Added: 5 years ago
From: g0d53nd
Views: 959,087
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,059)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Calculators don't record video smart one

  • next time dont record things with your calculator

  • @Fudgepack101 Didn't record it dip shit, uploaded it from a file i downloaded. Go pop in the goddamn dvd and look on your HDTV if your that worried about it.

  • dont like false ad

  • Also, remember the scene a little later where the Witch disappears from Munchkinland? If they couldn't afford retakes, why was a second take of the scene shot "for insurance", despite the first take being perfect? (This is why Margaret Hamilton was severely burned...the trapdoor that lowered her into the floor was mis-timed during one take, putting her right into the fire that accompanied her disappearance)

  • They also had no way to edit movies back then... so the hanging munchkin was never removed... it has been edited out in newer copies though while restoring the movie and making it more colorful and visually appealing.

  • Above drivers hat slightly to right far back... seems to sway back and forth left to right... that's the dead munchkin... back then they only had one shot to get the scene... it costed them a ton of money to film... at lot more than today that is.

  • @daky2kill - They didn't have "only one shot to get the scene", MGM was one of the biggest studios in Hollywood, and they could certainly afford to do retakes...why do you think Dorothy's hair length changes from shot to shot during the entire scene where she first meets the Scarecrow? And there's no hanging here, either, just someone swaying to the music...do you seriously believe that of the 100 or so people on the set for this scene, not one of them noticed something was amiss?

  • this is stupid.

    anyone who thinks this is a dead chick has to answer my questions right now.

    Why would the whole cast carry on filming when clearly someone has hanged themselves on set? How the hell did that munchkin tie the noose all the way up there? why are you so stupid?

  • The girl would be limp and less mobile had she truly been hung by the neck. Seems a little lively for a dead chick don't you think?

  • judy garland looks surprised and shocked

  • wrong scene. but the hanging scene IS NOT the scene with the bird. its the part where the good witch is like "the bad witch is dead" or watever (its been soo song sence i have seen da movie so dont quote me but you get the point). nice try dude.

  • its a bird!

  • some one please piont it out to me

  • I see it now. I never notice

    when i was a kid

  • I saw this but really closed up on the girl and she's just wearing a point hat swaying back and forth, no suicide :| dammit

  • such poor quality vid as to decieve people, its a girl in the top left of the background dancing munchkins. but she is just dancing, in higher quality vid you can see her put her hands behind her back casually and shes moving her legs. soooo many videos on this LOL

  • I am so confused....

  • ... What am I supposed to be looking for here ? It's a big group of munchkins swaying back and forth in excitement.

  • ok if you watch the vid of actor from the movie and others they will say that the scene where the 'hanging' took place was shot months before ANY muchkins were even in town.

  • The rope you think you see is her hat! She is Dancing swaying back & forth & for the other scene it's a Dam bird. No hanging ever happened

  • It's just someone swaying to the music...besides, there were about 100 people on the set for this scene, and don't you think at least ONE of them would've noticed if something like that was happening?

  • Omg...cant see anything. This is sooo blurry nd i got bad eyes and im wearing glasses! Better quality plzzz! BTW THIS IS ON TNT RIGHT NOW

  • Okay I think it is a dead munchkin. Her feet don't touch the ground, and her legs are moving in an impossible way.

  • that girl munchkin is dancing... her arm moves down to her side.

  • That person is swaying, but she is obviously stepping back and fourth with her feet on the ground.

  • That is very hard to see  >_<

  • OH SHIT LOOK IN THE TOP LEFT CORNER, TO THE RIGHT A LITTLE.

    SOMETHING IS SWAYING SIDE TO SIDE!!!!!

    LOOK!

  • @Tundraboy05 Dude, everything is swaying....

  • its a bird you can 10000% of its wings

  • @TheKingCameron did you even watch this video the birds not even in the scene

  • at the very end of this clip judy looks like shes seen a ghost.

