Added: 5 years ago
From: mdebrus
Views: 124,780
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (383)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I was at school, and when i told them about the eucharist my baptist friends laughed in my face, and my catholic friends told them it was a symbol, but according to our catholic faith, we are supppose to believe in that. That is what seperates us from the protestants. If it wasnt, why would we make a huge deal outta it, and pray to it during adoration if it was a symbol. Why would jesus show us these miracles, if it was a symbol. It may look like bread, but its not. That is the meaning of faith

  • Oh now I get it! The priest pushed in the middle of the giant host and after a while it just bounced up with a recoil. Pretty sneaky to call this a mirical dont ya think?

  • No wonder people have no faith! If only the church people would tell the truth instead of telling fake stories, then more people would become believers.

    This video is totally ridiculous! Thanks for weakening my faith once again!

  • Amen!!! 

  • its too bad that such beautiful music is used for the occasion of superstitious witchcraft rituals like this.

    i like pancakes too but this is just too funny.

  • i'm not catholic but during one easter vigil in canada when i was playing violin for the ceremony. i was invited to take communion. i drank the wine but i took the cookie and fed it to a duck.

  • @leptismagna10 Poor you :(

  • @2shoes4paws no, poor jesus. a duck ate him.

  • O my Lord! Praise be to Christ in the most holy sacrament. Alleluja! Amen.

  • blessed are they that hast not seen and yet believed...GOD's presence in the holy eucharist is real, and there's is nothing to argue, be the bread it represents levitated or not...the truth is it is the body and blood of our LORD JESUS CHRIST consecrated in the eucharist!

  • Go cannibalism.

  • @AnthemicPolemic Re: "Go cannibalism." Are you just trying to insult us? Is that really living up to the standards of reason and logic you've claimed to set for yourself in previous comments?

  • seriously...can a practical athiest give me an actual explanation for this one?? probably not but I'm curious lol

  • @dcrippen2000 There are many possible explanations. I can offer you what first came to my mind at least...

    It is dry bread, circular, not entirely flat but somewhat concave. Once it has been removed from the container and brought out into the open, it experiences a change in air humidity, temperature, pressure etc. It could either be inverting its form, i.e. going from concave to convex as it dries, or due to absorption/evaporation of moisture or any combination of those things. Buy some and see

  • @dcrippen2000 You can see the same thing happen to any circular, almost flat material as it reacts to change in the environment. If you wanted to be scientific about it, you'd have to ask them exactly what bread it was they were using, try and get some yourself, of the same size and shape etc. Find out how it is stored, store it likewise, and then bring it out into an atmosphere identical to that in the church they were in. That it happened at that particular moment is coincidence.

  • @7th75thCallaghan Okay thanks for the informative reply, it really is interesting

  • @dcrippen2000 Anytime. Of course, i'm not denying the possibility of it being some action of the holy spirit, but it seems highly implausible even if I was a devout Catholic. Why? Because it seems very trivial, in a world where human action has immeasurable consequence, one would think that a holy deity would be able to do more than lift a bit of bread. Furthermore, this is one Mass in a million, what was so special about this one? As a simple game of probability, my answer seems more likely.

  • @dcrippen2000 More importantly, that is not an atheistic answer, just a logical one. Please do not confuse atheism with science: science is a process, not a belief, don't let any idiot tell you otherwise, it is the process of deriving facts and developing theories based on testable, observable evidence that offers consistent results. Atheism is the denial, through the logical process (not scientific) of reason, of the theist claim that God exists. There is a very fundamental difference.

  • @7th75thCallaghan Nice shot at trying to sound scientific. Problem is, there is simply no law of physics which allows you to get a piece of bread to stay in one spot and defy gravity for nearly two minutes. That's simply bogus. No way you could reproduce this in a lab given normal conditions like this. In fact, considering that they do this *all the time* in conditions very similar to these, we'd expect to see it more often. Best bet, if you're going to deny it, is to say they simply faked it.

  • @rumpranger65 I don't try to sound scientific, I am, sorry but that is how it is. I made no such bogus claim, you failed to understand my offering of a fairly straightforward explaniation - there is no levitation occuring, scientific or otherwise, it is the inversion of a hemisphere causing it to rise above the other piece of bread. Your best best is rather poor it seems. If this happens all the time, then why this rather lame 'miracle' now? Is that really the best the holy spirit can do now?

