Added: 5 years ago
From: MrSpireite
Views: 483,491
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,085)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • This is the worst version of this song done by a bunch of untalented idiots.....that's all folks

  • Obviously you're an idiot, and dont understand nothing of music, feeling or creativity and art. So please delete your youtube account or go plant some potatoes somewhere we dont need to read your shit.

  • Durst & Manson & Diddy just rip off everybody elses songs

  • Terrible version...

    

  • I LIKE IT ♥

  • Better than the original by a mile :)

  • @twistoffate314 LOL, Good joke!!!!

  • this sounds like karaokee... terrible..

  • Durst is not the best singer but he's just such an awesome personality, especially on stage. My childhood hero, but I was to young to see them live :(

  • I just love how some people expects to find an exact replica of the original when listening to a cover. If they don't, they start hating. Don't you realise that you do not make a cover to sound just liek the original but to honor a band/song by making your own version of it?

  • 11!!

  • love this song

  • I hate that he changed the melody. It might be the right key, but he totally changed the notes of the vocal parts. Hate.

  • @JimmeeVeal so it's a version ... VERSION! If you wish you were here waiting like the original, then listen to the original ... idiot .... great cover!

  • Call me an idiot because I have a criticism? At least I didn't say it was a horrible song or something... Idiot...

  • Excuse me;but when there´s ONE person on this planet,who´s able to sing that song with soul and passion,then it´´s FRED DURST.He´s more as you can see with the eyes!!!Sorry,John ;)

  • flat.

  • terribleeeee!!!

  • no one, no one is like the composer.

    music is to aprecciate.. to play as you feel.. if want to hear the "real" u shouldn't try to hear it on a cover video.

  • Nada,nem a melodia nem a voz,faz jus a canção original

    Esses caras deveriam ser proibidos de cantar músicas boas,continuem com suas porcarias e deixem a perfeição dessa música do pink floyd com eles...

    meus ouvidos doem....

    PÉSSIMA VERSÃO!

  • Putzzz....

    Estragaram a música do Pink Floyd,PORRA!

  • Comment removed

  • I'm not sure which was more of a tragedy:  9/11 or this.

  • they could at least have played every chord... and what are these lyrics? i did a cover of the Pink Floyd song with a 20watt amplifier and my laptop and if it sucks at least i have a good excuse when they have the best gear money can buy! This is in fact the perfect version of that song if you want to show what's phoney about the so-called punkUS corporate rock bands

  • These men came together to give something of themselves to give relief to the 3,000 murdered americans. All you wannabe critics are missing the point.

  • I liked this video because of song, even Limp Bizkit and Goo Goo Dolls cant ruin it :D Even this was one of the worst cover of this song i have ever seen. :/

  • That sucked

  • Seriously? You wanted the souls to rest and you called Limp Biscuits to play this song?

  • Those of you bring politics into this need to stop... all this is two artists coming together and remaking a song that best expresses they're feelings in regards to a seriously tragic event. My opinion was it was different but its uniqueness is what made it good.

  • que buen cover dos grandes bandas la voz de fred es reconosible en cualquier lado me gusto el cover esta muy buena!!!!!!!!!

  • This was very heart felt. I remember listening this while after 9/11. It just sucks the Republicans and Democrats destroyed the Unity the country had at the time, now we are more divided then we have ever been.

  • @dinobot02 sucker.U got a hard-on for the land of the free (free as as long as you've got $ to pay and pay) and the home of the brave (not to difficult when in possession of superior technology/firepower) . Don't forget your "nation" is the result of a dozen of broken treaties with the original inhabitants that whitey has wiped out... remember Wounded Knee...9/11/2001 -10 years, twice WW2- was a karmic payback. and the karma I.O.U's are still piled high.. "keep on rockin in the free world"

  • @PIERRECLARY Your just more proof that morons still breed in high numbers.

  • This is an abomination in the eyes of god and man. If you like this song you're helping the terrorists win.

  • @DarkVertig0 yep. what a shame for Pink Floyd.

  • @The000Roy EXACTLY! All these people screaming about Limp Bizkit and Goo Goo Dolls (or anybody) touching Pink Floyd need to back the f**k up and realize that it wasn't an everyday cover for kicks! A few thousand people died and musicians were pitching in the best way they could!

