
Marilyn Manson is absolute crap. Trent Reznor is a skilled musician and has produced some awesome music, which thankfully most of Ghosts qualifies, but he's also created some absolute crap music, like Year Zero, and really most of Nine Inch Nails, excluding The Fragile and Ghosts.
WTF. You obviously have quite a narrow perspective on music. NIN were one the first bands to bring industrial music into mainstream consciousness where I am guessing is where you first heard of them.
"...excluding The Fragile and Ghosts."
DUH
What about Pretty Hate Machine, or perhaps The Downward Spiral, or hey what about Broken, they only got 2 Grammy Awards for it.
As for MM, they did the amazing early angst ridden albums, you cant really blame them for 'mellowing out' a bit.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
i agree with year zero. its definitely reznor's weakest album he ever produced. someone noted thereafter that reznor should start with drugs again for making good music...
i'm not so sure about manson anymore.. maybe when he cleans himself up.. but i buy trent's stuff to support him as much as anything else. i've loved all his albums and to fair- he has really taken an interest in meeting his fans half way on the internet download front. the man's a pioneer! I'm proud to buy his music.
*Reznor fan* Call it what you like, but that's the beauty of aesthetics; it's absolutely relative (ie. couldn't care less about what you think). For me at least... it's somewhere par to buying a shotgun from a pacifist, or a flower from a war criminal... Not the madening grind like The Downward Spiral, but easy to appreciate when you know it's origins
I was afraid Trent was going to abandon electronics more and more after having heard "With Teeth" Im so glad he didnt. There so few bands that really tread the same territory like Skinny Puppy or disquieter of subtracting all the rules from writing music.
notice how he says "FIRST four volumes of Ghosts"? there may be more coming. it seems like this is NIN playing math rock kind of stuff. i love it. very emotive without words.
i've been listening nin for a few years and at any release i always think "it just can't get any better", and trent always prove that i'm wrong, this is fuc*** awesome.
Agreed, mate. The creativity just never stops. This is the kind of thing that demonstrates the difference between music that will be heard for a few years, and music that can be pondered and appreciated fifty years after it's written.
I mean, look at The Downward Spiral. Twenty-some years after its release, Spiral is still one of the most downright dangerous-sounding albums yet to be made by anyone.
I think that the best part of the album is just the fact that it's a change of style. There is a different between artists who stay in their niche and always just keep releasing the same old albums and those who truly break out and take a risk.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
This is too much! Just a few moments ago I commented on another track from this whole "ghost" thing. My comment was pretty much the exact opposite of what the fuck this sound reminds me of. This reminds me of brushing my teeth, taking a shower, unfolding my socks, letting the dog out, eating and the grand finale of walking down the road for thirty minutes.
trent is the man he takes aim at the record industry like radio cuz the record companys try to steal from artist and make them work for chump change.. trent all the way
go to his official website and spend $10 you get all the songs in a download 320kps and you get the cd shipped to you In april. for a nice lossless rip to your computer ;)
good luck actually downloading it from the site though, ive spent $10 and god knows how much bandwidth trying to get it but the servers keep timing out... so now im listening to it all on youtube for the first time... musical experiment indeed!
It's an amazingly unique & interactive musical experiment. You're a bit hasty to blame the site, I downloaded it no prob on 1st try & on a semi-crap computer. Sounds likely the prob is on your end-try troubleshooting via the control panel; check server setting configurations, firewalls, connection speeds etc.Running a virus scan never hurts, esp if u notice your computer running slow with other applications. Maybe try a diff web browser- esp if u use Int Explorer-I recommend Opera or Firefox.
why dislikes :( great song
felixantoinetremblay 3 days ago
Oh, these comments...
Listen, it doesn't matter how uncomplicated the song is -- whether it be incredibly complex or 'just a few drumbeats' -- i'ts the feeling and environment it portrays. This song doesn't need any more. These songs are bloody fantastic just how they are..
AkanemaruNayuchi 3 weeks ago
Toward the end, it sounded like the ending riff to The Warning from Zero Sum.
