I don't care of the goyophobics , it's a beautiful song with beautiful lyrics and fuck Vatican II and racist talmud. Long live to the real Catholicism !
My Jesus, how can anyone not he so overwhelmed that they could say some of the things that are read here. I'm sure that I will receive some responses. It makes me very sad.
@pdobbing Don't be an anachronist. This music, with its antisemitism, is just a fruit of its time... You can't judge people of other eras with the ideas of your own age. If u were born in the Middle Ages or in Nazi Germany, you would probably be antisemite too.
@Anakay I don't care how 'antisemitic' this is, because it's beautiful music...I do however think that we can and should judge past cultures and attitudes...yes, some, like the Indian civilizations and tribes Europeans came across, were just less advanced so I don't think you can really judge of condemn their attitude, as they didn't know any better...but in areas were paganism and rationality triumphed for centuries, the bigoted Christian worldview is repulsive and should be attacked
They didn't have castrati in late 12th/early 13th Century France, when Perotin would have written this. The church castrato was "invented" in Italy, some 200 years later.
If Perotin's "Beata Viscera" wasn't sung by an (intact!) male falsettist, it would have been sung by an adult male with a non-falsetto voice, like a tenor.
Comment removed
bigfootedfred 6 days ago
I don't care of the goyophobics , it's a beautiful song with beautiful lyrics and fuck Vatican II and racist talmud. Long live to the real Catholicism !
apostatdurock 1 week ago
I wish the top comment didn't inform everyone that it was anti semetic, sort of ruins it.
Aeon135 1 month ago
Amazing voice.
tarkovskychild 2 months ago
My Jesus, how can anyone not he so overwhelmed that they could say some of the things that are read here. I'm sure that I will receive some responses. It makes me very sad.
goodcatholicboy 4 months ago
beautiful, sounds like an angel :)
angellinegirl 5 months ago
I've found it about this : toddtarantino(dot)com/hum/beataviscera : )
Ophelide 6 months ago
Comment removed
Ophelide 6 months ago
Lindo!
LOBOtranslucere 8 months ago
what recording is this??
gamgagirl 9 months ago
this was the amazingst music i ever enjoied .... nothing else^^
kokoshoden 11 months ago
How would you feel about a beautiful setting of a few unintelligible lines from Hitler's 'Mein Kampf'?
pdobbing 1 year ago
@pdobbing Gb2Israel, stupid self-righteous Yid.
andrewMLhero 6 months ago
For me the beauty is tarnished by the blatant anti-Semitism ('cor gerens conscium
delicet funebris' etc etc) that runs through the whole poem. Pity since the setting is truly gorgeous.
pdobbing 1 year ago
@pdobbing since I can neither read or write latin I can't say it bothers me any...
mightyafrowhitey 1 year ago
@pdobbing Don't be an anachronist. This music, with its antisemitism, is just a fruit of its time... You can't judge people of other eras with the ideas of your own age. If u were born in the Middle Ages or in Nazi Germany, you would probably be antisemite too.
Anakay 11 months ago 2
@Anakay I don't care how 'antisemitic' this is, because it's beautiful music...I do however think that we can and should judge past cultures and attitudes...yes, some, like the Indian civilizations and tribes Europeans came across, were just less advanced so I don't think you can really judge of condemn their attitude, as they didn't know any better...but in areas were paganism and rationality triumphed for centuries, the bigoted Christian worldview is repulsive and should be attacked
SROCeallaigh 4 months ago
@pdobbing So tell us how the entire poem is anti-semitic, smart boy.
jwz965 5 months ago
Stupenda!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Neosdedo 1 year ago
Stupenda!!
Neosdedo 1 year ago
OMG! I love this music ♥
IJustTrySomeThing 1 year ago
obviously in convents it would have been sung by a woman or by women.
mwheape 1 year ago
Meravigliosa!!!
TheAngelDark17 2 years ago
Re: castrati - they used young boys too!
sonicide1 2 years ago 4
would this song have orinally been performed by a male or a female?
rogermoore27 2 years ago
Probably a castrato
Jayne1286 2 years ago
Thanks for that. I just read what a castrato was. My gosh!
rogermoore27 2 years ago
They didn't have castrati in late 12th/early 13th Century France, when Perotin would have written this. The church castrato was "invented" in Italy, some 200 years later.
If Perotin's "Beata Viscera" wasn't sung by an (intact!) male falsettist, it would have been sung by an adult male with a non-falsetto voice, like a tenor.
ftumschk 2 years ago
ohh nice much like the contemporary hymn and latin rhyme.
saprissa18 2 years ago
Comment removed
BarbaraPloyer333 3 years ago