I always loved hearing Brooke back then and still do. She is a sweetie and I happen to LOVE her voice. Everyone has their own likes and dislikes but I think it was HARSH of dreamweaver to say it was an abomination of the song..come on now...lol..She's not suppose to be an exact replica of the Beatles..good grief..give her credit..she has a great quality I love...many of us do..and booo to the 12 dislikes...there is no accounting for taste in some people..lol..now smile and have a great day <3
you can tell that all of the little mistakes that she makes are due to her nerves which i totally sympathize with. Now, I never sang in front of millions of people on television but the feeling of stage fright is pretty much the same. I personally love her. All of her performances are so vulnerable and I think that's pretty appealing.
She has an AMAZING voice and her rendition of let it be was AMAZING, this song just isn't the best to be performed, especially for a girl, but she still did it amazingly!
George is probably rolling over in his grave at all the horrible uses his music is being out to. his music had meaning and was about changing the bad things in life and being inspirational- people who cover Beatles songs need to understand them and do it with feeling not just basically sing karaoke
what it started off nice.. then not only did it feel and look corny..i know,its mean but really, it was cheesy and then she added dancing(wrong move..literally) and had a yellow dress with yellow background and the name of the song was here comes the sun? no..it was to much and very amusing!! that's my opinion but i really like her.
She's too humble. This performance was far from perfect, but her voice was it's usual beautiful self. The show is very guilty of picking on non singing related issues while swearing up and down it's a show based solely on singing talent. Outfits, dancing, etc. are meaningless until you're a touring pro. Simon is obviously the biggest offender. He actually knows quite a bit about singing talent, but should spare us the other nonsense. He has major issues with dancing and clothing.
It's incredibly hard to sing Harrison songs. It's just something about them. She did as best as she could, but it's really not even a song that should be performed for a singing competition. It's more of a song that's good with the guitar and all of the instuments being heard. I liked her Let It Be much better.
she butchered let it be, but she did awesome on this song. i am a huge beatles fan and if someone is going to remake a beatles song, it has to be amazing for it to even compare. she did good on this song
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I don't like the Beatles very much at all but she does such a good cover, it makes me like this song now. I've never heard a better cover or original of this so i don't know why people don't like it.
she sang this song the day that my dog died. i know that it sounds so stupid, but my dog was around for my entire life. when brooke sang this, i started to cry. i know i'm pathetic, but i seemed to relate to the words. i never really focused on the words until that night. i thought she did great.
i didn't vote for brooke i voted for david archuleta, but i just couldn't help but love brooke. she was so nice and i love her singing style. she was my second fave thru-out the entire thing.
The Studio Version makes me smile every morning. Her voice isn't as powerful as some of the female performers but NOT ALL SONGS need to be SHOUTED. She sings great.
I always loved hearing Brooke back then and still do. She is a sweetie and I happen to LOVE her voice. Everyone has their own likes and dislikes but I think it was HARSH of dreamweaver to say it was an abomination of the song..come on now...lol..She's not suppose to be an exact replica of the Beatles..good grief..give her credit..she has a great quality I love...many of us do..and booo to the 12 dislikes...there is no accounting for taste in some people..lol..now smile and have a great day <3
MsHeavensarrow 1 month ago
Brooke does not like the dancing she did during the song. I think it's adorable.
calvininsf 3 months ago
One of the most polarizing contestants in Idol's history. I, for one, LOVED HER.
calvininsf 3 months ago
great job brook always loved you.........
jmill1948 6 months ago
Voice is a bit too harsh for my taste...this is an abomination of one of the greatest songs ever written.
DreamWeaver1988 8 months ago
im such a sucker to raspy voices <3
Rawrceo 8 months ago
shes just so beautiful. she really deserved to win!
KaylaAnne365 8 months ago
I hate her raspy ass voice ugh
kingof1 8 months ago
To be honest, I actually didn't like her singing this song..
xXColdaustinXx 9 months ago
you can tell that all of the little mistakes that she makes are due to her nerves which i totally sympathize with. Now, I never sang in front of millions of people on television but the feeling of stage fright is pretty much the same. I personally love her. All of her performances are so vulnerable and I think that's pretty appealing.
nothingreally1234 9 months ago
haha, I love her response to Randy. Her personality makes up w/e lack people see in her voice.
dmp1549 10 months ago 3
LISTEN!
AntmILoveYou 1 year ago
Looks like Claire from Lost
KillingOptions 1 year ago 3
Nina Simone sings it much better. I think with more practive she will get it.