Lovely stuff.
bluephreakr 3 weeks ago
This song reminds me of those repetetive "sound drug" tracks that are supposed to put you into a state of mind-wandering lucidity. Except this sounds much better and works a lot better.
Mafila 2 months ago
@Mafila You mean Ambient?
SuperiFox 4 weeks ago
@SuperiFox No, there's some stupid shit called "I-Dosing". Google it- it's basically for idiots who think that sounds can create the same effects as actual drugs and think it's worth it to pay outrageous amounts of money for a single "dose".
dotZodiac 3 weeks ago
@dotZodiac Yeah it's pretty stupid, I've never paid a penny for the I-Dosing crap but I've listened to some of it before and it's basically just repetitive noise patterns that are supposed to alter your brainwaves or some shit. The Ghosts albums are all the I-Dosing I'll ever need.
Mafila 1 week ago
Wow. it's hard to call it song...
jocika99 5 months ago
What a hot tune.
vetiarvind 5 months ago
I love this picture :)
dragonbreathwithfur 5 months ago
This could be a Donkey Kong Country level song..
hthemangs 6 months ago
@hthemangs lmao, so true... great tune nevertheless
Stanl3igh 4 months ago
lots of C's in this song.
ExpertiseGamer 7 months ago
@ExpertiseGamer lolz synesthesia
DemonofPlaid 4 months ago
IMO this sounds like something out of tron legacy
PaidInBoredom 7 months ago
I lik to think that the NIN ghost videos highlight just how many ignorant 'music fans' are on youtube these days.
QuantikMusic 9 months ago 3
sounds like your mom on a bicycle
78sincity 10 months ago
its what happens to the world when you tear out its soul---when all you allow for worship is the american idol...
lakekbschn 10 months ago
if you enjoy ghosts you should give my song a listen:
watch?v=FqphyhJuS8Y
hhlium 11 months ago
I wish they made a CD that had only the ghosts on it.
M3iscool 1 year ago
@M3iscool this a cd with only ghosts on it :P
JordMcDrummer 11 months ago
@JordMcDrummer Yeah I figured that out shortly after this video.
M3iscool 11 months ago
somewhat depressing, but in a kinda bright mood... like some of the WT era's song(only, ATLIT, TLBTB, etc)
freddy35kr 1 year ago
You'd have to walk through the city or maybe Tokyo while listening to this song to truly appreciate it.
JordMcDrummer 1 year ago
Huge kudos for uploading this whole album. It has kept me awake and happy through more school projects than I would like to admit.
popchris3 1 year ago
Thank you very much for taking the time to upload these albums.
superlost90 1 year ago
quake 3 contains this music.. no?
toymachine150 1 year ago
I AM THINKING OF CLOWNS.
...I'm not gonna be sleeping tonight.
TheAtticusFlame 1 year ago
For some reason this sounds like Now I'm Nothing
maybe the more happier side?
God I just love this song,hell I love all of Trent's songs equally.
What a mastermind that has taken the music industry to a whole new side of sound.
Withbleedthrewteeth 1 year ago
@Withbleedthrewteeth you are such a fag - he's the last good thing he made was fragile -
realguy640 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I am actually a fan of Trent put he is a annoyingly insecure guy who lets his public persona (what he believes it to be influence his music- rahter than just let loose and do his thing, he will purrposely put out loud noise crap so he can still be considered underground - can't have to many people like my musc bs, then put out this minalmist crap to be "artistic" - he is capable of better, but doesn't do it cause he's a pussy. This is just a drum machine and a few chords- that I can do -DOUCHE
realguy640 1 year ago
@realguy640 I agree. Your version of "Away in a manger" is so epic that Trent can't help but bow his minimalist pussy ass to your more superior and thought provoking art. No wonder why you are so godly and famous! I have every single last one of your albums. I am slightly obsessed, and it's unhealthy at this point. Will you have gay sex with me?
egobrain25 1 year ago 2
@egobrain25 wow. to get so personal and catty to a man who is simply giving his op. it's amazing you can write with a cock in your mouth at the same time.
realguy640 1 year ago
@realguy640 I've had a lot of practice. I took a shot in the mouth and wrote that in two seconds. I can walk and chew bubble gum, too. Thanks for recognizing my talents. - Fan for life.
egobrain25 1 year ago
@egobrain25 Trents just not trying anymore huh? i meen using fl studio now sheesh.