  • Good but nothing beats the emotional and heart warming original version that is pink floyds .

  • rapeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee­eeeeeeeeeeeeeee!

  • Esta bien chingona esta cancion

  • this is complete garbage

  • @Hogfanx10 this is not garbage, what u said that?

  • Waaau ! Pink Floyd Ft. Limp Bizkit..! :'D

  • ....they (especially limp bizkit) doesnt DESERVE to even touch pink floyd....they hve lost tht priviledge :P

  • I generally hate it when other artist cover Pink Floyd songs and this is no exception.

  • Nobody can sing this song like david gilmour

  • If you wanna hate, hate on the terrorists instead of these guys

  • ii really shouldnt of came here  this sucks

  • Fred did a great job. fuck off you monkeys!

  • You just can't sing this song wearing a cap!

  • the only floyd cover i like more than the original is: Probot - Have a Cigar, it hauls some serious ass... apart from that, if you're going to try to make a floyd song 'your own'... good fucking luck. out of 10, i give this a strong 4 (only cause they had the balls to do it).

  • nothing wrong with this version

  • Okay, Fred did a really bad. But Wes is still great :D

  • these fuckheads shoulda been the first to go on 911

  • @joeblow238 Wow, that was seriously an idiotic thing to say.

  • the lyrics crashes!! come on!! don't KILL the song!!

  • this is poor...

  • we made better version..

    not good quality because it was live and not a good camera.. :)

    but our is better!! :D

    youtube.com/watch?v=vr61iyQiIR­M

  • boooooooooooooooooo

  • @andreas7ax: Have you been living under a rock? I suppose you know I'm a "faggot" because I made you lick your own s**t off of my d**k, right? I don't care how fanboyish you are toward limp bizkit. I like limp bizkit's older stuff, but I'm just not feeling this one. I have many, many more comebacks for your chicken brain, since I see you love to haul what your puny intelligence thinks are insults. Limp bizkit is an good average rapper, but with this song, he's, well, "LIMP". Ciao.

  • ESta bien chingo el cover

    

  • too bad I can only dislike once :-(

  • @VypalonG you are one of the true rockers who thinks that some songs are untouchable right???? closedmind faggot...

  • Wow, I am surprised. In a good way! Good cover!!

  • what tha fuck is this

  • Fred Durst, pre-wanker

  • LMAO, if def needs it own telethon, well put! I agree, its a good cause, but a shame to change Rogers lyrics.... oh the disrespect

  • a Song for Heroes in 9/11 and Its sounds Nice in ears, this is Cover song from Alpha Blondy "Wish You Were Here"

  • a Song for Heroes in 9/1 and Its sounds Nice in ears, this is Cover song from Alpha Blondy "Wish You Were Here"

  • Changing Roger's lyrics? Do they think they are better song writers? I hope not..... I can respect the cause....respect them for trying. But if you want to do WYWH, you do Roger's lyrics.....

  • This cover is so tragic that it needs it's own telethon.

  • @dagfunk76 its not bad..what were you expecting?

  • @dagfunk76 don't agree, but lol xD

  • I respect the cause, and I thoroughly enjoy both Limp Bizkit as well as the Goo Goo Dolls. However, the changing of the lyrics just doesn't sit right with me. Wish You Were Here is one if my favorite songs, and I just can't bring myself to enjoy this. That's justbmy opinion.

  • Frank Durst is still a faggot.

  • @USRecovery2kX he's called Fred... who's the faggot now?

  • @LemonsInPoverty

    Thanks for the weatherbug updated, Captain Obvious. Care to state anything else that's not blatantly apparent to everyone else who views this video?

    Successful troll is successful, faggot.

  • @Teimaninja At least he can sing.. Emo

  • Comment removed

  • Why are they playing one whole note lower than the original?

  • FLOYD !

  • this isn't bad, considering i can't stand limp fucking bizkit

  • hi guys, I know you hate copy and paste comments, but please, if you got a moment come and check out our channel, we’re two 15 year olds from Japan who do electronic (not techno, may I stress :D) hip hop with singing, and we are looking for feedback on our music so we can improve and make better music for you.

