Added: 3 years ago
From: gferdinandus6
Views: 149,758
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (241)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • 7 people are Justin Bieber fans...

  • ameiiiiii, há muito tempo eu buscava esse música.

  • My grandfather was a WW1 pilot and he died at 91 years old. The stories he told were unreal....

  • @NinaTheCat yes my Grandad too.

    he had a shell blow his ass cheek of at the Somme, he died in 73 he was French.

  • @raywilkes This song and Video bring tears to my Eyes, I'm 62. Stop war for gods sake.

  • I remember seeing Ringo in here at one time, I cant spot him... its been years since i last saw this video!

  • Its supposed to the infamous "Christmas Day truce?"

  • Don't mean to be the history freak...but all the uniforms/trenches/setting is all wonderfully accurate! Except for the fact that they are walking across no man's land with no weapons...but hey its a song about peace =)

  • i love this song, and this videoclip, reminds me my childhood.Paul is always great

  • love this song!

  • Im watching this on Christmas :)

  • saca lagrimas,lindo

  • Comment removed

  • malvinas tendria que ser asi,paz,convivio entre los pueblos,dios no tiene banderas,ni patria.

  • isn't this a real story form ww1?

  • @mizcs It is

  • makes me bal every time

  • gran canción y un gran video :D

  • Beautiful man. <3

  • This is the best music video ever, I love you Pol ((:

    War is over, if you want it

  • 6 war-mongering politicians watched this video...

  • merci love and peace , i love paul mc cartney and the beatles.......

  • This is really beautiful.

  • siempre será uno de los mejores vídeos. Desde Spain...viva MacCartney!!!

  • It's was nice for a while, it's pretty sad that you know they'll all die , killed by the same people they played football with

  • Épico! *-*

  • sir paul...what a classy human being. an historically accurate storyline to the vid and appropriately written musical score.

  • paul looks like sgt pepper

  • The most beautiful thing about this is that it's a true story...

  • @MCullenHightopp Yeah, christmas eve.. :)

  • I really love the part where they start playing football.

  • AMO DEMAIS SIR. PAUL MCC!!! LINDA A MÚSICA ME FAZ CHORAR DESDE CRIANÇA!

  • Sgt. Pepper

  • I think that the people that participated in those events, britsh, german, and frenchman, are a true example of peace and of mankind fraternity. Also I think Paul Mccartney is a true genius and had a great idea for this song. It is just awesome the combination between the significance of the song and the events that happen in the video.

    I SALUTE PAUL MCCARTNEY AND THE SOLDIERS OF THE CHRISTMAS TRUCE OF WWI!! WAY AHEAD OF OUR TIME!!!!

  • McCartney is a genius. This clip just remembered me the chilean movie "Mi Mejor Enemigo".

  • Excelente, una joya,

  • i wish America and the middle east could re-creat this video in real life!

  • great song i wish all war was like this the world  would be great. Hitler and lots other arseholes should see this and think, 'what am i making them do'

  • @Armydude655 in hitlers defence he fought in ww1 so he new, just sayin.

  • @HearneNWFootball64 haha i love when people play the devils advocate

  • KSNAIDSNIDHSAI T_T

  • love this song. very nice video as well.

  • I first saw this video in 1983 while in the US Navy. I HATE the military and

    war. Years later I get it. In fact, there was an actual cease fire between British

    and German troops in France for Xmas. This vid is based on fact. Sadly,

    in January 1915 both sides resumed the slaughter. I did not pay attention in

    '83 but now I get it. Macca is great.

  • Baldrick ...go and get me McCartney ,because your custard has the consistency of dog vomit.

  • Pauls Mind Is A Miraculous World Full Of History, Knowledge And Music. I'm Really Pleased He Has Used His Thoughts Of Two Tribes At War And Having A Truce At The Most Joyful Time Of The Year, Thank You God For Sir Paul McCartney.

  • 3 can't play the pipes of peace

  • Amazing song, as usual

  • awww paul is adorable

  • Paul's really such an amazing man.

  • TWO PAULS OMG! THIS MUST MEAN PAUL IS DEAD!!!! lol

  • Great Video and song!

  • cool of McCartney to take this real event & place it to music & video.

