this is not out of tune, Rafi Saab just sang it different tothe original recording. Mate you should not make unqualified comments by calling a legend out of tune, In singing being called out of tune or out of taal is most insulting. This is just a sincere request. Thanks
@bambaikababu2 bambai ke babu . . . aap apni identity chupaa ke hi rkhna wrna youtube k rafi saahab ke fans aapko bahoth maarenge . . . agar kisi aur ne nahi maara toh Ragi saahab ke har gaanay ki Kasam mai aapki gaand phodh dunga ;) ! ! !
please dont evaluate him, he is beyond any evaluations.. studio-recording is one thing and live singing is another thing... He can never go wrong... God bless him where ever he is today... :(
@bambaikababu2 - This was recorded from the audience at a concert in 1977. I personally don't think he's out of tune... the quality of the recording is not the greatest, but I believe it's the only live version of this song out there.
@tanweermian Thanks Tanveermian. Rafi sahab was a great singer and also a nice man. But towards the end of his career knowledgeable people say he sang out of tunes many times. With the emergence of Kishore Kumar Rafi sahab's star went down and as Naushad sahab said Rafi sahab probably became nervous being the gentle man he was, and went out of tune many times.
yeh Mera Prem Patra is my favourite song . Kishore Kumar ji may be the greatest singer ever but Rafi sahab was also great
@bambaikababu2 :- I have a request. We should not compare one singer with another for this and that. Scales can be different. The same singer need not keep the same value throughout his career. Beyond these petty measuring scales, what we have to understand is the contribution of a singer to the enjoyment of the listeners' heart. From this standpoint, Rafi is perhaps the greatest singer of all times. You may also agree with me. Subramanian A, SBI< Palakkad
@bambaikababu2 bambai ke babu . . . aap apni identity chupaa ke hi rkhna wrna youtube k rafi saahab ke fans aapko bahoth maarenge . . . agar kisi aur ne nahi maara toh Ragi saahab ke har gaanay ki Kasam mai aapki gaand phodh dunga ;) ! ! !
wah jee wah ...kiyaa baat hai.....I love this song ....hats off to rafi ....undoubtedly the best in the business....his like shall never walk the earth again .....
u fool how dare u say that. ALLAHS VOICE cannot be heard and will be more beautiful than anything u have heard ever. ADMIT THAT YOU HAVE MADE A MISTAKE!
I don't think he meant it literally. We are all lovers of Rafi Saheb's music. Rafi Saheb was blessed with this voice, given to him by God. He was a very pious person, having performed Hajj 9 times, and was laid to rest on the last Friday of Ramadan. There's no doubt he was close to God. His nature, his humility, his actions...we all need to learn from him.
Thanks so much!!
suneriable 1 week ago in playlist Live concerts
Too good... he was never off key...
tasveeeren 5 months ago
My favourite song,very happy to hear it outside SJ BATON
DR SS CHANDRAKANTH
rahul45161 7 months ago
rafi sahab is master all r students :P
sunket1221 8 months ago
this is not out of tune, Rafi Saab just sang it different tothe original recording. Mate you should not make unqualified comments by calling a legend out of tune, In singing being called out of tune or out of taal is most insulting. This is just a sincere request. Thanks
lahore2 1 year ago 2
@bambaikababu2 bambai ke babu . . . aap apni identity chupaa ke hi rkhna wrna youtube k rafi saahab ke fans aapko bahoth maarenge . . . agar kisi aur ne nahi maara toh Ragi saahab ke har gaanay ki Kasam mai aapki gaand phodh dunga ;) ! ! !
exstreemcool 1 year ago 2
Wow,that is better then the original.rafi sahab is the only singer who can put that much emotions into a song which even kishore kumar could not.
TheKkverma 1 year ago
there are a few live versions of this song, i have a version which was recorded via the amp, and it sounds awesome.
safraznabi 1 year ago
@safraznabi Great! could you please share it with us. What other live numbers do you have?
tanweermian 1 year ago
Indian concert songs are normally not that good but Western singers use high tech equipment, hence giving studio quality sound.
RealMusicKing 1 year ago
please dont evaluate him, he is beyond any evaluations.. studio-recording is one thing and live singing is another thing... He can never go wrong... God bless him where ever he is today... :(
dryogeshmehta 1 year ago
You will find bambaikabubu2 criticizing Rafi everywhere. Ignore him, he is mentally sick and Youtube will ban him soon.
