Added: 4 years ago
From: celticyodels
Views: 22,065
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (184)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • qué falta de respeto es esta!!! estaba feliz escuchando a mi Tarja y de un momento a otro sale el video de esta seudo-metalera !!!

  • 2:14 ...a video...within a video.  Leo would be proud.

  • I don't care if Anette was the new singer or if people wanted Tarja back.. but Nightwish during the end of 2007 was an amazing band to see. Idk... there was an aura of magic in their shows during that small era <3

  • being there so many womans that have opera voice just like tarja i dont get why did the pick this girl that doesnt fit with this

  • i hate her

  • nah nah nah... una voz muyyy chillona para mi gusta... NO DAAAA!!!!...

    TARJA!!!♥

  • ieuw ieuw ieuw ieuw ieuw ieuw ieuw

    i've got to listen to tarja all day now to get this out of my system

  • She should not even attempt these songs. Her voice does not have the range or power, too whiney.

  • anette was sweet with black hair`:| my opinion :|

  • @MinnieMouse847

    She's gone back now... Check out her blog... It's a shame she added that horrible purple thingy on the side again though...

  • Annette always starts off this song facing Tuomas. Is she acting like she loves him like the lyrics say?

  • It's his favourite song, and she knows that, so she sings to him. :)

  • Anette is ok, but this is not Nightwish anymore :<

  • annete haters better listen to tarja single or watsoever......bcoz u cant change the fact that she is the vocalist now....so..all anette haters...piss off...

  • basura

  • anette haters make me laugh so hard

    get a life!

  • she sings like my little sister singing hannah montana's songs

  • Made my day

  • She sucks when she sings the old songs, her voice doesn't fit that style of music at all. They should just play the songs they made with her and come up with a new band name.

  • This is probably the best recording of Anette singing "Ever Dream". Just incredible.

  • I think this is one of her best early

    concerts period.

    All the songs they did she sang them

    so amazingly. Sleeping Sun was

    really good too!

    She has a beautiful voice.

  • LovingLife411, This was her first real tour, so at the very beginning, her voice was real good, but after a show almost every day, her voice started going out. in 2009, the tour wasn't as heavy, so her voice got better.

    Did you see her 2009 Meadows of Heaven? I know it's not an old song, but compare it to a 2008 Meadows of Heaven. :)

    If they don't want to let up on the shows for her, they should at least record these proper, so we can hear what she CAN make them.

  • @hjpaddock

    I just love Anette and her voice.

    Which Meadows of Heaven? The one in

    Sweden or in Hartwall? Did she perform MoH

    in 2008? I didn't know that...

    I wish they would make an album of her

    vocalizing these old, popular songs.

    I know, they were originally Tarja, but I think

    some of them Anette can do really well.

  • im septic about her voice....

  • I'll always love Nightwish happened what happened <33 the best band in this world and really with Anette <3

    And all Anette haters should fuck off.

  • Yeah i so agree

    they still cant get over something thats happened 4 yrs ago

    GROW UP

    theres one simple solution if u dont like anette.. stop listening to nightwish :)

  • eww anette cant hit that high note? the words "my love it lies so deep"? hell im a guy like marco and can hit that note in full voice! LOL and my vocal cords dont vurn out. unlike someone! :o

    but im not hating all anette's songs are awesome only she can sing those, and tarja can only sing tarja's songs...

  • anette does a good one here.

  • i like the way tuoams smile to the fans, it was so touching

  • annette is good but tarja is better! annette is shouting and tarja would not have to do it!

  • Anette é uma porcaria , não canta nada coitada ... Ela conseguiu arruinar o nightwish com a voz de pato fanho irritante que ela possui ...

    Anette, esta "coisa " me dá nauseas ! Não é possivel que entre tantas candidatas  justamente esta bosta tinha que ser escolhida... Eu tenho PENA dos meus ouvidos ao ouvir essa marreca cantando .. nem sei porque insisto em ouvir Nightwish , sinceramente ..Nightwish morreu no dia em que Tarja foi substituida por um GANSO ¬¬

  • this is the best variant of Annette's singing Ever dream. I can say that I even almost like it. wish she did the same every concert.

  • I said it on another video and here again.. Anette has a good voice! BUT Tarja sang this song with such a "soft" voice (especially at the end) and Anette has to scream to reach the higher notes (she doesn't even reach the high notes at the end)... and this kind of "opera" style just fits to this song and you keep it in mind and now hearing it with a "screaming" voice is just a little out of common... but don't get me wrong, I like Anette but you just have to take the compare...

