While Piotr Beczala is today's best Duque, best Alfredo, best Edgardo and best Lenski, I am afraid it is too early for Puccini. He can not maintain the standard he has set with the previous roles. In La Boheme the tones are there but often too spread, unsopprted and without a line. Although he reaches the high C, singing like this will lead him to the same problems as Alagna and Villazon. Anyway I wish him all the best for Salzburg 2012.
he actually sounds like he's starting to develop some vocal problems here. That would be a tragedy. He is clearly has to be the potential to be one of the greatest. Being a tenor myself, I understand that it could've been just an off-night as well. he may have had a head cold too?
Wielki Polski Tenorze. Wielbiciel talentu Jana Kiepury składa hołd godnemu Następcy. Jest Pan geniuszem. Nie umiem przestać płakać ze wzruszenia po wysłuchaniu ukochanej arii. Jest Pan dumą Polski. Jest Pan Skarbem Narodowym. Klęczę w pokorze przed Wielkością.
This is strained singing and on the high C he almost cracked. The role is too heavy for him. He also cracked badly in Roméo and Juliette. He should stick to Mozart.
This has been flagged as spam show
While Piotr Beczala is today's best Duque, best Alfredo, best Edgardo and best Lenski, I am afraid it is too early for Puccini. He can not maintain the standard he has set with the previous roles. In La Boheme the tones are there but often too spread, unsopprted and without a line. Although he reaches the high C, singing like this will lead him to the same problems as Alagna and Villazon. Anyway I wish him all the best for Salzburg 2012.
David45NV1 2 months ago
Dla mnie wspaniale, Pan Piotr śpiewa zdania a nie mruczy czy wykrzykuje , brawo !
agromag1 3 months ago 2
I think it's all in where you sing a particular role and how you sing it....
Dymension 3 months ago
he actually sounds like he's starting to develop some vocal problems here. That would be a tragedy. He is clearly has to be the potential to be one of the greatest. Being a tenor myself, I understand that it could've been just an off-night as well. he may have had a head cold too?
StuEppy 3 months ago
Uwielbiam Pana Piotra !!!! To skandal, że w Polsce nie można go usłyszeć.... Mamy bardzo dziwnych dyrektorów teatrów !!!!!
Dla mnie osobiście najlepszym Rodolfo jest Jose Carreras :) Pan Piotr jest na drugim miejscu.
baja6211 4 months ago
Wielki Polski Tenorze. Wielbiciel talentu Jana Kiepury składa hołd godnemu Następcy. Jest Pan geniuszem. Nie umiem przestać płakać ze wzruszenia po wysłuchaniu ukochanej arii. Jest Pan dumą Polski. Jest Pan Skarbem Narodowym. Klęczę w pokorze przed Wielkością.
malford11 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Three towsend yeses. High C is perfect. Everything is perfect. He,s a real star. From my country. I had been waiting for him all my life.
malford11 4 months ago
This is strained singing and on the high C he almost cracked. The role is too heavy for him. He also cracked badly in Roméo and Juliette. He should stick to Mozart.
AfroPoli 5 months ago
Bravo P. Beczala!!!
Eknalb 6 months ago
Bravo Beczala!
dalferr 8 months ago
Rodolfo is traditionally a lyric tenor role, which is what Beczala is. I don't think it's too heavy for him.
DragTas 8 months ago
@DragTas
Beczala is a bit on the lighter lyric side. Rodolfo, especially in the third act, is borderline spinto.
Honken 5 months ago
...oh, the high C was a little unstable. In my opinion, Rodolfo is too heavy for him.
dg6da 8 months ago