@0Smilelikeyoumeanit two takes actually, according to Mark Cousins. The first was abandonded, the film is the second take. An incredible piece of work.
@ribogok why would you say that? Imperial grandomania maybe but it's still history and must embrace ones history in order to continue their evolution. Nothing is black or white and monarchy with all its faults isn't an exception. As for the tastless part I hope you're not reffering to the cinematography, directing or costumes cause then I'm afraid you shoud do some research on how identical they are to reality. If you're reffering to the aisthetics themselves, well then it's your oppinion.
wow. so this film is listed as horror on rotten tomatoes, so halfway through the trailer I'm just beaming at the thought of this aesthetic being the premise of a horror movie, and then the critic quotes roll and I slowly realize rotten tomatoes has played a horrible, cruel joke on me.
I think Oscar today (don't know about the past) is all about pop culture and moving towards crap like teen choice awards etc.
And it isn't really worth paying attention to.
Real stuff is something like Venice Film Festival, where the author of this movie, Sokurov, received its highest prize lately (not for this film though)
The problem is, that dumbest nation on the planet (Americans) dont know anything about one of the biggest histries on the planet (russian history). The know only Soviets and Stalin - thats it. So no one there understeand what the film is about. No american would come on the idea that Sakurow goes with the camera through the time, through the 300 years of Russian history. He shows us what the walls of Hermitage know. Magnificent peace of art.
@Mig29tvc Excuse me, not all Americans are dumbasses. I have studied the amazing history of Russia from its beginnings in Kiev to the fall of the Soviet Union and more. I know about the tsars as well as the general secretaries. I still have much to learn but I love it. I love learning about Russia and I hope to master the language and visit one day. I know many people who would enjoy and understand this film. If you think that we're all stupid, come and see my America. You'd be surprised! :)
@Mig29tvc You're exactly right comrade. There's no way any of those stupid "Americans" can understand the beauty and complexity that is Mother Russia. Have fun with your stupid Jersey Shore you dumb Americunts.
I watched this last night and was rapt up in it. I lived in Petersburg years ago and went to the Hermitage eight times, so this was a return for me. What others are saying about this being like a dream is apt. It is a luminous perambulation through history, art, emotion, and culture.
It is simply like a dream, moving, strange almost to the point of horror and yet it is one of my favourite films of alll time, in a league of it's own with 2001 and other great films. And no I'm not over 30 I'm just 13 and the only person in my school to of seen it and I loved every second, brilliant, enchanting and wonderful.....
FORGOTTEN KING <<< is the new world record in the world .one take film 105 minutes. GEORGIAN people already beaten the guiness record in october 2010.
coming soon in cinemas in january 2011. you can see the trailer of this movie
Astonishing, and not at all boring, as gcorking12 said. It was in fact brilliant, though I can forsee the problem with our generation and the accompanying degraded attention span being incapable of immersing themself in something that takes hold of their imagination for longer than a few minutes at a time.
@folladordeprostis not ALL Americans think that this movie sucks!!! I'm an American, yes I do live in the hills of east TN, i assure you i am NOT a redneck!! This is a fantastic film!!!
two ghosts wander through the Winter Palace. They're eternal, so each room they enter they meet a different time in russian history, people they've met... It's also about the appreciation of art, about history, about being alone, about a lot of things. It's really open to interpretation. It can be really moving if you let it.
I saw it, and i loved it. I felt so, don´t get me wrong, relieved in the end. I´ve just witnessed something extraordinary and it´s a shame that this movie hasn´t gained the attention it deserves. You don´t have to be a professor in film history to understand how genius a film shot in a single take, is.
Btw props to the cameraman. Steadicams are heavy as shit and this guy managed to shoot continuously for 90 min. Pretty incredible. As for the film is it as good storywise as it is technically?
There is a story element, yes. But it is not imperative to the movie. Russian Ark is just that, an ark of culture. It is the closest thing us normal people will have to actually interacting with Russia's past. A living diorama. That in itself is what this movie should be graded on. And it was beautiful. Uninterrupted majesty.
@jimmyhooha not exactly...intraframe content its alco an editor work...changing plans inside the frame and stuff (sorry for my engilsh - its maybe not really good)
Wonderful film. Watching the DVD extras is important. For those who do not truly understand how hard it is to make an entire film like this in one shot, the DVD explains what tremendous labor is involved.