  • @AnthemicPolemic It's not clear to me what you mean by "inversion of a hemisphere." You could remove ambiguity and put it into a physical equation. You fail to address the point that, if that's all that takes place, and it's not a generally abnormal occurrence, then we should be seeing this result reproduced *every time Mass takes place*. We don't, so we have to go back to the respective predictions of each hypothesis, which leads to the miraculous one having higher probability given the set E.

  • @7th75thCallaghan Of course, on the *other hand*, which picture predicts that, if a piece of bread lifts up suddenly and levitates for two minutes inside a Church, that it will happen during some specifically religiously important moment, such as during the epiklesis: the picture which says that miracles occur, or the picture which says they do not?

  • @rumpranger65 The gestures and details of the eucharist have been changed and argued about so much over the years that there is absolutely no reason to suggest that any such moment would be particularly sanctifying, and more importantly why would it happen at this particular mass? Seems entirely unremarkable. It is rather sad that the church and its flock have to resort to such desperate resources in search of a miracle, but entirely unsurprising.

  • @AnthemicPolemic The epiklesis says "Let your Spirit come upon these gifts and make them holy so that they may become for us the body and blood of our Lord Jesus Christ." The epiklesis has *always* been held as a particularly important and sanctifying moment. So it's clear which hypothesis predicts that a miracle is more likely to occur at this time. And we know from probability theory that if we expect to see a certain set of data on a given hypothesis H that makes H more probable than prior-H.

  • @AnthemicPolemic To defeat naturalism all it takes is one miracle, not many, since naturalism makes universal claims. First, I don't believe that this is the only time a miracle has taken place, so the Holy Spirit indeed does more. Second, the event not happening somewhere else doesn't lower the probability of the event happening here (though if it happened somewhere else, which I think it has, that would increase the probability) so long as we have evidence (we've both testimonial and empirical

  • @rumpranger65 ** that was meant to say 'best bet'.

  • What is the chant in this video?

  • Does anyone esle notice nothing?!

  • The Eucharist is jesus Himself present and therefore it is extremely powerful. Many have miracles have taken place. Urgently need a miracle, see willann54 Miracle Prayer.

  • Satanic? Don't think so! So you're saying that satan is supporting the Holy Eucharist? It is just a proof that God exist! 

  • I think this is proff thath the catholic church is satanic! and since templars !!

  • I don't know about this. It appears the camera was shut off about the .59 and 1 minute mark. How do we know they didn't rig anything when camera was shut off at that point?

    If you look anywhere between the .58 to 1 minute mark, there was no "priest" on the right side and all of a sudden hes there. And why would the camera man only focus on the alter WAY before the "Host Vibrate sup and down?"

  • @bill1957111 I am glad you are uncertain for those that believe based on a miracle don't choose with faith I think that God does miracles with people that may not believe the miracle. so they still have to choose to have faith. please read something I don't know what but ask what you may have problems with and whose words would fit. I say this because it is best to find some one who talks similar to your thought process. May God bless you

  • @bill1957111 if you will notice, the lifting of the eucharist starts at the beginning of the video, and the camara was not shut off at all during the lifting, which continues through the rest of the video. if lifts at 7 seconds, so how do you explain that?

  • @tti01 what are u on about

  • @tti01 @bill1957111, Can't be true about the video not being shut off. Why? Because immediately after the epiclesis is the words of institution and the priest would take the unconsecrated host in his hands and then repeat the words of Christ. This skips from the epiclesis to after the consecration. So there was obviously some editing done.

  • I believe in miracles and was excited to see this ...but brothers sisters I see that the Host seems to spring up and is concave like a dish.and seems to look like it is levitating.

    I think perhaps with respect there was some tension in the host which caused it spring up..

  • @peterpap9 If you notice too, the Host vibrates up and down a second or two before returning to stability. Could be God getting everyone's attention, or maybe it's the result of a springing up.

  • Living God only in the Eucharist of the Catholic Church

    John 6:66

  • I'm Catholic, but this video is nowhere near proof. Any semi-decent video editor could pull this off. I'm not saying this is fake either though.

  • @bugeman0

    "I'm Catholic, but this video is nowhere near proof."

    proof of what ?

  • This does not really prove much.

  • Search for Blindness Gone in Jesus name on youtube you will find some good stuff..

  • Anyone who believes in Jesus is part of His gloroious body His Church !

  • That is a miracle!!! I have seen better magic tricks!! If your christen god is real and all powerful can’t he pull something off a little more convincing/spectacular like having an amputated lag restored.

  • @xbox1768 Done. The Miracle of Calanda is an event that allegedly took place in Calanda, Spain in 1640, according to 17th century documents. The documents state that a young farmer's leg was restored to him after having been amputated two and a half years earlier. (from Wikipedia entry)

  • @hermitcleric Not done. "Allegedly" is the key word here.