  • 2:31: OMG

  • @MaalePap I know, right? :)

  • Thanks for sharing this video, thanks Paul for making it.

    Next time some suits go on TV and tell us why we should make war - turn it off!!!!!! and put on some music. PEACE with Iran, PEACE with Korea - we're running out of excuses to kill each other. war is over.

  • Comment removed

  • @morebeauty This is what John was saying. War is over - if you want it.

  • he was a legend in the beetles he is a legend as a solo artist

  • @dawelshspartan *beatles not beetles

  • help me to learn how to play songs of joy instead of burn

  • Love this song! This video is soo sad! :(. Paul is awesome

  • makes me cry everytime :')

  • @thevintagekid69 You are not the only one! I am crying while hearing the song, and thinking, I always cry when I hear this song, always, since the first time I heard it.

  • @paliba1109 lmao xD

  • @thevintagekid69 - me too hon x

  • @thevintagekid69 It always makes me cry too.

  • that would be badass if i was in world war one and i was fighting and then just two paul mccartney twins came up and shot each other (not saying i want paul mccartney to die cuz i love him) but that would be cool as hell! :D

  • how old was paul in that video?

  • @NaziZombiefan82 well it came out around in the 80's so probably around to 40 years old

    PS love your username.

  • I love this song since I was a kid, as I grew up listening to it (dad is a huge fan of Paul), but I had never seen the videoclip. This is an amazing piece of art! I just can't understand why people say this is a lame record, or prefer Lady GaGa over it. This song is brilliant! *-*

  • Quite possibly my favourite piece of film in all of human history.

  • bellisimo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • very sad it is a shame that the 1914 truce at christmas did'nt last for the rest of the war God bless those brave souls of that conflict my heart goes out to them and my soul cries for their sacrafice

  • It's a shame that message has fallen out of fashion.

  • I LOVE this song! All of his eighties songs (all his others are great, too) are his best!

  • Those harmonies at the beginning and the end are the beat EVER

  • World is beautiful at peace and equalty. This song is inspiring.

  • bekieve it or not this video is more les based on real accounts during ww1 for one day on christams in one area the troops greeted each other and cleabrated the day... within 2 days they were shelling one another angin sadly high command on both sides did not like them coming together

  • my great grandad fought for that war and then for the WW2 he hided a family of jews in his cave to keep them away from the nazis thats why this song is important to me

  • que buena rola

  • This video as well as the song is really wonderful. there is so much to learn and adopt in this world. its a truth that we fight for defending our country but if we look deep into the reasons as to why the wars crop up, i attribute it solely to political issues. and we the commonplace people get succumbed to it. the pipes of peace is one such song which has touched my heart. i salute those who are there on the edges of our country who sacrifice themselves for our well being.

  • Cuánta nostalgia me trae este tema, y cuánto me gusta!

  • I love Paul say what you want about him I beleive he really isa blessed gift to all of us...hes touched SO many people around the world.

  • terrible sound compression

  • Como me gusta esta cancion Q_Q

  • Maravilhoso, Sir Paul!

  • "Casque D' Or " and "Mutter Museum " by peter coukis.wmv ...it's a 15min. Beatles Mockumentary i created

  • This is actually what happened in WW1. All it was , was a trench war. the trenches could be as close as 10 yards to 600 yard. World War 1 was kinda weird because the could talk to each other and make friends. There was only one time that they played soccer, shared wine and share food. This was during Christmas of 1916 when most of the people were kinda of sick of the war.

  • @tufsiinz actually it happend in 1914

  • Is the commander in German is Paul too? he look like Paul with a bear on :D

  • The first time I saw this video I cried my eyes out because at that point they realised there all human

  • Opppps! There goes a wiz bang!

  • Excellent video. Shows what man is capable of given the chance to see we have everything in common. ie family!!!!!!

  • beautiful song, bad video-clip

  • @Sandribsas actually it was a realy good clip btw im 10

  • the internet makes it possiable that all people all over the world can comment on things and there will be a language barrier for a lot of people as for me I admire them for trying . Just think what our language sounds to them and how it reads to them . People from other countrys' don't let others stop you from commenting .