Any of you could make this with a midi synth controler and fl studio oh and 30 secs lol gay. RIP OFF!!
Just using his name to sell crap now. Miss his older style.
spacintrvl2 1 year ago
@realguy640 howbout we see you use your musician skills (if you have any) to make an even better album than this one in less than the 10 weeks that trent made these awesome 36 instrumentals. oh and trent was a drug addict and thats what drugs do to you, you should know only a seriously stoned guy could have the stupid thought to type down what you did. oh and 5yr olds shouldnt be taking drugs
RetardedAndRandomTV 1 year ago
@RetardedAndRandomTV i like this song but that was a fairly lame insult/comment
armywifeponder 1 year ago
@armywifeponder it was probably the 5yr old part
RetardedAndRandomTV 1 year ago
This is awesome
rooster14crosss 1 year ago
its a beautiful thing, all the ghost songs give people very vivid pictures of what it is and no ones is the same, for me its a old western ghost town
Boowey116 1 year ago
haha this brings back memories of my best friend and I just chilling out and listening to this song while watching milkdrop on winamp. So hypnotizing :)
xaperfecttoolx 1 year ago
I know this is going to sound weird...but it reinds me of someone watching porn...like the first couple seconds its him just seeing a couple of pictures and then going back to his buisiness...then as the song continues...he frequents it more often...showing how it consumes your soul if you give in, lol.
Icerokou 2 years ago 6
you put to much thought into masturbating.
somehowsane 1 year ago 27
@Icerokou Kinda reminds me of a visual I get of either Les Claypool or Meynard Keenan suddenly appearing over my shoulder when I'm looking up porn... It kills the mood pretty quick. It appeared to me in a nightmare once...
ZhasX3 1 year ago 3
@ZhasX3 hahaha wait i could wank to Les..
DamionBaal13 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is a joke. This is what Trent has come to "artistically."
7YearMask 2 years ago
@7YearMask There's a simple beauty in all of the songs on ghosts. It's about what sort of mood the song puts you in or the images that it conjures up in your mind. This is an amazing song in disguise.
RedXmasLights 2 years ago 3
@7YearMask Trent has made many great songs with meaning, I doubt you have any as great as his
Carlit0Tit0 2 years ago
I need to check the multitracks, I can hear Trent singing distorted and extremely low
flannelking 2 years ago
@flannelking These are all instrumental songs. Unless theres singing in there as a hidden easter egg type thing? O_o
Carlit0Tit0 2 years ago
yeah it's more just like a vocal texture, no real words just vocalizing
flannelking 2 years ago
@flannelking I hear's it. It's definately there. I thought everybody could hear it! I mean, it's not even really subtle
ZhasX3 1 year ago
@ZhasX3 Yo man those are sampled vocals, though what it's saying I don't know.
frankiszero 1 year ago
the begining of this makes me feel like im walking through a completly deserted city just as the sun is going down, where everything slows down and everything in the world just seems to be perfect for a breif second. i love it
auzzification 2 years ago 4
@auzzification I get almost that same mental picture, except mine is in an old village in the wild west with tumbleweeds rolling around~~~and at 1:32 I usually see a beautiful woman standing somewhere, and then she disappears and keeps reappearing in other places everytime that guitar melody kicks in.
RedXmasLights 2 years ago 2
@auzzification i jus see a hill in the desert whith billions of soldiers in lines walking just starring ahead, not blinking.....
clonemaster1 1 year ago
hypnotic.
OldWiseMountainMan 2 years ago
this one is my favorite
iHooDoo 2 years ago
When I hear this it feels like I can float softly through the air.
churchy99 2 years ago 2
your passion is fruit?
TheCornholio713 2 years ago 16
No. Fruit my passion. ;o
mypassionfruit 2 years ago 24
@mypassionfruit maracuja?