Not an impressive feat? I would love to see you do better. Please post a video, done all in one take, that exceeds what we see here. I will be waiting.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
asinine? You must know alot about film. As for Rob zombie, the overall appearance of the devils rejects was surprisingly well finished - quality story or not. The fact that you were able to do a little research and come up with these spectacular counter points is a display of your ability to use imdb. Your opinions are based on those of filmmakers who have made it. Maybe if you begin taking a film at face value and giving it a personal rating you will be able to make it also.
OMG shut up! r u ppl 11 years old? This movie will be regarded an innovated beautiful cinematic masterpieace in 20,50,70 years from now like Gone with the Wind, Le Mépris or Wild Strawberries.
Yes, Russia is a theatre for you, Europeans. Like we are, Russians, playing roles of Europeans and nobody knows who we are under masks. Copyists like Kustin says? Theatre? Or not human at all, like Germans thought in 41st? Or Red monster that eats everything around him and his own tale? Thats easy, you need to be Russian to understand that, thats what this film about. And thats why this trailer focuses on technic, not idea. Idea is Just not for you.
@Fedotof This film says - Stop copying European style - don't take what is not yours. Petersburg - what's original there? soulless copy of european architecture. Your Glinka and his poor copy of polish mazurka... Be yourselves!
There is ark of EU arts inRussia. Part of these arts was made by Russians because Russia is a part of Europe. But Europeans will never admire that. Cause now, they cannot even understand their own art.
And you don’t know nothing about Glinka, if you think that Glinka is copyist of Polyaks music you just an idiot. I think, that’s because you like real Polyak think that only one music in the world is mazurka. It’s your Polyakocentism.
Seriously i watched this movie in my cinema class and every body were almost sleeping.. the concepts is good but its pretty boring if you are not a fan of cinema
I saw this first on DVD before I took any cinema classes. I found it quite atmospheric and sumptuous. It's a massive paraphrasing of Russian history but the seamless flow from eras more than made up for it. Have you ever been in a castle or palace that's anything like the Hermitage? I think it's more a movie for lovers of grand visual spaces than merely cinema but that's me. A continuous and uncut shot is quite amazing too and I didn't find it boring.
I'm not sure of the DP but as I understand it, Alexander Sokurov (director) operated the Steadicam rig and HD camera himself. Insisted on it, in fact.
This movie is best seen in the theater and you get the whole impact. I'm positive that there was a lot of preparation, rehearsing and choreography before this picture was shot.
Fucking awesome film. Shame this trailer focuses more on the technical aspects than the quality of the film itself. Watching this movie is like wandering through someone else's dream, a unique experience in cinema, and art generally. Anyone who was bored by it is a rank philistine.
@cage336 Then you probably deserve to watch a sport instead - maybe you'd understand it; or, that'd probably be too much for you - perhaps you could go shoot a gun at a target, repeatedly, over and over.
@LewisQ Well said- although enjoyzing what the film has to offer presupposes a certain amount of mental wherewithal of which many are simply bereft. Fortunately we are not, and we can enjoy experiencing ourselves through such clairvoyant sublimity.
Probably one of the most beautiful movies I have ever seen. Incredible. I felt like the proverbial fly on the wall to 300 years of Russian history. God bless the Tsar!
I have this on DVD and on the extras they interview all the people that worked on the film and he said he almost quit near the end but he held on until the end
Se necesitaron 4 intentos para lograrla; las primeras 3 veces, hubo fallos tecnicos que fastidiaban las cosas, y en la cuarta ocasion el camarografo casi tiraba la toalla del cansancio, pero logro terminarla.
If anything it would be pretentious to think that because a film or video is without tangible plot or dialogue that is drivel. Or it could be pretentious of you calling something as beautiful and remarkable as this film "meaningless" out of some sort of spite. Nothing is contrived, nothing is out to fool the West - it is clearly a passionate work of art done as a tribute to one's country. You don't have to like it, but don't be a jerk for the sheer sake of it.
