THIS IS INDEED A RARE, UNLOOKED FOR REUNION. I MISS THE SCHULMAN'S, BUT AT LEAST THEY AREN'T CALLING IT GENTLE GIANT. SOME NEW MATERIAL WOULD HAVE BEEN WELCOME BUT THIS WILL SURELY SUFFICE. THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR SHARING. I SAW THEM OPEN UP FOR TULL'S "BRICK" TOUR IN MISSISSIPPI OF ALL PLACES.
Gentle Giant, one of the greatest band ever. Although this band sounds pretty good, it is a pity that Kerry Minnear is no longer with the group. That was a fast movement, it sucks.
When are you guys coming to Seattle? If you need a place to stay you can stay at my house! Rent free, just some guitar lessons from Gary.Who I think is one of the most under rated guitar players in the rock world! Larry
Wow, Malcolm, you brought a tear to my eye around 6:43, when you paid tribute to John Weathers. I know you were the drummer for GG,until you broke your leg in a motorcycle accident? That's when they got John to take your place. You are a "CLASS ACT"! Hope you guys get into Minnesota in 2010. With Kerry!? Garry, you should wear that green and white striped shirt, and maybe pants.
I love these guys but it's a scary proposition for me to see them without the perfect GG voice of Derek and the most coolest most-animated & funkiest prog-bassist ever Ray. It's like going to see YES without Jon Anderson. Hard pill to swallow but still a fan for ever. May have to let my 70's live GG memories sustain me, then again the music is still HOTTTT!
I saw the original GG in Seattle years ago(decades?), they played with ELO and Kansas, I had never heard of them, but was evangelized by them, and still am to this day.
Loving everything but the singer. He can't even remotely hit the high stuff. He's running out of tone as he crosses the A below high C. He's cheating into the bottom of the B natural in the Acap. Copping Derek requires tone and power to HIGH D. You can't cheat, ya can't escape. Believe me I know. I was singing this very song in front of paying audiences all through the late 70's. Crazy huh? Still loving this post. Thanx to those who provided it.
re Dereks health, he did a fairly extensive interview with Eddie Trunk on VH1 a few years back and looked and sounded great. This interview can be seen as a special feature on one of GG's dvd's.
I saw the show yesterday in Montreal. This was simply amazing. You could feel the pleasure in the crowd and you could see the pleasure of the band also. After each songs the crowd got up and applauded for minutes. I think there is a special bound between Montreal and GG and it showed yesterday. Incredible show.
Pantagruel's nativity, Just the same, free hand, schooldays, mister class and quality, three friends, think of me with kindness, in a glass house, playing the game, cogs in cogs...and others. I hope i'm not mistaking on any of those but I think not. It was really incredible.
My first show ever was Gentle Giant opening for Yes July 23rd 1976..... and still the best show I've ever seen 33 yrs later !! Great stuff.... when's the official N American tour guys ???
yeah.. Malcolm is very good!!!!!!!! I still miss John P. Weathers a bit.. he played the drums the way i had never heard before and i have never heard afterwards....
No. This is a cover of the song, Free Hand off Gentle Giant's 1975 album. My question was does the band also do any of their own material? Covers don't count.
I'm sorry. I did not realize that Minnear, Mortimore & Green were playing. What happned to Rental Riant that Weathers and Green were doing?
It woulde bei interesting to see what new original material Three Friends would come up wth. Yiy have elements of Octopus then. Is that Dio from Dio? (Rainbow)
Einfach genial! Wer hätte das zu träumen gewagt? 1975 in unserer WG habe ich diesen Song zu ersten Mal gehört. Seitdem ist GG ein fester Teil meines Lebens - bis heute!! Ich habe GG 1975 und 1976 live in Düsseldorf gesehen. Natürlich war das einmalig, aber ich finde auch das was ich da höre toll. Und der Spaß, den die Jungs haben... Ich bin am 26. September in Würzburg und höre mir 3 Friends live an. Ich kann mein Glück nicht beschreiben...
I'm impressed with the precision and musicianship. Check out our version. There's no video, and its a crappy recording, but we are a bunch of kids...we did not include the big instrumental part like you did. We should have but oh well. This is pretty good.
i came across this the other day and thought this is as close as you will ever get to gg then i realised who it was these boyswere and stillare the best prog rock band ever to walk this earth of course thats my oppinion
The first one would have to be Martin Smith, right? He recorded some of the greatest GG songs with the boys but unfortunately he passed away during the 90's.