Oloimpresive 5 months ago
@mypassionfruit No. MYPassionFruit
StickyInADarkBlueCut 1 month ago
your passion fruit is ... ?
senortank 2 years ago
@TheCornholio713 nahh he's sayingthat the passion fruit is his. :D
ZavanMerchant 4 months ago in playlist More videos from mypassionfruit
i cant believe they actually made all these songs lol
Rave4Techno 2 years ago 2
I've neverbeen high in my life but I imagine it'd be much like listening to this song at 3 in the morning. this is probably my favorite album this month.
morgoth2000 2 years ago 7
I may be high right now, haha. This song doesn't feel like being in this state but I like it.
guitarobsessed85 2 years ago
On my album, this song is number 16, of disc one.
r1krulz 2 years ago
this is 18, i've got the album.
deanjones19 2 years ago
this is 17 actually, not trying to be rude
Ornerysob 2 years ago
sooo the video I have named 17, is wrong too? :z
mypassionfruit 2 years ago
yeah kinda, they have to be renamed only by 1 number likje ghost 35 is 34 actualy
Ornerysob 2 years ago
I highly doubt that. ;x It's been over a year since I uploaded this and you're the first to mention that. Plus if I labeled them wrong I think ninoffical would have noted me when they made the copyright claims.
anddd Ghost 1 would be Ghost 0? Does not make any sense. >:l
mypassionfruit 2 years ago
I think Ornerysob is judging based on the Amazon ads at the bottom of the vid...
I think the advertisement screwed up at 15 Ghosts II, because after that one they're all a number behind.
Plus, you can tell that they're the right track based on their track length.
2nerkid 2 years ago
this is 18 actually, not trying to be rude
I used Shazam, (a music id app) It says its 18, dont trust the amazon ad -_-
sk8dudejames 2 years ago
All is well then. :D
mypassionfruit 2 years ago
18 is played live.
woodcutter048 2 years ago
i suppose all 36 tracks do stand alone well,
but to follow "implied" instructions from the
album's title,i listen to the album in sections (Ghosts I,9 tracks)
philippeEmmanu 3 years ago
His electronic stuff is so much more profound than that bland pop rock bullshit.
novoneiro 3 years ago 7
what, the fragile?
obscureface 2 years ago
Just about everything after downword spiral. Pay attention to the lyrics. Hes admits hes done.
novoneiro 2 years ago
eh....i don't really care!
i like all his music!
obscureface 2 years ago
mmm? wats going on in trents head? brill work
JIMBR2k7 3 years ago 3
This one makes me feel better
avelione 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i love boobies
TeChNoRaBbI 3 years ago
Why does 18 have almost 40000 views when all the others have 10000ish? Lol.
enternius 3 years ago
Weird isn't it. A total mystery. It's certainly one of the best tracks on Ghosts in my opinion. I must have listened to it about 30,000 times. Wait a sec...
Aueneye 3 years ago 50
32 is the best and then 24 in my opinion, but they are all good enough
ninsotq 3 years ago 2
4s my fave, but they all are really kool to me
bandbass 3 years ago 2
They play 18 live.
sethdesade 2 years ago
@Aueneye
i dont get it
faaip0de0oaid 6 months ago
18 is a number people search more for???
Valholm 3 years ago 2
Because they play 18 live.
sethdesade 2 years ago
very krafwerkish
hikupoopoo 3 years ago 4
I prefer his instrumentals like 'gone still' much more compared to this, but its good... Different! Yey trent!
xshineythingsx 3 years ago 3
sound sex
Udedenkz 3 years ago 8
nice
velvetrevel 3 years ago
I like this one now too
lionel1100 3 years ago
it sounds like a ghost and its jangly
lionel1100 3 years ago 6
a Wonderful track.....
a LOUSY video --- more to still photography than actual filmmaking/videography...
This MUSIC is RESPLENDENT and FATHOMLESS in its SCOPE and DEPTH...
Come on ppl!!
Turn ON your brains and Reallly produce **ADEQUATE** ENGAGING visuals!!
DrTh0masW0nder 3 years ago
fool
wzampatti 3 years ago 2
^_^ ..... Yes...