  • @winstonsmithamm Every single miracle as quoted in Wikipedia is "allegedly" by Wiki standards, even with tons of objective evidence. The key is the evidence, not the buzzword which is attached to every single miracle entry in Wikipedia.

  • @xbox1768 Making an amputated leg restore itself is probably the greatest event in human history .. the greatest miracle ever performed ..and if true , concrete proof of God ...

  • @xbox1768 That isn't a magic trick. It's a real-life miracle caught on film. Our lord Jesus Christ allowed the camera man to capture it so he can make himself known in the Eucharist. The TRUE Eucharist....which belongs to the TRUE church of Jesus Christ.....the Catholic Church.

  • ????

    

  • ????

  • adoremus in aeternum sanctissimum sacramentum

  • Ha! gullible fools.

  • The Holy Father in his "Summorum Pontificum" states the traditional Latin Mass should be in ALL Churches and so that the youth may become familiar with it. The New Order of the Mass dropped most invocations of the saints by name, or mad them optional. It was rewritten to benefit the Protestants. The practice in Protestant churches is "communion in the hand", thus is based upon Christ's Real Presence and the priesthood.

  • Wow :)

  • Once again God displays his divine power, even if one thinks it was camera trix or whatever, the Eucharist is still the way to Eternal Salvation. For the non believers, i wud recommend jus openning yur hearts to Jesus Christ, and he will fill u with his divine wisdom and love, it may not happen over nite but be patient and u will be touched by him God Bless

  • where's the miracle? what's with the popcorn bowl on the table? People, attend the true Mass...the traditional Latin Mass!

  • @MsCampobasso Friend, Mass is Mass. It doesnt matter which language you hear it in. The one person we love and worship is still present - Jesus. :)

  • I believe in miracles and the power of the eucharist more than most would... but not in this video!

  • nicley done, but no miracle.

  • google Doe's Account.

  • this seems like nothing more than a parlor trick, at least compared to the grandiloquent nature of jesus' purported miracles in the bible. i mean, think about it: chronologically, we supposedly have:

    creating a UNIVERSE

    parting a sea

    a virgin birth

    turning water to wine

    walking on water

    healing diseases

    a corpse disappearing

    fastforward a couple thousand years, and a miracle can be something like a face appearing on a grilled cheese sandwich, or a piece of bread hopping up and down on a plate

  • very impressive!!!also saints like italian san pio,while celebrating the mass,levitate sometimes.

  • I once found an onion ring in my french fries. It was a glorious day, it was my Woodstock!

  • The Eucharist is real! Go to Eucharist adoration and feel Christ;s love for you!

  • Comment removed

  • Joke

  • Constructive :) I'd hope to see you at a science convention. You'd probably be the goon in the back saying "uuh, shut the hell up" :D

  • You guys have to be kidding me?

    THIS is what you take for "evidence"? Please, NEVER serve on a jury.

    Honestly this is one of the most pathetic examples I've ever seen. Even Padre Pio's fraud wasn't this lame.

  • I think the Lord is showing his displeasure for using 3rd rate vessels what is that stainless steel? ick

  • People who don't believe get nervous when God does something so obvious. They realize that there is a chance that they may have to be accountable for there lives and can not go about doing all they please because they are just monkey's anyways.

    For those who doubt this I ask you how many times when you were making a sandwich did the bread float off the plate. I believe in miracles precisely because I believe in the laws of science which God can interupt at any moment because He wrote the laws.

  • With all due respect, I'm an agnostic. I don't believe in a concious God-person up there with white beard and all. I do however believe that if there is a God, it's some energy which makes the entire existance exist. If you think about it that way, the God actually DID create everything. But it wasn't something concious, because that doesn't make sense. The other theory though fits perfectly with both evolution AND science. And we know that some energy makes up the existance :)

  • Yes, I understand what you are saying about God having magnetic quality, but what you are missing is what all the Catholics who watched this video did not miss. The bread levetated presicely at the moment that the priest called upon God to come upon the bread. That makes it almost infinately impossible. What would you say to the other videos on here where the bread starts bleeding? Magnets don't bleed. Or, what would you say to statues and pictures leaking oil by the gallon? Magnets arent greasy

  • I know, a friend of a friend of mine was there as well and he saw the whole thing too. So I know it's not some sort of movie magic or something. I honestly don't know what this might be, but assuming it's God doesn't make much sense. I can understand that it makes sense for some people, but it doesn't have to be God just because it seems so. It could be a phenomenon which just happened. I know it doesn't make sense for some people, but for others, God doesn't make sense either :)

  • @MrKennyBones Logic to have God consciously creating this wonderfully complex yet perfectly precise world than everything with all it complexity and perfectly balanced ecosystems and cosmos happen by pure chance. A person would have to be gullible to believe that! God the uncaused cause of everything! It is non sense to expect the energy for an explosion for example to create, rather it destroys. You get chaos from order not the other way around. That is what science says a tendancy to disorder.