  • wow .....swinging munchkins everywhere, and none of the cast noticed... watch out for the house landing on your head

  • Okay 1) the "noose" is a pointy hat. 2) She very off beat (probably drunk or somethin) 3) the more blurry it is the less of her body you see so the bluryyness makes it seem like she swaying side to side because it to blury to see her feet move. 4) she stops for like a sec then starts again 5) she puts her hand behind her back.

    Just my opinion dont be mean lol

  • Man people can take things way too serious. It is youtube guys calm down and go get laid.

  • why can't you just leave the poor munchins alone?!

  • idk, all i know is this fuckin creeps the hell outta me.

  • Where's Waldo????  xD

  • that was creepy. thats what 4 munchkins that killed themselves in this movie!?!

  • @cellogrl4ever7 Whhaaa??

  • Besides, why does she STOP in the middle of swinging back and forth?

  • She does look hung. But from what I saw, what would a munchkin be doing hung in a penguin with a santa hat for a noose?

  • She does look hung. But from what I saw, what would a munchkin be doing hung in a penguin with a santa hat for a noose?

  • it's a bird

  • @i8a4re23 asshole it is not a fucking bird in this scene you reatarted mexican

  • @MrMrbookers that was unencesary why u had to say that , that was totaly un called for racist

  • @i8a4re23 asshead

  • it's a bullshit rumor and this is the wrong scene. The famous hanging munchkin is the scene where the scarecrow gets set on fire.

  • ok the scene that looks like the person is hanging in the trees is a fruitcuppin bird!!!

    in this one shes not moving rythmicly shes dancing if shes getting hanged then half the frickin munchkins are hanging themselves retards!! SIDE TO SIDE MORONS!!

  • This is false, it was actually a bird prop to make the set more lively.

  • @Xienis everyone says every hanging scene there is is some damn bird.

  • its on the top screen look a lil toward the top left and ull see a munchkin swinging back and forth it looks like it hung itself but its just false

  • EPIC FAILZORZLLX :x} !!!!!!!!

  • WRONG SCENE

  • Damn can't she dance. Her hands are in the front then she puts them behind he back. And on the upclose videos you can clearly see her steping side to side. The only thing I see wrong. She is off beat.

  • at the very top at the left... is it? you'll see a ghostly picture of a mans face. thats all i saw. but remeber, the olden days camra was a bit bluery......

  • I think I saw a munchkin eating a kit-kat?

  • erg i cant see it...wayy too blury

  • really really fake

  • its all fake

  • creepy

  • i saw it. it took me a while though.

  • so wait... Wheres Wally??? lol

  • @ibainesy shes smoking a bowl with me right now

  • i think she was dancing not hanging but its at the very top, top of the screen kinda in the middle and to the left, if that makes sense!!lol!!

  • no she wasnt dancing look how she goes back and forward

  • ok ok ok so we were watching the wrong place all along oh jeez this case might be harder than i thought

  • Far right*

  • She's in the way back on the rat you can see her hanging or swinging.

  • Can't see a damned thing, actually

  • wow jerks.......this is the real spot now grow up and stop putting everyone down

  • no good can come from the wizard of oz.. it was always a scary movie to me

  • its on google type it in on google and it will pop up

  • yo, wtf is that this is bullshit

  • God, this isn't even the scene where the munchkin supposedly hangs himself. The real scene is where dorothey and gang are headed off into the woods after the witch sets scarecrow on fire. Old vhs tapes made it look like somebody jumped off and swayed in the background, but the clear image of dvd and blu-ray now clearly shows that it's just a bird spreading its wings. The tip of the wing is a slightly different color than the rest of the bird, and a fuzzy image can distort it. That's all.

  • that's a crane. a bird. u can even see the wings spred

  • You just repeated what I already addressed. Good job.

  • well excuse me for not looking rihgt at YOUR comment

  • It was my comment that you specifically replied to, bub. If you weren't talking to em, you shouldn't have replied to my comment.

  • comment to author of vid: the rumor was that the munchkin was a male, and you say "Her" feet swaying, so obviously you dont know what the hell your talking about. good try though

  • I got a clear version on my favourites.

  • yeah its a good vid but at 1:05 she swings out and pauses for a second which is impossible

  • omg there really is i see the rope

  • Since when is swaying side to side suicide?