I was... [still am]: a FOOL.
It's classic case of one's mouth making the REST of you trip upon yourself and rolling down a FLIGHT of concrete stairs: Or simply tasting one's [MY] own shoe soles ('cause I shoved me own foot way up inside my mouth)!
The day after I posted that comment I went to the official NIN site: I turned **BEET RED*** and my mouth went DRY! For all I know I DISSED Trent Reznor himself (u never know -- we all clearly realize how Utterly BRILLIANT he is! :(
DrTh0masW0nder 3 years ago
you didn't like it before you knew it was his, so you're saying that you like the work that he does merely because it is his work - and not because of its inherent quality.
that's a bit concerning.
thekillerbunny 3 years ago
best instrumental album of the year so far!!Its like being difted off to your own personal skycastle.
Big up yourself Trent. Lovin your work.
Anyone who thinks that this piece of art isn't music desperately need to get smacked....with the chopaxe. d:-)
xzamina2087 3 years ago 2
just sit back a feel the vibes...that all you have to do...every song will trigger different thoughts and moods. Its like experimenting on your own brain.
XXX
PIG
pigtelevision 3 years ago 2
i like number 29..
lionel1100 3 years ago
What is it that you like about 29,any thing particular.
01Kore 3 years ago
So many sad people out there, get a grip on it! Who are you to say what's good or not, where are your innovating music and albums!I like my music to be as diverse as the people i have known through my life, different and exciting.
autoduck2 3 years ago
no no no no no no NO NO NO NO NO!!!
this isnt music.
this is a progression of unsupervised, random, repeated, increasing beats, without lyrics to company them
what happened to NIN?
spasticemo93 3 years ago
listen to reznor's intro to the ghosts project. It's not supposed to be all about the standard NIN idea. It's not supposed to be about standard musical ideas at all.
nbradley318 3 years ago
so if you don't like it, it's not music? take a deep breath and try to engage your brain and think about it for a second.
susannalopez3 3 years ago
oh... lol you have a point...
sry for dissin NIN... its just not the kind of music i expected from them...
spasticemo93 3 years ago
i understand, i get a shock also when i hear a new album from someone and it's different than their other stuff :)
susannalopez3 3 years ago
This is regression into minimalism and something that should simply be called "noises" who happen to fall within a fairly structured beat.
ApalmerHels 3 years ago
noises aren't people.
MrAngy 3 years ago
Progression? No, that implies it gets better. Year Zero was, amazingly enough, even more of a terd than With Teeth was.
einsatzdeath 3 years ago
I think they were on the same level. I don't think anything is going to be as good as Fragile.
Malumbrus 3 years ago
this band is making HISTORY
TrentsRuiner 3 years ago 4
I love this track.. Super & Enigmatic...
fredmentor 3 years ago 2
i dont care what you all think, i'm going to that concert
Loserkidlots1 3 years ago 3
what the fuck a true fan of music an nin in general would love the path that hes taken with sound
killswitch131313 3 years ago
guys buyin Ghosts ii-iv is pointless(unless you like instrumental techno) they have ghosts i free at the website
sk8ordie9699 3 years ago
NIN tickets in seattle are at least two hundred bucks a piece. no wonder chosts was so inexpensive, he gets enough money from ticket sales.
psycopoe 3 years ago
Reznor doesn't do music for money if he was, he would be planning a big fucking tour with Manson and charging a lot of money for the tickets 'cause he knows we the fans would pay anything or almost anything for it. I don't know about that family thing but he's few of the artist out there that deserves every penny that he charges in his cd's, dvd's and concerts in general they're amazing just like Tool's!!
jo5erock 3 years ago 4
His name is Mr. Tiddles. He's 27 years old, so a bit of mileage on the old clock, and but otherwise a real find.
Aueneye 3 years ago
Do you reckon. I have a spare aunt if he's interested. Let's start the bidding at $200. Do i hear 200?
Aueneye 3 years ago 4
does she come with a cat?
wired23 3 years ago 4
heh heh...well , what's she look like ??
dancinginfidel 3 years ago
$450 if she puts a shoe on her head.
briani4735263 3 years ago
Funnily enough she has a hat made of shoes. It's a Flip-Flop Fedora.