  • Thing is, chaos is a concept the human race understands. Chaos doesn't exist in the universe outside of our own minds. Because it is a human concept. Nomatter how one says it, believing in God is such a huge leap. Believing in science is easier because it actually has a solid base and fundament. Religion, no matter which religion, does not. It's the human belief which is the centre of religion, therefore, it's OUR truth, not the universes. Therefore, I believe in science rather than religion.

  • @MrKennyBones Why not believe in Faith and Reason? I am a scientist. The scientific method was invented by the Church, so were Universities. i believe some 30 odd craters on the moon were named after Jesuit astronomers!

    The probability of the world the planet Earth (the Biosphere) coming about by chance are so beyond astronomical make it nonsense.

    Our Scientific observations show us that the planets in space are so unlike Earth, a hostile hostile universe. Not Our truth but reality.

  • Sure, religion has done some great things, like the ones you mention here. But it's done it's job. We don't need it anymore like we once did because we have the answers we need and the right approach to finding new answers. And sure, the probability of our planet even existing is amazingly small. And the fact that there's life here is even smaller! But it's still true. It still happened ;)

    And actually, the probability that God made everything is way smaller than what actually happened anyway.

  • Without religion it is the law of the jungle, you can kill, steel, lie, abort human life, willful and assisted suicide (euthanasia), war, exploitation, occupation, ethnic cleansing etc etc. God made me to know him, love and serve Him and be happy with Him in this life and in Heaven forever.

    you have not seen God because you have not looked for Him!

    He has revealed Himself and the Truth in so many way throughout history, even now. All those martyrs and saints who live and died for the truth!

  • It takes humility to believe in the Truth! We are but dust and unto dust we shall return. Life is short. Seek the truth and be filled with Joy. the Joy and Peace that the world cannot give!

    Why did blessed Mother Teresa do what she did?

    She did it for love of Jesus our Lord and God. If we were all true Christians with great faith there would be peace on Earth!

  • @MrKennyBones ?Some altheists reject God not because they have any proof but because to believe in God (The Law giver) means then that we must follow His Law and because they do not want to follow His Law then they try to justify their lifestyle by denying His existence. Doesn't matter if you believe or not. He was is and will be.

  • Well, that's not me anyway. I do not believe in a God simply because it doesn't make any sense. I do however believe in a universal energy which makes the existance exist. But I think that this energy can be measured and/or proven by science. It may be the same as some people call "God", but it isn't very likely that it is concious. In either way, there are laws as well, the laws of the universe and everyone has to obey them whether they want to or not.

  • I was catechised. If I had not maybe I would also not believe in God. I do not blame or judge my brothers and sister in that situation but simply say we were made for love like a plant needs water, sun etc. We need Gods Love. Jesus is God and He loves you as though you were the only one in existence! He loves us so much that He gave us a free will so we can actually reject Him, crucify him and injure him with our sins.

    Do you know of Jesus or have any knowledge of Him?

  • I know alot about Jesus and I do believe he existed. There's actually no question to whether or not he existed. But he was not unique in that time. There are actually writings of several Messiahs at that time, each one performing miracles and preaching to people. Jesus however truly meant what he did, no question to it. And he loved everyone. But that's all human nature. It's all evolution because loving each other was a huge advantage for us before we became the modern man. No God necessary.

  • Did you know that all the prophecies from different prophets and different centuries before his birth all came true in the person of Christ. It is ONLY JESUS Who said He was God and the signs he showed proved it. Many eyewitnesses testified and sacrificed there lives for what they held to be true when they could have denied him and been spared during the persecutions of the Christians. There have been people who have experiences either "heaven" or "hell" (death experience) .

  • Just look at the complexity of the earth, solar system, and the universe. This could not have happened by chance. There is a central controlling force. This central controlling force is God.

  • Look, during all my time debating this stuff, I've realised that people can and should have their own personal faith. But that's the thing, it's personal and what I don't like are preachers trying to preach to us, saying we're in touch with the Devil etc. Like that preacher saying that the earthquake in Haiti was because they made a pact with the Devil and that they deserved it. That's f*cked up dude. Besides that, you're free to believe whatever you want.