I totally agree. The boys really seem to be having a lot of fun along with Mortimore. I hope they write new songs as Malcolm has stated. That would be...
has Taken Care of Himself (and his Voice) There's No Reason to Believe That He Can't Do It... Look at Jon Anderson from YES he is an "Alto Tenor" and He Still has that High Voice, So it Depends on If You're Lucky, and If you Take Care of Your Self, So with Derek: Who Knows??... Maby Someday We'll See... I Hope :-)
Anyway, in the FMPM, Three Friends as a specially important reunion/new band are gonna be given more time to perform than other bands. And I think they're gonna be on the second night (and last) so no doubt it'll be great! And I bet by September they'll be even better and show a different track list.
They're coming in my corner of the worls in October. I'LL SO BE THERE!!!
plumage12 2 days ago
Exelente !!!
DonVitoco72 1 week ago
God gave us the Gentle Giant in the 70's. God could give us them back nowadays. Just keep the faith.
klinkerkk 3 months ago
I just discovered this! Thanks so much you guys! Thank you so much! I hope to catch you on the road! TRY AND STOP ME!
GolasgilEldemar 9 months ago
John weathers plays fine, with feeling, mortimore too, u can se mister class by thrre friends,
ezcarmona 11 months ago
THIS IS INDEED A RARE, UNLOOKED FOR REUNION. I MISS THE SCHULMAN'S, BUT AT LEAST THEY AREN'T CALLING IT GENTLE GIANT. SOME NEW MATERIAL WOULD HAVE BEEN WELCOME BUT THIS WILL SURELY SUFFICE. THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR SHARING. I SAW THEM OPEN UP FOR TULL'S "BRICK" TOUR IN MISSISSIPPI OF ALL PLACES.
dantalionable 11 months ago
Michael Mortimore ??????
I think I prefer Malcolm Mortimore
2318PAM 1 year ago
michaelmortimore plays better than john weathers altough john plasy so good
ezcarmona 1 year ago
@ezcarmona weathers has better feel in my opinion although mortimore is more skilled technically.
underagedpickle 11 months ago
How could I have not known about this? I could have seen these guys play! Well I hope to God they come around again soon.
kingcherub 1 year ago
very good cover.
goruby2 1 year ago
@goruby2 rather a self-cover. Kerry and Gary are playin' on stage.
klinkerkk 3 months ago
WOW... Great Vibe of the Old GG..!!
Please, play in South Florida...!
mrprogjazzgto 1 year ago
it's cool because some gg player are in , but the necessary isn't there
morrron5 1 year ago 2
@OldSchoolSkill ive heard the Schulmans and John Weathers want them to stop...i dont see why....promotes GG
PeeceSells 1 year ago
John digs them I think and is ok with it...
fyrwyrstrings 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
John digs them I think and is ok with it...from what I can gather..
fyrwyrstrings 1 year ago
Bravissimi....!!!!!!!!!!!
themurderock 1 year ago
Ya! Finally, my favorite band rocks the world again in the 21st century. Sounds great guys.
claytunes 1 year ago
These guys are great, but you can definitely hear how modern digital technology sucks the life out of the tone.
TerrellaMedia 1 year ago
Wow-do they sound great! Going to be a gig at BB KIng's in NYC in June, 2010...used to see GG in Montreal in early 70's.
maida1982a 1 year ago
Just love Gary Green's playing!! He still has it!
thehellhecould 1 year ago
Gentle Giant, one of the greatest band ever. Although this band sounds pretty good, it is a pity that Kerry Minnear is no longer with the group. That was a fast movement, it sucks.
tboneplayer8 2 years ago
When are you guys coming to Seattle? If you need a place to stay you can stay at my house! Rent free, just some guitar lessons from Gary.Who I think is one of the most under rated guitar players in the rock world! Larry
lferlan 2 years ago
Wow, Malcolm, you brought a tear to my eye around 6:43, when you paid tribute to John Weathers. I know you were the drummer for GG,until you broke your leg in a motorcycle accident? That's when they got John to take your place. You are a "CLASS ACT"! Hope you guys get into Minnesota in 2010. With Kerry!? Garry, you should wear that green and white striped shirt, and maybe pants.
waynedanberry 2 years ago
please! please!please!!!....
we demand a tour!!
love Gentle Giant!!!
Machadomm 2 years ago
I love these guys but it's a scary proposition for me to see them without the perfect GG voice of Derek and the most coolest most-animated & funkiest prog-bassist ever Ray. It's like going to see YES without Jon Anderson. Hard pill to swallow but still a fan for ever. May have to let my 70's live GG memories sustain me, then again the music is still HOTTTT!
wigginsdesign 2 years ago
F9(*&^&(ck yeah!
FoxtronInk 2 years ago
GG was the best progressive rock band all over the world !! They were incomparable and inimitable !
Francomassimo 2 years ago
I saw the original GG in Seattle years ago(decades?), they played with ELO and Kansas, I had never heard of them, but was evangelized by them, and still am to this day.
Brad
apisdude 2 years ago
Can you beleive there are so many of us that still dig GG? It's time to write that biopic movie I have been working on.
