Personally I think if you want to wear feathers then wear feathers, and if you want to have a dream catcher then have one, but don't go running around with a headdress on and red face paint under your eyes just because it's "fashion" It's kinda disrespectful, that you'd try to make yourself look like you're apart of this culture and you actually know nothing about it.
I personally see no problem with it. If people are willing to wear the stars and stripes of america or the union jack which can't we explore other cultures? Some people will still stay oblivious to Native Americans but what can you do about it? You can't force people to research and understand them or forbid them from wearing it? One trend I'm disgusted at is 'the military trend' I mean..really? You want to pretend your a soldier then get down on the frontline.
Probably an actual Native American shop, or a least from a fair trade shop because I would be paying for the quality-- I would be wearing the clothing multiple times in my life, I'm a minimalist and wearing a piece made by an artist. Plus, I don't want to support stores that may be involved with sweatshops. If I want to be cheap and not support such corporations, then I could always design my own Native inspired print just for myself or learn some crafting technique, as I'm a crafty person.
Cut me a break. People have been wearing our style of clothing since they came to Turtle Island. What do you think Trappers wore when they came here. This is such an old topic, but since you are young this is new to you. Read up on history
@waynah2 yes, I do know that the style has been worn for YEARS. But now that it is in fashion again, and we have the technology for it to be mass produced and sold at such a high level, I wanted to hear opinions.
you also left out the most important part of Sasha's argument--that UO and Forever 21 are American companies that do not include native americans in the design or production process. Instead,production is sent overseas. This is the most ironic part of boasting a "Navajo" line in UO stores.
I don't know if you're still doing your poll, but I hope that you, yourself as a shopper will stop to think about your intentions when you go to buy and wear native american inspired clothing. Do you care about saving MONEY and shopping at a place like UO or Forever21 more than you care about the disrespect the native american communities are feeling? You say you feel very close to the culture some how as a white person so why can't you empathize with their sentiments
@TheBasketcasey Well like you said, this was a poll based video, so I didn't go much into detail about how I felt on the manner. In regards to your other comment, I left the article below for other people to follow up on, because I couldn't touch on everything. PERSONALLY, not only do I like saving money - but I need to save money. Just because I can't afford top original quality doesn't mean that it should stop me from expressing my gratitude.
@TheBasketcasey I respect the culture and all that they have done. I think companies who rip off their designs need to be more socially conscious, but legally they don't have many set restraints right now. I think the hostility runs towards consumers more - some view the Native American culture/fashion as a fad, others like myself respect it much more. I don't see the point in hating on people who shop at regular stores, its all about the intention. At the end of the day, its up to you.
@JustACurbsideProphet I'm sorry for you and your opinions on this matter. It is inconsistent for you to say you both wish to promote native american culture and at the same time give your money to companies that are ultimately extinguishing native american authenticity in the arts. It seems clear to me (and I hope you see it too) that expressing yourself and representing yourself as a budget fashionista is your primary concern.
@JustACurbsideProphet as far as "all they have done"? what on earth do you mean??? Do you know your history? Not even history...do you know the current situation and what these communities are facing right now in terms of clinging onto their cultural identities? read a book.
@TheBasketcasey yes, I do know the current situation of the community, although people who haven't experienced it will not know the entire situation. I am very educated on the matter. What I'm saying is that I shouldn't be limited to my creativity. Granted I try to support the best I can, but I shouldn't be attacked because I'm wearing something out of gratitude. I rarely buy native american inspired items that from the places you mention...but I don't think you quite understand that.
im part native american , i believe uo, forever21, & h&m should aleast give a percentage of the profit from native american like apperal to the natives . too much for me is wen we already get to the point of disgracing my race for refrance the underwear is too much , but shirts & jewelry are expecible but when u get to the point of selling head pieces is just wrong thts not even fashion anymore, i admit native american stores are a little expensive but aleast you know it goes to a good cause
@cmorfin75 I agree that cheap headdresses are disrespectful... its not even regular clothing attire like moccasins. To the best of my knowledge, headdresses were used mostly for ceremonial occasions, and they were highly spiritual. Its just be opinion, but I will not be participating in that.. trend. Or whatever it is.
like some i've found in thrift stores and Native shops, that are handmade by Natives. like a necklace i found was made by a Native artist, i don't knw i guess it's more meaningful to me. Anyway thank you for this video and your own respect for Native American culture and i love! all your other videos. Hope you dont mind my super long response :)
@musicmind147 thanks for your long response! I loved it! You pretty much said what I wanted to say. Thank you for being so level headed and understanding!
i could still continue on but this topic or 'issue' because its personal to me and family. I understand its easier and way less expensive to shop at retail places rather than Native american stores but it would be great that if companies are going to use their designs that they should give back to them, because Native people could really use it. I personally wouldn't a shirt with a dream cather or native design on it from a store like UO because i like to find products...
but not about where we've came from and what we've been through. like the flask with the native designs, thats kind of offensive, cause of the whole 'Native's are alcoholics' stereotypes. They became that way because of what the 'white people' did to them. but yeah its an interesting style, but that is all people care about and when that trend passes people still wont care about the Native people. If companies gave back to native communities i think they would gain respect, like from me
First thing, i totally respect you for what you expressed in this video. I'm Native and i'm from Canada. It's eterenal for me because i come from that background and i'm drawn to art of Native American culture, i guess a way to describe it is 'it's in my blood", you know. I have a pair of moccasins from a small canadian shop that were handmade instead of buying pair from the mall and the 'Native Inspired' clothing and stuff, yes, it makes people aware of the nation, ... (continued)
I defiantly agree that incorporating Native Americans and alcohol abuse in photos etc., is extremely discriminating. Even though it may not be directed that way. It's like emphasizing the negative areas of a culture. However the way it can be used as far as feathers and fringed crop tops and such, are somewhat complementing. I have a fascination with all things involving Native Americans even though it's not my own culture, and I believe trends are trends. Just as say, African beads and prints
Although most of what is trendy in Chile is what is trendy here, I have NEVER seen a girl there wearing "Native American" (or Mapuche) fashion. The reason for this I believe is because in Chile,being a Mapuche Indian or having Mapuche blood (like me) is sort of considered to be shameful, mostly because many Chileans are of European descent. Here, being a Native Americans are still discriminated against and disrespected, but yet everyone is wearing what is considered "Native American inspired".
urban outfitters had clothes thats "boho" i dont think they ever actually meant (nor does anyone that wears that "fashion" of that sort) to be offensive to native americans. people just happen to like feathers a lot these days. :P
*did not mean this comment to be offensive to anyone of any race what so ever.
I think some commenters don't really understand the history behind the Sioux woman's reaction. Native Americans have been trying for centuries to survive in a country that does not respect them AT ALL. The Americans forced Natives into making contracts for every little thing (where they would go,what they would do, how they would make money) then they would turn around and break those contracts without really caring. The American government needs to start respecting the Native tribe's wishes.
I think that since so many companies & stores are putting out "Native American" styled clothes/accessories that are cheaply made, they loose their meaning and culture behind them. Not to sound like a complete hipster, but I wore NA inspired/made things since I was little and they mean a lot to me, but I think 90% of the people who wear them today, just wear them because they are a "trend" right now.
I also believe that NA culture isn't very respected. People don't get to know the TRUE NA culture and assume they all live on the reservations & drink. (I'm also Mexican) That's like saying all Mexicans work on plantations. The things people say about the NA & how Native American's are treated would be considered very racist if it were any other race/culture imo. You don't see a sports team called "The Africans" do you? (In reference to the RedSkins or the Chiefs)
I am Native American on my dad's side, but I don't know much about the culture or even what tribe my ancestors are from because I don't know that much about my dad's side. But I do love to learn about the Native American culture as a whole. I think the art and traditions and dances are beautiful. That being said, I would rather buy AUTHENTIC NA items rather than those "made in China"......
I think it's arts & crafts made by the Natives that others copy and make money on it by stating it's real native crafts when it is just a copy. Clothing is a different story, I don't think Natives claim people shouldn't wear clothes that are very similar to their own cultural style. If the pieces are designed and produced by Natives they can claim it is.
I love feathers! I think dream catchers are beautiful. is there anything wrong with that? I feel like if I wear a shirt with a dream catcher on it I'll be seen as something "wrong". I understand that it is a symbol from another culture but personally- I find it acceptable to just enjoy the beauty/ aesthetics of the symbol.
i work at american eagle and recently we had to put stickers over the pamphlets in our lanyards because the company used the term navajo, i think it is more the use of the name because it directly implies that it is made by that tribe
I think that if you want to wear clothing that depicts native american culture you should buy it from their shop or even make the item yourself. That is if you truly respect the culture because if you do then you wouldn't be buying the knock offs at these trendy stores!
I am Mexican-American with a little Native American in my blood and since I was a kid I always thought the culture was beautiful. I only purchase AUTHENTIC Native American jewelery and clothing, NOT cheap fabrications!
It's silly. I like native prints and such but never bought anything much related to them. It's not a law or anything and shouldn't be,it's oike if someone wears american clothing only americans can wear it. But now and days most people wears american like clothing but in different styles. The lady was exaggerating too much of it,it's yer opinion but other shops has same prints,styles,and such...so why would she bother of it? Lol
The fact that there is a law about the issue says that people should be more sensitive, giving some of the profit- or maybe giving jobs to some Natives would be appropriate I think. At the same time we forget that prints are prints- they have always been a fashion, in my country too. But the Native people on clothing and such, it shall go, the flask too.
When first hearing this i woot for the Natives. How dare they treat their life time culture as a seasonal trend. But then, we do it often. i am African- African not just African American, and i see many "tribal" prints be sold in costume fashion stores like Forever 21 all the time. I'm not saying its right or wrong, because I love wearing that stuff. But when i see a chief on a ring or a dream catcher around a neck i say we've gone to far.