  • Sush a big fan :):):):)

  • its weird people say religion= war

    But this kinda proved that wrong lol a long war put to stop by a religious holiday known as

    Christmas

  • quiza la mas perfecta union entre un canción y su video que vi en toda mi vida...espero poder ver en vivo a paul algún dia

  • maybe he/she does not understand the lyrics or is blind or else..?

  • Can anyobdy tell me the meaning of this video / song ?

  • (from Wikipedia) At Chobham Common, Surrey, a video was shot for "Pipes of Peace", depicting the famous 1914 Christmas truce between British and German troops. It portrays a British and a German soldier, both played by McCartney, who meet up in No Man's Land and exchange photos of their loved ones while other soldiers fraternise and play football. When a shell blast forces the two armies to retreat to their own trenches both men realise that they still have each-other's pictures.

  • You would need to be pretty retarded to not know what this song/video is about

  • Paul McCartney is a genius, a complete genius.

  • @marcel

    Maybe if you learned to use proper english and punctuation, people would be more likely to listen to you.

    And, are you saying something against Paul McCartney?

  • well

  • it is sad to think think that this was true it is sad to think that all that blood and guts was so unfair to all that fought in this war God bless them all

  • Wow this really hapenned and its my favorite song ever

  • Wish all the soldiers were like mccartney ;D awesome song!! Love it!

  • I love this<3

  • A bit sentimental, I know, but I a lovely song.

  • I am so happy that this incident ACTUALLY HAPPEND FOR REAL. Thats a prime example of how human beings should be....Defend your family and your house...But why fight for some asshole old man who's ordering 10000's of young men to fight to the death for HIS personal gain. Nobody condiers the pain the soldiers go through. The pain some suffer as they die slowly in a mud and rat infested hell hole. The pain they feel when they know they wont see their family again.... Every war is a tragedy.

  • Well said... As Pink Floyd (Waters) said... "Forward he cried, from the rear, and the front rank died..." It's a nice song and striking video.

  • @LegendOfJomtein I completely agree. Unfortunately, the greater tragedy is that war will never cease. At least not in our lifetimes.

  • @LegendOfJomtein - there were many leaders who considered the pain of the soldiers he sent to fight. All you simply need to is read some writing of Abraham Lincoln during the Civil War. He felt the pain of every fallen soldier.

  • Comment removed

  • @LegendOfJomtein I couldn't have said it better myself. Peace.

  • @LegendOfJomtein yep, they didnt even want to fight each other , i think it lasted for 3 days with no gun fire. the other thing is many german soldiers in ww1 were jews. war sucks.

  • @dontpanicblink I believe it lasted for up to 2 weeks in some parts, they had to be ordered back to fight in the end.Pity the soldiers didn't turn their guns on the cowards miles behind the front line on either side.

  • @stainlesssteelprat you cant say the English or France people were cowards those generals are the ones who defeated Germany an made the world this way,is they those generals didnt sent those soldiers you maybe wouldn't excist or you didnt have a dad

    Rip to all people who died in war,.

  • @xagas4 I didn't say the soldiers who fought were Cowards.The stuffed shirts far far away from any danger where the Cowards.I don't know if you have researched any of this stuff on the Tube but it seems that Wars are a good way for the "elites" to get what they want,make a shedload of money and thin out the herd a bit so their are more resourses for them to enjoy. Oh,by the way,assassins creed 1 is brilliant too.just a bit to much time out of the animus.Give it a GOOO!!!

  • @stainlesssteelprat

    i think we have the same opinion

  • @xagas4 Bellisimo

  • @LegendOfJomtein well put i agree it was a tragedy when you think of all those families who got news that their son or brother or father etc would not be coming home it was a shame that the match on xmas day did'nt settle the end of that bloody war

  • @LegendOfJomtein very well said my sentiments exactly god bless

  • @LegendOfJomtein merry christmas to you

    and peace on earth.

    uk/usaboy.

  • Good song, great video. Whoever they hired as the authenticity guy really knew his stuff.

  • the Germans simply examined the penis to identity all jewish subversives for either deportation or the labor camps. Americans then soon began to circumcise all male infants after the jews tricked them with bogus magazine articles. The jews schemed to remain hidden amongst other mutilated males in case Americans also turned against jewish supremacism. Untold millions of defenseless American infants would have been spared penis mutilation had Hitler defeated worldwide jewish supremacism.