Aueneye 3 years ago
Ooh... $535 if she puts on a Sandal Sombrero. But unless you can tempt me further with your ludicrously witty taste in aunt's clothing, that's where I'm staying.
briani4735263 3 years ago
Dio che Genio!
By
Zeus
valeryo4ever 3 years ago
music and visuals remind me a bit of aphex twin, especially of "druqks"... think that's great :)
DarthLuda 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Is this for real? you guys are joking right? a retarded monkey with a sequencer could do this crap. these aren't even songs. I was wondering why I haven't heard anyone talking about a new NIN album, and that is apparently because there is none. this is just a joke on you retards. Trent trying to make some money.
6m6i6c 3 years ago
hmm really? trying to make money? thats strange since it was release FREE on all the main torrent sites by Trent himself. Get your facts straight you douche bag.
hughes0687 3 years ago 5
hmmmm,so how did he make over a million dollars selling a bunch of crap? Its a scam. yeah its free but then he gets all these douche bags to buy a 300 dolar special edition. maybe you should check your facts. thats the genius part, he gave gave it away, but somehow makes millions on garbage. I'm not accusing him of being stupid, but i am accusing you of being retarded.
6m6i6c 3 years ago
people choose to buy stuff, they aren't forced to. those who would buy an expensive deluxe edition obviously deem it worthy of the money.
chonkindonker 3 years ago
I agree with you man, if we wanted to buy garbage we would buy Justin Timberlake shit or any American Idol's "music" So to finish my comment Marilyn Manson and NIN work is some of the work that I buy without even listening anything before hand because you know these guys make great music.
jo5erock 3 years ago
Marilyn Manson is absolute crap. Trent Reznor is a skilled musician and has produced some awesome music, which thankfully most of Ghosts qualifies, but he's also created some absolute crap music, like Year Zero, and really most of Nine Inch Nails, excluding The Fragile and Ghosts.
freeeekyyy 3 years ago
WTF. You obviously have quite a narrow perspective on music. NIN were one the first bands to bring industrial music into mainstream consciousness where I am guessing is where you first heard of them.
"...excluding The Fragile and Ghosts."
DUH
What about Pretty Hate Machine, or perhaps The Downward Spiral, or hey what about Broken, they only got 2 Grammy Awards for it.
As for MM, they did the amazing early angst ridden albums, you cant really blame them for 'mellowing out' a bit.
daemonicflame 3 years ago
freeky, keep your shitty comments to yourself.
dtc5793 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i agree with year zero. its definitely reznor's weakest album he ever produced. someone noted thereafter that reznor should start with drugs again for making good music...
keeroy 3 years ago
nice opinion. drugs work.
sascha1Musik 3 years ago
Year Zero was fucking awesome and most def. a progression in his music.
17aKaT 3 years ago
"a witha teetha" is worse.
jcrist 3 years ago
i'm not so sure about manson anymore.. maybe when he cleans himself up.. but i buy trent's stuff to support him as much as anything else. i've loved all his albums and to fair- he has really taken an interest in meeting his fans half way on the internet download front. the man's a pioneer! I'm proud to buy his music.
sparkydeltorro 3 years ago
*Reznor fan* Call it what you like, but that's the beauty of aesthetics; it's absolutely relative (ie. couldn't care less about what you think). For me at least... it's somewhere par to buying a shotgun from a pacifist, or a flower from a war criminal... Not the madening grind like The Downward Spiral, but easy to appreciate when you know it's origins
bitterchoir 3 years ago
if he was just trying to make some money then why would he make a 2 disc album of all untitled instrumentals?