  • Tarja had a lot of presence in stage...and WAYYY more voice than anette....this last is prettier though...I suppose Nightwish should have ended and then created a new project with anette...these no longer sounds like nightwish...it sounds like a cheap lacuna coil...Anyway...I keep more track of Tarja now than what I do for nightwish...

  • oh , i forgot..NIGHTWISH FOR EVER AND EVER!!!!!

  • well...i love tarja...i like the "old" nightwish with tarja...i love her voice...i love her songs , specially nemo, ever dream and wish i had an angel...BUT i also love anette... she does a good job with nightwish !her voice is cool ..beautiful...her outfits are cool...she is beautiful...her only flaw is that she' s older than tarja...in rest she's OK!!!

  • I wouldnt mine a release of Anette singing the old songs in her way.

  • Auweia...

  • Best I've ever heard Anette sing this song. She was in VERY good voice at this gig. There's a version of Sleeping sun from this concert on here that's very surprising.

  • Good song, but Anette ... she's crapy!

  • You're crappy. Go flush yourself in a toilet so we can all laugh as you gasp for air.

  • Fantastic!!! good song

  • ..I guess you like yellow coats better..

  • xD

    !!!

  • LMAO!! very nice! XD Tarja's yellow robe thing always looked gay.

  • nevertheless yellow coats don't look emo)))

  • hmm this outfit is actually gothloli like..but yes sometimes she is a little emo ..but whateve the voice metters

  • yes, tarja has got her own album now.

  • Well, I love Anette=D And I think she does a really good job in the band. And I love her clothes... they are better and cooler than Tarjas :D But, I think this song is good with anette, but the Wishmaster is much more better, and the sleeping sun is great... I'd like to hear her singing planet hell, or over the hills=D

  • Yes, that would be great!:-) In Amsterdam she didn't sing Ever Dream:-( Can't have it all, but she sang The Siren, sooooooo f*** good!

  • yeah!! It was. waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahXD

  • you mean it sounds great,she has good stage presence,she move's the audience,dont get me wrong,Tarja was great also,excellent vocals,

    but her stage presence sucked...i mean all she did was walked around in circles,etc,etc.with Anette the band looks more at ease,and enjoying each other's vibe's.not to mention they sound excellent......

  • got that right, sister in metal.....

  • I love Anette singing this song! Only 2 weeks and then..... Amsterdam:-)))

  • I'm going tooo!!!! so exited! only 6 more nights now... To bad i cant get to the meet and greet but that will come another time.

  • she is good single, but not with NIGHTWISH

  • they have smaller concerts now without tarja ...-.-

  • i'd prefer smaller and select, than huge sellouts where noone sees anything unless they are suffocating against the barriers at the front...

  • I don't think so. Look, they even had an Asian tour, and there've been more than 2000-2500 people there, which is fucking much, for a Finnish band. And many, many sold-out European gigs.

  • She looks like a witch

  • lol!!!! i love her outfit, actually i always say that i love her sexy witch look :)

  • I've always thought that she wears such outfit to hide her age. If not to look at the face I would give her 18-20... Maybe it's not so bad.. But for me it seems stupid.

  • This sounds great. This is an old song that really suits Anette's voice. Im glad to see them play in a cool place like the Nokia theater instead of some of the shitholes NW has had to play in the US in the past. Hopefully next time they come to NYC they will play an even bigger place like the Beacon Theater or Roseland.

  • They are playing the starland ballroom in May in jersey. love that place. very intimate.

  • This is my favorite nightwish song

    it's so beautiful!

  • Anette does a great job here. I agree that on some of the old songs, she doesn't do as well, but this is truly great. What you will all have to accept at some point is that Tarja will not be returning. You may not like Anette, and that's your choice. Anette has a good stage presence, at least she MOVES. With Tarja it was more like, "Look at me sing, I'm so pretty!" That said, Tarja did have more experience. I, however, am not a Tarja fan. I am not an Anette fan. I am a NIGHTWISH fan. Period.

  • Well said, I wish more would see it our way.

  • i think she's a breath of fresh air, we all know the old songs by heart, if someone comes up with new melodic lines, why is it so bad? if marco sings the "dream of me" well, the song is saved anyway...

  • I agree, but only in some songs. She really fucks up wishmaster for example...

  • lol whats that

    i fear next time they ll keep on with avril if they ll kick anette

    tarja must be laughing somewhere

    PS:i loved the skirt. will buy the same for my 13 years old cousin

    :D

  • I think that you're kind of right, indeed NG want a performer, they didnt really care for her voice. Annete is great and all, but she is not at the same level of some superb metal singers (Tarja, Simone Simmons, Liv Kristine, etc).

  • Very good quality video :P I like how Anette does this song, and i really can't wait to see them!

  • Anette - you're great!

