I never understand why ppl look up music of artist they hate. Get a life I don't like keshia but I am not going to listen to her music to bash her. MOstly because her "music" causes my skin to burn. ethier way its silly
@rangu66, no, not hateful, just don't like her and was saying so. She sounds better though since her voice changed after her nodule problem. Before she sounded like a demented munchkin from The Wizard of Oz.
Wow her voice has gotten richer. I liked it before in a strange ugly duckling/Neil Young kind of way, but now it's swan-like...early Joni Mitchell, but more character. I imagine her evolving even more over time.
Alright, I will finally admit. I never thought I would say this: Joanna Newsom is definitely an acquired taste. When I first heard her I was sort of shocked and honestly thought it was a joke. Then as I listened and listened, I just listened. She really is a great artist. Just wow. This song I was listening to it, and I did not even hear the vocals. I heard the actual -music-. It is just beautiful. Seriously beautiful.
@buttsuckable he has and it's not her. Of course I take your moniker into consideration as I comment here and that explains a lot. She does sound a little better after the nodule problem but truly she was crap before then. Good harpist though.
When I first started going to youtube videos to hear her music I was suprised how many people could not stand her voice. I think her voice is soulful and the lyrics are the best around for a modern artist, they tell a story like a folklore. I love her music.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
@discoheaven897 everyone has a right to their opinions, not just her fans. I thinks shes hideous. Especially that stupid accent she feigns and that Joe Cocker when she's performing She looks like she's having fits. This song isn't as bad as most of her songs but all in all, she sucks. She can play but can't sing for shit.
@Alilrebelchick Yes, you can have your opinions, but why do you want to express them like this? Calling a woman ugly and dragging people with disabilities and medical conitions into it (with that "fits" comment.) She's an unusual performer, so I have no expectation that someone will just necessarily like her-- and do not feel surprised and offended to hear it when they do not. But its not necessary to start spreading hate, that certainly is not what Joanna is trying to do.
@leisurelydinner it's so sad that people have to be negative because they're jealous of beauty and true art... she uses her real voice and her harp rather than synthesizers and provocation and/or seduction to promote happiness
i only just realised the album version isn't piano after reading some of the bitching on here haha, i love this version as much as the live performances, i love the production on this album
@nblumer ... have you never listened to her music before??? just because these shitty music reviewers say shes singing about fucking milk doesnt mean its accurate. shes always tackled themes that are beyond most people to even think about.
This one has its charms! Emphasizes the lyrics much more also, which are brilliant. if you notice it used to be she took her "heart to task" and now it's "god to task". And the part where she says "all day you hassle me" now sounds positively heavenly.
My cat is laying in my lap and she can hear it through the headphones. She keeps cocking her head up curiously. Something about Joanna's voice because she never does that for other songs.
Marry me, Joanna?
tabsnogs 5 days ago in playlist preferidas
lovely,.
futuristfood 3 months ago
I searched for "keep on whooping it up", and this was the top pick. Have a good day all!
bigjojo 3 months ago
I never understand why ppl look up music of artist they hate. Get a life I don't like keshia but I am not going to listen to her music to bash her. MOstly because her "music" causes my skin to burn. ethier way its silly
talkindurinthemovie 6 months ago 2
Joanna is a treasure amd she has a loyal fanbase, so I think she is used to the doubters.....their loss lol :)
husker666 6 months ago 4
lovely pic of jo. but most pics of her are.
wonspec 9 months ago in playlist jo new new
"blink once if god, twice if no god!"
this moment in the song is so strangely thrilling.
madkaye 9 months ago
@madkaye no one can keep from blinking more than once.
jumpyduck 8 months ago
@rangu66, no, not hateful, just don't like her and was saying so. She sounds better though since her voice changed after her nodule problem. Before she sounded like a demented munchkin from The Wizard of Oz.
Alilrebelchick 10 months ago
curled round the bottom rung.
doesn’t anybody want you?
well, come on, darlin.
I could use someone like you around.
mjcee93 11 months ago
Wow her voice has gotten richer. I liked it before in a strange ugly duckling/Neil Young kind of way, but now it's swan-like...early Joni Mitchell, but more character. I imagine her evolving even more over time.
jdbauer36 11 months ago
wow her voice is getting so goo di love her
jahstp 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Just one comment Beautiful!!!
eastofthemoon 1 year ago
Alright, I will finally admit. I never thought I would say this: Joanna Newsom is definitely an acquired taste. When I first heard her I was sort of shocked and honestly thought it was a joke. Then as I listened and listened, I just listened. She really is a great artist. Just wow. This song I was listening to it, and I did not even hear the vocals. I heard the actual -music-. It is just beautiful. Seriously beautiful.
teddybeyr 1 year ago 8
Could God create a more beautiful art / artist, i think not
buttsuckable 1 year ago 5
@buttsuckable he has and it's not her. Of course I take your moniker into consideration as I comment here and that explains a lot. She does sound a little better after the nodule problem but truly she was crap before then. Good harpist though.
Alilrebelchick 10 months ago
03:27 WOW
noradosmith 1 year ago 2
@noradosmith
3.27 to 4.00 is simply put, perfection.