    Despite the lack of evidence.

  • Every law of nature is made up of balance. The universe is in balance, our earth is in balance and even life. Evolution is a product of life adapting to it all and that's also balance. Even mathematics are a way of measuring this balance in a way we can understand. There's a reason why mathematics is said to be the language of the universe. And this is the reason why it is. Balance. I can't understand why this is so hard for religious people to understand and to cope with.

  • mathematicians physicists scientists (i am one) know very little of anything, believe me and we need to be humble about the truth that we know very little. e.g know one has ever seen an electron or can define it precisely. We cannot put God under a microscope and study him, rather it is He who knows everything. He has counted and numbered every hear on your head and know your innermost thoughts and feelings. God is Infinite Nothing is outside of God. He is AWESOME.

  • Fair enough, science don't know everything. But it's not right to say that because we don't know everything, God must be the right answer. Because that answer is even more far fetched. Well, it depends on what you mean God is.. I myself do not as I said believe in a concious God that has made everything. But I do believe in the energy of existance. And if you say that THAT is God, then God HAS made everything, just not conciously ;) And that way, he do know everything, he just isn't aware of it.

  • But wouldn't that be a funny sort of God. Like a watchmaker making a watch in his sleep. or a car manufacturer designing and assembling a rolls royce while unconscious? neither of these come remotely close to the world and the universe!

  • It wouldn't be a God in the sense that we know it. It would mearly be an energy that makes everything exist. And what lies within the existance is left on it's own. That is most likely what happened. Your examples doesn't make sense because evolution doesn't work the way you think it does. It hasn't created species. Evolution is just a term of results that happened on their own. In this example, the watch would have created itself gradually and the "God" would only have let it happen.

  • You can receive the most grace by receiving Holy Communion on the tounge while kneeing.

  • There can only be two possibilities here. Either this was a well directed hoax. OR some phenomenon happened here. Something like static electricity or something. But it was not God.. Unexplainable things happen all the time, independantly of religious faiths. Which can only mean that faith and/or religion has nothing to do with it. Which also means that it can somehow be explained and proven by science.

  • With all respect, unless you actually have the proof, you should take back your words. What explanation can science offer for this, that will actually make sense?

    Just wondering...

  • Well, strange stuff happen all the time. Just because we can't explain something doesn't mean that "God did it". I myself have sat in my couch, watching TV when all of a sudden, a small bluish light comes floating from one wall and right through the opposing wall. All without any sound, it didn't even light up the floor below. I don't think it was God or anything, I think it was a strange phenomenon.Besides, if this video is God, why doesn't he make more "woosh" of himself?Is this all he can do?

  • ok. an understandable question, i suggest you look up the feast of Corpus Christi and the story behind it. scientists did study this. this is REAL, but there's nothing wrong with questioning it, especially if you don't believe in it, so good luck my friend.

    God Bless,

    Ben

  • People are easily impressed when it comes to miracles.

  • Your so right. Because whenever I make a sandwich the bread comes floating off the plate. Its really annoying. You have got to be kidding me.

  • during concecration of the eucharist ask GOD what our heart needs, offer our shortcomings as a repentance of our sins and thank HIM for all the blessings received.

  • LIFE is a mystery and Blessed are those who believed in Him even without seeing HIM and telling us that HE is GOD. Do not critcize GOD's MIRACLE by giving much of your thoeries or scientific explainations for nobody will really be able to untold the mysteries. I KNOW THAT THERE IS GOD, I FEEL HIM IN MY HEART. I once asked for miracles and I affirm He is real.

  • These are very large hosts. One of them popped up and wobbled as it warped and rested on it's concave middle surface (temp change and/or suction release). Seeing the priests pass behind it is an opticle illusion since there is enough space made by the warp to make it seem they are totally separated.

    God uses nature and science to reveal Himself. The miracle here is not "what" happened but "when" it happened. Not a trick of the priests. It's God saying, "Here I am. I rule nature"

  • YES!!!! EXACTLY! Every non Catholic misses when its happening. Its precisely when the priest calls the Spirit of God to come down from heaven and be in the bread. The fact that its hovering, and at the exact moment when the priest said it makes the possibility just about infinite.