4. I feel like issue can be blown out of proportions. There are many fashion interpretations of other cultures too. I see plenty of fashion items that have oriental and african american inspirations. I don't think it's offensive to use them on underwear or flasks because people take it as just an embellishment. Not a representation of those matter. It can cross the line when the Native American style isn't done tactfully but done almost obnoxiously (to the point of ridicule) copied.
I love the Native American culture. Ever since I was little I've been interested in it. I actually have some family friends who lived on one of the reservations when they were younger. I prefer to shop at the Native American shops than urban outfitters because 1) it's easier access for ME where I live. But also, I'd rather pay more money to have an AUTHENTIC piece made by someone who does it for a living, where they get the money, and your piece has more of a story.
i think that telling companies or people what to do or wear goes against our first amendment rights as american citizens. there are lots of things that people do that may seem offensive to some particular culture or another but thats just the harsh reality and at the same time the beauty of it all. right or wrong we get to express ourselves as we see fit.
I prefer the term First Nation, because that applies to Canadians and Americans. Anyways, about the thumbnail... I find it heart wrenching to see a colored headress ): , Anywho... 1. I find it alright for others to try the style, it's not like we go around saying what you should wear and what you shouldn't, just because it looks like our style. Completely unrelated remark here... just as long as they don't go around acting like that offensive scene in Peter Pan lmao (:
5. Companies should give back, but this is kind of unrealistic, so at least they should not try to emulate closely the Native American styles. But I don't think they are doing a very good job at this currently anyway, so no harm done. Just makes them look lame and silly (:
3. I think companies can sell Native American style products, as long as the prints are merely inspired but not completely accurate. Also, Natives don't screen print clothing, but rather they weave, sew, etc, which generally isn't what you find at UO, H&M, F21, etc. Their clothes are obviously cheap and not nearly as timeless as the real thing.
4. The panties thing sounds kind of ridiculous and unnecessary.
1. I love fringe. And my fringed Minnetonkas are definitely classy and eternal.
2. I would much rather shop in a Native American shop because I'd prefer to have a more authentic, high quality, hand-made item. The real thing feels like it has a story behind it.
In Australia there has always been tension between our native Aboriginal people and white settlers. We have a history of treating Aboriginal culture with very little respect/completely ignoring it. You would never find a piece of clothing in popular stores replicating Aboriginal art, music or symbols; and I think this reflects our segregated society. By including your native people's culture into modern society, you are indicating respect, acceptance and assimilation. Great video :)
the company's have the right do make any style they want as long it's not something hurtful like if there was a shirt of a Native American drinking beer and it said "live the life" or something I could see that as hurtful but to have a shirt with a Native American print or a feather on it why should that be offensive I mean lets say a shirt has a Tribal print ah or a Asian print oh or a Hispanic print mmm do those nationality's get to sue the company for "there" nationality print being used?
im native from red lake rez....in my opinion we dnt have a certain fashion these days, my fam dresses like everyone else i guess you would say. my daughter dresses emo lmao. newayz it doesnt bother me that ppl use native like print on underwear lol id buy em haha.neways ppl needa quit being so offended by everything.yall wanna dress like that then go ahead go crazy!!!
bug me at first, but I wear moccasins because, like I said I love learning,being a part of the native culture, I also am very interested in ancient/historical lifestyles, how people lived back then etc.. I am very aware it is "trending" right now, I wear them because i simply like them, always will always have and I have very aware they do come from the native culture, not urban outfitters or forever 21. I would also love to shop at a store owned/selling genuine items from the native community
I live in Vancouver, BC and first nations/native culture is very big here,it is celebrated but very stereotyped unfortunately.-What do you like about Native American styles? Is it just fashion or is it eternal to you? My heritage is not native whatsoever but I'm curious and intrigued on learning about the culture, I think the patterns are beautiful and items such as dream catchers,feathers etc.. that resemble deeper meaning. Mean way more than a trend or fashion statement, It used to never-
i think this is so controversial. I have so many opinions on this..dont even know where to start. :/ but i think they might've gone too far with Native American fashion.. D;
I don't just love Native American culture I love all different cultures. Ive always been fascinated with the native American outfits though. Btw have you every tried the moccasin kit from hobby lobby?
Also, there was another comment about the spirituality of things. Completely agree. The reason things are the way they are gets completely lost when mainstream fashion decides it's interesting. When fashion suddenly tries to experiment with Wicca (not comparing, this is as an example), I can only imagine what they'll come up with!
-ship simply cannot be mass reproduced. It's not about flash and glamour. It's not about a fad for a couple of months. It's one thing to celebrate a culture. It's another thing to morph it into something it's not. Appreciating the beauty of something is one thing (wether it's the actual thing or as close as you can find for what you can afford) is one thing, bedazzling some moccasins and adding extra fringe to be "hot" is NOT. (the comment about native-inspired panties? YOU. ARE. AWESOME!!!!!!!)
I had a problem with this too... The amount of blood ties to Native American relatives is pretty arguable at this point, but I've ALWAYS been attracted to Native American ANYTHING. I love learning the history and stories, artwork, clothing...all of that is part of an entire group that NO ONE could ever hope to know all about. Indian chief rings with rhinestone eyes? The heck? NEVER would I buy something like that. If I had the money, I'd buy from Native American shops. Authenticity and craftman-
I'm Hispanic , I'd wear under wears with sugar skulls , and I wouldn't mind seeing people with sugar skulls on flasks, I think it would be flattering that they were inspired by my culture.
I am a Native American girl from the Choctaw Nation. This so called, "fashion trend", is nothing of the sort. Contrary wise, it IS cultural appropriation. The feather extensions, the bejeweled mocs, and the dream catchers shirts do draw attention to us--the wrong kind. You don't see me walking around with "caucasian-inspired panties". Sounds fucking crazy, right? Think again when you hear the controversy of the "Native-inspired panty" etc etc. I am NOT a fashion statement. Respect my people.
@MissNativeWarrior Well come on, there's always different fashions inspired by different cultures. And they're often exaggerated. For example, the Union Jack. British people don't get offended. And for a while Asian silk clothes were in style, but I didn't see anyone being upset. I'm just saying, a fashion statement is often inspired by a culture.
@MissNativeWarrior@MissNativeWarrior That is ridiculous. All fashion is derived from different cultures. Are you suggesting we are only allowed to wear clothing and accessories restricted to our direct ancestral culture?
@MissNativeWarrior I understand where you're coming from, and I entirely respect your culture. I respect it so much I love to learn about the culture and sometimes wear Native American patterns. I really think the arts are beautiful and don't see the problem with me, being white, wearing some. I wouldn't wear underwear, or a flask. But some shoes maybe, or a nice sweater.
I don't see how having designs in fashion similar to Native Americans, is offensive in any way. Its not like were mocking them, we simply like the style and patterns that have originated from their culture. Native Americans are not the only ones that we have gotten fashion inspiration from, so why is it such a big deal?
@HannahWhaleyyy I have a feeling its more about the type of products that are being sold - like cheap headdresses as a fashion statement rather than a spiritual item. Or the flask, how it brings negative connotations (not on purpose). Perhaps its about how we are capitalizing on their "religion" and culture. I think some styles and patterns are fine to use. I'm all for freedom in fashion, but how far it too far when it comes to the items? You know what I mean? :)
I dont see it as a problem BUT i understand how it could be offensive to someone who is Native American and for that reason I respect that. I am African American (and my great grandfather is native american) and if companies were to "exploit" a dashiki or "African inspired print" i wouldn't be offended. I think stores should just be more conscious and sensitive towards those who may be offended
Personally, I think that at the end of the day it's fashion, the natives wore it as clothing so it doesn't matter, It's not like we're taking something that wasn't meant to be worn and making it into a fashion piece.. like a rosary. the underwear issue is sorta kinda disrespectful though. As far as giving back, I think that it would be a great idea for the companies to give back some of the profits they make but it's highly unlikely they'd do so. fucked up but true.
or cause their great great grandparent got wronged they feel the government should give them a hand-out. It's just like, this is AMERICA.... if you're suffering its mostly self inflicted. Whatever happened to rising above and becoming a better person by your own two hands and feet?
@xercesproject I really like how you dive into the real problem - racial tension. But I feel its hard for Native Americans to transition back into America, because they have been secluded to poverty struck reservations. The fault lies mostly in their government I'd say. Its just sad how just over in another county there are white picket fences, but on the res people are getting hurt and raped everyday. Its hard to leave and start a better life, thats why some are fighting to keep their culture.
@JustACurbsideProphet I agree. I've never encountered Native American people. Its like they're swept underneath a rug somewhere.I don't think they should assimilate into the Nu-American people unless they want to. There's so many things wrong. Its hard to take a side cause if feels like no matter what they are the ones that get hurt. I wonder if there are any documentaries out there on this subject and if not, someone should make one.
I also don't believe that giving one set of people so many [ some are cool] "perks" or "retribution" helps them at all. I think it can actually hurt the culture even more. Im just really on the line about it. I think Native Americans were done wrong, but so far down the line when do you let it go? I couldn't imagine passing a grudge down for generations... and Im not saying thats what they do. it just feels like that sometimes. Like black people always assuming "its cause they're black"
I think that I would rather shop directly from a Native American. Most of their products are handmade... I just think that's so neat and authentic is always better.
One more thing, its a bit off subject and I'm totally going to sound racist. I'm not white, I am Hispanic,but American born. I know that Native Americans were put through horrible things, and the African American culture as well, in the past but I don't like when people try and make me feel bad for something I didn't do.
i know this has nothing to do with all your questions and stuff but i looked at your blog and i LOOOOOOOOOOVEEEEE that lace top dress on you, on the hanger its was eh, but on you im not even lying it looked gorgeous!!!!!!!! k oh and i dont really have much to say on companies. i think they should be able to make native american clothing as long as its not being racial or offensive to their culture:)
I have complete empathy for the hardships that Native American peoples have had to suffer. However, I think that putting a taboo on their fashion is ludicrous. I mean, it's not like they have their patterns copy-righted....I don't believe that any stores are being offensive...they are merely demonstrating that they like the style. As for giving back to the Native Americans: I don't think it necessary just because they are selling products like theirs, but it would be nice.