Thanks for this.
jamescdo 2 years ago
Great stuff. If I get achance to see them, I will. Hear rumours of a possible album being worked on.
buchla300 2 years ago
Gentle giant music is THE STANDARD of prog rock. Every musician, who wants to play prog rock is confronted with this hard matter of fact.
progmeck1 2 years ago
Any chance of a US tour? Just Florida then..
PLEASE!?!
Beadbud5000 2 years ago
NEARfest 2010 then they kick off their US tour. wooo!
evilchris3 2 years ago
LUCKY YOU!@
Beadbud5000 2 years ago
@evilchris3
Where can we get US Tour info (dates) from?
krsongs 2 years ago
Loving everything but the singer. He can't even remotely hit the high stuff. He's running out of tone as he crosses the A below high C. He's cheating into the bottom of the B natural in the Acap. Copping Derek requires tone and power to HIGH D. You can't cheat, ya can't escape. Believe me I know. I was singing this very song in front of paying audiences all through the late 70's. Crazy huh? Still loving this post. Thanx to those who provided it.
TheRealSlipperman 2 years ago
They uploaded some exceprts of the gig in Germany!
Pectiniculus 2 years ago
re Dereks health, he did a fairly extensive interview with Eddie Trunk on VH1 a few years back and looked and sounded great. This interview can be seen as a special feature on one of GG's dvd's.
hope2prosper 2 years ago
how fucking wicked is this??????
progbc 2 years ago
tighter then the stone of gibrolter
joealanouf 2 years ago
GG fan...from the inception...this has caused quite a stir!!!...
jamesbach54 2 years ago
I saw the show yesterday in Montreal. This was simply amazing. You could feel the pleasure in the crowd and you could see the pleasure of the band also. After each songs the crowd got up and applauded for minutes. I think there is a special bound between Montreal and GG and it showed yesterday. Incredible show.
christeli 2 years ago
What songs did they play?
Pectiniculus 2 years ago
Pantagruel's nativity, Just the same, free hand, schooldays, mister class and quality, three friends, think of me with kindness, in a glass house, playing the game, cogs in cogs...and others. I hope i'm not mistaking on any of those but I think not. It was really incredible.
christeli 2 years ago
thank you christeli!!
it's incredible! so they added cogs and cogs, schooldays and more! wow!
hopefully, they'll start creating new songs for next year's nearfest!
Pectiniculus 2 years ago
I hope some lucky guy from Montreal will be so kind to share an excerpt...
Pectiniculus 2 years ago
Wow! Montreal you're in for a treat, these guys were great last night.
400216ADM 2 years ago
All tickets are sold. Sorry.
ibafyarmtl 2 years ago
I saw Kerry, Gary and Malcolm play GG in Quebec City in 2005. It was magnificent, this is other worldly.
merp0001 2 years ago
I'm seeing them on Sept 13 in Montreal! BTW, not a 100% sure but i may have a few tickets available...
ibafyarmtl 2 years ago
I am interested in tickets for Sept 13.
merp0001 2 years ago
How many and how much???
vectorfive 2 years ago
My first show ever was Gentle Giant opening for Yes July 23rd 1976..... and still the best show I've ever seen 33 yrs later !! Great stuff.... when's the official N American tour guys ???
grayngreen 2 years ago
yeah.. Malcolm is very good!!!!!!!! I still miss John P. Weathers a bit.. he played the drums the way i had never heard before and i have never heard afterwards....
delfia406 2 years ago
THe BOOGIE WOOGIE phrase is OFF THE HOOK. This is one of several funkiest tunes in all prog. Damn Gary still kicks ars
wigginsdesign 2 years ago
yes! Great Mortimer.
antonjjok 2 years ago
Nice solo section!
Beadbud5000 2 years ago
Excellent job on doing the GG cover. Does this band write any of their own stuff?
Beadbud5000 2 years ago
This is their own stuff.
PCFDD 2 years ago
No. This is a cover of the song, Free Hand off Gentle Giant's 1975 album. My question was does the band also do any of their own material? Covers don't count.
Beadbud5000 2 years ago
Ok, sorry I was counting it as an original as Minnear and Green are involved.
Love the Free Hand record, amazing skill, even for prog.
PCFDD 2 years ago
I'm sorry. I did not realize that Minnear, Mortimore & Green were playing. What happned to Rental Riant that Weathers and Green were doing?