A masterpiece that is doubtless, from another experience, another country, the other perspective marvels at the artistry that can be woven into patriotism. I can't help but feel a little jealous. I agree it would be a shame to label any art in the mold of patriotism, the inseparableness of locality, passion, and being human leads a person to that impasse.
Patriotism is political, if one could feel some pride about cultural developed over hundreds of years, if that being your point, I would say it has nothing to do with patriotism but all to do with appreciating human development in a certain geographical area. I havn't seen the movie, but as one interested in Russian things, not communist things (and certainly not patriotic things) I am very interested in viewing this film. I am ashamed of the communists and their history.
I still have difficulty concieving this is possible.
Phersephoie 1 week ago
I really hope the DVD has a blooper reel
hollowcaustic 3 weeks ago 2
i woudl like to see this movie Ö
WikiWaki91 1 month ago
@WikiWaki91 you should, it is a masterpiece
Phersephoie 1 week ago
They rehearsed this thousands of times. There's probably hundreds of versions of the film, they just released the one that was the best.
zetaro128 2 months ago
@zetaro128 There was actually only 3 takes,
And the first two failed due to technical faults.
0Smilelikeyoumeanit 2 months ago 2
@0Smilelikeyoumeanit two takes actually, according to Mark Cousins. The first was abandonded, the film is the second take. An incredible piece of work.
BlowDeBloodyDoorsOff 1 month ago
Oh, fuck. I forgot the line. *getsshot*
623sandy 3 months ago
I also sometimes do one take films on YT, but they don't come out as polished as this. I probably need better equipment.
usenetposts 3 months ago
@usenetposts or millions of dollars
DpadProductions 2 months ago
Milestone my ass. More like a tasteless showcase of imperial grandomania.
ribogok 3 months ago
@ribogok why would you say that? Imperial grandomania maybe but it's still history and must embrace ones history in order to continue their evolution. Nothing is black or white and monarchy with all its faults isn't an exception. As for the tastless part I hope you're not reffering to the cinematography, directing or costumes cause then I'm afraid you shoud do some research on how identical they are to reality. If you're reffering to the aisthetics themselves, well then it's your oppinion.
Phersephoie 1 week ago
2000 actors
300 years of Russian history
33 rooms of the hermitage museum
3 live orchestras
and ONE freakin tired cameraman.
SpartnPride 3 months ago 3
they should've put Ricky Gervais in the leading role!
watcheem 3 months ago
KTO ETO??? DA ! PREVIT, A KAK DELA!!!!!!!
DontFuckWitDreDay 3 months ago
Comment removed
ComtedeTourville 4 months ago
wow. so this film is listed as horror on rotten tomatoes, so halfway through the trailer I'm just beaming at the thought of this aesthetic being the premise of a horror movie, and then the critic quotes roll and I slowly realize rotten tomatoes has played a horrible, cruel joke on me.
ledZeppelin7680 5 months ago 3
dewd, this ez lyke soooo kool!!!
lilcuddlekill 6 months ago
Actor: line line messup...
Director: Damn it! Back from the top people.
ca1cifer 6 months ago 3
imagine making an error 30 seconds from the end and then having to redo the whole thing
wookiewhat 6 months ago 12
russians are serbs
SRBIJAJEMAJKA 7 months ago
@SRBIJAJEMAJKA No, they're not.
LiamCrowley1990 5 months ago
@LiamCrowley1990 ignorance is bliss ...
SRBIJAJEMAJKA 5 months ago
@SRBIJAJEMAJKA Yeah, I'm sure it is.
LiamCrowley1990 5 months ago
How did this not win best picture at the oscars? Seriously the committee is biased towards American produced crap.
agugu42 8 months ago 2
@agugu42
I think Oscar today (don't know about the past) is all about pop culture and moving towards crap like teen choice awards etc.
And it isn't really worth paying attention to.
Real stuff is something like Venice Film Festival, where the author of this movie, Sokurov, received its highest prize lately (not for this film though)
alexgrinkov 4 months ago
im interested in seeing the film for its single-take extraordinaire, but it looks to me like tedious royal mechanics for 80 minutes straight.