I personally love the native american patterns not because they're fashionable at the moment but because they're really beautiful and organic looking. I can understand the woman's arguement, but in fairness it's being blown out of proportion. That native american arts and crafts act sounds a bit ridiculous.
... Many other cultures get trnds copied and misinterpreted all the time such as the spanish culture, afircan etc.. And they don't get offended and make a big deal, wanting money they feel they should be entitled to. That's just my opinion on the situation
On this topic I would say its being blown out of proportion! I don't think native americans should offended by people wanting to wear things inspired by their culture it only makes them more "popular" in a sense. If this was to offend them then Africans should be offended and what not when people copy their trends as well. Places that are distributing this type of clothing shouldn't have to pay the native americans either. That's them as a culture being stingy....
I'm Irish, and to be honest I think much too big a deal is being made about it. The celtic/irish design is used all the time by clothing and jewellery companies yet no one here finds that difficult to understand and no one certainly takes offence to it. I'm not sure if that's relevant or not but that's my view on things :)
I love everything about the fashion. It's just inspiration from the natives just a more affordable. If anything it's a compliment. I'm glad you put this vid ;)
In my opinion I feel like many people just see it as a trend to wear native american clothing, accessories etc. i believe that big companies see that trend and will obviously want to supply it for their buyers. im not native american but im sure if i was then i would be offended that people just buy it for the look of the product opposed to the actual culture. All in all, its just a trend to most people
...A lot of people actually commit suicide because they feel like there is no other option...People who don't care obviously have forgotten whose land their ancestors are really on and who they are benefiting off of....
Many Native Americans turn to drinking or other drugs to numb the fact that they are basically stuck in limbo, because they cant find any jobs on the reservations and they cannot improve their home life without them. Its sad really that they were stuck on these tiny plots of land basically forgotten.
3 and 4 combined. I personally feel like they are exploiting Native Americans. If you actually look at the living conditions on reservations it is definitely a lot different then what people think it is. They live in trailer homes that they don't have money to fix up so they have water leakage little to no heating.
I'm from Australian and honestly no one relay cares on who owns what style and stuff. I just wan't to say one thing which is that no one owned a serenity style or fashion she that chick is completable bonkers for making a big deal out of nothing :)
Tbh I don't know that much about native Americans but if stores are selling products that clearly have been influenced by the native American culture surely they should give some compensation to them. And the facts that it's an Act and that no one has acted on it before is strange to me :/ :)
not to sound too ignorant but i don't see why it's a big deal, the people who buy those clothes obviously like how they look and thats all that matters, native americans wear clothes that europeans made/invented or whatever, people can wear whatever they like, its not hurting anybody
@YellowZebra22356 it is hurting people.... Its hurting a culture and a race. Many Native Americans kill themselves because they don't have any other options because the government put them on reservations without jobs or options. So while you can go get a job at a mall to buy these clothes based off their culture they cant even afford to buy a home let alone heat it to stay warm or cool it in a hot summer....
I find it somewhat stupid.All the people who bullied me out of school for being native are now wearing items that come from my culture.I really do not mind if the person is respectful about it.It is kinda reminds me of the time my teacher wanted me to write a paper about who my favorite European explorer was.I can't stop it,or i'll just fail.
1. It's both, respectively. But what Americans, and people in general need to realize–I’m not saying that everyone is blind to this, by the way, mostly aiming this at the fashion industry/people who do not know about Native American culture, etc–is that this isn't just a fashion statement to them, this isn't just something that will fade away once the trend disappears, this is their culture, their LIFE, things that they've grown up around, know and believe in and have loved since before we
@makebelieved even knew it existed. It’s deeply offensive and incredibly disrespectful on some stores parts to blatantly ignore the fact that they’re ignorant when it comes to another culture apart from their own. The life they live, the clothes they wear, etc aren’t going to change once the pieces of Native American inspired clothing come off of the shelves.
...ignore that posting fail on my part. But anyway, this is coming from someone who is Native American. And sorry for getting so ranty..
@makebelieved I like your comment(s) a lot. It isn't just a trend that disappears - its their life. Out of mind, out of sight - for many people these days, unfortunately.
2) Native american clothing made from a Native American is pretty expensive and Usually, are only worn on special occasions, like a wedding dress, you only wear it during your wedding. I'm sure One could wear it at all times, but it is expensive and takes a lot of time to make. BUt I would choose something made from a Native American if I want that Big piece. For an everyday shirt, a nice Navajo pattern would be fine, which most likely will not have been made by a Native American
3:i think they should at least make it known or like a foundation towards it because i know some native americans and they are going through a rough time and not saying that All of them are going through a bad time but their ancestors did so yea :)
2.I wouldrather shopat an Native American Shop rather than Forever 21/Urban outfitter and any other store anytime because Its authentic and it was probably hand made by them...nd having a piece that was actually made by them is pretty awesome!
3. I think company's should give back atleast some of their profits to the native americans. I have so many opinons on this one.
4. I think stuff like the flask at Urban Outfitters is going too far..that just seems a little inappropriate..I think the Native American prints should be on clothes only. not..underwear or flasks..
5. They should definitely give back. And they should definitely pull things like what I said in #4
1. It's both. It's eternal to me because I'm half native american, My grandfather on my mom's side is full blooded Cherokee and so is my grandmother on my dad's side. I love native american style and culture. I've grown up around it my whole life.
2. I'd rather shop at a Native American shop, because it's authentic. even though i HAVE bought things from Forever 21 and Urban Outfitters.
This is why I love watching you, unlike a lot of people today you don't discriminate against other people's culture. You actually appreciate their crafts and are open to different things. I've met a lot of closed minded, ignorant people in my life that think they are better based on ethnicity and put others down, but you celebrate diversity instead of suppressing it and that can be rare sometimes. I will always support you and your channel as long as you keep up the great content. :)
I feel that they should definitely put in atleast some of there profits to the native americans. since they aren't even considering the Act. It only seems fair that way, we need to support Native American communities as well, or at least oblige by their rules.
super off topic but your hair is so beautiful and shiny and it looks so soft I just want to roll around in it. how do you take care of it? :)
1.I really like the patterns, the materials, the style and fit, really everything about Native culture really speaks to me.
2. I would rather shop and an actual NA shop (There's one here that I know of andI love it) I don't mind the expensive price because it goes to the people who deserve it.
3.It disgusts me.
4. When everywhere you turn - you see it.
5 Perhaps they should partner with Native American companies and have geniuine clothing in the store.
I personally don't buy any clothing with native American print from chain stores because I would rather support the community and culture/ heritage that it comes from. I feel like people are ignorantly following a trend and don't know that the chain stores are in a way taking away a profit that should go into the native American community. I have and will always think that the traditions and prints of native Americans are beautiful and no changes in fashion will sway my opinion.
Re. I just wish people would learn that there is so much more about the art an the people that thy don't know about or appreciate. The act was enstated to give the natives a right to their art and considering the Europeans slaid them of there rights to the land and killed so many natives the least Americans can do is keep our word and give them the exclusive right to their art. Thank you again for bringing light to this issue. I can't wait for the trend to simmer down.
I really appreciate this video. And I might do a video response tomorrow. But this issue bothers me a lot. My grandfather is 100% native American. So it is a huge part of my heritage. Ive went to services for native american rituals and gotten "blessings" by chiefs for coming of age. I got a feather tattoo on my back and a dreamcather on my leg, then all of a sudden it started to super trend and everyone is abusing it. My breaking point of aggravation was seeing a dreamcatcher at the dollar sto
i do like the native american print trend in small doses, but i think it's gotten very out of hand and kind of tasteless lately. I live in the south, so authentic native american stores and such you probably have in the west aren't around here as much, so it's nice to have access to some form of the trend, but urban outfitters has recently just made native american merch so repetitive it's getting really old.
i'm not a fan of tribal prints just because my style is more minimalist but cultural appropriation is NEVER okay imo. forever 21/UO are horrible with it.
I live in Japan, and tribal, floral, and bohemian fashion has been huge here for a long time, but it's just fashion to us. Not too many people in Asia are aware nor do they care about the effect it has on the actual Native Americans.
F21/UO/H&M have all replicated some kind of Asian print and pattern into their clothes, and while people in Asia would never buy or wear the imitated fashion, we're not really offended by it. It promotes our culture in other countries and brings tourism.
I've never purchased anything Native American like from a chain store..there's a Native American jewelry store at a mall near me and they sell some clothes too..the clothes isn't really my style but I absolutely adore the Native Jewelry and have saved up money to buy those because they're beautiful ,they won't break like the cheap kind ,and I know the money is going to the right place not some chain store
I really don't think companies can/should do what they want, specially big ones. I think the controversy is in the wrong point. If native americans rights were respected in all areas probably this controversy wouldn't exist.
Here in Argentina native comunities are "socially respected" but, in fact, their rights are smashed by big companies all the time, they steal their land, etc.
I know people like their style. But it is theirs, so people should respect their wishes. It's something special to them, and if they don't like it being a fashion thing it's perfectly fine of course. I understand it's their culture not something to make money off of. To be honest I wouldn't like it either. Underwear? that's not right. I don't think others would like it either. Their culture is not being taken seriously. It is mean, and offensive to them.
5. Should stores change, or should they change at all?
I'm definitely getting tired of seeing everyone wearing Native American print because it's "cute" and "in style". When you walk into Forever 21 it's overwhelming how much Native American print there is. This trend is going so far and it isn't giving anything back. I also think it is becoming to mainstream and overwhelming. What once used to be original and cultural is now seems popular and almost mind numbing.
I'm half Native, and I feel like people are just too ignorant to wear Native-style clothing. It's beautiful, obviously, but no one actually registers that their mocassins are a part of such an exploited culture. Natives were killed mercilessly by Europeans, and I feel like they don't think much of it as long as they can have their prints. It's extremely refreshing to see a white person (no offense intended!) know so much about their history and support them. As long as you're educated, wear it.