  • wow... this isn't even the right scene... duh.

  • never said it was a specific scene.. dont know what youre talking about

  • Why dont you put up a good quality version of this scene and we will see if the munchkin is hanging.... I think it is easy to make an assumption once you downgrade the quality 500%

  • I'll get you my pretty, AND YOUR LITTLE DOG TOO!

  • i see what ur tryin to get atdoes look like it

    but bein that it is right next to all the others

    well not too likely but good job though

  • Wrong scene. If you say you saw something you're crazy

  • in the back left theres someone swaying back and forth..

  • Everything's swaying back and forth..

  • in the back round there is a lady swinging off the ground jackass do some research.

  • No duh but this isn't the right scene for it. So you need to research your stuff not me

  • ya it is im looking at it

  • She's dancing. Wrong scene. Epic fail.

  • i think its a munchkin holding on to something and swinging by its hands

  • omg i see it

  • Nice, those munchkins were just hanging out....That's great almost 3/4 million people watched this, including my stupid self thinking, that's not the right scene? Although this is the hanging muchkin scene....nice

  • its in the very back, on the right, its swinged rapidly, almost looks like he's swaying, but hes hanging

  • wrong part!

  • where?

  • i dont see itt. where is it supposed to be?

  • FAKE FAKE FAKE! there actually isn't ne 'hanging munchkins' in this movie.

    people are silly.

  • where????????????????????????

  • top left corner

  • where is it suppose to be ?

  • that dead bodies got some rythm! lol

  • It.s a woman in a dress swaying back and forth to the music

  • wow u can see him swinging

  • the picture is too blurry can't see anything

  • the swaying is insync, if you watch the whole picutre everyone else lag's when the sway lag's......people just don't dance like that.

    "THE MUNCHKIN DRIVING THE CARRAGE WITHT HE BLACK HAT, TO THE RIGHT OF HIM IS A MUNCHKIN WITH A TALL HAT, ABOVE HIM"

  • OH MY GOD, that's horrible! Astonishing that it has largely been unnoticed for so long.

  • Point it out. you suck.

  • lay off the reefer.

  • I looked and I didn't see any hanging.

  • where is it i dont see it

  • Along with the bird, there's no hanging at all. You're supposed to look at the top left corner, then a little to the right. Someone's swaying back and forth like they're hanging, WRONG! I checked the scene on my VHS (cuz it's clearer) and it's just a Munchkin moving around like dancing (NO HANGING AT ALL). It's another attempt to prove a Munchkin actually killed themselves on the set

  • Sad thing is about the Munchkins is that they were all underpaid I mean the Dog got paid even more then Dorthy did.

  • it's at the top of the screen about a fourth of the way over from the left

  • i can't see it

  • i like to hump dogs

  • its soooooooooooooooo fun

  • watch the real movie. It just appears she is hanging because a) it's cut off at the top; and b) it's poor image quality. MWHAHAHAHAHA

  • i dont c shit.... i hav no idea where he is som1 tell me

  • I see what your talking about. The other scenes are more believable though. Im sure someone would notice a dead person swinging above them.

  • Wow, I see it. That's really creepy.

  • Where? D:

  • wtf?

  • uhm yes there was a guy who hung himself but it's almost impossible to find it's right before she meats the scarecrow it's a guy who tried out to be a scarecrow but his audition failed so he hung himself and no one knew for so long.

  • its a bird dumbass. no1 suicide, k?

  • onr was a bird

  • i dont see anything

    every fucking munchkin is moving

  • fuks its there bro its under th m and u in myunchkin

  • This is so ridiculous. It's obviously not someone hanging themselves. They would fucking let someone kill themselves on set. When they found out about it, they would obviously stop the show, and ESCPECIALLY not leave the fucking scene in the movie! I mean honestly! how fucking dumb can you be? She's dancing around like everyone else!

  • this is the third video i've seen where it says a body is hanging so far i believe only this one, one of them is a bird and the other i think is just a branch, but this one is scary!!!

  • I dont see anythin D: whereee??!!