  • These guys are too much zealous. The Human Brain is a funny instrument. The first thing that impresses you is the looks of a person, his face and so on. So you take a toddler, squash his neck, use psychological pressure, then use a man to transfer a hair/skin fungus, then upset his metabolism with pills and introduce fat in various parts of the body at night and you get a bald, neckless, bloated Ogre!!! And who would listen or obey such a derelict, let alone fall in love??? Bullshit??? Pure Evil

  • Religion is what keeps the poor from attacking the rich! If you speak to god it is prayer if god speaks to you it is schizophrenia! People love you because they can get some benefit out of it! Not enough is known about the Universe and not enough is known about the Human Brain! If you want to prove me that Jesus rose from the dead then raise up a shot dead child! If you want to see a real miracle grow back an amputee's legs or arms! Survival of the fittest means to kill the meek! These guys shit

  • These guys are real cruel. They squash toddler's necks and use medicine to ruin your health. They control who becomes rich and who is given the death sentence. They are as evil as the Emperor Palpitine.

  • Comment removed

  • 0:08 As the priest extends his hands over the Eucharist (transubstantiation is occurring) you can see Jesus sacred heart, his true body and blood. This is truly a miracle only thru the power of the Almighty.

  • wow!! i saw host 7 sec timeslot embling float about 5 centimeter from the plate..its real miracle!! another proof that the holy eucharist is true holy

  • I have stared at the host & can't see any movement - the only miracle is that singing is in pitch.

  • It's NOT fake!!!!!!!!

    Even if the Blessed Host didn't move or float... it's still and always will remain a true miracle from God.

  • i think this is proof that the catholic church is the true church of Jesus.

  • @tti01 OF COURSE IT IS! The Catholic Church is and always will be the true Church of the Lord.

  • @tti01 The Catholic Church is an apostolic church but to call it the true church of christ? I think not...

  • @dameanz Jesus told peter, "you are the rock that I will build my church on", and peter was the first pope. the catholic church is the only one with bonafide miracles happening, besides the orthodox church, which is another form of the catholic church. only politics caused the two churches to separate. but other faiths, like lutheran, methodist, etc, are breakoffs of the church because they did not want to fully obey Christ's teachings. neither did the jews, and look what happened to them.

  • @tti01 "You are Peter and on this rock i will build my church" The rock he was referring to was the rock of his faith not on him as a person because prior to this, St Peter correctly answered Jesus by saying " ..you are the Christ the Son of God". As for the Catholic church having bona fide miracles i will have to disagree. I am not saying that they do not occur but there are several apostolic churches who also have many miracles occurring. Methodists and Lutherans are not apostolic churches.

  • @dameanz for this I would say many churches have miracles(my baptist granddad heals) but none have eucharistic miracles meaning the true prescence of God is in our communion. If Peters faith is so strong explain him three times denying, fleeing after Jesus's death, and his astonishment of Jesus's resurrection. The Rock symbolize the position set in stone for all eternity and the keys symbolize the position as head of the church on earth but not w/out safeguards.I hope we can talk peacefully n <3

  • @tti01 ...and this proves nothing. My question is why there was no reaction by the priests or the congregation??

  • @dameanz well, 1st of all, the camera is only pointed at the eucharist. how do we know how the people reacted, since it was not filmed. as far as the priests, what do you expect them to do, scream like a little girl? if you will look to the left, you will see one priest's mouth fall open, but priests are instruments of Christ, so they are not too surprised by miracles, because they know that the eucharist is truly the body and blood of Christ. heck, i'm not catholic and even i know that.

  • @tti01 obviosly i do not expect him to run and scream like a girl....what kind of a question is that?

    No reaction what so ever is why this appears to be a naturall occurance as the host they use is actually waffer and is subject to humidity and heat, which is why i think they did not reac as it is a normal occurance.

  • Are people attributing this happening to supernatural cause? To a Holy intervention? If so, what meaning could a floating Eucharist possibly have?

    There are many possible ways what is seen in this video is 'fake' or an illusion of sorts. The "various camera angles" spread across 10 degrees left/right at best with no varying up or down. It's no more/less impressive than videos claiming to contain ghosts or UFOs or the face of Satan in a cloud of smoke.

  • mary is called a virgin because she gave birth to jesus as a virgin

  • People talking about Jesus not approving of the Catholic church make me laugh! Of course there is corruption and things like that! We are just people and people are weak and bound to fall short! People in positions of trust, or power or whatever tend to be heard about more often than one of us. This doesn't excuse it! The Catholic church is the one true church and anyone who doesn't think so needs to do their homework... I converted this year and wish I would have done it years ago!

  • Welcome home my brother...

