American Idol - Brooke White Elimination (4-30-08)

[acdff777]

I can't believe Syesha's amazing fortune she has. She is in the bottom 3 in the Top 12, 10, 8, 7, 6 and possible 5 and Top 4 but still managed to make it to the Top 3. That is a total of 8 times in the bottom three

[hotsparkles]

Nostalgia to the 10th power! This was the best American Idol season ever! Absolutely amazing :)

[popsingerstar]

@hotsparkles yeah & it was the last good "idol" season 2

[hotsparkles]

@popsingerstar So true. I really miss the old idol days..

[popsingerstar]

@hotsparkles yeah :( the show was the best until kara & ellen came along :(

[nicklazzarinirocks]

I still seriously can't believe Syesha made it to top three. She is completely forgettable whereas Brooke, Carly, Michael and Jason are all super memorable.

[coldplaytwilightluv]

jason sucked...brooke should have been top 3

[YounngRose]

SEE WHAT YOU DO AMERICAN IDOL?! YOU CRUSH PEOPLE! >=(. I still remember me and my mom watching this together, she loved her and so did I. She had such a sweet heart and Syesha crying for her was too sad. But...I cant help but think, "Why is Jason smiling and singing while she's just bawling her eyes out" o.0. Loved it, even when she was crying. Neil Diamond FTW. Brooke White FTW.

[sweetiepea13]

what should of happened: bottom 2- jason and syesha leaving- jason. next week: bottom 2- brooke and syesha leaving- syesha finale- 1st cook 2nd archie 3rd brookie

[sweetiepea13]

damn jason and syesha stole her spot! she was awesome! this was one of the saddest eliminations ever on idol. ;( i love you brooke and i dont care if some people dont like you! all that matters is i do. bitchy syesha and damn jason!

[PejaRapiLudzie]

This is a mistake. First Michael, next Carly, now Broke and Jason. Worst season ever.

[sweetiepea13]

@PejaRapiLudzie weve had alot of shockers on this show. christ daughtry leaving, 3 divas in the bottom 3 on season 3, michael this season leaving, bikini girl, bikini boy, window falling on that one auddition, jason in the bottom 3 and not kristy once, ruben in the bottom 3, and kris allen and adam lambert in the bottom 3 and then adam was in the bottom 2. this show keeps getting better and better with all the shockers. without them, the show would be boring.

[TheChristyLy]

Brook ish awesome

[DegrassiTop40]

that little 'yup" brooke utters after finding out she's been eliminated always breaks me too pieces. so sad. she was a great contestant and i hope she goes far

but...it was her time to go. i personally think the top 4 were overall stronger than brooke (yes, even syesha!)

[elpelozzz]

@DegrassiTop40 Hah Jason Castro stronger than her?! No way!!! Maybe the other three; but honestly Jason deserved leaving sooo many nights before and this week wasn't the exception. His two performances that night were lackluster and bad; he ruined two good Neil Diamond hits. Brooke only had one bad performance that night.

[fwens8]

David Cook so sweet 4:03-4:04, he wants to comfort her but yeah just leave her that moment..hehehe

[lala069]

Did any laugh they way she rejected Cook's hug and his persistance to hug her?

[AntmILoveYou]

I was heartbroken

[hydroquake]

this made me rlly sad. she was my favorite that year

[Edhson100]

Brooke, you're so pretty when you smile...........much more when you're crying. I'm a no. 1 fan and God bless you.

[angelbecca913]

wow, I just noticed Archie's face at :57 :(

I was sad to see her go. She has a lot of talent, and I have her CD. This was one of the saddest eliminations of this season., IMO.

[jlow121]

He also hid behind David Cook and Syesha, probably because he was crying.

Brooke's done great things. Proud of her.

[curlingiron7658]

MY ELIMINATIONS:

Bottom 2: Brooke and Jason

Eliminated- Jason Castro

[aeristhdeen]

I used to cry every time I watched this. But now that I know she'll have a cd out on July, this doesn't bother me anymore. I love you, Brooke!

[nudle19]

yeh i know...it was so sad to see megan go as well!!!! She was a stand out in season 8. But her song choice wasnt chosen wisely. She was VERY ORIGINAL and i liked that about her

[nudle19]

omg this is so sad.

everytime i watch this it brings me to tears

Brooke, jason and cookie was my fav all that season.

They really had a good combination of contestants & season 7 was VERY entertaining!!!

[peaceluvcoffee1234]

everyone's crying!

its so sad!

i loved brooke!

[spider23000]

"everyone's crying!"

Everyone, that is, apart from Jason Castro who just seems to stand there smirking while Brooke is singing.

(See 4.07)

[nudle19]

lol jason is just being JASON.

that's so him....lol funny guy!!!

[NIGELTHA1andONLY]

syesha was always in the bottom

[nudle19]

yeh it was sad when she left.

i dont understand y so many people hate her so much. why???

i thought she deserved her spot in the top 5.

[NinjangelRave]

I am...I said by Neil Diamond

[drifter6276]

Syesha looks gorgeous here.

[CMOUAROX]

You may think he was pure crap, but I don't. And my opinion is the only thing that matters to me. =)

[CMOUAROX]

Okay, David Cook WON the thing.

And Jason was the only REAL person on AI. Everyone except for him and Brooke were crap.

[knichoodiejoe]

Your a fucking idiot if you think that, seriously! Brooke was totally amazing and she is so beautiful. So I have no fucking clue what your talking about.

