In the midst of all this arguing, has anyone noticed how well they follow each other in this clip? It's completely effortless and intuitive. It reminds us all that for every film clip or photo there is of The Beatles, there's probably 10 undocumented hours of time spent playing, jamming, and developing themselves as musicians and songwriters. Sinfully talented? Obviously. But they also WORKED to be what they were. Wonderful clip...
@livininomaha A great book called The Outliers lays out a few reasons the author thinks The Beatles were as successful as they were. One of the main reasons he cited was "Hamburg." The band would play 12 hour gigs when they played there. That is where they really built their chops.
Paul learned to read music according to the book by Peter Brown. He just says he can't. He's such a smart guy it must have been very easy for him. I don't think the ability to read or write down music has made any difference for him, though. He had such success without it.
@minpinful Bullshit: the beatles could not read or write music Bullshit!
My grandfather was a classical bass player for latino groups on the radio back in the 60's... he never learned to read or write period- but he learned how to read and write music... its easier than learning how to read or write a language so im posisitive they picked SOMETHING up over the years....
Only paul looks like hes having fun. But thats only because he likes all the attention. George and Ringo nvr really liked being a Beatle near the end of there years as a band, so its only normal that they wouldnt like all that excited.
@ThatWasFred ya alright, my "Proof" kindof sucked, but still, u said None of them learned how to read or write music, and i kindof disagree with that, im not going to argue because i dont want to start an argument but i think the statement "none of the Beatles EVER learned how to read or write music" is quite incorrect.. thats just my opinion.
@minpinful I disagree, ive met a couple people with that opinion of Paul, but its not true at all, u dont even know him, ur just judging someone uve never met.......... I think ur wrong completely.
I heard that they couldn´t play their own songs because ...it could be far too expencive to the channel who shoot this one ..none of them 3 wanted to give money to the 3rd person who owns rights to the Beatles songs also...anyway they sounded as a Beatless... one less...
When I saw this back when Anthology was on TV for the first time I was dissapointed coz George didn't seem to be enjoying himself. I always got the impression that George never wanted to do Anthology in the first place (but for rumours he needed the money; and if that was his reason for participating, it seems to have been rewarding in that sense). I think George even said at the start something about doing the short version of this song. Paul looks like he is thoroughly enjoying himself.
@ThatWasFred The Beatles never learned to read or write music? Actually, ur wrong, thats a common myth, but that is not true at all. Heres proof: According to Guinness World Records, Paul McCartney is the "most successful musician and composer in popular music history". How could he hav ever acheived that if he still could not read or write music?? The Beatles could Definitely read and write music, its just a rumour that they couldn't.
@PauIsAlive Are you serious? That award doesn't mean he literally composes music like Beethoven or Mozart used to. It means he writes music in some shape or form. In this case, by coming up with how it should sound in his head, and playing that with instruments. He still wouldn't know what to do with a piece of sheet music if you put it in front of him.
Y'all realize they are performing the song like Elvis Presley did on his first Sun Records single released in July 1954. The A side was "That's Alright Mama"
And I don't know why people hunt for signs of tension between Paul and George. There aren't any. They made up about 10 years before this, you just have to listen to interviews from the 80s to know when they reunited.
If you look at younger clips of George he has the same expression. I don't think it's angry or embarrassed, just his expression - and it's just the facial hair that makes him look angry!
Why does everyone think George looks angry?He looks like he always does. I can't tell because the resolution is blurry for me, but I think he even smiles at one point.
Personal messages available in lennon harrison voice for a birthday anniversary etc... etc...I am a voice artist.Just joined as an uploader so I'll do it for free ...make someone's bday fun! Contact me
"They shared so much success together." What about the LOVE man! The love they shared with their fans and the rest of the world. That's pricesless. Whatever happened to the world since the Beatles split up.
I love that Paul doesn't know that his guitar is touching the guitar mic almost all the time
Lofgon 3 days ago
we all sadly know why john isn't there :/
turtlefanrecords 1 week ago
they tried to make it look like a band of four...
freebob3 2 weeks ago
What the hell is she wearing?
Zimnyification 3 weeks ago
Whoa, talk about bad hair days! They sound alright though. Always a strange distance between George & Paul...............
Davian67 1 month ago
John is not there, so it's not The Beatles
GustavoVillarBatera 2 months ago
Too bad John and Paul are dead
MyHairyBreasts 2 months ago
@MyHairyBreasts Too bad you're a retardad
GustavoVillarBatera 2 months ago 3
@GustavoVillarBatera Faul McCartney
MyHairyBreasts 2 months ago
@MyHairyBreasts oh shit ur also here?
Eleanor Rigby at Rio isnt enough for you?
Well anyway, you know hes alive, your just too proud for assuming that :)
GustavoVillarBatera 2 months ago
<3 .
LoryBEATLOVE 3 months ago
Dangit and I could have seen this on the ABC December 6 1996 when it was out to promote the Anthology.
asmith0251 4 months ago
Amazing musicians!
musicseverything 4 months ago
*-* Los extraño
xfernandiux 5 months ago
This cannot be The Beatles without John...