AbsurdRandomness3 9 months ago
@AbsurdRandomness3 its a good movie, shocking ending though. the beginning is slow but the scenes are so beautiful you'll find it worth the lag.
jlwinters1000 6 months ago
Este é um filme pra quem gosta de História.
flor20009 9 months ago
@azmi12345 yes, the "in one single, continuous shot," "in a single take" portion of the trailer appears to hint at that.
VivaLaUndead 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I LOVED this movie.
turtlewings 9 months ago
@azmi12345 damn I was about to write that.
CressidaTussaud 10 months ago
@Mig29tvc You're a fool most likely descended from serfs. You should keep your mouth shut if you decide not to embarrass yourself again.
That being said, I, as an ignorant American, enjoyed this film immensely.
tabber87 11 months ago 3
The problem is, that dumbest nation on the planet (Americans) dont know anything about one of the biggest histries on the planet (russian history). The know only Soviets and Stalin - thats it. So no one there understeand what the film is about. No american would come on the idea that Sakurow goes with the camera through the time, through the 300 years of Russian history. He shows us what the walls of Hermitage know. Magnificent peace of art.
Mig29tvc 11 months ago
@Mig29tvc Excuse me, not all Americans are dumbasses. I have studied the amazing history of Russia from its beginnings in Kiev to the fall of the Soviet Union and more. I know about the tsars as well as the general secretaries. I still have much to learn but I love it. I love learning about Russia and I hope to master the language and visit one day. I know many people who would enjoy and understand this film. If you think that we're all stupid, come and see my America. You'd be surprised! :)
ImmaDinoSoriaRawr 10 months ago
@Mig29tvc You're exactly right comrade. There's no way any of those stupid "Americans" can understand the beauty and complexity that is Mother Russia. Have fun with your stupid Jersey Shore you dumb Americunts.
partyhardydardy 10 months ago
I watched this last night and was rapt up in it. I lived in Petersburg years ago and went to the Hermitage eight times, so this was a return for me. What others are saying about this being like a dream is apt. It is a luminous perambulation through history, art, emotion, and culture.
andrjsh 1 year ago
Where can I watch it? *sigh* I really really really want to watch this movie. My kingdom for this movie!
AvatarMarxon90 1 year ago
It is simply like a dream, moving, strange almost to the point of horror and yet it is one of my favourite films of alll time, in a league of it's own with 2001 and other great films. And no I'm not over 30 I'm just 13 and the only person in my school to of seen it and I loved every second, brilliant, enchanting and wonderful.....
Saeched 1 year ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
Fine-looking big girls looking for you naneedj.info
mikaylwright 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Asian marriage **busizz4me.info**
RojekSoram568 1 year ago
FORGOTTEN KING <<< is the new world record in the world .one take film 105 minutes. GEORGIAN people already beaten the guiness record in october 2010.
coming soon in cinemas in january 2011. you can see the trailer of this movie
mixeili 1 year ago
Astonishing, and not at all boring, as gcorking12 said. It was in fact brilliant, though I can forsee the problem with our generation and the accompanying degraded attention span being incapable of immersing themself in something that takes hold of their imagination for longer than a few minutes at a time.
HazeyDrake 1 year ago
It was really clever. However it was oh so boring
gcorking12 1 year ago
valery gergiev!!
jin12345678 1 year ago
What a lovely film! I`ve never heard of it....but I wanna see it....
seriex5 1 year ago
Truly extraordinary film. It definitly leaves a mark on the viewer and in film history.
acdc14terrace 1 year ago
Americans rednecks said this movie sucks
folladordeprostis 1 year ago
@folladordeprostis not ALL Americans think that this movie sucks!!! I'm an American, yes I do live in the hills of east TN, i assure you i am NOT a redneck!! This is a fantastic film!!!
muffystjohn86 1 year ago
This movie looks good,what is the plot??
folladordeprostis 1 year ago
@folladordeprostis
two ghosts wander through the Winter Palace. They're eternal, so each room they enter they meet a different time in russian history, people they've met... It's also about the appreciation of art, about history, about being alone, about a lot of things. It's really open to interpretation. It can be really moving if you let it.
fbaraglia 1 year ago
i was very impressed by the uniforms
mastaODI56 1 year ago
this movie was insane... it was really cool but I still think cutting is essential to a movie
euginam91 1 year ago
Lovely
GWEN321able 1 year ago
boring movie? did u like it? snob
Beatnik00 1 year ago
I can imagine something like this:
"Cut! Good job people! Perfect performance!"