[danaduck486]

I love Brooke White. This such a heart wrenching moment to watch. She is such a raw, candid, and sweet gem of a woman. So very talented. Can't wait to see what is in store for her.

[drifter6276]

Syesha was in the danger zone hella times, but the reason she kept on surviving was because she was better than every contestant who was down there with her.

[Smileyglo]

I was happy with how far she made it! it was ether her or Syesha that was going to be in the top three(sorry for Carly lovers) but from the very beginning she was one of my favorites! But I always wanted both Davids in the top 2, But I stilled cried when Brook got cut cause she was so emotional, I love the look one Davids C face when he tries to comfort her! he seems like a really sweet guy!

[danaduck486]

I felt so bad for Brooke on her elimination night. She is such a talented and sweet girl. You could really feel her pain this night.

[abyssman9949]

you guys can go to hell because brooke is wayy better than all of the girls on the show. i mean like carly and syesha or sasha totally suck!

[holapearl]

why the hell does jason looks so happy and smiley... i hate when he does that when everyone else looks sad

[tiarnantman]

But anyway, I'd just like to say that Brooke was the most humble and all-round talented of the lot, and has the most potential to be a successful recording artist, despite what some of the freaks who've posted here are saying.

[tiarnantman]

You guys are total weirdos. Brooke disappointed you because she was upset at her elimination? Whatever...

[itsgoodforyourcolons]

Gosh Ryan stop hitting on her Brooke's already married!!!!!!! I've noticed on this season's Idol he's been giving her star treatment for some reason and I actually heard he flirts with her backstage.

[masacupana]

you guys are real mean people.

how dare you say that brook is not talented.

it just so happen that she doesn't have such a powerful voice like carly or syesha.

she knows that fact much more than we do so right from the beginning she knows she's gonna have a hard time.

She just can't really stand out in the voice department because of her not very powerful voice.

[MonaLq]

I actually love the husky tone to her voice. She cant sing as high, but she is more original, and her voice is recognizable.

[MSAmericanIdol21]

yeah i know

they were just unique

[fergalicious2468]

i honestly dont understand people these days. why else would a personw tih no talent come so far on a so-called talent show??

[whuhumuch]

It should Of BEen Brooke And JAson In The Bottom Two And Jason Would go

[qg6ff]

LMAO People are such dumb asses. On this show's site there are pics of where Syesha is smiling ... n people are like "she has no heart, she's smiling that Brooke is gone" Well watch here kiddos she was smiling BEFORE he said Brooke

[sheldeen1001]

I think she just shut herself off from everyone else because of how hurt she was. She seemed to want it more than others.

[nudle19]

yes i agree with u.

she was an emotional one and just couldnt handle it.

[MonaLq]

She said she was more overwhelmed than sad. I like her...

[nudle19]

yeh it was prob all emotion adding up.

it was so sad when she sang her last song on stage. And actually i thought it was really good.

yeh i like her too, she was very honest!!!!

[PopGirl1981]

all i can say is that im very dissapointed

she wouldnt let david or anyone hug her goodbye bc she wanted the camera to herlsef but other nights she would grab whoever left so she would be seen

i love her to death and i love her music but that night made me very dissapointed

[nudle19]

cos she was too emotional at that moment!!!!

i dont think she wants the camera focus on her.......

And she prob didnt feel david cook giving his hands out to her....she was too emotional to evn feel it.

[fergalicious2468]

yeah, did u notice simon said, about "i am, i said," that it was emotional or something, which i dont really understand. true, you must put feeling into your singing but i doubt you could actually call her hoarse rasp "Singing"

[V0rdh0sbn]

Word

[fergalicious2468]

y would anyone be jealous of brooke? i honestly dont see how she made it so far, it should have been carly smithson standing on the stage at that point of the competition. brooke was considered hot but she couldnt sing very well. could u actually see yourself buying her cd? she was very dramatic and fake in my opinion

[MSAmericanIdol21]

yeah i know

i always heard her voice crack and the judges never said anything about it

the top 4 should have been carly, michael, david c, david a

[puranijeans2002]

She made her way through by using different equipment to make her more presentable. It actually worked for her to get her through.

However enough was enough. She should had been eliminated a long time ago.

[puranijeans2002]

I can bet Brooke white will never be pro-singer in her life.

[puranijeans2002]

hahaha

you are funny.

[puranijeans2002]

I watched it and hated it. It was disgusting act that Brooke performed.

[puranijeans2002]

you probably has bad taste.. But its none of my business if you were interested in her because of your ------- orientation.

[puranijeans2002]

I enjoy the comedy of her overacting. (Isn't that funny when she goes 'Yes' after voted out?)

Seriously to stay in, she used various instruments. She is an untalented nanny, unless she puts a lot of effort on her singing.

[puranijeans2002]

We know Brooke white has no talent for being singer. So good luck with being a Nanny.

[fergalicious2468]

ur right. she should have made it so far

[puranijeans2002]

I was glad when Brooke White was eliminated. She stayed too long for her talent infact none.

[puranijeans2002]

I enjoy the comedy of her overacting. (Isn't that funny when she goes 'Yes' after voted out?)

Seriously to stay in, she used various instruments. She is an untalented nanny, unless she puts a lot of effort on her singing.

[iTV82]

Is Brooke White married?

[DeathlyScream]

'Brooke's Husband and Friends'

Believe you can answer that for yourself.

[jesicalea]

Aww that was sad. She made it really far though.