DCP80 3 years ago
electronic or not electronic, trent still kicks ass..
i like this new "album" the same way i like with teeth..
the man only does masterpieces
jimroot85 3 years ago
I was afraid Trent was going to abandon electronics more and more after having heard "With Teeth" Im so glad he didnt. There so few bands that really tread the same territory like Skinny Puppy or disquieter of subtracting all the rules from writing music.
balfordazzling 3 years ago
What sets NIN apart from other bands is the concept behind the music and its originality.
thrillseeker9909 3 years ago 2
notice how he says "FIRST four volumes of Ghosts"? there may be more coming. it seems like this is NIN playing math rock kind of stuff. i love it. very emotive without words.
blackfireINSANITY 3 years ago 6
Trent Reznor makes awesome sounds, especially on the album With Teeth, the song 'Only' is stuck in my fucking head, it's so awesome.
skinnyhatred 3 years ago 2
i've been listening nin for a few years and at any release i always think "it just can't get any better", and trent always prove that i'm wrong, this is fuc*** awesome.
viegasj 3 years ago 6
Agreed, mate. The creativity just never stops. This is the kind of thing that demonstrates the difference between music that will be heard for a few years, and music that can be pondered and appreciated fifty years after it's written.
I mean, look at The Downward Spiral. Twenty-some years after its release, Spiral is still one of the most downright dangerous-sounding albums yet to be made by anyone.
standingman33 3 years ago 8
I think that the best part of the album is just the fact that it's a change of style. There is a different between artists who stay in their niche and always just keep releasing the same old albums and those who truly break out and take a risk.
This album was a risk, but it really paid off.
HVF12 3 years ago 3
Actually "The Downward Spiral" was released in 1994. That would make it 14 years, not twenty-some. ;)
Trent's first album, "Pretty Hate Machine", was released in 1989.
ncrogdn 3 years ago
D'oh. I stand corrected. Keep getting my release dates mixed up. :O) Thanks.
standingman33 3 years ago
sounds really good. i like this track
joe13869 3 years ago
This really is in the same league as classical music, that Reznor, he's only a bloody Mozart.
Aueneye 3 years ago 3
nin never disappoint reminds me of skinny puppy quite a bit too love it (as well as most of the ghosts album i've heard)
mtemple 3 years ago
Am I just baked...or is there absolutely no video?
d8ahazard 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Really Bad!
WorstCase09 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
that was boring show some creativity. iono if it was too abstract for me or what but i didnt get much out of it sorry .
UnholySatyr 3 years ago
pretty good ^^
NINfuckingrules 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is too much! Just a few moments ago I commented on another track from this whole "ghost" thing. My comment was pretty much the exact opposite of what the fuck this sound reminds me of. This reminds me of brushing my teeth, taking a shower, unfolding my socks, letting the dog out, eating and the grand finale of walking down the road for thirty minutes.
OnDutyNinja 3 years ago
I think this is my favorite haha
codyscottmac 3 years ago 2
aaaaaaaawesome!!
nin56665 3 years ago 4
trent is the man he takes aim at the record industry like radio cuz the record companys try to steal from artist and make them work for chump change.. trent all the way
edgarneil 3 years ago
nice
DruidLineage 3 years ago
can someone tell me if there will be an "official release" like radiohead did? i would pay 1000 bucks for this.
PicturesForMyMom 3 years ago 3
you can get it of their official websight
Mbyford361 3 years ago
There will be. Album ships to stores April 8th.
Yaywalter 3 years ago
Sweet! :-) Just in time for the first anniversary of YZ yaaaaaaaaaay bye.
PicturesForMyMom 3 years ago
go to his official website and spend $10 you get all the songs in a download 320kps and you get the cd shipped to you In april. for a nice lossless rip to your computer ;)
xjager513 3 years ago 2
good luck actually downloading it from the site though, ive spent $10 and god knows how much bandwidth trying to get it but the servers keep timing out... so now im listening to it all on youtube for the first time... musical experiment indeed!
iamworkerdrone 3 years ago
It's an amazingly unique & interactive musical experiment. You're a bit hasty to blame the site, I downloaded it no prob on 1st try & on a semi-crap computer. Sounds likely the prob is on your end-try troubleshooting via the control panel; check server setting configurations, firewalls, connection speeds etc.Running a virus scan never hurts, esp if u notice your computer running slow with other applications. Maybe try a diff web browser- esp if u use Int Explorer-I recommend Opera or Firefox.
51Orion 3 years ago