  • cont...what good would it do me to carry hate for the rest of my life? And abortion..whoever tried to deny that religious people also have performed the act of abortion? No one! Catholics don't hate people who have had abortions! We 1st try to have them avoid the situation all together, and if not..we show them the love & forgiveness that Jesus still has for them, and help them with emotional & sometimes physical scars that they'll have to endure and carry afterwards, for a lifetime!

  • migely: You seem to want to blame the catholic faith for everything, don't you! Are you a person with no faults, then? I know all too well about abuse, too..physical, sexual, emotional, mental, and verbal! It's something I've had to endure most of my life! Do I forgive those who have offended me? Yes I do! For my sake, and for the sake of the perpetrators soul, as well! It is a great grace to be able to forgive someone when they've grieved you worse than any other and for so long!

  • There is moral & eithical corruption in just about everything these days, but that doesn't necessarily mean that the entire institution of the Catholic Church and it's beliefs are corrupt? You can't group together an entire institution for the faults of just a few!! Jesus would approve of the Catholic church...he's the one that founded it!! But anyways..this type of conversation is just going to be never-ending....so whatever!! I'm not going to change your mind, or mine! So this useless, yeah?

  • HolyCatholicApostoli....Thank you for your words of knowledge! There is so much that I could've said, and yet didn't know where to start! It's hard to believe that some persons, Catholic or not, could be so harsh and vindictive, like I've seen on some of these "text comments". What ever happened to people just being kind, considerate, and respectful to what others believe? There is so much anger that comes from some people, and unnecessary anger at that! Your words were refreshing! Thank you!!

  • pkolk523

    You are getting "knowledge" from holycatholicasshole? lol

    Talk about the blind leading the blind!

    The world would be such a better place without your anti-modern, anti-science, anti-progressive Catholic Church which has oppressed us for 1600 miserable years. Maybe no one should be angry about the molestation, warfare, torture, executions and usurping of democracy that have been the hallmark of Catholic behaviour, but some of us want to take Catholicism to task. No more free ride.

  • Part 1. How the Catholic Church Built Western Civilization

    THOMAS E. WOODS, JR.

    From the role of the monks to art and architecture, from the university to Western law, from science to charitable work, from international law to economics, How the Catholic Church Built Western Civilization delves into just how indebted we are as a civilization to the Catholic Church, whether we realize it or not.there have been good Christian and bad Christians.

  • Part 2 How the Catholic Church Built Western Civilization

    THOMAS E. WOODS, JR.

    there have been good Christian and bad Christians. Yes the bad does not go away but we learn from our mistakes. The people do not always follow the teachings, if they did there would be no War, crime, hate,...but we are sinners and have a fallen human nature but we must strive for Holliness (e.g Blessed Mother Theresa of Calcutta, who is among many, many holy people).

  • Dear pkolk523,

    We all come from different situations and must love even our enemies or those who preach false or contrary teachings.

    why? because God loves all of us and desires all to know and love Him and live with Him for ever in Heaven.

    We do not know why some people think the way they think. It is Grace that opens our minds, hearts and understanding (7 Gifts of the Holy Spirit).

    Continue to spread the Gospel of forgiveness of sins, His Church, The EuCharist (Jesus).

    People want TRUTH.

  • Cont.

    And Y does it always come back to a "sex" issue w/U? & yes ur words are very hurtful and cruel, when there is no need for it! The video above is in reference to something miraculous, NOT sex! But since u've brought it up...u've taken a handful of priest who have done wrong and have pinned it upon every priest. U call that fair and uncruel? There's contraversy that OJ killed his wife, does that mean every football player is a murderer? I have nothing backwards! Have I posted mean words?

  • migely

    no one ever said that sex couldn't be enjoyed? where did U get an idea like that? God created it to be enjoyed! Ur mind is obviously directing itself on a path all ur own! One of the offenses taken by the church & God when it comes to sex is the use of contraceptives, and there is just & cause reason for that, which is stated in the Bible! There is also certain situations in which it is okay'd, too! U don't know everything U seem to think U do!

  • Dude is that seriously floating? Crazy awesome stuff happens at Lourdes. :)

  • Wow! Not 2 surprised 2 find migely again, spewing out obsentities, and using constant vulgarity! I've run into migely b4 while I was peacefully and kindly commenting on another youtube video! If you don't like the catholic faith, God, Jesus, his Blessed Mother Mary, Y do you keep visiting & revisiting these videos/comments? Why don't you just entertain urself elsewhere? ur cruelty is obviously intentional, & mean! Ur really just making urself look bad & obsessed in a way! peace4ever! pray 4 U!