  • worderfull!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­+5

  • people are in such a situation now when all they think of is screwing each-other in a well known manner of greed. people out there or here knows that if they see a person that they don't know they will walk passed the person as if he/she doesn't exist. years ago you couldn't help but say hello to a new face even if you didn't know them. unfortunatly people think of themselves as superior to other people and thats fucked.

  • dont no why but the change of melody at 1:52 is the best bit of the song 4 me :S LOVE MACCA!!!

  • Loved this music video as a kid, really poignant stuff, glad its on Youtube. Thank you.

  • i dont know why people are argueing about when the christmas truce ended, your all right (well most of you) the trench systems on the western front stretched 600 miles from the english channel to the swiss border, there was numerous truce's in some areas the truce only lasted 1 day in others the truce lasted until january 1st 1915

  • politicts and people start wars, but send young men out to fight in them

  • Wars are pushed by weapon manufactures or political leaders who invest in things such as weapons,oil. Everytime a war starts two things should happen. 1. Weapon Manufactures profit should be limited. 2. The solders should vote on both sides weather or not they should go to war.

    Not some asshole sitting in a sit way high up who will never pick up a gun and shoot it, but just stand there and count his profit. WW1 and WW2 could have been avioded just like every other war.

  • One of the best Christmas songs ever!

  • i agree with awynner36o

  • it is hard to believe this actually happend god bless those brave souls

  • this is a true story that they actually played football on December football :) it shows that they didn't really hate each other

  • the germans laughed at the scots, who had on their kilts...... they drank beer, shared food, the catholics on both sides had mass together and had a good time. proof that wars are b/n politicians and not people.

  • Jawoll, Frieden Bruder ;O) Yes, peace brother. Now 100 years later our country´s life for a long time in peace. War is only a suggestion that politician told us. So let´s hope that we´ll more wiser than our grandparents. No more wars!Power to the people. Love & Peace from Germany!!!

  • schwester, not bruder :). i think that europeans finally had enough of war. i mean for the most part you guys spent the better part of recorded time, stomping all over the place, killing each other. after ww2, y'all basically said 'enough'. the stuff in the former yugoslavia not withstanding. and in america, we sit here, kind of set apart and separated. we haven't really had but two wars on our own soil. so maybe we don't get it. peace.

  • I love this video!! Paul rocks!!

  • LOVEEEEEEEEEEEE IT!!!! :33333333.

  • one of the best songs ever

  • God bless those brave souls in the great war on all sides

  • I did not realise Paul had a twin brother who fought againest us in the war, it must of been wierd for them both

  • LMFAO

    It's weird enough for US, though - what IS that thing living on Paul's twin's lip? Is it a cat or a moustache?!

  • Thank god Michael Jackson wasn't the German!

  • It's not meant to be his twin brother - it's giving the message that the men on each side weren't that different.

  • es una buena cancion parala union en el mundo yo soy de mexico y soy gran admirador y fan de paul

  • Gosto muito dessa canção, e o vídeo que relembra a Trégua de Natal de 1914 é muito bem feito.

  • paul mccarney es el mejorr!!!!!

    nada ni nadie lo va a superarr!!!!

    jamass!!!!!

  • One of my favourite Sir Paul songs.

    The video does make you think about those sad times.

    Great song and very god and simple lyrics,

  • Such a classic, love it <3

  • 0.10. laser beam noise when the camera looks at the machine gun. love it. xx

  • Based on a true story!

  • Отличная песьня и клип неплох. Надо бы фильм посмотреть про эти события.

  • LOVE IT!

  • the christams truce

  • хороший чувак павел макарыч

  • muy bueno

  • Beautiful Song.

  • Paul McCartney is a legend

  • nice song!!!

  • Hahahahahahahahahahahaha! 2PAC! HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA­HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH!­

  • hes so sexy ;)

  • gooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­od!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

  • One of the best things solo McCartney ever did

  • This video and song have a very powerful message.

  • This is a nice song : )

  • Great song,Terrific video...