My friend is a very proud Native American and I don't think that he believes the Native American prints being marketed in mainstream shops to be a bad thing. To me, using those patterns and textures is a celebration of our country's history. It should be done with taste, though. The usage of Native American patterns on underwear and flasks however is very offensive and disrespectful. I think companies should acknowledge Native Americans more when using native designs but it shouldn't...
Overall Subject: In my opinion on the matter, i find it very degrading that the new style this year are "tribal" Native American print. How bigchain retailers lik H&M, forever 21,& especially Urban outfitters imitate the culture. I myself am Native America, more than half Chiricahua Apache. It sickens me that they make money off the culture, making it out to b a fashion statement then a sacred culture. It sickens me that people r obseesed wit dream catchers, but don't know anything about them.
i also think were the disconnect is between this trend and the other trends mentioned is that a lot of the things being produced are associated with native religious practices and those practices aren't being respected. also, it seems sort of weird that white americans, who basically enacted genocide on natives, would wear native inspired clothing, and things that aren't just native inspired, but strikingly similar. to me, it isn't hard to see why they would be offended.
2. i would rather shop at a native american shop because i feel the pieces would be more unique and would be more personal and made with love than if they were made in a factory.
3. i think companies should be able to sell whatever they want, its not like their making fakes of their work, like people do with coach bags. They're just making cool things that are fashionable at the time and arent trying to be offensive. Native american culture is apart of our world, just as other things are.
1. what i like about native american fashion is that it is trendy, cute and it isnt just fashion for me but "culture". I feel like the pieces make me feel like im closer with nature and just at peace. I've grown up in the woods and have always loved native american culture, so it is something that brings me back to my childhood, even though im not native american myself.
I kind of think of it as the American Flag trend. Some people find it offensive, but its not meant to be. Just like the American Flag print, the 'Native American' print is trending right now. These products are not made with the intent of insulting someones culture. They are made because they are considered stylish. However, since this is apparently a touchy subject, they should at least have the decency to not intentionally name a product 'Native American', or 'Navajo'.
, because I'm not of the native american culture which I find pretty bias, seeing as they wear I guess "western" clothing, or just things of that stature. Not even just natives, many places cultures and styles are used and incorporated into fashion. It means the industry sees the beauty in it and would think people of different cultures would like to wear new unique things. I see no problem in that. It's clothing, it's a statement. It's not meant to stir any controversy, and it's ignorant.
@theanikanator do you mean western as in "cowboy" western or western as in american/european? because insinuating that native americans are not americans is a whole 'nother ball park.
I think Native American styles are beautiful, but honestly I don't really care who makes them. However, I do understand why people get upset even if it doesn't mean anything to me. I do like quality so if I want moccasins or a beautiful fringe mittens I buy them from Native American stores. I also live in the suburbs of a city on the East Coast, maybe that's why I don't care as much?
I don't understand the issue here. I'm from Quebec, and seeing as my town neighbours 10 minutes away from a native reserve I see this culture everywhere and mind you I'm very accepting. But why fight against a popular store incorporating a trend based off of different cultures all over? That's what fashion is, it's using different cultures and styles and putting it into daily clothing. There's nothing wrong with that. It's tiresome to hear complaints. I wear moccasins and get told not to>
@theanikanator I know what you mean. I think some Native people are upset because their culture is getting "trendy", and they aren't getting any compensation or recognition. That sucks that people give you shit for what you like because of your background. I think it fashion shouldn't be reserved for just one group of people.
This is just my opinion. I don't know if I would think differently if I were a Native American. I would by from clothing made from genuine Natives, however 1) they're not common, 2) they are a bit pricey 3) sometimes the shops aren't even supporting the cause as they claim to do.
Anyway sorry for writing so much! I appreciate your video(s)! Great work :)
. It bothers me how the U.S. schools spends several weeks learning about concentration camps in Germany, but yet spends little to no time teaching the awful atrocities that happened to the Native Americans and their current state in modern times. Don’t get me wrong, I think it is great that we concentrate on other countries atrocities; it just bothers me that almost no time is focused on the U.S. awful past.
@leonamaii So true. Our education here is really biased. The Dakota War of 1862 specifically.. within 10 miles from me Native Americans were hanged. It sickens me. This is why its so important to learn about them and their culture, so they can receive their rights that they were promised.
@leonamaii Didn't you know the USA never admits any of its faults? We still say that we 'won' the vietnam
'war', and if they won't admit that they say 'oh it wasn't actually a war anyways.'
But, I am part native american (a very small amount, but my grandpa is very versed in the culture and he helped raise me) and I think that as long as you are aware of not only native american history, but why certain things were worn and what they mean, its fine.
@leonamaii sure the same could be said not many people know that the Irish were brutally taken over and controlled by the uk for 800 years yet plenty of people can quickly speak of how great the British were but not the truth of their destruction and devastation. I Guess people feel its not relevant yet it truly is to discuss these issues.
I don't think there is anything wrong with the fashion world adopting styles from the First Nation cultures, namely the Navajo traditional print. Rather, I think it has a positive affect. It brings attention to the rights and concerns of Native American tribes. As a German, although I live in the U.S. for quite sometime, I believe it is important that the American people pay more recognition to the indigenous people of the U.S.
@RetroSpeck99 agreed -> comming from a thrift girl I don't like spending much money. If I have money to spend on quality, I would go for it. But if I'm dying to get my hands on a trend, I wouldn't pass up an item at a regular retail store.
Personally I think if you want to wear feathers then wear feathers, and if you want to have a dream catcher then have one, but don't go running around with a headdress on and red face paint under your eyes just because it's "fashion" It's kinda disrespectful, that you'd try to make yourself look like you're apart of this culture and you actually know nothing about it.
DyamonFTW 1 day ago
@DyamonFTW agreed!
JustACurbsideProphet 1 day ago
Hey, the thumbnail of this video, i also have on my tumblr and wall.
emilyisaddicted 2 days ago
I personally see no problem with it. If people are willing to wear the stars and stripes of america or the union jack which can't we explore other cultures? Some people will still stay oblivious to Native Americans but what can you do about it? You can't force people to research and understand them or forbid them from wearing it? One trend I'm disgusted at is 'the military trend' I mean..really? You want to pretend your a soldier then get down on the frontline.
lg1447 5 days ago
Probably an actual Native American shop, or a least from a fair trade shop because I would be paying for the quality-- I would be wearing the clothing multiple times in my life, I'm a minimalist and wearing a piece made by an artist. Plus, I don't want to support stores that may be involved with sweatshops. If I want to be cheap and not support such corporations, then I could always design my own Native inspired print just for myself or learn some crafting technique, as I'm a crafty person.
Classicwinter 2 weeks ago
i liked the video not just because i actually liked it but of your eminem's shirt....!
ferxapp 3 weeks ago
Cut me a break. People have been wearing our style of clothing since they came to Turtle Island. What do you think Trappers wore when they came here. This is such an old topic, but since you are young this is new to you. Read up on history
waynah2 1 month ago
@waynah2 yes, I do know that the style has been worn for YEARS. But now that it is in fashion again, and we have the technology for it to be mass produced and sold at such a high level, I wanted to hear opinions.
JustACurbsideProphet 1 month ago
@waynah2 Trappers didn't wear clothes for fashion. Read up on your common sense.
OlivesWay 2 weeks ago
you also left out the most important part of Sasha's argument--that UO and Forever 21 are American companies that do not include native americans in the design or production process. Instead,production is sent overseas. This is the most ironic part of boasting a "Navajo" line in UO stores.
TheBasketcasey 1 month ago
I don't know if you're still doing your poll, but I hope that you, yourself as a shopper will stop to think about your intentions when you go to buy and wear native american inspired clothing. Do you care about saving MONEY and shopping at a place like UO or Forever21 more than you care about the disrespect the native american communities are feeling? You say you feel very close to the culture some how as a white person so why can't you empathize with their sentiments
TheBasketcasey 1 month ago
@TheBasketcasey Well like you said, this was a poll based video, so I didn't go much into detail about how I felt on the manner. In regards to your other comment, I left the article below for other people to follow up on, because I couldn't touch on everything. PERSONALLY, not only do I like saving money - but I need to save money. Just because I can't afford top original quality doesn't mean that it should stop me from expressing my gratitude.
JustACurbsideProphet 1 month ago
@TheBasketcasey I respect the culture and all that they have done. I think companies who rip off their designs need to be more socially conscious, but legally they don't have many set restraints right now. I think the hostility runs towards consumers more - some view the Native American culture/fashion as a fad, others like myself respect it much more. I don't see the point in hating on people who shop at regular stores, its all about the intention. At the end of the day, its up to you.
JustACurbsideProphet 1 month ago
@JustACurbsideProphet I'm sorry for you and your opinions on this matter. It is inconsistent for you to say you both wish to promote native american culture and at the same time give your money to companies that are ultimately extinguishing native american authenticity in the arts. It seems clear to me (and I hope you see it too) that expressing yourself and representing yourself as a budget fashionista is your primary concern.
TheBasketcasey 1 month ago
@JustACurbsideProphet as far as "all they have done"? what on earth do you mean??? Do you know your history? Not even history...do you know the current situation and what these communities are facing right now in terms of clinging onto their cultural identities? read a book.
TheBasketcasey 1 month ago
@TheBasketcasey yes, I do know the current situation of the community, although people who haven't experienced it will not know the entire situation. I am very educated on the matter. What I'm saying is that I shouldn't be limited to my creativity. Granted I try to support the best I can, but I shouldn't be attacked because I'm wearing something out of gratitude. I rarely buy native american inspired items that from the places you mention...but I don't think you quite understand that.