    If you think we have potential, subscribe and helps us grow as a group

    Thanks :)

  • balls

  • Love it! ♥

  • Yes ,,, quality ... Wish you were here.. X RESPECT and quality cover

  • Fred Durst, go home and rap rock some shit you dumbfuck you call yourself a singer? punk

  • Comment removed

  • increible!!! temaaaaa!!!

  • you're missing the point numb nuts it was a tribute to the fallen using a great tune very well. Roger Waters was good with it. So maybe you should be too.

  • NO HATE. JUST LOVE. THANK YOU :p

  • Sucks!

  • nice cover..and yes the guitar part is really awesome...fred durst \m/

  • if u dont like it, suck my white nuts, suck em....

    LB rules !!!

  • it`s "only" a tribute to heroes ...

  • @daspinmonkey Yes, thats true. But it makes me wonder, why did they choose him to sing this then?

  • love it! when artists insert their own shit into covers, change shit up, its just awesome! PF is what I grew up on, its in my roots, but this is an awesome cover!

  • THIS SUCKS BALLS

    IM WITH ZAKK WYLDE ON THIS ONE

    FUCK FRED DURST

  • @MenaPaws21 Enjoy your ivory tower of ignorance. Same goes to every other person who throws their murky attitude all over something that they don't like.

  • That mess may be for a worthy cause but it was a brutal demolition of a classic tune maaaaan !!

  • The guitar part is really nice with the 12-string but the singing is shit!

  • this song was sung at a benefit concert in Dec 2001 raising money for 9/11 victims and there families. one of the better songs on the benefit album which helped skyrocket the sales. A few words were changed to personalize the song and identify with the victims and the horrific event on 9/11. Goo Goo dolls and limp biz kit were the shit at that time and everyone knew the song was not the exact as the original and they didn't try for that, they raised money. knuckleheads get a clue before bashing

  • Why did they change the lyrics????

  • this sucks bad!!!

  • @tool5777 you suck

  • @TheGigaBitezBand <- you suck...

  • @TheGigaBitezBand

    It does, though, be honest

  • @goldenshowercap Compare to the original song? Maybe, but cmon its tribute, very beautiful tribute

  • @TheGigaBitezBand

    Sorry mate, but I just can't bring myself to agree. I think it's awful; I've got more feeling in my big toe.

  • this sucks

  • is it me or did he change a bunch of lyrics? if he did, sorry fred, limp was what got me into rock when i was 10 but u dont get THAT much creative license over the song. if im just mishearing thing, bong hits FTW

  • Not a terrible cover, but fred durst should never be let anywhere near a Pink Floyd song. The vocals are flat and disappointing when held up to the original's. They sound almost like they're talking instead of singing. Probably because fred durst couldnt sing hot cross buns to save his life.

  • @jeffjuco maybe he can't sing because he is a rapper....

  • Comment removed

  • If there's one good thing Fred Durst is good at, it's taking a great classic song and taking a dump all over it. At least he saved the speak and spell solo for a later time.

  • que asco de version una verdadera cagada!!!! sigan con su estilo no incursionen en temas que son clasicos de la musica y no merecen ser esto ! es una verguenza!!!

  • Fred put a lot of heart into this. Great cover.

  • john otto put the groove in floyd :)

  • The intro can be a cool ringing tone..luv this cover!!

  • Comment removed

  • I respect the goo goo dolls but fred durst totally screwing up the song

  • Beautiful! The addition of the strings really make it a great cover.

  • I am a huge Floyd fan, and I love this song... covers are supposed to be different. At least it is "good" different... unlike the Velvet Revolver cover. Nice job on this!

  • nope doesnt do the song justice at all

  • well they jus ruined it for me

  • one of the best covers ever

  • @MrOld1964 WHAT DO YOU HAVE IN YOUR HEAD TO SAY THAT !! YOU F**KING IDIOT !

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • ...goo goo dolls, limp biscuit, pink floyld.

    fail, fail, fail.

    lols jks.

    but seriously.

  • I dont mind the arrangement but changing the lyrics sucks

  • @raulp123 Stupid people should not speak.

  • really like this version, i like the different chords used as compared to the original. Though i think their alternative lyrics are bit too cliche for me eg. phrases like " before its too late, so proud to be free, who can we blame, dont be ashamed" sound like they come from a dummies guide to songwriting handbook :)

  • AMAZING!

    wes borland is wearing a radiohead t-shirt.