CHEVAVAL04 1 year ago
She has an AMAZING voice and her rendition of let it be was AMAZING, this song just isn't the best to be performed, especially for a girl, but she still did it amazingly!
cydernie 1 year ago 3
@cydernie I do agree 100%! :) I love her rendition of this song. :)
dixiechiq810 1 year ago
@kidzwithoutmedz so does taylor swift.. but its all about looks now-a-days i guess
jordosarah 1 year ago
@jordosarah
It's always been about looks in pop music. Where have you been? That goes for men and women.
redwingsmike3718 1 year ago
@redwingsmike3718 under a rock.
jordosarah 1 year ago
George is probably rolling over in his grave at all the horrible uses his music is being out to. his music had meaning and was about changing the bad things in life and being inspirational- people who cover Beatles songs need to understand them and do it with feeling not just basically sing karaoke
QueenBeatlesWings 1 year ago
what it started off nice.. then not only did it feel and look corny..i know,its mean but really, it was cheesy and then she added dancing(wrong move..literally) and had a yellow dress with yellow background and the name of the song was here comes the sun? no..it was to much and very amusing!! that's my opinion but i really like her.
kyw0202 1 year ago
Shes the best singer of our generation.....
MusikDiggarn93 1 year ago
@MusikDiggarn93 Easy now... She's good, very good even, but settle down...
quedasobravo 1 year ago
she's one of my favorite finalist i love season seven sactually all of the top 12 are great
crenzaira 1 year ago
Comment removed
hollaatchaboiiii 1 year ago
Season 7 was awesome!
04141328223 1 year ago 2
fuck you
abunasser111 1 year ago
She is one of the few idol finalists i still remember :)
Beachbaybe245 1 year ago 3
brooke is so pretty and yet so humble. i miss season 7.. i think the "wooooh"is cute btw. lol
mariellacap 1 year ago 11
this was horrible, didnt enjoy, i love her let it be cover, but i dont think this was the right choice for a song for broke
MrCaberto 2 years ago
She's too humble. This performance was far from perfect, but her voice was it's usual beautiful self. The show is very guilty of picking on non singing related issues while swearing up and down it's a show based solely on singing talent. Outfits, dancing, etc. are meaningless until you're a touring pro. Simon is obviously the biggest offender. He actually knows quite a bit about singing talent, but should spare us the other nonsense. He has major issues with dancing and clothing.
SterlingRe 2 years ago
i love the beatles and brooke white
so102995 2 years ago
It's incredibly hard to sing Harrison songs. It's just something about them. She did as best as she could, but it's really not even a song that should be performed for a singing competition. It's more of a song that's good with the guitar and all of the instuments being heard. I liked her Let It Be much better.
SMK121 2 years ago
One of my favorite songs!
jeeblestein 2 years ago
Brooke is the greatest...so beautiful yet so humble...and the voice of an angel
jonallen9977 2 years ago 5
I can't believe Simon, the performance was great.
Au4Ob08 2 years ago 6
good!!! much good !!! bravo!!
exitoyfama 2 years ago
she is alot better than Taylor Swift but i love her
rongal6 2 years ago 4
she butchered let it be, but she did awesome on this song. i am a huge beatles fan and if someone is going to remake a beatles song, it has to be amazing for it to even compare. she did good on this song
hiddenchaos1 2 years ago
she does alot better on covers for beatles than most ppl do.
Tobi324 2 years ago
but no one is the beatles
Tobi324 2 years ago 3
her version of let it be was wayyy better than here comes the sun.
liv4soccer4 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I don't like the Beatles very much at all but she does such a good cover, it makes me like this song now. I've never heard a better cover or original of this so i don't know why people don't like it.
mysupercoolvideos1 2 years ago
to me, she sort of looks a bit liek taylor swift with that hair do. :) she is very great. nice song. :) :) :) :0 :)
05Piano 2 years ago
she responds too much to the judges..
globe211 2 years ago 3
Well, nice sung but she better performed "Let It Be" - it was more emotional.
WeirdHerb 2 years ago 2
it was SO NOT UNFORGETTABLE! i love this song!
fabulousadamparade 2 years ago 3
oh my gosh her outfit is so childlike, but it's so sweet and heartfelt
shulmanstallion240 2 years ago 3
LOVE that outfitt
ghostie7790 2 years ago 3
George would have been proud.
orangequartermusic 2 years ago 34
4:03 Paula's laugh HAHAHAHA
gianelvr4 2 years ago 3
i didnt know she was married! how old is she?
volley098 2 years ago
24 years old
RagazzaFit25 2 years ago
thanks
volley098 2 years ago
simon; "here comes the horrible sun"
Hahahahahaha!