JustACurbsideProphet 1 month ago
im part native american , i believe uo, forever21, & h&m should aleast give a percentage of the profit from native american like apperal to the natives . too much for me is wen we already get to the point of disgracing my race for refrance the underwear is too much , but shirts & jewelry are expecible but when u get to the point of selling head pieces is just wrong thts not even fashion anymore, i admit native american stores are a little expensive but aleast you know it goes to a good cause
cmorfin75 1 month ago
@cmorfin75 I agree that cheap headdresses are disrespectful... its not even regular clothing attire like moccasins. To the best of my knowledge, headdresses were used mostly for ceremonial occasions, and they were highly spiritual. Its just be opinion, but I will not be participating in that.. trend. Or whatever it is.
JustACurbsideProphet 1 month ago
like some i've found in thrift stores and Native shops, that are handmade by Natives. like a necklace i found was made by a Native artist, i don't knw i guess it's more meaningful to me. Anyway thank you for this video and your own respect for Native American culture and i love! all your other videos. Hope you dont mind my super long response :)
musicmind147 1 month ago
@musicmind147 thanks for your long response! I loved it! You pretty much said what I wanted to say. Thank you for being so level headed and understanding!
JustACurbsideProphet 1 month ago
i could still continue on but this topic or 'issue' because its personal to me and family. I understand its easier and way less expensive to shop at retail places rather than Native american stores but it would be great that if companies are going to use their designs that they should give back to them, because Native people could really use it. I personally wouldn't a shirt with a dream cather or native design on it from a store like UO because i like to find products...
musicmind147 1 month ago
but not about where we've came from and what we've been through. like the flask with the native designs, thats kind of offensive, cause of the whole 'Native's are alcoholics' stereotypes. They became that way because of what the 'white people' did to them. but yeah its an interesting style, but that is all people care about and when that trend passes people still wont care about the Native people. If companies gave back to native communities i think they would gain respect, like from me
musicmind147 1 month ago
First thing, i totally respect you for what you expressed in this video. I'm Native and i'm from Canada. It's eterenal for me because i come from that background and i'm drawn to art of Native American culture, i guess a way to describe it is 'it's in my blood", you know. I have a pair of moccasins from a small canadian shop that were handmade instead of buying pair from the mall and the 'Native Inspired' clothing and stuff, yes, it makes people aware of the nation, ... (continued)
musicmind147 1 month ago
I defiantly agree that incorporating Native Americans and alcohol abuse in photos etc., is extremely discriminating. Even though it may not be directed that way. It's like emphasizing the negative areas of a culture. However the way it can be used as far as feathers and fringed crop tops and such, are somewhat complementing. I have a fascination with all things involving Native Americans even though it's not my own culture, and I believe trends are trends. Just as say, African beads and prints
icunthearyou96 1 month ago
be thankful that your culture is being used as inspiration.
DylanLamuchcha 1 month ago
boho is short for bohemian. a type of fashion, kinda 70s hippie.
iHunii 1 month ago
Although most of what is trendy in Chile is what is trendy here, I have NEVER seen a girl there wearing "Native American" (or Mapuche) fashion. The reason for this I believe is because in Chile,being a Mapuche Indian or having Mapuche blood (like me) is sort of considered to be shameful, mostly because many Chileans are of European descent. Here, being a Native Americans are still discriminated against and disrespected, but yet everyone is wearing what is considered "Native American inspired".
Queen1108 2 months ago
@Queen1108 wow, thats really interesting. I never would have guessed that. Thanks for sharing!
JustACurbsideProphet 2 months ago
I've been researching this so called fashion.
and I wanted to be respectable an careful so that I do not go around wearing stereotypical Indian clothing, we already know about black face ...
this just seems to be a justifyed Native american verison of the same thing.
MagicalOillusions 2 months ago
urban outfitters had clothes thats "boho" i dont think they ever actually meant (nor does anyone that wears that "fashion" of that sort) to be offensive to native americans. people just happen to like feathers a lot these days. :P
*did not mean this comment to be offensive to anyone of any race what so ever.
<3
xtraxearthling 2 months ago
I think some commenters don't really understand the history behind the Sioux woman's reaction. Native Americans have been trying for centuries to survive in a country that does not respect them AT ALL. The Americans forced Natives into making contracts for every little thing (where they would go,what they would do, how they would make money) then they would turn around and break those contracts without really caring. The American government needs to start respecting the Native tribe's wishes.
fishyfishyfishyshark 2 months ago 4
I think that since so many companies & stores are putting out "Native American" styled clothes/accessories that are cheaply made, they loose their meaning and culture behind them. Not to sound like a complete hipster, but I wore NA inspired/made things since I was little and they mean a lot to me, but I think 90% of the people who wear them today, just wear them because they are a "trend" right now.
EyeoftheWhiteWolf 2 months ago in playlist More videos from JustACurbsideProphet
I also believe that NA culture isn't very respected. People don't get to know the TRUE NA culture and assume they all live on the reservations & drink. (I'm also Mexican) That's like saying all Mexicans work on plantations. The things people say about the NA & how Native American's are treated would be considered very racist if it were any other race/culture imo. You don't see a sports team called "The Africans" do you? (In reference to the RedSkins or the Chiefs)
EyeoftheWhiteWolf 2 months ago in playlist More videos from JustACurbsideProphet
I am Native American on my dad's side, but I don't know much about the culture or even what tribe my ancestors are from because I don't know that much about my dad's side. But I do love to learn about the Native American culture as a whole. I think the art and traditions and dances are beautiful. That being said, I would rather buy AUTHENTIC NA items rather than those "made in China"......
EyeoftheWhiteWolf 2 months ago in playlist More videos from JustACurbsideProphet
I think it's arts & crafts made by the Natives that others copy and make money on it by stating it's real native crafts when it is just a copy. Clothing is a different story, I don't think Natives claim people shouldn't wear clothes that are very similar to their own cultural style. If the pieces are designed and produced by Natives they can claim it is.
spareaxe 2 months ago
I love feathers! I think dream catchers are beautiful. is there anything wrong with that? I feel like if I wear a shirt with a dream catcher on it I'll be seen as something "wrong". I understand that it is a symbol from another culture but personally- I find it acceptable to just enjoy the beauty/ aesthetics of the symbol.
TheUnicornonthecob 3 months ago in playlist More videos from JustACurbsideProphet 2
i work at american eagle and recently we had to put stickers over the pamphlets in our lanyards because the company used the term navajo, i think it is more the use of the name because it directly implies that it is made by that tribe
abbeyhilary 3 months ago
I think that if you want to wear clothing that depicts native american culture you should buy it from their shop or even make the item yourself. That is if you truly respect the culture because if you do then you wouldn't be buying the knock offs at these trendy stores!
I am Mexican-American with a little Native American in my blood and since I was a kid I always thought the culture was beautiful. I only purchase AUTHENTIC Native American jewelery and clothing, NOT cheap fabrications!
21KathyKat 3 months ago
I mean Like not oike
13MintKeys 3 months ago
It's silly. I like native prints and such but never bought anything much related to them. It's not a law or anything and shouldn't be,it's oike if someone wears american clothing only americans can wear it. But now and days most people wears american like clothing but in different styles. The lady was exaggerating too much of it,it's yer opinion but other shops has same prints,styles,and such...so why would she bother of it? Lol
13MintKeys 3 months ago
I am half Cherokee and I see nothing wrong with wearing Native American clothing
mizzfitroses 3 months ago
very instructive thank you :)
Turtle66n 3 months ago
The fact that there is a law about the issue says that people should be more sensitive, giving some of the profit- or maybe giving jobs to some Natives would be appropriate I think. At the same time we forget that prints are prints- they have always been a fashion, in my country too. But the Native people on clothing and such, it shall go, the flask too.
mycaligurl 3 months ago
When first hearing this i woot for the Natives. How dare they treat their life time culture as a seasonal trend. But then, we do it often. i am African- African not just African American, and i see many "tribal" prints be sold in costume fashion stores like Forever 21 all the time. I'm not saying its right or wrong, because I love wearing that stuff. But when i see a chief on a ring or a dream catcher around a neck i say we've gone to far.
mycaligurl 3 months ago
4. I feel like issue can be blown out of proportions. There are many fashion interpretations of other cultures too. I see plenty of fashion items that have oriental and african american inspirations. I don't think it's offensive to use them on underwear or flasks because people take it as just an embellishment. Not a representation of those matter. It can cross the line when the Native American style isn't done tactfully but done almost obnoxiously (to the point of ridicule) copied.
ramaoohlalasarah 3 months ago 2
I love the Native American culture. Ever since I was little I've been interested in it. I actually have some family friends who lived on one of the reservations when they were younger. I prefer to shop at the Native American shops than urban outfitters because 1) it's easier access for ME where I live. But also, I'd rather pay more money to have an AUTHENTIC piece made by someone who does it for a living, where they get the money, and your piece has more of a story.
WonderfullyDani 3 months ago
i think that telling companies or people what to do or wear goes against our first amendment rights as american citizens. there are lots of things that people do that may seem offensive to some particular culture or another but thats just the harsh reality and at the same time the beauty of it all. right or wrong we get to express ourselves as we see fit.
memeinmakeupland 3 months ago
I prefer the term First Nation, because that applies to Canadians and Americans. Anyways, about the thumbnail... I find it heart wrenching to see a colored headress ): , Anywho... 1. I find it alright for others to try the style, it's not like we go around saying what you should wear and what you shouldn't, just because it looks like our style. Completely unrelated remark here... just as long as they don't go around acting like that offensive scene in Peter Pan lmao (:
TFEF2 3 months ago
5. Companies should give back, but this is kind of unrealistic, so at least they should not try to emulate closely the Native American styles. But I don't think they are doing a very good job at this currently anyway, so no harm done. Just makes them look lame and silly (:
jubilantJOSEFINE 4 months ago
3. I think companies can sell Native American style products, as long as the prints are merely inspired but not completely accurate. Also, Natives don't screen print clothing, but rather they weave, sew, etc, which generally isn't what you find at UO, H&M, F21, etc. Their clothes are obviously cheap and not nearly as timeless as the real thing.