It woulde bei interesting to see what new original material Three Friends would come up wth. Yiy have elements of Octopus then. Is that Dio from Dio? (Rainbow)
Beadbud5000 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Einfach genial! Wer hätte das zu träumen gewagt? 1975 in unserer WG habe ich diesen Song zu ersten Mal gehört. Seitdem ist GG ein fester Teil meines Lebens - bis heute!! Ich habe GG 1975 und 1976 live in Düsseldorf gesehen. Natürlich war das einmalig, aber ich finde auch das was ich da höre toll. Und der Spaß, den die Jungs haben... Ich bin am 26. September in Würzburg und höre mir 3 Friends live an. Ich kann mein Glück nicht beschreiben...
wagemorgen 2 years ago
Comment removed
wagemorgen 2 years ago
Love this! Please come to L.A., and thanks for making the efort to do this for all the GG fans out there.
jonsilence 2 years ago
I'm impressed with the precision and musicianship. Check out our version. There's no video, and its a crappy recording, but we are a bunch of kids...we did not include the big instrumental part like you did. We should have but oh well. This is pretty good.
EyMeng 2 years ago
the guy has a good voice but wrong expression.
and john weathers is NEEDED
MrBubzzi 2 years ago
I think Mortimore was actually the best player in those gigs.
Pectiniculus 2 years ago 9
After performing at the PMFM, Three Friends are going to Japan and Germany!!
Pectiniculus 2 years ago
absaloutley perfect well done boys lets see some more performances i n uk from the best prog rock band ever.
DeadDogHowlin 2 years ago
best prog rock band? haha you mean the best band... period...
jake15700 2 years ago
i came across this the other day and thought this is as close as you will ever get to gg then i realised who it was these boyswere and stillare the best prog rock band ever to walk this earth of course thats my oppinion
DeadDogHowlin 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
muito bem !!!!!!
=)
!!!
julianqq 2 years ago
Malcolm Mortimore is the third luckiest drummer in rock history........John Weathers being the second........can you guess the first?
What must it mean to Gary Green and Kerry Minnear especially, to be playing this incredible music again......TOGETHER!
chungiemunchin 2 years ago
The first one would have to be Martin Smith, right? He recorded some of the greatest GG songs with the boys but unfortunately he passed away during the 90's.
I totally agree. The boys really seem to be having a lot of fun along with Mortimore. I hope they write new songs as Malcolm has stated. That would be...
Pectiniculus 2 years ago
Christ! but it's good good to hear Gary take a solo again.
Fernweeks 2 years ago
John Weathers was in the audience! I bet he liked what he heard.
EmersonsL100 2 years ago
increiiiblee!!!
tero1712 2 years ago
Comment removed
Pectiniculus 2 years ago
thanks for this; lovely to see them back together, saw them in Toronto and Guelph around 74/75 methinks. of course, they were awesome.
those were the days i tell ya!
wordofgord
thewordofgord 2 years ago 2
I just know that a show's gonna end up close to Derek and he'll end up onstage with them!!. That would be Awesome!!, and this band sounds Great!!
100PIES 2 years ago
I doubt Derek has trained his voice these years, though. Besides, this band doesn't
Pectiniculus 2 years ago
Yeah, he's probably rusty, but give him a few Drinks and who knows! jej
100PIES 2 years ago
I loved Derek, but age and the range of the needed voice may be too much of a stretch
Beadbud5000 2 years ago
I know, but If He hasn't Been Singing and If he
has Taken Care of Himself (and his Voice) There's No Reason to Believe That He Can't Do It... Look at Jon Anderson from YES he is an "Alto Tenor" and He Still has that High Voice, So it Depends on If You're Lucky, and If you Take Care of Your Self, So with Derek: Who Knows??... Maby Someday We'll See... I Hope :-)
100PIES 2 years ago
Comment removed
Pectiniculus 2 years ago
WHAT A PERFORMANCE !!! A GREAT NEWS TO MONTREAL THIS SEPTEMBER 11-12 !!!! (From an happy owner of tickets for FMPM)
joctre 2 years ago
Wasn't it on 12-13?
Anyway, in the FMPM, Three Friends as a specially important reunion/new band are gonna be given more time to perform than other bands. And I think they're gonna be on the second night (and last) so no doubt it'll be great! And I bet by September they'll be even better and show a different track list.
Pectiniculus 2 years ago
Just watched and loved Malcom's ending drum "tribute"
JOHN WEATHERS! JOHN WEATHERS!
petecellar 2 years ago 8
It's so great to see the Giant is once again awake!
AndyKub 2 years ago 2
COME TO MICHIGAN!!!
bassplayer142 2 years ago
I got to see Gentle Giant in 1975 open in between Gary Wright and Rick Wakeman at Cobo Hall! GG stole the show from Wakeman
Beadbud5000 2 years ago
Why can't they play more gigs in the U.K. ?
I can't wait !
charleslsegal 2 years ago
Maybe a few trial runs in UK before they trot off over the pond (Please) otherwise I am booking a plane ticket,
teddingtontcu 2 years ago
Playing FMPM in Montreal Sept 12-13!!
nomorephil 2 years ago
great to see this! In HD as well! wooo
FunkyMuleFromSussex 2 years ago