  • k i have seen 3 scenes with this same footage in it...whats going on did he hang himself 3 times now?

  • everything is swinging, i cant see it

  • hahahah in the back.there is a man swinging not rocking around.hahah i see it now

    the bird is bullcrap.this one is fo so

  • this is bullshit there is not even anything that looks like a hanging person

  • where is it? i dont see any hanging, someone help me find him!!

  • top of the screen in the background a little left of center. you can see it swinging

  • I'm fairly confident that its just a person swaying like everyone else.

  • i cant see it please show us!!!!!

  • A lot of you are saying it isn't in the DVD version. But...if they don't MAKE the original because of these graphic killings, then how, may I ask, do you know it's REALLY there? Especially the scene with the birdie. You HONESTLY fucking think there were two hangings on the set? Fuck me with a fuckin' chainsaw, you dumbasses. It isn't real. When someone hangs themselves they hardly move like that! They barely move at all. Just a LITTLE side to side movement. This is like...stepping two feet. Wtf.

  • People have no life if they sit there and analyze the smallest details in movies that no one else noticed...its cool but...they really need to go out more.

  • Its all depression era political undertones, Dorothy and her family were poor farmer, the tornado was the economy and the flying monkeys was congress. Im sure the dead midget repesented FDR..

  • WTF? They're all swaying back and forth. Use some common sense to figure out that the "hanging" munchkin is swaying with the rest.

  • I don't see anything and why is the top part of the picture still in black and white?

  • i see it!

  • I don't get it. what am I supposed to seeing??

  • i see it but its a girl swaying back and forth . so fake no one dies T^T

  • i see it! but the one in the forest scene is a bird i saw it

  • And besides...the so-called suicide didn't even take place in this scene. It took place in the forrest after Dorothy, the Scarecrow, and the Tim Man met up with the Wicked Witch (right before meeting the Cowardly Lion).

  • oh good grief...you can clearly see its a person standing there swaying back and forth...not swinging from some rope.

  • i cant see where it is. i looked all over but i cant find it. should i pause it at some point to see it?

  • No, this video is a bunch of bull. The supposed hanging scene is when Dorothy, the scarecrow, and the tin man go marching on the yellow brick road through the forest. There is a huge debate over it being a munchkin or a crane of some sort.

  • oh ok thanks.

  • are you guys fucking retarded??? I'm sorry, I am , but really. If there was a munchkin hanging by a noose IN THE MIDDLE OF A HUGE CROWD don't you think that there would be panic attacks left and right in less than 2 minutes?? also why would the munchkin pause in the middle of her "swinging"??????????

  • Exactly! This scene doesnt even need to be debated over because it was abviously a change in floor level on the scene. The forest scene has a good debate vs. this one.

  • i see nothing

    were is it suposed to be?

  • dam it true...that's IS quite unsettling... :(

  • i see it. its near the middle of the crowd. the munchkin that just happens to be in the air. mandMRB is right, that is quite unsettling. ):

  • i can't even see any muchkin hanging

  • this isn't even the scene where the rumored suicide occured! and that was only a rumor. it turned out to be a bird (they had borrowed a lot from the LA zoo)

  • actually its in the newer version of the wizard of oz where they replaced the firgure of the hanging munchkin with a bird but in the origianal you can clearlly see the man being hung

  • omg really? that's quite unsettling... :(

  • yea, its true.

  • Oh yeah. By the way mate, there's two scenes actually. This is the other scene.

  • omg there was not a hanging during filming, only after the film was finishes, and when the hole cast was at a picnic

  • its not a munchkin or a midget, it's a bird strtching it's wing out. I saw the close up

  • did i miss something ??? anyways, i dont belive any of this junk ! nobody killed themself during the making of this film ! im 100% sure of that !

  • Guys that's a dancing munchkin

    The video is too blurry to tell, but it's dancing.

  • i see it. # in whenever they made that they couldnt make it so real. #2 they wouldnt do that to scare kids on pepoise it probably was seen after in theaters. #3. there is no number 3

  • were is it

  • lmao! yeah. cuz the other munkins would totally let her do that.