"Huh boss?"
"Yeah?"
"I forgot to press record."
*murder ensues*
ProfeTa6 1 year ago 37
Comment removed
daltonh12 1 year ago
what happens if someone fucked up
Gannondalf 1 year ago
@Gannondalf
they did. 3 times.
LateMetaL93 1 year ago
@LateMetaL93
so what happened? did they redo it? (i havent watched the movie)
Gannondalf 1 year ago
it is so good to see something completely different once in a while. loved this film
maccyjames64 1 year ago
whose is the music?
0casteloencantado0 1 year ago
thats CINEMA !
others is entertainment ;) for eating trash-food sitted in a cinema . like zombies
lucareale 1 year ago
I saw it, and i loved it. I felt so, don´t get me wrong, relieved in the end. I´ve just witnessed something extraordinary and it´s a shame that this movie hasn´t gained the attention it deserves. You don´t have to be a professor in film history to understand how genius a film shot in a single take, is.
Exeron91 1 year ago 2
@victorinoxical... Excellent comment. I clearly couldn't have said it better myself! Kudos
Wayshower1212 2 years ago
Btw props to the cameraman. Steadicams are heavy as shit and this guy managed to shoot continuously for 90 min. Pretty incredible. As for the film is it as good storywise as it is technically?
jimmyhooha 2 years ago 7
There is a story element, yes. But it is not imperative to the movie. Russian Ark is just that, an ark of culture. It is the closest thing us normal people will have to actually interacting with Russia's past. A living diorama. That in itself is what this movie should be graded on. And it was beautiful. Uninterrupted majesty.
victorinoxical 2 years ago 3
Must've been really easy on the editor. Lol.
jimmyhooha 2 years ago 175
@jimmyhooha rofl
theonlyonebuttwo 1 year ago
@jimmyhooha But think of the nightmare for an actor director...
Preacherunico 1 year ago
@jimmyhooha HAHAHAHA!
vokonick 7 months ago
@jimmyhooha not exactly...intraframe content its alco an editor work...changing plans inside the frame and stuff (sorry for my engilsh - its maybe not really good)
IIdman 7 months ago
@jimmyhooha Hahaha oh yeah, really really easy it must have been. :P
gregbboy619 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
are there any niggers in this?
j24800 2 years ago
Wonderful film. Watching the DVD extras is important. For those who do not truly understand how hard it is to make an entire film like this in one shot, the DVD explains what tremendous labor is involved.
chrisman737 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
one take isnt an impressive feat. its an attempt at originality. Too bad the movie was far from great. Fucking money grab
mataccnt 2 years ago
Not an impressive feat? I would love to see you do better. Please post a video, done all in one take, that exceeds what we see here. I will be waiting.
chrisman737 2 years ago 8
Wow. Well I think Scorsese, Sokurov, and many others would disagree with you. Then again, they're just amateurs.
And what kind of money grab is a single-shot film about an art museum? That aint exactly summer blockbuster fare.
Your statement was asinine. You probably like Rob Zombie's movies.
shootitinthehead 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
asinine? You must know alot about film. As for Rob zombie, the overall appearance of the devils rejects was surprisingly well finished - quality story or not. The fact that you were able to do a little research and come up with these spectacular counter points is a display of your ability to use imdb. Your opinions are based on those of filmmakers who have made it. Maybe if you begin taking a film at face value and giving it a personal rating you will be able to make it also.
mataccnt 2 years ago
@mataccnt
Man, whatever you said might have been intelligent but I didn't bother reading because
>Rob Zombie
>surprisingly well finished
Nah, man. Rob Zombie films have zero redeeming qualities.
SteamMachine 2 years ago
Ah suck it ben hurr! jk
Superhumanattack 2 years ago
TOTALLY INCREDIBLE. Hey i shot that scene. NOT.
punk2116 2 years ago
I feel lucky to have seen this movie, it's lovely.
margethemouse 2 years ago
OMG shut up! r u ppl 11 years old? This movie will be regarded an innovated beautiful cinematic masterpieace in 20,50,70 years from now like Gone with the Wind, Le Mépris or Wild Strawberries.