PiinKsHaaDoOw 2 years ago
aw simon is such a turkey. it wasn't HORRIBLE. it just wasn't her best performance.
chanteuse676 2 years ago 2
gobble gobble ;)
switchhitter2 2 years ago
I loved it
anniethefanny10 2 years ago 3
she has great legs!! :)
CAemerald96 2 years ago 4
Man, she looks like Taylor Swift.
katakenda 2 years ago 2
ik they have like the same exact hair (:
lovexXlaughxXshelly 2 years ago
I love the way she sings!
angreys 2 years ago 2
I love her! and she picks like all my favorite songs!
funkychic94 2 years ago 3
if it was lennon/mccartney week, why is she singing a song written by george harrison?
KatsavesAnimals 2 years ago
i wondered the same thing
lexip153 2 years ago
this was beatles weak i think... there was another weak where they did lennon/mccartney and she sang let it be
LGRuggeri 2 years ago
week* :p
Lonehwolf1 2 years ago
it's the beatles week :)
Sepia1989 2 years ago
She is adorable.
Shit, I couldnt move up there either. With all those people watching me, I would not know where to put my hands.
dosomethin888 2 years ago
haha her performance made me obsess with the song. <3
pinkstar02323 2 years ago
I love her.
aerorox1263 2 years ago 2
The top 12 was the Lennon/McCartney week, the top 11 was the Beatles.
o0obEaKeRo0o 3 years ago 3
She had my vote!!! Brooke ROCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
imaloud1 3 years ago 3
im so jealous of her legs lol
CAemerald96 3 years ago 3
Just one thing---weren't they supposed to do a Lennon/McCartney song that week?
TackyRackyComixNEO 3 years ago
it's beatles week
watch properly please
00008kid 2 years ago
But wasn't it only the rights to the Lennon/McCartney catalogue that they had secured?
More importantly, does it even matter???
TackyRackyComixNEO 2 years ago
Simon laid it on hard.
I love brooke but she needs to let the judges talk@
CAemerald96 3 years ago 3
and she will NOT shut up. talks back the the judges incessantly. my lord.
kcmet79 3 years ago
2:29 woooooo!!! as she twirls.
so, so bad.
kcmet79 3 years ago 2
She should have won!!!!!!
TopLevel32 3 years ago
Dave's cute!
MimiOfOz3 3 years ago
She is an incrediblely sweet person. She was my favorite on the show.
imaloud1 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Is Paula high again?
verycoldice2 3 years ago
I think she did a great job on this song!
ammacon 3 years ago 4
i sang this for my choir,
mochayum520 3 years ago
she sang this song the day that my dog died. i know that it sounds so stupid, but my dog was around for my entire life. when brooke sang this, i started to cry. i know i'm pathetic, but i seemed to relate to the words. i never really focused on the words until that night. i thought she did great.
orangerulz 3 years ago 7
Aww
loveDavidArchuleta28 3 years ago 2
why is that pathetic?
foxxy94j 3 years ago
i kinda thought people might think it's pathetic for me to get all sappy over my dog... but no one did that, so maybe it's not?
orangerulz 3 years ago
its not if one of my dogs died id cry
foxxy94j 3 years ago
well thanks :)
orangerulz 3 years ago
no problem
foxxy94j 3 years ago
luv she's :))
v1r4 3 years ago 2
I HEART BROOKE WHITE
artgirl95 3 years ago 3
it was not forgetable, not at all!!! I REMEMBER..........I LUV THAT SONG!
artgirl95 3 years ago 25
i didn't vote for brooke i voted for david archuleta, but i just couldn't help but love brooke. she was so nice and i love her singing style. she was my second fave thru-out the entire thing.
doubleDdog09 3 years ago 6
The Studio Version makes me smile every morning. Her voice isn't as powerful as some of the female performers but NOT ALL SONGS need to be SHOUTED. She sings great.
TwinFatality 3 years ago 3
Mine too (First Achie then her)
loveDavidArchuleta28 3 years ago
I luvv brook
she should hae won!!!
webkinzfan146 3 years ago 8
i think brooke did this song good but not good enuff to winnnn, i think david cook is gonna win but i want archuleta to win (:
xonanisox 3 years ago 5
I LOVE BROOKE!!
mikeycadoch 3 years ago 8
OMG i lovew brooks voice
eileenregina 3 years ago 7