This song is sung at a lower scale, not out of tune.
dptxp 1 year ago
its shockin i got this song on a record ... i play bit when i Dj
lalmodesto 1 year ago
My favourite song. But he seems out of tune here. How come. Maybe this was recorded in his older age.
bambaikababu2 1 year ago
@bambaikababu2 - This was recorded from the audience at a concert in 1977. I personally don't think he's out of tune... the quality of the recording is not the greatest, but I believe it's the only live version of this song out there.
tanweermian 1 year ago
@tanweermian Thanks Tanveermian. Rafi sahab was a great singer and also a nice man. But towards the end of his career knowledgeable people say he sang out of tunes many times. With the emergence of Kishore Kumar Rafi sahab's star went down and as Naushad sahab said Rafi sahab probably became nervous being the gentle man he was, and went out of tune many times.
yeh Mera Prem Patra is my favourite song . Kishore Kumar ji may be the greatest singer ever but Rafi sahab was also great
bambaikababu2 1 year ago
@bambaikababu2 IJIJIJIOJOKJOKOKP
anwaramg 1 year ago
@bambaikababu2 :- I have a request. We should not compare one singer with another for this and that. Scales can be different. The same singer need not keep the same value throughout his career. Beyond these petty measuring scales, what we have to understand is the contribution of a singer to the enjoyment of the listeners' heart. From this standpoint, Rafi is perhaps the greatest singer of all times. You may also agree with me. Subramanian A, SBI< Palakkad
1956Subramanian 1 year ago
@bambaikababu2 yea um kishore kumar was not the best...because even he admitted that rafi was better than him.....
watsgood2000 1 year ago
@tanweermian , Just ignore ths bambaikababu2. His nonsense comments are there everywhere on Rafi songs on youtube.
He is undergoing mentally sick and undergoing treatment.
May God save him.
dptxp 7 months ago
@bambaikababu2 also it seems "out of tune" because he is not singing at the same soor as he sang it originally. thats why
watsgood2000 1 year ago
@bambaikababu2 bambai ke babu . . . aap apni identity chupaa ke hi rkhna wrna youtube k rafi saahab ke fans aapko bahoth maarenge . . . agar kisi aur ne nahi maara toh Ragi saahab ke har gaanay ki Kasam mai aapki gaand phodh dunga ;) ! ! !
exstreemcool 1 year ago
@bambaikababu2 , you here too with your stupid comments?
dptxp 5 months ago
M.Rafi and k.kumar = legends of India!
afgtunes 2 years ago 7
@afgtunes no only m. rafi. not kishore kumar....get it straight
watsgood2000 1 year ago
Complete voice in all respects. If God is ever heard, it will be in this kind of voice!
bi11iards 2 years ago 4
Such sweet honey flows from Rafi saab's voice. Unbelievable. Long live Rafi saab.
peacock009 2 years ago
Without the full orchestra of SANGAM -The charm and sweetness is lost. Tablas are very slow like gazals.
aceji 2 years ago
This is voice of all time Favourite RAFI Saheb,Same voice since 1946,No Change.
malikasadkhanawan 2 years ago
No Doubt, There is no comparison of present era`s singers with all time Famous Muhammed Rafi Saheb.
malikasadkhanawan 2 years ago
Beautiful voice....wy wy I love this song.
thanks for posting
afghan619 3 years ago 5
wah jee wah ...kiyaa baat hai.....I love this song ....hats off to rafi ....undoubtedly the best in the business....his like shall never walk the earth again .....
sheetaan 4 years ago 8
u all show deep love for rafi
punjabilahori 4 years ago 4
Mohammed Rafi Saheb - God's voice.
sheikhbhai 4 years ago
u fool how dare u say that. ALLAHS VOICE cannot be heard and will be more beautiful than anything u have heard ever. ADMIT THAT YOU HAVE MADE A MISTAKE!
tomie867 4 years ago
I don't think he meant it literally. We are all lovers of Rafi Saheb's music. Rafi Saheb was blessed with this voice, given to him by God. He was a very pious person, having performed Hajj 9 times, and was laid to rest on the last Friday of Ramadan. There's no doubt he was close to God. His nature, his humility, his actions...we all need to learn from him.
tanweermian 4 years ago
any one born with gift is to share it with the world.and he did just that.he did what he had to do.
bsnash007 3 years ago
how ignorant one can be?? anyway he said God's voice not specifically Allah's voice. God's voice is allowed to be heard in many religions.
erasmus96 3 years ago 5
Rafi Saheb - God's voice.
sheikhbhai 4 years ago
wah kya baat hai rafi saheb mein mane to yeh gaana kam kam se 100 baar suna kya koi baata sakta hai ki is particular gaane ko kahin se download karen
pnt8469 4 years ago 2
Wow i wonder how the video of this would've been!
elvisrafi 4 years ago 2
rafi sahab is the best.
aezazuh 4 years ago 2
Fantastic, I love Rafi saab.wah ji wah, kya baat hai Rafiji ki aur jino ne yeh song hamare saath share kiya unka bohat bohat shukriya.Thanks
santkk 4 years ago 2