Added: 4 years ago
From: amir622000
Views: 13,192
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (85)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I think Dogs is #1

  • its great to love a band where they have so many great song that you forget a few, then you remember them and they sound like ur hearing them for the first time :D

  • hmm, i forgot about the song Time, i should listen to it more often :)

  • time belongs in the top 2

  • time is the first pink floyd solo that i learned to play its easy and sounds EPIC and that doesnt happen often

  • Time belongs in the top 5

  • 2 Motherfuckers like Justin Bieber

  • @luckyx95 do not mention him!

  • OKAY THIS TOP 15 IS ALL OUT OF WACK KEEP YOUR DAY JOB BUDDY

  • Dogs should be in a better position

  • i have met this legend!!!!

  • @mattaystig no way...tell me about it was he awesome?

  • @HinVids it was at a circus in my home town! he was standing behind me in the hot dog que! i turned round and had to turn round again! i just showed him my floyd tattoo and said i am your biggest fan and asked for a photo...(PROFILE PIC)... and shook his hand!!!! THEE GREATEST DAY OF MY LIFE!!! =)

  • @mattaystig dude holy fucking shit can u wack me off with the hand u shook his hand with? thats incredible hes my idol i love david man your so lucky!

  • i came

  • Where's Money solo at? Hard to put Fletcher before Money dude...

  • If you're gonna show dogs. you gotta show the last guitar solo of the song... it's INSANE!!!! My personal favorite..... the outro on Pigs is also stupendous!

  • This makes me want to throw away my guitar.

  • Dogs are the best, 17 minutes of great music!

  • @Sayajincof So true. One of the most fantastic songs I've ever heard.

  • David is the one that can make his guitar sing, with an otherworld felling. Hell, I love this guy.

  • David Gilmour is without a doubt in the top five greatest of all time, and my personal favorite.

    who is seriously better in the opinion of you guys? and don't just name off shred wankers who didn't innovate jack shit. I'm thinking what, Hendrix, Clapton, maybe, MAYBE Page, possibly Santana...that's about it..

  • @TheElusiveBirdMan Gilmour ftw ;)

  • gilmour is amazing

  • The guitar wizard of all time. Unique style and an unbelievable emotion in his playing only matched by Andy Latimer from Camel.

    I adore Dave and I hope to see him in concert soon (my ultimate dream)

  • For guitar solos, david is GOD. he may not have had the improv skills that the late great Hendrix and Allman were blessed with, but he creates such an incredible atmosphere with his guitar. I'd love to hear his take on the Stairway to Heaven solo!

  • It's hard to put Gilmour's solos in order since they're all so absolutely breathtaking.

  • Mother would be my number 5

  • Time number 14 ??

    I think time is as good as comfortably numb!

  • Yeah i agree

  • Raise my Rent should be in the top 10. It was on his solo albulm "David Gilmour 1978"

  • it must be a jolking .

  • The Fletcher Memorial Home

  • wtf dogs 13? thats in my top 5 lol

  • i like all of his music with pink floyd......

    the whole collection cost me like 100.00 bucks and brand new no scratches....i got it at virgins store..

    i made copies and saved the originals wer they wont be wrecked....

    good list man....

  • Good list. I disagree with many choices but who cares, they're all amazing in their own way.

    I'm very surprised Poles Apart didn't make your top15. I think you should go back and listen to that last 2minutes and appreciate the beauty and the emotion of that solo.

  • dogs is full of passion, should be higher up, still next to mother

  • Time 14 !!!

    jajajjajajaja

    is a joke ?

  • Chill you guys - he puts a note up during "Time" and says it's in his Top 3. Anyone able to read anymore?

  • you do not know good music if time is that low

  • time should definitely be higher

  • i think mother should be higher

  • nice list so far, but i really think it's atrocious (spelling?) that time is only 15.

  • Good job. I heartily disagree with the rankings of many songs, but who cares, I love the stream of Gilmour guitaring

  • Pink Floyd wrote "Dogs".