  • pkolk523

    I am cruel? Don't you have that a little backwards, Mr. Selfish?

    The Catholic religion is not benign and the harm of your ignorance, naivety, and support are the cause of immense suffering throughout the world.

    Women are allowed to enjoy sex. Mary was no virgin and sex is not a bad, dirty act. The Church' behaviour for 2000 years has shown that it should preach no moral authority when it comes to sex, birth control etc.  Enjoy your corrupt theology while the world suffers.

  • More than 48 Million Abortions in America alone all at the hands of the atheists.

    The Holy Catholic Church is the only True Church totally against killing of the unborn against this satanic evil!

    Judge the tree by its fruit!

  • holycatholichypoctrite

    The fact is that MOST people who get abortions are religious people. They go to church and they learn nothing of the real world. As soon as they get pregnant their CATHOLIC mommy and daddy arrange for them to get rid of their mistake.

    Religion is for hypocrites and their is no worse than the Catholic Church.

    Atheists are not responsible for organized murder in this world. It is always religious groups of one religion or another. YOU are the ones getting abortions.

  • A contradiction in terms.

    Religious and Abort (kill) their children?

    Religious and disobey the command " thou shalt not kill" ?

    I would say that they have an uniformed or illformed concience or just do not accept the church teaching like so many heretics! or they were pressured to have abortions.

  • Please try being logical sometime.

  • All human life deserves to be protected against people proposing Abortion.

    Remember you are ALIVE because your right to life was protected!!

    How about sharing this right with others?

  • It happens at 7 seconds in.

  • I don't understand why, if this is truly a miracle, the posters would cast such pearls before swine. Such a thing should be guarded and cherished. This just leaves the Sacrament vulnerable to mockery. BTW, what is is about vulgarity, childishness and atheism that they always go together. Please remove this video. Who can see what happened anyway, and what meaning would it have for the rest of us? I didn't see a thing, and resent having my Lord mocked by these juveniles.

  • At the very start the host begins to levitate. It only last 3 sec. Not a Mockery I am sure. A minor miracle of what we already know to be true. Those of us with faith do not need proof. Still it is nice to know that Jesus is always with us.

  • Pull you head out of the clouds. That wasnt the work of Jesus...that was the work of someone tricking you. What planet do you people live on?

  • You raise some very good points. I've thought the same. Why must these things be posted when the posting will leave them open to mockery? I'd post them, perhaps, but disable the comments and/or ratings. Who wants to read blasphemy and vulgarity?  Jesus Himself said, "Tell no one," after performing some of His miracles.

  • migely I would take your opinion seriously if you would refrain from the vulgarity. Many atheists resort to it , however, it just shows a lack of maturity.

  • That was not Jesus folks...you can see it bounce a few times...because of a mechanism. Sorry....but you need to not believe so blindly.

  • I believe what Jesus said every word.

    that is enough for me, faith is a gift from God!

    To believe without seeing, otherwise what is faith?

  • I dont know why people gave me the thumbs down. I believe in something higher than myself...I cant say its Jesus...or God...What I was trying to say is everyone knows that is not something holy....it was set up to look like it was. Do agree that it " floating " is a hoax...and further more, doesnt that make you angry? Honestly.

  • HolyCatholicfool wrote:

    "I believe what Jesus said every word."

    Jesus never wrote a single word. NOT one. EVER.

    You have no idea what you even pray to or believe as you just follow the crowd like a lobotomized lemming. There is nothing new or original with such mindful ignorance on your part and televangelists, bishops, cardinals and touchy-feely priests love your naivety and gullibility.

    Jesus wrote nothing. Anonymous authors wrote decades after his death.

  • Yes Our Blessed Lord and God Jesus never wrote a single word But He did preach for 3 years and His Apostles were witnesses. the 4 Evangelists and Saint Paul transmitted all that Jesus taught. These are contained in the Holy Gospel, Sacred Tradition and the Magesterium.

    There are too many factual, historical evidence and miracles then and now! All prophesies were fulfilled concerning the Person of Christ.

    That is why so many pagans and atheists converted then and now! People want the Truth!

  • ur all on crack lol

  • praise Christ, present in the Eucharist!

  • Praise nothing. And Mary was no more a virgin than your gaping butthole.

    Jesus had brothers and likely sisters. Remember James?

    Mary took it up the tuna shoot like every other woman in history you naive, wishful thinking, Easter bunny believing wanker.

    Mary a virgin? ha She likely had a stiffy in every hole. They didn't have the telly to watch, after all. What do you think she did with her husband? What a naive one you are.