Twiggy90Couture 2 years ago
Harold and Kumar's Star Wipe.
capitalistpigdogus 2 years ago
Unbelievable. I am in total awe
septip123 2 years ago
Russia is a theatre. Eternal people,live on and keep living. you`ll live forever.......
MrEdwardrochester 2 years ago
Yes, Russia is a theatre for you, Europeans. Like we are, Russians, playing roles of Europeans and nobody knows who we are under masks. Copyists like Kustin says? Theatre? Or not human at all, like Germans thought in 41st? Or Red monster that eats everything around him and his own tale? Thats easy, you need to be Russian to understand that, thats what this film about. And thats why this trailer focuses on technic, not idea. Idea is Just not for you.
Fedotof 1 year ago
@Fedotof This film says - Stop copying European style - don't take what is not yours. Petersburg - what's original there? soulless copy of european architecture. Your Glinka and his poor copy of polish mazurka... Be yourselves!
lucifersam111 1 year ago
Comment removed
Fedotof 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
There is ark of EU arts inRussia. Part of these arts was made by Russians because Russia is a part of Europe. But Europeans will never admire that. Cause now, they cannot even understand their own art.
And you don’t know nothing about Glinka, if you think that Glinka is copyist of Polyaks music you just an idiot. I think, that’s because you like real Polyak think that only one music in the world is mazurka. It’s your Polyakocentism.
Fedotof 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Seriously i watched this movie in my cinema class and every body were almost sleeping.. the concepts is good but its pretty boring if you are not a fan of cinema
doomood 2 years ago
I saw this first on DVD before I took any cinema classes. I found it quite atmospheric and sumptuous. It's a massive paraphrasing of Russian history but the seamless flow from eras more than made up for it. Have you ever been in a castle or palace that's anything like the Hermitage? I think it's more a movie for lovers of grand visual spaces than merely cinema but that's me. A continuous and uncut shot is quite amazing too and I didn't find it boring.
KahnBB6 2 years ago 5
What is this song called?! Is it by Glinka?
LeOceanLia 2 years ago
imagine messing up the last line...
pancholin89 2 years ago 21
hahahahah
jayandsilentbob96 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is the most gay film i ever seen! YOU SUCK
bandarrinhabrandao 2 years ago
How old are you seriously?
jayandsilentbob96 2 years ago
Amazing movie.
One of the must see movie.
MyHawaiiWebMagazine 2 years ago
Wow, one take!?! What an amazing DP this film must of had!
miaangel345 2 years ago 2
What do you mean by DP? Sorry, I'm not familiar with that term..
zehnli 2 years ago
Director of Photography?
mindtpi 2 years ago
I'm not sure of the DP but as I understand it, Alexander Sokurov (director) operated the Steadicam rig and HD camera himself. Insisted on it, in fact.
KahnBB6 2 years ago
no he didn't, Tilman Büttner was the steadicamoperator and DP. He also provided the running steadicam shots for "Lola Rennt" (run Lola run).
Nilsnqe 2 years ago
Not true. Watch the making of docs on the DVD. The DP/operator was not Sokurov, who followed beside him the whole time giving directions..
AgentCaution 2 years ago
This movie is best seen in the theater and you get the whole impact. I'm positive that there was a lot of preparation, rehearsing and choreography before this picture was shot.
johnyzero2000 3 years ago
Fucking awesome film. Shame this trailer focuses more on the technical aspects than the quality of the film itself. Watching this movie is like wandering through someone else's dream, a unique experience in cinema, and art generally. Anyone who was bored by it is a rank philistine.
LewisQ 3 years ago 70
@LewisQ i'm bored by this...
cage336 10 months ago
@cage336 Then you probably deserve to watch a sport instead - maybe you'd understand it; or, that'd probably be too much for you - perhaps you could go shoot a gun at a target, repeatedly, over and over.
Jessrackham 9 months ago 2
@LewisQ go to see Rambo, you motherfucker
javes1994 8 months ago
@LewisQ Well said- although enjoyzing what the film has to offer presupposes a certain amount of mental wherewithal of which many are simply bereft. Fortunately we are not, and we can enjoy experiencing ourselves through such clairvoyant sublimity.