4. The panties thing sounds kind of ridiculous and unnecessary.
jubilantJOSEFINE 4 months ago
1. I love fringe. And my fringed Minnetonkas are definitely classy and eternal.
2. I would much rather shop in a Native American shop because I'd prefer to have a more authentic, high quality, hand-made item. The real thing feels like it has a story behind it.
jubilantJOSEFINE 4 months ago
you're sucha hipster♥
abcterrorsquad 4 months ago
In Australia there has always been tension between our native Aboriginal people and white settlers. We have a history of treating Aboriginal culture with very little respect/completely ignoring it. You would never find a piece of clothing in popular stores replicating Aboriginal art, music or symbols; and I think this reflects our segregated society. By including your native people's culture into modern society, you are indicating respect, acceptance and assimilation. Great video :)
aeiou1aeiou2 4 months ago 2
the company's have the right do make any style they want as long it's not something hurtful like if there was a shirt of a Native American drinking beer and it said "live the life" or something I could see that as hurtful but to have a shirt with a Native American print or a feather on it why should that be offensive I mean lets say a shirt has a Tribal print ah or a Asian print oh or a Hispanic print mmm do those nationality's get to sue the company for "there" nationality print being used?
kiekie84 4 months ago in playlist More videos from JustACurbsideProphet
This has been flagged as spam show
im native from red lake rez....in my opinion we dnt have a certain fashion these days, my fam dresses like everyone else i guess you would say. my daughter dresses emo lmao. newayz it doesnt bother me that ppl use native like print on underwear lol id buy em haha.neways ppl needa quit being so offended by everything.yall wanna dress like that then go ahead go crazy!!!
mizzblackwolf1985 4 months ago
bug me at first, but I wear moccasins because, like I said I love learning,being a part of the native culture, I also am very interested in ancient/historical lifestyles, how people lived back then etc.. I am very aware it is "trending" right now, I wear them because i simply like them, always will always have and I have very aware they do come from the native culture, not urban outfitters or forever 21. I would also love to shop at a store owned/selling genuine items from the native community
aliahaliah 4 months ago
I live in Vancouver, BC and first nations/native culture is very big here,it is celebrated but very stereotyped unfortunately.-What do you like about Native American styles? Is it just fashion or is it eternal to you? My heritage is not native whatsoever but I'm curious and intrigued on learning about the culture, I think the patterns are beautiful and items such as dream catchers,feathers etc.. that resemble deeper meaning. Mean way more than a trend or fashion statement, It used to never-
aliahaliah 4 months ago
i think this is so controversial. I have so many opinions on this..dont even know where to start. :/ but i think they might've gone too far with Native American fashion.. D;
TheKrystalKookie 4 months ago
I don't just love Native American culture I love all different cultures. Ive always been fascinated with the native American outfits though. Btw have you every tried the moccasin kit from hobby lobby?
pumkinChuckin 4 months ago
Also, there was another comment about the spirituality of things. Completely agree. The reason things are the way they are gets completely lost when mainstream fashion decides it's interesting. When fashion suddenly tries to experiment with Wicca (not comparing, this is as an example), I can only imagine what they'll come up with!
KittyDreadful 4 months ago
-ship simply cannot be mass reproduced. It's not about flash and glamour. It's not about a fad for a couple of months. It's one thing to celebrate a culture. It's another thing to morph it into something it's not. Appreciating the beauty of something is one thing (wether it's the actual thing or as close as you can find for what you can afford) is one thing, bedazzling some moccasins and adding extra fringe to be "hot" is NOT. (the comment about native-inspired panties? YOU. ARE. AWESOME!!!!!!!)
KittyDreadful 4 months ago
I had a problem with this too... The amount of blood ties to Native American relatives is pretty arguable at this point, but I've ALWAYS been attracted to Native American ANYTHING. I love learning the history and stories, artwork, clothing...all of that is part of an entire group that NO ONE could ever hope to know all about. Indian chief rings with rhinestone eyes? The heck? NEVER would I buy something like that. If I had the money, I'd buy from Native American shops. Authenticity and craftman-
KittyDreadful 4 months ago
I'm Hispanic , I'd wear under wears with sugar skulls , and I wouldn't mind seeing people with sugar skulls on flasks, I think it would be flattering that they were inspired by my culture.
Floralleggings 4 months ago
I'm Hispanic. I'd buy under wears with sugar sku
Floralleggings 4 months ago
I am a Native American girl from the Choctaw Nation. This so called, "fashion trend", is nothing of the sort. Contrary wise, it IS cultural appropriation. The feather extensions, the bejeweled mocs, and the dream catchers shirts do draw attention to us--the wrong kind. You don't see me walking around with "caucasian-inspired panties". Sounds fucking crazy, right? Think again when you hear the controversy of the "Native-inspired panty" etc etc. I am NOT a fashion statement. Respect my people.
MissNativeWarrior 4 months ago 57
@MissNativeWarrior thank you for your comment. Its nice to hear a different perspective on the matter.
JustACurbsideProphet 4 months ago 26
@JustACurbsideProphet Of course. Thank you for having an open mind.
MissNativeWarrior 4 months ago
@MissNativeWarrior Well come on, there's always different fashions inspired by different cultures. And they're often exaggerated. For example, the Union Jack. British people don't get offended. And for a while Asian silk clothes were in style, but I didn't see anyone being upset. I'm just saying, a fashion statement is often inspired by a culture.
CrazyRainbo 3 months ago 3
This is sort of... stupid. That's like Christians suing Forever 21 for selling necklaces with crosses.
CrazyRainbo 3 months ago 13
@MissNativeWarrior @MissNativeWarrior That is ridiculous. All fashion is derived from different cultures. Are you suggesting we are only allowed to wear clothing and accessories restricted to our direct ancestral culture?
kittysaurusRAWR 3 months ago
@MissNativeWarrior I understand where you're coming from, and I entirely respect your culture. I respect it so much I love to learn about the culture and sometimes wear Native American patterns. I really think the arts are beautiful and don't see the problem with me, being white, wearing some. I wouldn't wear underwear, or a flask. But some shoes maybe, or a nice sweater.
PassionPulp 2 months ago
If Native Americans feel like their being stolen from then the companies should give them credit for their beautiful designs.
TheRetroMaddie 4 months ago
I don't see how having designs in fashion similar to Native Americans, is offensive in any way. Its not like were mocking them, we simply like the style and patterns that have originated from their culture. Native Americans are not the only ones that we have gotten fashion inspiration from, so why is it such a big deal?
HannahWhaleyyy 4 months ago
@HannahWhaleyyy I have a feeling its more about the type of products that are being sold - like cheap headdresses as a fashion statement rather than a spiritual item. Or the flask, how it brings negative connotations (not on purpose). Perhaps its about how we are capitalizing on their "religion" and culture. I think some styles and patterns are fine to use. I'm all for freedom in fashion, but how far it too far when it comes to the items? You know what I mean? :)
JustACurbsideProphet 4 months ago
@Xercesproject you don't sound racist at all, you sound educated, everything you said was completely right.
PaigeeB222 4 months ago
I dont see it as a problem BUT i understand how it could be offensive to someone who is Native American and for that reason I respect that. I am African American (and my great grandfather is native american) and if companies were to "exploit" a dashiki or "African inspired print" i wouldn't be offended. I think stores should just be more conscious and sensitive towards those who may be offended
ashleyrp2007 4 months ago
Personally, I think that at the end of the day it's fashion, the natives wore it as clothing so it doesn't matter, It's not like we're taking something that wasn't meant to be worn and making it into a fashion piece.. like a rosary. the underwear issue is sorta kinda disrespectful though. As far as giving back, I think that it would be a great idea for the companies to give back some of the profits they make but it's highly unlikely they'd do so. fucked up but true.
sofiapadernal 4 months ago
or cause their great great grandparent got wronged they feel the government should give them a hand-out. It's just like, this is AMERICA.... if you're suffering its mostly self inflicted. Whatever happened to rising above and becoming a better person by your own two hands and feet?
xercesproject 4 months ago
@xercesproject I really like how you dive into the real problem - racial tension. But I feel its hard for Native Americans to transition back into America, because they have been secluded to poverty struck reservations. The fault lies mostly in their government I'd say. Its just sad how just over in another county there are white picket fences, but on the res people are getting hurt and raped everyday. Its hard to leave and start a better life, thats why some are fighting to keep their culture.
JustACurbsideProphet 4 months ago 3
@JustACurbsideProphet I agree. I've never encountered Native American people. Its like they're swept underneath a rug somewhere.I don't think they should assimilate into the Nu-American people unless they want to. There's so many things wrong. Its hard to take a side cause if feels like no matter what they are the ones that get hurt. I wonder if there are any documentaries out there on this subject and if not, someone should make one.
xercesproject 4 months ago
I also don't believe that giving one set of people so many [ some are cool] "perks" or "retribution" helps them at all. I think it can actually hurt the culture even more. Im just really on the line about it. I think Native Americans were done wrong, but so far down the line when do you let it go? I couldn't imagine passing a grudge down for generations... and Im not saying thats what they do. it just feels like that sometimes. Like black people always assuming "its cause they're black"
xercesproject 4 months ago
I think that I would rather shop directly from a Native American. Most of their products are handmade... I just think that's so neat and authentic is always better.
One more thing, its a bit off subject and I'm totally going to sound racist. I'm not white, I am Hispanic,but American born. I know that Native Americans were put through horrible things, and the African American culture as well, in the past but I don't like when people try and make me feel bad for something I didn't do.
xercesproject 4 months ago
i know this has nothing to do with all your questions and stuff but i looked at your blog and i LOOOOOOOOOOVEEEEE that lace top dress on you, on the hanger its was eh, but on you im not even lying it looked gorgeous!!!!!!!! k oh and i dont really have much to say on companies. i think they should be able to make native american clothing as long as its not being racial or offensive to their culture:)
sevenlegitshrimp 4 months ago
I have complete empathy for the hardships that Native American peoples have had to suffer. However, I think that putting a taboo on their fashion is ludicrous. I mean, it's not like they have their patterns copy-righted....I don't believe that any stores are being offensive...they are merely demonstrating that they like the style. As for giving back to the Native Americans: I don't think it necessary just because they are selling products like theirs, but it would be nice.