JammerZice 5 months ago
@JammerZice True. It's three talented guys who used to work together.
JeffersonDinedAlone 5 months ago
There's someone missing there :(
verilu97 6 months ago
In the midst of all this arguing, has anyone noticed how well they follow each other in this clip? It's completely effortless and intuitive. It reminds us all that for every film clip or photo there is of The Beatles, there's probably 10 undocumented hours of time spent playing, jamming, and developing themselves as musicians and songwriters. Sinfully talented? Obviously. But they also WORKED to be what they were. Wonderful clip...
livininomaha 7 months ago 2
@livininomaha A great book called The Outliers lays out a few reasons the author thinks The Beatles were as successful as they were. One of the main reasons he cited was "Hamburg." The band would play 12 hour gigs when they played there. That is where they really built their chops.
ShelterDogs 2 months ago
Paul learned to read music according to the book by Peter Brown. He just says he can't. He's such a smart guy it must have been very easy for him. I don't think the ability to read or write down music has made any difference for him, though. He had such success without it.
rocharua 7 months ago
Paul mccartney reminds me of an annoying uncle who taught me blues chords on guitar he was a pain in the arse but new his stuff
majjam556 7 months ago
No one make it better than Beatles.
jcpons1967 8 months ago
The only thing that would have made this better is if Kentucky's own Diane Sawyer had done the reporting.
Still miss ya George.
tommyrock69 1 year ago
George and Ringo was there...nothing force they for Anthology...DON'T IS PAUL THAT FORCING
ballaesmeralda 1 year ago
@minpinful Bullshit: the beatles could not read or write music Bullshit!
My grandfather was a classical bass player for latino groups on the radio back in the 60's... he never learned to read or write period- but he learned how to read and write music... its easier than learning how to read or write a language so im posisitive they picked SOMETHING up over the years....
mizmarymack 1 year ago
Only paul looks like hes having fun. But thats only because he likes all the attention. George and Ringo nvr really liked being a Beatle near the end of there years as a band, so its only normal that they wouldnt like all that excited.
Beatlelover7 1 year ago 2
@ThatWasFred ya alright, my "Proof" kindof sucked, but still, u said None of them learned how to read or write music, and i kindof disagree with that, im not going to argue because i dont want to start an argument but i think the statement "none of the Beatles EVER learned how to read or write music" is quite incorrect.. thats just my opinion.
PauIsAlive 1 year ago
A fine tribute to a great artist, Elvis, and a great state, Kentucky!
pds3939 1 year ago
ポールはしゃいでるwwかわいいwww
うざそうにしてるジョージもかわいいww
リンゴもかわいい。
lesucre1969 1 year ago
he's not angry!
biancabeatles 1 year ago
He people fighting, The Beatles didn't know how to read music. Except after a few years (I forget what year) Paul learned.
Toady373 1 year ago
@Toady373 No, Paul never learned how to read or write proper notation. He admitted as much in a 2007 interview for Nightline with Cynthia McFadden.
MegaObserver1 1 year ago
@minpinful I disagree, ive met a couple people with that opinion of Paul, but its not true at all, u dont even know him, ur just judging someone uve never met.......... I think ur wrong completely.
PauIsAlive 1 year ago
idiot
favd2002 1 year ago
I heard that they couldn´t play their own songs because ...it could be far too expencive to the channel who shoot this one ..none of them 3 wanted to give money to the 3rd person who owns rights to the Beatles songs also...anyway they sounded as a Beatless... one less...
SpaceGuitar69 1 year ago
Now pop in John and everything would've been perfect.
stephkills 1 year ago
not to make this sound sad, but if john HAD been there, yoko would have too -.- if it was JUST john then its ok :D
Hotchilipepprz4 1 year ago 2
Ringo looks good in this one. He looks really happy.
PeregrineTrousers 1 year ago 3
Fuck, I hate the eighties!
sgtpeppergreg 1 year ago
Fuck I hate the nineties!
JoshWattsBlues 1 year ago
There are many negative comments here on the tube that george has made against paul. He(george) looks pissed off at paul here.
cast390 2 years ago 6
I agree. He doesn't appear to be into it at all. Probably thinks Paul is hamming it up and trying to hog the spotlight.
Derby14 2 years ago 2
When I saw this back when Anthology was on TV for the first time I was dissapointed coz George didn't seem to be enjoying himself. I always got the impression that George never wanted to do Anthology in the first place (but for rumours he needed the money; and if that was his reason for participating, it seems to have been rewarding in that sense). I think George even said at the start something about doing the short version of this song. Paul looks like he is thoroughly enjoying himself.
August8th1969 2 years ago 2
i saw in a interview that george doesnt know how to write music he just memorizes what it sounds like now thats talent
tyblomberg27 2 years ago 5
That's what all the Beatles did. None of them ever learned to read or write music.
ThatWasFred 1 year ago 4
@ThatWasFred The Beatles never learned to read or write music? Actually, ur wrong, thats a common myth, but that is not true at all. Heres proof: According to Guinness World Records, Paul McCartney is the "most successful musician and composer in popular music history". How could he hav ever acheived that if he still could not read or write music?? The Beatles could Definitely read and write music, its just a rumour that they couldn't.