  • Comfortably Numb first, then High hopes or Time..

  • i think time is number one...it sounds like a gospel choir singer...most original solo of all time

  • i like his solo from the fletcher memorial home

  • Agree. What a sound.

  • Agree, Gilmour's solos are so touching, it does feel he's in the room with you. Good list.

  • Good list. But i think that time is one of the best

  • Me too

  • The dogs solo has few notes but the tone and bends just cut through you! Bst guitarist ever!!

  • Gilmour has no peer

  • Time is the best, Echoes second!

  • Gilmour has been an inspiration to me for a while. I have never heard such passion in a guitar than any other artist. It's going to be so sad when he passes away. Lets hope that, thats not too soon :)

  • He would change your life without you realizing it , David Gilmour is the name I say when I wake up , god listens to him :)

    I'd lose anything but my ability to hear , because David exist..

  • Gilmour Is The greatest!!!!

  • David Gilmour is the reason i started playing guitar in 1982. I learned to mimick him pretty well in our own music with double and tripple fret bends, sometimes up a fifth. but to do it with his emotion is hard to recapture or duplicate. Gilmour to me is the best and always brings out my emotions in music better than any other guitarist. And yes his solos are harder to hit than alot of page/clapton/hendrix/VH solos where they just play there fastest and there riffs. There is not as much emotion

  • Indeed my friend...There is much passion in Gilmour's solo's..so much soul.One can actually feel something vibrating inside,when listening to him.He plays with enormous emotion,and that makes him the best guitarist from the planet...

  • @ltcurry Hendrix's solos are full of emotion.

  • one of the greeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeaaaaaaaa­aaaaaaatest guitarist to have walked this planet longlive gilmour without him pinkfloyd would have been nothing!!!

  • I'll probably kill myself when Gilmour dies...

    :(

  • @infidel93 IF he dies ;) 

  • @infidel93 gods cant die unless of course thor was there but even then david would just make his ears melt xD

  • @infidel93 We'll learn Harakiri together, I guess :(

  • Time should be at like the top 5!!!! sooooo much felling in that solo...

  • Agreed. Watch my video =) 3#

    Just search for, Pink floyd, top 8 solos

  • David Gilmour's solos may not be technically complex, but the feeling in it is so hard to capture while playing them, and while listening to them you can almost feel his presence in the room. Thats why I think he's so great.

  • I couldn't have said it better!

  • @amir622000: amen my brother!

  • I totally agree about how powerful his solos are.

    However, I think there is actually quite a bit of technique needed in order to play them correctly and sound good. The amount of bends and re-bends Gilmour does is insane. To have that control like he has takes a certain amount of effort needed to hit every note on its correct pitch every time.

    I'm personally having a harder time playing some of his solos than the guitar solos of his peers.

  • Time should have been higher up i think...

  • not just guitar, PINKFLOYD WAS THE GREATEST BAND OF ALL TIME, minds like theres only come together every 2000 years

  • I absolutely agree with you my friend, It was only the collection of four of them that made this incredible band. Without any of them, pink Floyd could not be pink Floyd!

  • @amir622000

    urmm actually 5 xD

  • @musicdied In that case I'm super pumped for like, 3970.

  • @musicdied Agreed my friend. It's a shame they couldn't realize that without Gilmour, the band had no soul, but without Waters, it had no mind. Together they made history.

  • all you guys are like my best friends. I mean this video literally brought me to tears. He is the greatest guitarist that will ever walk this planet!!!!

  • David gilmour is my hero., my jesus

  • mine 2 ;)!

  • Marooned = the best.

  • the time solo should be at least #1

  • No Comfortably Numb is still a bit better...

    #2 though...

  • That is, #14.

  • It's not in the order. If it was in order, Time solo would be second for me! :)

  • I don't get how the Time solo is only #15. It doesn't get better. This solo is beautifully constructed, but then again the same could be said of the rest!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more