CemelDosce11 4 months ago
I personally love the native american patterns not because they're fashionable at the moment but because they're really beautiful and organic looking. I can understand the woman's arguement, but in fairness it's being blown out of proportion. That native american arts and crafts act sounds a bit ridiculous.
xxChocolateMalteaser 4 months ago
@scottishOwannaObe I'm Irish too and I completely agree with everything you said.
xxChocolateMalteaser 4 months ago
They're just clothes.. who cares?
hahaBAMellie 4 months ago
... Many other cultures get trnds copied and misinterpreted all the time such as the spanish culture, afircan etc.. And they don't get offended and make a big deal, wanting money they feel they should be entitled to. That's just my opinion on the situation
obeyfashion 4 months ago
On this topic I would say its being blown out of proportion! I don't think native americans should offended by people wanting to wear things inspired by their culture it only makes them more "popular" in a sense. If this was to offend them then Africans should be offended and what not when people copy their trends as well. Places that are distributing this type of clothing shouldn't have to pay the native americans either. That's them as a culture being stingy....
obeyfashion 4 months ago
I'm Irish, and to be honest I think much too big a deal is being made about it. The celtic/irish design is used all the time by clothing and jewellery companies yet no one here finds that difficult to understand and no one certainly takes offence to it. I'm not sure if that's relevant or not but that's my view on things :)
scottishOwannaObe 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
And what do you think ???
hellobombshelle1 4 months ago
I love everything about the fashion. It's just inspiration from the natives just a more affordable. If anything it's a compliment. I'm glad you put this vid ;)
hellobombshelle1 4 months ago
In my opinion I feel like many people just see it as a trend to wear native american clothing, accessories etc. i believe that big companies see that trend and will obviously want to supply it for their buyers. im not native american but im sure if i was then i would be offended that people just buy it for the look of the product opposed to the actual culture. All in all, its just a trend to most people
kelseywelseyy 4 months ago
You are awesome for making this video :)
samanthanoellesings 4 months ago
...A lot of people actually commit suicide because they feel like there is no other option...People who don't care obviously have forgotten whose land their ancestors are really on and who they are benefiting off of....
thesprinklerhead 4 months ago
Many Native Americans turn to drinking or other drugs to numb the fact that they are basically stuck in limbo, because they cant find any jobs on the reservations and they cannot improve their home life without them. Its sad really that they were stuck on these tiny plots of land basically forgotten.
thesprinklerhead 4 months ago 11
@thesprinklerhead "stuck in limbo" <-- so true. Thanks for the great comment
JustACurbsideProphet 4 months ago 2
3 and 4 combined. I personally feel like they are exploiting Native Americans. If you actually look at the living conditions on reservations it is definitely a lot different then what people think it is. They live in trailer homes that they don't have money to fix up so they have water leakage little to no heating.
thesprinklerhead 4 months ago
I'm from Australian and honestly no one relay cares on who owns what style and stuff. I just wan't to say one thing which is that no one owned a serenity style or fashion she that chick is completable bonkers for making a big deal out of nothing :)
JaydeSherry15 4 months ago
* Bonus question
Tbh I don't know that much about native Americans but if stores are selling products that clearly have been influenced by the native American culture surely they should give some compensation to them. And the facts that it's an Act and that no one has acted on it before is strange to me :/ :)
babycakes9999999 4 months ago
not to sound too ignorant but i don't see why it's a big deal, the people who buy those clothes obviously like how they look and thats all that matters, native americans wear clothes that europeans made/invented or whatever, people can wear whatever they like, its not hurting anybody
YellowZebra22356 4 months ago
@YellowZebra22356 it is hurting people.... Its hurting a culture and a race. Many Native Americans kill themselves because they don't have any other options because the government put them on reservations without jobs or options. So while you can go get a job at a mall to buy these clothes based off their culture they cant even afford to buy a home let alone heat it to stay warm or cool it in a hot summer....
thesprinklerhead 4 months ago
I find it somewhat stupid.All the people who bullied me out of school for being native are now wearing items that come from my culture.I really do not mind if the person is respectful about it.It is kinda reminds me of the time my teacher wanted me to write a paper about who my favorite European explorer was.I can't stop it,or i'll just fail.
TigerLillies13 4 months ago
1. It's both, respectively. But what Americans, and people in general need to realize–I’m not saying that everyone is blind to this, by the way, mostly aiming this at the fashion industry/people who do not know about Native American culture, etc–is that this isn't just a fashion statement to them, this isn't just something that will fade away once the trend disappears, this is their culture, their LIFE, things that they've grown up around, know and believe in and have loved since before we
makebelieved 4 months ago 3
@makebelieved even knew it existed. It’s deeply offensive and incredibly disrespectful on some stores parts to blatantly ignore the fact that they’re ignorant when it comes to another culture apart from their own. The life they live, the clothes they wear, etc aren’t going to change once the pieces of Native American inspired clothing come off of the shelves.
...ignore that posting fail on my part. But anyway, this is coming from someone who is Native American. And sorry for getting so ranty..
makebelieved 4 months ago
@makebelieved I like your comment(s) a lot. It isn't just a trend that disappears - its their life. Out of mind, out of sight - for many people these days, unfortunately.
JustACurbsideProphet 4 months ago
Comment removed
makebelieved 4 months ago
Comment removed
makebelieved 4 months ago
2) Native american clothing made from a Native American is pretty expensive and Usually, are only worn on special occasions, like a wedding dress, you only wear it during your wedding. I'm sure One could wear it at all times, but it is expensive and takes a lot of time to make. BUt I would choose something made from a Native American if I want that Big piece. For an everyday shirt, a nice Navajo pattern would be fine, which most likely will not have been made by a Native American
bluegirubootsgalore 4 months ago
3:i think they should at least make it known or like a foundation towards it because i know some native americans and they are going through a rough time and not saying that All of them are going through a bad time but their ancestors did so yea :)
Miztexasbabe 4 months ago
2.I wouldrather shopat an Native American Shop rather than Forever 21/Urban outfitter and any other store anytime because Its authentic and it was probably hand made by them...nd having a piece that was actually made by them is pretty awesome!
Miztexasbabe 4 months ago
3. I think company's should give back atleast some of their profits to the native americans. I have so many opinons on this one.
4. I think stuff like the flask at Urban Outfitters is going too far..that just seems a little inappropriate..I think the Native American prints should be on clothes only. not..underwear or flasks..
5. They should definitely give back. And they should definitely pull things like what I said in #4
Alli92409 4 months ago 3
1. It's both. It's eternal to me because I'm half native american, My grandfather on my mom's side is full blooded Cherokee and so is my grandmother on my dad's side. I love native american style and culture. I've grown up around it my whole life.
2. I'd rather shop at a Native American shop, because it's authentic. even though i HAVE bought things from Forever 21 and Urban Outfitters.
Alli92409 4 months ago
It's part of their CULTURE NOT just a TREND to make money of. We should respect their wishes..
stephylovesvideos 4 months ago
This is why I love watching you, unlike a lot of people today you don't discriminate against other people's culture. You actually appreciate their crafts and are open to different things. I've met a lot of closed minded, ignorant people in my life that think they are better based on ethnicity and put others down, but you celebrate diversity instead of suppressing it and that can be rare sometimes. I will always support you and your channel as long as you keep up the great content. :)
amelie1800 4 months ago
3.
I feel that they should definitely put in atleast some of there profits to the native americans. since they aren't even considering the Act. It only seems fair that way, we need to support Native American communities as well, or at least oblige by their rules.
super off topic but your hair is so beautiful and shiny and it looks so soft I just want to roll around in it. how do you take care of it? :)
nectarinesnoam 4 months ago
Fashion is fashion. Arts and inspiration should be for everyone. It keeps our little world exciting.
softfocus85 4 months ago
1. I LOVE NATICE AMERICAN STYLE!!!!!! But, my whole family on my mom's side has a huge past with Native Americans, so it is eternal to me.
2. A vintage Native American store! That would be so cool!
3. Um....that's a hard question 'cause, there isn't many Native Americans left these days. Unless it's a genuine Native American!
4. When people start wearing leather thongs! :D
5.Not change at all! For the people that love fashion, we should be able to express ourselves through that trend! :)
rainfallonme 4 months ago
1.I really like the patterns, the materials, the style and fit, really everything about Native culture really speaks to me.
2. I would rather shop and an actual NA shop (There's one here that I know of andI love it) I don't mind the expensive price because it goes to the people who deserve it.
3.It disgusts me.
4. When everywhere you turn - you see it.
5 Perhaps they should partner with Native American companies and have geniuine clothing in the store.
kaitlinsherry 4 months ago
I personally don't buy any clothing with native American print from chain stores because I would rather support the community and culture/ heritage that it comes from. I feel like people are ignorantly following a trend and don't know that the chain stores are in a way taking away a profit that should go into the native American community. I have and will always think that the traditions and prints of native Americans are beautiful and no changes in fashion will sway my opinion.
SapphireMonster 4 months ago 2
Re. I just wish people would learn that there is so much more about the art an the people that thy don't know about or appreciate. The act was enstated to give the natives a right to their art and considering the Europeans slaid them of there rights to the land and killed so many natives the least Americans can do is keep our word and give them the exclusive right to their art. Thank you again for bringing light to this issue. I can't wait for the trend to simmer down.
FromInsideMyCloset 4 months ago
I really appreciate this video. And I might do a video response tomorrow. But this issue bothers me a lot. My grandfather is 100% native American. So it is a huge part of my heritage. Ive went to services for native american rituals and gotten "blessings" by chiefs for coming of age. I got a feather tattoo on my back and a dreamcather on my leg, then all of a sudden it started to super trend and everyone is abusing it. My breaking point of aggravation was seeing a dreamcatcher at the dollar sto
FromInsideMyCloset 4 months ago 8
I honestly find it weird how white people wear Native American clothing....but fashion is fashion.