  • Toumas has to die a little every time annete dose tarja.She (annete)has a decent voice but she acan't do what tarja did.

  • Okay. With Nemo, her voice was almost fading away from trying to reach the high notes. With Sleeping Sun, it was okay until this certain part. This one, she did pretty well!

  • What?! I like her & all, but lets be real, she couldn't do the last choruses once the key changes... She just changed the music completely... She was ok up untill then, but it pretty much ruined it for me, sadly... I'm trying so hard to enjoy her singing.

  • Marco is so cool

  • you're crazy...

  • I love it when she sings, "For my taste, for my lust"! She sounds like a southern belle.

    Anette does a great job, saying Ever dream was made more for Tarja's style than hers. This is stepping out of her comfort zone.

    For example, Tarja would sound terrible singing Amaranth or The Escapist. Why? Because its not her style, not because she's a bad singer. Same goes for Anette here, save that she does GREAT here. So think about THAT before commenting on Anette.

  • yeah thats the key! Nightwish has changed their style and are running after popularity ( which i cant understand they were über succesful! )

    look at their prom pics or anettes clothes

    I dont like the change but it was a "wise " choice anettes voice is easier to listen and not that """extreme""" as Tarja's

    ( mean that many people cant stand the opera dumbs.. )

    so with the new album ( the next chapter ((or the copy)) of Once their popularity will rise to the sky... :S

  • Heard this in Finland 12.12

    Fucking rocked, as did pretty much everything else, especially sacrament of wilderness.

    Go home you utter wankers who say anette can't sing.

  • you're lucky. i wish they played sacrament of wildnerness when i saw them.

  • Ever dream is magic and beautiful no matter who sings it...I think we can all agree with that, at least!! :)

  • Anette sings all the old songs well ^^

  • iuu

    ¿por qué la vestirán tan espantoso?

    Why she's always wearing those horrible dresses?

  • Ehhhh...rara tu pregunta, alguna vez escuchaste hablar del pop-metal? bueno, así se visten.

  • anette can't sing old songs right!let's face it!

  • + 1 ...

  • ppl gotta stop bein so hard on anette i think shes great, and tarja was aswell!

  • i saw them a few weeks ago, and anette does not suck by any means live. she's great both in terms of singing as well as interacting with the crowd.

  • She has great stage presense, I went to their show & it was realy fun to watch her, esspecialy her dialogues with Marco.

    She just still has to grow on me in terms of singing. On some songs on DPP she sounds stellar. On others it's a bit painful, but I still say "give the girl a chance, she'll improve". Then she goes along & pretty much butchers the old songs... I wish they'd just lower the keys for her... Even Live it was pretty unbearable at times.

  • ur all evanescence fans anette lovers

    anette sux live ... 101%

    tarja wasn't always good but ... when she did, she was the best ever was

  • Ever dream is one of the best pop/rock songs of all time.

  • Wow. Seriously. I can't wait till I get to see them in London in March!

  • i flew all the way from mexico to catch that show and i'd do it again 10000 times, it was beautiful

  • guuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuooo!!!! i like!!!! so much!!!!!! :/, i miss tarja but anette was sing this song soooo good!!! 5 stars :/ hehehe.. thanks for the video!, i love you nightwish!!!! tuomas youre the best (K)""" hahaha

    P.D: yes i know, im so crazy <3 hahahaa x.x bye!

  • Go, Nettan!!

  • Anette, you're amazing!

  • Gosh people if you don't like Nightwish anymore leave it and go listen to Tarjas new stuff. I liked Tarjas voice with the songs too but I also like Anette... Take it or leave it...

  • take your hating somewhere else plz, u dumbass closed minded asshole

  • If you cannot accept that someone has an opinion that is different from yours, then who is close-minded ?

  • To be honest, neither of you are open minded. In fact, it's difficult to be truly open minded when it comes to music, because music is something dominated by taste and taste is, at its core, a bias or opinion, one that is difficult to change on a whim.

    Just thought I'd throw that out there.

  • Sorry about the other message I just wrote (starting with "Calm down"), it was not adressed to you but to the other person that answered to me. I forgot I had already answered to her XD

    People can love Anette, I don't really care. I just don't want those people to be close-minded and tell me stuff like "go away, fucking hater".

  • Go see them live, and then tell us if your opinion hasn't changed ;)

  • Calm down. I'm just a NW fan telling her opinion. That song has a deep meaning for me and I didn't know Anette would kill it that way...

  • I thinks she sounds surprisingly good. We are used to hear Tarja performing it, so of course hearing someone else singing it sounds weird.

    Tuomas knew what he was doing when he hired Anette. There would always be criticism, no matter who would be singing Nightwish songs after Tarja.