VelikyUstyug1 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
the beginning of this movie sucked. i didn't have the patience to watch the rest of it. ://
dazzlingdarkness 3 years ago
last night i watched half of it. i wish i'd bette slept instead. didn't like it
nazirdjon 3 years ago
i think you got a right to say such a thing.
luuko656 3 years ago
Yeah it isn't bad to have a different opinion like so many people think
KaptainKlein 2 years ago
that's one big advertisemnt for the camera
nazirdjon 3 years ago 3
Probably one of the most beautiful movies I have ever seen. Incredible. I felt like the proverbial fly on the wall to 300 years of Russian history. God bless the Tsar!
BoborGlenn 3 years ago 5
did the guy get tired holding the camera???????
mdoub 3 years ago
it was a horse
michaeldoocey 3 years ago
i couldn't read the credits at the end
mdoub 3 years ago
I have this on DVD and on the extras they interview all the people that worked on the film and he said he almost quit near the end but he held on until the end
jimupsman 3 years ago
Excellent film! I enjoyed it so much.
PiusMatthias 3 years ago
One of the best films I have ever seen. Eerie, decadent, mesmerizing and confusing, but a masterpiece.
kitt75 3 years ago 2
this was so trippy to watch and i wasn't even on drugs at the time!
mickywagner 3 years ago
Samo Rusi!
DjordjepunX 3 years ago
Samo Rusi!
DjordjepunX 3 years ago
I can't wait to see it! I rented the DVD today!
QueenRenee 3 years ago
Y cada vez que alguién se equivocaba tenían que repetir TODO denuevo.... pueden imaginarse?
lourdesjazmine 3 years ago
ay si, que lastima!
tehPhire 3 years ago
Se necesitaron 4 intentos para lograrla; las primeras 3 veces, hubo fallos tecnicos que fastidiaban las cosas, y en la cuarta ocasion el camarografo casi tiraba la toalla del cansancio, pero logro terminarla.
espp1973 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Russian Argh, indeed.
RusskiSuperPower 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Pretentious and meaningless Post-Modern drivel without a plot or coherent dialogue contrived to fool Western critics with Russian exoticism.
RusskiSuperPower 3 years ago
If anything it would be pretentious to think that because a film or video is without tangible plot or dialogue that is drivel. Or it could be pretentious of you calling something as beautiful and remarkable as this film "meaningless" out of some sort of spite. Nothing is contrived, nothing is out to fool the West - it is clearly a passionate work of art done as a tribute to one's country. You don't have to like it, but don't be a jerk for the sheer sake of it.
justinoakey 3 years ago 13
A masterpiece that is doubtless, from another experience, another country, the other perspective marvels at the artistry that can be woven into patriotism. I can't help but feel a little jealous. I agree it would be a shame to label any art in the mold of patriotism, the inseparableness of locality, passion, and being human leads a person to that impasse.
EntropyHaptens 3 years ago 3
To say art and patriotism are naturally separate, is a naive premise, I agree.
EntropyHaptens 3 years ago 3
you talk smart
TheThroney 2 years ago
Patriotism is political, if one could feel some pride about cultural developed over hundreds of years, if that being your point, I would say it has nothing to do with patriotism but all to do with appreciating human development in a certain geographical area. I havn't seen the movie, but as one interested in Russian things, not communist things (and certainly not patriotic things) I am very interested in viewing this film. I am ashamed of the communists and their history.
PrinceMushkin 2 years ago
The greatest piece of cinematic art EVER made-thankyou-a miracle
bradsnot 3 years ago 3
Glad to hear everyone is saying this awesome, I want to see it!
dedicatedrr 3 years ago 3
Finally, something positive. = )
psychologicalshock 3 years ago 4
one of the most unique films of our time!
BonjourBrend08 3 years ago 7
This is one of the most amazing movies ever!! Over 90 minutes in just one shot all around the Hermitage Museum.
WeirdoNorb 3 years ago 10
One of the best movies I have ever seen!
PeterStoev 3 years ago 8
Thanks for sharing!:)
bossa 3 years ago 7
its from the best ever films
Sokurov kick the holywood ass in one shot
alkhth 4 years ago 10