ZaideProductions 4 months ago
i do like the native american print trend in small doses, but i think it's gotten very out of hand and kind of tasteless lately. I live in the south, so authentic native american stores and such you probably have in the west aren't around here as much, so it's nice to have access to some form of the trend, but urban outfitters has recently just made native american merch so repetitive it's getting really old.
ManiaFromMonsters 4 months ago
i'm not a fan of tribal prints just because my style is more minimalist but cultural appropriation is NEVER okay imo. forever 21/UO are horrible with it.
zerofourninezero 4 months ago
I live in Japan, and tribal, floral, and bohemian fashion has been huge here for a long time, but it's just fashion to us. Not too many people in Asia are aware nor do they care about the effect it has on the actual Native Americans.
F21/UO/H&M have all replicated some kind of Asian print and pattern into their clothes, and while people in Asia would never buy or wear the imitated fashion, we're not really offended by it. It promotes our culture in other countries and brings tourism.
maahreechan 4 months ago
I've never purchased anything Native American like from a chain store..there's a Native American jewelry store at a mall near me and they sell some clothes too..the clothes isn't really my style but I absolutely adore the Native Jewelry and have saved up money to buy those because they're beautiful ,they won't break like the cheap kind ,and I know the money is going to the right place not some chain store
05ALMA20 4 months ago
I really don't think companies can/should do what they want, specially big ones. I think the controversy is in the wrong point. If native americans rights were respected in all areas probably this controversy wouldn't exist.
Here in Argentina native comunities are "socially respected" but, in fact, their rights are smashed by big companies all the time, they steal their land, etc.
seisdecorazones 4 months ago
I know people like their style. But it is theirs, so people should respect their wishes. It's something special to them, and if they don't like it being a fashion thing it's perfectly fine of course. I understand it's their culture not something to make money off of. To be honest I wouldn't like it either. Underwear? that's not right. I don't think others would like it either. Their culture is not being taken seriously. It is mean, and offensive to them.
DearMarlet 4 months ago 2
@DearMarlet I totally Agree.
stephylovesvideos 4 months ago
5. Should stores change, or should they change at all?
I'm definitely getting tired of seeing everyone wearing Native American print because it's "cute" and "in style". When you walk into Forever 21 it's overwhelming how much Native American print there is. This trend is going so far and it isn't giving anything back. I also think it is becoming to mainstream and overwhelming. What once used to be original and cultural is now seems popular and almost mind numbing.
projects141 4 months ago
I really like to see that not every american fashion vlogger is brainless
seisdecorazones 4 months ago
Hi! im from Argentina, my opinion is: a5.sphotos.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-snc6/34852_1493144299562_1562683019_1203951_4803966_n.jpg
seisdecorazones 4 months ago
@seisdecorazones YES!
JustACurbsideProphet 4 months ago
I'm half Native, and I feel like people are just too ignorant to wear Native-style clothing. It's beautiful, obviously, but no one actually registers that their mocassins are a part of such an exploited culture. Natives were killed mercilessly by Europeans, and I feel like they don't think much of it as long as they can have their prints. It's extremely refreshing to see a white person (no offense intended!) know so much about their history and support them. As long as you're educated, wear it.
Cobain136 4 months ago 31
@Cobain136 "As long as you're educated, wear it" <-- I like that. thank you
JustACurbsideProphet 4 months ago 16
@Cobain136 I know how you feel. I'm 3/4 native. I'm blackfoot tribe, comanche, and inca. :) You?
camilovesyou13 4 months ago
@camilovesyou13 I'm Woodland Cree :)
Cobain136 4 months ago
...be necessary for companies to give back money-wise.
BellieTheShortyDoll 4 months ago
My friend is a very proud Native American and I don't think that he believes the Native American prints being marketed in mainstream shops to be a bad thing. To me, using those patterns and textures is a celebration of our country's history. It should be done with taste, though. The usage of Native American patterns on underwear and flasks however is very offensive and disrespectful. I think companies should acknowledge Native Americans more when using native designs but it shouldn't...
BellieTheShortyDoll 4 months ago
Overall Subject: In my opinion on the matter, i find it very degrading that the new style this year are "tribal" Native American print. How bigchain retailers lik H&M, forever 21,& especially Urban outfitters imitate the culture. I myself am Native America, more than half Chiricahua Apache. It sickens me that they make money off the culture, making it out to b a fashion statement then a sacred culture. It sickens me that people r obseesed wit dream catchers, but don't know anything about them.
canisaurus13 4 months ago
i also think were the disconnect is between this trend and the other trends mentioned is that a lot of the things being produced are associated with native religious practices and those practices aren't being respected. also, it seems sort of weird that white americans, who basically enacted genocide on natives, would wear native inspired clothing, and things that aren't just native inspired, but strikingly similar. to me, it isn't hard to see why they would be offended.
prettyrainyday 4 months ago
2. i would rather shop at a native american shop because i feel the pieces would be more unique and would be more personal and made with love than if they were made in a factory.
3. i think companies should be able to sell whatever they want, its not like their making fakes of their work, like people do with coach bags. They're just making cool things that are fashionable at the time and arent trying to be offensive. Native american culture is apart of our world, just as other things are.
3.
runimashley 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
1. what i like about native american fashion is that it is trendy, cute and it isnt just fashion for me but "culture". I feel like the pieces make me feel like im closer with nature and just at peace. I've grown up in the woods and have always loved native american culture, so it is something that brings me back to my childhood, even though im not native american myself.
runimashley 4 months ago
Comment removed
runimashley 4 months ago
I kind of think of it as the American Flag trend. Some people find it offensive, but its not meant to be. Just like the American Flag print, the 'Native American' print is trending right now. These products are not made with the intent of insulting someones culture. They are made because they are considered stylish. However, since this is apparently a touchy subject, they should at least have the decency to not intentionally name a product 'Native American', or 'Navajo'.
youthtruly 4 months ago
, because I'm not of the native american culture which I find pretty bias, seeing as they wear I guess "western" clothing, or just things of that stature. Not even just natives, many places cultures and styles are used and incorporated into fashion. It means the industry sees the beauty in it and would think people of different cultures would like to wear new unique things. I see no problem in that. It's clothing, it's a statement. It's not meant to stir any controversy, and it's ignorant.
theanikanator 4 months ago
@theanikanator do you mean western as in "cowboy" western or western as in american/european? because insinuating that native americans are not americans is a whole 'nother ball park.
prettyrainyday 4 months ago
I think Native American styles are beautiful, but honestly I don't really care who makes them. However, I do understand why people get upset even if it doesn't mean anything to me. I do like quality so if I want moccasins or a beautiful fringe mittens I buy them from Native American stores. I also live in the suburbs of a city on the East Coast, maybe that's why I don't care as much?
rileyyysays 4 months ago
I don't understand the issue here. I'm from Quebec, and seeing as my town neighbours 10 minutes away from a native reserve I see this culture everywhere and mind you I'm very accepting. But why fight against a popular store incorporating a trend based off of different cultures all over? That's what fashion is, it's using different cultures and styles and putting it into daily clothing. There's nothing wrong with that. It's tiresome to hear complaints. I wear moccasins and get told not to>
theanikanator 4 months ago
@theanikanator I know what you mean. I think some Native people are upset because their culture is getting "trendy", and they aren't getting any compensation or recognition. That sucks that people give you shit for what you like because of your background. I think it fashion shouldn't be reserved for just one group of people.
JustACurbsideProphet 4 months ago
3)
This is just my opinion. I don't know if I would think differently if I were a Native American. I would by from clothing made from genuine Natives, however 1) they're not common, 2) they are a bit pricey 3) sometimes the shops aren't even supporting the cause as they claim to do.
Anyway sorry for writing so much! I appreciate your video(s)! Great work :)
leonamaii 4 months ago
@leonamaii I agree with all of your points!
JustACurbsideProphet 4 months ago
2)
. It bothers me how the U.S. schools spends several weeks learning about concentration camps in Germany, but yet spends little to no time teaching the awful atrocities that happened to the Native Americans and their current state in modern times. Don’t get me wrong, I think it is great that we concentrate on other countries atrocities; it just bothers me that almost no time is focused on the U.S. awful past.
leonamaii 4 months ago 35
@leonamaii So true. Our education here is really biased. The Dakota War of 1862 specifically.. within 10 miles from me Native Americans were hanged. It sickens me. This is why its so important to learn about them and their culture, so they can receive their rights that they were promised.
JustACurbsideProphet 4 months ago
@leonamaii SOO true. Here in Argentina is the same.
seisdecorazones 4 months ago
@leonamaii Didn't you know the USA never admits any of its faults? We still say that we 'won' the vietnam
'war', and if they won't admit that they say 'oh it wasn't actually a war anyways.'
But, I am part native american (a very small amount, but my grandpa is very versed in the culture and he helped raise me) and I think that as long as you are aware of not only native american history, but why certain things were worn and what they mean, its fine.
JacolynOWNS 4 months ago
@leonamaii sure the same could be said not many people know that the Irish were brutally taken over and controlled by the uk for 800 years yet plenty of people can quickly speak of how great the British were but not the truth of their destruction and devastation. I Guess people feel its not relevant yet it truly is to discuss these issues.
NiamhTbh 4 months ago
1)
I don't think there is anything wrong with the fashion world adopting styles from the First Nation cultures, namely the Navajo traditional print. Rather, I think it has a positive affect. It brings attention to the rights and concerns of Native American tribes. As a German, although I live in the U.S. for quite sometime, I believe it is important that the American people pay more recognition to the indigenous people of the U.S.
leonamaii 4 months ago
idk.. but native american style is pretty cool, as long as you incorporate it into modern day style! ;D
elizabethumanzor 4 months ago
@RetroSpeck99 agreed -> comming from a thrift girl I don't like spending much money. If I have money to spend on quality, I would go for it. But if I'm dying to get my hands on a trend, I wouldn't pass up an item at a regular retail store.
JustACurbsideProphet 4 months ago