    I for one, like Anette's sound. Her voice is pretty strong and she brings something new to the band.

  • Well Tuomas made this song so he can do what ever he wants for this song. And this sounds better now with Anette.

  • i love Anette!!!!

  • I really love both of them. I loved Anette as soon as I heard that sample of Amaranth..

  • Same here! \m/ They made a great choice of Vocalist!

  • she sounds better live in lofi. studio album is disapointing.

  • where ist that dammned needed power?

  • No emotion conveyed... by her singing this song..

  • well Amy Lee??? she is Anete and she is a great singer...BUT Tarja wastn't just a great singer......:) L U TT

  • she cant sing NIGHTWISH! i want tarja back T.T

  • Make that 2:58.

  • At 3:03 she forgot the words. How pathetic.

  • OMG, she's out of tune in more than a few places. This sucks ass.

  • Despite the bad quality, this is great.

  • gah...i don't like anette's sense of style...almost as bad as all those tarja banana coats

  • I love how Anette does the old songs; she doesn't try to imitate Tarja too much; she adds her own touch.

  • true to form, the new york audience is out of control! it's a new york thang!

  • Anette sounds better than I expected

  • What is this??? She is screaming... She dont sing... She cannot sing the old nightwish songs...

  • yea she's kinda screaming..so what? It's more metal..almost all metal vocalists scream...

  • bestwishes for u anette , just let NW RIP in peace

  • She done this one well but in my opinion she shouldn't attempt tarjas songs . still can't wait to see them live

  • Annette actually sings that better live than Tarja (and I do like Tarja). I think Annette is the perfect choice of singer for where Nightwish is musically now and Dark Passion Play is the strongest album to date. Awsome stuff.

  • And you wrote like asshole

  • I think you're the bitch if I read all of your messages ..

  • So awesome! Only the 'thing' that she's wearing worries me a bit :)

  • it hurt! Anette speaking not singing... she "sing" like a pop singer! i love this song whit Tarja!!!

  • just waiting to see the band in Joensuu, Finland 12.12.. Home of NW. It will be the great evening!

  • Never seen a woman singing this clear, high, and precisely at a live concert.

    She's just ways better than Tarja...

  • your funny

  • because she's speaking not singing man, u might understand that listening Tarja ...

  • Absolutely right! I truly hated Tarja's live version. Anette is very good live! Let's hope it stays like that .

  • Dont listen to Nightwish if its so "Shit" then ^^

    I think the change in singer has brought life to the band, dont get me wrong, Tarja was good, But Anette has brought attitude and power into the band, And i cant wait to see them on 4/4/08 at The Manchester Acadmey.

  • You make about as mutch sense as your argument ^^

  • Best wishes!

  • Yes you are right... This is a SHIT

  • Amy Lee is a great singer and you comment makes no sense.

  • Pathetic!You need to listen to Floor Jansen,Fabienne Gondamin,Liv Kristine or Anette Gulbrandsen!

  • Do you call everyone "pathetic" who has a different taste in music than you? Floow Jansen is a great singer, yes, but how does she fit into the Amy Lee discussion?

  • i can see why the guys picked her. isnt this her "resume" song when she tried to get in the band? i think it was! if so...yup EXCELLENT!

  • es perfecto!!! te amo Anette xD

  • nightwish rocks and anette is amezing =]

  • Perfect band.

  • damn I love her! and they're finally coming to italy, cant wait.

  • this is really good : )

  • I love it. She's amazing. They all are amazing. I can't wait to see them! This was great quality, thank you so much! <3

  • when you seeing them? im going to on halloween, in seattle!

    did you here her do sleeping sun yet? its around here somewhere. she nails it! if she keeps that up she's gonna outdo tarja before this year is over! (& im a big fan of tarja so thats saying a lot)

    GO ANETTE!!!

  • I must wait until 1st of December... They're coming to Oslo. :) She's really improving every time, she didn't have much time to practise the old songs before the tour. She's doing so fantastic job!

  • amazing. i saw them at the worcestor concert yesterday also. anette is absolutley amazing. she is truly getting better with each and every show.

  • I was there....it sounded amazing!

  • i just got bak frum the worsester concert and they were fuckin awsum!! i got 2 meet them aftr!

  • I had a lot of fun at this show too, and Ever Dream was one of my favorite songs of that night.

    Very clear recording for being on the floor! Based on the angle of this video, I was probably standing about 3 people behind you.. ~_^

  • just perfect !!! great ...

  • Thank you~ thank you~ for posting this!!! I wanted to go see them Thursday night SO BADly~ but I couldn't! But at least I can watch it here, great quality~ thanks so much again!! :)