  • this song was sung at a benefit concert in Dec 2001 raising money for 9/11 victims and there families. one of the better songs on the benefit album which helped skyrocket the sales. A few words were changed to personalize the song and identify with the victims and the horrific event on 9/11. Goo Goo dolls and limp biz kit were the shit at that time and everyone knew the song was not the exact as the original and they didn't try for that, they raised money. knuckleheads get a clue before bashing

  • Comment removed

  • Why would Fred Durst ever try to cover Pink Floyd? You should have musical talent to try that.

    I liked this version when it came out, but after becoming a big Pink Floyd fan I've realized how awful of an idea it is for anyone to cover Floyd.

  • Comment removed

  • This is shameful !!

  • It'd be better if they got rid of Fred or got someone who could sing in his place. Same could prob be said for the entire Limp discog tho so whatever.

  • They play very fast, they changed the lyrics ruined the song. If I were Gilmours, I would make a case in court against Them. Damn metalheads.

  • Wes is my man (Y)

  • great cover by great bands of The Greatest Bend In The WORLD.

  • A fitting tribute to the victims of 9/11.

  • My dad loves this song

  • Awsome COVER. Yeah thats right, Its a cover damn it! you guys are stupid. Like it, or dont.

  • great cover, but still it's just wrong to change the words.

    the original fit the mood easily.

  • Wtf? This song didn't need additional lyrics.

  • good, very good cover. don't understand why are you dislike it.

  • terrrible.  really bad.

  • Not good.

  • When a band like Limp Bizkit makes a cover it doesn´t mean that it wil be exactly like the original, of course it wiil be different it´s there vision of the song

  • @ajohnynune0123456789 When a band like any band ever makes a cover it doesn't mean that it will be exactly like the original, of course it wiil be different it's there vision of the song

  • I like this. Pretty good actually. Props to Durst and Borland!

  • Im one of the biggest Floyd fans out there and nothing compares to them, but this is not a bad cover at all....and for anyone to argue about the differences and whos better is just moronic!! Enjoy them all!!! Its an honor for other bands to play Floyd!!

  • @captainmedvar I'm right here with you! I love Floyd. I have EVERY ALBUM (saucerful of secrets might be the best).. wish I could have seen the whole band together, but at 20 yrs old I'm proud to say I got to see Roger Waters Perform 'The Wall' live.. my favorite song of ALL time Comfortably Numb actually brought tears to my eyes.. it was Stellar and life changing.

  • @tommyq91 Awesome! I got to see Waters do the Wall At Nassau coliseum last month...I dont think I would have been able to live with myself if I didnt go...I wish I could go again.....but He's too far away now! It was Fantastic and there are Great clips on youtube!! Maybe we will get Mason,Gilmour and Waters together soon...woudnt that be nice!

  • @captainmedvar At first i was like this is gay! Limp bizkit!? Really but about have way through it i was like wow...i dont even know what to say i love it!

  • Hey whatever you guys say...well . I think they killed the originality of the song..

    You can get drunk ,get high ,sing in a sad or good mood,it's ok to sing with original way,but you try to change your own way then the feelins song use to give stops and the mind start yelling shut the fuck up....

  • Man, fuck Fred Durst.

  • @surfinalien man, fuck you!!!

  • i don't like it... cmon this guys can't make a good version of this great song or of a group like pink floyd...

  • every cover is peculiar and we should regard this but the song is just epic!

  • FFS. Only an american would think it's ok to fuck up a Pink Floyd track like that.

    They re-write stuff all the time. Like history etc.

  • This was from the heart and during a very strange time and it still touches my heart today. It always will. I love floyds version but I also love this version. It depicts the eerily sad emotion of not knowing whats to come or what just happened and why? I love it!

  • Fred Durst you fucking butchered this song.. WOW.

  • First a terrible tragedy like 9/11 happens, and then to top it off all the people that died have to be honored with a shitty pink floyd cover by Fred Durst. To me thats just disrespectful. At least bring in someone that can sing, not this whiny little bitch. I was waiting for Fred to start trying to rap it instead, that would have been hilarious.