PauIsAlive 1 year ago
@PauIsAlive Are you serious? That award doesn't mean he literally composes music like Beethoven or Mozart used to. It means he writes music in some shape or form. In this case, by coming up with how it should sound in his head, and playing that with instruments. He still wouldn't know what to do with a piece of sheet music if you put it in front of him.
ThatWasFred 1 year ago
@PauIsAlive actually, i saw a video with Paul admitting that he can't read music at all.
noraacmw 1 year ago
@noraacmw I also read a quote somewhere of Paul admitting when hes buying strings he dont know the name of them
lfgubrs 1 year ago
Man, George and Paul sound great singing together.
eteachout 2 years ago 11
what year was this?
ilovenarutarded15 2 years ago
1994.
aarfeld 2 years ago
OOH GEORGE !!!!!!!!!!!!!
DrivingAngel 2 years ago 4
Y'all realize they are performing the song like Elvis Presley did on his first Sun Records single released in July 1954. The A side was "That's Alright Mama"
himself801 2 years ago 2
HAHAHA I remember that part of Anthology! It's in the special features disk!
I was telling everyone how much I wanted Ringo's drumsticks! They make the drumming sound so much cooler! :)
koolkalee123 2 years ago
joan looks hot
y4m5m5 2 years ago
doooooooooooo! ok, alright!
albertoisetan 2 years ago
And I don't know why people hunt for signs of tension between Paul and George. There aren't any. They made up about 10 years before this, you just have to listen to interviews from the 80s to know when they reunited.
msradx 2 years ago 2
If you look at younger clips of George he has the same expression. I don't think it's angry or embarrassed, just his expression - and it's just the facial hair that makes him look angry!
msradx 2 years ago 4
@msradx i agree...George nevere more happy in nothing exibhition
ballaesmeralda 1 year ago
my little george <3
amandathunstrom 2 years ago 6
Why does everyone think George looks angry?He looks like he always does. I can't tell because the resolution is blurry for me, but I think he even smiles at one point.
Nostawyn 2 years ago 47
This has been flagged as spam show
Personal messages available in lennon harrison voice for a birthday anniversary etc... etc...I am a voice artist.Just joined as an uploader so I'll do it for free ...make someone's bday fun! Contact me
laosandburma 2 years ago
I wonder why George is so embarrassed. He's hating every moment of it!
atlflut 2 years ago
now if only john was there....
LesPaulDude999 3 years ago 75
WHY DID HE HAVE TO BE KILLED!!!
sob sob
nafi12 2 years ago 8
I KNOW RIGHT!?
marcb27 2 years ago 3
KIILL Mark Chapman!
grade3turnsto4 2 years ago 6
now thats something i would do.
kevinfanofthebeatles 2 years ago
@LesPaulDude999 Dude, he IS there.
Just like he's there every time Paul or Ringo are on stage, same with George.
Beatleboy62 1 year ago
aw i love George
:]
he was so sweet
brittanytward 3 years ago 4
George was always like that with everyone....RIP George we miss you!
CinCin421 3 years ago
i noticed a lil, just a LIL tension between george and paul. ringo is just hanging back.
trev8200 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
george is pissed see paul he could sing just like u and john and much better and better lookin too!!!
bluesluvor65 3 years ago
"They shared so much success together." What about the LOVE man! The love they shared with their fans and the rest of the world. That's pricesless. Whatever happened to the world since the Beatles split up.
JimMorrisonsWidow 3 years ago 2
rockabilly yeah!!
oh and yes, George does not look happy at all. C'mon Georgie, was it really that bad?
blackspace007 3 years ago
George is hilarious -- he looks like he is in pain to be jamming with Paul McCartney.
daleroes 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Is Paul senile? Does he think that he was Elvis? I know that his songwriting talent virtually died in '77.
dakilla4life 3 years ago
what a pissant you are. note all the thumbs done you get. loser.
dougalmac54 3 years ago
I wonder why they didn't play a beatle song
1981omar 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
yeah cuz he didnt want to play with paul again!! lol
ilovethebeatles64 3 years ago
George looks less than thrilled...
ShockDoc 3 years ago 4
Any ideas why they never show all three together in the same shot? The camera could have panned out and got all three in.
canuheadca 3 years ago 2
the shadows of paul and george are shown in the ringo's shot wall anyway...
and not in this song, but other shots of the same anthology have them together in the same place.
correilloparaedwin 3 years ago
ringo had some funky hair that day
great song by the way
☺☻☺☻☺☻☺☻☺☻☺☻☺☻☺☻☺☻☺☻☺
RingoStarr911 4 years ago 2
great song
jptributer 4 years ago
que lindo
ahorayya 4 years ago
george should have sang lead paul doesnt realy have the voice for blues
250lespaul 4 years ago
Great song!
GOTHMIDNIGHTMERMAID 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
The Beatles should have been born in Kentucky!
zluvu4ever 5 years ago
LOL
a blue moon....
jonsol 5 years ago
thanks! thinking of linking funn y song haha
jonsol 5 years ago