Hauntingly beautiful.
kingoftheshelters 1 year ago
@kingoftheshelters nightmarish is more like it
Alilrebelchick 10 months ago
When I first started going to youtube videos to hear her music I was suprised how many people could not stand her voice. I think her voice is soulful and the lyrics are the best around for a modern artist, they tell a story like a folklore. I love her music.
KingdomComeToonight 1 year ago 4
rubBBBBiiiiiiishhhhhhhhHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
underc0n 1 year ago
I so agree undercon, lol.
Alilrebelchick 10 months ago
Somebody keep penises away from this genius's vagina.
Joanna: do you cry through this song on stage? No, you don't. It's not bad, but it's not genius.
opinioninflicting 1 year ago
@opinioninflicting It is genius.
mikeyyy3 1 year ago
@mikeyyy3 It's okay. It's like a Paul McCartney album from 1990 compared to "Hey Jude."
opinioninflicting 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
god, she sounds awful
leisurelydinner 1 year ago
@leisurelydinner If you don't like it then don't listen to it. There are some actual Joanna fans on here so just GTFO. Okay?
discoheaven897 1 year ago 34
@discoheaven897
It's his/her right to comment Joanna's Songs on Youtube. That's wath this site is for. ;)
Traeumeer 1 year ago
@leisurelydinner ur an ass how bout u dont listen to her
lilyspence 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@discoheaven897 everyone has a right to their opinions, not just her fans. I thinks shes hideous. Especially that stupid accent she feigns and that Joe Cocker when she's performing She looks like she's having fits. This song isn't as bad as most of her songs but all in all, she sucks. She can play but can't sing for shit.
Alilrebelchick 1 year ago
@Alilrebelchick See Teddybeyrs comment. It's clear the only reason you posted that is because you're hateful
rangu66 10 months ago
@Alilrebelchick Yes, you can have your opinions, but why do you want to express them like this? Calling a woman ugly and dragging people with disabilities and medical conitions into it (with that "fits" comment.) She's an unusual performer, so I have no expectation that someone will just necessarily like her-- and do not feel surprised and offended to hear it when they do not. But its not necessary to start spreading hate, that certainly is not what Joanna is trying to do.
bendabledoll 4 months ago
@discoheaven897 im only here cuz im tryina like her...reason? she's dating Andy Samberg.
welshgirlism 7 months ago
@leisurelydinner it's so sad that people have to be negative because they're jealous of beauty and true art... she uses her real voice and her harp rather than synthesizers and provocation and/or seduction to promote happiness
melovernotafighter23 1 year ago 23
@melovernotafighter23 They are not jealous. They just don't have the capacity to understand Newsom's beauty.
RickesRives 4 months ago 2
@leisurelydinner Excuse me sir? Go choke on your own Saliva :)
kay thanks bye <3
wylandy 1 year ago
@leisurelydinner how bout this u sound awful
lilyspence 1 year ago
@leisurelydinner
geez, you suck.
NIMRODakaNIMROD 1 year ago
Wow her voice really changed. Not bad though.
NutButt12345678910 1 year ago
6:33
I must find that shirt
shitakeshiset 1 year ago
i only just realised the album version isn't piano after reading some of the bitching on here haha, i love this version as much as the live performances, i love the production on this album
xSecretChordx 1 year ago
'Beautiful'. ... .thanx Joanna
spidemaker 1 year ago
Anyone else notice that her lyrics and voice are getting maturer?
nblumer 1 year ago
@nblumer ... have you never listened to her music before??? just because these shitty music reviewers say shes singing about fucking milk doesnt mean its accurate. shes always tackled themes that are beyond most people to even think about.
serenartheterrible 1 year ago
@nblumer Yep. I think it's a deliberate evolution actually.
DisembowelMe 1 year ago
I adore the dress she's wearing.
pippacummings 1 year ago 2
must get this album!
madisonn90 1 year ago
I'm so glad she recorded this onto an album. I love this song of hers.
AnElephantThatPaints 1 year ago
shoulda stuck to the upbeat piano version
philipsmog 2 years ago
This one has its charms! Emphasizes the lyrics much more also, which are brilliant. if you notice it used to be she took her "heart to task" and now it's "god to task". And the part where she says "all day you hassle me" now sounds positively heavenly.
purpleandgreen 2 years ago
@philipsmog I know!, the album version: not so great!
Chamako87 1 year ago
yes, yes, and more yes.
redfacedpresident2 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Joanna likes it when I bounce myy balls of her chin .
kustomchainwerks 2 years ago
wow your mother sure taught you well and to respect women...
jmedranomusic 2 years ago
kind of roger water-ish. you kind of have to have listened to every lyric he ever made a 1000 times to make the connection. a fine tune.
greatsea 2 years ago
Her voice sounds so beautiful...different sound, then her older stuff but just as good.
rainjustice38 2 years ago
Comment removed
fosterni 2 years ago
Sort of shaggy-dog songs...
brightcloudful 2 years ago
I can't wait to get this album!
Megera85 2 years ago
My cat is laying in my lap and she can hear it through the headphones. She keeps cocking her head up curiously. Something about Joanna's voice because she never does that for other songs.
greatsea 2 years ago
@greatsea
My mum heard me listening to an album of Joanna's and told me it sounded like caterwauling. :)
aesthete0 1 year ago
Absolutely beautiful, it tugs at my heart.
marionhammer 2 years ago